Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Edited by
Copyright © 2008 by Panchanan Mohanty, Ramesh C. Malik and Eswarappa Kasi and contributors
All rights for this book reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system,
or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or
otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 1
Conceptual and Methodological Issues of Ethnography
Panchanan Mohanty, Ramesh C. Malik and Eswarappa Kasi
Contributors............................................................................................. 323
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The present book developed out of a variety of papers invited for the
International Conference on Ethnographic Discourse of the Other
organized by the School of Humanities and School of Social Sciences,
University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad, India during July 3-5, 2007. We
express our deep gratitude to the anonymous referees for their insightful
comments and suggestions on the papers incorporated in this volume. We
fondly remember all the institutions and individuals who have provided
sponsorship, encouragement and various kinds of help without which this
book would never have seen the light. We are greatful to the following for
financial support: Indira Gandhi Rastriya Manav Sangrahalaya, Bhopal;
Centre for World Solidarity, Secunderabad; Dean, School of Humanities
and School of Social Sciences, University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad,
India.
We thank the Cambridge Scholars Publishing, U.K. for bringing out this
volume very promptly.
The Editors
INTRODUCTION
1. Introduction
The conceptual and methodological issue of ethnography has emerged
from the tradition of cultural anthropology. Ethnography has dual
meaning: one refers to the process and the other refers to the product of
this process. Ethnography is interdisciplinary in nature and deals with the
allied disciplines of humancentric subjects, like language, education,
health, history, caste, tribe, gender, dalits and other focal themes of human
studies. In short, ethnography deals with a scientific interpretation of
human beings and their surrounding cultures. Meaning, nature and use of
ethnography are important for researchers as they can use this knowledge
not only to write about ethnography but also to evaluate ethnographic
writings, and this is the main intention of this exercise.
besides the road map of describing and preserving cultural practices of the
concerned people. As a product, it means a documentation of the entire
cultural behaviours of the people or group of people including their
livelihood, social institution, rituals, beliefs, economy, cultural dynamics,
indigenous knowledge, knowledge shifting, language, literature, history,
and all related biological and ecological information. So, the term desires
a double meaning, referring to a form of research and to product of that
research: ethnography as a practice produces ethnographies. (Hammersley
2007:1479). The goal of this volume is to provide a comprehensive notion
on ethnography which will help researchers to read, write and understand
ethnography and its cross-disciplinary functions.
3. Use of Ethnography
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other, is interpreted here as a theoretical
and empirical description of the research process and products from the
4 Introduction
The second chapter by Rita Afsar deals in detail with arsenicosis patients,
a cross-section of the community members and health service providers,
what kind of health care is currently available, what types of barriers are
there to use these services, what kind of services would patients and
communities prefer to see and what is considered reasonable by the health
care service providers.
(iii) Why Kamsa, maternal uncle of the Indian mythological hero Krishna,
was the latter's arch enemy.
(Key words: kinship, Indo-European, Indo-Aryan, Dravidian, Munda,
Tibeto-Burman, convergence, taboo)
In Chapter Fourteen Smita Das, how the Most Indian's especially the
Hindus are brahmana by behaviour and intellectuality when they utter the
mantras, slokas and analyse sastras. The process of intellectuality functions
within their utterance in an excellent and wonderful way of speech
delivery, dialogic orientation, access to word knowledge, mnemonic
technique, analysing skills, etc. Likewise they are tribal by belief, when
they worship a god like Jagannatha, their ancestor deity in the form of a
wooden log. They believe in a genealogical legacy, kinship-‘kutumba’
(family) relationship with a supernatural power belong to the Munda
racial root. Shireen Mirza, in her paper tried to discuss the notion of
‘Islam’ and ‘Indian’ in sociological and ethnographic discourses. Tracing
the roots historically, she presented clear picture about the Indian Islam in
Chapter Fifteen.
Bibliography
Brewer, J.D.2000. Ethnography. Buckinghum: Open University Press.
—. 2001. The Ethnographic Critique of Ethnography: Sectarianism in the
RUC. Edited by Alan Bryman. Ethnography, Vol.IV.London: Sage
Publications.
Bromly, Yu.V.1984. Theoretical Ethnography. Moscow: Nauka
Publishers.
Clough, Patricia Ticineto.1992.The End(s) of Ethnography from Realism
to Social Criticism. NewYork: Sage Publications.
Fetterman,D.M. 1998. Ethnography Step by Step. (second edition).
Thousands Oaks: CA.Sage.
Greenberg, Joseph H. 1971. The Science of Linguistics. Edited by Anwar
S.Dil. Language, Culture and Communication. California. Stanford
University Press: Stanford.
Hammersley,M. and Atkinson, P.1995. Ethnography. (second edition).
London: Routledge.
Hammersley,M. 2007. Ethnography. Edited by George Ritzer.The
Blackwell Encyclopedia of Socioogy.Vol. II. Blackwell Publishing
Marcus, G.E .and Fischer, M.M.J.1986. Anthropology and Cultural
Critique: An Experimental Moment in the Human Science. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press.
Spillman,Lyn.2007. Culture. Edited by George Ritzer.The Blackwell
Encyclopedia of Socioogy.Vol. II. Blackwell Publishing
Wolcott, H.F.1973.The Man in the Principals Office:An ethnography.
NewYork: Holt. Rinehart and Winston. (reissued by Waveland Press)
CHAPTER ONE
In this paper an attempt has been made to study the dynamics of forager
worldview and the changing ideology of Human-nature relationship in a
comparative perspective. In fact, changing ideology of Human-nature
relationship is studied, not with reference to time and space but with
reference to different cultures. Changing ideology so studied is aimed at
giving an understanding of the dynamics of forager worldview as reflected
in Human-nature relationship. Forager worldview is used in generic sense
and therefore, is the expression of worldviews across culture, and over
time and space. The premise of the paper is that the ideology of Human-
nature relationship, in terms of the relationship between Human-nature-
super nature, varies across the culture concomitant to the extent and
variation in the foraging activities. In view of this, three tribes, namely
Sulungs, Nyishis and Khamptis of Arunachal Pradesh in northeast India,
have been selected. These three tribes manifest variations in the extent of
foraging activities in that at one end there are Sulungs who are gatherers at
heart and at the other there are Khamptis who are virtually settled
agriculturists, but depend on gathering, hunting and fishing to supplement
their subsistence needs. In between are Nyishis who depend on shifting
cultivation and foraging activities for their subsistence.
set of mental realities whose presence and intervention are essential if this
activity is to occur at all” (ibid: 132). He concludes, “ if thought is present
at the heart of the most material aspect of social activities, a fortiori, there
can be no social relation which does not contain within it an element of
thought, mental part” (ibid: 137). Obviously, Godelier’s analysis has
Marxian content in that he explains the mental reality associated with
‘labour processes’.
Human’s relation with nature changes over time and space. A community
redefines its relations when put to a different natural setting. Conversely,
in two different environmental conditions people behave differently.
Environment compulsion of Apatanis in the form of limited land
resources, for example, has evolved an adaptive strategy (Haimendorf:
1946, 1950, 1962, 1980, 1982, 1989; Behera & Mantaw: 1996;
Ramakrishnan: 1997 and Singh: 1991, 1994a, 1994b) quite different from
their Nyishi neighbours whose land resource is not limited in a spatial
scale. Apatanis are found to have the tradition of planting trees after
cutting down trees even in clan owned forests. The Nyishis of plains and
hills have apparently distinct behavioural pattern in their interaction with
nature. Nyishis in plains for example, kill indiscriminately using guns and
surplus meat is sold. They use explosives in rivers. In hills Nyishis still
follow traditional norms, believe more in sharing the surplus than selling.
Nyishis in plains exploit nature for subsistence needs and commercial
uses. Concomitant to these differences, there is the difference in various
aspects of their cultural behaviour. Mutual reciprocity for example, is not
as pronounced in plains as it is in the hills. Undoubtedly, it could be
assumed that there exists variation at ideological level in terms of
Human’s relation with nature between Nyishis of plains and hills.
The paper, therefore, begins with the premise that a study of the
worldviews in a comparative perspective would provide an understanding
of changing ideology of Human-nature relationship. In the conventional
development paradigm, Human’s relationship with nature is more
exploitative and thus unsustainable with the increasing level of material
development. But there is a shift in paradigm (Mohanty: 1991) and the
concern for a sustainable development and environment friendly
relationship is growing day by day4.
perception of the community about its relation with the resource base i.e.
the nature. Discussion in other aspects about the nature and extent of
resource use limits the scope of the concept of mode of resource use in
dealing with ideological base of the community in a holistic perspective.
Barnard’s ‘foraging mode of thought’, however, is an improvement over
mode of resource use concept in that ideological perceptions form the core
of discussion across the topics of foraging mode. Hence, in this paper, an
attempt is made to explain the ideology of Human-nature relationship by
formulating an analytical frame with relevant tools from both mode of
resource use and foraging mode of thought concepts. In agreement with
this line of thinking, such themes as land, kinship and politics have been
chosen from mode of thought frame and ideology from mode of resource
use scale. A discussion on land directly relates to Human-nature
relationship following Barnard’s line of discussion. Other topics have least
of such relations, though a discussion on these topics have indirect bearing
on the relations in that they define Human-nature relationship in terms of
‘universal kin system’ (Barnard: 1978) and of social control and
management of natural resources in terms of the system of political
organization. Apparently, the present discussion is analytically more
comprehensive in its scope than above two concepts in addressing the
issue of the ideology of Human-nature relationship.
With this backdrop, three tribes, namely Sulung, Nyishi and Khampti5
have been selected as samples for case study. A single tribe with different
levels of economic pursuits by different sections of its people could have
been a better sample. But relevant cross-section data on a single tribe are
not available adequately for any meaningful analysis. Obviously, the
choice is on a comparative study across the communities. However, the
influence of time variable on each community has been considered
wherever possible keeping the comparative perspective in view.
In Momong, data were collected from five surplus households and six
deficit households. Of the deficit households, three were from households
whose produce lasts up to 6 months and others from households whose
produce lasts up to 10 months. The field study was conducted for a period
of one week from 25th June to 1st July, 2001. Households were selected
from a list of households prepared with the help of Chow Soepey Mannoi
on the basis of surplus and deficit criteria. Data collected for the period of
one week were supported by information collected using time line
technique of participatory methods (cf.Mukherjee: 1997: 69-71). Items
other than rice, maize, etc. were recorded about 500 grams as daily
average intake of an individual in surplus households. These included
vegetables, fish and meat. It was found that children used to take
comparatively less of vegetables and non-vegetable items while females
consumed comparatively a substantial portion of vegetable items. Male
folks, however, used to take both items, comparatively more of non-
vegetable items, in sufficient quantity. Intake of non-vegetable items with
only meals is estimated. Consumption of non-vegetable items with
beverage has not been taken into consideration.
Sulungs (Stonor: 1972; Deuri: 1982) are virtual serfs of Nyishi and Miji
tribes of the state. They inhabit inaccessible terrains of East Kameng,
Papumpare and Kurung Kumey districts. Their concentration is more in
Chayeng Tajo, Bameng, Khenewa, Pipu-Dipu and Sewa circles in East
Kameng district. Nyishis of Arunachal Pradesh (cf. Shukla : 1965) have
spread over present Lower Subansiri, Kurung Kumey, Papumpare and
East Kameng districts of the state. They inhabit almost central region of
the state and to their northwest, there is the inhabitation of Sulungs.
Khamptis (Gogio: 1971; Behera: 1994) inhabit eastern part of the state in
Namsai sub-division of Lohit district, and in adjacent Bordumsa circle of
Changlang district. However, they are one among Humany eastern tribes
of Arunachal Pradesh.
Sulungs are “at heart food-gatherers and hunters who infinitely prefer a
nomadic life in the forest” (Stonor: 1972: 14; cf Haimendorf: 1950:7) even
though “maize, millet is grown in fair quantities as subsidiary crops”
(Stonor: ibid.) Food –gathering “consists almost entirely in collection of
wild sago” (ibid: 15) along with occasional expeditions to collect a great
variety of leaves, fungi, fruit, bamboo shoots, etc. (ibid: 16). I was told
during field study that collection of bamboo shoot is a regular feature in
their annual calendar of food gathering during July to September, because
shoots are preserved for the whole year and used daily with staple food. It
was also reported that all Sulungs do not cultivate rice, maize and millet
regularly but most of them cultivate at least few sago palms from which
they obtain their foodstuff. However, even to these days, bulk of the
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 17
supply is obtained from the forest directly and as it was in 1940s, “for
most of the wet summer months they live by food gathering and hunting”
(ibid: 14). “Their poverty and their nomadic habits rule out the keeping of
pigs or mithun and the domestic fowl is the only animals kept, with the
exception of a few small dogs for hunting and watch-dogs” (ibid; cf.
Deuri; 1982). However, the fowls are used mainly for sacrifices in times of
sickness.
Sulungs draw their resources for subsistence needs from nature either
through direct collection or through cultivation. Their relationship with
Nyishis, however, has not affected their adaptation strategy for
subsistence. Their cultivation practice of rice, maize and millet, though
believed to have been learnt from the Nyishis (cf. Stonor: 1972; Deuri :
1982), could be viewed in terms of their cultivation of sago palms also.
Even for making some articles of daily use, weaving, etc. they also depend
on nature. They use hides and skins of animals for making chukh chenam
(pouch), sattam(shields), saruks(belts), etc. Nyishi women use tachak
chaknam/pober(a spindle made of bamboo) for spinning and locally
18 Chapter One
available creepers and plants for preparing dyes for the clothes they weave
in their tapo/ezi chunham (indigenous looms).
Khamptis, on the other hand, are settled agriculturists who practise both
dry land and wet rice cultivation. They irrigate their fields by indigenous
methods of embankment. Almost all Khampti households husband flower
plants, medicinal plants and plants having religious significance in their
compounds. They carry out trade with neighbouring people and sell forest
products like honey, ivory, rubber, elephants, besides agricultural products
like rice and potato. Though they are agriculturists, they supplement their
food supply with hunting, fishing and gathering. They gather edible roots
and leaves and house building materials from forests. For their subsidiary
activities like bamboo and can work, ink Humanufacturing, dying of
yearn, etc. they largely depend on natural resources (Behera : 1994; cf.
Cooper: 1995: Dalton: 1973; Elwin: 1959). The relationship of Khamptis
with the nature goes beyond their survival strategy, for they use forest
resources to obtain items of conspicuous consumption. For their survival
also they use resources more extensively than the Nyishis and Sulungs
with added practice of wet rice cultivation and associated irrigation.
Of the two Nyishi villages, namely Tajo and Watte, Tajo has 8 families
with 59 persons who roughly depend on Sulung slaves for their
subsistence from foraging for about 6 months (185 days). For other 6
months (180 days) they depend on foraging at the rate of 400 grams per
individual per day. Total consumption of these families from foraging was
estimated to be 70 percent. These 8 families, on average, depend on total
foraging for six months (185 days). Of remaining 32 families, 4 families
depend on non-foraging for 6 months, 20 families for 4 months and 8
families for 3 months. On an average this comes about four and half
months. These families also get benefit from the Government social
security schemes like BPL (Below poverty line) quota of rice and
sometimes purchase from the market. Hence, roughly their dependence on
non-foraging subsistence has been calculated to be lasting for a period of
six months (185 days). This is because, they feed pigs and hens from the
rice purchased. They use little of it for self-consumption because they find,
as I was reported, its taste different from their own produce. These
households annually consume about 51344 kg from foraging, which also
constitutes 70 percent of their total consumption. In total, the villagers of
Tajo depend on foraging for about 70 percent of their total food
consumption.
Bamboo, cane, timber, thatching materials, etc. are collected for house
building and for sale. Twenty households during 2000 had sold ninety
percent of their collections from the jungle. However, this excludes
extraction of forest resources for formal sector activities. On an average,
roughly 30 percent of materials collected are sold for use in non-formal
sector activities. This includes materials used by tenant households of
Khamptis, though they do not make any direct payment.
It was reported during field study that Khamptis who have purchasing
capacity, even prefer jungle vegetables because of food habit. Such
vegetables are now available in the market for sale and well-to-do
Khamptis usually prefer vegetables prepared through traditional methods.
The following table may give a rough idea about the nature and extent of
foraging in subsistence and its variations among three tribes:
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 21
Sulung 84 55
Nyishis 66 5
Khamptis 42 30
V. Ideological perceptions
Sulungs depend on nature for their subsistence needs. Their needs are few
which are obtained without much damage to the nature. Perhaps, for this
reason, they do not have a well-defined Human-nature relationship from
conservation point of view. They believe in malevolent and benevolent
spirits, which are supposed to cause diseases (cf. Deuri: 1982:78-89), but
do not have elaborate rituals or belief in spirits of nature for good catches
during hunting or fishing. At the end of one or two unsuccessful hunting
expeditions, they perform Masuwai in the jungle by sacrificing a fowl so
that games are available in their next attempt (ibid., 39).To a Sulung
,nature is capricious and beyond human control, but at the same time
nature is ‘giving’ though the idea is not well defined in their belief system.
Nature is ‘giving’ because they do not go for any rituals in order to obtain
subsistence needs from foraging in the nature.
As the legend goes, Abo Tani and wiyus were contemporaries. Wiyus were
jealous of Abo Tani’s supernatural power and always were in search for
the opportunity to harm him. Tu Tungung as Bingdarbo (Mediator who
settles disputes, presently gingdung) settled the dispute by demarcating
area for their dwelling. Abo Tani was allotted areas suitable for human
settlement and wiyus were given inaccessible places, trees and hills, rivers
and marshy land for their dwelling. So, the Nyishi do not cut nor use trees
like domrang, sangrik (ficus species), tara posi sangkang because they are
believed to be the dwelling places of the wiyus. Sanda dumbangbo (any
tree with a special structure), osso dumbangbo (cane with special
structure), hatek hanek (knotted bamboo) etc. are believed to be the
dwelling place of wiyus. Nyishis do not use leaves of kamyar plant, for
wiyus are believed to use it. Sangne netebo (very big trees), aleng patebo
(peculiar shaped big stones), senyik (marshy land), sele koibo (deep river
with dark-colour water) and distant and inaccessible forest and mountains
are believed to be the shelters of wiyus. Tab (snakes) and birds like pup
(owl), puwa(crow) are dreaded as wiyus.
That the belief system of the Nyishis puts restraint on resource use could
be comprehended from the following example. Peagaa (horn bill) is a
much sought after bird among the Nyishis. Its hibu (beak) is decorated on
the top of the gopiya/bopiya (hat) that gives a social status to its user. But
still, they do not go for its indiscriminate killing in the belief that one who
does so will never prosper. They use the term Khumom-ho/who to mean
misery of all sorts for the present and future. Nest-killing is practised but
silently, lest the shewu/swng(the protecting spirit in the jungle) would
harm the hunter. This belief stops indiscriminate killing because the killing
expedition in a particular nest breaks silence and checks further killing.
They do not kill all members of its family in the fear that the killer’s
family would be subject to supernatural punishment. In the same line of
thinking, Nyishis do not kill a male peaga flying alone as they know that it
carries food to the female bird that hatches egg in the hole-nest. Its killing,
as the people believe, amount to the destruction of its family of starvation
that would bring bad-luck to killer’s family.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 23
There are some specific trees having specific uses. For example, trees like
kora, karsing, porio, tai are used as house building materials and trees like
kora, ninch and plants like tajar are used for constructing ugang (ritual
structure). After major rituals with mithun sacrifice, such as ganda wiyu
panam, himi panam, entire community observes taboo for five days when
outside work including felling of trees are prohibited. The Nyishi also
observe restraint in the matter of harvesting trees during flowering and
bamboos during shooting period. They strictly observe taboos because of
the fear of supernatural punishment consequent upon their violation.
There are restrictions on the harvest of trees in certain seasons. At the time
of flowering, harvesting is prohibited because of the belief that trees will
yield soft wood prone to insect-infection. Same belief prohibits bamboo
harvesting during Nuen Napi (fortnight preceding full moon day) and
when shoots are tender. Harvesting of bamboo and trees are prohibited
during festivals such as Nawa and Sangken.
In earlier days, the Khamptis followed a practice called Tang Ton Mei (to
put a new tree in place of old one) to appease phinoy. Perhaps this was the
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 25
Among Sulungs (cf. Deuri: 1982), Nyishis (cf. Shukla :1965) and
Khamptis(cf. Cooper: 1993: 149; Behera:1994: 63-67) land traditionally
belongs to the community/clan/tribe. It is worth mentioning that the term
community is used to mean village community in a single clan village. In a
multi-clan village land belongs to clan and at the same time to the village
community in which a particular clan is a constituent. Above village
26 Chapter One
Humantaw from the village in the lower reaches and Humannow from the
village in the upper reaches of a river. Humantaw and Humannow literally
mean villages in lower and upper reaches of the river respectively.
Relation with land fosters the notion of identity of the clan and/or the tribe.
Khampti as the name of a group has its origin in the significance of the
place, referring to either a place full of gold (kham-gold, ti-land) or a place
which they adhered to (Kham-to adhere to, or to stick to; ti-land) (cf.
Behera : 1994:21-22).The term Nyishi also refers to people (Nyi-Human)
of hills. However, the origin of the term Sulung is not known. Presently
they call themselves ‘Puroik’, meaning ‘Human’.
The worldview of the Khamptis does not recognize his supremacy over the
nature but places him as one among other members in the nature. In this
sense, the worldviews of Nyishis, Sulungs and Khamptis recognize a
universal kinship (Barnard: 1978) in that all of them are bound with the
nature, with which they interact for one reason or the other.
modify the nature for its subsistence and considers the nature ‘as giving’
or ‘as a store house’, it takes a casual attitude in its relationship with the
nature. On the other hand, if it finds the nature capricious and uncertain
and does not have the ways and means to control the nature or minimize
the risk of uncertainty for its subsistence, it probably becomes subdued
and submissive in its relationship with the nature. But the community that
can exercise at least some control over the nature and can modify it for its
members’ subsistence, establishes a different relationship. Understandably,
therefore, Sulungs don’t have a strong feeling for the super nature as the
Nyishis do have in their relationship with nature. Sulungs’ dependence on
nature for sustenance is not uncertain because of their foraging of sago,
which is not subject to much variation. Nyishis, on the other hand, are
seemingly more vulnerable to uncertainties. Probably, this could be the
reason for their wide range of sustenance activities; hunting, fishing,
gathering, domesticating and producing, than those of Sulungs. Their
uncertainty has made them more submissive to the nature with the belief in
the spirits of the nature. Their Human-nature –supernatural relationship is
well defined and more pronounced than that of the Sulungs.
Khamptis, however, exercise control over nature. But this control is not
full-fledged to meet their subsistence needs. They depend on the nature
directly and this could be the contributing factor to the continuity of their
earlier worldview. Their relationship with nature is a divided entity. A
Khampti enjoys individual ownership over cultivated land as long as he
cultivates it. Even when he shifts the village, he holds the right to his land
for three years and if he returns to the village during this period, he
cultivates his earlier plots. Khamptis have village chieftains to regulate
land relationship. But in terms of their foraging activities, they enjoy
collective ownership, and the produce from the collective efforts is shared
(cf.Gogoi: 1971; Behera: 1994). Over the years, collective efforts in
agriculture have given place to individual operation (ibid). Their ‘ritual
association’ with land and belief in the supernatural in their relationship
with nature is more diversified and diluted than the Nyishis. The practice
of tang ton mei by Khamptis substantiates to the point.
conquered territory and does not have mythological significance like that
of Nyishis and Sulungs.
Acknowledgements
During field study among the Khamptis, Chow Suliksa Namchum, Chow
Thanin Humansai, Chow KeHumang Namchum, Chow Soepey Humannoi
and Nang Helina Humantaw helped me in Humany ways- accompanying
me to different villages, acting as interpreter,and being first inforHumants
and hosts in their respective villages. I am sincerely grateful to them,
Unfortunately, Chow Suliksa was no more during my last field study in
June and July 2001. I fondly remember all his help and affection he had
shown me during all my previous field works since 1986. My insight into
the Nyishi worldview is the result of my interaction with Shri Joram Begi,
present Director of Higher Education Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Sri Tana Showren, Faculty, Department of History, Arunachal University
and of my earlier work with Sri N. T. Rikam, presently a Lecturer in
History, D.N. Government College, Itanagar. Sri Kata Rangmo. DAO,
East Kameng District, Seppa, a Nyishi by himself, was my interpreter
during my field study to Sulung and Nyishi villages in May and June
2002. I am sincerely grateful to all of them. I am also gratefully indebted
to Prof. Alan Barnard for his valuable suggestions to improve upon the
earlier draft structurally.
32 Chapter One
Notes
1
Revised version of the paper Presented at The Ninth International Conference on
Hunting and Gathering Societies, held at Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, 9th to
13th September, 2002, Session-33: South Asian Hunter-Gatherers.
2
Sharing is a functional mechanism to fight against uncertainty. As Cashdan
(1980) puts it, sharing is a means ‘of buffering environmental variability’ for
hunter-gatherers, whose interaction with nature for their subsistence is marked by
mobility and therefore, discourages ‘storage’ (cf. Ingold: 1983). Draper (1978)
and Wiessner (1977) also believe in sharing as the kind of “insurance” against
environmental variability with which Human interacts for his survival needs. In
Wiessner’s (1977) discussion, sharing is a strategy of ‘pooling risk’ and takes the
form of a “storage of social obligations” even though the “mechanism for
economic levelling among the !Kung”. In hunter-gatherer societies, Human –
nature relationship is marked by uncertainty with regard to access to food supply in
that demand for food is limited by its immediate availability due to variation
and/or deleterious environmental conditions and lack of mechanism to buffer the
variability. Sharing as a mechanism to buffer such variability and minimize risk in
food supply is associated with Human’s attempt to secure subsistence needs from
nature. This speaks of an economic component behind sharing patterns, though
sharing may be a mechanism to foster social net-works (Kent: 1993) and
sociability (Sahlins: 1972; Aspelin: !979).
3
Organised thought may include the values, beliefs, opinions, icons, symbols,
idealizations, conceptualizations, formulations, dreams, etc. of individuals or
collectives (Drew: 1998). Organised thought enables human beings to impose a
sense of order and meaning on the world of appearances. It further provides
humanity with a means to wrest a sense of individual and collective identity, a
sense of ongoing selfhood, of ontological security. The notion of identity, thus
grounded in sets of representations produces a feeling of permanence and stability,
the belief of being something. (ibid).
4
Sustainable development means development, which meets the needs of the
present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own
needs. Sustainability refers to the sustenance of development in a long perspective
and emphasises on the needs of the Humankind in relation to environmental
sustainability. Environmental stability on the other hand, emphasises (Ghildial &
Pandey: 1999) stability for the biological and physical systems. There are several
linkages, which operate towards such stability. The first one, socio-environmental
linkage, stresses on the issues of intergeneration, equity and common interest of
Humankind to save nature. The second one is econo-environmental interface. This
raises the issues of valuation and internalization of environmental costs. The socio-
economic interface deals with the vital matters relating to targeted relief to the
deprived against the loss he suffers from environmental damage. There are
geographers who talk of the development as part of ecology in that development
helps nature to help Human and other creatures (cf. Pande & Pandey : 2001 :208).
World Development Report (1992) warns that without adequate environmental
protection, development will be undermined and without development
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 33
References
Aspelin, P., (1979), “Food Distribution and Social Bonding among the
Mamainde of Mato Grosso, Brazil”, Journal of Anthropological
Research, Vol. 35 pp: 309- 327.
34 Chapter One
I. Introduction
The term ‘social exclusion’ is used as a shorthand term for what can
happen when people areas face a combination of linked problems such as
poverty, low and or irregular incomes and health problems, particularly the
threat of arsenic hazard that often cause health disorder, known as
arsenicosis. The social context for this paper is the health concern arising
out of arsenic crisis in a poverty-ridden, unequal and sex segregated
Bangladeshi society. Over time a whole range of studies reveal that
although the threat of arsenic looms large for the country as a whole, the
prospects of people in certain social and ethnic groups and in particular
geographic areas remain grim. Indeed, in the most deprived local areas,
concentrated disadvantage is reinforced through lack of opportunities and
social support that would enable the people who live there to improve their
situation. Given that arsenicosis is caused by contamination in the source
of water, it is likely to affect poorer groups more than non-poor, because it
is related to nutritional status. As under-nutrition is a defining aspect of
poverty, and also poorer segment of population is less likely to afford to
change the arsenic contaminated source of water, they are more
susceptible to arsenic menace. One area of particular concern is the degree
to which health care professionals and facilities are easily available to
women and girls and to poor households. Large-scale epidemiological
studies suggest that men are more likely to develop arsenicosis and other
arsenic related health problems (DCH and UPSHON 2000; Majumder et
40 Chapter Two
al. 2001; Columbia University 2003; Yunus 2003; AAN 2004). On the
contrary, one small-scale study carried out in Faridpur and Comilla
districts (WHO 2002) found higher prevalence of arsenicosis among
women than men. Moreover, social surveys also suggest that it is more
difficult for women to gain access to (often men too) health professionals
for both diagnosis and treatment (APSU, 2004). Therefore, it is possible
that the higher arsenicosis prevalence among men reflects that women are
more likely to be excluded from health services. It is also possible that
poorer households face greater difficulties in accessing health care
services and their needs warrant particular attention.
The study was carried out in arsenic contaminated Upazilas1 where at least
100 patients had been identified. Upazilas with at least 100 patients were
listed in accordance to their geographical locations from Bangladesh
Arsenic Mitigation Water Supply (BAMWSP) database. The Upazilas
were clustered as far as possible into those where significant health
interventions had taken place and where only limited health interventions
were provided. Significant health intervention areas were those where
either government or non-governmental organizations provided
coordinated, continuous and comprehensive healthcare for patients with
arsenicosis including patient screening, tube well screening, provision of
safe water options, patient management and awareness-raising. Areas of
limited health interventions were those where service provision was not
comprehensive, that is, only some of the above services are provided, and
they are provided in a sporadic and un-coordinated way.
42 Chapter Two
From the list, five Upazilas were selected. Two were selected from the
group of Upazila where significant health interventions had occurred and
the remaining three from the group of upazila where the arsenicosis
patients had received limited health interventions (Table 1.1).
Source: Arsenic Policy Unit (2006) Social aspects of access to healthcare for arsenicosis patients, Arsenic Policy Support Unit,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
44 Chapter Two
The notes taken during the focus group discussions was transcribed and
analyzed thematically. Extracts from the transcripts are used to illustrate
key points. All the names have been removed from the text to ensure
confidentiality and codes have been ascribed to extracts. The names of the
villages are, however, real and this is done intentionally to generate greater
understanding of the geographical variations.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 45
Major Goals:
Mapping existing
health care services
for arsenicosis;
Focus Group Social Impact
Discussions: Assessment of
arsenic across
• Patients
Additional Focus gender and class
• Community
Group with lines; identifying the
Service needs of the
Providers community,
particularly women
and poor groups, and
exploring preferred
types services as
well as realistically
achievable activities
including modes of
community
participation.
Study Areas: Sharsha, Tala, Laksham, Champai Nawabganj Sadar and Manohardi
Upazila
[2 Villages from each Upazila]
[4 Villages from each Upazila]
[1 Service Providers: Government & NGO in each Upazila]
Figure 1.1: Schematic diagram showing the interactive continuum of the key
themes and the methodological approaches adopted to achieve the major goals
46 Chapter Two
The villages that we covered in FGD can be broadly divided into two
categories in terms of detection and confirmation of arsenic contamination.
One is the first wave of arsenic detection, which took place around mid
1990s, and Samta and Tangra villages in Sharsha Upazila, Jessore district,
and Chamagram, Rajarampur and Maharajpur in Champai Nawabganj
Upazila were among those villages. All the remaining villages fall under
the second wave category where arsenic was detected during 1998-2003.
In late 1995 four people died of arsenic poisoning in Samta village and this
came as a news item. A noted journalist made a feature article on arsenic and
its fatal impacts in the New Nation, which provoked thorough investigation
into the causes of the mortality and subsequent testing of arsenic in ground
water in the village by a Department of Public Health and Engineering (DPHE)
led team composed of doctors from National Institute of Preventive & Social
Medicine (NIPSOM) and Japanese experts. (Source: FG with community
members)
In the case of second wave arsenic detection villages too DPHE took the
lead under BAMWSP. This involved many local and national NGOs for
arsenic testing in the ground water. The villages that had more patients
attracted greater attention both in terms of diagnosis and treatment, which
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 47
Table 3.1: Criteria for categorizing health care facilities in the upazila, based on
datafrom the FGD
CCategory Criteria and rules
GooGood All t Three criteria are present
Inte If tw Two of the three criteria are present
Intermedia
te
PoPPoor If o No criteria are present or If two criteria are
present but at low levels
Diagram 3.1: Ranking study areas by the types and quality of existing
health care services
number of people than the other villages. However, NGO activities for
arsenicosis patients in Samta, Tangra and Kaliani villages in Jessore
district have shrunk considerably over time. In Laksham the active role
played by one individual doctor was thought have significant influence on
the level of service provision.
Respondents stated that all the sample villages have NGO run health
programmes, which largely provide health education and awareness
raising and/or nutritional services. With the exception of Samta and
Betmali none of the villages have government run satellite clinic or Family
Planning Welfare Centre (FPWC) although barring a few, all study
villages are covered by the government Expanded Immunization
Programme. In-depth interviews with the hospital staff revealed that the
number of arsenicosis patients barely exceeds five a month. The exception
to this was Laksham where on average 30 patients seek treatment for
arsenicosis per month.
From the above analysis we may say that individual initiative emerged as a
critical factor in the delivery of health care services at the government
level whilst for NGOs the continuity of funding and priority of the funding
agencies emerges as the most decisive factor, which needs to be examined
systematically.
• Under the existing system, women generally serve the best and
the larger quantity of food to husband and children and eat last
and the least which results in malnutrition leading to their low
immunity. Existing statistics reveal higher rates of stunting
(48.5% versus 49.1%) among girl child than boy, and girls’ and
women’s higher mortality than men on account of fever and other
water-borne diseases and also anaemia (BBS, 2003).3 There is
little wonder that women are more susceptible to arsenicosis than
men.
Women eat less. They keep better quality and more food for the male
members of the family. Thus they become weak and more susceptible
to arsenicosis.
Unlike men women cannot afford to buy anything they like. They are
often malnourished and have limited access to arsenic free water.
Similar views were expressed in FGDs with community members in
Laksham, CNG Sadar and Tala. Women eat less and only the leftovers
as they eat last. They are more malnourished and as such have low
immunity.
This view was also held by a few other male patients of villages like
Samta , Tangra, Jalapur that had dominant agricultural economy.
I get burning sensation while washing clothes and grinding spices. I get
tired too easily and cannot sleep well at night (FD with patients, Tala).
One of the major needs of the patients in the process of social inclusion is
described as lack of “su-chikitsa”, which literally means lack of both good
54 Chapter Two
and fair treatment. In this section we present the reasons for lack of “su-
chikitsa” including the barriers, which the respondents report facing in
accessing the existing health care services from the government hospital at
the Upazila level. Factors associated with “su-chikitsa”, which the service
providers experienced in the process of delivering those health care
services are also discussed.
Gender values
In addition to heavy domestic workloads, cultural values have taught
women to nurse others and treat their own disease as a matter of shame.
Hence, women are often not encouraged to seek treatment. In some places
religious values and Purdah also pose barriers to women accessing
treatment, for example preventing women from sharing their problems
with male relatives or doctors or allowing doctors to examine them. These
orthodox attitudes among many women and male members of the family
often discourage women from seeking treatment from hospital. There are
also indications from the FGDs that females are reluctant to seek treatment
and disclose they have arsenicosis due to the possible social and marital
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 57
Also some women patients do not open up with male doctors. For them
it is better to have female doctors (FGD with community members,
CNG Sadar).
There are many girls who think that disclosure of arsenicosis will
jeopardise their prospect for marriage, and hence, they do not come to
the hospital (FGD with government service providers).
Box 3.6: Barriers associated with the relationship with health care
providers
Hospital provides treatment to those who can give money. Those who
do not have money are not likely to get doctors’ attention, free
medicine and facilities for X-ray and blood testing (FGD with patients).
Discrimination between the rich and poor patients persists. Rich and
influencial patients always get priority over poor patients and they do
not need to come early for maintaining serial as the doctors invariably
call them first (FGD with patients).
that there was limited recording and reporting of arsenic patients, although
this is noted as necessary in the Implementation Plan for Arsenic
Mitigation in Bangladesh. A large number of health service providers in
the FGDs, from both government and NGOs, were not aware of this
requirement. Whilst registration lays the basic foundation in the whole
treatment process, monitoring and supervision of patients are no less
60 Chapter Two
Attitudes in treatment
The slow and steady manifestation and recovery process of arsenicosis
often generates frustration and helplessness amongst arsenicosis patients.
As a result it is extremely difficult to sustain patients’ interest in seeking
long term treatment. The doctors interviewed for the study noted that the
major treatment for arsenicosis is preventive in nature, which demands
time and patience. The current treatment available to doctors is symptom
management.
There was confusion and lack of clear understanding about treatment for
arsenicosis patients. In one FGD with community members of respondents
frankly admitted that they do not know where they should go for proper
treatment. In addition some patients and community members were
concerned that taking medication did not result in quick recover from the
disease, whilst others seem to lose faith in hospitals as a result of patients
not recovering (or be seen to be recovering) from arsenicosis (Box 3.7).
One woman shared her experience during FGD that a few years ago
she took one of her neighbours who was suffering from arsenicosis to
hospital. After waiting for 2/3 hours they managed to consult the doctor
and got a prescription. However, her neighbour did not recover even
after taking the medicine as prescribed by the doctor. Therefore, they
lost their trust and do not go to hospital.
Arsenicosis patients from one village also suspected that the ointment
they get from hospital are “less effective as these are diluted with a
large quantity of water”.
Doctors do not listen to our health problems rather tell us to go. They
just give us one piece of advice and that is ‘drink arsenic free water’.”
Respondents also commented that NGOs were very active at the initial
stage of arsenic detection and providing necessary health care services,
however, some have reduced their support services. Moreover they also do
not have enough trained doctors and field level workers and no monitoring
system is in place to account for the old patients.
On the demand side, the patients identified three major barriers; poverty,
62 Chapter Two
If our parents managed to drink from this tube well and lived a happy
life, why do we need to change this tube well now?
• Alternative healthcare
Poor people do not get necessary medicine from hospital. Also they do
not have access to specialised doctors. What they get easily in the
village is the service from pharmacist and/or FWV. As they do not
have enough money to buy medicine, they go to a homeopath who
supplies medicine for free or at nominal price (FGD with community
members in Tala).
4.Concluding Remarks
The study unfolds clear cases of social exclusion particularly for the poor
and women who are suffering from arsenicosis. Time and distance are
significant barriers to accessing health care, especially for the poor and for
women. This is particularly problematic as it is important that patients are
diagnosed early and that they continue to attend healthcare facilities to be
monitored and receive treatment over a long period of time. The
implementation of mobile clinics and follow up by village health workers
would significantly reduce these problems and thus would increase access
to healthcare services considerably. It is important, however, that these
two services are coordinated to ensure good communication of
information and a comprehensive treatment service. The lack of women
doctors receiving training and the specific need for them to provide care to
women is also problematic. It is therefore recommended that women
doctors should be prioritised for training in arsenicosis. Training should
also incorporate the importance of registering and reporting procedures
and how to do this. Regular monitoring and supervision from Directorate
General of Health Services (DGHS) would ensure that doctors maintained
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 67
Notes
1
Upazila means sub-district. It is the second tier in the rural administration.
2
With regard to deviation, it was extremely difficult to stick to a particular
criterion due to lack of accurate and/or reliable data on arsenicosis patients. Unlike
updating of arsenic contaminated tube wells, which were largely done by DHPE,
there was no systematic registration of patients suffering from arsenicosis.
3
At the national level 30% of the adolescent girls (13-19 years) suffered from
anaemia as against 26% boys during 2001/2003 (BBS, 2003).
4
Union Parishad is the local government body at the Union level.
References
Arsenic Policy Support Unit (APSU) (2006), Social Aspects of Access to
Healthcare for Arsenicosis Patients, APSU, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
—. (2004), Risk Assessment of Arsenic Mitigation Options, APSU, Dhaka,
Bangladesh
Asia Arsenic Network (AAN) (2004a), Integrated Approach for Mitigation
of Arsenic Contamination of Drinking Water in Bangladesh: An
Arsenic Mitigation Project in Sharsha Upazila, Jessore, Dhaka: Japan
International Cooperation Agency (JICA) and AAN.
—. (2004b), Samta: Coalition Against Arsenic, Dhaka: JAICA and AAN
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. (2003), Statistical Pocketbook of
Bangladesh 2003, Planning Division, Ministry of Planning, Dhaka.
Columbia University Cohort Study. (2003) Arsenic in Drinking Water: A
Global Public Health Problem, [PowerPoint Presentation at National
Dissemination Workshop, 22 October] Dr. Habibul Ahsan, Principal
Investigator, Dhaka Project Office and New York Department of
68 Chapter Two
PANCHANAN MOHANTY
1. Introduction
By `other maternal uncles' I mean those human or non-human beings that
are designated as maternal uncles. Data from various Indian languages
reveal that the term `maternal uncle' is used for the tiger, the moon, the
sun, the jackal, the mouse, monkey, and the policeman. Apparently it
looks quite strange, because there does not seem to be any similarity
among these seven entities, and there is also no reason why they should
be called maternal uncle. I intend to discuss this problem and give a
plausible explanation for it in this paper. But we must have a clear idea
about the term for maternal uncle used in various Indian languages and his
role in the social life of the Indians in order to understand the problem in
its proper perspective. So I will first deal with these things, and then
come to the central problem in what follows.
X <------> Y
The Munda and the Tibeto-Burman societies allow only the exchange of
sisters. Thus they form a part of the Dravidian system, and it can be
schematized as follows:
The other point to be noted here is that all the Dravidian languages use
/ma:ma:/ or its variants. The present Indo-Aryan languages also use the
same instead of the Sanskrit /ma:tula/ or any term derived from it. So it
can be argued that Indo-Aryan has taken the term for maternal uncle
from Dravidian, and this indicates that a deeper cultural convergence
has taken place in this subcontinent over the millenia.
There are two words to denote `sister' in Sanskrit, i.e. /swasa:/ and
/bhagini:/. The former is inherited whereas the latter is an innovation in
this language. For this reason cognates for /swasa:/ are found in other
Indo-European languages, like soror in Latin, heor ~ eor in Greek, sestra
74 Chapter Three
in Old Slavonic, siur in Old Irish, and in Old High German, etc. But
amazingly this inherited term went out of use right in the Middle Indo-
Aryan stage, and the other term /bhagini:/ took over after that. This is the
reason for which Neo Indo-Aryan languages show only the terms derived
from /bhagini:/. For example:
Assamese : bhani
Bengali : bon
Gujarati : ben
Hindi : bahan
Kashmiri : benni:
Marathi : bahi:N
Nepali : bahini
Oriya : bhauNi
Panjabi : paiN
Sindhi : bheNi:
Now the question is: What is the source of Sanskrit /bhagini:/? And also
what is the possible cause of its retention in the New Indo-Aryan
languages? Scholars are of the view that the PIE *swesor consisted of
swe- `own' and sor `woman'. Thus, it was a classificatory term denoting
`own woman' or `a woman of one's own clan', e.g. sister or any
patrilateral female cousin (Friedrich 1979: 212, Benvineste 1973:173-4).
So the Indo-Aryans preferred a more concrete and definitive term
/bhagini:/ which consists of bhag+in+ŋi:p (Wilson 1979:528). The
meanings of /bhag/ are good fortune, happiness, welfare, prosperity
among others (Monier-Williams 1976:743). In other words, /bhagini:/
was an embodiment of fortune, welfare and prosperity. It is significant to
point out here that in the ancient Indian society, both brother and sister
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 75
had an equal claim over the paternal property (Karve 1965:355). Even
Manu, the law-maker of ancient India, had declared that "according to
law the right of inheritance belongs to both children (the son and the
daughter) without any distinction (whatsoever)." (Sarup 1967:40). This
is most probably the reason for which prosperity and fortune have been
associated with /bhagini:/. Not only that, in those days, after sister's
death her son was entitled to inherit the paternal property due to her
(Karve 1965:355). So it is not at all surprising that a man would send
gifts and presents to his married sister and her son in order to please
them so that he can enjoy the property on which they have a claim.
For this reason, right from the olden days, we notice a very cordial
relationship between maternal uncles and their nephews or sisters' sons.
For example, in the Maha:bha:rata the advisor of the Kauravas is their
maternal uncle Shakuni. On the other hand, in the absence of maternal
uncle, his son Krishna has acted as the advisor to the Pandavas. Not only
that he has looked after his sister Subhadra and her son Abhimanyu when
the Pandavas were in exile for twelve years. I strongly believe Ram, the
crown-prince of Ayodhya and the son of Kaushalya who hailed from
Koshala, decided to come to Central India on being banished from his
kingdom simply because it was the land of his maternal uncle. This must
be one of the major reasons for which he got an overwhelming support
from the masses while in exile. This is something not peculiar to India.
In many other societies, the relationship between maternal uncle and his
nephew is very intimate and cordial. In fact, this relationship is so close
that on the basis of his study of the peoples in South Africa and
Polynesia, Radcliffe-Brown (1952:19) described maternal uncle as a "male
mother". A discussion from this perspective will make it clear as to why
the tiger, the moon, the sun, the jackal, the mouse, the monkey, and the
policeman are addressed as the maternal uncle.
languages ten are spoken in Orissa. The reason for mentioning all these is
that the tiger has an important role to play in the lives of the peoples
belonging to the Tibeto-Burman and Munda stocks. To be specific, it is
treated as a god in Arunachal Pradesh and Nagaland. For example, we find
folk-tales regarding the origin of tiger among the Adi, Tagin, and Tangam
Tribes of Arunachal Pradesh. It is the son of the god Kaddong Battey and
goddess Peddong for the Adis. The Tagins believes that the supreme lord
and creator Abotani is the ancestor of both men and tigers. The Tangams
consider it a son of the mythical mother Pedong Nane. When a tiger is
killed they perform certain rituals with a moral teaching to the tiger at the
end which is as follows: “you have been killed because you have been bad
and have done wrong to us and so you should not take it ill. Now go back
to your home in the jungle and try to live a good life. Do not harm
anybody and nobody will harm you.” (Ghosh and Ghosh 1998a:58).
According to the Angami and Rengma Nagas, the man and the tiger (along
with the spirit) are the sons of the same mother, but the Konyak Nagas
treat them as friends and kinsmen. (Ghosh and Ghosh 1998b). In Manipur
the people “…put a high premium on the role of tigers in folk tales and
literature, and analogies. The tiger is always compared with a brave man. x
x x It is considered as a dangerous animal.” (Singh 1993:49). The Lakhers
of Mizoram are quite superstitious about the tiger as it “… has the power
to cause sickness or ill luck. Therefore, when a tiger has been killed, a
special ceremony called chakei ia is performed where laughter is
forbidden.” (Chattopadhyay 1978:235). There are quite a few Naga tribes
like the Mara:ms, Quoirengs, and Kabuis for whom to see a tiger
“…means an attack of sickness due to some evil spirit.” (Hodson
1974:130-131). About the Sema Nagas, Hutton (1968:77) reports as
follows: “The dead body (of a tiger) is treated much as that of an enemy, at
any rate in many parts of the Sema country, the head being taken back
with the village and hung up outside it where the heads of enemies are
hung.” Also “Eclipses are said to be caused by a tiger eating the sun or the
moon, as the case may be, and in the case of the former they foretell the
death of some great man within a year.” Thus, the speakers of the Tibeto-
Burman languages except the tiger as a god, a kin, and a friend; and at the
same time they are also very much afraid of this dangerous animal. A
similar trend can also be noticed among the Munda tribes. For example,
the Soras call it kinnasum or tiger-god, and at the same time they are
mortally afraid of it. The following statement of Elwin (1955:525) proves
this point : "It is further taboo to speak or make any kind of noise through
out the rites for someone killed by a tiger.” There is a group of Santals
who also worship it when “… in Ra:mgarh only those who have suffered
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 77
Eastern India. In a Bengali folk tale entitled ‘The boy with the moon on
his forehead’, the boy met a gigantic demon while going to his uncle’s
place in the north of a forest, and addressed him as uncle. In return, the
demon said, “… I would have swallowed you outright, had you not called
me uncle, and had you not said that your aunt had sent to you to me.”(Day
1969:422). It is also reported that in Nepal “… neither gun, bow, or spear,
had ever been raised against him (tiger). In return for this forbearance, it is
said, he never preyed on man : or if he seized one would, on being
entreated with the endearing epithet of “uncle”, let go his hold.” (Crooke
1993:324). There are quite a few tribes in India belonging to different
linguistic stocks, e.g. the Dravidian Oraons and the Tibeto-Burman Nagas
who claim their descent from the tiger. In a Manipuri folk-tale entitled
‘The tiger and the heron’ when the tiger threatened to eat an old man, he
said, “Grandpa, what good in eating me. I am too weak.", and the tiger
went away. The old man’s son also saved himself from the tiger
addressing it as 'grandpa' (Singh 1993:17). It should be pointed out that
most tribes in the North-Eastern India have relatively less kinship terms.
So they tend to use one term, which is classificatory in nature, to express a
number of relationships. So the term 'grandpa' here actually does not mean
either father’s father or mother’s father, but all male relatives. To take an
example, in Purum, spoken by an old Kuki tribe of Manipur, kapu means
father’s father, all male agnates belonging to and above his generation, and
all male members of mother’s father’s and wife’s father’s families
including mother’s brother, his son, wife’s elder brother, and his son (Das
1945:142). But 'grandpa' has been used in the translated text because he is
the eldest male resident in a house-hold. If we take the Ja:taka stories, in
the Baka Ja:taka, the crab calls the crane maternal uncle in order to get
mercy when it comes to know that the latter has an intention of killing it.
Again, in the Ga:maNicaNDa Ja:taka, Ga:maNicaNDa is addressed as
maternal uncle by a horse-keeper, by the village headman and by a
prostitute so that he would do favours to each of one them. Then, after
coming face to face with the tiger in Di:pi Ja:taka, the lamb decides to
convey its mother’s regards to the former and tries to establish a
relationship with the former by calling it maternal uncle.
argue that the tiger, that is very dear and at the same time has potentials of
causing harm to others, was addressed as maternal uncle so that this
address would soften its heart when it tries to cause harm and as a result, it
would not do so. This was the reason for using the term maternal uncle for
the tiger. It is interesting to note that its seed lies in the Tibeto-Burman and
Munda stocks which had a close contact with each other in the pre-historic
times. (Bhattacharya 1976, Dalton 1978). Oriya and Bengali have
appropriated it from these languages and developed it in a way which is
Dravidian.
It is also well known that the waning moon in the dark fortnight is
considered inauspicious and harmful by various peoples. This is the
cause for which words for the moon have changed from time to time in
different languages. For example, the early Greek word for the moon, i.e.
me:ne:, which was there as an inheritance from the Proto-Indo-European
(PIE) parent, became obsolete very quickly, and sele:ne:, occupied its
place. It should be noted that sele:ne:, literally meaning `radiant', was
derived from śelas `radiance'. Interestingly, this substitute also fell under
taboo in course of time, and was replaced by phenga'ri which literally
80 Chapter Three
It should be pointed out that /candra/ has also been subjected to taboo
partly in Sanskrit in course of time. It is evidenced by the Hindu
tradition that no one should look at the moon on the Vina:yaka-caturthi:
day, which falls some time in late August or early September. Not only
that there is even a ritual of /candra-darśana/ `looking at the moon',
observed by the traditional Hindus, on the day following the
/ama:ba:sya:/ or the no-moon day. The Sema Nagas believe that even
“Seeds sown at the wane of the moon do not sprout.” (Hutton 1968:220).
Further, "There is a widespread belief that the light of the full moon
turns humans who are so disposed into were-wolves and causes lunacy
if one sleeps in its beams. Very common in Europe and America is the
idea that, during the night of the full moon, more crimes are committed,
more children are born, and more patients committed to mental
hospitals than at other times." (Eliade 1987:90). So I want to contend
here that because of the love discussed above and the fear that it will be
harmful unless its bad effects are warded off, the moon is addressed as the
maternal uncle in many Indian languages, the only exceptions being
Assamese from the Indo-Aryan stock, and the Munda and the Tibeto-
Burman languages. It is certainly surprising and interesting that when
other NIA languages treat the moon as the maternal uncle, Assamese does
not do so. As has been mentioned above Assamese uses /jonba:i/ for the
moon and it means ‘moon-sister’. In other words, the moon is female in
Assamese, and therefore, there is no scope for it to become maternal
uncle.4 The same is found in the Munda languages. All these languages
treat the sun as their Supreme Deity or His visible symbol. Further, in
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 81
most of them the moon is the sun’s wife (Das 1945:33; Elwin 1955:80,96;
Dalton 1973:186). But it is treated the sun’s sister by the Bonda speakers
(Elwin 1950:141) and as the sun's younger brother by the Pa:uRi Bhũiya:s
( Roy 1935:279). On the other hand, there is a chaos in the Tibeto-Burman
languages, which surround Assamese, regarding the relationship between
the sun and the moon. For the Purums, the sun or Ni, is the wife of the
moon called Hla (Das 1945:200). According to the Khasi and Jaintia
tribes, the sun (Ka Sngi), water (Ka Um), and fire (Ka Ding) were three
sisters; and the moon (U Bymai) is their younger brother (Barkataki
1970:149). In Adi, the sun (Donyi) and the moon (Polo) were identical and
both had equal light and heat (Ghosh and Ghosh 1988a:85). Similarly, the
ballad of Nu:mit Ka:ppa tells us that long ago there were two sun gods in
Manipur (Hodson 1975:111). But in all these languages, the moon has
been portrayed as a wicked character. For example, in the Khasi and
Jaintia folk-tales, the moon tried to make love to his sister, the sun, who in
turn threw ashes on his face and he became pale.2 The Adi community
decided to kill the moon so that they could have night to rest. The Lepchas
of Sikkim also have a similar tale. (Stocks 1925:363-365). In Meitei, the
Moon-God Pakhangba is reported to have three hundred names, the most
frequent ones of which are “Harava (destroyer), Leithingai (trouble-
maker), Leinung longa (one who hides in a place).” (Singh 1993:201).
From all these, it is clear that there was a negative attitude towards the
moon among the Tibeto-Burman people. These are the most probable
reasons for which the moon is not addressed as maternal uncle in
Assamese and in the Munda and Tibeto-Burman languages.
attest that the jackal is the most shrewd among all animals. In Manipur,
Assam, and West Bengal, it is portrayed as a wise and learned animal. It
is called /śeya:l paNDit/ ‘jackal, the learned one’ in Bengali and
Assamese. It also helps and assists others at the time of their troubles. In
Bengali folk-lore, it is the most significant of all animals. It is portrayed as
a teacher as well as a match-maker. For example, let us take the following
rhyme (Bhattacharya 1963:47) :
ek je chilo śeya:l,
ta:r ba:p diyeche deya:l,
śe karechilo pa:Thśa:la:,
paRto śetha:y a:Rśula:.
Here the jackal is portrayed as a teacher who educates other animals. The
cockroach is just symbolic and it has found a place here most probably due
to the demand of rhyming with /pa:Thśa:la:/ ‘school’. Regarding match-
making, there is a tale “The match-making jackal” in which the jackal with
the help of its intelligence marries a very poor weaver with a princess
(Day 1969:407-413). As discussed above, under the Dravidian influence,
the maternal uncle is the dearest and the most important kin in Eastern
India and this is what he normally does for his nephew. So it is quite
natural for the Bengalis to honour the jackal by addressing it as maternal
uncle.
whole story in the form of a song (Dexter 1938:70-76) 5. At the same time
we know that a mouse can consume so much of food grains in a day that it
is enough for a meal for six people. Thus, the mice cause the greatest
harm to people by creating shortage of food. Sen states that
“…mu:Saka has been derived from the Sanskrit word Mu:Ska denoting
‘the stealthy one’ or destroyer…” and “It is the destroying habit of the rat
which brought the animal in contact with GaNeśa, the ‘Vighnara:ja’ and
turned it in to his mount. x x x Even Manu advises the kings not to select
‘Mahidurga’, a fort which was made with brick-ramparts around as it is
infested with rats or mice. Such was the dread associated with the creative
among the ancient people who considered it as a ‘vighna’ or trouble.”(Sen
1972:26).6 So my contention is that the Marathi and Gujarati speaking
people have established the relationship of maternal uncle with the
mouse so that it would not cause any vighna or trouble to them. Most
probably this is the reason for addressing the mouse as the maternal uncle
in Marathi and Gujarati. It will not be out of place to mention here that
mouse-worship is prevalent in the western parts of India.
belief that taking his name “…in the morning brings starvation for the rest
of the day.” (Crooke 1993:215). So people call it /hanuma:n/
euphemistically in the morning. Most probably due to these reasons the
monkey is referred to as the maternal uncle in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh.
he tried his best to kill the latter by all means. So the Kamsa episode
demands an explanation so that the hypothesis put forward in this paper is
not at stake.
6. Conclusion
From what has been discussed above, the following conclusions can be
drawn: (i) Maternal uncle was not an important kin for the Indo-
Europeans. That he is quite important in the Indo-Aryan kinship system
makes it clear that they have converged with the non-Aryans, or the
Dravidians to be specific through contact and convergence. It is
evidenced by the fact that they use the term that the Dravidians do.
Speakers of the Munda family also use the same term which is indicative
of convergence of Munda with Dravidian. (ii) The relationship between
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 87
maternal uncle and his nephew is very close in Indian society. (iii) The
Ja:taka stories provide evidence for the argument that alongwith the
people who help at the time of need, those who have the potentials to harm
and those whom people are afraid of are addressed as maternal uncle in
Indian languages. In the latter case, people try to soften the potentially
harmful person's heart and establish kinship with him by elevating him to
the status of maternal uncle. This is the reason for which the tiger, the
moon, the sun, the jackal, the mouse, the monkey, and the policeman are
called maternal uncle in Indian languages. (iv) Kamsa is not a
representative maternal uncle in the Indian tradition and there are obvious
reasons for which he was so cruel towards his nephew, Krishna.
Notes
* In this paper [T, Th, D, R, N, L, S] have been used for the voiceless unaspirated
retroflex stop, voiceless aspirated retroflex stop, voiced unaspirated retroflex stop,
unaspirated retroflex flap, retroflex nasal, retroflex lateral, and retroflex sibilant
respectively.
1. I owe gratitude to Prof. K.K. Mishra, University of Hyderabad for this
information.
2. Tyler (1964) reports that a very similar tale exists in the Polar regions.
3. I am thankful Dr. Kaushalya Verma, Himachal Pradesh University for this
information.
4. In some parts of Bengal, the moon is also treated as a mother who gives food
and life-span (See Bhattacharya 1962:178). Again, the tantric and yogic texts,
according to which yoga is the unification of the sun and the moon, treat the sun
as the eater as well as the father’s seed and the moon as the food as well as the
mother’s ovum (see Dasgupta 1962:235-236).
5. For a similar tale where the rat has been replaced by a monkey see 'Monkey
losing the tail' in Seethalakshmi (1969).
6. For a comparison see Frazer (1954:530-531) who mentions about an ancient
Greek treatise on farming that contains a piece of advice to farmers as to how to
propitiate the mice and rid their lands of them.
7. Thanks are due to Professors Padmakar Dadegaonkar, University of Hyderabad
and Bharati Modi, M. S. University of Baroda; and Dr. G. Uma Maheshwara
Rao, University of Hyderabad for these pieces of information about Marathi,
Gujarati, and Dravidian languages respectively.
8. This fact was brought to my notice by Drs. Kamal Swroop, Azamgarh (Uttar
Pradesh) and Maheshwar Mishra, Barauni (Bihar).
88 Chapter Three
References
Archer, W.G. (1974), The Hill of Flutes : Life, Love and Poetry in Tribal
India ( A Portrait of the Santals). London : George Allen & Unwin.
Banerjee, G.C. (1982), Introduction to the Kharia Language. New Delhi
: Bahri Publications.
Barkataki, S. N. (comp.) (1970), Tribal Folk-tales of Assam (Hills).
Gauhati : Publication Board, Assam.
Benveniste, E. (1979), Indo-European Language and Society. London:
Faber and Faber.
Bhat, D.N.S. (1968), Boro Vocabulary. Poona : Deccan College.
Bhattacharya, Asutosh (1962), ba:ŋl:ar lok-sa:hitya, Vol. I (in Bengali).
Calcutta: Calcutta Book House.
—. (1963), ba:ŋl:ar lok-sa:hitya, Vol. II (in Bengali). Calcutta: Calcutta
Book House.
—. (1977), The Sun and the Serpent Lore of Bengal. Calcutta: Firma KLM
Private Limited.
Bhattacharya, S. (1968), A Bonda Dictionary. Poona : Deccan College.
—. (1976), Studies in Comparative Munda Linguistics. Simla: Indian
Institute of Advanced Study.
Burrow, T. and M.B. Emeneau. (1984), A Dravidian Etymological
Dictionary. Oxford : Clarendon Press. (2nd edition)
Chatterji, Suniti Kumar (1970), The Origin and Development of the
Bengali Language. London : George Allen & Unwin. (first published
in 1926)
Chattopadhyay, Kamaladevi (1978), Tribalism in India. New Delhi : Vikas
Publishing House.
Choudhury, P.C. (1959), The History of Civilization of the People of
Assam to the Twelfth Century A. D. Gauhati : Department of
Historical and Antiquarian Studies (Govt. of Assam).
Cowell, E.B. (1957), The Jataka or Stories of the Buddha's Former Births
(Vols. I-VI). London : Pali Text Society. (reprint)
Crooke, W. (1993), Folklore of India. New Delhi : Aryan Books
International. (reprint)
Dalton, E.T. (1973), Tribal History of Eastern India. New Delhi : Cosmo
Publications. (reprint)
Das, S.T. (1987), Life Style : Indian Tribes (Locational Practice). Delhi :
Gian Publishing House.
Dasgupta, Shashibhusan, (1962), Obscure Religious Cults. Calcutta :
Firma K.L. Mukhopadhayay. (2nd ed.)
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 89
Narula, Joginder (1991), Hanuman : God and Epic Hero (The Origin and
Growth of Hanuman in Indian Literary and Folk Tradition). New Delhi
: Manohar.
Pischel, R. (1965), Comparative Grammar of the Prakrit Languages (tr.
by. S. Jha). Delhi : Motilal Banarsidass. (2nd ed.)
Radcliffe-Brown, A.R. (1952), Structure and Function in Primitive
Society. London and Henley : Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Raghavan, V. (1956), The Indian Heritage. Bangalore : The Indian
Institute of Culture.
Rhys Davids, T.W. (1975), Pali-English Dictionary. New Delhi :
Oriental Books Reprint Corporation. (reprint)
Roy, Sarat Chandra (1935), The Hill Bhũiya:s of ORissa:. Ranchi : "Man
of India" Office.
Sarup, L. (ed.) (1967), The NighaNTu and the Nirukta. Delhi : Motilal
Banarsidass.
Seetalkashmi, K.A. (1969), Folk Tales of Tamilnadu. Delhi : Sterling
Publishers.
Sen Asis (1972), Animal Motifs in Ancient Indian Art. Calcutta : Firma
K.L. Mukhopadhayay.
Singh, M. Kirti (1993), Folk Culture of Manipur. Delhi : Manas
Publications.
Stocks, C. de Beauvoir (1925), Folk-lore and Customs of the Lep-chas of
Sikkim. Calcutta : Asiatic Society of Bengal.
Trautmann, T.R. (1979), The Study of Dravidian Kinship. In, Aryan and
Non-Aryan in India, ed. by M. Deshpande and P.E. Hook. Ann Arbor
: University of Michigan.
Trautmann, T.R. (1995), Dravidian Kinship (Indian ed.). New Delhi :
Vistaar Publications. (first published in 1981)
Tyler, E.B. (1964), Researches into the Early History of Mankind and the
Development of Civilization. Chicago and London : University of
Chicago Press.
Warder, A.K. (1963), Introduction to Pali. London : Pali Text Society.
Wilson, H.H. (1979), Sanskrit-English Dictionary. Delhi : Nag
Publishers.
Wolcott, Leonerd T. (1977), The Power Dispensing Monkey in North
Indian Folk Religion. The Journal of Asian Studies XXXVII, No.4, pp.
653-661.
CHAPTER FOUR
REDDY SEKHARA
I. Introduction
Religion is considered as a part of human’s mechanisms to conduct their
daily life by bringing in particular contact with their natural environment.
Therefore the primitive man tried to evolve a mechanism to come over the
crisis while encountering the problems of life in a margin of uncertainty,
anxiety etc.. and this mechanism was slowly took the forms of belief in the
existence of super humans or supernatural power. It is stated that
experiences of certain day to day sudden happenings of disease, death and
the un expectable things led the tribal people in believing in other than the
material visible world i.e. in the invisible spirit-world or supernatural
power.(Vidyarthi and Rai1985). This contact is established into two ways.
They are one way is by controlling or over powering the spirit by
enhancing or practicing some techniques and canalizing the power, for
good or bad. The second way is by offering puja or worship to propriate
the superhuman power for acquisition of the thing or object desired.
The religious life among the tribals is based on their myths and legends.
Their belief in Bonga or Bhagavan is referred to the attributed of objects,
which are supernatural. Similarly Saoras believe the Kithung as the creator
of the earth and man.
II. Methodology
The present study Religion, beliefs and practices among the Koyas is
produced from the two sources. One is primary data that is collected
through personal interaction with key informants. Another one is
secondary data mainly from published resource material, which are
available at Tribal Council Research in Hyderabad, and University of
Hyderabad, and Integrated Tribal Development Agency, Bhadrachalam,
Khammam district.
Without rapport building one cannot get the data from key informants. For
authenticity of the data it is very important. I have used schedules for
constructing the ethnographic profile of the village. This helps in
understanding the economic, social groups and kinship networks, political
aspects in a holistic perspective. Questionnaires and case study techniques
are used to collect detailed information from individuals. As a part of
typical fieldwork method of participant observation most of the data
collection for this study was relied on observation. This method
extensively utilized for collecting the data on nature of magic practices
and sanctify of rituals etc.
In addition to the above formal tools of field, the camera technique for
photography is used in the fieldwork. Photographs are taken for the
94 Chapter Four
The Koyas are popularly known as Koi, Koyalu, Koya dorallu, and
Dorallu sattam. Major categories of the Koyas living in Andhra Pradesh
are Racha Koya, Lingadri Koya, China Koya, Raja Gond, Kottu Koya are
major categories. Each category again subdivided into many sub
categories like Gotee Koya, Basa Koya, Kommu Koya, Gampa Koya,
Patadi Koya, Yeddu Koya, Adi Koya and Dora Koya etc.
The folktale of the Koyas referring that there was a big egg before the
creation of the universe. The upper part of the egg became the sky and
lower part of the egg became the earth. Instantaneously the god Brahma,
the Vishnu and Maheswara came out of the broken egg. Later Brahma
created Bhumikkaraju. Over period of time Bhumikaraju has given birth to
101 children under the Rela tree (Cassia Fistula), which was situated on
an island surrounded by seven seas. The descendants of 101 people
became the Koyas.
The main purpose behind the worship is that only after worshipping
Muttalamma they go for sowing, harvesting and hunting. They offer first
crop to their deity after which they consume grains. Without offering they
do not take any crop and it is considered sin.
participates in the procession. At the same time the poojari does pre-
worshipping preparations near the Muttalamma Image. Poojari cleans the
place in front of the image and applies rangoli there. Muttalamma image is
decorated with turmeric ad Vermillion by poojari. Water is taken by
poojari’s wife or daughter in law and poured on the image of the
Muttalamma meanwhile he recited mantras.
The second day also they bring turmeric water to Muttalamma. This day
actual function takes place. Almost all the community people participate in
the festival. Some of them get possessed by devaras (spirits). They remain
in trance. Poojari tries to pacify them through the act of chanting mantras
and pouring turmeric water on them. Third day they sacrifice two or three
goats to the Muttalamma. This task is done by the poojari along with the
chanting mantras. They share meat and it is taken to their homes for
cooking. They have sent off their deity before the sunrise. They enjoy the
whole night with dancing and singing along with drum beating.
The fourth day early in the morning they all gather at one place to send off
their deity. They prepare one small auspicious structure with bamboo
sticks and neem leaves are placed on the top of the structure. It is held by
the Voika clan people only because their high status among koyas. This
tradition is transmitting from generation to generation. The traditional bath
is given to the person who is actually going to carry the structure. They
wear traditional dress i.e. white dhoti and white cloth tying in the fore
head like a turban. Four persons assist the person who actually holds
structure because he is fully drunk. Then big procession takes place along
with drum beating by men and the women singing. Poojari has been
moves around the procession and sprinkles turmeric water on the
procession. The materials placed in the small structure is given below
jaggery, cereals like dal, candle, flower, sugar mixed with rice, coconut
and turmeric and vermilion. The first day they sacrifice a cock at the rime
of lifting the structure and it is carried nearly half kilometer to the Bali rai
in a procession. It is in the middle of the village. They sacrifice one Bucca
(buffalo) there and finally they carry the structure to the outskirts of the
village and sacrifice one goat there. After completion of the process all the
devaras go out of their bodies. Later they come back to the village and stay
under tree for some time. They eat whatever they bring along with them
and they take away meat to their homes. Thus the Muttalamma ceremony
is finished.
Madakam clan also worship perform the rituals. They worship the Jammi
tree. They do not use Jammi wood as firewood because they it as sacred.
Those have the Madakam the supreme cone from distant places to attend
the festival. On the day of the festival all the clan people gather at one
secret place (which they did not disclose even to the researcher) and
celebrate the ritual in the same way as explained. Uran clan they do not
eat tortoise because they believe that they are descended from the tortoise.
These three are majority clans in this village.
V. Rituals
Rituals are associated with regular occasions such as in the agricultural
seasons, birth, marriage, illness and other rare occasions. Rituals are
mainly divided into two types. They are life cycle rituals and annual
rituals. The life cycle rituals are Purudu ceremony, naming ceremony,
tonsure ceremony, first feeding, ear piercing ceremony, puberty ceremony
marriage and death ceremonies. The annual ceremonies are like festivals
bhumi panduga, chigurukose panduga, samalla panduga, jonna, chikkudu,
gaddi and veduru panduga. There are two important rituals hunting rituals
and fishing rituals.
The life cycle rituals, which confer the social roles, involve a passage from
one stage to another. Although culture defines these stages in different
ways all cultures celebrate the passage from one to another with rites of
passage. It is to note that these passage rites ceremonies are informal
without much involvement. However these celebrations much depend
upon individual family economic status the poor out of anxiety and fear do
not hesitate to fall in debts to celebrate these rituals.
To get them out of the pollution created by the child birth and to give him
a first bath the poojari wife on behalf of this sacred bath the surroundings
are cleaned, later they apply turmeric and vermilion to the deity and
poojari’s wife comes back to this house with turmeric water which is given
to the deity and this tur4meric mixed with the water which is taken by the
all members of the family. Until the fifth day Mantrasani Pays regular
visits to this house to look after the child meanwhile she paid to be 50
rupees and offered a sumptuous meal, which includes liquor and chicken.
This ritual conducted on the fifth day of delivery end is called is the
Chinna Purudu.
On this account the close relatives are invited to bless the child. The China
Purudu follows the Pedda Purudu ceremony on which a lavish feast is
arranged on the day. But this ceremony is not compulsory and celebration
depending upon their financial position at that time. Mantrasani is once
again paid 50 rupees, a hen a saree. Mother’s brother’s roles of relatives
who are not only bring blessing but also gifts. Mother’s brother has to
offer something special and more than other relatives as an obligation.
After completion of the purudu mother will go as usual daily work in the
field as well as in the house. Before Purudu she cannot allow to do work.
Ear piercing is common for women of but the males undergo only if there
is oath. This ceremony takes place in front of the Muttalamma deity. The
ear is pierced with the Thumma Mullu later a gold is tied. Puberty stage is
also important among them. This starts with the report by the daughter to
the mother regarding the first menstruation. Taboos attached, the concept
of pollution exists here, and she is made to sit separately for seven days
without touching any one and joining in the regular daily work. No bating
for seven days. The girl is served a nutritious and special food to make her
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 101
to recover the blood lost and to make her strong. After seven days by
taking traditional bath she joins in the mainstream work.
V (e). Marriage
A sacred institution preferably performed in the summer season as they get
free time. The concept of bethral at the time of birth is not prevails. They
look marriage alliances only after the puberty is acquired. It indicates that
the absence of child marriages. Predominantly four forms of marriages are
practices in the community marriage by negotiations, marriage by
elopement, marriage by exchange. It is observed that marriage by
negotiations is mostly found. Parents of the groom visit house of bride
accompanied by groom with Kallu (which is locally available liquor)
bottles. They keep these bottles in front of the parents bride asks the
acceptance of bride for their son. The bottles are drunk together by the
both families of bride accepts the alliance, if not bottles are taken back.
The members of the groom’s family pays second visit to the brides house
for further talks such as date fixing requirements of bride in terms of tali
etc. With the bottles here also the marriage takes place for five days. The
activities are take place in these five days goes as follows.
First day they called relatives with the help of members of the groom’s
family constructs a permanent shelter (Pandiri) in case of elder’s
marriage. The traditional bath is given to both the groom and their relative
houses. Second day groom is taken to one of the families of his lineage
and he is given bath and new clothes by that family it is called as pelli
koduku cheyyadam (preparation of bride groom). He offered sumptuous
food. Third day the bride likes bridegroom is taken to her one of the
families of lineage, she is also given traditional bath, new clothes,
sumptuous food there it is called as pelli Kuturu cheyyadam (preparation
of bride). Forth day a big feast is arranged which includes liquor, mutton,
for the visited relatives. The relatives in the evening accompanied by the
items such as tali (Nalla Pusalu) ceremonial chain represent marital status,
saree, bhasikam (amulet) to the bride house along with big procession and
drum beating if bride’s house is in the village. Otherwise the bride with
her relatives wait at the groom’ village until they are received in the
above-mentioned manner. Fifth day (day of the marriage) both are given
specially traditional turmeric bath is given to them to keep their bodies
cool from the heat generated in their bodies due to the conscious feeling of
becoming united it is called nalugu pettadam. A big size basket full of
paddy is tied with the pasupu thadu (turmeric) and the paddy is pounded
102 Chapter Four
for some time by the couple later the groom ties tali around neck of bride.
The newly married couple goes for traditional rounding around the basket
for three times. The new couple will take meal only after all the relatives
are finishes their food.
ages 6-14 years, dead body buried or burnt whatever they like.
all of the annual rituals. Day before the ritual they clean houses and smear
the floor with cow dung and apply rangoli on the floor. They wash vessels
and clothes to abide by the purity concept. Later all men and women go to
the shrine of Muttalamma. On the day of the ritual pooja will be celebrated
on the name of the muttalamma. They bring one healthy plan and plant it
in some other place in the village. There is no controversy regarding the
place of planting. They perform pooja to it and after they sacrifice two
goats. The meat is shared among villagers and men go for haunting.
Before going for hunting they celebrate a small ceremony called shikaru
devata panduga (haunting deity). They keep an egg at a distant place and
hit the arrows. Only after successfully breaking the egg they go for
hunting. In the evening they come back with hunting animals. They eat its
meat and participate in a communally arranged dancing programmed with
drum beating. They enjoy whole night with beautiful dances. Again in the
morning they go hunting for four days continually. After that they stop
going to hunting and concentrate on agricultural activities.
sweets and cook the meat. After these performances new grains are
consumed it is known as the Pachcha panguga.
In addition to this they place some jower put on the rasada leaves. The
poojari and landowner perform the whole ritual process. They offer two
hen and one chick to the deity. After drawing the lines with rangoli poojari
starts reciting mantras after some time they sacrifice two hens. They place
the heads of hen on the spot. The bodies are thrown in field and chick is
sacrificed on the east boundary of the field. Nearby some other person
boils water in the spot for the preparation of the rasadamm (sacred
food). The main ingredients consists in the rasadamm are boiled milk
rice, turmeric, water and the jower. Later they add chicken flesh to it.
After some time poojari ties the three jower plants together with thread it
is called pogukattadam. Priest dips (tied plants with jower) into the boiling
pot and sprinkle into the field. He does it for three times it is taken on
three rasada leaves to place it in the end of the harvesting programme.
Later rasadamm is consumed there itself and they may harvest at any
time after the ritual. As they believe that if it is not performed it will affect
the lives of the family in terms of deaths by snakebites and attack from any
wild animal such as tiger during harvest. Therefore each and every family
tries to perform this festival without fail.
killed and thrown away. In the process the poojari and another person
recite mantras until the end. As they did not cut the beans until the ritual is
performed.
decorate with rangoli, vermilion and turmeric. One egg is placed on the
cleaned place. It is celebrated by poojari with continuously chanting
mantras. He places his hand on the cleaned part and performs pooja to the
deity. Later one chick is forced to eat rice. After that only it is sacrifices to
their deity and head is placed in front of the cleaned portion. Later they
catch fishes and share equally. In ritual functionaries they worship neeti
devata.
have dynamic power. It is apart of religion may figure in the life of the
people those have belief in supernatural unknown to known god. But it is
much of the religious ritual containing the magical elements. It is
especially connected with economic activities of justice and medicine.
Magic may be used to fortify individual or community in any undertaking
such as love war, haunting, gardening and other economic pursuits. The
virtue of the magic may be held in the objects used, oral formula, spell, the
person or magician or magical expert in matters.
The magical experts (witch doctor or witch) may gain his power by
knowledge and severe training. He may learn it from by other experts by
saying some honorium to them or inherit it. It may reside in some part of
his person. He may have to observe special taboos or special regime of life
an account in certain circumstances. There may be a great importance
which may due to magic and protection by magic may be sought. There
exists a strong belief regarding magic either benevolently or malevolently.
Magic is playing a key role in their daily life. When there are no rains they
perform imitative magic, which is called Bhimuni pelli. Magic is done for
the better harvesting driving out spirits and welcoming the spirits also.
Mainly magic used for the curing of the diseases among the koyas. As
mentioned above some families to take revenge use it malevolently.
In the process if fever occurs they suspect it in terms of evil spirits and
they go to the ejju if it is very serious. He starts shivering while chanting
mantras and keeps some pieces of noted in his mouth, after some time he
bites near by the naval of the layperson. Then patient scream with high
intensity then ejju splits the peaces of bones on the floor. Then the
patient lives that it is object, which cause him fever, and it is removed
now. Patient feels that spirit also gone out the screamed sound and also in
the form of pieces of bones. Some of them also belief in spirits called as
gali (air), Demons(Bhutas) and Deyyam. They believe that all the spirits
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 109
Magic is not only malevolent but also benevolently. It could be used for
increasing the food production, curing disease. They are frequently
meeting with the witch doctors. They offer sacrifices for the things. It
indicates how it interwoven in their life but they never consume any new
crop without offering to the god or supernatural. Sometimes some of the
feathers of peacock tied and made into a broomstick, which is used, for
driving out spirits. With this broom patient will be beaten irregularly until
the evil goes out from his body. Among close relatives may exist property
disputes. Madakam Papaiah grabbled his close relative’s land and did
magic on him. In the village there is no witness for magic is done to
replace the chief or others. Some people believe that magic or witchcraft
ensure. Their economic stability and also it breaks the economic stability
110 Chapter Four
X. Changing Patterns
As change is permanent feature of culture which clearly through
Ogbourn’s concept of culture lag where he says changes in material
culture is swifter than non-material and in this religion is the last one to
fall prey. Present site at present the phenomenon of religious conversation
seems to be evolving rapidly have been already two families converted
fully. They are reading bible and doing prayer as followers of Christianity.
There is one church named Rahebotu mandiram in the village. The
converted people attend the church and they have the Christ photos in their
houses. This Christianity influenced in the village by Loyola institute for
tribal development agency (LITDS), which is, established a base to spread
Christianity indirectly through different food and medicine. When
villagers fall in troubles and become more susceptible they give moral
support in terms of saying Jesus is the one who can save you and prey
him.
Culture contact has only some influence in the village in terms of their
assimilation of many major Hindu festivals, which were absent earlier in
their lives. Festivals like Dasara, sankrathi are new celebrations. They
have learnt from the non-tribal people. A surprising change in the attitudes
of the native people is their momentum towards urban hospitals for the
health problems unlike the earlier where they use to visiting witch doctor.
Through many of them still pay visit to him their interest in moving
towards city is under improvement. The reasons may be up to their feeling
the witch doctor himself going to health centers. This is an interesting
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 111
development in the boded guide in their belief system. They not only
curtained their visit to witch doctor but not following those spirits
possessed women and men’s order. They are avoiding even consuming the
juice herbs, which was very rampant earlier. There is change in their
material culture of religion for example they offering agarbatti and using
samurai for their ritual performances. By these changes are quick clear in
the houses, which are nearby main road than the houses located remotely
meaning near by dense forest.
XI. Conclusion
Religion is the essential and powerful institution in every society. With
regard to religion, an attempt has been made to study the Koya community
and various aspects relating to festivals and rituals are converted for the
study. It is found that the Koyas are closely associated with the socio-
cultural environment. Their belief system is highly in super naturalistic
nature. They worship gods and goddess like muttalamma, chintanamma,
Banadevata. Besides they worship ancestral spirits, ghost and supernatural
beings. However they are not static in nature with their culture and
religion at the same time they are dynamic and changing their attitudes,
customs due to contacts of non-tribals.
References
Bose, N.K.(1971), The tribal life in India, National book Trust, New delhi.
Durkheim.E. (1915), The Elementary forms of Religious Life Tranx. New
york.
Elwin,V.(1954),. tribal Myths of Orissa, Oxford University Press, London.
Evans-pritchard, E.E. (1937), Witch craft, Oracle and Magic among
Azande, Oxford.
Firth, R. (1971), Elements of Social Organization Tavistock publications,
London.
Frazers, J.J. (1935), The Golden Bough The magic art and the evolution of
kings, New york.
Freud, S. (1953), Moses and Monotheism Random house, New York.
Malinowski, B.(1954), Magic Science and Religion Dowrleday &Co.Inc,
Garden city, New York.
Marett,R.R . (1990), The Threshold of Religion Methen, London.
Majumdar,D.N. (1967), An introduction to Social Anthropology, Asia
publishing House, Bombay.
Radcliff,B. (1952), Structure and Function of Primitive Society, Oxford
112 Chapter Four
I. Introduction
As in other south Asian countries, untouchables are also considered as the
lowest group of people in the Varna System in Hindu belief, i.e. Sudhra.
The Varna System denotes human as the creation of different parts of the
body of divinity Purusha defining the social standing and their jobs.
According to this system, untouchables have no any Varnas. It is the
Manusmriti ( a classical Hindu text) that defines and justifies the caste
systems, classical jobs and behaviour and practices to be shown by
different castes in Hindu religions in Nepal. By which, Dalits are
considered a lowest untouchable castes in Nepalese Hindu class system.
Traditionally, Dalits were considered as the isolated group of people to
such an extent that their shadows to the upper class people, access to
eating-places, school and water sources were denied, and worship in
temples forbidden by so-called upper castes. Dalits or untouchables”
(laborers, cobblers, and manual scavengers) occupy the lowest position
within the caste hierarchy in Nepal (Gautam and Upadhya, 2001).
Dalits are segregated from other castes, based on the belief that they are
“polluted.” They are also prohibited from touching non-Dalits and their
ritual possessions including to carry dead bodies of upper castes in
funerals, inter-caste marriage with upper castes, entering and using public
places of non-Dalits (e.g. hotels, shops, restaurants, and temples). If they
are entered in the restaurants, they have to use separate glass and plate to
drink water and eat meal (JUP, 2001). There are evidences of physical
violence and attacks on Dalits from upper castes and even among Dalits of
different caste group, in the name of lower and upper caste symbol (see
ALRC, 2003:8, The Kathmandu Post, October 25, 2003, Bhatta, 2003 and
HRW, 2003).
Legal provisions and concessions made for the social and economic uplift
of Dalits, marginal people and other deprived people in order to enable
them to achieve upward social mobility could not be reached to the
approach of target people. These are limited only to the upper in Dalits,
who have already been enjoying better educational facilities and
comparatively better quality life than other common Dalits.
However, the position of Dalit workers has been assessed in the overall
framework of Dalit’s social structure. They suffer from multi-cornered
discrimination, deprivation, and exploitation in the society. Dalit workers
suffer not only from economic exploitation but also have become victims
of the worst form of jobs, dehumanisation, and social deprivation
including sexual harassment/abuse to the female workers by upper castes
and male co-workers. Unhygienic occupations have been socially imposed
on them and they are paid very low wages for such work.
As such, the labour market where the Dalit workers has to work is
characterized by informalisation of labour hiring, unfreedom in economic
relations and various forms of extra-economic coercion. The labour hiring
process is informalized to such an extent that there is neither any fixed
duration of working hours nor any standard wage that every worker is
paid. Dalit workers are primarily hired on negotiable wages. Similarly,
they face various forms of unfreedom and exploitation by employers.
These include widespread use of unpaid labour services, the practice of
untouchability, caste oppression and verbal, physical, and sexual abuse.
Dalit manual workers have been facing severe caste hostility, including the
practice of untouchability and verbal abuse from the upper castes. Sexual
abuse against women workers is very common at work places (Mandal
and Chaudhary, 2003). Thus, many female Dalit workers feel insecure in
going to work by themselves and only worked in groups.
Despite the constitutional provisions and government policies for the uplift
of Dalits in Nepal, they have not been received any remarkable help from
the government. Though many of the Dalit children are getting education,
the quality of it is not so good that they may be expected to get a better job
to any significant level. Being numerically a major component they do not
enjoy the same political power as of non-Dalits. They have failed to get
the full attention of politicians, academicians, and non-governmental
organizations. Therefore, their problems neither have been properly
addressed nor have been tried to be solved by the government or non-
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 121
governmental organisations.
In future, there is a danger that Dalit workers will not be able to get
opportunity of the unskilled jobs in the government sector as the
government is leaving its active participation in economic activities in the
name of privatisation and globalisation. Similarly, political leaders and
organisations have not successfully raised their voice and mobilise
opinion in favour of the Dalits workers, being concentrated more in the
other sectors of development.
As Dalits did not have sufficient asset base in the village, they migrated
122 Chapter Five
permanently along with their families to the town. They got involved in
different occupations and changed their occupations according to the
available opportunity. However, despite occupational change they have
maintained some links with their traditional occupations.
V. Reform Movement
Being impressed by the reform movement led by Dr. Ambedkar, many
Dalits, politicians, social activists, and non-governmental organisations
have been involving to abolish discrimination against castes and to bring
Dalits in main stream of political and developmental process of the
country. The Humanist Association of Nepal (HUMAN) is a leading
organization in the country to fight against all kinds of inhuman
discriminations on Dalits in the name of caste, race, and religion and so
on. It has been involving in supporting Dalits economic activities,
organising educational, training and awareness programs along with
advocating the rights of Dalits in Nepal.
The quality of life (QWL) of Dalits and the workforce cannot be improved
until and unless the vicious circle of poor health-education-poverty is
broken by the joint intervention of Dalits and non-Dalits with the keen
support of government, politicians, lawyers, journalists, teachers, religion
leaders, I/NGOs, donor agencies and so on. Dalits and Non-Dalits have to
come out from the feeling of upper and lower castes and get ready to
change their superstitions of castes and religions. For this, educational
programs and programs for generating employment and opportunity in
employment can play a vital role. Thus, government has to ascertain
certain quotas in government jobs for Dalits and encourage activities that
create employment opportunities to the marginal people like Dalits.
Access to the school and university education should be made easy for
Dalits by making the provision of scholarship for Dalits, aimed at
improving their status. Informal educational and training programs should
be launched by I/NGOs to aware Dalits about their rights and improve job-
oriented skills. Similarly, awareness program for non-Dalits is to be
124 Chapter Five
The traditional jobs of Dalits and the goods and services produced by them
should be preserved and promoted as a heritage of the country. Their
traditional jobs should be developed as a respectable profession by
improving their quality of operation. If so, everybody will accept all jobs
without hesitation and irrespective of their origin of caste and ethnicity.
Thus, there will not be a question of upper and lower castes in terms of
jobs and it will trigger the development across the caste and have positive
impact on national development itself.
the Dalits (untouchables) and attain justice by working together. Thus, let
us unite to fight against discrimination and abuse on Dalits in the name of
caste and to change the way of thinking and attitude of society.
References
ALRC (2003), Alternative Report to the 16th periodic Report of State
Party Nepal to the Committee on the Elimination of Racial
Discrimination, Asian Legal Resource Centre, Kathmandu.
Bajracharya, Hridaya, (1999), “Child Labour in Informal Sector”, In Jha
Hari Bansh (ed), Status of Informal Sector Workers: The other Side of
Economy in Nepal, Centre for Economic and Ttechnical Studies(
CETS) in Cooperation with Friedrich-Ebert Stiftung (FES),
Kathmandu.
Bishwakarma, P. (2001), “Caste Discrimination and Untouchability
Against Dalits in Nepal”, Conference Paper prepared by the Society
for the Liberation of Oppressed Dalit Castes, Nepal for the Global
Conference on Caste Discrimination, March 1-4, 200, New Delhi.
CBS (2003), Population Monograph of Nepal Vol.I, Central Bureau of
Statistics, Kathmandu.
Dahal, D.R. et.al (2002), Situational Analysis of Dalits in Nepal, National
Dalit Strategy Report Submitted to the Action Aid Nepal, Care Nepal
and Save the Children US for National Planning commission,
Kathmandu.
Gautam, R. and Upadhyaya, Umesh (2001), Garbage Cleaning
Community and Child Labour in Nepal,
www.gefont.org/research/sweeper/html/ chapter1.htm.
Helvetas Nepal (2005), Empowering Dalits, Helvetas Nepal, Kathmandu.
HRW (2004), www. hrw.org/English/docs/nepal7322_txt.htm
Human Rights Watch Communication with Expert on Dalits in Nepal,
January 2003.
Jha, Hari Bansh (1999), Status of Informal Sector Workers: the other Side
of Economy in Nepal(ed), Centre for Economic and Technical Studies
(CETS) in Cooperation with Friedrich-Ebert Stiftung (FES),
Kathmandu.
—. (2003), Dalit of Tarai and Dalit Women(ed), (in Nepali), Centre for
Economic and Technical Studies, Kathmandu.
—. (2003), “Economic Violence against Dalit Women” (in Nepali)”, In
Dalit of Tarai and Dalit Women(ed), Centre for Economic and
Technical Studies, Kathmandu.
JUP (2001), Dalit in Nepal and Alternative Report For WCAR 1-2, Jana
126 Chapter Five
UPLIFTMENT OF WOMEN
IN SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
In India, as per the 2001 census women constitute about 48 percent of total
population. Women comprise one third of the national labour force and a
major contributor to the survival of the family. But even after 58 years of
independence.
effective tools for involving women in the development process and this
task can be fully performed by the involvement of self – help groups in
women’s Empowerment. The benefits of self- help groups are based on
co-operation rather than competitions.
Where women have set up enterprises this has often led to small increases
in access to income at the cost of heavier work loads and repayment
pressures. In many cases the loans have been used by men to set up
enterprises over which women have little control. In some cases they have
been employed as unpaid family workers with little benefit. In others there
have been indirect benefits and improvements in various aspects of
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 129
In some cases women’s increased autonomy has been temporary and led to
withdrawal of male support. In some programmes there are increasing
fears that women’s small increases in income are leading to a decrease in
male contribution to certain types of household expenditure. Within
schemes impacts often vary significantly between women.
The need for such a process is signaled both within the financial systems
approach itself and empowerment approaches where the need for grass
roots participation is assumed. However, experience suggests the need to
address some of the shortcomings of existing systems of participation.
Participation takes time skills and resources which are often in scarce
supply particularly for very poor women and ‘participation’ per se 1 is not
necessarily empowering.
As on June 19, 2002 it covered 18.59 lakh women who got enrolled in
1.08 lakh SHGs in both rural and urban areas. Women below poverty line
are the focused group. It also pays attention on welfare of windows
destitute, divorcees, physically handicapped women, women belonging to
weaker section and adolescent girls. About 47 per cent of the members
belonged to SC/STs. The training course covered the following wide
spectrum of activities, nursing, computer training, export garments
making, mat weaving, silk reeling and twisting, handloom spinning and
weaving, cement hollow block making, micro concrete roofing, seed
production, leather goods making etc.5
The NABARD has been taking keen interest in developing SHGs in order
to Empower the womenfolk economically since 1992-93 bank loan
disbursed was Rs. 7992.90 lakh and NABARD refinance were at Rs.
7935.52 lakhs. The NABARD has also conceptualized the Vikas
Volunteers Vahni (VVV). It is an experiment in social engineering in the
field of rural banking by adopting a multi pronged strategy on the part of
the lending institutions.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 133
In this context to bridge the gap between the demand and supply of funds
in the however ranges of rural society, SHGs, which operate on the
principles of mutual trusts and co operation have emerged as informal
financial institutions for the poor under the guidance and support of Non
Government Organisation. (NGOs)
For this purpose, the micro finance Development Fund (MFDF) was
redesignated as micro finance Development and Equity Fund (MFDEF)
and the corpus of the fund was increased from Rs. 100 crore to Rs. 200
crore. The central Government is considering the need to identify and
classify the MFIs and rates such institutions to empower them to
intermediate between the lending banks and the clients. To facilitate the
process of rating of MFIs., NABARD has decided to extend financial
assistance to commercial banks and RRBs by way of grant to enable them
to avail the services of credit rating agencies for rating of MFIs.
There are arguments both for and against each structure. These dilemmas
are very contextual and only strengthen the argument that no unique model
is applicable for all situations. They have to be context specific. The four
pillars of microfinance credit system are supply demand for finance
intermediation and regulation. Whatever may the model of the
intermediary institution. The end situation is accessibility of finance to
poor.7
Notes
1. Meenakshi Malhotra : “Empowerment of women” (In 3 volumes) ISHA Books
Delhi - 2004, pg.1.
2. Ibid., pg. 2.
3. Ibid., pg. 3.
4. Ibid., pg. 5.
136 Chapter Six
5. The Indian Economic Association 89th IEA Annual conference volume 27-29th
December, 2006. Part – II, Department of Economics Kurukshetra University,
Kurushketra, Haryana. Pg. 1089.
6. Ibid., pg. 1090.
7. Meenakshi Malhotra, “Empowerment of women”, op. cit. pg. 154.
CHAPTER SEVEN
BETWEEN ETHNO-METHODOLOGY
AND ETHNOGRAPHY:
CONSTRAINTS AND STRATEGIES
DR.BINDU RAMACHANDRAN
Introduction
Field work is considered as the part and parcel of anthropological research
with specific methodologies. That does not mean that anthropologists and
sociologists can conduct field work in all types of societies, in the
contemporary situation. As researchers they are experts in making rapport
with any kind of societies with the aid of their research techniques, but
some times they are restricted from entering in to alien cultures. This is
mainly because of the fact that a person’s [anthropologists] moral
commitments, values, personal restrictions and restrictions imposed by
ruling party or government on certain cultures and research areas may not
permit a scholar to conduct field work among all societies and groups.
come in terms with the self and the’other’.How far the ‘other’ accepts this
feeling is really a question in front of ethno methodological strategy . This
is a main problem faced by anthropologists working in village and caste
studies. Evans –Pritchard [1973:3] clearly stated that ‘one cannot really
become a Zande or a Nuer or a Bedouin Arab, and the best compliment
one can pay them is to remain apart from them in essentials. In any case
always remain oneself, inwardly a member of one’s own society and a
Sojourner in strange land’. This statement supports Madan’s (1994:136)
argument regarding ‘self’ and ‘other’. Taking all into consideration it is
clear that ethno methodological approach cannot make moral judgments
about meanings, but it is a very good method of analyzing how individuals
make sense of the social world for themselves.
In some of the societies there are many restrictions for men in entering
certain areas exclusively meant for women. If a researcher avoids those
situations for not getting access, then his description regarding that
community is incomplete and it is chiefly from the male perspective. More
over it may not be possible for the solitary anthropologist to observe every
thing that goes on in the community. When an event is taking place the
anthropologist cannot be present at all places of action and this will be
reflected as a gap in the ethnographic description. Gananath Obeyeskere
(2004) opined that ‘good ethnography goes beyond the native point of
view and beyond the surface reality of every day understandings. For
example the physical like death, birth, marriage…etc may carry different
meanings in different cultures. Each culture recognizes the meaning of
each phenomenon in a distinctive way though the underlying phenomenon
is identical. An ethnographer’s duty here is much more responsible that he
has to make clear the differences.
References
Evans-Pritchard, E.E. (1951), Social Anthropology. London: Routledge &
Kegan Paul.
Madan, T.N. (1994), Pathways: Approaches to the study of society in
India. Delhi: Oxford University press.
Mead, Margarett, (1970), The Art and technology of fieldwork in R.Naroll
and R.Cohen (eds).A hand book of method in cultural anthropology.
Garden city, NewYork: The Natural History press.
Srivastava, V.K. (1991), Ethnographer and the people :Reflections on field
work, economic and political weekly,XXVI (22&23):1408-11,1413-
14, XXVI (24): 1475-81.
Obeyeskere, Gananath. (2004), The first intersubjectivity: The
anthropologist & the native in methodology of fieldwork (ed)by V.K
Srivastava.
CHAPTER EIGHT
ALVIN CONCHA, MD
I. Introduction
In a separate paper, (Concha 2007) I have written about the results of a
cyberethnography that I did, which aimed to describe the creation of male
sexualities among self-ascribed Filipino men in online chatrooms, describe
the virtual environments wherein cyber male sexualities are constructed,
and discuss the extent to which virtual male sexualities reflect contemporary
physical world male sexualities and implicate masculinities.
For over two years, I went to chatrooms in the Yahoo chat system as
participant observer. I chatted with chatroom goers who spoke Filipino or
Bisaya and who self-identified as males. The results of such study were
derived from cyberethnographic descriptions of chatroom environments,
textual analysis of conversations and webcam screenshots and discourse
analysis of masculinities in chatrooms. I summarized the results of the
study in the succeeding paragraphs.
persons, but which would have been unacceptable in the physical world. It
permits easy shifting among identities, and it permits disappearances and
sudden appearances of online identities.
The research eventually reminds us that we play multiple roles in life that
require more than one fixed self. It also teaches us a potentially powerful
and empowering practice of determining for ourselves the sexual identities
that we want to project in particular situations, without the fear of being
rejected, denigrated or silenced. It tells us that it is possible to create and
express sexual identities that are multiple, fluid or malleable if other
identities around it subscribe to attitudes of open-mindedness, acceptance
and respect for the countless possibilities that persons may articulate
themselves.
Advantages offered by studies done over the Internet include saving time
and money spent on travel and easy access for participants, especially
those from other countries. “Online homes participating in the very
experience of fieldwork [in] cyberspace can bring together physically
dispersed people.” With the Internet technology, “[t]he researcher can now
engage in research on a world-wide, low cost, almost instantaneous scale –
and ways which potentially overcome some of the barriers imposed by
more conventional research approaches.” (Illingworth 2001)
“Most internet studies written and published in the past decade project a
feeling of innovation in both the conceptual and the methodological
understanding of fieldwork in cyberspace.” (Kuntsman 2004) Classic
(offline) ethnography became the inspiration of many researchers who
started employing ethnographic principles in doing research in cyberspace.
This gave way to a growing research methodology genre called virtual
ethnography or cyberethnography. Because of the virtual nature of the
research, what constitutes as symbols of power in the physical context –
such as race, sex, gender, class or appearance – lose their potential to call
forth subordination. According to Kuntsman, cyberethnography is
“dehegemonizing” because it lessens power relations between
ethnographer and study participants. (Kuntsman 2004)
tool, contribute to the debates concerning its value in research and “to
explore the implications of the use of the Internet for the feminist research
project.” (Illingworth 2001)
Eley studied online storytelling among elderly support group members and
combined online and offline methods in gathering data. She claimed to
have made use of the ethnographic tradition in doing her research. She
described her technique as follows:
Online methods have included observation of an older people’s virtual
discussion area, “harvesting” and e-mail interviews with some members
and participant observation and archival “harvesting” of an online
bereavement support group and e-mail interviews with some members.
Offline methods have included participant observation of a “traditional”
bereavement support group and informal interviews with members and
associates... The content of storytelling in the support groups was also
explored. (Eley 2003)
Gajjala did an online research that “centered (on) ongoing studies of South
Asians online and the centrality of woman as symbol for cultural/national
identity.” (Gajjala n.d.) She came up with a more specific definition of
“cyberethnography,” which she refers to as a methodology anchored on
“studying through doing.” She describes the process of cyberethnography
as follows:
The approach emphasizes the doing of technology, building of
cyberspatial environments and sustained interaction and “being” online in
order that the researcher may understand the everyday practices associated
with the context, as well as begin to engage the specifics of such an
engagement. Living online thus emphasizes immersion so that there are
relational links between the ethnographer and the subject(s) being studied
and so that the ethnographer understands how the spatio-temporal praxis
of being in such environments might shape her subjectivity. Thus the
researcher not only inhabits such spaces, s/he also learns to code herself
into existence within such spaces by building, interacting and collaborating
within them. Thus s/he dialogically produces cyberselves. (Gajjala 2005)
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 147
The foregoing studies tell us that “cyberspace enables (and even forces) us
to re-examine and reframe old concepts of fieldwork.” (Kuntsman 2004)
At the same time, our usual concepts of research participants and data also
need rethinking.
148 Chapter Eight
Boundaries of social situation, such as time, space and location are all
distorted or eroded in computer-mediated communication, giving us new
events, behaviors and situations. At best, the private-public divide in
cyberspace is conceptually and experientially blurred. (Waskul n.d.) To
date, there is no convention yet that regulates communication boundaries
in cyberspace. Some refer to it as “publicly private” or “privately public.”
(Bakardjieva and Feenberg n.d.; Waskul n.d.) Consider what Bakardjieva
and Feenberg said about this, which has great implications in obtaining
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 149
receiver only gets messages (mostly textual only) which are selected by
the sender to be conveyed through the medium. The other non-textual cues
that usually accompany offline communication such as voice and gestures
are filtered out most of the time in online communication. (Mason 1999)
This makes cyberselves vulnerable to different interpretations by
cyberspace goers and prone to different online situations. “Cyberselves are
always situated.” (Waskul n.d.) This kind of environment also promotes or
tolerates changes in self construction and representation through time and
location in cyberspace. Because this environment in cyberspace is
increasingly taken advantage of by cyberspace goers, a cyberself can now
be experienced as multiple, non-fixed, constantly changing, and in fact,
fluid.
The least that one can say in all these is that truths present themselves
differently in online research. There is little probably that one can verify
what another one willfully projects in cyberspace. Moreover, there is no
point in trying to disprove a persona that is willfully projected online. As
Hine puts it, “[t]he point for the ethnographer is not to bring some external
criterion for judging whether it is safe to believe what informants say, but
rather to come to understand how it is that informants judge authenticity.”
(Hine 2000 as cited by Carter 2005) The cyberethnographer’s interest is
precisely that persona which is projected, the discourse that creates and
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 151
IV. Cyberethnography
The research that I did among Filipino cyborgs in chatrooms drew on
knowledge production by methods of cyberethnography, a fairly new
genre of qualitative research.
devices to convince the audience and the historical, political and socio-
cultural context of the text. (Kintanar 1999)
V. Research Environment
In this section, I will give a background of the chatroom environment and
the things that, in the context of online research, can take place in the
chatroom and that are not usually observable or practiced in offline
research. I specifically refer to the chatroom’s “indulgent ambiance,” as I
call it, and the researcher’s practice of lurking within chatrooms.
VII. Lurking
One possible definition of “lurking” is: merely observing events without
contributing to the conversations while virtually present in a chatroom. In
physical world research, this is called “non-participant observation.” In
most newsgroups, only 10% post messages (posters); 90% are lurkers.
(Mason 1999) Frankel and Shang describe what lurkers-researchers do:
“On the Internet, group discussion formats make it relatively easy for
researchers to engage in covert or unobtrusive observation. An investigator
can record the online conversations of a community without making her
presence as a researcher known.” This practice is, to a large extent,
tolerated by cyborgs in a chatroom. Kizior explained:
If one registers for a list-serve it would be because that individual has
some interest in receiving whatever they have signed up for, whether they
be active or passive players. If one joins a chatboard, they do so because
they find the topic interesting and may want the opportunity to respond, if
not now then at a later time. There is no requirement that one has to be an
active participant. (Kizior 1999)
In the chatroom, you put on a mask, somehow. You enter with a created
username that is (usually) different from your name in the physical world
precisely because you want to put on a mask and create an identity that is
novel and different from what you project in the physical environment.
You put up a performance that you normally do not show in the physical.
It may be seen as a means of “hiding” your physical identity, but it may
also have a host of other reasons behind it. For one, hiding behind a mask
in the chatroom is hardly a conscious effort. The chatroom environment
makes putting on a mask inherent among cyborgs.
A whole lot of possibilities can be done when one is anonymous. One can
experiment or explore other possible identities. One may also savor
anonymity for the fun of it. Or one may want to be anonymous to elicit
different reactions from other cyborgs. “Anonymity constitutes the
fascination of chatting for the users.” (Orthmann 2000)
After all, in a chatroom, one deals with other cyborgs who are possibly
putting up their own masks or performances too. The physical persons
behind the cyborgs may be total strangers to you, but they may also be
your friends from the physical world or another researcher. But you don’t
necessarily run after the bodied persons behind the masks. In cyberspace,
you are after the masks. You are interested with the representations, rather
than the authors of those representations.
Identities in the chatroom heavily rely on “asl” – the chat acronym for
‘age, sex and location.’ It is usually the first information one asks of
another cyborg. One usually types “hi! asl?” to which another may reply
with “23 m dvo,” meaning 23-year-old male from Davao. Very seldom is
one’s “real” name asked. The usual usernames are, however, can be very
graphic and evocative, bearing strings like “huge penis” or “horny hunk.”
Other revealing “technologies of the self” would be text fonts, font sizes,
font colors and emoticons that accompany the texts. All combinations of
these “rudiments” of chatroom identities are chosen and deliberately
assembled by their authors. Chatroom identities are classic illustrations of
self-ascribed identities.
The chatroom name may not be used as a basis for establishing the identity
of cyborgs. To some extent, many Filipinos could be found in a Philippine
chatroom, and a lot of self-professed lesbians do chat inside a lesbian
chatroom. But the composition of chatters cannot be absolutized. Many
lurkers could be present in a particular chatroom out of curiosity. Some
cyborgs just want to hang around for no particular reason at all.
If we are to be sensitive of the nature of the field and the cyborgs that
constitute this research, coming to terms with the newly-emerging and
different angles by which “trustworthiness” can be looked at would
probably not be as difficult. Kuntsman emphasized this sensitivity through
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 159
The ethical response to this model is, of course, something that prevents
alienation of human subjects from their cultural production. If alienation
takes place in the researchers’ act of saving or using the products of group
communication, such as the chat transcripts, then a ‘non-alienating’ move
would be for the researchers to ask permission of their use preferably
before the production takes place. (Bakardjieva and Feenberg n.d.)
The human subjects model further requires that “research on humans must
take care to respect autonomy (free will), beneficence (minimizing harm
and preserving privacy), and justice toward human subjects.” (Walther
n.d.) Walther added that “the research use of spontaneous conversations, if
gathered in a publicly accessible venue, is not human subjects research…
Behavior in public settings is in fact not protected from recording for
research.” But is entering a chatroom and conversing with other chatters
for the purpose of research really “spontaneous conversations?”
The single most important document in ensuring that human rights are
taken care of while conducting the research is the informed consent. If we
consider online research to be one that deals with human subjects, we will
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 163
have to deal with issues of obtaining informed consent in every data that is
gathered and saved, every time we interact with other cyborgs, every time
we enter the chatroom to participate in discussions, observe or lurk and, in
fact, every time we “switch” to cyborg mode, i.e., every time we open our
computers.
At any rate, the task of profusely obtaining informed consent while doing
online research is not easy, of course, and practical considerations are
called for in these instances.
For cyborgs who additionally gave me other contact details such as email
by which the persons behind them could be further reached, I offered to
provide them with a copy of the drafts of my research as my way of
reciprocating them for being research participants and to solicit comments
and suggestions on my work. I had very low turn outs in this effort. Very
seldom could I go back to the research participants to talk to them for the
second time. I figured that, as it were, they might have already used a
different username after the first time we chatted. Yet even if they used the
same username and I saw them online again, they don’t usually exhibit the
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 165
And then again, it was always possible that the stories or personal details
about themselves that cyborgs told me the first time we meet did not really
happen to them, so they could hardly carry on talking about them during
subsequent online encounters. While I did not intend to reconcile different
versions of personal details or narratives – recognizing that even “fiction”
that comes out of conversations in cyberspace (cultural production) is
constructed and owned by a particular person – this phenomenon rendered
triangulation very difficult, if not outright impossible.
Finally, I relied heavily on the promise that my study would help bring to
the fore new epistemologies of masculinities that would be useful in
espousing egalitarian, non-oppressive and liberating forms of
masculinities. I always thought that these intentions would hopefully
address the issue of justice to research participants and that, as long as I
would put all the data gathered for my study to good use, I could be
confident that I would not cause great harm to the study participants.
XII. Conclusion
I have thus discussed the prominent methodological and ethical issues that
I have encountered in doing a cyberethnography among self-ascribed male
Filipino cyborgs in chatrooms. Many of my research techniques were
based on my assertions that cyberethnography is a research method that is
different from physical ethnography because it is done in a different field
among different selves who discursively deal with each other using a
different kind of truth. The research methodologies consequently had to be
constantly reshaped and renegotiated in the course of data gathering.
Ethical considerations were likewise approached keeping in mind that
ethical pluralism is always a possibility in cyberethnography. Perhaps,
more than elsewhere, the process of contextualizing decisions on what to
include as technically acceptable and ethically sound research
methodologies requires special attention in an emerging research genre
such as cyber ethnography.
166 Chapter Eight
References
ACNielsen, (2005a). Global consumer attitudes towards online shopping.
Australia: ACNielsen Company.
—. 2005b. Global online shopping habits. [Internet] Accessed on 16 April
2006. Available at
http://www2.acnielsen.com/press/documents/ACNielsen_OnlineShopp
ing GlobalSummary.pdf
Amazon. 2006. Review: Life online: Researching real experiences in
virtual space. [Internet] Accessed on 8 April 2006. Available at
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0761990313/104-7528530-
5012752?n=283155
American Association for the Advancement of Science. n.d. Ethical and
legal aspects of human subjects research in cyberspace. [Internet]
Accessed on 8 April 2006. Available at
http://www.aaas.org/spp/sfrl/projects/intres/main.htm
Armentor, J. 2005. The dynamics of a web chat community. [Internet]
Accessed on 18 December 2005. Available at
http://conferences.aoir.org/viewabstract.php?id=246&cf=3
Bakardjieva, M., Feenberg, A. n.d. Involving the virtual subject. [Internet]
Accessed on 7 April 2006. Available at
http://www.cddc.vt.edu/aoir/ethics/private/4S13.pdf
Basset, E.H., O’Riordan, K. n.d. Ethics of Internet research: Contesting the
human subjects research model. [Internet] Accessed on 8 April 2006.
Available at
http://www.nyu.edu/projects/nissenbaum/ethics_bas_full.html
Baym, N. 1995. The performance of humor in computer-mediated
communication. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication 1(2).
Boase, J., Horrigan, J.B., Wellman, B., Rainie, L. 2006. The strength of
Internet ties. Washington, DC: Pew Internet and American Life
Project.
Bruckman, A. 2002. Ethical guidelines for online research. [Internet]
Accessed on 18 April 2006.
Available at http://www-static.cc.gatech.edu/~asb/ethics/
Campbell, J.E. 2003. Always use a modem: Frames of erotic play and
performance in cyberspace. Electronic Journal of Communication
13(1).
Carter, D. 2005. Living in virtual communities. An ethnography of human
relationships in cyberspace. Information, Communication & Society
Vol. 8, No. 2, June 2005, pp. 148–167.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 167
MARGINAL COMMUNITIES
AND THEIR LIVELIHOODS: ROLE OF NGO
IN THE WATERSHED DEVELOPMENT
IN ANANTAPUR DISTRICT
OF ANDHRA PRADESH1
ESWARAPPA KASI
I. Introduction
Livelihoods approach was first taken up by scholars like Diana Carney and
Scoons (1998). One of the important features of livelihood approach is
that, it focuses upon people’s assets (physical, natural, financial, human,
social and political capitals). It also looks at how people utilize these
assets and negotiate their problems.
The sustainable livelihoods approach goes back to the mid 1980’s when
Robert Chambers first initiated thinking in this area. These early
theoretical formulations were further developed in early 1990’s by
Chambers, Conway and others (1999). Since then, a number of
development agencies, Governmental and non-governmental, such as
Department for International Development (DFID), United Nations
Development Programme (UNDP), CARE and OXFAM, have made
efforts to implement it. There have been many attempts to define
livelihoods. Chambers and Conway defined livelihoods as “the ways in
which people satisfy their needs, or gain a living” (1992:5).
shocks and maintain or enhance its capabilities and assets both now and in
the future, while not undermining the natural resource base”
(Carney,1998: 2).
Livelihood Security means “Secure ownership of, access to, resources and
income- generating activities, including reserves and assets to offset risk,
ease shocks and meet contingencies” (Chambers, 1988: 2).
Robert Chambers (at IDS) and Gordon Conway (at IIED), themselves
drawing upon insights from previous research on food security and agro-
ecological sustainability, are widely acknowledged for having put
livelihoods, then usually called ‘sustainable livelihoods’, at centre stage
(Chambers and Conway, 1992).
This is not to say that livelihood is not a matter of material well-being, but
rather that it also includes non-material aspects of well-being. Livelihood
should be seen as a dynamic and holistic concept. In the words of
Bebbington (1999: 2002)
A person’s assets, such as land, are not merely means with which he or she
makes a living: they also give meaning to that person’s world. Assets are
not simply resources that people use in building livelihoods: they are
assets that give them the capability to be and to act. Assets should be
understood only as things that allow survival, adaptation and poverty
alleviation: they are also the basis of agents’ power to act and reproduce,
challenge or change the rules that govern the control, use and
transformation of resources.
A valuable step forward has been made by Scoones and Wolmer (2002) in
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 175
whether they are ethnic minorities or groups that are in some other way set
apart from the mainstream” (177-178).
The World Bank (2005) uses the term "Indigenous Peoples" instead,
which is defined in Our Operational Policies 4.10 (link to OP 4.10
provided below) as: The term "Indigenous Peoples" is used in a generic
sense to refer to a distinct, vulnerable, social and cultural group,
possessing the following characteristics in varying degrees:
As Bokil rightly pointed out that the first and foremost problem before the
tribal communities in India is to earn and sustain livelihoods. This
problem is assumed alarming proportions because the traditional means of
obtaining livelihoods are increasingly threatened. In the past fifty years the
access to and control over the resources has undergone radical changes.
Thus, it is in this context demonstration of the tribal communities which
can make use of the available natural resources and obtain sustainable
livelihoods (2002, 163-165).
There are many definitions of NGOs. The voluntary sector includes non-
governmental, non-profit organisations. They may be engaged in a variety
of activities: implementing grassroots/sustainable development, promoting
human rights and social justice, protesting against environmental
degradation, and many other similar tasks. Baviskar (ibid) as rightly
mentioned that some activists resent and reject the term non-governmental
organisation and instead designate themselves as social action groups,
political action groups or social movements. Anna Hazare’s village
development group at Ralegan Siddhi in Maharashtra and Ela R. Bhatt’s
Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA) in Gujarat are both
identified as NGOs but are very different from each other in terms of size,
membership, funding, approaches, strategies and outcomes.
I quote from Baviskar (2001) who also said that while there are many
definitions of NGOs, there are several classifications too. Shah and
Cahturvedi (1983) divide NGOs in three main categories: techno-
managerial, reformist, and radical. Hirway (1995) classified NGOs in
Gujarat into welfare-oriented, development organisations, and
empowering NGOs. Iyengar (1998) classified NGOs in Gujarat into four
categories: Gandhian, service delivery organisations, professional
organisations, and mobilisational organisations.
There are studies which explains the link between NGO, CBO, Civil
Society and DWCRA is cordial and making a good success all over India
and most importantly in Andhra Pradesh. Andhra Pradesh role in the
country is highest in the SHG’s and NGO’s and they are acting as good
agents of the development. Namerta (1995) as rightly said that the NGOs
could only facilitates the undertaking of subsistence activities, and income
from such activities was either equal to or less than the existing wage
income. These activities made a difference to the people in so far as they
180 Chapter Nine
could be undertaken during the lean season and that the problem of
seasonal unemployment could be, to some extent, solved (Radhakrishna
and Ray, 2005).
V. Methodology
This paper is based on the data collected from Ananthapur district in
Andhra Pradesh during the year 2003-2004. The present study is basically
a qualitative study aimed at understanding the livelihood systems of the
marginal communities and shocks, stresses and trends involved in their
livelihood processes. In order to fulfil the objective of the study,
qualitative anthropological tools and techniques are employed. These are
mainly Observation (participant and non-participant type), Interviews
(formal and informal) using detailed checklist, Key-Informant interviews,
Case Studies, Focus Group Discussions, etc. Understanding the natives
concepts and people’s views regarding the livelihood systems of the
people, existing systems of utilization, local knowledge of the different
capitals involved and also, most importantly, role of vulnerability context
in their daily life systems.
Data from secondary sources are gathered from books, articles, published
reports, census reports, and government documents from the respective
departments. Quantitative data with regard to demographic and economic
aspects, and accessibility and availability of different assets, services, and
also other information regarding the study was collected from primary
sources through detailed census schedules.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 181
While DPAP is targeted towards the semi-arid and dry sub-humid areas,
182 Chapter Nine
The entire district is declared as hot arid due to severity of soil erosion,
high temperatures, and low and erratic ad uneven distribution of rainfall
resulting in ‘soil and moisture stress’, excessive evaporational losses and
crop losses as the ultimate effect of drought and high aridity index. Trends
of desertification are also seen in parts of district. The district is
unfortunately had skipped from drought prone to hot arid district. Ground
water levels are alarmingly receding. Further degeneration of existing
marginal and degraded forests had happened in the last 4 decades and
acute scarcity of drinking water, fodder and fuel is taking place in every
alternative year which is a serious drought year. All these factors are
creating tremendous concern and awareness regarding the danger that is
looming large among the masses of the district.
desertification trends.
However, with all the developmental strategies carried out under DPAP
upto 1994-95 nearly 2.62lakh hectares out of 19.5 lakh hectares of
geographical area could be covered and about 2.07 lakh individual
beneficiaries could be assisted. At this stage trends of desertification were
noticed in various parts of the district. It is declared as hot arid district and
programme of DDP is introduced in the year 1995 onwards. In this
programme a concerted integrated micro watershed development approach
was envisaged under Dr. Hanumantha Rao new guidelines of Government
of India. According to this, area of watershed would be approximately
500 ha, and programmed to spend Rs.22.50 lakhs in each watershed. Out
of which Rs.18.00 lakhs will go for works component and Rs. 4.50 lakhs
for community organisation and administrative cost. It is contemplated to
execute the works and to implement the programme through NGO’s and
Government, officials as Project Implementation Agency (PIA).
184 Chapter Nine
Pradesh already under his belt, Rajen Joshua set out to register his own
NGO and the Social Education and Development Society (SEDS) was
born. With the help of his wife and eight friends he established a central
campus on a farm in the village of Anandapuram and began working with
the local population towards improved community organization. Twenty-
one years later it has blossomed to employ 35 full-time staff, organize 60
village health workers (soon to be more than 100) and often day labor for
up to 500 people. Its programs have expanded from simple community
organization to include large-scale watershed, child sponsorship, village
health, and community and women’s empowerment programs serving 120
villages with more than 100,000 people.
Tree and grass introduction, initiated on the hills using local species such
as Neem, Tamarind and Pogamia Glabva, has since expanded to roadsides,
homesteads, schools, bunds and other SEDS landscaping projects. The 17-
km road leading from Penukonda to Anandapuram and the SEDS farm has
blossomed amazingly. Large green canopies now hang over previously
brown expanses, providing shade and shelter to passing workers and
travelers. Possibly most impressive however, is the farm itself, which has
grown into a virtual oasis with its towering palm trees, nurseries, gardens
and paddy fields.
In the same manner as hillside trees, grass planted along contour bunds,
dams and gully checks has proven essential to their maintenance and
durability. The root structures of the vegetation give strength and cohesion
to the soil by trapping water, and allow low-cost production that utilizes
natural elements instead of relying on artificial materials such as concrete.
Wood lots have been established for basic fuel needs in order to ease the
188 Chapter Nine
Gully checks and check dams are the primary methods by which the flow
of water over natural terrain is controlled. The water's course is slowed
and directed by dirt and concrete barriers constructed by SEDS with the
assistance of the benefiting farmers and villagers. The barriers are placed
in ravines and natural waterways where erosion and deforestation have
greatly diminished the ability of the terrain to retain moisture and the
crucial topsoil is continually washed away. When the heavy rains do fall,
they run off almost immediately, providing nothing to the vegetation in the
higher regions. With this system of checks, both water and the eroding
topsoil are trapped, preventing loss and benefiting previously desperate
areas.
Through all of these efforts, SEDS has managed to drastically improve the
situation in which the area finds itself with respect to its water supply.
With the extensive construction realized under its water management
program the water table has risen 38 feet and crop production has doubled.
Furthermore, the health and growth benefits to the economy, the residents
and the region itself have been immense.
and soil rejuvenation has increased which resulted in the crop yielding to
the farmers.
Horticultural crops have been given to the farmers through which changes
have come in the cropping pattern. Due to the watershed programme,
ground water table has increased to 110 feets from 80 feets according to
the sarpanch. According to Venkatesu, who is practicing Dairying, milk
yield has improved drastically from 60 litres to 300 litres over a period of
three years. People have also felt that forestland has increased. According
to the farmer by name Ramanjaneyulu, crop yield has gone up from 5 to 6
bags per acre to 8 to 10 bags after watershed programme.
Non –form activity has also increased after watershed programme in the
village. There are 3 hotels, 3 petty business shops in the village which
were not there before watershed programme. Some of the people have
maintaining autos and running between Mallapuram to Kalyanadurg. They
said that due to watershed programme, self employment has been
improved according to Chandrasekhar.
Notes
1
An earlier version of the paper was presented in the International Conference on
Natural Hazards and Disasters: Local to Global Perspective, November, 25-27,
2006, Anantapur, Andhra Pradesh, India.
References
Baviskar, B.S. (2001). NGO s and Civil Society in India, Sociological
Bulletin, 50 (1) March 2001.
192 Chapter Nine
Conwy.
Pretty J. Ward H (2001), Social Capital and the Environment. World
Development 29(2): 209-227.
Prowse, Martin. (2003), Towards a Clearer Understanding of
‘Vulnerability’ in relation to Chronic Poverty, CPRC Working Paper
No. 24, Manchester: University of Manchester.
Radhakrishna, R. and Shovan Ray (2005), Handbook of Poverty in India,
New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Scoones, I. (1998), Sustainable Rural Livelihoods: A Framework for
Analysis. IDS Working Paper No.72. Brighton: IDS: Sussex.
Social Education and Development Society (2004), Annual Report of
Social Education and Development Society prepared to submit to the
donors, 2002-2004. Source: www.seds.org
Seeley, Janet (2001), Recognising Diversity: Disability And Rural
Livelihoods Approaches In India, Natural Resource perspectives,
Number 72, October, DFID.
Sen, A. (1981) “Poverty and famines: An essay on entitlement and
deprivation” Clarendon Press: Oxford.
Williams G. (1999), Assessing poverty and poverty alleviation: Evidence
from West Bengal. Trans Inst. Br. George: NS 24: 193-212.
CHAPTER TEN
I. Introduction
Aggregate studies of the urban social geography of Pune city have shown,
in common with most other countries having a multi – ethnic or linguistic
population, a degree of ethnic residential segregation that is independent
of social class or other influences of residential choice (Johnston, 1973a,b;
Timms, 1971). These were confirmed by detailed mapping of the
distribution of particular groups, which showed their members
concentrating in particular sections of the chosen cities (Thomson and
Trlin, 1970). Are these types of enclave found in all urban areas, small and
large?
Pune at present is one of the ten large cities of India. The population of
Pune city in 1941 was only 275, 000. After Independence, initially due to
196 Chapter Ten
II. Hypotheses
1) Migrants generally marry the girls from their native places.
2) Assimilation of migrants in the main stream takes place when
they mix with the culture and tradition of the area and become
familiar with the language.
It has been observed that in Pune city the migrants from different parts of
the country and abroad are concentrated in different parts of the city. For
example, migrants coming from Gujarat and Rajasthan have a high
concentration in Guruwar and Raviwar Peths (Core area) of Pune city
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 197
For the analysis of the formation of enclaves of migrants within the city a
separate sample of 500 households was taken. While selecting this sample
some of the known enclaves of agglomeration of migrants from specific
sending areas were chosen.
Among the states of the Indian Union, the first six (excluding
Maharashtra) contributors to the flow of migrants were Karnataka (200),
Andhra Pradesh (85), Uttar Pradesh (65), Gujarat (60), Kerala (50), and
Rajasthan (40). Separate information has been taken from early migrants
from Pakistan are Sindh. The each enclave sample has taken 5 percent of
the total migrants from the particular states and the total sample size is
500. The information for enclave formation has been collected with the
help of detailed questionnaire. Each group has formed enclave within Pune
city. To demarcate the enclave, city survey map was used.
IV. Methodology
It was observed that the migrant communities are the minority
communities and they feel more secure when they live in their own
community. Considering this, the survey was undertaken of such localities
where the migrants coming from different parts of the country were
concentrated. Subsequently, first six states from where more migrants
have settled in Pune i.e. Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh,
Rajasthan, Kerala and Gujarat and the early migrants from Sindh, were
selected for study.
An inquiry was made (using snow balling technique) with several people
from different states about their places of residence and finally concluded
that they are living in different areas in the city but only a few, which are
dominating by one regional (other than Marathi) language people, have
been selected, such as Karnataka (Kannada) in Jay Bhavani Nagar (south -
eastern part), Andhra Pradesh (Telugu) in Bhavani Peth (Western part of
core area), Uttar Pradesh (Hindi) in Bhayyawadi (north part), Kerala
(Malayalam) in Aundh-Khadki Road (north - eastern part), Gujarat and
Rajasthan in Guruwar Peth and Raviwar Peth (Core area) as well as new
areas like Adinath Society and Suparshwanath Society (south - eastern
part). The Sindhis are concentrated more in the Sindh Society (north -
198 Chapter Ten
western part), cantonment area (south - eastern part) and Meera Society
(central part) of the city.
In cases of many migrants the deity they worship is the same, and the
festivals they celebrate also are the same. Migrants need certain articles for
day-to-day consumption, which are generally not used by the local
community. Though majority of the migrants see Hindi movies, some of
them prefer to see movies in their regional language. Many times the
migrants prefer to go to a doctor with whom they can communicate in
their regional language. Many times migrants have an organization in the
form of an association or a club joined by the people coming from the
same region and speaking same language. To meet these demands of the
community, a place of worship devoted to a particular deity commonly
worshiped by the people coming from the same region comes up. A school
giving instructions in the regional language comes up. Medical
practitioners who can communicate in the regional language start their
dispensaries. A movie house in the locality starts showing movies in their
regional language, if not for regular show, at least for the morning shows.
Commercial establishments come up which cater to the special needs of
the community. A community hall comes up in the particular enclave.
Generally, migrants are of two extreme types, one type, qualitatively the
cream of the society but numerically the less significant, consists of bright
youths, who migrate in search of education or wider opportunities. These
groups can adapt to urban culture and way of life easily. The second type
is poor and less educated migrants who come for livelihood they in slums
in the city and in groups with people of same language, and form enclaves
in the cities (Table No.2).
The presence of relatives’ friends and acquaintances in the city helps the
newly arrived migrants in securing initial shelter. This also favours their
entry in the enclaves. It has been observed that, the arrival of the migrant
in the city has not been due to a random search for employment but has
depended largely on the presence of friends, caste men, relatives, fellow
villagers or migrants from neighbouring areas (Mujumdar and Mujumdar,
1987: 42).
Whenever immigrants arrive in groups, they also bring with them their
language and religion. (Chandana 1986: 113). Language is the basic
medium for exchange of ideas and emotions. Migrants, who are new in the
urban culture, prefer to stays together with people who speak the same
language, generally, which is their language. Similar language is the
important reason for enclave formation. “For many migrants, the
abandonment of the mother tongue does not happen until the second
generation, especially amongst the women, who remain at home whilst
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 201
their husbands are forced to adopt the new language at work”. (Garnier
1967: 231).
but the majority of them are usurers pure and simple. (Crawford 1987:
195) They are segregated in Kalyan society, Suparshwnath society and
Marketyard. Most of them had come from the districts of Kota, Sirohi,
Ajmer and Jodhpur, which are nearer and have better access by railway
and road to Pune. They are early migrants, out of total samples 72 percents
had come before 1960. Almost 92 percents of the heads of migrant
families at the time of migration belonged to the working age group, that is
20-40 years. Fifty percents migrants are literate up to 10th standard, 44
percents are graduates and 6 percents are postgraduates. They are rich
migrants, 78 percents of them earn above 10,000 Rs. per month and 6
percents earn above 50,000 Rs. per month. This shows that they are
economically in good condition.
Sindhis’ are early migrants and they came at the time of partition from
Pakistan to the city. Most of the Sindhis had come empty handed and
entered in different business activities. Seventy-five percents of the Sindhi
migrants are engaged in business of selling electronic goods, utensils,
grocery and sport goods in the city.
This shows that, the important reasons for enclave formation are similar
language speaking people, relatives and friends from their own region and
security. Because of all these reasons migrants prefer to stay together in
the metro cities.
IX. Discussion
Scholars have come to a conclusion about the formation and reasons of
segregation. There are racial, ethnic, linguistic, economic and religious
segregations all over the world. The pattern may be different but the
reasons are similar everywhere such as, to regain the identity, for security,
economic purpose and due to socio-cultural affinity. According to
Dipankar Gupta in Mumbai linguistic and religious groups are found for
the sake of security and cultural affinity. Muzumdar’s study on Delhi
shows that, migrants came to city due to friends, caste men, relatives,
fellow villagers or migrants from neighbouring areas and formed enclaves.
204 Chapter Ten
As per Khandwale and Chorgade, in the city of Nagpur poor working class
migrants stay together. One may ask a question; are such levels of
segregation still present in the cities. As far as Pune city is concerned
migrants in their initial stage search acquaintances for accommodation.
After getting familiar with the socio-cultural tempo and after achieving
certain economic level some of them shift either to other places or towards
new areas. The rich migrants like Rajasthani and Gujarati and their
children shifted to satellite enclaves in the periphery such as Adinath
society and Kalyan society.
X. Conclusion
The study reveals that, the observation shows that, the construction
activity of Pune city has attracted more migrants from Karnataka, whereas
most of the migrants from Rajasthan and Gujarat are engaged in Trade and
Commerce activity. When the Migrants enter urban way of life, they are
new to the entire urban environment. In such situation various aspects like
security, common language of sending State, other than Marathi, common
social ties and regional affinity influence their activity and the migrants
have a tendency to live in the groups (segregation). They feel more secure
when they live in the group.
References
Aijazuddin Ahmad (1995), Tibetan Migrants In India., Population
Geography., 17,7-14.
Bagley, C. (1971), Immigrant Minorities in the Netherlands: Integration
and Assimilation. International Migration Review., 5: 18-35.
Carmen Voigt-Graf (1997), Migrant experience in Australia- Three groups
of Indians compared. Population Geography., 19: 15-28. (1997).
Census of India (2001), Government of India, “Provisional Population
Tables - A” PP. 17-18,.
Chandna R.C. (1986), A Geography of Population: Concepts,
Determinants and Patterns. Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi.
Crawford Archur (1987), History of Poona and Deccan in a Perspective.
Gian Publishing House. 29/6 Shakti Nagar. Delhi-110007. India.
Dipankar Gupta (1982), Nativism in Metropolis: The Shiv Sena in
Bombay. Manohar Books, Delhi.
Garnier B. (1966), Geography of Population. Longman, London.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 205
I. Introduction
The present paper is based on the field work carried out in selected
districts of the state of West Bengal (the lateritic part which is in the
eastern part of the state) between November 2006 till February 2007. It is
an effort to portray the importance of folk festivals and customs acting as
important means to perpetuate cultural anxieties as expressed through time
and under changing circumstances. It attempts to understand the changes
within folk culture through festivals, and their relation with economy and
environment of the region. Though the various festivities emerge from the
body of the folk tradition, yet certain characteristics of these festivals often
change over a period of time under various socio-cultural conditions.
However, inspite of changes, a significant aspect of the ethnic mosaic of
the folk tradition continues through its very expression, which is handed
down from generation to generation. The paper attempts to portray the
same through two important folk festivals of the lateritic region in West
Bengal, with the help of a brief historical understanding of their
development in the region and their place in modern times. They are-
1. The revered significance associated with the worship of goddess
Manasā
2. The celebration of Tushu festival
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 207
The two festivals under study are intrinsically different in their mode of
expression as well as worship, yet they were selected as they portray quite
aptly, the aspect of a parallel analysis of continuity and change of folk
culture through time and both are folk in origin. Both the festivals have
their special and separate place in the socio-cultural and religious life of
the region. Both Tushu and Manasā are local deities, but the varied
perspective of worship bring to light an interesting aspect of folk culture-
their importance as well as changes within the folk culture. Tushu is
worshipped as a harvest goddess and Manasā as a goddess that cures as
well as brings the wrath of snakebites. The worship of Manasā is rather
induced with a sense of fear and veneration, while Tushu festivals and
brata rites today, form a part of natural expression of livelihood during the
winter harvesting season. However, since both emerge from the same folk
platform of the region, it is interesting to note their varying nature of
expression through time under different socio-cultural circumstances. And
finally, both have survived due to the continuity of the tradition through
generations.
hired labourers.
Though, Manasā is revered and worshipped throughout the year, the main
worship or puja of Manasā however, takes place in the month of Shravan
(officially the second monsoon month according to the Indian agricultural
calendar, consisting of the months of July-August).
From the Mangalkavyas3, one gets to know much about the goddess
Manasā, as an integral part of the daily life of local people. The
theriomorphic representation of Manasā is older than the anthropomorphic
representation, but much is known about the anthropomorphic form and
mythologies of Manasā, since her depiction in the Manasa Mangalkavya4-
the latest Purana, composed towards the end of 15th century A.D- when
the deity is considered to be formally absorbed within the Brahmanic set-
up and thereby got accepted within the fold of the ‘Greater Tradition.’
Thus, the deity is also an example of the admixture of the 'Greater' and the
'Little Traditions' and the acceptance of the latter within the framework of
the former. She is also similar to the snake goddess Manchamman in
South India, but Manasā, related to the ecology of the region, is more
powerful in both protecting people from snakebites as well as causing
them. She is considered to be a very belligerent goddess who propagates
her own following amongst humans in competition to the following of the
so-called ‘Greater Tradition’ of Śiva and Vishnu quite aggressively.
The iconography of the goddess comes to light in about 9th century A.D.
Initially she was worshipped through a pot full of water and a twig of the
Sij tree (earthen pot is a symbol of the womb and the Sij tree signifies
natural fertility of the region). Later, her anthropomorphic form shows her
standing on a lotus (again a sign of fertility, related especially to goddess
210 Chapter Eleven
Lakshmi) with two as well as four arms, issuing out of an ornamental pot.
Her head is covered with the hood of seven snakes. She holds in her hands,
a snake, a pot, a rosary and a manuscript (another evidence of
sanskritisation). In one instance, dated to 11th century A.D., she is shown
in connection to Śiva Linga. In another instance of the same period, she is
seen holding a child and also a fruit (also symbolising a womb). She is
also shown sometimes with her vahana (mount) as a dog or an elephant
(11th century), where the former might be the remnant of some ancient folk
tradition, while the later might be the result of an attempt of sanskritisation
by connecting her with Gaja-lakshmi. In some still later sculptures, she is
also depicted with a third eye, akin to Śiva (10th, 11th and 13th century).
In all the description, her attributes seem similar like known Puranic gods
and goddess and also she retains her folk tradition as a Mother goddess,
through the reference of fertility symbols and secondary sexual organs
which is an important aspect of the recognition of Mother goddesses.
Manasā seems to be an original folk deity. She might have been just a
deity of the snakes or a deity of fertility, portrayed by the pot of water and
the twig of the Sij tree. She was later absorbed within the Brahmanic fold
by upper caste Hindus to gain the confidence of the lower caste and thus
the inclusion of the deity in the Mangalkavyas. Interesting is to note
Manasā’s identification with various other religious philosophies and
concepts. She is identified as being identical to Saraswati (Bhattasali,
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 211
Though being an integral part of the folk culture, Manasā worship, today
occupies a central and important part of worship as a popular deity
throughout the year, especially in Bankura. Her worship not only portrays
an important and significant aspect of change, but also the process of
admixture of the folk with mainstream and more popular Puranic religious
deities, as compared to Durga or any of her several popular incarnations.
Today, the deity is worshipped in both theriomorphic as well as
anthropomorphic forms. Existing as an independent divinity, without a
male consort, quite unlike most of the more popular Puranic or
mainstream goddesses, Manasā worship forms an important part of folk
religious life.
A field work in the region also revealed the prevalence of Manasā temples
in all the para’s or settlements, especially of the Bauri community in the
region, being parallel in popularity to any prevalent important deity of the
respective villages. Mention may be made of the field work in the village
of Chhatna (Bankura), which revealed the prevalence of Manasā
worshipping temples in all of the four Bauri para or settlements (namely,
Bansberia, Saturgaria, Tantipukur, and Metiapara), though the presiding
deity of the village is Basuli. The fieldwork for the present paper was
conducted in the Bauri para of Bansberia, under No. 1 Gram Panchayat
(village authority). The temples, consisting of clay anthropomorphic
images of the deity, is not only visited during the auspicious month of
Shravan, but also on a regular basis for wish fulfillment and worship by
both married and unmarried women, as well as men. The Bauri’s of the
village mostly work as hired labourers in the field of others all year round,
to which modern professions like, driving a rickshaw-van, working as
hired labourers in the nearby city of Kolkata, etc.- has added an element of
difference. Interestingly, though it is a folk goddess, the importance of the
deity is witnessed through a temple on the main road of Chhatna, in the
Jamadar para, connecting to the main town of Bankura. The worship
officiated by a Bauri priest, (Sudarshan Kaviraj was the temple priest
during the fieldwork in November 2006, who insisted that the worship
mainly consists of Tantra Sakti rites) the anthropomorphic deity made of
terracotta is worshipped on a regular basis. The temple is often visited all
year round by people from other higher castes as well. The offering to the
goddess or the priest consists on a daily basis of the morsels available at
home, including milk, fruits and sometimes with donations for an
elaborate puja by a devotee that consists of luchis (wheat flour pancakes
deep fried in oil) and kheer (dessert made of milk and sugar), though these
are rare being costly offerings. The priest also takes part in the customary
Jhapan festivities on the 15th of every month of Bhadra. The popularity of
the deity, is however, not only limited to the Bauri para’s alone, but also
the main city of Bankura, which has several temples of the goddess which
are regularly visited and worshipped by devotees all year round, often
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 213
being officiated by Brahmin priests. Apart from the main city, other
villages also has similar trend, where a Brahmin priest is seen officiating
the rituals, e.g. the village of Indas (especially of the two para’s- Dibakor
Bati and Haripur) has stones, located under shrubs and trees, worshipped
as the deity Manasā and the puja is officiated by a Brahmin priest.
A part of the folk culture that remains true to its tradition, there are no
historical recording of the genesis of Tushu ceremony or brata songs.
However, it is interesting to note a mention of a similar winter harvest
festival, corresponding to the similar time of the year and having similar
characters of a harvest festival in king Ashoka’s (B.C.-269- 232) Dhauli
and Jaugada Shilanushashan’s (Rock Edicts) (Sen, p-65). In these two
Rock Edicts, Ashoka speaks about two specific folk festivals concerning
harvesting during the month of Paush. The Dhauli Rock Edict (located in
Puri district, Orissa, India, near Bhubanaeswar and referred to as Number
1 Separate Kalinga Rock Edict) records- “This Edict should be heard at the
time of Tishya Nakshatra (Tishya constellation). Outside the period of
Tishya, it can be heard individually as well from time to time (Sen, p- 93).
Sen explains it as- “Every Tishya period, probably, a gathering was held
for listening to this edict.” The Jaugada Rock Edict (located in Ganjam
district, Orissa, India and referred to as Number 2 Separate Kalinga Rock
Edict) records, “This Rock Edict, will be heard for a period of four months
during the time of Tishya Nakshatra (Tishya constellation). Outside the
period of Tishya, at other times as well, this edict can be heard. If need be,
it can be heard individually as well.”(Sen, p- 96). Sen explains this also, as
being an edict that was listened to during the time of Tishya Nakshatra.
Though no specific date of these inscriptions on the edicts can be
ascertained, however, it can be postulated that these date back to more
than two thousand years on the basis of the formation period of the Rock
Edicts. Sen elucidates, “Numbers 5 to 14 Rock Edicts were put up during
the 13th and 14 years of his reign, including the 1 and 2 Separate Rock
Edicts.” With an approximately postulated date, these rock edicts help to
portray the importance of a winter harvest festival more than two thousand
years ago.
However, there has been no special mention of the songs pertaining to the
festival in the inscription. The prominence of the songs and its
preservation on paper seems to have been an added benefit of the
invention of the printing press. Through time, Tushu festival has also been
variously termed as Poshla, Sanjo, Sodo Bhasano, amidst others. (Sen, p-
65).
It should be noted that the mere mention of the winter harvest festival in
the Ashokan inscription does not specify a royal patronage of the same.
There is also no specific available evidences to suggest the same. Certain
folk festivals got escalated to the rank of a higher order and gradually got
absorbed within the folds of the ‘Greater Tradition,’ as is witnessed in the
case of Manasā puja. The festival of Tushu, till date, is specifically
observed by the Bauri’s and other lower communities of lateritic West
Bengal. Till date, the festival remains outside the purview of the
mainstream religion. Though it never faces opposition from other higher
castes, but this does not denote that the festival finds a patronage amidst
the other higher castes or the local royalty. No record is also available to
suggest that the festival in the region used to be patronised by the local
royalty previously.
The brata rites and songs6 of West Bengal are often associated with folk
festivals. They not only convey a cultural message to the next generation,
but also help to build up a belief structure for oneself within which one
operates and thereby helping to shape a mode of communication with the
next generation. Through changing times, the brata rites have helped to
perpetuate cultural anxieties and they represent a binding force of ethnic
mosaic. This paper tries to look into the aspect through the Tushu brata
rites and songs of the village Chhatna in Bankura district in West Bengal
(India).
The Tushu songs are quite unique in their character as they are
spontaneous and not repetitive. They are not written down or the lyrics are
never memorised from books. Rather, the lyrics are formed at the very
moment of singing and are unprompted. However, this unaided and
unprompted character never deters the womenfolk to join in the songs. As
one starts the song, the rest in the same group immediately picks up from
the very second word of the song. The song maintains the same pitch
throughout and continues unabated without any disturbance or flaw of
repertoire. It is important to note the pattern of the melody of Tushu songs.
It follows a beat of 2 + 4, famous as the Sashti Taal in Indian music.7
However, since there has been no exact records to stipulate the date of
genesis of music let alone folk music, it becomes very difficult to ascertain
for how long these songs in their specific beat has been a part of the lives
of this folk tradition. (Bankura Jela Sankhya, p-190). The language of the
Tushu brata songs remain to be a mixture of Bengali and Santhali dialects,
though modernisation has made them more Bengali in recent times.
218 Chapter Eleven
The song (mentioned below) show the revered nature of the festival in the
hearts of the folk tradition that speaks about the pain of a daughter who is
away from her father’s home at the time of the Tushu festival and pines to
return home. She complains within herself to her mother.
[Mother dear you married me off to such a distant place across the big river,
You kept me away on the occasion of such a big festival of Paush,
Mother, I feel sad and my mind is in turmoil
Quite like the corn kernels popping in a heated frying pan…]
The Tushu songs also sometimes reflect the mental anxiety of the father
who is finding it hard to find a suitable groom for his daughter since the
dowry demand is too high-
Still at other times, the Tushu songs also reflect the anxieties arising out of
the payment of heavy taxation-
220 Chapter Eleven
And, not forgetting the young mind, love also finds an expression through
Tushu brata songs-
The festival of Tushu has mainly four main parts with each having specific
songs-
Or
“Tushu Tushu kore amra
Tushu amar ghorey go…”
2. Stuti (worship)
“Tushli eyorani tumi boro bhagyamoni
Puji tomar charon dukhani…”
The present paper focuses on the Tushu ceremony of Bansberia para (the
other three para’s are Saturgaria, Tantipukur, and Metiapara), under No. 1
Gram Panchayat (village authority). Tushu brata rites form an integral
part of the festivities in wintertime at the Bauri para of Bansberia.
According to the local people, the festival is an integral part of the lives of
the Bauri’s that is marked by a pompous gathering on the final day of the
festival- on the day of Paush Sankranti.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 223
All the three examples portray three different types of subject matters
within three different contexts. They also reflect the varied situations and
circumstances that prompt the songs to be framed and thereby echo a
medium of expression of social and cultural anxieties. Being associated
through generations, the songs and their repertoire is an oft-repeated
phenomenon for the younger generations, especially the women. By the
time, the girl reaches a marriageable age, the songs have already become
an integral part of their lives. Finally, after marriage, they join in to
celebrate the festival through singing the brata songs.
VII. Conclusion
Both Manasā and Tushu brata rites and festival are integral parts of the
lives of many in lateritic West Bengal, especially in the regions under
study and both have the same folk origin. Both have been handed down
through generations, however, the method of preservation of cultural
symbols differs between the two festivals. As Manasā worship got a
gradual acceptance within the fold of the ‘Greater Tradition’ and found its
place in the written literature in the form of the famous Manasā
Mangalkavya, Tushu worship and the festival remains an integral part of
the ‘Little Tradition’ and the folk culture. The reason for this may be
found in the nature of acceptance of these festivals from a very early time.
As Manasā, being a part of a widely observed festival, got a gradual
acceptance through the patronage of the local higher castes, prompted by
changing political and social circumstances, Tushu seems to have
remained within the parameters of the folk, finding a natural space parallel
to other prominent festivals of the region. Being a popular winter harvest
festival, it might have survived side-by-side the more popular Brahmanical
festivals, but it never became a part of the mainstream Brahmanic rituals
and today, forms an integral part of the lives of the Bauri’s, especially in
the areas under study, who work as mostly hired labourers in others fields
or even engaged in other modern activities in modern times in the village
and cities outside the villages.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 225
Agriculture being the main subsistence pattern of the people, especially for
the Bauri’s, where most of them work as hired labourers in the fields of
others- the festival of Tushu occupies a significant position in their daily
lives. Tushu festival is often connected to fertility rites, since it is
associated with agriculture and was mainly observed by unmarried girls
and later by mostly women. Today, it not only celebrates the winter
harvest, but also acts as a tool of expression for certain socio-cultural
anxieties and agonies with both men and women of the communities
concerned. The worship of Manasā on the other hand, has helped to built
up an important conduit of expression where the historical development is
a proof enough of the need for its acceptance within certain folds of the
society and thereby acting as a reaction towards certain socio-cultural
changes. It is also significant to note that both the festivals have survived
the test of time as being handed down through generations and thus
bearing witness to the survival of oral and certain folk symbols acting as
means of perpetuation of certain socio-cultural and religious anxieties and
agonies. Though both are the worship of local folk deities, their historical
226 Chapter Eleven
Notes
1
Asok Datta had attempted to speak of three economic divisions of the different
regions of West Bengal. Though, the following citation is entirely according to the
author’s deductions, but it is a pointer in the direction of the economically active
regions of West Bengal in ancient times. Datta spoke about Chalcolithic
settlements at different regions of West Bengal with different regional characters
and identity immediately after the Harappan civilization around 1750 B.C, where
certain areas, especially including modern districts like South Western Midnapur
remain sparsely populated while adjoining areas because of its rich soil and being
near port cities, developed much faster with an increasing number of population.
(1990:77).
2
William L. Smith describes the survival of the ‘Little Tradition’ as the “oldest,
the most valuable and the most authentically Bengali traditions in the delta.”
3
This class of literature flourished during the post-Chaitanya period and formed to
what is considered the most important branch of literature next to Vaishnava
literature. Manasā, Chaņdi and Dharma Ţhākur were the principal non- Purāņic
deities whose glory was sung in books possesing high literary merit. This section
of literature was meant to be sung and was also known as Pāñchālī. Its subject
matter was the glorification of deities of later times and its main object was to
preach their cults and make them popular. It is very likely that these cults were
introduced into Hindu society by primitive people and the Mangal Kavyas were the
principal means of spreading it among the higher classes in Hindu society. The title
of the long narrative poem of this class was formed by the addition of the word
‘mangala’ or ‘vijaya’ to that of the deity concerned. These two suffixes were
indiscriminately used whether the deity concerned is Purāņic or merely one of a
local cult evolved in comparately later periods. Thus, we have both Kŗishņa-
mangala and Kŗishņa -vijaya as well as Manasā-mangal and Manasā -vijaya
(Majumdar p-287)
4
The oldest books amongst the Mangalkavyas are the songs based on the legends
of Manasā, a cult deity, the popular accounts of whose origin, connection with Śiva
and his wife Chaņdi and quarrel with the latter constitute the main essence. In
short, the theme of Manasā-mangalkavya is- goddess Manasā tried to induce the
trader Chānd Sadāgar (a merchant named Chānd) to worship her, but the latter,
who was a devotee of Śiva refused to do so. Enraged at this Manasā killed six of
his seven sons. The 7th son- Lakhinder was bitten by a snake sent by Manasā on his
wedding night. The newly married wife Behulā put her husbands body on a raft
and floated away. She reached heaven and pleased the gods by her dance and
music. She even propitiated Manasā and succeeded in having her husband and six
brothers back to life. She returned home and succeeded in persuading Chānd
Sadāgar to finally worship Manasā. The first book of Manasā-mangal is not found
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 227
which Kāņā Hari Datta composed and which is only referred to in the text of some
later poets. There are other poets who became famous as writers of various
versions of Manasā-mangalkavya. They made the kavya famous at various parts of
Bengal- including the west and east. Mention may be made of Bijaya Gupta and
Bipradās Piplāi of 15th century, Nārāyandeva of 16th century, Vamśīdas of 17th
century, Ketakādās Kshemānanda of mid-17th century and also others like-
Sītārāmdās, Dvija Rasik, Dvija Bāņeśvara, Kavichandra, Kālidāsa and Vishņupāl
all of whom flourished in the 17th and 18th centuries. Many poets of North Bengal
also composed versions of Manasā-mangalkavya like, Durgābari Bibhūti of 16th
century, Jagajjīvan Ghosāl, Jīban Kŗishņa Maitra of 18th century.
5
The Puranic goddess of wealth and property who is widely worshipped in West
Bengal. She is also considered to bestow a good harvest.
6
India’s folk culture is an appropriate symbolical revelation of the invisible realm
of the subconscious, which often is recognised as the prime reality behind the
visible world. The brata art of Bengal is typical to this. The brata rites and songs
are specified by the fact that they mainly constitute of aniconic worship and reflect
spontaneous expression of changing times. These are ‘magico-religious’ rites
performed by womenfolk in Bengal, for invoking the blessings of various deities to
secure domestic happiness and welfare of the dear and near ones. They reflect the
social and religious beliefs of an area, which is among the richest in ancient
traditions. These brata rites, which are oral symbols handed down from generation
to generation, is also a representative of changing times and also acts as a mode of
perpetuation of cultural anxiety through time.
7
This beat is more famous as the Sashti Taal as created by Rabindranath Tagore,
but quite uniquely the beat was already prevalent amidst the folk Tushu songs of
Bankura and has been a part of their lives for a long time.
8
According to the West Bengal District Gazetteers (1968) a family of zamindars
(local ruling chiefs) once enjoyed the title of Rajas (kings), established themselves
here in 1403 A.D. The family was devoted to the local goddess, Bāsuli, whose
patronage, it was believed, was the source of their fortune. According to a local
legend, a Saont, by the name Sańkha Roy was the first king of Sāmantabhum,
having his capital at Chhatna. The Sāmanta line was disrupted after the death of
Sańkha Roy, when Bhabāni Jharāt, a Brahman, ascended the throne of
Sāmantabhum. He was later murdered and a protracted period of turmoil ensued in
the region. In due course of time, however, Sāmantabhum emerged from this state
of chaos with the establishment of a Kshatriya dynasty later on- all of which has
found a place of description in the local oral tradition and legends. The temple of
Bāsuli and the idol occupies a significant position in the legend as well as the
history, and to date maintains its importance in the village of Chhatna. Tradition
also has it that the medieval Bengali poet, Chandidas, who was a worshipper of
Bāsuli used to reside in Chhatna. The exploits of goddess Bāsuli have been
described in the Sanskrit text, Bāsuli Māhātmya by Padmalochan Sarmā. Though a
controversy ensued regarding the exact identity of Chandidas and his residing area,
however till date, a small quarter, marked as the residing place of Chandidas is
found in the village. At present, the village is well connected with the main town
of Bankura and other adjoining villages through a main roadway where buses and
228 Chapter Eleven
MUV’s (Multi Utility Vehicles) fly frequently. The village is also well adjusted
with certain modern amenities as an effect of globalisation, like an air-conditioned
village branch of the Bankura District Co-operative Bank and courier service
facilities providing connection via railway lines to the nearest metropolitan city of
Kolkata.
Fig. 2. A Manasā temple, Chhatna village, Bankura district, West Bengal, India.
Sudarshan Kaviraj, the priest stands outside the temple
Fig. 3. A patua (West Medinipur district, West Bengal, India) singing and
demonstrating through a scroll painting a story from Manasā-mangalkavya
230 Chapter Eleven
Fig. 4. Active participants of Tushu brata festival: women of Bauri para (locality)
of Bansberia- under No. 1 Gram Panchayat, Chhatna village, Bankura, West
Bengal, India
References
Agrawala, P.K (1984), Goddesses in Ancient India. Abhinav Publications,
New Delhi, India
Bandopadhyay, Bireshwar (2001), Paschim Banger Loukik Deb Debi O
Lokobishwash (Bengali). Loksanskriti O Adivashi Sanskriti Kendra
Kolkata, India
Banerji, Amiya Kumar (1968), West Bengal District Gazateers: Bankura
Kolkata, India
Basu, Gopendrakrishna (1966), Banglar Loukik Debota. (Bengali). Dey’s
Publishing, Kolkata, India
Bhattacharya, Ashutosh (1927), Banglar Lok Samskriti (Bengali). National
Book Trust, New Delh, India
Bhattacharya, B (1924), Buddhist Iconography. Oxford University Press,
Kolkata, India
Bhattacharya, Ashutosh (1970), Bangla Mangal Kavyer Itihash. (Bengali).
A Mukherjee and Co Pvt Ltd, Kolkata, India
Bhattacharya, D. K (2005), Studying folklore- The Indian Experience.
Lecture paper unpublished, University of Delhi, India Bhattacharya, D.
K (2006), The Development Dilemma In Tribal India. Lecture paper
unpublished, Paper presented as Special Lecture in the Session on
Anthropology, Indian Science Congress, Hyderabad, India
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 231
TRAPPED IN POVERTY:
PLANTATION WORKERS IN SRI LANKA
SHOBANA RAJENDRAN
AND ANOMA ABHAYARATNE
I. Introduction
Plantation workers in Sri Lanka represent the poorest group in the country.
Contrary to the modest reduction in national poverty in Sri Lanka poverty
in the plantation sector has increased considerably. Compared with the
other two sectors, poverty in the plantation sector is much higher than that
of the urban sector and higher than that of the rural sector were poverty is
considerably high. Though the plantation population consists of 5% of the
total population, 8% of the country’s poor live in this sector.
The persistence of high poverty levels and lower social and economic
indicators in the plantation sector is a result of long history of social and
economic isolation of plantation residents. This has led to a lack of
education and employment opportunities which contributed to a persistent
cycle of low capability, low earning potential which would result poverty
among plantation residents (World Bank, 2007).
Indian Tamils are the descendants of the 19th and early 20th century
migrants from Tamil Nadu, India brought to Sri Lanka to work in the
plantations by British entrepreneurs. ‘Indian Tamil’ (IT) is the official
term of identity given to them in ethnic classification in population
censuses.
The major factors responsible for this relative backwardness are many:
These include the denial of citizenship rights and their poor educational
attainments (Amali, 2000). Plantation workers of Indian origin continue to
experience social exclusion and political marginalization too with
inadequate links with the public sector organizations, including health,
education and administrative services (Tudor Silva, 2007). Although Sri
Lankan law now grant plantation workers citizenship rights, low levels of
education, language barriers often prevent them from understanding anf
exercising these rights.
236 Chapter Twelve
1990-91 2002
National 26.1 22.7
Urban 16.3 7.9
Rural 29.4 24.7
Estate 20.5 30.0
Source: WB 2007
Though the consumption poverty of the households in the estate sector has
worsened, the other aspects of the human development such as education,
health and housing have improved over the years. However, in spite of
these improvements, estate sector still lag well behind the other sectors of
the country.
Poverty among the estate workers is mainly caused by low incomes as
well as lack of opportunities for enhancing their capabilities. Majority of
the residents in the estates rely solely on estate wages for earned income.
When compared to the other sectors, the average monthly income of the
estate workers are lower than the worker in others sectors and industries
that perform comparable tasks. Recent statistics of the DSC (2004) reveal
that the average monthly income of estate households is lowest in the
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 237
Housing
Almost all the estate workers live within the plantations in houses
provided by the estate management. Generally these houses consist of
single houses, line rooms and row houses. However, a large percentage of
these houses are line rooms which can not be considered as a desirable
arrangement of living. Most of these houses are old and have only one
room without proper kitchen and sanitary facilities. These are shared by an
average of six household members. Estate workers are still living in most
deprived shelter conditions compared to their counterparts in the urban and
ruaral sector. According to CFSES in 2003-04, 64%of the houses in this
sector are line rooms. Over the years, due to the efforts of the government
and estate management in providing better housing for the estate residents,
the percentage of line rooms has declined from 84% in 1996-97 to 64% in
2003-04. However, this percentage is still much higher than the national
level of 3.9%. The improvements are also reflected in the increase of
percentage of single houses from 10%in 1996-97 to 28% in 2003-04.
Education
The poor in Sri Lanka are predominantly from uneducated and less
educated social groups. The incidence of poverty is as high as 45% among
individuals with no schooling (HIES, 2002). According to HIES (2002),
19% of estate household heads have no schooling compared to 8% for Sri
Lanka as a whole (Table 2). It has been recognized that one of the biggest
constraints to the upward social mobility of the residents of the plantation
sector is the deficiencies in education. Despite of the high rates of
education indicators such as school enrolments, literacy achieved by Sri
Lanka still there are wide sectoral disparities. Though these indicators
have improved over the years, estate sector lag behind the other two
sectors.
Level of Sector
Education Sex Urban Rural Estate All sectors
No 5.5 7.5 19.9 7.9
Schooling Both
Male 4.3 5.6 13.0 5.8
Female 6.6 9.2 26.3 9.7
Primary 24.3 29.9 43.7 29.9
Both
Male 24.4 31.8 46.0 31.6
Female 24.1 28.2 41.6 28.3
Secondary 41.1 41.8 28.9 41.0
Both
Male 41.9 43.6 34.6 42.9
Female 40.5 40.1 25.6 39.4
Post 29.1 20.9 6.5 21.2
Secondary Both
Male 29.4 19.1 6.5 19.7
Female 28.9 22.5 6.4 22.5
Source: CFS
country. Another 141 schools have been developed under other projects.
However 270 schools remain in their original neglected state.
Literacy rates, dropout rates, and the educational attainment of the estate
population are still lagging behind that of the rest of the population,
although the gap has been narrowing over the last two decade.
Period
Sectors
Urban Rural Estate
All sectors
1996/97 3.3 3.0 7.3 3.3
2003/04 2.9 1.8 4.6 2.1
Source : CFS
The plantation residents who enjoy very limited education facilities within
plantations face many obstacles when using the facilities available outside
the plantations. Major constraints faced by them in sending their children
outside schools are the cost involved and lack of transport. Most of the
estates are isolated from the other sectors and the lack of road connectivity
act as a major constraint to the social mobility of residents through
education and employment opportunities outside the estates.
Parents who want to continue their children’s education beyond the level
available in their estates, must send them to the schools outside the estates.
This is a serious problem for girls. Parents are hesitant to send their
daughters far away on their own. Because of lack of transport facilities
children are forced to walk more than 6 kilometers along footpaths and
other roads, surrounded by jungles. Despite parents’ desire to send their
girl children to secondary schools, most girls stop going to school when
they reach puberty (Amali, 2000).
Employment
The plantation sector is still the largest organized sector in Sri Lanka. In
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 241
the import–export economy in Sri Lanka, the plantations still rate as one of
the highest in terms of foreign exchange earnings. Cheap labour is one of
the essential ingredients of its success. Hence the plantation workers were
bonded and under paid. In 1921 workers were empowered to break this
bond of indebtedness tying them to the estates. The minimum wages
ordinance was extended to plantation labour in 1927 marginally raising the
wages that not changed since the 19th century. This daily wages was 41 cts
in 1933. Owing to trade union activities it was raised to Rs 17.83 in 1983.
Rs 72.24 in 1993 and become Rs 101.00 in 1998. The wages of female
workers was lesser then males but has been equalized since 1984. Even
though there was an increase in wages, the living wages are not sufficient
to meet their day to day needs and lower than the wages of the comparable
workers in other sectors.
Unemployment in Sri Lanka has been a major national problem over the
past three decades and it has caused difficulties and uncertainties for
successive governments since the 1960s. However, unemployment was not
high among plantation youth belonging to the 19–25 age groups in the
mid–nineties: 42% in the plantations compared to 51% in the urban and
37% in the rural areas (CFS 1996/97). But the situation appears to have
changed considerably in more recent times. In 2003/04, in the estate
sector, 44.8% belong to 15–18 age group is unemployed compared to
29.6% and 35.8% in the urban and rural sectors respectively (Central Bank
2004). Unemployment among youth in the estate sector has now been
identified as an issue of grave concern. Young youth prefer to work
outside the estate. Employment opportunities within the estate sector are
not attractive to the youth. The social stigma attached to manual work,
traditional work patterns of the estates, the difficult and strict working
conditions and the top–down management style are factors that encourage
them to seek off–estate employment. But finding such alternative
employment has not been easy for these youths for several reasons.
and vocational education and opportunity for jobs outside the estate
including overseas employment.
Health
Sri Lanka is an exception among the developing countries which has
achieved impressive improvements in health status since Independence
despite its low income per head. However, the improvement has been
uneven, with plantations consistently lagging behind. As reflected by the
health indicators, health status of estate workers and their families are
much lower than that of the other sectors. However, since nationalization
in 1975, there has been considerable investment on estates and, with the
introduction of a uniform health policy designed to meet the needs of
estate workers, the health status of workers and their families has
dramatically improved. Interventions have included components on
housing, water supply and sanitation as well as health and child care and
have been planned with the involvement of the workers. The components
which have brought about the improvements were specifically designed to
meet the needs of plantation workers and developed within a structure
quite different from that which applies in rural peasant areas
Provision and utilization of health care services in the estate sector
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 243
continue to remain far behind the rest of the country. These are reflected
by a number of health indicators such as low birth weight, child
malnutrition which are lower compared to that of other sectors. Low birth
weight is more prevalent among poor estate households. According to
World Bank (2007), 30% of babies born to mothers in the estate sector
were low in birth weight (Table 4). Almost 40% of the pre school estate
children are stunted (do not have the height for age) which imply severe
and prolonged malnutrition among them. Among the pre school children
in the estate sector 12.5% have low weight for age which is a result of
short term and acute food shortfall. It is not only among estate children
under age of 5 years that malnutrition is prevalent. Nutiritional status of
women in this sector is also poor. In this sector, 48% of women have low
body mass which can result intrauterine growth, retardation and low birth
weight. Malnutrition among mothers and children can have a number of
consequences for their education, adult health and earnings.
In 1992, the estates were privatized and the responsibility for estate health
and welfare activities was taken over by the Plantation Housing and Social
Welfare Trust (PHSWT) currently known as the Plantation Human
Development Trust (PHDT).
The major concern is the lack of proper health services to meet the
demand. These health services are often not designed to look into the
problems of women. malnutrition, which is one of the major problems in
the plantation sector, affects the lives of children who do not get basic
nutrition they require and malnutrition is found to be high among women.
The lack of food due to poverty, resulting in unequal distribution of food
at homes where its allocation favors the males is seen to be the main cause
(Amali, 2000).
244 Chapter Twelve
IV. Conclusions
Plantation workers in Sri Lanka are the poorest group in the country as
30% of the households live in poverty. Contrary to the modest reduction in
national poverty in Sri Lanka poverty in the plantation sector has increased
considerably. This paper attempts to identify how and why the plantation
community lags behind other communities in the country in almost every
aspect of life.
References
ADB, (1999), Skill Development Project Report, Asian Development
Bank, Sri Lanka.
Amali, P. (2000), “Gender Ideologies and Gender Relation in the Tea
Plantation”. PALM Foundation, Nuwara-Eliya. Sri Lanka.
(Unpublished Survey Report).
Central Bank of Sri Lanka, (1996 / 97, 2003 / 04), “Report on Consumer
Finances and Socio Economic Survey”, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
—. (2005), “Economic and Social Statistics of Sri Lanka”, Colombo, Sri
Lanka.
Department of Census and Statistics (2001), “Census of Population and
Housing 2001”. Department of Census and Statistics, Colombo, Sri
Lanka.
—. (2005), “Statistical Abstract 2005”. Department of Census and
Statistics, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Ministry of Estate Infrastructure and Livestock Development (2007),
“National Plan of Acton (NPA) for Social Development of the
Plantation Community 2006 – 2015, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Ministry of Education, (2005), “School Census” Report Statistics Branch.
Ministry of Education, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Mookiah, M. S. (1997), “Education of the Plantation Tamil Community:
Historical Background and Current Status”. Workshop on Education of
the Plantation Tamil Community: Past, Present, Future 26th – 27th
September, 1977. ISD, Kandy.
Rajendran, S. (2001), “Relationship Between Female Labour Force
Participation and Fertility: in the Tea Plantation Sector, Sri Lanka. M.
Phil Thesis, University of Peradeniya.
—. (2004), “A Study of Preventing Child Labour in the plantation Sector –
Badulla District”. International Labour Office, Colombo. (Unpublished
Survey Report).
—. (2005), “Economic Opportunities Survey & Training Needs
Assessment (2005). International Labour Office, Colombo.
(Unpublished Survey Report).
Sinnathamby, M. (2003), “Socio – Economic Conditions of the Up –
Country Tamils”. Seminar on Rights and power Sharing Mechanisms
for Non – Territorial Minority Communities. 24th May 3003, Trans
Asia Hotel. Colombo.
Tudor Silva, K. and B. Sasikumar, (2007), “Transition from Tea Worker to
out grower”. ISD, Kandy.
World Bank, (2007), “Sri Lanka Poverty assessment”. Engendering
246 Chapter Twelve
ETHNOGRAPHIC METHOD
AND ITS APPLICATIONS IN CULTURAL
AND SOCIAL ANTHROPOLOGICAL RESEARCH
Every science depends upon observed phenomena for its analytical and
interpretative statements. Anthropology, in common with other social
sciences, depends for its data upon observations of human behavior,
including verbal behavior. The process of making such observations has
been called ‘Ethnography’. It is production of highly detailed accounts of
how people in a social setting lead their lives, based on systemic and long-
term observation of, and conservations with, informants.
I. Defining Ethnography
1. “When used as a method, ethnography typically refers to fieldwork
(alternatively, participant-observation) conducted by a single
investigator who ‘lives with and lives like’ those who are studied,
usually for a year or more.”(John Van Maanen, 1996).
5. In-depth interviewing.
7. Case Studies
8. Problem-oriented research.
Not all of these techniques are used by ethnographers, but interviews and
participant observation are the most widely used.
Cultural & social anthropologists today place such a high value on actually
doing ethnographic research that ethnology—the comparative synthesis of
ethnographic information is very fruitful now a days.
actually do—avoiding the pitfalls that come from relying only on self-
reported, focus-group data.
References
Agar, M (1996). The Professional Stranger: An Informal Introduction to
Ethnography, Academic Press.
Barry, H. III and Schlegel, A eds. (1980). Cross-cultural samples and
codes, Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Denzin, N K and Lincoln Y S (1994). Handbook of qualitative research,
Thousand Oaks, Sage Publications.
Fetterman, (1998). Ethnography, 2nd ed., Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
Hammersley, M (1990). Reading Ethnographic Research: A Critical
Guide. London: Longman.
Harris, M and Johnson, O (2000). Cultural Anthropology, (5th ed.),
Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
Hodson, R (1999). Analyzing documentary accounts, Thousand Oaks,
Sage Publications, and Quantitative Applications in the Social
Sciences Series No. 128, Describes random sampling of ethnographic
field studies as a basis for applying a meta-analytic schedule, Hodson
covers both coding issues and subsequent use of statistical techniques.
Moll, LC & Greenberg, JM (1990). Creating Zones of Possibilities:
Combining Social Constructs for Instruction. In: L.C. Moll (ed.)
Vygotsky and Education: Instructional Implications and Applications
of Sociohistorical Psychology, New York, NY: Cambridge University
Press.
Patton, MQ (1987). How to Use Qualitative Methods in Evaluation,
Newberry Park, CA: Sage Publications.
Van Maanen, J (1996). Ethnography. In: A. Kuper and J. Kuper (eds.) The
Social Science Encyclopedia, 2nd ed., pages 263-265. London:
Routledge.
CHAPTER FOURTEEN
Introduction
Most Indian's especially the Hindus are brahmana by behaviour and
intellectuality when they utter the mantras, slokas and analyse sastras. The
process of intellectuality functions within their utterance in an excellent
and wonderful way of speech delivery, dialogic orientation, access to word
knowledge, mnemonic technique, analysing skills, etc. Likewise they are
tribal by belief, when they worship a god like Jagannatha, their ancestor
deity in the form of a wooden log. They believe in a genealogical legacy,
kinship-‘kutumba’ (family) relationship with a supernatural power belong
to the Munda racial root. In the same way, they worship Ka:li, the black
force and mother goddess of the Dravidians who believe that she can
articulate her power among them for victory and well being. The holistic
character of Krishna in the Indian heritage in different times and spaces
developed with the combination of both the significances .
This ukti / discourse analysis, which is one of the three poetic qualities has
been used in this paper to find his stylistic and thematic uniqueness.
Nannaya has proposed ‘ukti’ as ‘arthaukti’ which can be translated as the
technique of semantic structure (associated with a pleasing narrative
structure) and has named it as ‘prasannakatha:’. It has been considered as
the main feature of literary art. Sisir Kumar Das (1995) opines in this
context that, the main component derived form the Sanskritic epics which
have created a deep structure of perception on which one constructed new
images and allegories (p.125-126). Nannaya’s discourse also symbolises
the deep structure of perception that succeeded in bringing the ‘other’
tradition of non-Aryans into limelight.
The word power of Krishna became a prime marker for intellectuals and
was glorified by the elite khsatriyas as a supreme model of
‘va:kyamulapaddhati’. Krishna has been adored by many elites and with
many adjectives of his vachananipuna virtues. A few dialogues of
Bhishma, Dharmaraja, Arjuna and their interpretation of Krishna’s
excellence in speaking are good examples. Dharmaraja glorifies his
character as a ra:yaba:ri (duta) for his fitness of va:kyamulapaddhati
(Udyoga: 3rd aswas, padya 34). Bhishma as a great learned person praises
his richness of Va:k. He says, ‘You are expert in Va:k, you are
‘Va:kvibhuda’. There is everything in your richness of talking, richness of
words.’ (Shanti: 2nd asvas, padya 119). Krishna’s exchange of dialogue
with a knowledgeable person like Bhishma is considered appropriate by
Dharmaraja when he says, ‘Except you there is no other person to
exchange samla:pa with Bhishma.’ (Shanti 2nd aswas, padya128). In
Arjuna’s perception Krishna is the only person whose ‘vimalava:kya’
(pure sentence) can inspire and instigate a kshatriya like him to get victory
over the enemy and can make his life successful (Bhishma: 1st aswas).
Bhishma has defined his sentences as ‘suva:kyamulu’, which are equal to
the Veda (Shanti: 2nd Aswas padya 146-50), and as ‘madhurava:kya’
(sweet sentences) where he has added literary sublimity (rasa) to it and
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 259
opines that, this has the capability to make him satisfied and happy. He
says, ‘Your madhurava:kya is like amrutarasa for my ears and fills me
with happiness’ (Shanti: 2nd aswas, padya 118)
His cultural encounter starts with his enunciation of ‘I’ and its three
significant representation of self development can be:
1. “Yenu (ne:nu) Krishnudu” (I am Krishna). (Sabha. 1st aswas: padya
192)
260 Chapter Fourteen
Krishna explores his own heroism and places this before his A:rya:barta
allies. As a kshatriya he is described with adjectives of great physical
gesture which can be verified with the words like maha:bhuja,
pruthulavaksha, simhapara:krama, jita:ditya, nikhilalokajaitrundu (Sabha.
1st aswas: vachana 182, Sabha 2nd aswas: padya 37). Krishna’s victorious
character became the model of an ideal hero and has been taken up as an
example of intellectuallity, bravery, and dharma of kshatriyas by many
heroes of that space and time.
The motive of becoming the most learned in the world and to expand his
intellect as an enlightenment within a straightforward description of his
own language – “For the Shreyashu (well being) and Yasha (fame) I am
the main source. You please listen to my word… I am already a famous
person. So I don’t want new fame. I want to give you the fame and make
you famous in this world. That’s why I have introduced my mind in you”
(Shanti, 2nd aswas: padya 128). Krishna’s access on vividhatattva (various
kinds of knwledge) Bhishma, 1st aswas: padya 126), atmatatva (knowledge
262 Chapter Fourteen
of self) Bhishma, 1st aswas: vacana 229) embedded with anupama guna
(unique qualities) (Aranya, 1st aswas: padya 128) and heavenly form (Ibid:
padya 220) made him a ‘pravartanaka:ra’, i.e. the founder a new
substratum in the Indo-Aryan heritage.
The otherness can be related to the subject matters of the oldest Sangam
literature, specifically ‘Puram’ poems which contain the bardic/oral
tradition of ancient Tamilians and the songs popularly known as
Gathasaptasati attributed to Satavahana Hala (2nd -3rd century) containing
lot of information about the folk life, praise of village headman, his wife,
description about pulinda tribe,description in memory of the departed dear,
etc (Dutta(eds) 2001:1374-75).‘Puram’ poems are the poems of ancient
Tamil culture, celebrating the ferocity and glory of the powerful kings,
264 Chapter Fourteen
lamenting the death of heroes, the poverty of poets. The subject matters of
popular and famous war, heroism, glory of the kings are also current in all
the Southern Dravidian languages and in Telugu and Tulu (Ramanujan
1985: 235). Some patterned thematic properties, like the birth of a hero,
his wars, his city of strong hills, strong walls, chariots, drums, horses,
flags of ancient Cera and Cola chieftains,village headmen, or folks
were found from the descriptions of bards and poets of Puram poems,
Gathas, as well as from Krishna’s narration of Jarasandha which could be
the patterned Dravidian literary trends developed in different times and
spaces.
Puram poems describe the virtue of a hero as : ‘great king, you shield
your men from ruin, so your victories, your greatness are by words’
(Puran:anuru: in Ramanujan 1985:115). Gathasaptasati describes a man's
quality this way: 'Two things lighten a man even if he is as big as a
mountain;when he brags before accomplishing some thing, and brags after
accomplishing it'( translation of Canto 4 in Sharma(eds)2002:715).Krishna
describes about Jarasandha’s power : ‘I can not describe his power. He
defeated everybody . He is famous in wrestling and nobody in this world
can defeat him’ (Sabha parva, 1st Aswas109-10 ,161). Puram poem
describes about king’s war: ‘this Porai, so fierce in war? How big are his
armies really?’, (Patirruppattu :77 in Ramanujan 1985: 116-7); it also
describes about the king’s city covered with hills and strong walls
‘…Uraaiyur, city of tall towers’, ‘stand here, you can see the hill, go far
away, you still see it …the hill of our great chieftain; hill of Ay ,with war
anklets on his feet, hill inaccessible to great kings’, (Purana:nuru:
69,114,128 in Ramanujan. 1985:127,147,152). Krishna describes about
Jarasandha’s city this way: ‘five mountains surround this city like mighty
warriors, that’s why the city named as Girivajrapura/city like thunderbolt
of hills‘. In Puram poems, poets describe king’s chariots, drums, flags as :
‘the tall gold- covered chariots given by Malalaiyan of ever lasting fame ;
Pari’s Parampu hill…great drums of war; ..you are such…lofty one with
bright umbrellas of fame (Purana:nuru: 123, 102,109 in Ramanujan
1985:141,142,153). Krishna descries: ‘there were three big Bheris of
magical power in the city’ (Sabha, 1st aswas:175 ). He also glorifies the
city of Saumbhaka, chariot/divya ratha, flag/Garuda ketana of powerful
king Salva (Aranya ,1st aswas and 3rd aswas ).
legitimacy.
Jarasandha’s victory over every king and country also throws light on
Yadava–Haihaya conflict which is a historical fact and resulted in shifting
of Yadavas from Mathura region to Raivata mountain (where they built a
fort) (Sabha, 1st asvas: 111-113).
The political network of Magadha and its adjacent regions are drawn
closer to show Jarasandha’s regional expansion as well as their
connection, relationship with the local tribal groups. This stronghold is
distinct in Jarasandha's connection with his friends, allies, relatives,
servants, subordinates. They were a:yattabhuja Hamsa Dimbaka (Kausika
Chitrasena) who were described as the right and left hands (Sabha:1st
Aswas:padya114) of Jarasandha; Sisupala,the king of Chedi who has been
described as his ally/senapati (chhamupati). The discourse of Krishna
provides further references to make the united networking more powerful.
Kamsa the son of Ugrasena, described in the Maha:bha:rata as the
incarnation of asura Kalanemi (Sorensen, 1978:379). and the son-in-law of
Jarasandha (got married to Jarasandha’s two daughters),was the enemy of
Krishna. Then the Yavana Kurusha, the king of the east and south, the
Kirata king Paundrika Vasudeva of Anga, Vanga, Kalinga, were described
as the subordinates and were always at Jarasandha’s service. Bhagadatta,
the ruler of west of Magadha is said to have put his service to Jarasandha.
Thus the rich cultural heritage with primitive religious materials, glorious
ruling history, political legitimacy had occupied a distinctive position in
the textual continuum which can be treated as the other half of the total
Maha:bha:rata heritage.
The cultural gap between the 11th century Andhra and 15th century Orissa
bridges the literary competence with brahmanic supremacy and a
ritualistic cult with tribal legitimacy.
Literary tradition bears the testimony of glorifying a local hero’s life and
heroic activities in the `Veera-Nayaka’ tradition of the South. Telugu
`Katha’, Kannada `Kathe’ meaning story are based on these stories of
heroes. Haihayas of Palnad (Sekharam 1973:21), are glorified in “Palnati
Veerula Katha” (Yasoda Devi 1995:29-30), glorification of Velanati
general’s and Choda supremacy in Keyurabahu Charitramu (Sekharam
1973:218-219), glorification of Chodas’ and Yadavas’ heroism in the
ballad “Katamaraju Katha” are the finest examples of such. It is also seen
embedded with ritualistic celebrations like “veerapuja”, “a:yudhapujua”,
which are even now popular in every Telugu house.
The literary themes of 11th through 15th centuries vernacular languages and
the medieval history of India show a patterned echo of the life and heroism
of the local rulers/chiefs with patterned Dravidian and Munda religious
behaviour and experiences. Under such legitimacy Arjuna becomes the
hero in Pampa as well as in Sa:rala: signifying a single hero approach in
the local tradition. Arikeshari of western Chalukyan dynasty of Karnataka
(Mugali 1975:21) and Gajapati Kapilendradeva, the builder of Suryavamsi
dynasty of Orissa became Arjunas of their respective areas. The Kamta
king Durlabhanarayana has been described as Babrubahana by the court
270 Chapter Fourteen
The myth becomes the base for the total deification process of Krishna,
and his ancestral connection with hero-stone worship. Again according to
the order of another heavenly voice Savara starts worshipping the `Pinda’
with all ritualistic systems by placing the Pinda in the form of a stone
under a sandal wood tree which is symbolically sacred and secret (Musali
58-88). The next phase of the stone worship becomes the worship of a
‘Blue stone’/Nila Ma:dhava by the order /as an oracle of Krishna himself.
The whole myth is embedded in sacred places, objects or symbols and are
fused with the religious value systems of Mundas and Dravidas.‘Swapna’
(dream), ‘A:kasha v:ani’ (voice from the heaven) are all unifying symbols
activated, regulated, analysed in a dream and in an oracle by Krishna to
signify the tribal features of religious beliefs, experiences, practices, and
behaviours. He appears in front of his clan members in dreams,
sometimes orders through a divine and unseen voice as a shamanic
initiator of primitive imaginary fantasy. His orders, instructions, advices in
the form of sacred speech are utilized as the legitimate devices for the
establishment of little communities over the regional kings of then
Orissa.
The dream process and oracles of Krishna are given below to study the
above facts:
(1) Krishna orders Jara to worship his ‘Pinda’ (body) and says – “I will
stay here secretly in the from of a stone. You worship me with water
and leaves without the knowledge of your ‘kutumba’ (family) and
272 Chapter Fourteen
The function of dream and oracle in the myth explores Krishna’s status of
a tribal Kondh character, his development, transformation and assimilation
in a tribal Savara domain under some cultural transformation processes
like the following:
show the relationship between the imaginary world of the poet and the
new cultural conventions which explores man’s two belongings stated by
Tylor, a life for feeling, thinking, functioning and a phantom (in dream) as
being its image or second self. (Tylor 1958 (part II):XII) It is also termed
as “Magical realism” by Garcia Marquez (Garcia Marquez in Bassnett
1993:87-88).
Colophon
I am thankful to Dr. Bhujanga Reddy of University of Hyderabad for his
help in translating the Andhra Maha:bha:ratamu for me.
References
A:ndhra Maha:bha:ratamu (Telugu). (Adi, Sabha, Aranya, Birata,
Udyoga, Bhisma, Santi). 2000. Hyderabad: P.S. Telugu
Visvavidyalaya.
Barua, B.K. 1978. History of Assamese Literature. New Delhi: Sahitya
Akademi.
Bassnett, Susan. 1993. Comparative Literature: A Critical Introduction.
Oxford UK & Cambridge. USA: Blackwell.
Berthes, Roland. 1977. Image, Music, Text. London: Fontana Press.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 275
SHIREEN MIRZA
Introduction
Scholarship on Islam in the modern context is conceptually grappling to
adequately understand and characterize ‘contemporary’ political Islamic
movements, such as post-revolution Islamic republic of Iran, the Hamas in
Palestine, Hizbullah in Lebanon, Muslim brotherhoods in Egypt, and
Taliban in Afghanistan etc. A vast amount of contemporary literature
focus on the rise of political Islam that characterizes Islamic thought as—
failing to enact a separation between religion and politics (Gellner:1981);
or as tending to make a distinction between Islam as a faith and political
Islam (Piscatori: 1996).
The need to understand and theorize ‘political Islam’ is even more relevant
in contemporary South Asian context, where the direct violent effects of
the supposed ‘rise of Islamism’ are a living reality for not only the rest of
India but for the Indian Muslims as well. An intriguing illustration for the
supposed transnational connect of the local and global through ‘Islamist
ideology’ is evident, for instance, in the ‘Hyderabad bombings’. On 25
August 2007, two bombs almost simultaneously exploded in Hyderabad,
the capital of Andhra Pradesh in the Deccan, at two chosen local public
spaces: 1) the Lumbini Amusement Park and 2) a local eatery, the Gokul
Chat Bhandar. The inexplicable and perhaps the most intriguing aspect of
the incident was the fact that a militant Bangladeshi group, the Harkat-ul-
Jihad-al-Islami, was suspected for carrying out the serial blasts; though the
connection between the site chosen for the blasts and the supposed site of
operation of the Harkat-ul-Jihad-al-Islami appear unrelated.
through ethnographic discourses. In the fourth and the final section I seek
to provide a possible direction for an anthropology of Indian Islam
drawing from debates and theoretical positions of scholars from the field
of Islam, given the diversity of Islamic practices in India as well as the
common historical locations of power from which it emerges.
The functional adaptive reasons that both Ahmad and Madan provide
through the explanation of the Indianisation of Islam presupposes a pre-
existing unified coherent worldview upon which a new coherent
worldview is integrated. These explanations gives rise to two sets of
problems: firstly the normative position from which the process of
integration is viewed. Following from this, non-Indian forms of Islam, can
appear un-integrated. The second manifesting problem is the general
implication of Islam being ideological and Hinduism being practice
oriented4. Such a division would fail to explain instances of ideologies
based on Hindu theistic models at one level, and the instances of Islamic
practices that do not correlate to a normative Islamic model, at another.
between the masters of the land and the rest; and not in terms of ritual.
After demonstrating the congruence between different systems of social
stratification: such as endogamy to kinship system, professional
specialization to the economic ‘system’, dominance to the ‘political
system’ he concludes that the principle of status summation seems to be
the structural feature which characterizes caste. For Barth then, the
definition of caste must be based on structural criteria, and not on the
‘particular features of the Hindu philosophical scheme’ (Barth: 1960, pg.
145). Thereby the definition of caste need not be confined to the ‘classical
caste system of Pan-Indian civilization’ (ibid) but can also be extended to
explain the internal segmentations in ‘plural’ societies in the Middle East.
In critiquing the various premises that lie beneath the theories of caste
among Muslims, Charles Lindholm shows the internal difficulties of
assuming either a symbolist interpretive/normative stance or a comparative
structural/diffusionist view by tentatively proposing a conflict model8. The
fundamental difficulty, according to Lindholm is that, these theoretical
stances, according to their respective approaches, reify social order or
beliefs into objects with properties that are either divisible or unitary. He
argues for an approach ‘that focuses on the relationships first, especially
relationships of antagonism and contradiction, and which sees order and
belief growing from these oppositional relations. This mode of analysis
assumes that cultures and values are chosen and defined in relation to what
is ignored, denied or negated. Consequently, the analysis of opposition,
exclusion, and the struggle for identity within the framework of often
opposing interests is a necessity for social theory, particularly theory of
change.’ (Lindholm: 1986, pg. 72; Emphasis in the original)
From the discrepancy in Mines’ narrative, one might be able to recover the
nodes through which he maps being Muslim and being Tamil. It would
seem for Mines, the category Muslim emerges from an attachment to
286 Chapter Fifteen
seek the “true” Islam, makes it a challenging and legitimate gauntlet that
can help further appropriate anthropologies of Islam in India.
For instance, both Shail Mayaram and Jackie Assayag dwell on the theme
of the hybrid faith, communities that straddle boundaries that separate
being either Hindu or Muslim. Mayaram (1997, 2004) locates her analysis
within Turner’s concept of liminality in the study of rituals. Within this
framework she examines her own fieldwork among two communities, the
Mers and the Meos, in the state of Rajasthan and shows how categorizing
them in exclusive categories can be problematic. The Mers are a bi-
religious community having both Hindu and Muslim sections with the
possibility of passage from one to the other. The Meos are Muslims and
perceive themselves as such but share many rituals, rites and folklore with
their Hindu neighbours. This, according to her problematizes identity in
exclusive terms because these communities are able to live in a liminal
space of religious existence.
The reason for this is, as Harjod Oberoi (1994) claims, that it was used
indiscriminately by colonial and postcolonial authors to describe all kinds
of religious movements that appeared to them as ‘hybrid’ or ‘ambiguous’
and which did not conform to their understanding of either Islam or
Hinduism. For this reason, both Yoginder Sikand (2004) and Dominique-
Zila Khan (2004) prefer to use the term ‘liminal’, following Mayaram’s
analysis of ‘fuzzy’ communities, in order to understand common religious
traditions and shifting identities. Though acknowledging that the
conceptualization of a ‘fuzzy’ community is premised upon a binary
formulation, it nonetheless is useful to explain their fieldwork, because it
implies the existence of ‘a line of thought that emphasizes ‘fuzzy’ thinking
as an alternative to bivalent, either/or logic’ and may suggest a potentially
anti-structural questioning of categorical identities, in this case, ‘Hindu’
and ‘Muslim’.’ (Mayaram: 1997, pg. 37, 39)
But as Ute Falasch (2004) reiterates the term ‘liminality’ does not remove
the dichotomy which is implicit in all the former categories, and in the
category of the ‘syncretic’. The difficulty of seeing religious traditions that
are not purely Hindu or Muslim, as a third different tradition detached
from the ‘centre’ or ‘mainstream’, reaffirms the existence of centre to
which it is attached .
From the problems raised and acknowledged by the above studies that
attempt to explain Islamic practices through experience, it becomes
apparent that the emphasis on ritual practice or ritual behaviour constructs
discourses within the lived or the experiential realm, which are similar to
the manner in which discourses are constructed from either texts or
ideology. This is compounded by the fact that behavioural interpretations
clearly deviate from the subject’s own understanding of practice that are
either contradictory, or at odds with each other, or may replicate
theological or authoritative discourses. Therefore it would appear that the
premise on which Islam as an anthropological subject is constructed
continues to remain theoretically elusive as problems of how to understand
Islam in India are raised.
It would appear that for Asad, Islam as a tradition is both taught and learnt
through instituted structures of authority. Therefore any analysis of Islam
necessarily includes an analysis of both political and religious power
structures, whose histories of relation and differentiation may vary, in the
constitution of Islamic traditions.
Notes
1
Textual traditions vary on questions such as what constitutes the Shariya or
Islamic law as well as on the principles or traditions of interpreting: the Quran, the
hadith or the codified traditions consisting of pronouncements and precedents of
the prophet. Sunni Muslims are divided into four broad schools: the Hanafi, the
Maliki, the Shafi and the Hambali, based on the four schools of Islamic
jurisprudence differing on the constitution of codified laws and on the principles of
interpreting them.
2
For instance Shiism is divided into sects based on different genealogies of
Imams. The Twelver Shiites or the Ithna-Ashari who follow twelve Imams tracing
their genealogy to Prophet and Ali, are the majority Shiites. The other groups
292 Chapter Fifteen
divert in tracing genealogical lineages, such as the Zaidia, are the followers of
Zaid, second son of Imam Zainul Abidin, the fourth Imam of the Shiites. They are
mostly found in Yemen. The Ismaili sect, are the followers of Ismail, son of Imam
Jafar Sadiq, the sixth Imam of the Shiites. The son of Ismail, Mohammad
Abdullah, was founder of Fatimide dynasty that ruled North Africa for three
centuries. The Ismailis are further divided into: Aga Khani Khojas, Bohras (known
as Dawoodi Bohras) etcetera . See Husnain: 1988 for more.
3
For more see for instance Satish Chandra. 2002. Parties and politics at the
Mughal Court, 1707-1740 4th Ed. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
4
Ashish Nandy (1990), for instance differentiates between religion as faith (read
custom) and religion as ideology to distinguish between Semitic and non-Semitic
roots of religion.
5
The volume of essays mostly focuses on the variations in caste patterns as they
occur in Ceylon and North-west Pakistan, from typified sociological
understandings of caste as peculiar to Hindu India.
6
See Werbner (1989) for more on this discussion. Werbner uses Dumont’s
dialectic approach to explain the persistence of caste as a system among Pakistani
labour migrants in Manchester.
7
Critiques of Dumont’s book Homo Hierarchicus are varied, but can be divided
into the following areas, as Dumont does in the preface to the complete edition
published by the University of Chicago press. He has been criticized: for analyzing
ancient text or empirical evidence in terms of [personal?] values such as hierarchy,
for making the distinction between status (hierarchy) and power and between the
role of the Brahmin in opposition to the king, for defining caste system in India as
an ideology and not directly in relation to the reality as it is lived (Marriott: 1990), and
finally for explaining caste from the superior castes’ or the Brahminical conception
of the social system as opposed to the conception of caste from the view of the
Untouchables (Gupta: 1991, 2004; Béteille:1965).
8
One maybe reminded, from Lindholm’s proposition of a theory of conflict, of
Max Gluckman’s understanding of ritualized ceremonies (as opposed to ritualism,
which according to him must be reserved for ceremonial actions in wider religions,
such as Catholicism, with stylized actions referring to mystical notions) as
emerging from the texture of social relations and dealing with conflicts between
groups and relationships. For Gluckman, rituals and ceremonies are related to
segregation of roles, necessary to "redress the equilibrium at any alteration of
social dispositions, or to establish a new equilibrium in changed relations—in Van
Gennep’s terms, to achieve re-aggregation or aggregation." (Gluckman: 1962, pg.
38) Role segregation in tribal societies is responsible for the highly ritualized
nature of its social life, according to Gluckman, and is conversely responsible for
absence of ritualization on Modern societies, where different spheres of relations
exist between political, kin, and religious. For Gluckman, then conflict pertains to
the "many values, customs, loyalties, and allegiances, on which groups are based,
are independent of one another and sometimes even discrepant with one another.”
ibid. These fundamental conflicts, Gluckman goes on to explain, arises out of the
common interest which society has in the fertility of fields and flocks and women,
while it is precisely over fields and flocks and women that individuals come into
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 293
competition and dispute. "The political system represents the peace and the moral
order within which it is possible for individuals to strive for good things that are
also valued by society as a whole; and hence the political system is vested with a
mystical value which places it beyond discussion and criticism.” (ibid, pg. 39)
Though it seems that if for Gluckman conflict is related to materiality and to
interest groups, it would appear that for Lindholm conflict arises out of
internalized values and probably makes his analysis seem closer to Dumont’s
method of analysis.
9
In fact, Lindholm appreciates Mines analysis of value conflict divergence
between Muslims and Hindus. See Lindholm: 1986, pg. 71 for more.
10
Referred in the earlier section 2.
11
This idea of ‘competitive sharing she derives from Robert M. Hayden.
12
According to Assayag, the term ‘composite culture’ is used to describe popular
religion in India, the shared religious traditions of Hindus and Muslims in large
parts. This term, she explains, gained currency in the 1940’s as a reaction to the
creation of Pakistan by nationalistic studies in India. See Assayag: 2004.
References
Abu-Lughod, Lila. (1989), “Zones of Theory in the Anthropology of the
Arab World” Annual Review of Anthropology 1(18): 267-306.
Ahmad, Imtiaz and Helmut Reifeld. Eds. 2004. Lived Islam in South Asia:
adaptation, accommodation, and conflict. New Delhi: Social Science.
Ahmad, Imtiaz. Ed. 1973. Caste and Social stratification among the
Muslims. New Delhi: Manohar.
—. Ed. 1976. Family, kingship and marriage among Muslims in India.
New Delhi: Manohar.
—. Ed.1981. Ritual and religion among Muslims in India. New Delhi:
Manohar.
Ahmad, Irfan. (2006), ''The state in Islamists thought '' ISIM Review 18
Autumn: 12-13.
Asad, Talal. 1986 .The idea of an anthropology of Islam.Washington,
D.C.: Georgetown University, Center for Contemporary Arab Studies.
—. 1993. Genealogies of religion: discipline and reasons of power in
Christianity and Islam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins university press.
—. 2003. Formations of the secular: Christianity, Islam, modernity.
Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
Assayag, Jackie. 2004. “Can Hindus and Muslims Coexist?” Eds. Ahmad
and H. Reifeld. Op cit. pp. 40-61.
—. 2004. At the confluence of two rivers: Muslims and Hindus in South
India. Transl. Latika Sahgal. New Delhi: Manohar Publishers &
distributor.
294 Chapter Fifteen
SREEJA CT
India exemplifies the politics of refugee asylum and care in South Asia.
South Asia has the fourth largest concentration of refugees in the world. A
majority of displaced persons who have crossed international borders in
this region are not regarded as "refugees" by the host governments. They
are usually treated as "undesirable aliens" or "illegal immigrants". There
are no national laws which define or distinguish "refugees" from others
who cross the borders. The governments in this region have also not
signed or ratified the 1951 UN Convention Concerning the Status of
Refugees and its 1967 Protocol, though most of the countries, like India,
Pakistan, and Nepal have the UNHCR’s presence in select areas. India
became a full member of the High Commissioners Programme in 1995.
However India still remains a non-state party to both the 1951 Refugee
convention and the 1967 Protocol.1
Scholars from the region point out the limiting factor in the definition of
“refugee” as incorporated by the 1951 UN Convention on Refugees and its
1967 Protocol. Only those who are persecuted in their home countries for
their political belief, opinion, race and religion are regarded as refugees by
the UNHCR. Many relief agencies and non-governmental organizations in
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 297
the region have gone beyond this mandate. Another important reason is
that the states of the region are extremely defensive about the criticism of
their human rights record. As violations of human rights is often the main
cause of forced population movements in South Asia, the governments
have been reluctant to involve the UNHCR and other international
agencies in the process.3 Another reason put forth by a former Foreign
Secretary of India, articulates these issues as, ‘perceived threats to national
security resulting from cross-border movements and domestic tensions. He
pointed out the difficulties in pushing back persons in the Indian
subcontinent, since they could not be clearly identified as refugees, given
the precedent for economic migrants. The argument of, ‘the necessity of
identifying and distinguishing between foreigners, immigrants and
refugees,4 pushes one into a territory of ethnic conflict. Roots of the ‘anti-
foreigner’ movements and state violence against minorities, by way of
evictions, are few of the scenarios that also await such an exercise by any
state. It becomes all the more evident, if the state is controlled by a
particular ethnic group and has its own agenda for the classification.
India faced a refugee crisis in the western and eastern borders during
1946-1958.5 During the 1970’s India’s eastern states faced a major
refugee crisis from East Bengal, which ultimately led to the formation of
Bangladesh.6 India’s northeast, and especially the state of West Bengal,
still face a constant flux of people from across the borders. The Muslim
migrants from the erstwhile East Pakistan and present day Bangladesh
have become the target of an "expulsion campaign" launched by the
radical Hindu nationalist parties of India.7
In the south, India also had to deal with Tamil refugees, after the ethnic
crisis in Srilanka in the 1980’s and the continuing civil war between the
militant Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) and the state. India is
host to a large population of Tibetan refugees who fled the country after
Chinese government followed various policies to weaken both the
temporal and the religious authority of the Dalai Lama, and change the
socio-economic structure of the region. The 1955-56 Tibetan uprising
brought Tibetans to various transit camps in Assam and West Bengal and
moved to more permanent settlements in different parts of India. In the
1980’s, there was a second exodus of people from Tibet, who have been
accommodated by the Indian authorities. Apart from this, India is also host
to Afghan refugees, and the Chin-Burmese refugees from Burma (present
day Myanmar) fleeing from the repressive policies of the State Law and
Order Restoration Council (SLORC) have taken shelter in the north-
298 Chapter Sixteen
The partition refugees, the influx of Tibetan refugees, refugees from the
former East Pakistan in 1971, the continuous movement of people across
the porous border in the east, all highlight the Indian states’ pragmatic
response to the refugee crisis. The Chakma refugees, the Afghan refugees,
refugees from Myanmar and the Sri-Lankan refugees have elicited an
altogether different response over the period they have been associated
with India. The responses of the Indian state are important to understand
the scenario of refugees in South Asia, since such policies usually impinge
on those of the others.
Samaddar takes the issues of power and care, to understand the refugee
flows and practices of Indian state. The politicisation of refugee
populations, which is highlighted by the two differing attitudes of the state
– one towards the Sri-lankan refugees, and the other towards the East
Pakistan refugees, is relevant here. The former was disliked for its active
political stance, and the other though legally barred, was allowed to
indulge in politics. It is important in understanding the Indian states
response in these cases, while addressing the refugees from Bhutan.
Another case is that of the Tibetan, the Burmese/ Myanmarese refugees
which also highlights the ambiguity inherent in these issues.
Sarbani Sen addresses among other issues, the lack of a specific refugee-
protection law, pronounced court judgments, massive and mixed flows of
forced migration.10 The political convenience for India, in utilising an ad
hoc approach to refugee issues, works out in its bilateral relations with the
neighbouring countries. Bhutan’s case is a glaring example of this
expedient policy.
in the west, the Sharchopsin the east who seem to be subsumed under the
dominant Drukpa Kagyupa culture of the ruling Ngalong elites. In contrast
to these two groups, are the Nepalis given the term ‘Lhotshampas’ by the
Bhutanese in mid 1980’s are predominantly Hindu and more distinctively
they have familial and extended relations in Nepal and India.13
The Nepali-Bhutanese entered into the country and were allowed to settle
only in the South of the country, in area considered inhabitable by the
northern Drukpa population15. The policy of settling the Nepali’s in the
eastern Himalayas was first followed by the British who wanted an
effective bulwark against the Tibetans and the Chinese16. The British
policy of the settling the Nepalese as a “buffer” against the Tibetan and the
Chinese is manifest in their calculations that, “as in India, Hinduism will
assuredly cast out Buddhism, and the praying wheel of the lama will give
place to the sacrificial implements of the Brahman”.17
The southerners sought spouses from their brethren/ ethnic kin across the
borders, and this act imposed severe penalties on their full participation in
Bhutan’s polity.21
It was alleged that both demonstrators and security forces committed acts
of violence. After the demonstrations, the Bhutanese army and police
began the task of identifying participants and supporters, who were classed
as Ngolops (anti-nationals), and the flow of refugees out of Bhutan began.
It reached a peak in May 1992, with 11,000 arrivals recorded for that
month in the camps in Nepal. The refugees brought with them detailed
allegations of torture, brutality, rape, and forced evictions.
Bhutan unique geopolitical position and its Buddhist culture have helped
contribute in no small measure to the international community’s apathy to
find a just solution for the refugees. King Jigme Singye Wangchuck, has
emphasized in all the interviews, the fact that Bhutan was a small nation
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 303
between giant neighbours, and all it had to define it was its cultural
identity, and that it was too small to enjoy the luxury of cultural pluralism.
As the `concerned neighbour’ in this refugee issue, which has borders with
both Bhutan and Nepal; however, it has formally avoided dealing with the
304 Chapter Sixteen
issue of refugees. Presently, the concern for India is not the plight of the
refugees, but the question of a stable regime in Bhutan, that will not upset
its status quo in its relation with Bhutan.27
officer’ in Bhutan and his close personal friendship with the ruling family
in Bhutan. His writings and his experience as a political officer in the
north eastern region of India throw interesting light on the way Bhutan’s
polity operated. While Rustomji does not hide his affection for Bhutan,
and his caution against the dilution of the Drukpa culture, in his writings, a
careful reading of his account on the elite crisis of the late 1960’s reveals a
great deal about the workings of the Bhutanese royalty and thus the polity.
Startlingly similar sentiments can be seen in the National Assembly
proceedings, following the crisis of the 1990’s.
Within this group, the scholarship has been focused either from the point
of view of strategic concerns of India in South Asia, bilateral relation
between India and Bhutan. Most of the relational studies, end with
stressing how vital, a friendly, stable (read= monarchy) Bhutan is for
India. Books written by former officials posted in Bhutan, include, Nari
Rustomji, and B S Das. Others like G N Mehra, Nagendra Singh, B J
Hasrat, Ram Rahul, P P Karan, Laxman Singh Rathore and Paramanand
have focused on Bhutan over the years, and whose works were also
published prior to the ethnic crisis in the Kingdom. A C Sinha’s work
offers a more critical look on the polity and the interaction of the British
and the Bhutanese.29
B S Das’ book in the wake of the crisis of the 1990’s, Bhutan: A Nation
in Transition with his background as the first resident Indian
representative in Bhutan from the years January 1968 to March 1972. The
fact of the ‘demographic threat’ is again stressed in his book, pointing out
that the Bhutanese rulers ignored the complexities of a mixed population
in the south and believes that "placing restrictions on citizenship rights and
movement of Nepalese settlers" limited the problem. The author believes
that "basic issues were lost sight of" because the ethnic problem really
has its roots in perceived inequities. Das, was also the Chief Executive in
Sikkim during the crucial period when the kingdom merged with India,
says "it was the discrimination economic disparity created by a feudal
306 Chapter Sixteen
system for self-preservation that led to the agitation," and points out the
fact which has immense relevance for Bhutan, that "it was not the 75 per
cent Nepalese population of Sikkim that led to the ruling pattern." He is
sympathetic to Bhutanese fears of demographic changes but advises
Bhutan to take lessons from Sikkim’s history. Scholarship on Bhutan,
from India, follows the above trend and there are few exceptions to it.30
Absence of special legal regime on the refugees in India has meant that the
refugees are dependent on the benevolence of the State rather than regime
of rights. Even the limited mandate given to the UNHCR is concerned to
refugees from outside the South Asian region, mainly Afghan refugees.
The Bhutanese refugees know that unless India puts pressure on Bhutan,
they would remain in exile. Bhutan has maintained its relationship with
India playing on the aspects that allows it to maintain the status quo. The
energy starved Indian states bordering Bhutan depend on the Hydro-
electric plants built in southern Bhutan, plus a sure vote in the UN, and a
proactive Bhutanese diplomacy allows the refugee issue to remain
unresolved.31
Notes
1
Aung Phyro & Tapan Bose , “Refugees in South Asia: An Overview”, Refugee
Watch No.1, January 1998;
www.mnet.fr/aiindex/Refugee-Watch/Index.html
2
Augustine Mahiga, ‘Foreword’, in R Samaddar ed., Refugees and the State:
Practices of Asylum and Care in India: 1947-2000 (New Delhi: Sage Publications,
2003), p.16.
3
SAARCLAW, UNHCR, Round table Workshop Report: Refugees in the SAARC
Region: National Legislation on Refugees (India Habitat Centre, New Delhi:
SAARCLAW, UNHCR, 30 April, 1999) , p.1.
4
Tapan K Bose, Protection of Refugees in South Asia: Need for Legal Framework
(Kathmandu: South Asia forum for Human Rights, January 2000), p.8.
5
Muchkund Dubey, quoted in SAARCLAW, UNHCR, Round table Workshop
Report: Refugees in the SAARC Region: National Legislation on Refugees (India
Habitat Centre, New Delhi: SAARCLAW, UNHCR, 30 April, 1999) , p.4.
6
Aung Phyro & Tapan Bose, n.133, Samir KumarDas, ‘State Response to the
Refugee Crisis: Relief and Rehabilitation in the East’, in R Samaddar ed.,
Refugees and the State: Practices of Asylum and Care in India: 1947-2000 (New
Delhi: Sage Publications, 2003).
7
Samir Kumar Das, ‘State Response to the Refugee Crisis: Relief and
Rehabilitation in the East’, in R Samaddar ed., Refugees and the State: Practices
of Asylum and Care in India: 1947-2000 (New Delhi: Sage Publications, 2003).
8
They claim that about 20 million Bangladeshis have illegally entered India after
1971. The Indian Home Ministry has however chosen to remain silent on the
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 307
20
For various Citizenship Acts, see Annexure, in Sreeja C T, Ethnicity in South
Asia: A Study of the Nepali-Bhutanese Refugees (Unpublished Thesis submitted to
University of Hyderabad, August 2006).
21
Interview with a cross-section of refugees. Annexure, in Sreeja C T, Ethnicity in
South Asia: A Study of the Nepali-Bhutanese Refugees (Unpublished Thesis
submitted to University of Hyderabad, August 2006).
22
In 1958, the 'Lhotshampa' population of the southern districts of Bhutan was
granted Bhutanese citizenship and tenure of its lands etc. Driglam Namzha:
Bhutan's sixth Five-Year Plan (1987-92) included a policy of 'one nation, one
people' and introduced a code of traditional Drukpa dress and etiquette called
Driglam Namzha. Language at the beginning of the school year in March 1990 the
teaching of Nepali was discontinued and all Nepali curricular materials
disappeared from Bhutanese schools.
23
Bhutan: A Traditional Order and Forces of Change: Three Views from Thimphu
(Thimphu: Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Royal Government of Bhutan, 1993), p.21.
24
Christopher Strawn and DNS Dhakal, Bhutan: A Movement in Exile (New
Delhi: Nirala Publishers, 1995), p.285.
25
A Smith, 1986, p.217.
26
Rodolfo Stavenhagen,” Ethnic Conflicts and their impact on international
society”, International Social Science Journal (Oxford, Basil and Blackwell)
February 1991, p.321.
27
Ibid, p.321.
28
Stavenhagen Ibid, Partha Ghosh, pp.9-16.
29
A C Sinha, Ethnic Identity and National Dilemma (New Delhi: Reliance Pub.
Hs., 1991).
30
Mathew Joseph C, Ethnic Conflict in Bhutan (New Delhi: Nirala Pub., 1999)
being one of the few exceptions to the general trend in the scholarship about
Bhutan, emanating from India.
31
Hydropower is the major source of revenue, with India as the major market.
Major projects like Chukka, Basochhu, Kurichhu and Tala will substantially
increase energy generation in the future. It is estimated that Bhutan’s rivers have a
capacity to generate 30,000 megawatts of hydropower:
http://www.mti.gov.bt/energy/energy_in_Bhutan.htm,
http://www.pc.gov.bt/fyp/7thplan/07fyp_20.pdf.
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN
AZMAT RASUL
Van Dijk (2005) has highlighted the constraints journalists have to face in
Europe during the process of collection and dissemination of news. He
argues that journalists act as gatekeepers and deicide content for
publication that could please the advertisers and owners. They are hardly
objective as they are socialized in a dominant culture that shapes their
mode of thinking. The journalists are a part of the middle class and they
maintain frequent contact with the elite who are a main source of
information for them. Consequently, they are influenced by the ideology
312 Chapter Seventeen
of the elite and promote that ideology unknowingly through their news
stories and opinion pieces. Similarly, while selecting topics to be covered
about culturally different people in Europe, journalists are biased and
usually select violent themes which prove that immigrants and ethnic
minorities are a threat for a peaceful majority (van Dijk, 2005).
How can journalists work properly and cover other cultures adequately has
always been a difficult question. Furisch (2002) says that through travel
journalism, other cultures can be understood in a better way. She argues
that passive critique of the representation of other cultures is not a good
approach but the media critics should put forward a plan and engage
themselves actively in the media discourse. On the contrary, the era of
globalization has also remarkably changed the media scenario where
journalists have to deal with material coming from alien cultures. Media
globalization is fostering a new culture all around where cultural lines blur
and it is possible to have a representative account of the heterogeneous
cultures.
of identity are given life through their articulation.” This means that
recurring language used to describe Islam and Muslims (such as ‘Islamic
terrorism,’ ‘Muslim fanatics’) can come to be representative of all
Muslims and Islam as a religion.
There are a number of studies which indicate that media overrepresents the
elites in society as sources of news and it is obsessed with a celebrity
oriented culture. It has trivialized politics by engaging in portrayal of elites
in entertainment-oriented programs and citizens today are less informed
about other cultures and important issues facing their society (Postman,
1985). Media has a bias in favour of value system of the elite and even in
fictional media content, elite locations are shown and the minorities or
other underprivileged sections of the society are sidelined and negatively
stereotyped (DeFleur, 1964; Golding and Elliot, 1979; McQuail, 2005).
However, there are other intervening variables as well and it is not only
the media which is responsible for the negative imaging of Muslims in the
West. Barker and Galasinski (2001, p. 7) argue that “texts are unable to
police the meanings to be constructed from them.” It is clear that social
forces other than textual discourse also contribute to dominant images and
stereotypes of Muslims and Islam. As social actors, humans do possess the
ability to create different meanings and representations of Muslims.
Muslims in Europe have experienced alienation, racism and vilification
before the terrorist attacks in 2001. The racial stereotyping of all Muslims
as Arabs and all Arabs as Muslims during the Gulf War led to series of
physical attacks, racial insults and negative stereotyping of Muslims
(Asmar, 1992).
Denmark
The available studies of media discourses on ethnic minorities reveal that a
subtle form of racism persists in reporting on ethnic situations in Denmark.
Minorities are portrayed not only as an outgroup, but also as a threat to
Danish culture and society. However, the Danish media and academia
have realized the need to understand immigrants, which are largely
Muslims, in a better way especially after the cartoon crisis (Sorensen,
2006). The Muslim immigrants living in Denmark feel frustrated at the
continuous negative portrayal of their communities and they have
developed a tendency to avoid mainstream Danish media (Christiansen,
2004).
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 315
Germany
According to ter Wal Report (2002), negative stereotypes were frequently
associated with migrants and the media mainly addressed migrants in the
context of negative happenings and conflicts. News reporting was subject
to discursive changes, for instance from an emphasis on foreigners' issues
in the 1980s to a greater attention to asylum issues in the early 1990s.
However, whenever foreign employees were discussed, it was usually in
relation to crime or violence. Turkish community was overrepresented in
the mainstream media in a stereotypical manner.
France
During the 1980s, news and current affairs coverage of minorities was
most commonly featured under the broad heading of immigration, a media
framing device which worked to the disadvantage of those concerned.
According to the Report, media content analyses have shown that there are
significant imbalances in media representations of different migrants and
minorities. The minorities are underrepresented in certain media genres
and overrepresented in others while the Muslims largely received negative
coverage due to Hijab controversy and rioting in France.
The Netherlands
The ter Wal Report (2002) has analyzed the studies published between
1995 and 2000 and the findings indicate that the persistence of negative
and stereotypical portrayals of ethnic minorities coexists with more
diversified and positive approaches. Ethnic minorities themselves are
dissatisfied with their coverage and as study of D'Haenens et al. (2005)
indicated that the interviewees during a survey perceived the reporting as
one-sided and negative and found that positive new stories were neglected.
United Kingdom
Hall (1988) has commented that there is a politics of representation going
on in the UK among blacks, however, the ter Wal Report (2002) finds an
overall improvement in standards of journalism regarding the
representation of minorities. There is a broad range of coverage of issues
relating to immigration and ethnic relations across the full spectrum of
broadcasting and print media. Despite these measures, Muslims in UK feel
neglected and stereotyped in the mainstream media. Muslims and the
316 Chapter Seventeen
Germany
According to Ouaj (1999), only a small group of people having foreign
origin or with a multicultural background are employed in German TV.
The proportion of ethnic minorities employed in the television channels in
Germany is estimated to a value around 2%. This is not corresponding to
the proportion of ethnic groups and immigrants living in the country which
is estimated at 8.5% of the population.
United Kingdom
According to Ouaj (1999), the proportion of ethnic minorities in the audio-
visual sector varies from 2 to 6.7% in the United Kingdom. The presence
of ethnic minorities is relatively high in the BBC and Channel 4. But in the
other private television stations, the proportion of ethnic minorities
remains very low. However, BBC has set up professional structures for
providing equal access to disadvantaged groups, although, the minorities
still complain about the attitude of the seniors at BBC who treat them on
unequal footings.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 317
France
In France, according to Ouaj (1999), there is no information available on
employment and access of ethnic minorities to the television industry. But
research has revealed that people belonging to certain social classes might
have more difficulties than other to enter into jobs and develop careers in
television.
The Netherlands
In the Dutch audio-visual sector, the number of minorities is 2 to 3
percent, although, the minorities constitute 8.5 per cent of the total
population. According to Ouaj (1999), a research conducted on NCRV
(Nederland’s Christelijke Radio Vereining), which is the national
Protestant broadcasting organisation of the Netherlands, shows that it has
five employees with an ethnic minority background among a total staff of
about 270. A personnel manager confirms that “Christianity” is a selection
criterion for employment, and this is advertised with job announcements in
newspapers (Ouaj, 1999).
surveyed did not think Mr. Rasmussen, the Danish Prime Minister during
the crisis, should apologize for the drawings while 58 of those surveyed
also said they could sympathize with displeasure expressed Muslims in
Denmark. As a nation it became exhausting to discuss it further and Danes
hoped that they could put the events behind them.
VII. Conclusion
The unavoidable conclusion inherent in this essay points to the importance
of balanced and careful news coverage of events related to the minorities
in general and Muslims in particular. Various scholars have urged on the
need to promote multicultural tendencies which call for tolerance and
cooperation among various groups in the society (Fraser, 1990; Fursich,
2002; Glasser et al., 2006; Hussain, 2000; ter Wal, 2002). Given the
implicit influence of media on their readers and audience, it is imperative
that news on sensitive issues are investigated in depth and represented
with due care to their impact on inter-ethnic and inter-faith relations. This
will mean avoiding stereo-types and reflecting the social, political and
ideological diversity of the immigrant Muslims. Simplistic reports and
recycling cliché do not inform readers and create misunderstanding. They
reconfirm bias against a community that has become a subject of intense
public scrutiny (Hussain, 2000).
Notes
1
Revised version of the paper Presented at The Ninth International Conference on
Hunting and Gathering Societies, held at Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, 9th to
13th September, 2002, Session-33: South Asian Hunter-Gatherers.
This case study has been an academic exercise which the students of Erasmus
Mundus Program in Journalism and Media – 2006-2008 – were supposed to submit
before the formal commencement of the program. The focus was the coverage of
unrest among Muslims in the respective countries of the students. The coverage of
the cartoon crisis in Danish media was compiled by Miriam Christensen, a student
in the program from Denmark, and the discussion in this case study is based on the
information provided by her.
References
Asmar, C. (1992), The Arab Australian Experience’ Australia’s Gulf war.
Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
Barker, C., & Galasinski, D. (2001), Cultural Studies and Discourse
Analysis: A Dialogue on Language and Identity, London: Sage.
Christiansen, C. C. (2004), News Media Consumption among Immigrants
in Europe. Ethnicities, 4(2), 185-207.
DeFleur, M. L. (1964), Occupational Roles as Portrayed on Television.
Public Opinion Quarterly, 28, 57-74.
Dunn, K. (2001), ‘Representation of Islam in the Politics of Mosque
Development in Sydney’. Tijdschrit voor Economische en Sociale
Geografie, 92(3), 291-308.
Fraser, N. (1990), Rethinking the Public Sphere: A Contribution to the
Critique of Actually Existing Democracy. Social Text, 25/26, 56-80.
Fursich, E. (2002), How can Global Journalists Represents the Other?
Journalism, 3(1), 57-84.
Graber, D. (1980), Crime News and the Public. New York: Praeger.
Glasser, T. et al., (2006), The Claims of Multiculturalism and Journalism’s
Promise of Diversity. San Francisco, CA.
Golding, P., & Elliot, P. (1979), Making the News. London: Longman.
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 321
(EUMC), 11-88.
Young, I., M. (1989), Polity and Group Difference: A Critique of the Ideal
of Universal Citizenship. Ethics, 99(2), 250-274.
CONTRIBUTORS
11. Dr. Rita Afsar, Senior Research Fellow and Head, Human Resources
Research Division, Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies(BIDS),
E-17 Agargaon, Sher-E-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka-1207, Bangladesh. Email:
rita@sdnbd.org; rita_afsar@yahoo.com.au
17. Ramesh C. Malik, UGC Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Applied
Linguistics & Translation Studies (CALTS), School of Humanities,
University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad- 500046, Andhra Pradesh, India.
E-mail: ramesmalik@gmail.com
Ethnographic Discourse of the Other 325