Sei sulla pagina 1di 9

Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems 29 (2015) 469–477 469

DOI:10.3233/IFS-141178
IOS Press

Study on BIM-based construction project


cost and schedule risk early warning
Chengshuang Sun, Qingpeng Man∗ and Yaowu Wang
School of Management, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, China

Abstract. Due to the more complex structure, greater size, and longer constructing period, most construction projects are facing
more and greater risks than before and need more effective methods and tools to manage risks. However, because of the complex
mathematic formulas, the difficulty of collecting data, or low profit margin etc., professionals are finding that few risk management
methods and tools are sufficient, and they typically rely on their experience in practical construction-project risk management. To
solve these problems, we present Building Information Modeling (BIM) as a new technology and the future of the Architectural,
Engineering and Construction (AEC) industry. This combined with Earned Value Analysis (EVA) for providing a BIM-based
construction project cost and schedule risk early warning model (BIM-CPCSREWM) to better and effectively manage construction
project risks. Herein we will present a background and a description of the proposed model, develop the system prototype of
BIM-CPCSREWM, and utilize a practical medicine construction project to illustrate the model’s validity.

Keywords: Construction project, risk management, BIM, risk early warning, cost and schedule

1. Introduction over $312 million in real and severe financial losses


as well as in social consequences [33]. For another
At present, most construction projects are facing example, because they used unskilled workers to erect
more and greater risks than before because their scale scaffolding for a high-rise construction in Jalan Bukit
is becoming larger, their structures more complex, con- Bintang, Malaysia, two workers died and ten were
struction technology more difficult, and construction injured when the scaffolding collapsed [35].
periods longer, and they have more uncertain factors [1, Admittedly, as Latham [25] suggests, all projects
7]. If risks cannot be managed effectively, the risks will have risks: “No construction project is risk free. Risk
become actual problems, bringing construction-project can be managed, minimized, shared, transferred or
participants more financial and possibly life losses, accept. It cannot be ignored.” Therefore, it is very
or lead to construction project failures. For example, important that the risks be managed effectively. Many
with construction 40.7% completed, a paper mill con- scholars have deeply studied the theories and the meth-
struction project in Chandler, Quebec, Canada, was ods of construction-project risk management. Taroun
abandoned due to socio-logics and ideo-logics overrid- [31], for example, conducted a literature review of con-
ing economic rationality or eco-logics. This resulted in struction risk modeling and assessment, and pointed
out that many substantial efforts are being put for-
∗ Corresponding author. Qingpeng Man, School of Management,
ward to improve the Probability-Impact risk model,
Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, 150001, China. Tel.: +86 451 reflecting construction projects’ increasing complexity.
86402181; Fax: +86 451 86402181; E-mail: manqp@126.com. Also, Kang et al. [24] developed a 5D CAD system for

1064-1246/15/$35.00 © 2015 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved
470 C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning

visualizing a construction risk degree of each activity


by linking 4D object data with the risk data, in which
they analyzed the possibilities of delay, greater-than-
expected spending, and accidents due to operational
risks. Jia et al. [22] presented a prototype of Risk
Management Maturity System (RMMS) in large-scale
construction projects by using the Analytic Network
Process method for assessing the overall effectiveness
of risk management against major risk factors. Many
scholars have studied risk early warning as an impor-
tant part of risk management. For example, Ding and
Zhou [8] developed a web-based system for risk early
warning of urban metro construction to imitate human
experts giving safety-risk assessment and early warn-
ings automatically based on multisource information, Fig. 1. Flow of the overall research framework.
and this system has been successfully applied to many
metro construction projects in the cities of Wuhan,
Shenyang, Zhengzhou, and Kunming in China. Chen facilitate risk modeling and management on the recon-
et al. [6] presented an outlier-detection model based on struction at the World Trade Center (WTC) site.
the Knowledge Discovery in Database (KDD) method Hartmann et al. [15] provided a case in which BIM was
for tender evaluation-decision and risk early warning, used to support risk management activities on a large
and they illustrated the model through a questionnaire scale, a D 620 million infrastructure project within a
survey to effectively detect the latent risks. Although European metropolitan area.
these methods and risk-management-assessment tools This paper presents a construction project cost
are effective, few of them are applied in practical and schedule risk early warning model (BIM-
construction projects due to the complexity of the CPCSREWM) based on BIM technology, in which
mathematic formulas, the difficulty of collecting data, we also adopt Earned Value Analysis (EVA) to bet-
or the low profit margin etc. [18, 30], and because ter provide overall risk information. For illustrating the
professionals typically rely on their own experience validity of BIM-CPCSREWM, we have developed a
[31]. However, professionals regard risk-management system prototype and applied it in a practical, medicine-
computer systems as an effective way to solve the related construction project.
above-mentioned barriers [24].
Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology is
changing the construction industry and is the future of 2. Research methodology
the AEC industry [17]. The General Services Admin-
istration (2007) says this about BIM: 2.1. Overall research framework
“BIM is the development and use of a multi-
The methodology employed in designing an inte-
faceted computer-software data model that not only
grated BIM-CPCSREWM is based on EVA as a
documents a building design, but simulates the con-
quantitative tool for data analysis and BIM for data
struction and operation of a new capital facility or
provider and results visually demonstrating. Figure 1
a recapitalized (modernized) facility. The resulting
shows the flow of the overall research framework, which
model is a data-rich, object-based, intelligent, and
consists of the following steps.
parametric digital representation of the facility from
Step 1. Collect planned and actual data. According to
which views appropriate to various users’ needs can
EVA’s calculation requirements, the planned data are
be extracted and analyzed to generate feedback on
retrieved from BIM model, and the actual data are pro-
and improvement of the facility design.”
vided by the construction site’s engineer.
BIM model (the resulting model) can be used Step 2. Calculate the parameters of EVA. After
as a data provider and a collaboration platform for receiving the planned and actual data concerning the
construction-project risk management. Harvey et al. construction project, we will calculate the parameters
[16] discussed BIM’s use and implementation to of EVA, such as Planned Value (PV), Earned Value
C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning 471

Table 1
Parameters and formulas of earned value analysis and its interpretation
Name Formula Interpretation
Cost Variance (CV) EV-AC Negative is over budget, positive is under budget.
Schedule Variance (SV) EV-PV Negative is behind schedule, positive is ahead of schedule.
Cost Performance Index (CPI) EV/AC CPI of 1.0 means that the actual cost equals to the planned cost;
CPI greater than 1.0 means the cost of completing work is less
than what is planned; CPI less than 1.0 means construction
project is facing cost overrun.
Schedule Performance Index (SPI) EV/PV SPI of 1.0 means that the schedule of completing the work is right
on plan; SPI greater than 1.0 means work is accomplished ahead
of schedule; SPI less than 1.0 means work is accomplished
behind schedule.
Estimate At Completion (EAC) BAC/CPI AC + ETC A forecast of most likely total construction project costs, based on
current construction performance and risk quantification.
Estimate to Complete (ETC) EAC-AC The estimated additional cost to complete the construction project
at any given time.
Variance at Completion (VAC) BAC-EAC Money over or under budget at the end of the construction project.

(EV), Actual Cost (AC), and Budget at Completion result, they have paid more and more attention to BIM.
(BAC), etc. At present, many BIM tools have been developed, such
Step 3. Analyze the risk status of the construction as Autodesk Revit and Navisworks, Graphisoft Archi-
project’s cost and schedule according to the EVA CAD, Bentley MicroStation, etc., and they have been
parameters, and visually demonstrate the risk early used in many different kinds of construction projects.
warning information in BIM model. Many benefits can be obtained by applying BIM
in practical. Case studies of construction projects that
2.2. Earned value analysis use BIM indicate that there are 8 to 15% savings on
new projects and up to 35% savings on repeat projects
EVA is a project management technique for measur- [21]. The design team at the General Motors Production
ing project performance and progress that uses “work Plant in Flint, Michigan estimated that the use of BIM
in progress” to indicate what will happen to work in technology, specifically automated collision detection,
the future. It is an “early warning” program/project saved 3 to 5% in overall costs, and the 3D digital work-
management tool that enables managers to identify and flow contributed an additional 2 to 4% in cost and time
control problems before they become insurmountable savings [9]. Too much special emphasis has been placed
[27]. EVA can simultaneously manage both the sched- on the research and application of BIM. For example,
ule and the cost of a project. Wisconsin Department of Administration [34] was the
To measure project performance from both schedule first governmental organization to issue a “BIM Imple-
and cost points of view, we have introduced the sched- mentation Announcement” requiring all construction
ule performance index (SPI) and the cost performance (new and addition/alteration) with total project fund-
index (CPI) as earned value metrics. SPI and CPI are ing of $5M or greater to apply BIM technology, as of
calculated by dividing EV by PV and AC, respectively. July 1, 2009. The National Building Information Model
Table 1 shows the summary of important parameters Standard Project Committee–United States [28] was
and formulas of Earned Value Analysis [4, 27]. originally chartered in 2005 as a Facility Information
Council (FIC). They then released the National Build-
2.3. Building information modeling ing Information Modeling Standard Version 1 – Part
1: Overview, Principles, and Methodologies in 2007.
Eastman et al. [9] described the earliest concept of Other countries, like Japan, Singapore, Finland, China
BIM as a working prototype “Building Description etc., also pay close attention to BIM technology, and
System,” and it dates back nearly forty years. Since have released BIM standards to improve the BIM appli-
then, researchers have found that BIM can solve many cation in the construction industry [11].
problems in the construction industry, such as inter- Although BIM can bring great benefits to project
operability [14], conflict analysis [37], construction participants, there are many barriers limiting BIM
sustainability [2], and prefabrication [20], etc. As a application, and BIM adoption is much slower than
472 C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning

Table 2
A summary of previous studies related to construction project cost and schedule risks
No Author(s) Year Risk factors
1 Tummala & Burchett 1999 Cost risk factors: financial, economic, political, environmental, design, site construction,
physical, and acts of God.
2 Baloi & Price 2003 Cost risk factors: estimator related, design related, level of competition related, fraudulent
practices related, construction related, economic related, and political related.
3 Kaliba et al. 2009 Cost risk factors: bad weather, inflation, schedule delay, scope changes, local government
pressures, strikes, technical challenges, environmental protection and mitigation cost.
Schedule risk factors: changes in drawings, changes in specifications, material procurement,
construction mistakes, poor supervision, equipment unavailability, financial process,
financial difficulties, delayed payments, economic problems, labor disputes and strikes,
contract modification, staffing problems, and poor coordination on site.
4 Luu et al. 2009 Schedule risk factors: owners’ financial difficulties, inadequate contractors’ experience,
materials shortages, contractors’ financial difficulties, slow site handover, delays in owners’
progress payments, low-awarded bid prices, inappropriate construction methods, defective
works and reworks, material price fluctuations, lack of capable and responsible site
supervisors, inclement weather, owners’ site clearance difficulties, lack of capable
owners/project managers, designers’ inadequate experience and capability, and equipment
shortages.
5 Chan et al. 2011 Cost risk factors: change in scope of work, insufficient design completion during tender
invitation, unforeseeable design development risks at tender stage, errors and omissions in
tender document, exchange rate variations, unforeseeable ground conditions, actual
quantities of work required far exceeding estimates, lack of experience of contracting
parties, inflation beyond expectations, and unrealistic maximum price or target cost agreed
in the contract, etc.
6 Issa 2013 Schedule risk factors: contractor problems and inadequate experience, change in material
prices or price escalation, unskilled workers and poor labor productivity, inefficient use of
equipment, delay in running bill payments to the contractor, delay in material procurement,
design/ suitability errors, clients’ problems, inadequate and slow decision-making
mechanisms, poor quality of local materials, poor coordination among parties, rework due
to errors in execution, improper accommodations for workers.

anticipated [10]. Gledson et al. [13] pointed out cul- [36] divided construction project risk into three groups:
tural, legal, and commercial implications. And the lack external risks (political, economic, social, and weather),
of e-readiness within an organization appears to be the project risks (time, cost work quality, construction, and
most prominent barrier to BIM implementation. Many technological), and internal risks (resources, project
problems existing in the process of applying BIM in members, construction site, documents, and informa-
practical construction projects need to be studied. In tion). Construction project costs and schedules are two
this paper, we employ BIM as a real-time data provider vital targets, and we have presented many risk factors
to study construction-project risk early warning affecting them in Table 2.
management. IT can be seen in Table 2 that there are still many
risk factors that influence construction projects’ costs
and schedules, although in previous decades, many
3. Analysis of risk factors affecting project-delivery methods and many risk-evasion strate-
construction project cost and schedule gies were put forward. So studies need more innovative
risk-management methods. In practical construction
Risk management can be divided into six parts: risk projects, analyzing all the related risk factors and
management planning, risk identification, qualitative assessing their impacts on construction projects’ costs
risk analysis, quantitative risk analysis, risk response and schedules is difficult and complex. Considering the
planning, and risk monitoring [29]. Risk identifica- characteristics of onerous risk types, EVA is a suitable
tion is one important part that greatly influences other tool for risk early warning because it mainly compares
parts. Many researchers have conducted previous stud- actual data with plan data and doesn’t concern itself
ies for risk identification, and have thereby identified with which risk factors cause cost overrun or schedule
many construction project risk factors. Zavadskas et al. delays. Accordingly, we present BIM technology, as a
C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning 473

Fig. 2. Diagram of BIM-CPCSREWM framework.

construction project data provider, combined with EVA is the risks’ visual demonstration by using the BIM
for risk early warning, and BIM-CPCSREWM. model.

4.2. System flow chart of BIM-CPCSREWM


4. Establishment of BIM-CPCSREWM
A system flow chart is a graphical representation of
4.1. Framework of BIM-CPCSREWM
system data flow and represents the system’s work pro-
BIM-CPCSREWM includes three parts: input, data cess. Figure 3 shows the BIM-CPCSREWM system
process, and output. Figure 2 presents the framework flow chart, which presents the main procedure steps
of BIM-CPCSREWM. for risk early warning of the construction project.
Part 1: Input. There are four kinds of data: cost
and schedule data of practical construction projects; 4.3. Preconditions of model application
new labor costs, building materials, and construction
machineries; construction project schedule plans; and Application of BIM-CPCSREWM should meet the
the BIM model. The first two kinds need to be imported following preconditions.
into BIM-CPCSREWM and updated frequently. For (1) Detailed level of BIM model should satisfy the
example, these kinds of data should be updated when requirement of EVA calculation.
one key construction procedure is completed, or when BIM-CPCSREWM has no function of establish-
the price of construction materials greatly rises. The ing the BIM model, so the BIM model should have
last two kinds generally need to be imported into BIM- been developed first by other BIM tools and then
CPCSREWM once, except design changes. The BIM imported into BIM-CPCSREWM. Because the major-
model not only is used as the data provider for Bills ity of data needed for calculating the parameters of EVA
of Quantities (BOQ), but also can be used as a visual come from the BIM model, the BIM model should
demonstration of risk early warning information for be as detailed as possible. Besides, the bill of quan-
construction projects. tity (BOQ) should be automatically calculated by BIM
Part 2: Data process. In this part, BOQ are retrieved tools because BOQ is a base for BIM-CPCSREWM.
from the BIM model, as well as are other data, such Once the design change occurs, the new BOQ can
as cost, schedule plan, practical construction site data, immediately and easily be calculated and imported
etc. We then combine and summarize the calculation into BIM-CPCSREWM for comparing with previous
of parameters of EVA. Then, we can retrieve the risk design schemes and for guaranteeing the real-time early
information (if the construction project costs have been warning.
overrun and if the schedule has been delayed, etc.) (2) Data interface should adopt the IFC format.
according to the CPI and SPI values. The IFC data exchange standard now is the most
Part 3: Output. BIM-CPCSREWM can give two out- widely applied in BIM tools. Almost all the pop-
puts. One is detailed information about the construction ular BIM tools are compatible with IFC, such as
project’s cost and schedule risk early warning; another Autodesk Revit, Bentley MicroStation, and Graphisoft
474 C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning

Fig. 3. system flow chart of BIM-CPCSRWM.


C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning 475

Manu of BIM-CPCSRWM
Under construction
BIM model of practical
View tools of BIM model construction project

Information of delayed construction processes

Fig. 6. Demonstration of delayed construction processes.


Schedule and cost data which are inputted and
connected to the related parts of the BIM model.

Fig. 4. Schedule and cost data input interface in BIM-CPCSREWM. Searching condition input

Risk related information about risk factor


name, risk factor classification, risk
response strategies, etc.

Fig. 7. Searching for risk response strategies.

The case for illustrating the validation of BIM-


CPCSREWM is a famous hospital construction project
Fig. 5. Interface of calculating parameters of EVA in BIM-
CPCSREWM.
in China, for which the overall planned investment was
3.35 billion RMB Yuan (550 million dollars), in which
the cost of civil works construction was 1.45 billion
ArchiCAD, etc. For interoperating with existing BIM RMB Yuan (238 million dollars) and the amount of
tools, IFC is adopted in BIM-CPCSREWM. floor space under construction was 62 million square
meters. There are three floors underground and 22 floors
above ground. Figure 4 shows the master drawing. For
5. Prototype of BIM-CPCSREWM implementing the Flow Process Method, the construc-
tion site from the 3rd floor to the 5th floor was divided
The programming language for developing a pro- into five construction sections, and from the 6th floor
totype of BIM-CPCSREWM is C#, which is a to the 22nd floor, the construction site was divided into
multi-paradigm, general-purpose, and object-oriented two construction sections.
programming language. The database is Microsoft Firstly, the BIM model of this hospital construction
SQL Server 2008. The prototype of BIM-CPCSREWM project was created by Revit 2014 and saved as a Nav-
adopts the Autodesk.Navisworks.Api.dll for interface isworks file and then inputted into BIM-CPCSREWM.
with the Navisworks model. Then, from the construction organization plan files, we
476 C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning

entered the planned schedule and cost data, includ- basic data of construction projects’ costs and schedules
ing the planned start date, planned end date, planned for risk early warning, and dynamically demonstrate
bill of quantity, and planned cost of each construc- construction sites’ risk results.
tion procedure. After the construction project started on Because both the BIM and the risk early warning of
November 7, 2012, the actual schedule and cost infor- construction projects are very complicated, there are
mation were entered, such as the actual start date, actual many key problems that need to be studied. This paper
end date, actual bill of quantity, actual cost of each has initially explored the framework of applying BIM
construction procedures. The interface of inputting the on the risk early warning and its feasibility, and the
planned and the actual construction project’s schedule follow-up study will focus on the further development
and cost data can be seen in Fig. 4. After the planned and of the BIM-based construction project risk early warn-
actual data of the construction project were acquired, ing system and its application in practice. Among these
the parameters of EVA could be calculated. key problems, auto-generation of schedule plans and
For this hospital construction project, we only cal- automatic exact pricing of each constructing process
culated the parameters of EVA twice, once on July 24, of a construction project from the BIM model are the
2013, and then on October 24, 2013, as shown in Fig. 5. most important things that need to be studied, and
According to the first calculation results, CPI>1 and urgently so.
SPI>1 means cost under budget and ahead of schedule.
But the second calculation results, CPI>1 and SPI<1
Acknowledgments
means cost under budget and behind schedule. All the
calculation results can be visually shown in an Excel-
The research was supported by the National Nat-
format graph. If the number from the calculation is
ural Science Foundation of China under the grants
enough, the trends of EV, AV, and PV will be much
No.71071043, No. 71201038 and No. 51378160, and
more obvious and significant to a risk analyzer.
the Scientific Research Foundation for the Returned
Figure 6 shows the detail information about
Overseas Chinese Scholars of Harbin Science and
the delayed construction processes, and dynamically
Technology Bureau of China under the grants No.
presents construction conditions.
JJ20120070.
After knowing the information about the construc-
tion project delay or cost overrun, the participants can
search for the related risk-response strategies in BIM- References
CPCSREWM, as shown in Fig. 7.
[1] M. Abdelgawad and A. Fayek, Risk management in the con-
struction industry using combined fuzzy FMEA and fuzzy
6. Conclusions AHP, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
136 (2010), 1028–1036.
[2] S. Azhar, B. Justin and F. Rizwan, BIM-based sustainabil-
The cost and schedule are two very important main ity analysis: An evaluation of building performance analysis
targets for construction projects, and the risk manage- software, Proceedings of the 45th ASC National Conference
ment is the guarantee for implementing these targets. (2009), pp 1–4.
[3] D. Baloi and A.D. Price, Modelling global risk factors affect-
This paper has presented a new risk early warning ing construction cost performance, International Journal of
method based on newly emerging BIM technology. Project Management 21 (2003), 261–269.
(1) Although many scholars have studied risk [4] S.K. Bhosekar and G. Vyas, Cost controlling using earned
management and have presented some methods for value analysis in construction industries, International Journal
of Engineering and Innovative Technology 1 (2012), 324–332.
evaluating and mitigating construction-project risks, [5] D.W. Chan, A.P. Chan, P.T. Lam, J.F. Yeung and J.H. Chan,
most methods aren’t easily applied in practice due Risk ranking and analysis in target cost contracts: Empirical
to their complication and difficulty in collecting data. evidence from the construction industry, International Journal
So more effective and easy-to-use methods of apply- of Project Management 29 (2011), 751–763.
[6] T. Chen, Y. Wang and Y. Sun, Development and application of
ing advanced and new technology like BIM are worth tender evaluation decision-making and risk early warning sys-
studying. tem for water projects based on KDD, Advances in Engineering
(2) BIM has great advantages for construction- Software 48 (2012), 58–69.
[7] H. Cui, Z. Xuan and R. An, Study on risk analysis for con-
project risk management. Due to BIM’s powerful
struction project based on BOT, Information Management
capability, such as its data-rich, parametric digital rep- and Engineering (ICME), 2010 The 2nd IEEE International
resentation, and 4D simulation, etc., BIM can provide Conference on IEEE (2010), 186–189.
C. Sun et al. / Study on BIM-based construction project cost and schedule risk early warning 477

[8] L.Y. Ding and C. Zhou, Development of web-based system for [23] C. Kaliba, M. Muya and K. Mumba, Cost escalation and
safety risk early warning in urban metro construction, Automa- schedule delays in road construction projects in Zambia,
tion in Construction 34 (2013), 45–55. International Journal of Project Management 27 (2009),
[9] C. Eastman et al., BIM handbook: A guide to building infor- 522–531.
mation modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers, [24] L.S. Kang et al., Development of 5D system for visualizing
and contractors, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. NJ, USA, 2008. risk degree and progress schedule for construction project,
[10] M. Fischer and J. Kunz, The Scope and Role of Informa- Proceedings of the 2011 ASCE international Workshop on
tion Technology in Construction, Palo Alto, CA: Center for Computing in Civil Engineering (2011), 687–690.
Integrated Facility Engineering, Stanford University, 2004. [25] M. Latham, Construction the team, HMSO London, (1994).
[11] W.L. Ge, BIM the second dimension – BIM application for [26] V.T. Luu, S.Y. Kim, N.V. Tuan and S.O. Ogunlana, Quantifying
different project participants, China Architecture & Building schedule risk in construction projects using Bayesian belief
Press, (In Chinese), 2011. networks, International Journal of Project Management 27
[12] General Services Administration, GSA Building Information (2009), 39–50.
Modeling Guide Series 01 – Overview, http://www.gsa.gov/ [27] S. Nagrecha, An introduction to Earned Value Analysis.
bim, May 15, 2007. http://www.pmiglc.org/COMM/Articles/0410 nagrecha eva-
[13] B. Gledson, D. Henry and P. Bleanch, Does size matter? 3.pdf, 2002.
Experiences and perspectives of BIM implementation from [28] NBIMS-US, National Building Information Modeling Stan-
large and SME construction contractors, 1st UK Academic dard Version 1 – Part 1: Overview, Principles, and Method-
Conference on Building Information Management (BIM), ologies. http://www.wbdg.org/pdfs/NBIMSv1 p1.pdf, 2007.
Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK (2012), [29] PMI, A guide to the project management body of knowledge,
5–7. Project Management Institute (2012).
[14] A. Grilo and R. Jardim-Goncalves, Value proposition on inter- [30] S.J. Simister, Usage and benefits of project risk analysis and
operability of BIM and collaborative working environments. management, International Journal of Project Management
Automation in Construction 19 (2010), 522–530. 12 (1994), 5–8.
[15] T. Hartmann, H. Meerveld, N. Vossebeld and A. Adriaanse, [31] A. Taroun, Towards a better modeling and assessment
Aligning building information model tools and construction of construction risk: Insights from a literature review,
management methods, Automation in Construction 22 (2012), International Journal of Project Management, http://dx.doi.
605–613. org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2013.03004, 2013.
[16] R. Harvey, T. Bahgat, D. Gerber, J. Kotronis and D. Pysh, [32] M. Tummala and J.F. Burchett, Applying a risk management
BIM as a risk management platform enabling integrated prac- process (RMP) to manage cost risk for an EHV transmission
tice and delivery, Journal of Building Information Modeling line project, International Journal of Project Management 17
(2009), 14–17. (1999), 223–235.
[17] E. Hoffer, BIM Adoption – Catalyzed by Industry Trends. [33] G. Vit, Competing logics: Project failure in Gaspesia,
http://www.greenbuildingcommunity.com/feature full.php?cp European Management Journal 29 (2011), 234–244.
featureid=29823, August 22, 2008. [34] Wisconsin Department of Administration. BIM Implementa-
[18] B.G. Hwang, X. Zhao and L.P. Toh, Risk management in tion Announcement,
small construction projects in Singapore: Status, barriers and [35] Z. Zakaria et al., Accidents at the construction site in north-
impact, International Journal of Project Management 32 ern area: Malaysian experienced, Management Science and
(2014) 116–124. Engineering 4 (2010), 106–116.
[19] U.H. Issa, Implementation of lean construction techniques [36] E.K. Zavadskas, Z. Turskis and J. Tamošaitiene, Risk assess-
for minimizing the risks effect on project construction time, ment of construction projects, Journal of Civil Engineering
Alexandria Engineering Journal 52 (2013), 697–704. and Management 16 (2010), 33–46.
[20] Y.S. Jeong, C.M. Eastman, R. Sacks and I. Kaner, Benchmark [37] J.P. Zhang and Z.Z. Hu, BIM- and 4D-based integrated solu-
tests for BIM data exchanges of precast concrete, Automation tion of analysis and management for conflicts and structural
in Construction 18 (2009), 469–484. safety problems during construction: 1. Principles and method-
[21] F.E. Jernigan, Big BIM, little BIM, The practical approach to ologies, Automation in Construction 20 (2011), 156–166.
building information modeling: Integrated practice done the
right way! 4site Press, Maryland, USA, 2008.
[22] G. Jia et al., Measuring the maturity of risk management in
large-scale construction projects, Automation in Construction
34 (2013) 56–66.

Potrebbero piacerti anche