Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
• in the hardened state, achieves the required strength, 11.2 C&CI method
adequate durability, and satisfactory dimensional This method is derived from ACI Standard 211.1-91[11.2] and
stability; is based on the following:
• The strength, at a given age, of fully compacted concrete,
at the lowest cost. cured under standard conditions, is governed by water:
cement ratio w:c and type of cementitious material
Because of the large number of variables involved in used. Note: w:c means the ratio of total mass of the
designing a mix theoretically, the use of approximations and water in the mix, including water in the aggregates, to
short-cut methods is justified and undue refinements may the total mass of cementitious materials.
be discarded.
• The amount of water required per unit volume of
According to McIntosh:[11.1] concrete for a given consistence and with given materials
"Precise relationships have not been established is substantially constant regardless of cement content,
between the properties of concrete, and even the w:c or proportions of aggregates and cement. The
more specific characteristics of the mix such as water: main factors determining the amount of water are
cement ratio, aggregate:cement ratio and grading aggregate properties, cement properties, maximum
let alone such elusive qualities as aggregate particle size of the stone and the selected workability range.
shape and texture. The data used in selecting mix (This assumption is normally valid in the strength range
proportions should be expected to do no more than of 20 to 30 MPa, but the water requirement of concrete
serve as a guide. Mix design is a matter of trial and of strengths outside this range should be determined.)
error, and any calculations based on design data are • For any particular concrete mix and combination of
really only a means of making an intelligent guess at materials, there is an optimum stone content which
a starting point for the first tests to be made." depends on size, shape and compacted bulk density
of the stone, fineness modulus of the sand and desired
A competent concrete technologist can combine the science consistence of the concrete.
of mix design with experience and intuition and obtain
• The volume of compacted concrete produced by any
proportions which will be so close to the final figures that
combination of materials is equal to the sum of the
only one or, at most, two trial mixes will be required.
absolute volumes of the cement and aggregates plus the
volume of water and that of any entrapped or entrained
Mixes are normally proportioned in the laboratory using
air. The absolute volume of each material is calculated
samples of specific materials to be used for the concrete.
from the mass and the relative density of the material (D).
Proper care during sampling is essential in order to obtain
a representative sample, but clearly it is also important for
the materials being used in the concrete to be as uniform as Mass of material, kg . ..................(1)
Absolute volume, m3 =
possible. D x 1 000
This chapter describes a method of mix design used by the While all concrete mixtures contain some air, normally this
Cement & Concrete Institute and gives guidelines for mixes may be ignored when calculating the concrete yield, except
for some special applications. Worked examples are also when air-entraining admixtures are used.
included.
219
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
220
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
1 and 2: Specify strength of concrete and stone size Effective particle relative densities of blends of different
By the designer of the structure. Optimum stone size materials should be calculated as follows.
depends on the dimensions of structural elements, depth of
cover and spacing of reinforcement. D= 100
. .........................................(2)
%X %Y
Dx + Dy + ...
3: Specify slump
By the contractor to suit methods of transporting, placing where D is the effective particle relative density of the
and compacting. blend; %X and %Y are percentages by mass of materials X
and Y respectively in the blend; and Dx and Dy are particle
4, 5 and 6: Specify cement type, maximum w:c ratio and relative densities of materials X and Y respectively.
minimum cement content
By the designer/consultant to meet durability requirements. Values for factory-blended cements may be obtained from
Not done in all cases. Sometimes these items alone are cement producers.
insufficient to provide adequate durability and additional
protective measures, eg a protective coating, may have to be FA blends tend to reduce the quantity of water required for a
used. Specification should be in line with the latest relevant given consistence and permit higher stone contents.
code or technical literature.
11: Characterise stone
7: Select cement type and source CBD – Compacted bulk density is a measure of
By the mix designer for maximum economy but choice packing capacity.
could be overridden by action 4 above. (See Table 11.7 for RD – Particle relative density is needed to
guidelines for selecting cements and blends for specific calculate solid volume.
applications.) Consider all requirements for the concrete, Grading – A sieve analysis is done to determine or
eg any requirement for early strength. verify nominal size.
The strength performances of South African cements may be Note that the compressive strength of site-made, 150-mm cubes
obtained from cement producers. may be about 2 MPa lower than that of 100-mm laboratory
specimens. This difference is small and may be ignored.
Particle relative densities of some cementitious materials are
shown in Table 11.1. 14: Estimate water requirement, W
Table 11.1: Particle relative densities of cementitious materials Depends on:
• Particle shape and surface texture of sand
Material Particle relative density
• Stone size
CEM I 3,14
GGBS 2,9 • Required slump
FA 2,3
• Type of cementitious material (The inclusion of FA
CSF 2,1
tends to reduce water requirement.)
221
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
An estimate of the water content of the mix, using the 15: Calculate cement content, C
particular aggregate and cement combination selected, may C = W ÷ w:c from actions 13 and 14. May be overridden by
be made in one of three ways: requirement of action 6.
• By using figures obtained from mixes previously made
with the same materials 16: Calculate stone content
The formula for stone content is:
• By estimating, based on experience of similar materials
Ma = CBD (K - 0,1 FM) . . . . . . . . (3)
• By using average figures from Tables 11.2 and 11.3
where
The water contents given in Table 11.2 are for concrete made
Ma = mass of stone in one cubic metre of concrete, kg
with an optimum quantity of 19-mm stone and having a
slump of 75 mm. CBD = dry compacted bulk density of stone, kg/m3,
determined in accordance with SANS 5845 [11.3]
For other sizes of stone, adjust the water content by the K = a factor which depends on the maximum size
amount shown in Table 11.3. of the stone and the workability of the concrete
(Values for K are given in Table 11.4.)
A difference in water content of between 10 and 15 l/m3 will
FM = fineness modulus of sand determined in
normally halve or double the slump.
accordance with SANS 201[11.4]
Very poor 240 235 If a FA blend is used, calculated stone content may be
Poor 225 225
increased as shown in Table 11.5.
Maximum 25 4
size of 9,5 13,2 19,0 26,5 37,5
stone, mm 30 5
Correction, 40 6
3 +20 +10 0 -10 -20
l/m 50 7
K
Approximate
slump range, Placing
Maximum size of stone, mm
requirement
mm
9,5 13,2 19,0 26,5 37,5
* Calculated on CBD of 37,5-mm stone when using a blend of 37,5- and 19-mm stone
222
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
21: Approve mix To calculate the yield of a batch, add the total water content
Approve the mix if results of actions 19 and 20 are acceptable. and solid volumes of cement, sand and stone.
Make cubes, preferably for crushing at seven and 28 days, to
check that strength development is normal.
223
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
11.3 Mix design for special applications state, as a starting point for the design of AEC. To calculate
This section gives guidance on the design of mixes for the the proportions for the first trial mix of the AEC:
following:
• Reduce the water content by 7%.
• Concrete mixes for pumping
• Increase the cement content per m3 by 20 kg for lean
• Air-entrained concrete
concrete (20 MPa or less at 28 days) to 40 kg for rich
• High-density concrete concrete (30 MPa or more at 28 days).
• Low-density concrete • Use the same stone content.
• Mixes for compaction by heavy vibration • Include the volume of air expected to be entrained in
• Mixes made with very fine sand the calculation of absolute volumes.
• Shaft linings The design of AEC may require several trial mixes to
• Sliding formwork verify air content and consistence of the fresh concrete, and
strength of the hardened concrete.
11.3.1 Concrete mixes for pumping
The method of design is similar to that used for conventional 11.3.3 High-density concrete
concrete but, because of certain restrictions imposed by the Concrete with a high density may be produced by using
pump and pipeline system, there are some limitations to the high-density aggregates as discussed in Chapter 18.
range of materials and concretes that can be used:
The methods of design of mixes for high-density concrete
Cement content is usually in the range of 250 to 380 kg/m3, are the same as for normal-density concrete.[11.2] High-
however, concretes containing higher cement contents can density concretes are, however, more prone to segregation,
be pumped using suitable admixtures, if necessary. All particularly if there is a large difference in the particle
common cements are suitable for pumped concrete. The relative densities of the coarse and fine aggregates and if
inclusion of FA may improve pumpability. mixes with a high slump are used. Often a number of trial
attempts are required in order to produce a cohesive mix
Water content is normally about 10 to 15 l /m3 higher than with minimal segregation and bleeding.
in conventional concrete when slump is 125 mm.
11.3.4 Low-density concrete
Sand of good particle shape should be selected. At least Because of the difficulty of estimating water contents
20%, but preferably 30%, of the sand should pass the of mixes containing low-density aggregates, conventional
300-micron sieve. Sand content, by mass of total aggregate, methods of mix design as described in this chapter are
is generally about 3 to 8% higher than that for conventional usually unsatisfactory. Low-density mixes are often designed
mixes, and the fraction of sand by mass of total aggregate is on the basis of cement content rather than on w:c.
usually in a range of 38 to 55%.
Useful data on methods of designing mixes for low-
Stone of good particle shape is recommended. The size density concretes are given in the ACI Guide for structural
of stone for 100-mm delivery pipes should be limited to lightweight aggregate concrete[11.5] and in the FIP Manual
26,5 mm but 19,0 mm is preferable. The stone content may of lightweight aggregate concrete.[11.6]
be estimated using the K factor given in Table 11.4.
11.3.5 Mixes for compaction by heavy vibration
Admixtures are beneficial in some instances but they should Mixes of very low workability that are suitable for intense
be tested under site conditions. vibration are designed in the usual manner. Note that:
• Water content for very low workability will be about
A slump range of between 60 and 90 mm is regarded as 20 l/m3 less than for medium workability.
optimal for piston pumps, and 100 to 125 mm for pneumatic • Stone content may be determined from equation (3)
pumps. and Table 11.4.
224
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
11.3.6 Mixes made with very fine sand desired mix having characteristics not necessarily covered
In cases where the only available sand is very fine by conventional methods. It should preferably be done in a
(FM < 1,7), a satisfactory mix may be designed by using one laboratory pan mixer having a watertight pan.
of the following two approaches.
The method is especially suited to the design of mixes for:
The first approach is to blend 6,7-mm stone with the sand. • Exposed aggregate concrete
The ratio of 6,7-mm stone to sand should be such that the
• High stone content and heavy vibration
FM of the blend is about 2,5. Use equation (3) to determine
stone content. • Special placing conditions such as pumping and placing
by tremie
The second approach is to use a blend of two sizes of stone • High-strength concrete
instead of a single size. The smaller stone should be about
half of the size of the larger stone. As a starting point, use Method
a ratio of one part of smaller stone to two parts of larger 1 . Select w:c.
stone.
2. Weigh the water (usually 1,5 or 2,0 kg) and the cement
and place them in the mixer.
Insert the CBD for the larger stone together with its K value
from Table 11.4 in equation (3) to determine total stone 3. Have ready sufficient sand and stone weighed in
content. containers in easily handled quantities (5 or 10 kg).
225
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
= 665 kg
(The result is very different from the intuitive
[0,6 x 2,65] + [0,4 x 4,55] = 3,41.)
The quantities per cubic metre of concrete are therefore:
Cement 315 kg
Example 3: Design a trial mix
Sand 665 kg
Type CEM I 42,5N Stone 1 185 kg
Cement
Dc 3,14 Water 210 l
Ds 2,65
Sand FM 2,30
Example 4: Design a trial mix
Quality Average Type CEM I 42,5N
Given
Cement
Da 2,70 Dc 3,14
Stone Size 19,0 mm
Ds 2,65
CBD 1 540 kg/m3
Sand FM 1,90
Degree of control “Average” Quality Excellent
Given
Characteristic Da 2,74
25 MPa
strength at 28 days Stone Size 26,5 mm
Required
75 mm CBD 1 460 kg/m3
slump for Degree of control
Consistence
moderate " Good"
vibration
Characteristic
35 MPa
strength at 28 days
Step 1: W:C 25 mm
Required
Consistence
For “average” degree of control, strength margin is slump
10 MPa (see Table 16.1). For characteristic strength of
Maximum w:c for durability 0,43
25 MPa, target strength is therefore 25 + 10 = 35 MPa. From
cement producer,w:c = say, 0,67.
Step 1: W:C
Step 2: Water content For “good” degree of control, strength margin is 8,5 MPa
The sand is of average quality. (see Table 16.1).
Either from Table 11.2 or by visual examination of the sand, For characteristic strength of 35 MPa, target strength is
estimate the water content of the mix, say 210 l/m3. No therefore 35 + 8,5 = 43,5 MPa.
adjustment is necessary for size of stone (Table 11.3) because
the stone is 19,0 mm, or consistence because the required From cement producer: w:c for strength = 0,60.
consistence is 75-mm slump.
But maximum w:c is specified as 0,43; this value must be
Therefore water content = 210 l/m3 used.
Step 4: Stone content Adjustment for slump is minus 10 l (roughly, slump halves
From equation (3) and Table 11.4: for each 10 l reduction).
Ma = CBD (K - 0,1 FM)
= 1 540 (1,0 - 0,1 x 2,30) Water content = 180 - 10 - 10 = 160 l/m3
= 1 186 kg/m3, say 1 185 kg/m3
226
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
Step 3: Cement content The amount of moisture in the stone is usually very small
Mc = Water content and it is customary to ignore it.
w:c
= 160/0,43 Assume that the sand in Example 4 contains an estimated
= say 370 kg/m3 4% of moisture by mass. Adjustments are made as follows:
227
Fulton’s concrete technology • Concrete mix design
Application Comments
References
11.1 Mclntosh, J.D. Basic principles of concrete mix 11.5 ACI 213R-03, Guide for structural lightweight-
design, Proceedings of a Cement and Concrete aggregate concrete, Farmington Hills, Michigan:
Association symposium on mix design and American Concrete Institute, 2003.
quality control of concrete, London, May 1954,
11.6 Federation Internationale de la Precontraint
pp.3-27.
(FIP), FIP manual of lightweight aggregate
11.2 ACI 211.1-91, Standard practice for selecting concrete, 2nd ed. Glasgow: Surrey University
proportions for normal, heavyweight, and mass Press, 1983.
concrete, Farmington Hills, Michigan: American 11.7 Stewart, D. A. The design and placing of high
Concrete Institute, 1999. quality concrete, London: Spon, 1951.
11.3 SANS 5845:2006, Bulk densities and voids 11.8 SANS 1491:1, 2 and 3:2005-2006, Standard
content of aggregates, Pretoria, South African specification for portland cement extenders.
Bureau of Standards, 2006. Part 1: Ground granulated blastfurnace slag.
Part 2: Fly ash. Part 3: Condensed silica fume,
11.4 SANS 201:2008, Sieve analysis, fines content Pretoria: South African Bureau of Standards,
and dust content of aggregates, Pretoria: South 2005-2006.
African Bureau of Standards, 2002.
228