Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
net/publication/3275077
CITATIONS READS
31 4,544
7 authors, including:
He Jinliang R. Zeng
Tsinghua University Tsinghua University
772 PUBLICATIONS 8,487 CITATIONS 359 PUBLICATIONS 3,731 CITATIONS
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Characteristics of aluminum agglomeration at burning surface in AP/AN composite propellants View project
All content following this page was uploaded by He Jinliang on 26 December 2014.
Abstract—Grounding system is very important to maintain the not in good sites with low soil resistivity, but on the hill or in
safe and reliable operation of power network and ensure the safety other regions with high soil resistivity.
of power apparatus and operators. A new technique to decrease High grounding resistance would affect the safe operation of
grounding resistance of substation is presented in this paper, which
makes use of deep ground well to decrease the grounding resis- power system. Several various methods had been applied to de-
tance. The ground well is formed by metal tube with water perco- crease the grounding resistance of the grounding system. Reg-
lation apertures in the soil with groundwater, which has the ability ular methods include enlarging the grounding grid, connecting
to gather the groundwater and wet the surrounding soil. The prin- the main grounding grid with a subsidiary external grounding
ciple of deep ground well to decrease grounding resistance is to de- grid, increasing the burial depth of the grounding grid, utilizing
crease the resistivity of the soil region surrounding the grounding
well by leading the groundwater moving to the deep ground well natural grounding object such as steel foundations of structures,
under pressure, and consequently decrease the grounding resis- adding long vertical grounding electrodes, and changing the
tance of the deep ground well. This novel method was applied in soils around the grounding grid with low resistivity materials.
a substation grounding engineering, and good effect was achieved. These methods are suitable for different geographical situations
Index Terms—Deep ground well, grounding electrode, grounding but that does not mean they should be taken up independently.
resistance, grounding system, soil resistivity, substation. In fact, in a specific soil environment, two or more methods
should be taken up to decrease the grounding resistance effec-
tively. The method to add deep vertical grounding electrodes to
I. INTRODUCTION
the grounding grid is very effective especially in urban substa-
Fig. 4. Sketch diagram of groundwater movement. Fig. 5. Forming low-resistivity channel connecting with the soil layer
containing saturated water.
The steel tube is inserted into the drilled hole. A deep ground
well is connected by several short steel tubes, two short tubes are
connected together by straight fitting, and the connecting region
Fig. 8. Schematic diagram of the grounding system with the deep ground well
is welded as shown in Fig. 7(b). The gap between the sidewall for 110-kV Luohu Substation.
of the drilled hole and the steel tube is filled with carbon powder
with very low resistivity by pressure. The filled carbon powder
has good water absorbability, which can keep itself and neigh- substation. The total lengths of these 10 deep ground wells are
boring soil in humidified state. On the other hand, the carbon 130 m, and total lengths of those horizontal grounding electrode
powder has good permeability, the groundwater can easily move to connect the deep ground wells with the grounding grid are
inside the ground well through it. In order to impede the carbon about 600 m.
powder into the steel tube, special filtering film is used to cover
these permeable holes on the steel tube. Other materials, such B. Field Installation Method
as fine loess or bentonite, can be used to fill the gap between A drilling machine was used to drill the hole for a deep ground
the sidewall of the drilled hole and the steel tube. The top of the well; the diameter of the drilled holes is 150 mm. Galvanized
steel tube to the ground is 1 m, a small aeration hole is left to steel tubes with inner diameter of 40 mm and thickness of 5 mm
keep the pressure in the well is the air pressure. were used as the grounding electrode of deep ground well. Water
permeating holes were drilled uniformly on the steel tube. A
V. APPLICATION OF DEEP GROUND WELL deep ground well has several segments of short steel tubes with
a length of about 6 m, and short steel tubes were connected
A. Description of the Engineering together by connecting straight fittings.
The proposed deep-ground-well method was applied in the Fine carbon powders with good conductivity were filled into
grounding system reconstruction engineering of 110-kV Luohu the gaps between the steel tube and the drilled hole by high
Substation in Heyuan city, Guandong Province, China, where pressure to ensure carbon powder having good contact with the
belongs to southern China, there is abundant groundwater steel tube and the surrounding soil.
resource.
The 110-kV Luohu Substation locates in hill region, the old C. Measuring Results and Analysis
substation grounding grid was built in September 1984, and The reconstructing engineering was fulfilled in December
the original area of this grounding grid is about 90 90 m , 1999. After one month, the grounding resistances of all ten
the tested grounding resistance is 1.79 . In 1989, the area of deep ground wells were measured. Before measurement, the
this grounding grid was enlarged to 90 120 m , in the mean- connecting conductors between the grounding grid and the
time, horizontal grounding electrodes were added to connect ground well were untied; the measured results of all ten deep
the grounding devices of transmission lines together, as illus- ground wells were shown in Table I.
trated in Fig. 8, the added area is about 3000 m , and the tested The apparent soil resistivity data under different electrode
grounding resistance was 1.35 . span by Wenner four-electrode configuration were measured
The grounding system of 110-kV Luohu Substation was re- [4], too. The measured results in the west and south of sub-
built in the end of 1999 by applying this novel deep-ground-well station are different from the results measured in the north-east
method. The schematic diagram of the grounding system with of substation, The average data were shown in Fig. 9; the ana-
the deep ground well for 110-kV Luohu Substation is shown in lyzed results show the soil geological structure of substation can
Fig. 8. Ten deep ground wells were added, the lengths of these be handled as 3 horizontal layers, the resistivity and thickness
ten deep ground wells are in the range between 11 m to 15 m. of the first layer is 112.50 m and 2.05 m, the resistivity and
In order to decrease the shielding effect of the grounding grid thickness of the second layer is 452.50 m and 4.50 m, the re-
to vertical deep grounding wells, they are arranged around the sistivity of the third soil layer is 161.50 m.
742 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 20, NO. 2, APRIL 2005
TABLE I
GROUNDING RESISTANCE TESTED RESULTS OF TEN DEEP GROUND WELLS
Fig. 11.Equivalent low-resistivity region of deep ground well with the shape of
(a) cylinder and semi-sphere in the bottom and (b) cylinder.
TABLE II
ANALYZED WIDTH OF EQUIVALENT LOW-RESISTIVITY REGION
Fig. 9. Relationship between the apparent soil resistivity and the test electrode VI. ESTIMATION OF EQUIVALENT LOW-RESISTIVITY REGION
span by Wenner four-electrode configuration. FORMED BY DEEP GROUND WELL
The deep ground well can be treated as a vertical grounding
electrode with low-resistivity region around it, which can be
modeled by a cylinder region, the bottom region is modeled as
a semi-sphere region as shown in Fig. 11(a). But the grounding
resistance of this equivalent model is difficultly calculated. So,
a cylinder region is used to simulate the low-resistivity region
around the deep ground well as shown in Fig. 11(b), is the
diameter of the steel tube, and is the equivalent width of the
low-resistivity region.
The grounding resistance of a deep ground well can be calcu-
Fig. 10. Geological structure of the substation area. lated by numerical analysis software package according to the
horizontal multi-layer soil model analyzed above. The CDEGS
software package was used in our analysis [5]. The resistivity
According to the soil drilled out, the first 2 m soil is black in the equivalent cylinder soil region is supposed as 0, the ana-
sandy one, then gravel soil layer and loess layer with thickness lyzed results of deep-ground-well’s (DGW’s) equivalent width
of 3 to 5 m appear alternately as shown in Fig. 10. Below the are illustrated in Table II. The analyzed equivalent width is in
second gravel soil layer, the soil is moist. The gravel soil layer is the range of 0.26 m to 2.04 m, and the average width is 1.44 m.
full of apertures, which has very good capability to keep water. So the diameter of the equivalent region with low-resistivity is
The first loess layer is close-grained, which prevents the ground- 0.57 to 4.13 m, and the average diameter is 2.93 m. The diam-
water volatilized. eter of the ground well is 50 mm, then the equivalent diameters
Before adding these ten deep ground wells, the grounding re- are 11.4 to 40.8 times of that of the ground well.
sistance of the grounding grid is 1.35 , and the area is about
11 000 m , so the estimated equivalent resistivity is 283.2 m.
A. Equivalent Soil Resistivity of Deep Ground Well
After these ten deep ground wells were added to the grounding
grid, the tested grounding resistance is 0.5 by the fall-of-po- As discussed above, the deep ground well can be analyzed as
tential method [4], this value keeps unchanged in every year rou- a vertical grounding electrode, if the soil is regarded as uniform,
tine test. The total area of the grounding system is about 14 600 then the equivalent resistivity of each deep ground well can be
m , the respective equivalent resistivity decreases to about 120.8 calculated by [4]
m. Comparing with the 1.35 , the grounding resistance is de-
creased about 63%. These deep-ground-wells are very powerful
to decrease grounding resistance.
HE et al.: DECREASING GROUNDING RESISTANCE OF SUBSTATION BY DEEP-GROUND-WELL METHOD 743
TABLE III grid should be decreased to 0.5 by these ten popular vertical
EQUIVALENT SOIL RESISTIVITIES OF TEN GROUND WELLS grounding electrodes, then all their length should be 40 m,
this shows the deep-ground-well is powerful in decreasing
grounding resistance of substation. For the grounding system
with deep-ground-wells in Fig. 8, the numerically analyzed
grounding resistance of the grounding system is 0.528 , which
is very close to 0.5 measured by field test.
REFERENCES Rong Zeng (M’02) was born in Shaanxi, China, in 1971. He received the B.Sc.,
M.Eng., and Ph.D. degrees from the Department of Electrical Engineering, Ts-
[1] IEEE Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding, IEEE Standard
inghua University, Beijing, respectively, in 1995, 1997, and 1999.
80-2000, 2000. He became a Lecturer in the Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua
[2] Q. B. Meng, J. L. He, F. P. Dawalibi, and J. Ma, “A new methods to de-
University, in August 1999, and an Associate Professor in the same depart-
crease ground resistances of substation grounding systems in high resis- ment, Tsinghua University in December 2002. His research interests include
tivity regions,” IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 911–916, high voltage technology, grounding technology, power electronics, and distri-
1999.
bution system automation.
[3] G. H. Li, Z. C. Liu, and X. Zhang, Water Resource Application and Man-
agement Engineering. Beijing, China: Tsinghua Univ. Press, 1998.
[4] IEEE Guide for Measuring Earth Resistivity, Ground Impedance, and
Earth Surface Potentials of a Ground System, ANSI/IEEE Std. 81-1983,
1983.
[5] F. P. Dawalibi and F. Donoso, “Integrated analysis software for
grounding, EMF, and EMI,” IEEE Comput. Applicat. Power, vol. 6, no.
2, pp. 19–24, 1993.
Bo Zhang was born in Datong, China, in 1976. He received the B.Sc. and
Ph.D. degrees in theoretical electrical engineering from the North China Elec-
Jinliang He (M’02–SM’02) was born in Changsha, China, in 1966. He tric Power University, Baoding, in 1998 and 2003, respectively.
received the B.Sc. degree from Wuhan University of Hydraulic and Electrical Currently, he is a Postdoctoral Researcher in the Department of Electrical En-
Engineering, Wuhan, China, the M.Sc. degree from Chongqing University, gineering at Tsinghua University. His research interests include computational
Chongqing, China, and the Ph.D. degree from Tsinghua University, Beijing, electromagnetics, grounding technology, and EMC in power systems.
China, all in electrical engineering, in 1988, 1991, and 1994, respectively.
He became a Lecturer in 1994, and an Associate Professor in 1996, in the De-
partment of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University. From 1994 to 1997, he
was the Head of High Voltage Laboratory in Tsinghua University. From April
1997 to April 1998, he was a Visiting Scientist in Korea Electrotechnology
Research Institute in Changwon, Korea, involved in research on metal oxide
varistors and high voltage polymeric metal oxide surge arresters. In 2001, he
was promoted to Professor at Tsinghua University. Now he is the Vice Chief
of High Voltage Research Institute in Tsinghua University. His research inter-
ests include overvoltages and EMC in power systems and electronic systems, Jun Zou was born in Wuhan, China, in 1971. He received the B.S. and M.S.
grounding technology, power apparatus, dielectric material, and power distribu- degrees from Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, Henan Province, in July 1994
tion automation. He is the authors of four books and many technical papers. and July 1997, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree from Tsinghua University in
Dr. He is a senior member of China Electrotechnology Society, and a Beijing, in July 2001, all in electrical engineering.
member of the International Compumag Society. He is the China representative He became a lecturer in the Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua
of IEC TC 81, vice chief of China Lightning Protection Standardization Tech- University in Beijing in August 2001. His research fields include computational
nology Committee, and members of Electromagnetic Interference Protection electromagnetics and EMC.
Committee and Transmission Line Committee of China Power Electric Society,
member of China Surge Arrester Standardization Technology Committee, and
member of Overvoltage and Insulation Coordination Standardization Tech-
nology Committee and Surge Arrester Standardization Technology Committee
in Electric Power Industry. He is the chief editor of the Journal of Lightning
Protection and Standardization (in Chinese).
Gang Yu was born in Shandong, China, in 1961. He received the B.Sc. degree Zhicheng Guan was born in Jilin, China, in 1944. He received the B.Sc.,
from Shandong University of Technology, in 1972, and the M.Eng. degree from M.Eng., and Ph.D. degrees from the Department of Electrical Engineering,
China Electric Power Research Institute in 1998. He is doing part-time research Tsinghua University, Beijing, China, respectively in 1970, 1981, and 1984.
for a Ph.D. degree in Tsinghua University. From 1984 to 1987, he was a Lecturer and the Director of High Voltage Lab-
Now he is Deputy President of China Power Engineering Consulting (Group). oratory in the Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University. From
His research field includes power system design, electromagnetic environment 1988 to 1989, he was a visiting Scholar in University of Manchester Institute
of power system, and grounding technology. of Science and Technology (UMIST), U.K. From 1989 to 1991, he was an As-
sociate Professor and the Director of High Voltage Laboratory. In 1991, he was
promoted to a Professor of Tsinghua University. From 1992 to 1993, he was the
Head of the Department of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University. From
Jingping Yuan was born in Heyuan, Guangdong, China, in 1966. He received 1993 to 1994, he was the Assistant President of Tsinghua University, and from
the B.Sc. from the Department of Electrical Engineering, South China Univer- 1994 to 1999, he was the vice President of Tsinghua University, and since March
sity of Technology, Guangzhou, July 1988, and the M.Eng. from the Department 1999, he has been the Vice President of Tsinghua University Council. His major
of Electrical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing, in 2002. research fields include high voltage insulation and electrical discharge, com-
He is now a Senior Engineer in Heyuan Electric Power Company, Guang- posite insulators and flashover of contaminated insulators, electrical environ-
dong, China. His research interests include high voltage technology, grounding ment technology, high voltage measurement, and application of plasma and high
technology, power electronics and distribution system automation, and power voltage technology in biological and environment engineering. He owns many
system management. titles in academic societies. He is the author of more than 150 academic papers.