Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Credit Risk Review - Internal Audit
3216-Final Testing CRR
To:
AR_3356
From:
Credit Risk Review - Internal Audit
CC:
Audit Team:
Jahanzaib Amlani (Team Lead)
Fawad Aziz(Team Member)
Muhammad Asad Nadeem(Team Member)
m_umair(Team Member)
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Table of
Contents
OBJECTIVE .................................................................................................................................. 3
SCOPE OF WORK ....................................................................................................................... 3
REVIEW RATING ......................................................................................................................... 3
CRR SCORE AND MATRIX ......................................................................................................... 3
RECOMMENDED ORR DOWN GRADES CONSOLIDATED ..................................................... 5
RECOMMENDED ORR DOWN GRADES SUMMARY ............................................................... 6
RECOMMENDED ORR DOWN GRADES DETAIL ..................................................................... 7
ACTION PLAN .............................................................................................................................. 9
CPM OBSERVATIONS ................................................................................................................ 40
PORTFOLIO BREAKUP ............................................................................................................... 42
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .............................................................................................................. 42
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 2
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Objective
Scope of Work
Review Rating
.
The focus of our review has been on:
1. Assessment of Portfolio Quality (including Internal Risk Ratings duly worked out as per Credit Policy).
2. Credit Management Process (from origination, approval stages, monitoring & handling thereafter, including
Credit Administration process, compliance to SBP regulations and Bank's internal policies).
Following ratings as per approved CRR Score Card Matrix* have been assigned after review of the CBG South on the
basis of Obligor Risk Ratings and Observations on the Credit Management Process.
Current Audit Rating Last Audit Rating
CRR Score and Matrix
.
Portfolio Health Credit Management Process
Rating* Rating**
If major observations are in <25% OR
If >60% of approved limits are in ORR1-
Low Risk Exposure Amount of the sample. Acceptable
3
(Whichever is higher).
If major observations are in >or =25%
If >20% of approved limits are in ORR 4- Needs
Medium Risk but <50% OR Exposure Amount of the
6 Improvement
sample. (Whichever is higher)
If major observations are in >or=50% Needs
If > 20% of approved limits are in ORR
High Risk OR Exposure Amount of the sample. Significant
7-12
(Whichever is higher) Improvement
*In case a portfolio complies to one or more rating bucket, the higher risk category will apply (i.e. if Low Risk and High
Risk buckets are met, the portfolio will be rated as High Risk).
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 3
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
**Any observation highlighting a significant weakness in, 1) Due Diligence 2) Credit Rating 3) Documentation 4)
Exposure / Security Monitoring, will constitute a major observation.
If there are more than one major observations in an account of the sample the first observation will carry 100% weight-
age and the subsequent observations each will carry 50% weight-age for calculation of percentage of CMP rating.
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 4
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Recommended ORR Down Grades Consolidated
.
Borrower Name Limit (F + NF) Outstanding (F + NF) ORR Down Graded ORR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 5
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Recommended ORR Down Grades Summary
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 6
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Recommended ORR Down Grades Detail
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 7
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 8
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Action Plan
.
Action Required / Management Target Date
Nature SR # Observation Responsibility
Recommendation Comments of Compiliance
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 9
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
3 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for BU 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
4 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for BU 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
5 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for BU 22-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 10
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 11
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 12
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 13
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 14
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
19 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 14-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
20 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
O/s:
BTF: 231,232.00 M 231,232.00
M
O/s:
RASHID SEED FARM BTF: 231,232.00 M 231,232.00
VIII ORR 2
Expiry: 30-Sep-2020 M
O/s:
BTF: 231,232.00 M 231,232.00
M
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the the matter to Group the matter to Group
Information
21 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Chief RMG and Chief RMG and 21-Sep-2020
security
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 15
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 16
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
26 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for FIG 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Retail Banking the matter to Group
27 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 08-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Group Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the the matter to Group the matter to Group
Information
28 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Chief RMG and Chief RMG and 16-Sep-2020
security
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 17
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 18
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 19
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
35 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for FIG 28-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
O/s:
3,2131: 3,213.00 M
3,213.00 M
O/s:
3,2132: 3,213.00 M
K.M. STEEL MILLS 3,213.00 M
XIV O/s: ORR 1
Expiry: 14-Sep-2020 3,2133: 3,213.00 M
3,213.00 M
2323AAA: O/s:
3,213.00 M 3,213.00 M
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
36 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 15-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
M/S SHAH MIR TRADERS ORR 2
XV
Expiry: 15-Sep-2020 Recommended ORR 3
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 20
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 21
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
Information
44 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for ABC ABC 18-Sep-2020
security
revaluation?
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 22
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 23
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
conducted by referring conducted by referring
matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for
51 the matter to Group Marketing the matter to Group 22-Sep-2020
revaluation?
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
52 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
53 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
O/s:
BTF: 2,321,213.00
123,213.00
M
M
O/s:
BTF: 232.00 M 321,321.00
AA ENTERPRISES
XIX M ORR 2
Expiry: 14-Sep-2020
O/s:
322,223.00
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 24
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
BTF: 323,123.00 M M
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
54 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for KYC 14-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
55 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for BU 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
56 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Marketing 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the the matter to Group the matter to Group
57 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Chief RMG and FIG Chief RMG and 16-Sep-2020
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 25
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 26
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
manufacturing of steel manufacturing of steel
billets / ingots, through billets / ingots, through
melting process. Mr. melting process. Mr.
Abdul Aziz Khan is an Abdul Aziz Khan is an
extensively extensively
experienced person. He experienced person. He
had been working as a had been working as a
scrap dealer in Karachi scrap dealer in Karachi
since 1988 till 1999. He since 1988 till 1999. He
joined Sanjam Steel joined Sanjam Steel
Furnace, Gujranwala as Furnace, Gujranwala as
a partner in year 2000 a partner in year 2000
and remained partner and remained partner
till 2007. Having till 2007. Having
practically engaged practically engaged
with this industry/trade with this industry/trade
business line, he business line, he
gained enough gained enough
experience & experience &
knowledge, to run a knowledge, to run a
steel furnace industrial steel furnace industrial
unit, smoothly, unit, smoothly,
profitably & profitably &
independently. independently.
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the Therefore, he set up Therefore, he set up
Information
60 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Rajput Steel Industry in security Rajput Steel Industry in 28-Sep-2020
revaluation? the year 2008 with Ch. the year 2008 with Ch.
Muhammad Saeed Muhammad Saeed
Khan as a partner, who Khan as a partner, who
after a year left this after a year left this
industry/business line, industry/business line,
share of whom was share of whom was
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 27
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
purchased by Mr. Abdul purchased by Mr. Abdul
Aziz Khan; since then Aziz Khan; since then
Mr. Aziz khan is Mr. Aziz khan is
running this entity & running this entity &
unit being its sole unit being its sole
owner. The industrial owner. The industrial
unit of the entity, unit of the entity,
comprising of one Hi- comprising of one Hi-
tech imported furnace tech imported furnace
backed by related backed by related
machinery / equipment machinery / equipment
having capacity to having capacity to
produce 7 metric tons produce 7 metric tons
steel billets / ingots per steel billets / ingots per
heat, is located on 6- heat, is located on 6-
KM, Dewan Road, KM, Dewan Road,
Eminabad, Gujranwala Eminabad, Gujranwala
. However, due to . However, due to
ongoing electricity ongoing electricity
crisis, now a days, the crisis, now a days, the
entity is operating with entity is operating with
one shift of 12 hours one shift of 12 hours
and producing 60 and producing 60
metric tons steel billets metric tons steel billets
/ ingots/day. / ingots/day.
Rajput Steel Industry, Rajput Steel Industry,
established in the year established in the year
2008, is a sole 2008, is a sole
proprietorship concern proprietorship concern
owned by Mr. Abdul owned by Mr. Abdul
Aziz Khan, and is Aziz Khan, and is
engaged in engaged in
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 28
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
manufacturing of steel manufacturing of steel
billets / ingots, through billets / ingots, through
melting process. Mr. melting process. Mr.
Abdul Aziz Khan is an Abdul Aziz Khan is an
extensively extensively
experienced person. He experienced person. He
had been working as a had been working as a
scrap dealer in Karachi scrap dealer in Karachi
since 1988 till 1999. He since 1988 till 1999. He
joined Sanjam Steel joined Sanjam Steel
Furnace, Gujranwala as Furnace, Gujranwala as
a partner in year 2000 a partner in year 2000
and remained partner and remained partner
till 2007. Having till 2007. Having
practically engaged practically engaged
with this industry/trade with this industry/trade
business line, he business line, he
gained enough gained enough
experience & experience &
knowledge, to run a knowledge, to run a
steel furnace industrial steel furnace industrial
unit, smoothly, unit, smoothly,
profitably & profitably &
independently. independently.
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
Therefore, he set up Information Therefore, he set up
61 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 08-Sep-2020
Rajput Steel Industry in security Rajput Steel Industry in
revaluation?
the year 2008 with Ch. the year 2008 with Ch.
Muhammad Saeed Muhammad Saeed
Khan as a partner, who Khan as a partner, who
after a year left this after a year left this
industry/business line, industry/business line,
share of whom was share of whom was
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 29
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
purchased by Mr. Abdul purchased by Mr. Abdul
Aziz Khan; since then Aziz Khan; since then
Mr. Aziz khan is Mr. Aziz khan is
running this entity & running this entity &
unit being its sole unit being its sole
owner. The industrial owner. The industrial
unit of the entity, unit of the entity,
comprising of one Hi- comprising of one Hi-
tech imported furnace tech imported furnace
backed by related backed by related
machinery / equipment machinery / equipment
having capacity to having capacity to
produce 7 metric tons produce 7 metric tons
steel billets / ingots per steel billets / ingots per
heat, is located on 6- heat, is located on 6-
KM, Dewan Road, KM, Dewan Road,
Eminabad, Gujranwala Eminabad, Gujranwala
. However, due to . However, due to
ongoing electricity ongoing electricity
crisis, now a days, the crisis, now a days, the
entity is operating with entity is operating with
one shift of 12 hours one shift of 12 hours
and producing 60 and producing 60
metric tons steel billets metric tons steel billets
/ ingots/day. / ingots/day.
Rajput Steel Industry, Rajput Steel Industry,
established in the year established in the year
2008, is a sole 2008, is a sole
proprietorship concern proprietorship concern
owned by Mr. Abdul owned by Mr. Abdul
Aziz Khan, and is Aziz Khan, and is
engaged in engaged in
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 30
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
manufacturing of steel manufacturing of steel
billets / ingots, through billets / ingots, through
melting process. Mr. melting process. Mr.
Abdul Aziz Khan is an Abdul Aziz Khan is an
extensively extensively
experienced person. He experienced person. He
had been working as a had been working as a
scrap dealer in Karachi scrap dealer in Karachi
since 1988 till 1999. He since 1988 till 1999. He
joined Sanjam Steel joined Sanjam Steel
Furnace, Gujranwala as Furnace, Gujranwala as
a partner in year 2000 a partner in year 2000
and remained partner and remained partner
till 2007. Having till 2007. Having
practically engaged practically engaged
with this industry/trade with this industry/trade
business line, he business line, he
gained enough gained enough
experience & experience &
knowledge, to run a knowledge, to run a
steel furnace industrial steel furnace industrial
unit, smoothly, unit, smoothly,
profitably & profitably &
independently. independently.
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
Therefore, he set up Information Therefore, he set up
62 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 14-Sep-2020
Rajput Steel Industry in security Rajput Steel Industry in
revaluation?
the year 2008 with Ch. the year 2008 with Ch.
Muhammad Saeed Muhammad Saeed
Khan as a partner, who Khan as a partner, who
after a year left this after a year left this
industry/business line, industry/business line,
share of whom was share of whom was
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 31
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
purchased by Mr. Abdul purchased by Mr. Abdul
Aziz Khan; since then Aziz Khan; since then
Mr. Aziz khan is Mr. Aziz khan is
running this entity & running this entity &
unit being its sole unit being its sole
owner. The industrial owner. The industrial
unit of the entity, unit of the entity,
comprising of one Hi- comprising of one Hi-
tech imported furnace tech imported furnace
backed by related backed by related
machinery / equipment machinery / equipment
having capacity to having capacity to
produce 7 metric tons produce 7 metric tons
steel billets / ingots per steel billets / ingots per
heat, is located on 6- heat, is located on 6-
KM, Dewan Road, KM, Dewan Road,
Eminabad, Gujranwala Eminabad, Gujranwala
. However, due to . However, due to
ongoing electricity ongoing electricity
crisis, now a days, the crisis, now a days, the
entity is operating with entity is operating with
one shift of 12 hours one shift of 12 hours
and producing 60 and producing 60
metric tons steel billets metric tons steel billets
/ ingots/day. / ingots/day.
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 32
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
64 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 14-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the Risk
the matter to Group the matter to Group
65 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Management 28-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation? Group
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the the matter to Group the matter to Group
Information
66 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Chief RMG and Chief RMG and 21-Sep-2020
security
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 33
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
69 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 07-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 34
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
O/s:
KASHIF SPINNING MILLS BTF:
232,312,321.
XXV 232,312,321.00 M ORR 1
Expiry: 15-Sep-2020 00 M
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
70 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for KYC 14-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the Risk
the matter to Group the matter to Group
71 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Management 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation? Group
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
72 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 28-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 35
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 36
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Retail Banking the matter to Group
76 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 30-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Group Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
77 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for KYC 21-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
78 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for KYC 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information the matter to Group
79 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for 29-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and security Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 37
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was pledged stocks was
conducted by referring conducted by referring
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group the matter to Group
80 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Retail 28-Sep-2020
Chief RMG and Chief RMG and
revaluation?
obtaining his formal obtaining his formal
approval for approval for
revaluation? revaluation?
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 38
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 39
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
CPM Observations
.
Action Required /
Nature SR # Observation Responsibility Management Comments
Recommendation
PAK PIPE INDUSTRIES PVT
I LTD ORR 1
Expiry: 28-Sep-2020
Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was
conducted by referring Is revaluation of pledged stocks was
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information conducted by referring the matter to
1 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for
Chief RMG and security Group Chief RMG and obtaining his
revaluation?
obtaining his formal formal approval for revaluation?
approval for
revaluation?
Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was
conducted by referring Is revaluation of pledged stocks was
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group conducted by referring the matter to
2 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for Marketing
Chief RMG and Group Chief RMG and obtaining his
revaluation?
obtaining his formal formal approval for revaluation?
approval for
revaluation?
MASTER WOOL SPINNERS ORR 1
II
Expiry: 09-Sep-2020 Recommended ORR 2
Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 40
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Is revaluation of
pledged stocks was
conducted by referring Is revaluation of pledged stocks was
Is revaluation of pledged stocks was conducted by referring the
the matter to Group Information conducted by referring the matter to
5 matter to Group Chief RMG and obtaining his formal approval for
Chief RMG and security Group Chief RMG and obtaining his
revaluation?
obtaining his formal formal approval for revaluation?
approval for
revaluation?
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 41
CREDIT RISK REVIEW
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION 3216-Final Testing CRR
Portfolio Breakup
Executive Summary
Audit Code (Final Testing CRR) 42