Comparative Chart

Contract Name: Upgrading of Seugha Simaghat Barbot Wagla Road (Dhurkot Rural Municipality Access Road)
Contract ID:RIDO-GUL-RB-W-NCB-16-2076/077
RAYAMAJHI-PTR Dhulikhel - Shrestha - Dev & Sayar Sunil Samir Singha- Bhubaneshwori
PE's Estimate Lumbini-Prakritik JV ANK-Mountain JV Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. PS- RAMECHHAP JV Pacific-Karna JV
SL. ADHIKARI JV Siddhratha J/V J.V J/V.
Item Name & Description
NO Official Rate Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
(NRs) Rate (14%)
Insurance of works, equipment, Contractor's
workmen and employees and Third party
1 Insurance against damage to other persons and 1 PS 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000 1160000
property.
Relocation of services (electrical pole, tap
2 stand water supply pipe lines etc ) all 1 PS 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 500569.44 0 500569.44
complete as per engineers instructions.
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) and
Personnel Protective Equipments (PPE) as per
3 1 PS 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000
Occupational Safety and Health Guideline
2017.
Provide Operate and maintain quality control
laboratory including equipment ,accessories
and consumables for both field testing
facilities and off site test with manpower along
4 with transportation facility for employer and 1 PS 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000
handover all laboratory equipments to office
after completion of project as per spec. as
instructed by Engineer
Provide and installation of project information
5 board with size of 1.8*1.2m as per 2 Nos. 20000 40000 10000 20000 30000 60000 50000 100000 37500 32250 64500 10000 20000 10000 20000 5000 10000 15000 30000 10000 20000
specification and instruction of Engineer.
Provide and maintain the road operable by
removing the debris and other obstruction with
6 traffic safety, control measures and temporary 1 LS 500000 500000 50000 50000 100000 100000 20000 20000 375000 322500 322500 50000 50000 500000 500000 40000 40000 100000 100000 200000 200000
diversions during construction period as
instructed by the Engineer.
Provision and maintenance of labour camps,
Engineers site office with required facilities
7 1 LS 600000 600000 50000 50000 100000 100000 50000 50000 375000 322500 322500 50000 50000 500000 500000 40000 40000 100000 100000 200000 200000
with safety and hygenic environment as
instructed by Engineer

Roadway , drain and Foundation excavation

8 in all type of soil and rock material including 39179.71 Cum 81.19 3181000.65 31 1214571.01 150 5876956.5 100 3917971 112 96.32 3773789.667 60 2350782.6 280 10970318.8 75 2938478.25 70 2742579.7 100 3917971
disposal of excavated material at approved
environmentally safe tipping sites.
Providing and laying of hand pack Stone
soling with 150 to 200 mm thick stones and
9 packing with smaller stone on prepared 1127.7 Cum 3581.51 4038868.83 3000 3383100 2000 2255400 2000 2255400 2500 2150 2424555 2000 2255400 2000 2255400 1200 1353240 1500 1691550 1500 1691550
surface as per specifications.

Providing and laying Stone Masonry work in

10 cement mortar 1:4 in structure including 110 5598.04 Cum 9935.29 55618150.83 7000 39186280 7000 39186280 6000 33588240 10000 8600 48143144 6800 38066672 8000 44784320 6200 34707848 6500 36387260 7000 39186280
mm dia 6 kgf HDPE pipe Weep Holes and
Pointing etc all complete as per specifications.
Providing and laying Plum concrete ( Boulder
mixed concrete) as per drawing and
11 specifications , 60% M 15 concrete and 40% 1600 Cum 11758.79 18814064 6500 10400000 7000 11200000 4500 7200000 12500 10750 17200000 8500 13600000 9500 15200000 9000 14400000 8500 13600000 8000 12800000
boulders/stones.
12 Supply and place concrete class M15/40. 1025.73 Cum 13649.39 14000588.8 11000 11283030 12000 12308760 10000 10257300 15000 12900 13231917 10000 10257300 11500 11795895 10000 10257300 9000 9231570 10000 10257300
Providing , Preparing and Installing form
13 work including necessary supports and 16000 Sqm 412.39 6598240 500 8000000 500 8000000 30 480000 125 107.5 1720000 250 4000000 500 8000000 300 4800000 350 5600000 100 1600000
removing after completion .
Providing and Laying RCC 450 mm dia NP3
Flush jointed hume pipe for culvert including
14 40 R.M. 9433.48 377339.2 10000 400000 6000 240000 7000 280000 7500 6450 258000 8000 320000 6500 260000 8000 320000 8000 320000 4500 180000
fixing with cement mortar 1:2 as per
specifications.
Providing and Laying RCC 600mm dia NP3
15 Flush jointed pipe for culvert including fixing 100 R.M. 11916.31 1191631 15000 1500000 8000 800000 10000 1000000 10000 8600 860000 10000 1000000 8500 850000 13000 1300000 10000 1000000 7000 700000
with cement mortar 1:2 as per specifications.
Providing and Laying RCC 900mm dia NP3
16 Flush jointed pipe for culvert including fixing 10 R.M. 21599.25 215992.5 20000 200000 11000 110000 20000 200000 25000 21500 215000 16000 160000 15000 150000 15000 150000 15000 150000 11000 110000
with cement
Providing mortar 1:2 aswoven
mechanically per specifications.
double twisted
crates / mattress including rolling, cutting
and with lacing wire and binding wire Heavy
zinc coated Hexagonal mesh type 100 mm x
120 mm, mesh wire 3 mm, selvage wire 3.9
mm, lacing wire 2.4 mm, assembling, placing
in position including stretching; forming
17 compartments; tying the sides and diaphragms 5884 Cum 4072.12 23960354.08 4000 23536000 4500 26478000 3500 20594000 7375 6342.5 37319270 3600 21182400 4200 24712800 3800 22359200 3850 22653400 4000 23536000
with binding wire in each mesh; tying with
bracing wires and tie wires; and tying down
the lid with providing and filling
stone/boulder in gabion boxes/mattress etc..
Including dressing, bedding, bonding all
complete.
Providing, laying and fixing of Geo-textile
18 2104 Sqm 101.32 213177.28 30 63120 100 210400 200 420800 125 107.5 226180 100 210400 80 168320 80 168320 80 168320 100 210400
(filter fabrics).
Providing suitable material and Back filling
behind abutment, wing wall , Retaining
19 9575 Cum 344.69 3300406.75 30 287250 100 957500 100 957500 125 107.5 1029312.5 50 478750 100 957500 50 478750 50 478750 200 1915000
Structures, return wall complete as per
specifications.
Providing and laying of Reinforced/ Pre-
stressed(Grade M25) cement concrete in super-
20 312.85 Cum 17205.96 5382884.59 15000 4692750 15000 4692750 16000 5005600 18750 16125 5044706.25 16000 5005600 16500 5162025 12000 3754200 14000 4379900 15000 4692750
structure with necessary form works, as per
drawing and Technical Specification.
 RAYAMAJHI-PTR Dhulikhel - Shrestha - Dev & Sayar Sunil Samir Singha- Bhubaneshwori
PE's Estimate Lumbini-Prakritik JV ANK-Mountain JV Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. PS- RAMECHHAP JV Pacific-Karna JV
SL. ADHIKARI JV Siddhratha J/V J.V J/V.
Item Name & Description
NO Official Rate Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
(NRs) Rate (14%)
Providing and laying , fitting and placing
21 HYSD bar reinforcement in sub-structure 27.84 Ton 123216.04 3430334.55 100000 2784000 100000 2784000 100000 2784000 125000 107500 2992800 95000 2644800 95000 2644800 100000 2784000 100000 2784000 110000 3062400
complete as per specifications.
Loosening, leveling and Compacting original
ground supporting embankment to facilitate
placement of first layer of embankment,
22 scarified to a depth of 150 mm, mixed with 78000 Sqm 17.76 1385280 15 1170000 20 1560000 30 2340000 50 43 3354000 20 1560000 40 3120000 30 2340000 20 1560000 25 1950000
water at OMC and then compacted by rolling
so as to achieve dry density as per
specifications.
Providing,laying, spreading, levelling,
watering of granular sub-base on prepared
surface, mixing at OMC, and compacting to
23 12900 Cum 2565.57 33095853 1800 23220000 1800 23220000 1000 12900000 1500 1290 16641000 1250 16125000 2300 29670000 1200 15480000 1000 12900000 1500 19350000
achieve the desired density, all complete as per
Drawing and Technical Specifications and
Engineer's Instructions.[Spec. cl. No: 1201]
Providing, laying, levelling Crusher Run
Macadam on a prepared surface, spreading
and mixing , watering and compacting to form
24 a layer of base course to achieve desired 11700 Cum 3567.17 41735889 4000 46800000 2500 29250000 2000 23400000 2125 1827.5 21381750 3200 37440000 3200 37440000 2700 31590000 2500 29250000 3000 35100000
density (max size 45mm) as per Drawing and
Technical Specifications and Engineer's
Instruction.[Spec. cl. No: 1204]
Prime Coat, with MC 30 / 70 by Mechanical
Means : Providing and applying prime coat
with Hot Bitumen ( including cutter) on
25 prepared surface of granular base including 65070 Ltr 118.09 7684116.3 110 7157700 100 6507000 90 5856300 125 107.5 6995025 120 7808400 115 7483050 110 7157700 105 6832350 110 7157700
cleaning of road surface and spraying by
mechanical means as per specification.
Providing and applying tack coat with hot
Bitumen By Mechanical Means at specified
26 rate on the prepared non-bituminous surfaces 159060 Ltr 106.22 16895353.2 110 17496600 100 15906000 90 14315400 125 107.5 17098950 120 19087200 115 18291900 110 17496600 105 16701300 110 17496600
including cleaning as per Technical Speciation
.
Providing and laying surface dressing as
wearing course in single coat using 19mm
nominal chipping size gravel of specified size
27 on a recently applied layer of bituminous 72300 Sqm 62.81 4541163 80 5784000 100 7230000 50 3615000 75 64.5 4663350 49 3542700 70 5061000 90 6507000 110 7953000 70 5061000
binder on prepared surface all complete as per
Drawing and Technical Specification and
Engineer's instructions. [Spec. cl. No: 1303]
Providing and laying surface dressing as
wearing course in single coat using 10 mm
nominal chipping size gravel of specified size
28 on a recently applied layer of bituminous 72300 Sqm 49.12 3551376 40 2892000 100 7230000 60 4338000 65 55.9 4041570 49 3542700 70 5061000 90 6507000 70 5061000 60 4338000
binder on prepared surface all complete as per
Drawing and Technical Specification and
Engineer's instructions. [Spec. cl. No: 1303]
Providing and mixing of Anti stripping agent
29 795.3 KG 398.75 317125.88 700 556710 500 397650 100 79530 815 700.9 557425.77 750 596475 450 357885 100 79530 500 397650 700 556710
as per Design/ direction of Engineer
Providing and mixing of Bitumen cutter as
30 9543.6 Ltr 110.4 1053613.44 125 1192950 100 954360 120 1145232 150 129 1231124.4 120 1145232 115 1097514 120 1145232 110 1049796 110 1049796
per design / direction of Engineer
Direct Seedling on side: Broadcasting grass
31 seeds on slopes ; Seedling rate 25 gm per 2000 Sqm 36.06 72120 2 4000 100 200000 40 80000 50 43 86000 10 20000 500 1000000 50 100000 50 100000 50 100000
sqm.
Sowing shrubs or tree seeds on all slopes at 25
cm intervals, including digging planting holes
32 1481.42 Sqm 51.11 75715.38 2 2962.84 100 148142 40 59256.8 75 64.5 95551.59 20 29628.4 500 740710 100 148142 100 148142 40 59256.8
to 5 cm depth and covering with soil. Two
seeds per planting hole.
Preparation and planting of live pegs selected
species (eg asuro, namdiphul, simali) of
33 minimum length to 0.5m into soft debris. Pegs 800 RM 254.21 203368 5 4000 300 240000 220 176000 160 137.6 110080 30 24000 250 200000 100 80000 200 160000 40 32000
spaced at 5 c to c within rows, and interoven
with vegetation.
Providing, furnishing and laying of live sods
of perennial turf forming grass on
embankment slope, verges or other locations
34 800 Sqm 357.72 286176 5 4000 100 80000 100 80000 90 77.4 61920 10 8000 350 280000 100 80000 200 160000 40 32000
shown on the drawing or as directed by the
Engineer including preparation of ground,
fetching of sords and watering.
Planting rooted grass slips on the slopes >
60 degree including preparation of slips on
site a maximum of 5 cm depth with metal rod
35 or operation iclude diggig, planting hole to 445.1 Sqm 2240.38 997193.14 5 2225.5 100 44510 250 111275 75 64.5 28708.95 25 11127.5 400 178040 100 44510 200 89020 50 22255
hardwood peg, depending on the nature of the
soil.
Providing and installation of 150 mm *
150 mm 1. 5 m long delineators (road
way indicators, hazard markers, object
markers), 80-100 cm high above ground
36 level, painted black and white in 20 cm 500 Nos. 1271.76 635880 2000 1000000 2000 1000000 3000 1500000 1875 1612.5 806250 1200 600000 4000 2000000 2000 1000000 1500 750000 3000 1500000
wide strips, buried or pressed into the
ground and conforming to the drawings
and Technical Specifications.
 RAYAMAJHI-PTR Dhulikhel - Shrestha - Dev & Sayar Sunil Samir Singha- Bhubaneshwori
PE's Estimate Lumbini-Prakritik JV ANK-Mountain JV Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. PS- RAMECHHAP JV Pacific-Karna JV
SL. ADHIKARI JV Siddhratha J/V J.V J/V.
Item Name & Description
NO Official Rate Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
(NRs) Rate (14%)
Supplying and erecting traffic sign in place
including 50mm dia. Steel tube, 2mm. thick
steel plate, cement concrete, painting, writing
37 and supporting steel angle nut and bolt etc. 30 Nos. 4890.42 146712.6 2500 75000 20000 600000 5000 150000 12500 10750 322500 2800 84000 4000 120000 1500 45000 5000 150000 3000 90000
completea) 60cm. Dia. Circular, 60cm.
equilateral traingle and 60cm.x 45cm.
rectangular shaped sign (single post).
Supplying and fixing in place M20/20 RCC
38 Slab for drain cover size (1.00m X 0.3m X 200 Nos. 1068.36 213672 1500 300000 1500 300000 4000 800000 2125 1827.5 365500 1100 220000 2000 400000 2000 400000 5000 1000000 3000 600000
0.150 m) as per drawings and specification
Providing and erecting a "W" metal
beam crash barrier comprising of 3 mm
thick corrugated sheet metal beam rail, 70 cm
above road/ground level, fixed on ISMC
series channel vertical post, 150 x 75 x 5 mm
39 spaced 2 m center to center, 1.8 m high, 1.1 500 R.M 6096.04 3048020 7000 3500000 1500 750000 5000 2500000 8125 6987.5 3493750 3000 1500000 2000 1000000 6000 3000000 7000 3500000 7000 3500000
m below ground/road level metal beam rail
to be fixed on the vertical post with a spacer
of channel section 150 x 75 x 5 mm, 330
mm long with paintingetc all complete as
per Drawing and Technical Specifications.
Supplying and placing R.C.C. kilometer post
including excavation, back filling, painting
40 and writing etc. all complete as per 12 Nos. 2601.93 31223.16 2000 24000 15000 180000 4000 48000 9375 8062.5 96750 1200 14400 5000 60000 2000 24000 10000 120000 5000 60000
specification a) Standard KM post placed at
each kilometer.
Supplying and placing R.C.C. kilometer post
including excavation, back filling, painting
and writing etc. all complete as per
41 specification 3 Nos. 5985.66 17956.98 3000 9000 15000 45000 5000 15000 12500 10750 32250 1200 3600 5000 15000 2000 6000 10000 30000 7000 21000
b) Bigger kilometer post (placed at each 5
km.)
42 Backhoe Loader 142 Hrs. 2820.46 400505.32 2500 355000 2000 284000 2500 355000 3125 2687.5 381625 1600 227200 2000 284000 2000 284000 100 14200 1500 213000
43 Unskilled Labor 151 Md 680 102680 500 75500 700 105700 1600 241600 1000 860 129860 700 105700 1200 181200 800 120800 100 15100 600 90600
Total Price (Without VAT and PS) 257954025.5 218675749.35 211592408.50 163216404.80 217123115.1 195347467.5 242972677.80 193496850.25 189358887.7 202659568.8
VAT (13%) 33534023.31 28427847.42 27507013.11 21218132.62 28226004.97 25395170.78 31586448.11 25154590.53 24616655.4 26345743.94
Total Price (With VAT and PS) 294398618.21 250014166.21 242009991.05 187345106.86 248259689.53 223653207.72 277469695.35 221562010.22 216886112.54 231915882.18
Below or Above 44384452.00 52388627.16 107053511.35 46138928.68 70745410.49 16928922.86 72836607.99 77512505.67 62482736.03
Percentage Below or above (%) 15.08% 17.80% 36.36% 15.67% 24.03% 5.75% 24.74% 26.33% 21.22%
Required Performance Security 12613037.95 16214916.77 40814114.65 13402552.45 24475469.27 258049.8299 25416508.14 27520662.1 20757265.76
Rank 8 6 1 7 4 9 3 2 5