Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1993
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
(Nwaugo et al., 2006a). In Nigeria concrete pit zone. Second sample came from the
data concerning the effects of drilling wastes drilling waste pit zone i.e., the fallout point
in inland water bodies are very scanty (Ifeadi (FP). Two downstream samples were
et al., 1985; Benker-Coker and Olumagan, analyzed as downstream 1 (DS 1), 120m
1996). away from fallout area and downstream 11
Considering the increasing production (DS 11), about 120m from downstream 1. At
of oil in Nigeria and the accompanying each sampling area, water column was
improper disposal of the drilling wastes so collected in triplicate and pooled together to
generated, there is need for environmental make one sample. Samples were collected
impact assessment of these practices.. This thrice for physicochemical parameters
work therefore examines the environmental analysis at one month interval while ten
effects of over flooding and seepage of samples were collected for microbiological
drilling wastes pit contents into Orashi River, analysis at two weeks interval within the
Egbema, Rivers State, Nigeria. same period of study.
The water sampling bottles for the
Materials and Methods analyses were washed clean and soaked in
Study Area acid-alcohol for 24 hours. They were rinsed
The study area is Egbema, Rivers in sterile de-ionized water and kept for use.
State. Egbema is located at the northern apex With sterile disposable hand gloves, the
of Rivers State and has all the features of a bottles were lowered into the water body
typical tropical climate of the rainforest type. against the current 2-3 cm below the surface
The area has two distinct seasons – rainy and to obtain water column samples. Using
dry seasons. While the rainy season spans similar bottles, the sediments were similarly
from March to September, the dry season collected from the shores without diving into
covers October to February. the water. The collected samples were then
Several oil companies operate in the pooled as described earlier and taken to the
area, drilling several oil wells in the process laboratories within 1-2 hours of collection.
and the disposal of the wastes generated is
often improperly done. This is because no Analysis of samples;
cemented embankments are made for the Physicochemical analysis;
waste/burrow pits (Ifeadi et al., 1985). The physicochemical parameters
The particular portion of study is a measured include pH, temperature, salinity,
recent well drilled about 85m from the banks total dissolved solid (TDS), total soluble
of Orashi River and the wastes were buried solids (TSS), dissolved oxygen (DO) and
within the same vicinity. The well-head biological oxygen demand (BOD), sulphate
equipment (Christmas tree) was raised on a (SO4) nitrate (NO3) and phosphates (PO4).
metal platform to ensure safety during The temperature and pH were measured at
flooding as the entire area is covered by the site (on the spot) using multipurpose
water during the floods . This work was tester (Model Jenway HANNA 1910). The
done between June, 2005 – September, DO and BOD were measured using the
2006. Winklers titration method as described in
Sample Collection APHA (1992). The SO4, NO3, PO4, TDS and
The samples analyzed were obtained TSS were determined using the
from four (4) different sampling sites of the spectrophotometric method with HACH/D2/
Orashi River. One of the sites was upstream 2010 spectrophotometer at various
(control), 120m up before the drilling waste wavelengths, depending on the parameters.
1994
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
The metallic ions of Ca, K, Na and square, standard deviation and ANOVA
Mg were determined using the flame atomic (Analysis of Variance).
absorption spectrophotometric (AAS) method
of APHA (1992). The oil content of the Results
samples was analyzed using the method of The values of the various
Okpokwasili and Okorie, (1988). physiochemical parameters analyzed are
shown in Table 1. Most parameters measured
Microbiological Analysis had their highest values in the fallout point
The various samples were inoculated (FP). These include salinity, total dissolved
on Tryptone soy agar using streaking solids (TDS), total soluble Solids (TSS),
technique. The observed colonies were biological oxygen demand (BOD) and
subcultured to obtain pure isolates which carbonate (CO3). Others were sulphate (SO4),
were subjected to macroscopy followed by phosphate (PO4), and nitrate (NO3). The
microscopy (after staining) and biochemical second highest values were seen in the
tests as described by Chessbrough (2001) and downstream 1 and downstream 11. Values of
Cowan and Steel, (1976). They were cross- these parameters from the upstream samples
checked according to Buchanan and Gibbons were the lowest (Table 1). The values
(1976) for proper identification. showed statistical significance (P=0.05) in
Further microbiological analyses were the direction of fallout zone > downstream 1
done based on the effect of the drilling > downstream 11 > upstream. In the case of
wastes on some groups of bacteria. The total DO, more was seen in the up stream sample,
heterotrophic bacteria (THB) were cultured followed by the downstream II, and then
on Nutrient Agar, hydrocarbon utilizing downstream I with the least in fallout point.
bacteria (HUB) on modified mineral salt For metallic ions, only Na+ showed
agar, and coliform bacteria (CB) on statistical significance as the values changed
McConkey agar as described by Okpokwasili from 0.2 mg/l in the upstream (US) to 1.01 in
and Okorie (1988), and Nwokoro and the fallout point (FP) but this decreased to
Okpokwasili (2003). 0.85 and 0.53 mg/l in DS 1 and DS 11
Screening of isolates for Chrome – respectively. The oil contents also showed
lignosulfonate utilization the highest values in the FP (16.5 mg/l),
Screening of isolates was done followed by the DS 1 11.3 and then 8.11 in
according to Okpokwasili and Okorie (1988) the DS 11. The upstream (US) samples had
using modified Mineral Salt Medium of Mills the least values of 1.2 mg/l. Results obtained
el al (1978). To 9.9 ml of the medium was showed that the pH changed from slightly
added 0.1 ml of the drilling waste from the alkaline 7.05 in US, through 6.89 in DS 11,
waste burrow pits. This was incubated at 6.62 in DS 1 and then to the least 6.31 in FP.
room temperature for one week (7 day) and The temperature rose from 27.1oC in US to
then examined for growth using turbidity and 29.3oC in FP decreasing gradually till 28.5oC
pH change as indicators. in DS 11.
Statistical analysis; The bioloads of the various groups of
The various data generated in this organisms as shown on Table 2 indicated a
investigation were subjected to various definite gradient. Highest values were
statistical analysis to find out if there were observed in the DS 1 followed by the DS 11
significant differences among the sites. The before the FP. The US had lowest values of
statistical methods applied include Chi- each bacterial group except coliforms with
lowest bioload in the FP (3.9 X 102 cfu/ml).
1995
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
The values obtained are as shown in Table 2; Nwaugo et al, (2007a, 2009). Again, Carlton
for THB count, it was DS 1 (5.2 x 104) > 4.9 and Darby (1985) reported that Drilling –
x 104 (DSII) > 3.3 x 104 (US). The same operations affected the physicochemical
trend continued with the other bacterial properties of Alabama Mobile Bar Waters, a
groups but with lower biolaods. In all the fact also expressed by Wills (2000) and
sampling points, the order was THB > HUB Richards and Love (2002). This is similar to
> CB except in the upstream (US) where CB the findings of this study. However, the little
was higher than the HUB. The other oil observed in the upstream showed that
observations were similar. other activities upstream had added the oil.
In the prevalence of each observed All the observed parameters which changed
organism (Table 3), a similar trend as in values showed a common gradient. Most
observed in bioloads was also recorded. In of them had lower values in the upstream but
the US samples, most prevalent organism increased in the fallout point and decreased
was Bacillus species (80%) followed by again from DS 1 to DS 11. This showed the
Saccharomyces species (60%) while the least diluting effects of the water as one moved
were Serratia, Pseudomonas and Alcaligenes away from the Fallout Zone.
species with 30% each. On the other hand, Several researchers working on oil
the highest prevalence of each organism was related matters have at various places and
observed in the DS 1 samples except time isolated most of the organisms observed
Streptococcus species which did not change in this study. Pseudomonas, Alcaligenes,
much (Table 3). The highest prevalence was Serratia, Saccharomyces and Micrococcus
in DS 1, followed by DS 11, the FP and then species have been reported in oil
the US. This was statistically significant (P < contaminated sites (Enemchukwu and
0.05). Okpokwasili, 2000, Nnubia and Okpokwasili,
Results obtained from the screening 1993, 1997; Benker-Coker and Olumagan
of chrome lignosulfonate utilization (Table 4) 1996, Spain and Vanveld, 1983; Nwaugo et
showed that Enterobacter and Xanthomonas al., 2007b). However, not much report have
species did not metabolize chronic been made of Xanthomanas, Enterobacter,
lignosulphate as there was no change in Eschericha and Streptococcus species in oil
turbidity and pH. On the other hand polluted area but their presence in natural
Saccharomyces, Pseudomonas and Serratia water bodies had been a major issue
species utilized the test substrate. These (Nwaugo et al., 2006b, Nwachukwu and
organisms showed high turbidity (growth) Otukanefor, 2003 and Okpokwasili and
and change in pH (towards acidity). Akujuobi, 1996). Ogbulie (1996) had also
reported the presence of these organisms and
Discussion others in a fish-farm in the study area. Some
The analysis of the physicochemical of these organisms have also been associated
parameters at the various sampling points with human activities (Prescott et al, 2001).
showed some variations in some parameters This further explains the presence of such
while a few did not really change. Salinity, organisms as Saccharomyces, Eschericha,
TDS, TSS, BOD and DO showed extensive Micrococcus and Staphylococcus species as
increase from the FP till the DS II indicating Orashi Rivers serves several purposes for the
adverse effects of the wastes. Among the Egbema people including recreational
metallic elements only Na+ showed statistical domestic, occupational and food processing
change from 0.4 (US) to 1.01 (FP) mg/ml. (Cassava Fermentation).
Similar situation had earlier been reported by
1996
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
The prevalence of each of the in THB was because THB encompass all
observed organisms varied according to the groups of organisms (Chessbrough, 2001).
sampling point. The down stream (DS 1) had Screening of isolates for chorme-
the highest prevalence, followed by the lignosulfate further explained the observation
downstream (DS 11) and the upstream (US) in the prevalence and bioload. While
before the fallout zone (FP). This showed Pseudomonas, Serratia, Saccharomyces
that the organisms were present in the water Staphylococcus and Alcaligenes species have
but in low level before the pollution. The at various times and places been implicated
high prevalence observed in the DS 1 showed in oil spillage and its remediation, other
that the drilling wastes from the FP was organisms are not common in oil polluted
diluted which enhanced microbial growth in habitats. These were the major organisms
the DS I. Nwaugo et al., (2006b) had earlier which utilized the drilling wastes. Bacillus,
observed this dilution effects in abandoned Micrococcus and Staphylococcus species
quarry pit waters. With the dilution, the only metabolized very little of the substrate
levels of the concentrations of waste water while Xanthomonas and Enterobacter species
were moderated, resulting in the utilization of could not. Atlas (1981), Benker-Coker and
the drilling wastes as nutrients by the Olumagen (1996),Okpokwasili and Okorie
microorganisms. Organisms which could not (1988) and Nwaugo et al, (2007b)had
metabolize the wastes utilized the less toxic implicated these organisms too. Analysis of
intermediates produced by the drilling wastes utilization of Chrome-lignosulfate showed a
utilizers. change of pH towards acidity. Metabolism of
Observations in the bioloads of the various the substrate turned the medium acidic. The
groups of organisms investigated agreed with level of acidity was commensurate with the
the prevalence explained above. Highest level of chrome-lignosulfate utilization as
bioloads were observed in the DS 1 but shown by Pseudomonas, Serratia and
decreased in DS 11. This showed that the Sacharonmyces species along with
wastes, though foreign, were metabolized as Staphylococcus and Alcaligenes species
nutrients hence the increases in numbers, but showed much change in pH (towards acidity)
the nutrient decreased in DS 11 resulting in Xanthomonas and Enterobacter species
lower bioload. The most adversely affected which could not utilize the substrate, could
were the coliforms while the most not change the pH of the medium. This
beneficiaries were the total heterotrophic observation agrees with Nweke and
bacteria (THB). The hydrocarbon utilizing Okpokwasili (2004) Okpokwasili and Okorie
bacteria (HUB) also increased extensively in (1988) Enenchukwu and Okpokwasili (2000)
line with the increase in oil content. Richard and Nwaugo et al,(2009).
and Love (2002) and Wills (2000) reported In conclusion, the drilling waste
this increase in oil contents. The lignosulfate seepage and over flooding of the drilling
in the drilling wastes served as nutrients for waste pit caused extensive modification of
both the HUB and THB. The general increase the physicochemical and bacterial spectrum
of the Orashi River.
1997
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
Table 2; Bioload of the various groups of organisms observed in the water examples (cfu/ml).
Group of organism Upstream Fallout Point Downstream I Downstream II
THB 3.1 X 104 3.3 X 104 5.2 X 104 4.9 X 104
HUB 2.1 X 102 3.5 X 103 4.3 X 104 3.6 X 104
3 2
CB 2.3 X 10 3.9 X 10 4.3 X 104 3.1 X 103
*Values reported are averages of three samplings.
THB = total heteroltrophic bacterial;CB = coliform bacteria ;HUB = hydrocarbon utilizing bacteria
Table 3: Prevalence of Microbial species in the various water samples types analyzed
Upstream Fallout point Down stream I Down stream II
NE NO % NE NO % NE NO % NE NO %
Saccharamyces sp 10 6 60 10 5 50 10 6 60 10 7 70
Bacillus sp. 10 8 80 10 6 60 10 7 70 10 8 80
Pseudomonas sp 10 3 30 10 6 60 10 8 80 10 6 60
Alcaligenes sp. 10 3 30 10 5 50 10 7 70 10 7 70
Escharichia coli 10 5 50 10 4 40 10 7 70 10 6 60
Enterobacter sp. 10 4 40 10 4 40 10 5 50 10 5 50
Seiratia sp. 10 3 30 10 4 40 10 6 60 10 4 40
Staphylococcus sp 10 4 40 10 5 50 10 6 60 10 5 50
Micrococus sp 10 4 40 10 5 50 10 7 70 10 6 60
Streptococcus sp 10 4 40 10 3 30 10 3 30 10 3 30
NE=No. of samples examined; NO= No. of isolates observed; %=Percentage
1998
Ogbonna et al., 2010 Nig. J. Microbiol. 24(1): 1993 - 2000
Nwaugo, V.O., Etok, C.A., I.S.Onwuchekwa Oteri, A. U. (1985) Ground Water Pollution
and Chima, G.N. (2009) Assessment of Monitoring in Environmental
the physicochemical and microbial Investigation. The Petroleum Industry
diversity of Orashi River Flood plains and the Nigerian Environment. 1985
in Egbema. J. Appl. Sc 12(2) :8380 - Int. Oil Seminar NNPC. Nigeria.
8391 Prescot,t L.M., Harley, J.P and Klein, D.A.
Nweke, C.O. and Okpokwasili, G.S.C. (1999) Microbiology, Fourth edition,
(2003) Drilling fluid Base Oil WCB, McGraw Hill, Boston.
Biodegradation Potential of Soil Richards, M.T. and Love, W.W. (2002) Bulk
Staphylococcus species. Afr. J. Biotech. Transportation of Drilling waste
2(9) 293-295. AADE – 2002 Technology Conference.
Nwokoro, C. and Okpokwasili, G.C. (2003). Drilling and Completion Fluids and
Ex-situ bioremediation of oil- Waste Management, Radisson
contaminated sediment. Nig. J. Astrondoe Houston, Texas, April, 2-3
Microbiol. 17(2) 105-109. 2002.
Ogbulie, A.N. (1996). Microbial Ecology of Spain, J.C. and Vanveld, P.P. (1983)
Nigerian Fresh water Fish Culture Adaptation of natural microbial
System Ph.D Thesis. University of communities to degradation of
Port-Harcourt Rivers State, 90-167. Xenobiotic compound; effects of
Okpokwasili, G.S.C., and Akujuobi, T.C. concentration, exposure time,
(1996) Bacteriological indicators of innoculum and chemical structure.
tropical water quality. Envirm Toxicol Appl. Environ. Microbiol 45:428-436.
Water Quality Int. J. II: 77:81. Williams, K., Connon, G.E. and Johnson,
Okpokwasili, G.C.S. and Odokuma, C.O. D.G. (1981). Filtration properties of
(1996) Response of Nitrobacter to Drilling Muds. API – Drilling and
toxicity of drilling chemical. J. Petrol. sProduction Practices Williams and
Sec. Eng. 16: 81-87. Williams Co. London. 24-39.
Okpokwasili, G.C.S. and Okorie, B.B. Wills, J.C. (2000) A Survey of Offshore Oil
(1988) Biodeterioration potentials of Field Drilling Wastes and Disposal
micro-organisms isolated from car Techniques to reduce the Ecological
engine lubricating oil. Trib. Int. Impact of Sea Dumping. Sakhahm
21;215-220. Environment Water. 13:23-29.
2000