Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
Since 2009, this field has been operated by TVD), each of them with distinctive mineralogical and
Operaciones Rio Napo CEM (ORNCEM), a joint fluid characteristics:
venture company between PAM & PDVSA.
It currently has an average oil production of 72,000 LOWER HOLLIN RESERVOIR: consists of quartz
STB/D of oil with 26.5 °API from 225 active wells. Oil rich, consolidated cross-bedded sandstones, in part
is pumped up by different systems: electric submersible friable, generally coarse grained, subrounded to
pumps (ESP) 84%, hydraulic pump 14%, and subangular, well sorted with occasional clay matrix, and
mechanical pump 2%. local coal, seams displaying aggrading pattern. The
depositional environment for Lower Hollin varies from
The effect of volumetric reservoir pressure depletion incised valley fill at the base to braided system towards
was addressed through a water injection project carried the top. The reservoir characteristics are: 27.8 °API, Bo
out into 6 peripheral wells. Unfortunately, this has not 1.108 RB/STB, µo 4.42 cPs, Pi: 4450 psia, underlying
been sufficient enough for pressure boosting. As result, by a strong aquifer that maintain reservoir pressure. The
this condition has an enormous impact on drilling porosity generally is higher than 16% and permeabilities
campaign development and constitutes a risky factor in reach values of 600 mD on average.
wellbore operations.
UPPER HOLLIN RESERVOIR: is a fine to very fine
Under this scenario, ORNCEM has searched for grained, subrounded, well sorted, glauconitic rich quartz
alternative technologies to substitute the information sandstone, interbedded with thin limestone, marl, and
absence from not being able to run conventional open- shale (White et al, 1995.), consolidated, with clay matrix
hole well logs. The NEO technology by Baker Hughes and calcareous cement. The reservoir characteristics are:
offered an optimal solution for capturing information 27.8 °API, Bo 1.108 RB/STB, µo 4.42 cPs, Pi: 4450
under low operational risk. psia, current Pr (4287-2150 psia). Porosities are usually
lower than 13% and permeability ranges
This publication attempts to clarify the technical from 10 mD up to 50 mD.
aspects for the calibration of a neural network that has
yielded petrophysical data emulating open-hole curves NAPO T RESERVOIR: the lowermost section (lower
with their respective influence in the selection of areas Napo T) consists of light brown, medium to fine-
of completion. grained, locally coarse-grained quartz sandstone, with
calcareous cement and clay matrix. Towards the top
changes gradually (upper Napo T) to glauconitic
GEOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK sandstones interbedded with shales (White et al, 1997).
The reservoir characteristics are: 30.5 °API, Bo 1.27
RB/STB, µo 1.44 cPs, Pi: 4146 psia, current Pr (1200-
Structurally, the Sacha field consists of an anticlinal 2100 psia). Porosities usually are lower than 13% and
fold of north-south orientation, with 30 km long and 7 permeabilities up to 100 mD.
km wide in average. It is bounded to the west by a high
angle reverse fault. Some lateral faults (transpressive - NAPO U RESERVOIR: the lowermost section (Lower
dextral) with NW-SE direction have been inferred based Napo U) is light brown, medium to fine-grained,
on reservoir behavioral. Reservoir pinch-out from east to regular-well sorted quartz sandstone, often with
west contributes to the formation of stratigraphic traps. calcareous cement and rarely siliceous cement. Towards
the top (Upper Napo U) consists of shales, calcareous
The stratigraphic column of the field consists of sandstones, bioturbated glauconitic sandstones and
siliciclastic / carbonate sediments of Cretaceous age marine limestones. The depositional environment of this
(Fig. 2), represented by sedimentary cycles associated unit is an estuarine influenced by tides, for both Napo T
with platform environments, shallow marine, transitional and Napo U reservoirs (Shanmugan G. et al .. 1998).
environments, and fluvial domain. From base to top The reservoir characteristics are: 22.8 °API, Bo 1.21
these are: Hollin Fm. (lower Cretaceous), Napo Fm. RB/STB, µo 3.5 cPs, Pi: 4054 psia, current Pr (1200-
(Lower Albian - Late Cretaceous) which is subdivided 1600 psia), average porosity of 14% and permeabilities
into the following Members: “C” Limestone, Napo T, up to 400 mD.
“B” Limestone, Napo U, “A” Limestone, “M2”
Limestone, “M1” Limestone, Upper Napo Shale, and BASAL TENA RESERVOIR: consists of translucent,
Basal Tena (Maastrichtian age) (Jaillard, 1997). medium to fine-grained, subangular to subrounded,
poorly to regularly sorted quartz sandstone, with
There are 5 producer reservoirs in Sacha Field, which calcareous cement. This unit represents a fill paleo-
are vertically separated by capillary and pressure seals valley at the base of a major eustatic transgression. The
(The reservoirs depths vary from 8,500 ft to 9,700 ft reservoir characteristics are: 20 °API, Bo 1.11 RB/STB,
2
µo 9-11 cPs, Pi: 3680 psia, current Pr 1300 psia, AN ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK
porosities ranging from 8-17% and permeabilities up to
450 mD. A neural network is an interconnected assembly of
simple processing elements, units or nodes, whose
functionality is loosely based on the animal neuron. The
STATEMENT OF THEORY AND processing ability of the network is stored in the inter-
DEFINITIONS unit connection strengths, or weights, obtained by a
process of adaptation to, or learning from, a set of
MULTIDETECTOR PULSED NEUTRON TOOL training patterns (Kevin Gurney, 1997).
Pulse neutron instruments are based on measurements Neural networks are generally organized in layers.
of the gamma rays caused by the interaction between Layers are made up of a number of interconnected nodes
neutrons and the formation and borehole elements which contain an activation function. Patterns are
nuclei. A pulsed neutron generator (commonly called presented to the network via the input layer, which
“source”) produces bursts of high-energy neutrons communicates to one or more hidden layers where the
averaging 14 MeV, from a deuterium-tritium reaction. actual processing is done via a system of weighted
The timing and repetition rate of these bursts is precisely connection. The hidden layers then link to an output
controlled by the electronics of the instrument. layer where the answer is output.
The gamma rays are detected using scintillation
detectors composed of NaI crystals coupled to photo The artificial neural networks are programmed to
multiplier tubes (PMTs). These tubes produce electrical learn by sifting data repeatedly looking for relationships
pulses whose amplitude is proportional to the energy of to build mathematical models, and automatically
the detected photons. The amplitude of the pulses is correcting these models to refine them continuously.
measured using a Pulse Height Analysis (PHA) circuit Figure 3 represents a general artificial neural network.
that converts the analog value into a digital number.
These numbers are accumulated in an array called an
energy spectrum. The timing of the gamma detection METHODOLOGY AND RESULTS
relative to the initiation of the burst is measured by a
Multi-Channel-Spectra (MCS) circuit. This device NEUTRON EMULATION OPEN-HOLE TECHNIQUE
produces a histogram of the number of detected gamma
rays versus time. For the application of Neutron Emulation Open-hole
technique, a first well called “training well” is necessary
The neutron generator is a nuclear fusion reactor. In it for feeding an artificial neural network model.
the same reaction occurs as does in the sun. However in
the generators case the reaction is not spontaneous; For training phase, the open-hole data as well as
energy must be supplied to enable the reaction process. cased-hole data must be available. The cased-hole data is
In the sun the energy to initiate the reaction is derived obtained from the acquisition with the Baker Hughes
from gravity. The generator uses a deuterium-tritium Reservoir Performance Monitor Tool in PNC3D mode.
fusion reaction to generate neutrons. It can be turned on The minimum open-hole data required for the training
and off, thus we generate neutrons in bursts. Deuterium process is: density, neutron, resistivity, and borehole size
ions strike the tritium in the target and neutrons are curves.
generated by a fusion reaction.
The neural network model for open-hole log
Neutrons leave the generator and enter the formation emulation considers data from 18 curves logged in
(and borehole). Some of them undergo inelastic cased-hole. Those curves contain the needed data for the
interactions before they lose much energy, and produce input layer. A total of 36 hidden layers are created as
gamma rays in the process. These gamma rays have computational nodes. An output curve is generated with
energies that are characteristic of the atomic nuclei that the emulation of resistivity curve, density curve or
produced them. These include carbon, oxygen, silicon, neutron curve. Figure 4 shows the neural network
calcium, and some others. Some of the neutrons are architecture for the emulation of the open-hole curves.
slowed in the formation to thermal energies, where they
are captured by various atomic nuclei - again producing All cased-hole data used as input for the model
gamma rays. These gamma rays also have energies that contains curves related with some rock and fluid
are characteristic of the nuclei that produced them. properties. For example, GR curve that is a shaliness
These include hydrogen, silicon, calcium, chlorine, iron indicator, SGFC, RATO, and RATO13 depend on the
and some others. water salinity and also formation shaliness. RICS curve
reacts to the formation porosity and also is affected by
3
salinity and borehole environment. RIN is associated to The training wells located at the northern part of the
the formation Hydrogen index. RBOR responds to the field exhibited a good correlation with the application
borehole environment and others curves. The well which is located at the center of the field (Fig. 5).
combination of these parameters in hidden layers allows
the model to obtain the expected output: resistivity, Properties such as salinity were also slightly different;
neutron, and density curves. even though, the model created was trained with
appropriate data to face this challenge.
The open-hole data set in the training well is used as a
comparison factor during the learning process of the TRAINING THE NEURAL NETWORK MODEL
neural network. The better the correlation is between the (SACHA-440V AND SACHA-443D WELLS)
output emulated curve and the open-hole curve, the error
decreases. The neural network model was trained with data from
wells Sacha-440V and Sacha-443D.
Once the model is trained, it could be used for
application in offset wells. More than one well could be Both wells present the same stratigraphic column as
used during the model training process. depicted in their correlations (Fig. 6). The formations
have similar thickness and development. The wells are
FIELD APPLICATION located in the same sector of the field and most of their
rock and fluid properties are similar.
Sacha-440V and Sacha-443D wells were used to feed
the neural network model for the emulation application Data used as input from the training well Sacha-440V
in Sacha-421D offset well (Fig. 5). in the artificial neural network model, corresponds to
interval 8760 ft – 9980 ft in MD. A total length of 1220
The neural network model was calibrated for the ft was emulated in Sacha-440V which permitted to
section between Basal Tena and Napo Formation. The present a composite log with the results of the emulated
model does not include calibration for Hollin Formation curves for the training well Sacha-440V (Fig. 7).
due to mechanical restrictions in training wells (Sacha-
440V and Sacha-443D) that did not allow the cased-hole The resistivity emulated curve for Sacha-440V
data logging acquisition. training well exhibits good results, and all the changes
are correlating to the lithological changes in the
Sacha-440V well was drilled and logged in November emulated section. This is illustrated in a cross plot
2013. The available data for this well were conventional between open hole data and emulated data (Fig. 8). This
open-hole data set (GR, SP, compressional sonic, cross plot applies for all of the emulated section in the
density, neutron, array laterolog resistivity, array well. Indeed, the emulated data and open-hole (measured
induction resistivity) and cased-hole data set. In March curve) presents a good agreement with a correlation
2014, Sacha-443D well was drilled and open-hole data coefficient R2 of 0.961.
was logged. As soon as the casing was run down hole,
the cased-hole data for neutron log emulation was The neutron emulated curve also presents good results
acquired. with a good correlation of the cross plot between neutron
open-hole curve and neutron emulated curve (Fig, 9).
A real case was undergone in April 2014, when The cross plot also applies for all the emulated section in
Sacha-421D well could not be completely logged due to the well (1220 ft). The neutron emulated curve and
well geometry and instability problems increasing the open- hole (measured curve) shows a good agreement.
operational risks during the open-hole logging operation. The correlation coefficient for the neutron cross plot is
The main section in 8.5” hole size included Hollin, 0.965.
Napo, and Tena Formations. Normally, the Formations
logged are (from base to top): Lower Hollin Formation, Density emulated curve presents good results,
Upper Hollin Formation, as well as the informal units although there are few zones were the data seems to be
Lower Napo shale, “C” limestone, Napo T sandstone slightly affected by the washouts. However, the
(Lower and Upper units), “B” limestone, Middle Napo emulated density curve shows reliable results in most of
shale, Napo U sandstone (Lower and Upper units), “A” the section. Thus, the cross plot between density open-
limestone, “M1” and “M2” limestones, Upper Napo hole curve and density emulated curve shows a relative
shale, and Basal Tena (Fig. 2). In Sacha-421D well, the good agreement (Fig. 10). Actually, the correlation
only data available in open-hole section was: a) all the coefficient R2 for the neutron cross plot is 0.795, slightly
sensors from Basal Tena to A limestone top, b) some above 0.7 which is considered good for the predicted
sensors (not resistivity, neutron nor density) from A model.
limestone top to total depth.
4
Data used as input from Sacha-443D training well in The emulated section was confined to the Basal Tena
the trained neural network model corresponds to interval and Napo Formations and did not include the Hollin
9300 ft – 10512 ft. A total length of 1212 ft was Formation. The emulated curves showed not only a good
emulated in Sacha-443D, illustrated in a composite log response to the present lithology but also a good
with the results of the emulated curves in Sacha-443D agreement in the upper section (9584 ft – 10440 ft)
training well (Fig. 11). where it was possible to obtain open-hole measurements.
This is shown in the cross plots for the emulated curves
The prediction of resistivity emulated data for Sacha- in the upper section where the correlation coefficient is
443D training well is excellent, and all the changes are 0.75 (Fig. 17).
correlating to the lithological changes in the emulated
section. The cross plot between open-hole data and The neutron curve presents also good quality data for
emulated data was built for all of the emulated section the predicted curve. The cross plot corresponding to the
(Fig. 12). The resistivity emulated data and open-hole interval 9584 ft – 10440 ft shows a correlation
resistivity curve (measured) shows a good agreement coefficient of 0.865 (Fig. 18). Undeniably, the neutron
with a correlation coefficient of 0.936. curve is the curve that exhibits the best results.
The neutron emulated curve in Sacha-443D presents The emulated density curve shows relative good
also reliable results as shown in the cross plot between results in the emulated section in the upper interval.
neutron open-hole curve and neutron emulated curve There is a good correlation coefficient between open-
(Fig. 13). The cross plot applies for all the emulated hole measured curve and emulated curve and the density
section in the well (1212 ft). The neutron emulated curve cross plot presents a coefficient R2 of 0.7 (Fig.19).
and open-hole (measured curve) shows a good
agreement with a correlation coefficient R2 of 0.916. By using the output curves from emulation, a basic
formation analysis was conducted as shown for the
Density emulated curves also presents good results. petrophysical evaluation of U and T sandstones (Figs. 20
However, some peaks show differences especially at the and 21).
zones where caliper data indicates washouts. Even
though the considerable effects of the washouts in the Thus, the U sandstone exhibited 2 prospective
quality of the predicted data, the density curve shows intervals with So average around 70%. (Table1),
reliable results in most of the section as illustrated in the meanwhile, the T sandstone, presented 2 prospective
cross plot between density open hole curve and density intervals with oils saturations around 60%, (Table 2).
emulated curve with a correlation coefficient R2 of 0.737
(Fig. 14). Because of these results, ORNCEM decided to
perforate the intervals 10846 ft - 10875 ft and 10894 ft -
10907 ft (lower Napo T) using high penetration charges
and one trip perforating system. The production before
APPLICATION IN THE OFFSET WELL (SACHA-421D the perforating phase is shown in Table 3. The stabilized
WELL) production test was Qf: 890 STB/D x Qo: 516 STB/D x
Qw: 374 STB/D, and 42.02% BSW.
5
blocks, therefore the neural network must be Qf = Total Fluid Production Rate
calibrated for those particular cases. Qf = Water Production Rate
The NEO technique in the Sacha Field, has
Qo = Oil Production Rate
demonstrated its usefulness in obtaining the basic 2
R = Correlation Coefficient
curves for petrophysical evaluation of geological
formations and the importance of well selection, RATO = Short/long space countrate ratio
proper training and continuous improving of the RATO13 = Short/extra-long space countrate ratio
neural network. RBOR = Short spaced early gate countrate ratio
Training a neural network should be viewed as RICS = Short spaced inelastic to capture countrate ratio
an uninterrupted process that needs an endless and RIN = Inelastic short to long spaced countrate ratio
permanent feedback. So, the more the network is SE = South-East
fed, the more powerful and reliable it will become
So = Oil Saturation
for the different responses that can occur during the
STB = Stock Tank Barrel (volume unit)
curve emulation phase.
STB/D = Stock Tank Barrel per Day (daily production rate unit)
Sw = Water Saturation
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
TVD = True Vertical Depth
The authors would like to thank Operaciones Rio μo = Oil Viscosity
Napo CEM (ORNCEM) for permission to publish this
paper.
REFERENCES
NOMENCLATURE
6
Appendices (Tables) Appendices (Figures)
U Sandstone
Interval So, % ɸ, % Vsh, %
10588’-10598’ 60 8 15
10602’-10632’ 80 15 8
T Sandstone
Interval So, % ɸ, % Vsh, %
10846’-10875’ 50 16 7
10894’-10909 65 15 10
7
Figure 3. General artificial neural network
8
Figure 6. Formation Correlation in Training wells.
SACHA-440V (left), SACHA-443D (right)
9
2
R =0.961
R2=0.965
R2=0.936
R2=0.795
10
R2=0.737
R2=0.75
11
R2=0.865
R2=0.7
Figure 21. T sandstone petrophysical evaluation with
emulated curves
12