Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Chunfa Lin, Yuqiang Han, Chunhuan Guo, Yunpeng Chang, Xiaoxiao Han, Lin Lan,
Fengchun Jiang
PII: S0925-8388(17)32044-3
DOI: 10.1016/j.jallcom.2017.06.057
Reference: JALCOM 42125
Please cite this article as: C. Lin, Y. Han, C. Guo, Y. Chang, X. Han, L. Lan, F. Jiang, Synthesis and
mechanical properties of novel Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) ceramic-fiber-reinforced metal-intermetallic-laminated
(CFR-MIL) composites, Journal of Alloys and Compounds (2017), doi: 10.1016/j.jallcom.2017.06.057.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
composites
PT
Chunfa Lin a, Yuqiang Han a, Chunhuan Guo a,*, Yunpeng Chang a, Xiaoxiao Han a, Lin Lan b,
RI
a
Key Laboratory of Superlight Materials & Surface Technology, Ministry of Education,
SC
Harbin 150001, PR China
b
College of Materials, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, PR China.
U
* Corresponding author: fengchunjiang@hrbeu.edu.cn, +86-13946184358
AN
guochunhuan@hrbeu.edu.cn, +86-18804631852
M
Abstract
D
(CFR-MIL) composites were successfully fabricated by vacuum hot pressing using titanium foils,
aluminum foils and SiC ceramic fibers. The synthesized Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) composite showed a
EP
fiber as reinforcement) and Ti layers. In addition, reaction annealing technique was employed to
AC
improve the interfacial performance of SiC fiber with Al3Ti matrix. The microstructure evolution
of the laminated composite during hot-pressing and annealing was experimentally characterized
using scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive spectroscopy. The formation
the Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite and its components were investigated by tensile and
1
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
nanoindentation tests. The results indicated that Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite exhibited
superior mechanical properties compared to Ti-Al3Ti, which was likely attributed to the
introduction of SiC fiber. The failure mechanism of CFR-MIL composite was the combined
fracture behaviors of ductile fracture of Ti, brittle fracture of Al3Ti and fiber debonding, pullout
PT
and breakage of SiC.
RI
Keywords: SiC ceramic fiber; metal intermetallic laminated composite; reaction annealing;
SC
1. Introduction
U
Recently, inspired from the structure of shell with the interactive brittle inorganic
AN
compounds layers and ductile organic compounds layers, laminated composites were
M
designed and produced to obtain specific layered structures with desirable properties [1-3].
This bionic design is based on energy dissipation principle and the purpose is to minimize the
D
effect of raw micro-cracks on the mechanical properties of the materials [4]. The unique
TE
laminated composites comprised of alternating ductile and brittle layers have received
EP
metal layers were incorporated into the brittle intermetallic compounds to fabricated
C
AC
Metal-Intermetallic Laminated (MIL) composites, such as Ti-Al [5-8], Fe-Al [9-11], Ni-Al
[12,13] systems. In MIL composites, the intermetallic compounds provides strength and creep
resistance at elevated temperature and the ductile metal enhances the toughness as a layer
metal-intermetallic laminated composite, the intermetallic Al3Ti possesses low density, high
specific strength, high specific stiffness, high specific melting point and excellent oxidation
2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
resistance at elevated temperatures and it is toughened by the layers of ductile metal Ti. It is
such a unique laminated structure that the Ti-Al3Ti system offers an excellent combination of
specific strength, toughness and stiffness for structural applications in aerospace, automotive
PT
To thoroughly understand the relationships of processing, structure and property of
RI
metal-intermetallic laminated composites, the microstructure evolution, damage evolution,
SC
investigated via quasi-static and dynamic compression tests, tension tests, bending tests and
U
ballistics tests as well as experimental-numerical hybrid method [15-19]. The results revealed
AN
that the fracture toughness of the laminated composite exhibits more than an order of
due to the addition of ductile Ti phase in the form of continuous layers. Furthermore, the
D
resistance to fatigue crack propagation of the MIL composites increases with increasing
TE
primarily to uncracked ductile Ti layers that bridge the crack wake and shield the crack tip
EP
from far-field loading. In addition, the MIL composites have excellent damage tolerance due
C
to the multiple energy-absorbing mechanism. All the studies mentioned above indicated that
AC
this kind of laminated composites show excellent mechanical properties for being used in the
aerospace field.
[20-22]. In recent years, combined the aforementioned MIL composites and FR-IMCs, the
3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
intermetallic compounds as a whole part [23,24]. In these composites, the properties were
found to be superior than that of the Ti-intermetallic multi-layered composite or the SiC
PT
fiber-reinforced Ti-matrix composite. In addition, another ceramic fibrous-layer reinforced
RI
MIL composite, Ti-Al3Ti-Al2O3-Al, was fabricated by reactive foil sintering using “metpreg”
tapes (50% Al2O3 fiber volume in Al metal matrix) [25]. In this fibrous-layer reinforced
SC
laminated composite, the fibers were oriented in 0° and 90° layers with an attempt to enhance
U
the toughness of the MIL composite. The results demonstrated that Al2O3 ceramic fiber layer
AN
arrested cracks formed in the brittle Al3Ti phase and had a considerable toughening effect.
Nevertheless, there is no reported work on introducing SiC fibers into intermetallic layer to
M
In this paper, a novel metal foil metallurgical method involving hot pressing and reaction
TE
into the laminates with the purpose of improving the comprehensive performances of the
C
composites were investigated systematically. This work also aims to evaluate the room
2. Experimental procedures
100 mm × 0.5 mm), commercial pure aluminum foils (100 mm × 100 mm × 0.5 mm) and SiC
fibers (fiber diameter 10-15 µm) were used as raw materials in this work. It should be pointed
out the as-received SiC fibers were packed into bunches (every 500 single item) originally.
Before utilization, the fibers had been pretreated at 600 ºC for 0.5 h to remove the colloidal
PT
materials on the surface, thus the fibers packed together were divided into single ones. Before
RI
sintering, the foils were polished with silicon carbide papers to remove surface oxide layers.
Then the foils and fibers were cleaned in water bath using ultrasonic cleaning machine for 20
SC
min, rinsed in alcohol and then dried rapidly. All these procedures were well prepared for
U
fabricating the laminated composite.
AN
Fig. 1 shows the preparation procedure of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite. The
metal foils were alternately stacked with SiC fibers arranged in the midst of Ti-6Al-4V and Al
M
foils. The top and bottom layers of the stack were both Ti-6Al-4V foils, and hereafter Ti refers
D
to Ti alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) throughout this paper. The SiC fiber was fixed on the surface of metal
TE
foils by the mean of adhering both end of the fiber to the edge of the foils using double
sided sticky tape. The stacked Ti/SiCf/Al foils were sintered in a vacuum hot pressing furnace
EP
(ZRY-60-30) with a vacuum of ~10-3 Pa to allow them to react with each other under
C
appropriate processing parameters that include temperature, pressure, and time. The initial
AC
pressure applied on the stacked Ti/SiCf/Al foils was 5 MPa that was higher than that normally
used in preparation, such that the metal foils and fibers can compact. The temperature firstly
heated to 600 ℃ and held for 30 min. Then the temperature increased to 630 ℃ at a heating
rate of 1 ℃/min and kept for 10 min, while the pressure reduced to 1.5 MPa in this
temperature level. The temperature was then raised to 660 ℃ and held for 5 h. During this
5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
process, in order to avoid the expulsion of molten Al, the pressure nearly dropped to zero
along with the liquid-solid reaction occurred. When the aluminum layers have been
completely consumed, the pressure increased to 3 MPa. Finally, the sample was
PT
Ti-Al3Ti laminated composite without fiber reinforcement was also fabricated using the same
RI
method for making a comparison with Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti). Both the laminated composites with
and without SiC fiber have the similar titanium volume fraction of ~30%. It should be pointed
SC
out that it is hard to accurately calculate the volume fraction of SiC fiber ( f SiC ) in the
U
CFR-MIL composites owing to the small diameter of SiC fibers. Here, it is estimated
AN
approximately using the initial diameter and number of SiC fiber and calculated by the
following equation:
M
S SiC ⋅ π ⋅ (rSiC ) 2
f SiC = (1)
( STi ⋅ tTi + S FRI ⋅ t FRI ) ⋅ WL
D
Where the SSiC, STi and SFRI are the number of SiC fibers, Ti layers and SiCf/Al3Ti
TE
fiber-reinforced-intermetallic (FRI) composite layers, respectively; the tTi, tFRI, WL and rSiC are
EP
the thickness of Ti and FRI layer, the width of the laminates and the radius of SiC fiber,
respectively. The volume fraction of SiC fiber in the CFR-MIL composites calculated using
C
AC
6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of fabrication and post-heat treatment process of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti)
laminated composite.
The as-fabricated Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminates prepared in the current study was comprised
of Ti layers and SiC fiber reinforced Al3Ti matrix composite layers (SiCf/Al3Ti). Subsequently,
annealing treatment at 950 ℃ for 3 hours was performed to the as-fabricated laminates. Thus,
PT
the bonding of SiC fibers with intermetallic Al3Ti matrix could be improved due to the
RI
metallurgical interfacial reaction occurred in the process of annealing.
SC
Metallographic specimens were cut from the as-fabricated and as-annealed
U
Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminates using an electrical discharge machining (EDM). The polished
AN
surface was perpendicular to the fiber orientation. The cross section was prepared by grinding
step by step with 800, 1000, 1500, 2000, 3000 grit silicon carbide papers in order, polishing
M
with abrasive finishing machine. The microstructure of interfacial reaction zone was observed
D
by HITACHI SU-70 Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM), and the elements content was
TE
detected with XFlash Detector 6|60 energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). The phases in
laminated composites were identified by X’Pert PRO X-ray diffractometer (XRD). The X-ray
EP
2.3 Nanoindentation
AC
tests were conducted at room temperature. Cross-sectional samples were polished and
prepared for indentation. During the indentation, the various loads were applied to different
7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
zone for obtaining the limited maximum displacements that 1500 nm for Ti and Al3Ti layers
and 500 nm for SiC fiber, respectively. The hardness and Young’s modulus were determined
from the load-penetration results using Oliver-Pharr analysis. Additionally, Vickers hardness
tests were also performed to the layers and the fibers for evaluating the availability of
PT
nanohardness.
RI
2.4 Tensile tests
SC
were carried out on Instron 5500R load frame with a constant loading rate of 0.5 mm/min at
U
room temperature. The tensile loading was parallel to the SiC fiber orientation for both the
AN
as-fabricated and the as-annealed Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite. During the tensile test,
an extensometer was used to monitor the deformation of the sample. Bone-like tensile
M
specimens with a gauge of 65 mm (length) × 12.3 mm (width) × 3.6 mm (thickness) were cut
D
from the laminated composite plates using electrical discharge machining. Before testing, the
TE
samples were ground from 600 to 2000 grit, and then carefully polished. The tensile
stress-strain curves were plotted using experimental engineering stress and strain data. The
EP
tensile strength and elongation at fracture were achieved from the experimental stress-strain
C
curves. After tests, the fracture surfaces of tensile specimens were observed by SEM.
AC
process of hot pressing and reaction annealing. As indicated in Fig. 2a, it can be seen that the
8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
fiber-reinforced-intermetallic (FRI) composite layer. The SiC fibers distribute along the
central section of the SiCf/Al3Ti composite layers. Pure Al foils were completely consumed
and transformed into Al3Ti phases, which was determined by the result of XRD (see Fig. 3a),
PT
in which no residual Al phase was detected by XRD patterns. When Al was exhausted, the
RI
residual aluminum oxide connected together at the center of the SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer
and the micro-pores appeared. Thus, discontinuous “center line” formed within the composite
SC
layer, which was similar to Ti-Al3Ti laminated composite [26]. Whereas, a portion of Ti was
U
remained after hot pressing. In addition, it is clear that the interface between SiCf/Al3Ti
AN
composite layer and Ti layer is rather compact and well-bonded, and none of other
intermetallic compounds form (see Fig. 2b). The characteristics of interfacial zone between
M
fiber reinforcement and intermetallic matrix are shown in Fig. 2c. The interfacial reaction
D
products are presumed to be TiC and TiSi2, which is in accordance with the result of XRD
TE
shown in Fig. 3a. It is also noted that the circle interface around SiC fiber is not intact. There
are interstices and gaps in some region of the interface. Therefore, the experimental facts
EP
indicate that the bonding between fiber and intermetallic is the mixture of the metallurgical
C
9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Fig. 2 Representative SEM images of microstructure of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) composites: (a), (b) and (c)
show the layered structure, the interlamination interface and the fiber/matrix interface of the
as-fabricated composite, respectively; (d), (e) and (f) show the SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer, the
M
metallurgical bonding of SiC fiber with Al3Ti and the interaction product layer between Ti layer
and Al3Ti layer in as-annealed laminates. The schematic diagram for EDS point scanning around
the interfacial zone was indicated in (e) and (f).
D
Subsequently, the following annealing at 950 ℃ for 3 hours with no pressure was carried
TE
out in heat treatment furnace with the purpose of improving the bonding strength of
in Figs. 2d-2f. The corresponding chemical composition of elements detected by EDS point
C
scan are given in Table 1. Conspicuously, interfacial reaction occurred between SiC fiber and
AC
Al3Ti matrix, and thus the fiber is well-bonded metallurgically with the matrix, as is shown in
Fig. 2e. In addition, a reaction product layer with the average thickness of ~1 µm forms
surrounding the SiC fiber. The reaction product layer is comprised of dark gray phases with
the respective chemical compositions of 11.4 at. % Si-31.0 at. % C-45.4 at. % Al-12.2 at. %
Ti according to EDS point scan, corresponding to the complex compounds, including TiC,
10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
TiSi2, Ti2AlC and Al4SiC4 phases). XRD patterns also give evidence for the results, as
indicated in Fig. 3b. Moreover, interfacial product layer (~8 µm) between SiCf/Al3Ti
composite layer and Ti layer is obviously observed, which contains two different phase: white
phases and light gray phases (see Fig. 2f) with the respective compositions of 61.1 at. %
PT
Al-34.0 at. % Ti-4.9 at. % V and 47.5 at. % Al-49.9 at. % Ti-2.6 at. % V based on EDS point
RI
scan, which corresponds to TiAl2 phases and TiAl phases. This is in consistence with the
SC
bonding are achieved through hot pressing and reaction annealing.
U
AN
M
D
TE
Fig. 3 X-ray patterns of the Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) composites (a) without and (b) with annealing
EP
treatment.
Table 1 Typical chemical compositions of each layer and phase detected by EDS
Composition (at. %)
Number Possible phases
C
Si C Al Ti V
Spectrum 1 47.6 51.8 0.4 0.2 0 SiC
AC
11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
series of reaction-diffusion process during fabrication and heat treatment. After vacuum hot
pressing, the Metal/FRI (M/FRI) laminated structure formed containing alternating metal
PT
layers and fiber-reinforced intermetallic compounds layer. The formation mechanism of this
RI
unique laminated microstructure is similar with that of Ti-Al3Ti metal-intermetallic laminated
SC
(MIL) composite [27]. Then, owing to the reaction annealing, further interfacial reactions
occurred between Al3Ti and Ti, as well as Al3Ti and SiC. This interaction is a diffusion
U
behavior accompanied by the formation and transformation of a series of Titanium-Aluminum
AN
intermetallic compounds and some other binary or ternary compounds [28-30]. Fig. 4 shows
M
12
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Fig. 4 Schematics of the synthesis mechanism of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite: (a) First
stage, showing the interdiffusion of layers during fabrication; (b) Second stage, indicating the
formation of M/FRI laminated structure consisting of newly-formed SiCf /Al3Ti composite layer
and remained Ti layer; (c) Third stage, displaying the interaction between individual layer or SiC
and Al3Ti during anneal; (d) Fourth stage, exhibiting the final microstructure of Ti-(SiCf /Al3Ti)
laminated composite with good interfacial bonding after heat treating process.
First, during hot pressing, the interdiffusion of Ti and Al in solid Ti layer and the mixture
PT
layer (including liquid Al, SiC fiber and aluminum oxides) occurred and thus Al3Ti layer
RI
formed at the interface between the solid Ti layer and the liquid Al layer. In the composite, the
intermetallic Al3Ti was the solely newly-formed intermetallic compound because Al3Ti was
SC
thermodynamically and kinetically favored over the formation of other titanium aluminides
U
due to this low synthesis temperature (660 ℃) [27]. It is noteworthy that as the hot pressing
AN
time increased, the thickness of remnant mixture layer became thinner due to the outward
diffusion of Al atoms within the mixture layer and the compressive stress originated from the
M
thickening of Al3Ti layer. Thereby, SiC fiber and aluminum oxides began to concentrate
D
towards the center of mixture layer. Additionally, Al3Ti layer grew much faster towards the Al
TE
layer than that towards the Ti layer because of the higher diffusion of Al in Al3Ti than that of
Ti (the Kirkendall effect [31]). Thus, the as-fabricated laminates were composed of alternating
EP
remained Ti layers and SiCf/Al3Ti composite layers. The fiber distributed along the “center
C
line”, which formed as a result of aluminum oxides and voids. Furthermore, the results of
AC
EDS line scan are shown in Figs. 5a and 5b. The content fluctuation trends of reaction
elements across the interface between Ti layer and SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer reflect the
characteristics of element diffusion. A trace amount of TiC and TiSi2 formed between SiC
fiber and Al3Ti matrix, which was demonstrated by the results of XRD (Fig. 3a). Nevertheless,
vacancies formed at the interface between SiC and Al3Ti because of the diverse diffusion rates
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Fig. 5 SEM images (a) and (c) of the metal/intermetallic interfacial zones in the as-fabricated and
M
as-annealed Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) composite, respectively and the corresponding EDS line scan results (b)
and (d) obtained along the red arrow.
As the anneal treatment proceeded, the Al atoms in SiCf /Al3Ti composite layer and Ti
D
TE
atoms in Ti layer continued to diffuse, leading to the formation of TiAl intermetallic layer at
the Ti/Al3Ti interface, as shown in Fig. 5c. Subsequently, ascribing to the decomposition of
EP
TiAl, island-like Al2Ti phase nucleated within TiAl phase (see details in Fig. 5c). Fig. 5d
shows the identical result with the content fluctuation trends of Ti and Al across the interfacial
C
AC
reaction product layer between Ti and Al3Ti in the as-annealed laminates. Meanwhile, more
reaction products (Ti2AlC and Al4SiC4) formed at the interfacial zone surrounding SiC fiber
and good interfacial bonding of the fiber with the matrix was achieved. The EDS line analysis
results of the interfacial zone between SiC fiber and Al3Ti matrix are presented in Figs. 6b and
6d. The content fluctuation of reactive elements reflect the characteristics of downhill
diffusion at the interfacial reaction product layer. The element C was not detected accurately
14
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
by EDS line analysis, which was consistent with the literature [32]. The results of EDS point
scan analysis (as shown in Table 1) indicate that C atoms diffused authentically from SiC
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
Fig. 6 SEM images (a) and (c) of the fiber/intermetallic interfacial zones in the as-annealed
Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) composite and the corresponding EDS line scan results (b) and (d) obtained along
TE
Therefore, interfacial behavior of the layers involved three steps: 1) formation of Al3Ti
EP
phase at the interface between Ti and Al; 2) generation of intermetallic TiAl phase; 3)
C
nucleation of island-like Al2Ti phase within TiAl layer. The following reactions may occur
AC
Ti + 3 Al → Al3Ti (2)
Fiber/matrix interfacial behavior involved two steps: 1) formation of TiC and TiSi2 phases
during fabrication; 2) formation of Ti2AlC and Al4SiC4 phases during reaction annealing.
15
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
According to the above results and analysis, the following reactions may occur between SiC
and Ti or Al3Ti:
SiC → Si + C (5)
Ti + C → TiC (6)
PT
Ti + Si → TiSi2 (7)
RI
3.3 Nanoindentation studies
SC
Fig. 7 shows the typical load-penetration curves and the derived nanohardness and
Young’ modulus for different phases (Ti, Al3Ti and SiC) of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated
U
AN
composite. The results obtained from nanoindentation and traditional Vickers hardness tests in
the present work are summarized in Table 2. It is noted that the dimensionless microhardness
M
values (HV) were switched to the unit of GPa according to Eq. (9) [33]:
(9)
TE
Where, HGPa and HV are the transferred hardness value and traditional Vickers hardness value,
respectively. It is evident that the nanohardness of Ti (Ti-6Al-4V, ~4.2 GPa), Al3Ti (~7.5 GPa)
EP
and SiC (~28 GPa) phases is close to those obtained from the Vickers method. It is also noted
C
that the nanohardness values show good consistency with other published works [34-36], as
AC
can be seen in Table 2. Additionally, the fiber (SiC) and the layers (Ti and Al3Ti) exhibit the
approximate elastic modulus values compared to the results of the previously reported works
(nanohardness and elastic modulus) derived from nanoindentation tests are characterized
properly and accurately. Moreover, the results shows that SiC fiber has higher elastic modulus
16
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
and hardness than Ti and Al3Ti. Besides, the density of SiC fiber is lower than that of the
density and higher modulus in comparison with Ti-Al3Ti MIL composites without fiber
reinforcement. These experimental facts reveals that SiC fiber is an appropriate reinforcement
PT
for designing intermetallic matrix composites to improve their mechanical and physical
RI
properties.
U SC
AN
Fig. 7 (a) Schematic of load-penetration depth curves and (b) average Young’s modulus and
M
Table 2 Comparison of mechanical properties of metal Ti, intermetallic Al3Ti and ceramic SiC
D
SiC fiber (in laminates) 28.4 ± 0.4 25.6 ± 5.3 225 ± 4 This work
SiC fiber (as-received state) - - 236 This work
Ti-6Al-4V - 3.7 - [34]
C
Al3Ti+0.3%Al - 6.0 -
[36]
Al3Ti - - 216
Fig. 8a shows the representative tensile stress-strain curves of the as-fabricated and
be seen that all the laminated composites show a two-stage tensile characteristics consisting
17
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
of an initial linear region, followed by a non-linear yield stage up to the ultimate tensile
strength (σUTS), and then an obvious plastic deformation region before fracture. While the
as-fabricated CFR-MIL composite exhibits a sudden light drop of stress at the end of yield
stage, as indicated in Fig. 8a. This is credited to the debonding behavior between SiC fiber
PT
and Al3Ti matrix due to the relatively poor bond of the fiber with the matrix. It is noteworthy
RI
that the stress of the as-fabricated CFR-MIL composite for the plastic deformation region is
higher than the corresponding one of Ti-Al3Ti MIL composite. This deformation region before
SC
failure is mainly attributed to the elongated ductile Ti layers and the incompletely ruptured
U
SiCf/Al3Ti composite layers that possess numerous micro-cracks.
AN
M
D
TE
EP
Fig. 8 (a) Tensile stress-strain curves of Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) CFR-MIL and Ti-Al3Ti MIL composite; (b)
showing the tensile properties of the laminated composites.
Fig. 8b illustrates the histograms of ultimate tensile strength (σUTS) and elongation at
C
AC
fracture of the MIL and the CFR-MIL composites in the present work. The mechanical
properties of both the MIL and the CFR-MIL composites obtained from room temperature tensile
tests are also summarized in Table 3. Besides, some reported results of Ti-intermetallic layered
composites elsewhere [23,24,37,38] are also listed in Table 3. It is noted that the ceramic or
(strength and ductility) than those of the Ti-intermetallic laminates, including strength and
18
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
ductility. In addition, it can be clearly seen that compared to Ti-Al3Ti laminated composite
without fiber reinforcement, the σUTS and the elongation of the as-fabricated Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti)
laminated composite have increased by 22% and 7%, respectively. The increase is ascribed to
the debonding, pullout and fracture of SiC fiber during the deformation process of CFR-MIL
PT
samples. The results indicate that the strength of the CFR-MIL composite is significantly
RI
enhanced while improving the ductility because of the added fiber reinforcement. In light of
this, strategy of the CFR-MIL composite could provide a feasible approach for solving the
SC
inversion problem of strength and ductility, which was also investigated elsewhere [38,39].
U
Moreover, the as-annealed Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composites exhibit slight enhancement
AN
of strength and ductility in comparison with the as-fabricated composite. It is believed that
owing to the good interfacial bond between the fiber and the matrix, the load was effectively
M
transferred from the matrix to the fiber that possessed high tensile strength. Hence, more
D
energy was necessary to cause the rupture of the fiber reinforced composite, and then strength
TE
improved.
EP
Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti)
HP + Reaction annealed 471 ± 13 4.6 ± 0.3 This work
(SiCf/Ti)-intermetallic 610 4.2 [23]
Ti-intermetallic 404 4.3 [24]
HP
Ti-Al3Ti 327 3.6
394 4.3 [37]
Ti-(Al2O3f/Al3Ti)
HP + Hot isostatic pressed 434 4.8
Ti-(NiTif/Al3Ti) HP 613 4.6 [38]
fracture surfaces of the tested samples were observed via scanning electron microscope (SEM)
19
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
in SE mode for both the as-fabricated and the as-annealed CFR-MIL composites. The typical
fracture characteristics observed from the overall fractured sample surface are shown in Figs.
9a and 10a. It can be seen that the fracture surfaces of the laminates are rather rough,
implying tortuous crack propagation paths. The fracture are obviously divided into two
PT
individual layers: rough Ti layer and fragmented SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer. When
RI
macro-strain reached the maximum tolerance, micro-cracks would be formed in the brittle
SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer and propagated to the interfaces between SiCf/Al3Ti composite
SC
layer and Ti layer. Afterward, the debonding or delamination between Ti layer and the
U
fiber-reinforced Al3Ti layer occurred due to the effect of the ductile Ti layer [18,19]. This
AN
crack deflection and blunting could delay the premature fracture of the SiCf/Al3Ti composite
layer, effectively improving the elongation of SiCf/Al3Ti composite layer. Ultimately, the
M
brittle cracks were mainly distributed in the brittle composite layer, which revealed an
D
Figs. 9b and 9c show the fracture surface morphologies of the fractured Ti layer and
Fig.9b that the surface of fractured Ti exhibits obvious plastic deformation with numerous
C
dimples, which contains the formation, growth and coalescence of micro-voids in the process
AC
of deformation and fracture, namely micro-void coalescence fracture mode. Further fracture
observations of Ti in the as-annealed CFR-MIL composite present the similar ductile fracture
(Fig. 10b). The plastic deformation plays an important role in the tensile behavior of
Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite with and without annealing treatment. Whereas, the
20
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
brittle fracture with different fracture modes. As shown in Fig. 9b, the near-interfacial
cracking is observed in the brittle phase, which is similar with the previous work [18]. As can
be seen in Fig. 9c, in terms of the as-fabricated composite, the major fracture mode of the
PT
but it only take a relatively small portion compared to the intergranular. Adharapurapu et al.
RI
[19] also showed the similar results in the fatigue fracture surfaces of Ti-Al3Ti MIL
SC
as-annealed composite, indicating the typical transgranular cleavage fracture mode, as
U
indicated in Fig. 10c. This is because the crack preferred to propagate within Al3Ti grains due
AN
to the stress concentration at grain boundaries. Therefore, transgranular cleavage fracture is
the major failure mode, which is consistent with intermetallic Ti3Al reported in the previous
M
literature [40,41].
D
As shown in Fig. 9d, debonding, pullout and breakage behavior of SiC fibers are found
TE
in the as-fabricated composite, which can improve the properties of the fiber reinforced
extension. However, fiber fracture is the main failure mechanism in the as-annealed
C
composite and the form of fiber pullout is not found (see details in Fig. 10d). This implies that
AC
the excessive interface bonding strength of the fiber with the matrix may limit the
enhancement effect of the fiber reinforcement, which is in accordance with that reported in
literature [42]. The fiber reinforcement plays a key role in increasing the ductility and strength
21
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Fig. 9 The typical fracture characteristics observed from the fractured specimen surface of the
as-fabricated Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite: (a) the overall fracture morphology; (b) Ti
M
layers; (c) intermetallic Al3Ti; (d) indicating the fracture feature of SiCf/Al3Ti composite.
D
TE
C EP
AC
Fig. 10 The typical fracture characteristics of the as-annealed Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite:
22
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
(a) the overall fracture morphology; (b) Ti layers and Al3Ti layers; (c) intermetallic Al3Ti; (d)
SiCf/Al3Ti composite.
tensile strength and ductility, which is attributed to: (i) The intrinsic high tensile strength and
superior ductility of Ti layer have a significant effect on the improvement of the ductility and
PT
strength for the laminated composite; (ii) SiC fiber can increase the resistance to crack
RI
propagation by fiber pullout and breakage, which improves the tensile strength effectively; (iii)
Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composites show the multi-layered structure, which can effectively
SC
redistribute stress and inhibit strain localization by load transferring to adjacent layers. Thus,
U
the formation of micro-cracks will be postponed and the extra deformation capacity is
AN
imparted by the laminated structure, as reported in the references [43-45]. Therefore, both the
laminated structure and the fiber reinforcement have considerable contribution to the ductility
M
4. Conclusions
TE
(CFR-MIL) composite was successfully fabricated using vacuum hot pressing and heat treated
C
properties and fracture behavior of the CFR-MIL composite were investigated systematically.
The principal conclusions drawn from the current work are summarized as the following:
(1) The feasible approach has been successfully explored to fabricate Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti)
23
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
(2) Interaction between SiC fiber and Al3Ti matrix occurred during annealing treatment
and good interfacial bonding was achieved between the fiber and the Al3Ti. Thus the
PT
(3) Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) CFR-MIL composite showed a good combination of low density and
RI
high modulus, which indicated that SiC fiber was a candidate of reinforcement for Al3Ti
SC
composites having enhanced mechanical properties.
U
(4) The Ti-(SiCf/Al3Ti) laminated composite exhibited superior ductility and strength
AN
compared to Ti-Al3Ti MIL composite, showing a significantly toughening and strengthening
effect of SiC fiber on the CFR-MIL composite. This was because the fiber debonding, pullout
M
and breakage absorbed fracture energy and delayed the premature fracture of Al3Ti matrix.
D
Acknowledgements
TE
The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial supports of this study by the National
EP
Technology Innovation Fund Project (SAST2016052) and the Fundamental Research funds
AC
References
[1] R.O. Ritchie. The conflicts between strength and toughness. Nature Materials 2011,
10(11):817-22.
24
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[3] W.J. Clegg, K. Kendall, N.M. Alford, T.W. Button, J.D. Birchall. A simple Way to Make
PT
of a novel fiber/metal laminates. Materials Science & Engineering A 2010,
RI
527(18-19):4920-4925.
[5] D.J. Harach, K.S. Vecchio. Microstructure evolution in metal-intermetallic laminate (MIL)
SC
composites synthesized by reactive foil sintering in air. Metallurgical & Materials
U
Transactions A 2001, 32(6):1493-1505.
AN
[6] L.M. Peng, H. Li, J.H. Wang. Processing and mechanical behavior of laminated
A 2005, 406(1-2):309-318.
D
[7] P.J. Zhou, C.H. Guo, E.H. Wang, Z.M. Wang, Y. Chen, F.C. Jiang. Interface tensile and
TE
quasi-static and high strain rates. Materials Science & Engineering A 2016, 665:66-75.
EP
[8] Y.B. Sun, J. Chen, F.M. Ma, K. Akeyama, W.L. Xiao, C.L. Ma. Tensile and flexural
C
2015, 102:165-172.
25
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
2016, 649:325-337.
[11] Y. Wang, K.S. Vecchio. Microstructure evolution in a martensitic 430 stainless steel-Al
PT
2015, 643:72-85.
RI
[12] P. Zhu, J.C.M. Li, C.T. Liu. Combustion reaction in multilayered nickel and aluminum
SC
[13] H. Wang, J. Han, S. Du, D.O. Northwood. Effects of Ni foil thickness on the
U
microstructure and tensile properties of reaction synthesized multilayer composites.
AN
Materials Science & Engineering A 2007, s445-446:517-525.
[14] S. Suresh. Modeling and design of multi-layered and graded materials. Progress in
M
[15] A. Rohatgi, D.J. Harach, K.S. Vecchio, K.P. Harvey. Resistance-curve and fracture
TE
2003, 51(10):2933-2957.
EP
[16] T.Z. Li, F.C. Jiang, E.A. Olevsky, K.S. Vecchio, M.A. Meyers. Damage evolution in
C
[17] Y. Cao, C.H. Guo, S.F. Zhu, N.X. Wei, R.A. Javed, F.C. Jiang. Fracture behavior of
[18] R.R. Adharapurapu, K.S. Vecchio, F.C. Jiang, A. Rohatgi. Fracture of Ti-Al3Ti
26
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[19] R.R. Adharapurapu, K.S. Vecchio, F.C. Jiang, A. Rohatgi. Effects of ductile laminate
PT
metal-intermetallic laminate composites. Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A
RI
2005, 36(6):1595-1608.
SC
and interfacial phenomena. Materials Science & Engineering A 2001, 300(1):211-218.
U
[21] X.H. Lv, Y.Q. Yang, Z.J. Ma, C.X. Liu, C. Yan, A.Y. Long. Kinetics and mechanism of
AN
interfacial reaction in SCS-6 SiC continuous fiber-reinforced Ti-Al intermetallic matrix
[22] G. Jiang , G. Wu, Y. Liu. Research Progress in Continuous Fiber Reinforced Titanium
D
[24] K. Zhu, W. Yu, Y. Aman, T. Jing. Synthesis, microstructure and mechanical properties of
C
[26] R.D. Price, F.C. Jiang, R.M. Kulin, K.S. Vecchio. Effects of ductile phase volume
27
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[27] L.M. Peng, J.H. Wang, H. Li, J.H. Zhao, L.H. He. Synthesis and microstructural
PT
Materialia 2005, 52(3):243-248.
RI
[28] X.P. Cui, G.H. Fan, L. Geng, Y. Wang, H.W. Zhang, H.X. Peng. Fabrication of fully
SC
Materialia 2012 ,66:276-279.
U
[29] X.P. Cui, G.H. Fan, L. Geng, Y. Wang, L.J. Huang, H.X. Peng. Growth kinetics of TiAl3
AN
layer in multi-laminated Ti-(TiB2/Al) composite sheets during annealing treatment.
[30] S.H. Qin, X.P. Cui, Z. Tian, L. Geng, B.X. Liu, J. Zhang, J.F. Chen. Synthesis and
D
[31] Y.H. He, Y. Jiang, N.P. Xu, J. Zou, B.Y. Huang, C.T. Liu, P.K. Liaw. Fabrication of Ti-Al
EP
[32] D. Zhang, Y.B. Sun, Y.Q. Zhao, T.T. Wang, J. Chen, H.X. Li, C.L. Ma. Interfacial
products in SiC fiber reinforced Ti-Al based intermetallic alloys. Rare Metals 2011,
30(1):524-528.
[33] Z.H. Xu, J. Agren. A modified hardness model for WC-Co cemented carbides. Materials
28
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[34] M. Niinomi. Mechanical properties of biomedical titanium alloys. Materials Science and
Engineering A 1998,243:231-236.
PT
and Ti-TiB composite materials produced by selective laser melting. Materials Science &
RI
Engineering A 2017, 688:20-26.
[36] Z.C. Lu, N.X. Wei, P. Li, C.H. Guo, F.C. Jiang. Microstructure and mechanical properties
SC
of intermetallic Al3Ti alloy with residual aluminum. Materials and Design 2016,
U
110:466-474.
AN
[37] Y.Q. Han, C.F. Lin, X.X. Han, Y.P. Chang, C.H. Guo, F.C. Jiang. Fabrication, interfacial
[38] E.H. Wang, Y. Tian, Z.Q. Wang, F.F. Jiao, C.H. Guo, F.C. Jiang. A study of shape
[39] E.H. Wang, C.H. Guo, P.J. Zhou, C.F. Lin, X.X. Han, F.C. Jiang. Fabrication, mechanical
AC
9:446-454.
[40] L.I. Yakovenkova, L.E. Karkina, M.Y. Rabovskaya. Super dislocation core structure in
type I and type II pyramidal planes of Ti3Al intermetallic: glissile dislocations and
29
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[41] L.E. Karkina, O.A. Elkina, L.I. Yakovenkova. Electron microscopic study of Ti3Al
494:223-232.
PT
[42] Kyeong Ho Baik. Tensile Failure Behavior of SiC/Ti-6Al-4V Composites: Manufactured
RI
by Plasma Spraying Route. Materials Transactions 2006, 47(11):2815-2820.
[43] H. Wu, G.H. Fan, M. Huang, L. Geng, X.P. Cui, H.L. Xie. Deformation behavior of
SC
brittle/ductile multilayered composites under interface constraint effect. International
U
Journal of Plasticity 2017, 89:96-109.
AN
[44] H. Wu, B.C. Jin, L. Geng, G.H. Fan, X.P. Cui, M. Huang, R.M. Hicks, S. Nutt.
[45] X.P. Cui, G.H. Fan, J.X. Gong, H. Wu, T.T. Zhang, L. Geng, S.H. Meng. Preparation of a
TE
foils and TiB/Ti composite foils. Materials & Design 2016, 101:181-187.
C EP
AC
30
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Highlights:
PT
(3) The composite shows good comprehensive mechanical properties.
RI
(4) The effect of reaction annealing on the microstructure and mechanical properties of the
SC
composite are investigated.
U
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC