Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
11
12 *E-mail: t.hasanbasri@unsam.ac.id
13
14 ABSTRACT
15This study is to develop a tsunami-based digital map (application) to help both students
16and the public accessing information about earthquake mitigation. Besides, it also aims to
17identify factors affecting learning outcomes in the implementation of a tsunami-based
18digital map for disaster mitigation learning. The study was quantitative and developmental.
19The data collection techniques were questionnaire distribution and observation with the
20help of an instrument. It was conducted in Samudra universities. The population was all
21individuals involved in the learning process and management in Universitas Samudra. The
22samples were 39 geography students taking disaster mitigation classes, lectures, and
23Head of geography Study Program of Universitas Samudra. This study using Multiple
24Linear Regression Analysis. That lecturer’s ability has a significant influence towards
25geography student’s learning outcome, lecturer’s and student’s activity in the classroom
26has a significant influence towards geography student’s ability in using the tsunami-based
27digital map as a learning medium for disaster mitigation class and student’s response has
28a significant influence towards geography student’s ability in using a tsunami-based digital
29map as a learning medium for disaster mitigation class. Furthermore, the three
30independent variables, lecturer’s ability, lecturer’s and student’s activity in the classroom
31and student’s response have a significant influence on geography student’s ability in using
32a tsunami-based digital map as a learning medium for disaster mitigation class (student’s
33learning outcome). This study is a pioneer study in which researchers developed a
34tsunami-based digital map as a medium to enhance student’s understanding of disaster
35mitigation.
36
37Keywords: Tsunami, Digital Map, Disaster Mitigation
38
39
40INTRODUCTION
41 Indonesia is prone to earthquakes and tsunami. Indonesia is one of the World’s
42most active earthquake zones because the country is a subduction zone where three main
43active tectonic plates, Indo-Australian, Eurasian and Pacific Plates meet. Based on the
44seismic activity map of Indonesia, about 290 cities (60% of Indonesian cities) are prone to
45earthquakes and are located 11,000 kilometers away from the coast making these cities
46prone to the tsunami. A tsunami occurs in Indonesia almost every year. Picture 1.1., 1.2
47and 1.3 show Indonesian cities vulnerable to earthquake and tsunami and tsunamis that
48occurred in Indonesia. Shallow earthquake (more than 6 Richter Scales) that occurs on the
49bed of the sea may cause a tsunami. Indonesian tsunami is a local tsunami that strikes
50very quickly as its epicenter is located close to most of the Indonesian beaches.
51Indonesian earthquakes and tsunamis resulted in a lot of fatalities and material losses.
52Besides the 9.5-Mw tsunami taking place in Chili in 1960, the most severe tsunami in the
53last 100 years is the Aceh tsunami (9 Mw) that took place on December 26, 2004. Not only
54did it damage millions of buildings, but the tsunami in Aceh also killed a thousand people
55in seven countries in the Indian Ocean. The highest fatality occurred in Aceh and
56neighboring provinces (150 thousand victims).
57 Having analyzed the history of the tsunamis, tsunami casualties are generally
58caused by several factors. Besides the magnitude of the tsunami (including the epicenter,
59wave height, speed of propagation and height of inundation), the number of tsunami
60fatalities is also influenced by a lack of knowledge about tsunami and poor disaster
61mitigation. The public has very little information about tsunami and the regional
62government does not have adequate preparation should tsunami strikes.
63 The dynamics of nature are two sides of a coin; some are beneficial for living beings
64while others can be disastrous. Science can predict and anticipate some of the dynamics,
65particularly those that can potentially damage human beings, such as volcanic eruptions,
66hurricanes, and floods. However, several natural dynamics are difficult to detect, for
67example, earthquakes and tsunami. To minimize and prevent casualty, people, more
68particularly people who live in an area prone to natural disasters, should have sufficient
69knowledge, understanding, and skills to prevent, detect and anticipate various types of
70disasters before they strike.
71 The objective of education represents human resource quality, integration between
72moral quality, attitude, knowledge, and anticipative and creative behavior. Education is a
73set of systems that consists of learning materials, teachers/lecturers, students, methods,
74media, infrastructure and facilities, and stakeholders in both micro-scale (Dean) and
75macro-scale (the Ministry of Research and Technology). Alvin Toffler stated that to
76develop the education sector, we should take into account learner’s needs in the future or
77“super-industrial education system” (Enok 2007). Furthermore, (Tilaar 2008) argued that
78national education needs new paradigms and one of which is to prepare students for both
79internal and global challenges. Both challenges require human capital that later is
80transformed into a competitive advantage. These are the platform that developed
81competency-based education.
82 Life-skills refer to not only job-oriented skills but also survival skills that consist of
83self-awareness, thinking skills, social skills, academic skill, and vocational skills. Social
84science is one of the first subjects students learn at school. It discusses simplification,
85adaptation, selection, and modification of concepts and skills on geography, sociology,
86anthropology and economically arranged in both scientific and psychological manner for
87learning purposes. (Enok 2007) explain that mitigation (mitigate) means an action that
88minimizes casualty or fatality. Mitigation involves activities and preventive steps, namely
89preparation, analysis and evaluation (towards how severe natural disaster is and how
90much damage it costs) and disaster mitigation (rescue, rehabilitation, and relocation).
91According to the 2003 Minister of Domestic Issues Decree number 131, mitigation is effort
92or activity of which objective is to minimize casualty a disaster may cause; it consists of
93preparation, awareness, and prevention.
94 Based on elaboration, students should learn various topics related to natural
95disasters. Natural disasters are a series of natural events that threaten and disrupt the
96lives and livelihoods of people (Tilaar 2008). A natural disaster will result in casualties,
97environmental damage, property losses, and psychological impacts, more particularly
98when people have very little knowledge of natural disasters. One method to improve
99student’s understanding of natural disasters is through integration between topics
100discussing natural disasters and one of the subjects at school (Arief 2013).
101 Schools should develop learning material that enhances student’s understanding
102and develops their skills in disaster mitigation. One of the alternatives is to develop a
103geophysics module. The module helps students obtain information about discussed topics
104(Arief 2013). Module fosters a student’s independence (Dahar et al. 2006). The module
105helps students achieve learning objectives and targets.
106 Previous researchers have discussed integration between natural disaster mitigation and
107geophysics. Wahyudi’s study showed that integration between earthquake and mitigation
108techniques into the wave symptom module got positive feedback; the integration
109developed students’ understanding of geophysics and increased their average scores by
1100.6 (average). Besides that, the integration enhanced students’ understanding of disaster
111mitigation (Indriantoro and Supadmo 1999). Good disaster mitigation will result in high
112disaster awareness. Disaster awareness refers to any action to prevent, deal with and
113overcome the disaster.
114 Based on the background, the university needs an accurate digital map as a medium to
115identify areas where natural disasters once struck and a part of disaster mitigation
116learning. Therefore, the objective of this study is to develop a tsunami-based digital map
117(application) to help both students and the public accessing information about earthquake
118mitigation. Besides, it also aims to identify factors affecting learning outcomes in the
119implementation of a tsunami-based digital map for disaster mitigation learning. This study
120is a pioneer study in which researchers developed a tsunami-based digital map as a
121medium to enhance student’s understanding of disaster mitigation, different from the
122previous related studies conducted by Arends (1997), Arief (2012), and Erwin (2013).
123
124LITERATURE REVIEW AND DEVELOPMENT OF CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
125Behaviorism
126Behaviorism is developed by B. F. Skinner. The most important principle of this theory is
127that behavior changes based on the direct consequences of the aforementioned behavior
128(Gredler 1994). The positive consequence will reinforce behavior, while negative ones will
129gradually eliminate the behavior. A positive consequence is called reinforcer, while the
130negative one is the punisher. The implementation of both reinforcer and punisher for
131behavioral change is called operant conditioning (Slavin 1994). According to behaviorism,
132early or immediate reinforcement and punishment have a positive influence on the
133upcoming behavior.
134
135Social Learning Theory
136 Social learning theory discusses behavioral learning principles and emphasizes on
137internal mental processes. Kardi (1997) suggested that most people learn through
138selective observation and remembering other’s behaviors. There are two types of
139observational learning, namely Vicarius Conditioning or learning by observing other people
140and learning by observing other people (observer) and later replicating the behavior of the
141models even though they do not get any reinforcement or punishment during the
142observation. Bandura stated that behavior modeling theory is a three-stage process that
143consists of attention, retention (imitation/memory), and production (practice). There five
144possible outcomes of observational behavior, namely introduce new behavior or attitude,
145encourage existing behavior, change unwanted behavior, divert attention and foster
146emotion. Dahar et al. (1996) suggested that human being observes his or her behavior,
147analyze the behavior against his or her criteria, and then give himself or herself
148reinforcement or punishment.
149
150Definition and Types of Disaster
151 Disaster as serious events that disrupt society and cause material, economic and
152environmental casualties to the society and therefore, the society is unable to use their
153resources to overcome the events (Adi 2010). Based on the UN International Strategy for
154Disaster Reduction (Adi 2010), there are two types of disaster, natural and technological
155disaster. Natural disaster consists of three categories, hydro-meteorological (flood,
156hurricane, drought, and landslide), geophysical (earthquake, tsunami and volcanic activity)
157and biological (epidemics, plant and animal disease). The technological disaster also
158consists of three categories, namely industrial incident (chemical leaks, industrial
159infrastructure damage, gas leaks, and radiation), transportation incident (land, rail and
160water transportation, and airplane crash) and miscellaneous incident (domestic or non-
161industrial structure, explosion, and fire).
162
163Earthquake and Tsunami
164 Earthquake is vibration from within the Earth which then propagated to the Earth
165surface when the Earth is breaking and shifting violently (Yulaelawati 2008). An
166earthquake may be caused by the dynamics of the Earth (tectonics), volcanic activity,
167falling meteors, avalanches (below sea level) or nuclear explosion below the surface. A
168tsunami usually occurs if an earthquake with a large enough vertical movement takes
169place on the seabed. A tsunami can also occur due to volcanic eruption at sea or an
170avalanche occurs under the sea. Some information to take into account earthquake and
171tsunami are that small earthquakes do not always lead to large earthquakes; the seismic
172waves rock the Earth for days. This phenomenon is called earth free oscillation; the
173weather does not induce earthquakes; most earthquakes occur at less than 80 km below
174the Earth's surface, and the frequency of most earthquake waves is less than 20 Hz and
175thus, the human can only listen to the sound of shaken objects.
176
177
178
179Earthquake and Tsunami Mitigation
180Mitigation or activities to minimize earthquake and tsunami casualty consist of predicting
181an earthquake, pre-, whilst- and post-earthquake or tsunami activities. There are 2 (two)
182earthquake prediction methods, namely short-range prediction and long-range prediction.
183
184Social Science Learning Model
185Piaget argued that learning occurs continuously between individual and constantly
186changing environment. Flew (2007) defined learning as a systematic combination of
187human, material, facility, media, and procedures to achieve learning objectives. Hasan in
188Enok (2007) postulated that learning model should meet the following principles, namely
189learning causes improvement, good learning occurs when a teacher spends fewer times to
190engage students in learning, learning accommodates different learning styles and is
191facilitated by a teacher or lecturer, and there is not one perfect learning method.
192
193Definition and Types of Media
194 Based on the Association of Education Communication Technology (AECT), media
195are various types and channels for spreading information. On the other hand,
196Mirso described media as any object that delivers the message and at the same time,
197stimulates student’s thoughts, feeling, attention and willingness to study. Media are
198classified into three categories, visual, audio, and audio-visual.
199
200Digital Map
201 A Digital map refers to the representation of geographic phenomenon stored,
202shown and analyzed on computers. Every object in a digital map is stored as one or a
203group of coordinates. Compared to the analog map, a digital map has reliable quality, is
204easy to store and transferrable from one device to another, and can be updated. The
205Digital map also has map attributes such as scale, geographic reference, projection
206system, and map projection.
207
208Previous Related Studies
209 Arends (1997) conducted a study entitled “Mitigation Socialization Model for
210Disaster Prone Community in West Java.” It reported that West Java is very prone to
211natural disasters since natural disaster takes place once a year and epicentrum is
212relatively close. The area is densely populated and the number of individuals at non-
213productive age is high. In other words, West Java has a high dependency level. Quality of
214building and mobility are low. The locals have very little information about disaster
215mitigation. The survival rate is lower due to poverty, low education level and poor access
216to technology. Arief Budiman’s study reported that Indonesia is prone to earthquakes, for
217example, the ones taking place in Aceh and Yogyakarta a few years ago. This study
218developed a cellular phone application that consists of information about earthquake
219mitigation (Arief 2012). Erwin’s study aimed to describe the quality of learning types
220equipment in integrated natural science classes as well as responses of natural science
221teachers in junior high school/Islamic junior high school towards developed learning
222equipment. The findings showed that the developed learning equipment can be used as
223one of the learning types of equipment for integrated natural science class in junior high
224school/Islamic junior high school (Erwin 2013).
225
226METHODOLOGY
227 The study was quantitative and developmental. The data collection techniques were
228questionnaire distribution and observation with the help of an instrument. It was conducted
229in Samudra universities. The population was all individuals involved in the learning process
230and management in Universitas Samudra. The samples were 39 geography students
231taking disaster mitigation classes, lectures, and Head of geography Study Program of
232Universitas Samudra. In order to identify the influence of the lecturer’s ability, lecturer’s
233and student’s activity in the classroom, student’s responses and learning quality, multiple
234linear analysis methods and SPSS program were used. The analysis formula was as
235follows:
236
237 ŷ =a + b1X1 + b2X2 + b3X3
238Where:
239ŷ : quality of learning outcome
240a : constant
241b1 : lecturer’s ability regression coefficient
242b2 : lecturer’s and student’s activity in the classroom regression coefficient
243b3 : student’s response regression coefficient
244X1 : lecturer’s ability
245X2 : lecturer’s and student’s activity in the classroom
246X3 : student’s response
247e : Standard error
248
249Coefficient of Determination Analysis
250 The coefficient of determination measured how much a model can explain the
251dependence variable variance (Ghozali 2011). The coefficient of determination with the
252following formula is used to identify percentage that represents how much influence the
253lecturer’s ability, lecturer’s and student’s activity in the classroom, and student’s response
254towards the quality of learning outcome.
255
256 R2 = r2 x 100%
257Where:
258R2 : coefficient of determination
259r : coefficient of correlation
260The coefficient of determination is between zero and one. Lower R2 means independent
261variables have very limited ability to explain the dependent variable but when R2 is closer
262to one, independent variables can provide nearly all information to predict the dependent
263variable.
264
501
502REFERENCES
503Adi. Y.F., 2010, “Determination of Variables”, Universitas Indonesia.
504Ardianto, E., Bambang, Q. A., & Anees, M. A., 2007, “Philosophy of Communication”,
505 Simbiosa Rekatama Media, Bandung
506Arends, RI, 1997, “Classroom Instruction and Management”. New York; McGraw-Hill
507 Companies, Inc.
508Arief, B, 2012, “Disaster Mitigation and Earthquake Spatial Planning Yogyakarta 2006”,
509 Yogyakarta
510Arief, B, 2012, “Development of Mobile Application for Learning Earthquake Disaster
511 Mitigation”, Sentika, 36-40
512Atwater, M.M, 1996, “Social constructivism: Infusion into the multicultural science
513 education research agenda. Journal of Research in Science Teaching”, The Official
514 Journal of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, 33(8), 821-837.
515Dahar, N., Hollins, G. W., Thomas, S., Lanigan, D. J., Jodrell, D., Kaye, S. B., & Kirk, D,
516 1996, “Retroperitoneal surgery: its wider role in the management of malignant
517 teratoma”, British Journal of Urology, 77(4), 571-576
518Enok, M, 2007, “Disaster Mitigation Model in Social Sciences Learning in High Schools”,
519 UPI, Jakarta
520Enok, M, 2010, “Mitigation Model Socialization in Prone Areas Communities in West Java”,
521 UPI, Jakarta
522Erwin, P, 2013, “Development of Integrated Science Learning Tools PAUD Based on Iqra
523 Model and Merapi Eruption Disaster Mitigation” UIN Sunan Kalijaga. Jakarta
524Flew, T, 2007, “New media: An introduction” Oxford University Press.
525Ghozali, I, 2011, “Multivariate Analysis Application with SPSS” Badan Penerbit Universitas
526 Diponegora, Semarang
527Gredler, M.E.B., 1994, “Learning to Learn " Raja Grafindo Persada, Jakarta
528Hamalik, O., 2001, Proses Belajar Mengajar, Bumi Aksara
529Indriantoro, N. & Supomo, B., 1999, “Business Research Methodology”, BPFE,
530 Yogyakarta.
531Kardi, S, 1997, “Learning model”, IKIP Surabaya
532Munib, A., 2004, “Introduction to Education”, UPT MKK UNNES, Semarang
533Nur. M., 1999, “Science Learning Devices That Can Meet Individual Needs” Unesa,
534 Surabaya
535Slavin, R.E., 1994, “Educational Psycology Theory Into Practice”, Allyn and Bacon
536 Publishers, Boston
537Tilaar, H.A.R, 2008, “National Education Management”, Remaja Rosdakarya, Bandung
538Yulaelawati, E, 2008, “Mencerdasi bencana: banjir, tanah longsor, tsunami, gempa bumi,
539 gunung api, kebakaran”, Grasindo
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
(
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576 Figure 1. Indonesian Tsunamis between 1991 and 2006 ( Source: Hamzah Latief, 2016)
577
578 597
579 598
580 599
581 600
582 601
583 602
584 603
585 604
586 605
587 606
588 607
589 608
590 609
591 610
592 611
593 612
594 613
595 614
596
615Table 1. Multiple Linear Regression Output
Variable Coefficient Beta t Sig t Result
Constant 0.712 0.489 0.513
Lecturer’s Ability
0.341 0.235 3.121 0.004 Significant
Lecturer’s and
Student’s Activity in 0.257 0.215 2.116 0.045 Significant
the Classroom
Student’s Response
0.413 0.436 5.244 0.000 Significant
Fvalue = 25.454
Sig F = 0.000
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641Table 2. Coefficient of Determination
642Model Summary
Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. error of the Estimate
1 .854a .732 .715 1.178
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653