Answer

Correct Answer TIVANIA PUTRI AS SOFYANA DPM

Question
1 None of the above 0 0 0 0
The rebuttal weakens the argument, but 1 1 1 0
2 does not defeat it entirely

1. The team must show that the practical

benefits of their side's position outweight
the concrete practical harms.
3 0.5 0.5 0.5 1
2. That team must have done the most to
persuade a reasonable, neutral observer
that the policy should be enacted (if on
Govt), ot that it should not be enacted (if on
Opps).

4 They are the only speech, which the judge is 0 1 1 1

allowed to assess using her own spesific
values, knowledge, and opinion as it is the
last speech in the debate.
5 True 1 1 1 1

6 If an argument is 'principled', that does not 1 0 1 1

necessarily mean it is better than one that is
'practical'. It depends what the argument is
trying to prove and how well it does so.

Closing Opposition’s argument proves the

same point as Opening Opposition’s
argument,but proves it substantially better.
7 Therefore Opening Opposition should be 1 1 1 0
credited for the parts they proved and
Closing Opposition should be credited only
for the additional analysis they added.

This definition was not quite a squirrel,

8 though it was clearly not in the spirit of the 1 1 1 1
motion. The leader of the opposition did the
right thing in complaining about the debate
but debating it nonetheless.

9 Compromise. As second place is the best 1 1 1 0

approximation to the actual opinion of the
panel, this is where first opposition should
finish. Explain this to your wings.
 On this particular point, it’s a complete tie.
10 Both sides can claim credit for their 1 1 1 1
contributions, but neither is in any way
winning this particular issue at this point in
time.
Total Theoretical score 7.5 7.5 8.5 6
Percentage 2.25 2.25 2.55 1.8
Practical score 0 7 5 0
Percentage 0 4.9 3.5 0
OVERAL TOTAL SCORE 2.25 7.15 6.05 1.8

CONGRATULATION FOR PUTRI AS

My evaluation of Practical test:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BFWdZPYnbz8sBQWJB6fzckmNi50ECxQ95ld841cjOEE/edit?usp=sharing
1cjOEE/edit?usp=sharing