Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CASE STUDY:
SYLPHIDE (GROUPE BEL)
1. STRATEGY
a. Macro View
b. Company Sales Data
c. Product / Service Intro
d. Job to be done
2. DIGITAL
a. Digital Presence
b. Increasing points of purchase
3. COMMUNICATIONS
a. People
b. Positioning
c. Promotion
4. COMPETITIVE THREATS
5. RECOMMENDATIONS
6. HOW PROMOTION CHANNELS WORK TOGETHER
7. IMPLEMENTATION
STRATEGY
3
MACRO VIEW
4
8 TRENDS IN DAIRY
Digital Strategy
can create direct
retail channels
*Consumer purchasing power eroded significantly during the year in this region, where the majority of dairy raw materials are
imported. In this environment, selling prices could only be raised moderately to offset higher dairy raw material prices.
PRODUCT INTRO
11
WHAT IS SYLPHIDE?
Given that Sylphide isn’t completely new in the market, the problem is less of awareness,
and more frequency of purchase.
To drive frequency, the product should be associated with a wider range of buyer personas,
it should be visualized (so we see more people eating it) and there should be more
opportunities to buy it.
● Video
● More health related content / Partnerships with 3rd parties
● Online sales
DIGITAL
16
DIGITAL PRESENCE
17
WEBSITE
Ideally there would be a brand website eg Sylphide.com, to serve global customers, with the option
of localization
We also need to make sure the parent company website (Groupe Bel) is localized and has all the
relevant information for both consumers and other stakeholders (distributors, retailers).
For many international CPG brands, having a localized site per country they operate in, can require
a lot of resources.
Often the HQ site will allow for choice of country in a drop down menu, but typically for Middle
Eastern users, they are either grouped in with a wider cohort (eg “Rest of World”) or, if regional
countries are listed, they might only be hubs (eg Dubai, or Riyadh, or Cairo).
Furthermore, they often don’t show the full local product range, or where to buy it.
WEBSITE
Most results
dominated by
Sylphide the ballet.
There is no cheese
related content for
this brand name on
page 1 of SERPS
SEARCH RESULTS: “SYLPHIDE CHEESE”
Currently the product is placed next to the rest of the Bel product range in the
dairy fridges of supermarkets and small groceries. More in store collateral can
help for tasting and driving first touch with consumers.
29
CARREFOUR (LEBANON)
static content
CARREFOUR (UAE)
SPINNEYS (LEBANON)
MONOPRIX (LEBANON)
static content
LE CHARCUTIER AOUN (LEBANON)
static content +
flash
A NOTE ON SUPERMARKETS ONLINE
As retailers move online, it makes sense for CPG brands to follow them,
increasing the opportunities to buy.
We can already see highly visible presence for some of Bel brands (La Vache qui
rit, Picon) which suggests that a consolidated and proactive presence here can
help to dominate the market.
Countering this, is the emergence of several well funded grocery delivery apps
across the region. With better usability and high adoption rates, these are
superseding traditional outlets.
36
GROCERY DELIVERY - MENA MARKET LANDSCAPE
Source: Arabnet.me
Grocery delivery startups in MENA have attracted significant funding over the past few years.
Leading players GoodSmart (Egypt), Knock Mart (Egypt), Insta Shop (UAE), El Grocer (UAE) and
ToDoorstep (KSA) have collectively raised more than $4.4 M in funding since 2015.
A Global Nielsen survey showed the percent of respondents willing to use digital retailing options
was highest in developing markets, particularly in MENA (58%).
GROCERY APPS
Instashop - UAE Danube - KSA Zitaat - Kuwait
100,000
users
Groceries on
Amazon
39
AMAZON SOUQ SUPERMARKET
BEST PRACTICE
41
NESTLE IN MALAYSIA
In 2015 Nestle opened its first ecommerce stores hosted on Lazada and
11th Street ecommerce platforms under the “Wellness Together”
umbrella, and tripled its growth during 2016. It’s on track to reach
$100 million in ecommerce sales within 3 - 5 years of launch.
While many firms had sacrificed brand investment during 2016 in response to a
subdued consumer sentiment, Nestle was aggressive and invested 50% more in
marketing and branding to deliver growth.
Nestle does not intend to reduce its advertising expenditure (adex) in print,
television or radio, but will add to this spend by investing additionally in digital
going forward.
Nestlé said it will also enhance programs and online services designed to
provide parents and caregivers with more nutritional knowledge, healthy recipes
and practical tips.
In 2017, more than 300 partnerships worldwide helped the company reach
more than 14 million children.
NESTLE ON LAZADA.COM
TANGIBLE INFORMATIONAL
RESPONSE TO
EATING ACTIVITY PACKAGING AND INTENT
DESIGN
TANGIBLE BEHAVIOUR MATRIX
Wants to indulge,
POST PREGNANCY / Work out at home, Withstand being in
taste + energy
STAY AT HOME focuses on reducing transit, easy to open
without calories.
MOMS Calories (possibly also for kids)
Active Passive
Intent level
Sylphide 12 pack. Other items shown Inner sleeve was difficult to Individual portions also difficult to
for scale. push out. quickly unwrap, no “tag”.
Package is quite large and feels Could be a problem for Consistency is very soft, unlike Babybel
considerably wider than a similar pack people with limited hand which can easily be eaten without an
of Kiri. mobility accompanying product (eg bread,
crackers, vegetable)
Colors feel somewhat muted, suggest
bland, diet type food.
CHANNEL BRANDING
CONTENT THEMES - FB & INSTAGRAM
Personal:
Product:
Product:
There doesn’t appear to be a consistent and clear brand message at the moment. The
graphics in particular seem to suggest an optimistic happy upbeat brand tone of voice,
whilst some of the underlying messaging can appear to be quite strict and focused on
extreme measures.
The overall takeaway for the customer from the 2 key content themes, is that the brand sees
women as having two main problems in life; how to remain thin and what to cook. Possibly
by extension, that this is what women should also find important. This suggests applying
out of date thinking to today’s current audience.
The messaging doesn’t show empathy with the user and creates a causational relationship
between successful restriction of calories and happy love lives. Helping customers with their
lifestyle goals shouldn’t mean demonizing others, or using guilt as a tool.
Customers vehemently disliked some of the brand imagery (woman with duct tape over her
mouth) to the extent that it was removed from owned platforms. This feeling does not lend
itself to increased purchase activity.
APPROACH TO NEW POSITIONING
Engagement
The best value, the The best quality with
CONSUMER NEEDS Right food at right price (we’ve got interesting content you’ll want
most flexible to me the minimum hassle
to share)
DIGITAL PROMOTION
Instagram posts stopped in June 2017, and started again in April 2018.
Active Passive
Intent level
CREATIVE $$$$ $$ $
MEDIA $ $$ $$$
ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK
LOW
Diet specific FB groups / online
SPECIAL DIETS fora,
Provide value (we aren’t specialists in this area
so we can’t add extra value yet)
ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK:
Both multinational leaders such as Nestle, Unilever, Kraft - and - local mega brands
such as Al Marai, Al Rawabi and NADEC exert competitive pressure on Bel.
Multinationals who have digital expertise in other markets can simply replicate
their model in the region once the customer base is large enough to offset any
capital investment costs. That time is rapidly approaching.
Local brands enjoy widespread trust and mindshare and length of time in market.
Should they start heavily competing on healthy cheese, Bel may find itself at a
disadvantage, especially regarding access and costs to raw material. (NADEC for
example is one of the largest vertically integrated dairy companies in the world).
Overall growth in dairy sales in MENA and consumer trends for more healthy
options means Sylphide needs to double down on early growth now to be able to
withstand future threats to positioning and brand equity.
THE LOCAL DAIRY INDUSTRY VIEW
“
Looking ahead to next year [2018], we see a number of
challenges for the industry, the biggest of which is
competition. It’s getting harder and harder and the
competitors are coming from all over the world, especially
from Northern European countries where their cost
structure is much better than ours.
”
challenge for the sector for local manufacturers.
Follow the example of Bel’s acquired MoM site and create a Sylphide global website.
Create localized versions (either for all of the region or for each country). Ensure multiple
languages
Our aim here is to own the Brand term Sylphide for online searches. Users and search
engines should find our site easily when searching.
Build for flexibility and regular updating. Since we’ll lead with a content heavy approach,
we’ll use the website as the primary publishing platform.
It will also include lists and locations of partner retailers and other purchase points.
INCREASING POINTS
OF PURCHASE
78
INCREASING POINTS OF PURCHASE
Opportunity to increase brick and mortar PoP as well by understanding where these apps source
merchants.
Be a preferential brand! Make it easy to do business with you and reap the benefits of real
partnership.
Encourage your existing retailers to “move online” with your Grocery App partner. Reward them for
doing so
People > Products. If the brand has different managers in each MENA country, consider grouping
them all into a Task Force with a Chief Regional Digital Officer overseeing them. Set stock,
presentation, visibility KPI’s similar to offline stores.
Create cross team units between Bel and Grocery App partner to train rest of company on new
initiative. Host this at an incubator and generate lots of positive press in both retail and tech circles.
POSITIONING
80
POSITIONING
Online positioning is different to traditional positioning. New rules and paradigms apply.
Fortunately , selling through grocery apps means you get a halo effect from the platforms of “Convenience”
Also, digitally:
Half of positioning online is being present where the customer expects to see you (website, search results,
relevant directories, online stores, social channels), being consistently present (don’t go silent on Instagram
for a year).and finally ensuring a smooth journey between channels (usability).
Develop a lot of Google friendly content that answers questions from users on special diets.
Particularly Keto. Cheese is encouraged on this diet, and as a healthy cheese, Sylphide
should jump on the opportunity to own this area of consumer demand.
Repurpose this content for use on grocery delivery app blogs / mailshots. Adding extra value
to their users creates more opportunities for buying. More content distribution helps drive
the brand message and positioning home, and of course helps with SEO.
People who are on special diets are always looking for places to get particular ingredients.
Sylphide can create content that answers this for their own channels and others.
Enhance this by backing niche influencers in the special diet sector (eg CrossFit on Keto, or
The Intermittent Fasting Mom)
PROMOTION - COMMUNITY
Promotion to community groups requires a lot of listening first, action later. The key to success is being able
to provide something of value.
If you’re in a forum for working women and most of the requests are for the best accounting softwares for
SMEs then there’ll be little use jumping in on the conversation. But you might end up subsidizing a
workshop on how to use that (best) accounting software, which has a clear value proposition.
If you’re in a community of women who want to lose weight, a key value proposition might be to
subsidize workout apparel, or to run personal training sessions at a discount.
Other less cash intensive ways to provide value, are to focus on information gaps in your community
groups. Most people join a community to get answers to questions they can’t easily find online. There’s an
opportunity here to develop content that answers that question and that can be easily found by the
audience.
So a user searching for “best accounting software for SMEs” may see a result titled “Best accounting
Software for SMEs in Lebanon 2018 ranked by the top 10 women in business” which is more than likely to
get a click.
PROMOTION - READING / WATCHING
Sylphide needs to own the conversation about cheese amongst post pregnancy and stay at home moms
because our key metric is credibility with this audience.
This means creating and paying for content (either created by the brand, or by the publisher) to act in
favour of it.
Efforts here on the part of the individual brand, Sylphide, could be enhanced by the parent company
Groupe Bel, investing in a long term pro cheese PR offensive across the region to increase the demand for
all types of cheese in general. A Bel Cheese Lobby perhaps.
The ideal situation would be multiple sources of content that answer the question “can eating sylphide post
pregnancy help you lose weight” with a positive yes.
Aim to get coverage on a macro scale from local news and lifestyle publishers, down to the individual level
eg niche bloggers and mom influencers.
But always start from the top down. You want the individual influencers to be able to have source material
to back up the claims you want them to assert.
HOW PROMOTION
CHANNELS WORK
TOGETHER
86
MECHANICS
PAID
ADVERTISING/
PR
ORGANIC SYLPHIDE
SEARCH WEBSITE
SOCIAL OFFLINE
RETAIL STORE
CHANNELS ACTIVATION
IMPLEMENTATION
88
OUTSOURCING PARTNERS
EMAIL: ALEXANDRATOHME@GMAIL.COM