Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CBSasCIA
CIA Rebels
· Supply U.S. Heroin
Chemical Warfare
in Afghanistan
, Iraq· lr(iln War
AIFLD in El Salvador
· Rightwing Terror
in Guatemala
USIA/ICA: Arrowhead CIA Bari(ing in Australia:
of Penetration Nugan Hand
Colonia Dignidad: New Hebrides:
New Revelations Independent at Last
Fingermen Are All Thumbs CIA Cops in Guatemala
CIA in Turkey
Editorial
/
Due to public opposition and despite :Lh- In response to the press conference, the
; tense illegal lobbying by the CIA, the New York Times issued a stateme'nt of con
"I�telligence Identiti�s Protection Act'" siderable import:
failed to reach a floor'vote in Congress "N_? editor or executive of this paper
before it recessed. ,HR5615 and S2216�would has any knowledge of what Love was sup
make it a crime to disclose information posed to have .done 271 years ago. What
leading to the identification of CIA and- every editor and executive of this pa
' FBI officers, agents and informers, even per does know, however, is that The New
it the information whi�h led to the iden York Times has an absolute rule against
tification was already public. any reporter working for any government
_ Some Senators and Representatives are agency.. This paper has repeatedly urged,
opposed to the present bills because tbey .President carter to reverse the CIA's
a.re unconstitutional. Others argue that present policy of permitting use of
the bills are not strong enough. Unfortu journalists as agents when the Director
nately for the public, botH the former and of Central Intelligence approves.
the latter still want to see some version "We are confident that no member of The
of the bills passed. · New\ York Times would agree to be used
Counter'Spy believes that the only prin by the CIA. But not until the CIA's
cipled and constitutional position is to policy is publicly reversed will there
tal opposition to any version of the so- be a total confidence abroad that the
'Called "Int.elligence Identities Proi:ection CIA and other government agencies are
Act". Moreover, exposure of FBI and CIA respecting the spirit of the First
activities is one of the few protections Amendment and not getting involved with
for persons tqrgeted by CIA and FBI �pera
tions, particularly•. in foreign countries.
the press."
Counterspy believes that the �rn
Since the CIA and the FBI have not Times' "absolute rule" position is a re
changed, it is as crucial and urgent as sponse to past abuses of the Times by the
ever for the press to examine and write CIA. In other words,' Times employees have
more about the CIA and FBI, not less. Any worked with the CIA and found it impossi
version of HR5615 and S2216 would reduce, ble to serve both the ,CIA and the re
if not eliminate, these vitally needed e« quirements of honest journalism. Thus,
pos7s. Therefore/ Counter�py is flatly op the Times' absolute opposition to CIA in
posed to the so called "Intelligence Iden volvement is doubLy important: it is
tities Protection Act" and urges concerned based on both a theoretical analysis and
people to work actively to stop HR5615 and .;.;.1 actual history of involvement with the
S2�16. CIA.
The controversy surrounding.HR5615 and Counterspy fully supports this absolute
S2216 has resurrected the question of the oppo�ition to CIA involvement with the
relationship between the CIA and the media. media� and recommends that all other com
The consequences of CIA-media affiliation ponents of the media "' follow the example
were illustrated at a Counterspy press of the Times in this regard.
conference on September 25', 1980. Counter In order to further debate on the CIA
� disclqsed that Kennett Love was in and the media and to encourage other sec
volved with the CIA's 1953 coup in Iran tors of the media to follow the stated
while he was a New York Times reporter. /position of the New York Times, Counter
(Foi the comple�story, see Counterspy, � is featuringilir�rticles which
vol.• 4 no.4.) The devastating aftermath of highlight the need to seve�. all ti.�s be
t�t CIA coup is a matter bf public re tween the media and U.S. government
cord. agencies, especially the CIA.
\
Contents
CBS as CIA
CBS as CIA
by John Kelly
by John Kelly••• � •••••••••••.•...•.•3
_4 - Counte-i-Spy
USIA/-ICA: Arrowhead of
Penetration by Martha Wenger
"I believe in the power of ideas. I be trolled wartime propaganda operations,
lieve that ideas are what the Internation evolved into the Office of International
al camnunication Agency is all about••• In Information and Cultural Affairs, a branch
the ebbs and flows of history, there are of the State Department, given its legal
those who place their trust in military basis in the Smith-Mundt Act of 1948.
might, those who lean to economic determi This development closely paralleled the
nism, those whose ultimate regard is for creation of the _Central Intelligence Agen
scientific'and technological innovation. I cy in 1947. In fact, in the early days,
turn to ideas ••• " l the functions of the two agencies all but
With these words, John E. Reinhardt was intertwined. "The double face of American
sworn in April 3, 1978 as director of the propaganda, 'black' and 'white', covert
International Conununication Agency (IO\) and overt, h�d exis\ed from the days of
-- the major propaganda arm of the United World War II, when the Office of War ::i:n
States governmen� abroad, with a 1980 bud formation, the forerunner of USIA, was not,
get of $426 million, over 200 cultural and always sure of its functions vis-a-vis the
information posts in 12 6 cbuntries, 2 apd Office of Strategic Services, the forerun
an international shortwave radio station, ner of the CIA. " 3
the Voice of Ame�ca (VOA) ·• 'In 1953 the information program was sep
The ICA (and its pr-.edecessor, the United arated from the State Department a�d es
States Information Agency, USIA) however, tablished as an independent agency: the
is involved in much more than.straightfor United States Information Agency, USIA.
ward propagation of ideas: it is an inte Its missio� was to prepare and disseminate
gral part of U.S. government penetration "information about the United States, its
abroad. rts goal is to influence and/or people, and its policies, through press,
manipulate events in foreign countries
along lines favorable to U.S. corporate UNITED STATES INFORMATION PROGRAMS
and goverrtment foreign policy objectives.
Condretely, those objectives translate to Office q.f_ War Information (OWI), World
economic rape by u.s. multinational corpo War II propaganda agency.
rations for many third world countries, Voice q.f_ America (VOA), short-wave r.a
and military and cultural domination for dio developed 1942. Presently adminin
others. istered by one of the four associate
A major task for America's information
program has always been propaganda aimed directors of ICA.
at the Soviet Union and Eastern European Office q.f_ International Information and
countries through the Voice of America. Cultural Affairs (IIA), develope as
radio and various publications. In peacetime continuation of OWI; a branch
countries where the u.s •. government has of the State Department, given legal
greater access, the tasks have·. gone be mandate in 1948 Smith-_Vundt Act.
yond so-called "white" propaganda to in United States Information Agenay (USIA),
fluencing opinion leaders in government, created August 1, 1953; first indepen
business, and education; feeding pro-u.s. dent peaaetime information agency. USIA
stories into local press and media; intel� posts abroad are known as USIS (United
ligence collection; and psychological war States Information Serviae).
fare campaigns in collaboration with U.S. International Communication Agency .
military operations. (ICA), created April 1, 1978; combined
At the close of World War II, the U.S. USIA and State Department Bureau of Ed
government became convinced of the useful ucation and Cultural Affairs. Head
ness of a peacetime propaganda agency. In quarters: 1776 Pennsylvania Ave. ·N.W.,
th� course of seve·ral' years the Office of Washington D.C. 20547.
liar Information (CMI), which had con-
Counterspy - 5
publications, radio, motion pictures, and the information program to coordinate with
other information media,, and thro�gh in- the CIA to assure "desired and practicable
. fbrmatiori centers and instructors . ab- support." 7
r�d." 4 During the same period, the USIA greatly·
· ··The USIA, in its• early years was an expanded its intelligence gathering and
i.dei>logical weai;lpn of the Cold war and·was analysis by establishing: its own Office of
molded by those battles into a single- • Research and Intelligence in late 1954.
11\indedly c\11ti-Communist· agency. Its propa The Eisenhower administration saw the
g,anda was largely directed at the Soviet creation of a _top-level Presidential ae
Union and Eastern _European countries. sistantship devoted primarily to the for
Succeeding. P��sidents, however, refined eign information program. TWO ioen who held
the USIA into a component of the totaf ap- that post were Nelson Rockefeller and
paratus whose function it was to achieve William H. Jackson, former deputy 1
director
e9onomic and political conditions favor of the CIA. 8 ru;>ckefeller had previously
able to world-wide U.S. interests. Thomas run the Coordinator of Inter-:-American Af-·
c. Sorenson, deputy director of the USIA fairs which condU:cted_psychological ,war
in Ithe early 1960's, explained: "••• _, the fare campaigns in tiatin America before and ·
US'IA is the psychological instrument of during World War II.
the United States Government overseas, U�IA's role as political activist esca
just as the State Department -is the diplo� lated under the Kennedy administration.
matic in�trument, tne Agency, for Interna Sorenson, USIA Peputy Director, wrote,
_tional Development the econ,omic assis "The Kennedy Administration has acknowl
�ce instrument, and the Central Intelli� edged political communication as a major
gertc;e, Agency th� intelligence ipstru arm of policy. No major and few minor �or
mtmt." 5 eign policy decisions are made without the
In August 1950 President.Harry Truman. active participation of USIA." 9 Edward '
created a national "Psychology Strategy Murrow, Director 0£ USIA, was given an NSC
Boar:d" (later called the Operations·Cool:1- seat and appointed.to.the _commi�tee which
dinating Board under Eisenhower) to coor- was to formulate the new counter-insurg,n�
·dinate "foreign information and psycholo g
' I
was designated a member of the Operations under the state Department - with a nearly
Coordinating Board and invited to be an identical mission, and many of the,same
observe� at National Security·eouncii personnel. carter di�ected th� ICA to:
(NSC) meetings, and met with_the President "Give foreign peoples the best possible
regularly once,a month. understanding of our policies and our in
Also during the 1950's, a plan was drawn tentions, ahd sufficient information about
, up to qrganize "Foreign Information and American society and culture to canprehend
�sychological Operations" during war:time. why we have �hosen certain policies over
11,.is now declassified (secret) docunlent, others••••" 11
c!ated 1950-51, described the u.s. informa carter's charter for the ICA reaffirmed
tion program's wartime functions as: sup- a previous Congressional restriction on
' porting the. Oefenae Department "in con• diaaeminat.ion of U.S. information agency
. cl\xsting foreiqn information operations in · propaganda within the Ubit•d States itself
llilitary theatre■ of operation■ (and) •••
-
All we ■hall aee, however, there are a num
planninv and ooor4inatinq foreign info:r:ma ber of ■ignific,ant,waya in which tCA pro
'cion opel'ation■ " J.n area■ outaide the paganda.doe■ •••P . .back
. into th• u.s.
field of ocmbat. 'l'he plan also directed
,, - Count�l'Spy
ceived crisis. The most recent occurrences people. Such manipulation is an extremely
- \
of such "directed programming" by the serious matter when the issue at stake is
Voice were the responses to events in Af- one that President Carter has used as a
ghanistan and· Iran. In a "crisis situa- , justification for reviving the Cold War,
tion", it is VdA's task to continuously reinstituting draft regist�ation t further
re-broadcast the official U.S. government- inflating the military budget, and intro
al version of events. In some cases, this ducing the "Carter _Docti;:ine".
"official version" has proved to be almost
total fabrication. PROPAGANDA OPERATIONS --FOR FOREIGN
A ease in point is recent VOA broadcast GOVERNMENTS
ing on the Afghanistan situation. Robert
risk, a journalist of the Times (London), During the time that ICA was known as
while reporting from Kabu� in February USIA it conducted several highly question-
1980, heard a VOA broadcast from Washing- able operations that were essentially do
ton, D.C. It reported "fierce fighting in mestic propaganda programs for foreign
the centre of Kabul. Afghan soldiers, the governments. No,t surprisingly, these gov-
station announced, were in conflict with ernments were regimes closely tied to the
Soviet troops at the Bela Hissar Fort in U.S. government.
the centre of the city." Fisk, with a In the 1950's a national liberation--·move-
clear view of the fort area from his hill- ment, the Huks, developed in the Philip
side hotel balcony, saw t�is scene: "... pines. The USIA was on t� scene to help
there was no smoke o.r fire, no sound .of'_ the Philippine government put down the
car horns from the city's traffic. Nor was movement. The USIA "worked closely with
there fighting. Th_e Bela Hissar was peace- the Philippine Armed Forces in continuing
ful. There were no Soviet troops to be a successful psychological warfare carn-:-
seen and the Afghan army was evidenced on- paign against the Huks", according to the
ly by a soldier drinking tea in the main 1954 USIA Report to Congress. "As the earn-
street ••• Not to put too fine a point on paign progressed, the Philippine Govern
it,· the Voice of America was talking rub- ment was able to devote more time and en-
bish." 20 ergy to economic reforms and to assume �
� In another instance, VOA (as well as the role of growing importance in Asian af-
BBC) reported that Mohammond Baryalai, a fairs. 11 -23 Put another way, the USIA aided
high-ranking Afghan government official a counterinsurgency campaign to suppress an
was killed in a shoot-out during a meeting internal opposition movement and to main-
of the Afghan Revolutionary Council in t�in a pro-u.s. Philippine goyer�ent in
February. Only three weeks later, Baryalai pow�r.
was interviewed, alive and well, by West , One of the most extensive pf this genre
German journalist Warner Poelchau. 2l of USIA operations was conducted in Vietnam
The two pri��Y �ources for the VOA during the war. In May 1965, President
broadcasts - "travell�rs pas_sing through Johnson delegated responsibility "for all
_Afghanistan to Pakistan", and "senior di- psychological actions in.Vietnam (except in
plomats in Kabul" have been thoroughly dis- direct support of military op�rations in
credited by foreign correspondents on the the field)" to the Director of the USIA. 24
scene. Regarding the main "diplomatic This,mission was carried out through the
- source", Ian Mather, correspondent for the Joint U.S. Public Affairs Office _(JUSPAO),
Observer (London), said: "The American Ein- Saigon; essentially a coordination of mili
bassy here ••• has been feeding wildly inac- tary and civilian psychological operations
curate information to American journalists, under one authority. JUSPAO maintained
exaggerating the number of Russian troops close and interlocking relationsqips at all
in the country, the number of Russians levels with its military counterpart, U.S.
killed, and the extent of• the engage- Army Broadcasting and Visual Activity, the
ments." 22 military psychological operations command
These boldfaced lies have not only been in the Pacific which had a detachment in
reported widely on the Voice of America, Saigon. 25 This relationship held in the
bu� - in a world in which mass media.is an whole region: "In all cases where such pro
international business - have· infiltrated grams are conducted the local major command'
media reports worldwide and have come back and the 7th PSYOP (psychological opera-
to propagandize and misinform the American_ tions) Group work in close and intimate co-
8 - Countei'Spy
William Donovan - head of the Office the official 'handouts'." 2B At the same
of Strategic Services (OSS), the fore time, to enhance favorable foreign report
runner of the CIA - has called propa age of the war, the USIA in 1965 started a
ganda �•the arrowhead of penetration" program to encourag_e foreign reporters and
into another country. According to The , writers selected by local USIA posts to
� Report of the oss, Dohovan person visit Vietnam and see the situation first
ally fought for the inclusion of psy hand. At least thirty of these had their
chological warfare techniques as part trip paid for by the USIA. 29
of propaganda. The Vietnam role of USIA in news manage
The euphemistic term "psychological ment.constituted a major violation of the
warfare 1' has been far deadlier in prac rule that USIA materials should not be di
tice tpan it sounds. Since the days of rected at the U.S. public. Since the USIA
the OSS it has at times include d assas controlled all official sources of news in
sinations. This gruesome aspect of psy Vietnam, the, majority of reporting about
war was captured by Stanley Karnow fol the war in the U.S. was, at least, influ
lowing an interview with CIA Colonel enced by the USIA.
Edward Landsdale who directed psywar
operations in Vietnam and the Philip ATTRIBUTION
pines.
"One (Landsdal�-initiated) psywar op
eration played oh the superstitious One criteria used to distinguish "white"
dread in the Philippine countryside of from "black" propaganda is attribution:
the ansuang,a mythical vampire. A psy whether the material identifies its sour
war squad entered the area, and planted ces. ICA/USIA frequently, particularly in
rumors that an ansuang lived.•• where its propaganda operations for foreign gov
the Communists were based. Two nights ernments, and in its utilization of local
later, after giving the rumors time to media contacts, deliberately fails to put
circulate among Huk sympathizers, the its label on its products. In a major 1961
psywar squad laid an ambush for the USIA operation on behalf of the Royal Lao
rebels. When a Huk patrol passed, the government, there was no attribution to
ambushers snatched the last man, punc USIA. This operation included a bi-monthly
tured his neck vampire-fashion with two magazine, wholely USIA-produced, with a
holes, hung his body until the blood distribut�on of 43,000 copies in a country
drained out, and put the corpse back on where the largest newspaper at the time
the trail." (Victor Marchetti and John circulated a mere 3,300 copies. The USIA
D. Marks, The CIA and the Cult of In magazine was identified as coming from the
telligence�.27.)-- -- -- - - Royal Lao government. 30
When the ICA/USIA deliberately fails to
ordination with USIA. In almost every case attribute, or falsifies its source, its
Cdeleten) the military and USIA programs true role becomes close to the CIA-style
are nutually supporting." .26 "gray" or "black" propaganda operations.
JUSPAO's total output of newspapers, mag "USIA might stress its own overt character
azines, posters and pamphlets produced in as against the.covert nature of the CIA,
1970 was put at 24 million plus copies. And but too often its method had to be to gen
that figure excludes the 1.5 billion leaf erate American propaganda without the USIA
lets dropped by the military psychological label, a kind of infiltration of communi
operations units. The JUSPAO budget alone cations. Thus, ·it was not always too dif
was $10.9 million in fiscal year 1970. 27 ferent from the CIA, though it might try
One of USIA's major responsibilities to set itself apart spiritually." 31
within JUSPAO was to "manage the news" in
support of the U.S. war operations. USIA C.I.A. TIES
issued the official news, both military and
political, to correspondents based in Sai
gon and, in some cases, withheld the news. The comparison between the ICA and the
This USIA function as an organ of propagan CIA at various points in this article nat
da and misinformation created a "violent urally provokes a closer scrutiny of their
conflict with�the small corps of young relationship. Unquestionably there are
American correspondents who did not believe
Counterspy - 9
In late 1958, Chiang Kai-Shek moved Farsi (Iranian language) broadcasts by VOA
90,000 Nationalist troops to the islands relay stations located in Greece in Decem
and a U.S. ship was ordered to protect ber 1979. Andreas Papandreou, leader of
their supply lines. Whe_n China bombarded 1the main opposition party said that the
the islands in August, the U.S. threat presence of U.S. propaganda transmitters
ened to intervene, secretly considering in Greece was "most dangerous", and urged
the use of nuclear �eapons. And, the USIA his government to make it clear to the
was there to provide a top secret intel United States that "it has no right to use
ligence estimate for the decisionmak our country for propaganda purposes." 45
ers-. 39 In effect, USIA analyses can ·
"not be told fran CIA appraisals, 6r the · "Voiae of Amer-iaa... tr-ansmitter- time
kind of 'sociological' projects the Pen is a pr-eaious r-esour-ae. Deaisions to add
tagon engaged in••• ". 4 0 or delete language serviaes are aareful
ly made by representatives of Uf[ICA., the
EXPORT PROMOTION State Depar-tment and the National Seau
rity Counail. This group_ deaided to de
vote all available transmitter time to
A major "U•.S. objective" abroad is, of Ir-anian Farsi broadaasts in Apr-il 1979
course, promoting u.s.-based multination (br-oadaasts also heard and u_nderstood by
al corporations. ICA progtams, therefore, eduaated Afghans). Following, the Soviet
include heavy promotion-of U.S. exports invasion of'Afghanistan., time was taken
and corporations. In 1974 the USIA Report fr-om Farsi to make room for- Dari., the
� Congress included a success story lingua fr-anaa of Afghanistan. • • • We
about i�s centers in 26 sub-Saharan Afri will be on the air in Dari next month."
can countries, who "utilized every avail (Miohael Pistor., Direator.,
able·opportunity to boost U.S. commercial Offioe of Congressional and Pub7
exports• " 4l · lio Liaison., I.C.A • ., 8/21/80 in a
In May 1971, a "Talking Paper" was is letter- to the editor of the -- New
sued to all USIA Latin America posts with Yor-k Times)
.questions and answers about U.S. economic
activity there, to help them defend U.S. These attacks are constant reminders
interests mqre effectively. one section that the true goal of the.ICA is to facil
extolled the humanitarian efforts �f such itate and garner support for U.S. foreign
u.s. corporations as Ford Motor CQ., coca pol•icy and the American economic system.
Cola, and United Fruit CO. The "Talking As George Allen, former USIA Director, put\
Paper" did not mention.the extraction of it: "In.many - perhaps all - international
tremendous profits from Latin America by disputes, the program is not that foreign,
these same corporations. 42 · people do· not understand (U.S.) policies.
Progressive people in foreign countries Often they understand them only too well -
have consistently identified ICA facili and do not like them." 46
ties as symbols of U.S. danination of
their nations and ha�e repeatedly at- DEVELOPMENTS TO WATCH
- tacked them as such. To name only a few
recent such attacks: December 1978, Bina
tional centers in three Iranian cities at Wherever possible, U.S. government/cor
tacked, in Shiraz alone the damage porate interests prefer to use the weap
amounted to $50,000J 43 August 1978, mi ons of economic and military aid with
nor damage at an ICA facility in Stock their inevitable attached strings to make
holm, Sweden. on May 17, 1980, police other countries dependent on the U.S.-
clashed with hundreds of demonstrators dominated economic system. ICA is a key
who h�d set fire to a U.S. flag on 1.,he weapon in this strategy. And, in cases
roof of the "Amerika Haus" cultural center where u.s. aid programs have been dras
in West Berlin to protest the annual mili tically reduced or suspended due to the
tary parade by the p.s., France, and Brit- pressure of human rights activists in the
ai�. �4 U.S., ICA has taken u� the slack. As a
The Greek government was forced by in 1977 Congressional team to Latin America
ternal opposition .to deny VOA permission reported, when military and ecdnomic aid
to use an additional frequency for its have been cut, "the attention of U.S. Am-
CounterSpy - 11
bassadors and otjler Embassy officials has identifying and developing close ties with
nrturally focused on the USIS (United foreign nationals who support and benefit
_ states Information service, as USIA was fran a strong u.s. military and econOnlic
known abro�d) program as a resource of · dominance of their country at the expense
last resort - to be utilized in the pro of the independence and ecoRomic well
_motion of U.S. foreign policy objec- being of the majority of the people.
\.ives." 47 ·
�In_areas where the U.S. government is
preparing to use military foree to secure FOOTNOTES
.'its interests - notably the Middle East
iOil regions targeted in the carter doc-
trine speech of January 1980 - ICA's pro 1) u.s. International Ocmmunication Agency
paganda apparatus will be there to back·· Proceedings, . swearing-In � � Director
up'the military action. Preparations are John!.:,_ Reinhardt, April 3, 1978, pp.1-2
, already being made:· for example, the Feb 2) u.s. Int�rnational Camnunicatiori Agency
X11ary 1980 budget for ICA included a re Factsheet, October 1979, p.l, ·
. quest for ·three new ICA posts in strate 3) Alexander 'Kendrick, Prime Time, Little,
. gically located Middle Eastem ·countries: 'Brown & Co., Boston, 1969, p.�
Iraq, Cknan, and Qatar. A'VOA Farsi lan 4) U.S. 'Congress, House Committee on For
guage broadcast was begun - belatedly - . eign Affairs, £:.!.:_ -Information Agendy 9£- _
in March 1979. 48 erations, Hearings before� Subcommittee
In Africa, ICA Director John 1 Reinhardt , � State Department Organizations � �
noted in Febrtiacy 1980, once Zimbabwe eign Operations, Parts ! � g, 91st Con
and Namibia become independent, "they aresi:; _. 2nd session, 1970, p.51.
would represent high-priority opportuni 5) 'l'homas C. Sorenson, "New Directions Un
ties for us and- we would follow tqe op� der.the Kennedy-Administration",
. . ' in ...__
Pro-
portunities." 49 ICA was also hoping to paganda �··El!!�!!!!:_, ed. John B.
expand its branch center
·· in Soweto,
· South Whitton, Public ..Affairs Pre1ss, WashingtQn,
Al'riea·. o.c., 1963, p.66 •.
� 1\mong the new VOA projects is a relay 6) Urban G. Whitaker, Jr., ed. Pro aganda
,· station on the island of Antigua. The · � International J!elations ,- ·Howara - - ' ·
� tr,ansmitter wi:11 _ be placed in th_e u.s. Chandler, Publ·., "san' Francisco, 1960, pp.
; m.i,litary installation there. Un.like other 22-23, 25�
JvoA
I
transmitters, this station , will .7) Wartime Organization� Foreign Infor
; broadcast in medi-um wave and will become mation� Psychol0gical Operations, u.s.
one of the most powerf,ll AM stations in Government Declassified Documents, Library
the Eastern caribbean. of Congress, #254A, pp.S-6.
A major new request in the 1980 budget \8) cf supra #6, p.26.
; was $4. 45 million to develop the Hubert H. 9) cf supra #5, p.681 See also: PresidE!nt
HUlllphrey-Fellowship program "to provide Kennedy "Memo to USIA" in_ u .. s. Congress,
1 mid-career training for young professional Senate Committ�e on Foreign Relations,
; people who are likeiy to become important United states Security Agreements �£2!!!,
. -· public officials of Third i'7orld countrfes mitments·Abroad. Kingdom of�- Hearings
' ••• it holds the promise of forging sig ��subcommittee� o.s. Security
•nificant,links to fu�u:re leaders who might Agreements� Committments _Abroad,�
1 otherwise have no direct expe;-ience with II, 91st Congress. 1st session, 1969, , _
• the United States." SO p.588.
'.. And finally, a major re�onstructing of 10) cf supra, #3, pp.462, _464. ·
I ICA' s res·earch and intelligence operation 11) U.S. International Communication Agen
is taking place-"to sharp�n both the rele cy, Memorandum for Director,. International
vance of our research and ·the speed with communication �cy, from President
which it is conducted" in order to better carter, 3/13/78, p.2.
carry·out the mandate·to advise the Presi 12) L. ·Natarajan, America's Two Pincers,
dent and the�Secretary of State. 51 Pradip Prakashan, I¥cknow, Inci'fa, 1970,
Given the past histOfY of the ICA it is p.2 • ' .
important to watch what role it wil: play, 13) cf supra #4, p.160 •
. particularly ·in these strategic regions� 14) u.ri. Congress, House, Committee on
Clearly, one function will continue
' . '
to ... be Government Operations, _£.:!.:.·Government In-·
l Z - Counterspy '
\
An Afghan proverb says:. 11 You can't hide One of the most contradictory·aspects
a camel under a dressing.gow:p." Likewise; · of u. S .' reporting on Afghanistan is the
even a well orchestrated media campaign on information regarding the Afghan Army.
Afghanistan canriot hide the truth. On Au For instance, the Washington� said on
gust 24, 1980 the Washington� was com January 2, 1980 that: "The Afghan mili
pelled t� admit that quite a few reports tary, estilnated by the United States at
orr Afghanistan - including some in the 80,000 to 90,000 men_ a year ago, was -re-
po�t itself - were p�re fabrication. � .ported to have dwindl�d to no more than
ington � reporter sty-art Auerbach 10,000 or 15,000 effective troops even be
wrote: fore [the ouster of Hafizullah Amin on ne
"Even the best sourced reports on Afghan cember 27, 1979] ••• U.S. analysts ex
fighting produced errors. In the Paki pressed doubt that more tban a few garri�
stani capital of Islamabad in January, a sons with a few hundre� soldiers each are
reliable Western European diplomat told .still capable of functioning." -4 A second·
an inquiring'reporter that his country's Post story _of September 13, 1980, more
embassy in Kabul was reporting heavr than eight months later, reported that:
fighting around the airports, with Sovi "Afghan sources ·say.the size of the Afghan
et Mig fighters seen striking around the Army, once put at 80,000 troops, has dwin
city. dled 'to abou.t 20,000 since �he Soviet in
"In an on-the-record interview later vasion." 5 In other words: from an esti
, that day, P.akistan President Mohammed mated 10,000 to ls,·ooo effective troops in
Zia ul-Haq confirmed and elaborated on December 1979, the.Afghan Army has "dwin
that report on the basis of information dled" in eight months up to about 20,000.
he said he had received. Many of the repo�ts in the U.S. media
11 The Washington'Post, acting on two dif quote "travelers from Afghanistan·• as re
ferent sources, including·one who al� liable sources. Rainer Wolfgrairlll, a corre
lowed his name to be attached to the re spondent for the state-owned ¥est German
port. carried a front page story of the TV network ARD revealed on June 12, 1980
fighting. that the manner in which reports quoting
"The onli' problem · is it never took · travelers are created "is ' always the same.
)
place." . · . · There are four or five reporters at the
Auerbach pointed out reports•bn other airp?rt in New Delhi, who run up to trav
e�ents that probably never took place such elers from Kabul. They are asked to give
a� the 20,obo - some reports said 30,000 - their �pressions, whether there was
"rebels" that "were massing outside Ka shooting, fighting, unrest, how strong the
bul". The Auerbach article also stated soviets .are." 6 Foreign radio reports,
tha� correspondents who were in :i<abul e.g. the BBC, broadcast these travelers'·
early this- year said that "some of the_ impressions back into Afghanistan. People
most hysterical and unre.li,able reports on in Afghanistan talk about them, the story
activities within Afghanistan came from is exaggerated and falsified and: ".The
daily briefings given by American diplo next traveler takes these stories with him
mats." 2 · to Delhi. This way, in a short time, you
In addition to the erroneous stories have huge troop movements and drawn-out
doc;:'8ented by Auerbach, Washington Post fire-battles. Rumors like th�t can be
reporter William Branigan was expelled easily manipulated in the desired direc•
.fr.an.Afghanistan in early January 1980 tion by whoev�r is interested in a certain
along with other journalists for writing type of reporting." 7 Wolfgramm also
"inventions and insinuations, each one pointed out �hat many of the_reports about
more clumsy than the one before." 3 Un "shooting near Kabul" are true since there
daunted, the Post continues to print ar are .firing ranges close fo Kabul airport.
ticles based �ources Auerbach 9alls . Another.widely used source for article13
unreliable. in the u.s� media is st�tements issued
1◄ · CounteztSpy
After U.S. withdrawal from Indochina, Western Europe and the U.S. Not surpr,is
heroin use in the U.S. declined, and Pres ingly,, the unleashing of this flow' coin
ident Carter could brag on January 21, cided with the arrival ot' the CIA on the
1980: "At the beginning of my administra -Afghan-Pakistan border - to support and
tion there were over a half million heroin arm the tribes who were opium producers
addicts in the United States. our contin - all in the name of the fight against
ued emphasis on reducing the supply of ConnnU:nism.
heroin, as well as providing the treat Hoag Levins of the Philadelphia magazine
ments and rehabilitation of its victims, asked a "high level law enforcement offi
has reduced the addict population to cial in Washington" in an off-the-recorp
3 80,000 ",
13 the lowest number in 25 interview about the U.S. government re
years. Reportedly, the supply of heroin sponse to influx of Golden Crescent hero
available in the U.S. had plummeted to a in. He answered:
ten-year low of four metric tons. 14 "Ypu have the administration tiptoeing
By now, the encouraging statistics of around this like it's a land mine. The
January 1980 are ancient history. The her issue of opium and heroin in Afghani
oin supply is on the rise, and its use has stan is explosive•• In the State of the
jumped dramatically. We are, in the words Union speech, the President mentioned
df one high-level law enforcement official, drug abuse but he was very careful to
"about to enter another heroin hell." 15 avoia mentioning Afghanistan, even
This time, the heroin is coming from the though Afghanistan is where things are
Golden Crescent of Southwest Asia. The really happening right now. H� said
Newark Office of the DEA, for one, reports something like he was worried about
that "the known quantities of Golden Cres 'drugs from Iran and Asia', but he spe
cent heroirt on the atreets have suddenly cifically avoided dropping Afghanistan
. jumped � 600%." 16 In Chigaco, the po in there because the White House is
lice reportedly expect a 10 percent in worried that' that will cause the media
crease in add�cts in 1980 because of the to ask an obvious question:'••Why aren't
influx of the Golden Crescent heroin. In we taking a more critical look at the
New York State, admissions to drug treat arms we are now shipping in to gangs of
ment programs are up 26 percent. 17 In drug ru�ners who are obviousty going to
Washington, D.C. medical examiner, James use them to increase the efficiency of
Luke, has recorded an iRCrease in the num ·their drug smuggling operation ?'" 21
ber of deaths from heroin overdose from 7 David G. Canaday, special agent in
in 1978 to 4 3 in the first nine months of charge of the DEA's Washington, D.C. of
1980 �lone. The heroin comes from the· fice,•. has S9ited that the DEA can't do
Golden Crescent, and Dr. Alyce Gulatte of anything about the,heroin influx from the
the Drug Abuse Institute of Howard Univer Golden Crescent because "we have virtually
sity says that it "is destroying the no diplomatic ties in that part of the
city. II 18 world." 2 2 His statement is, at best, c1
Certain parts of Afghanistan have been weak excuse, given the diplomatic ties be
opium country for decades. In a 1972 book, tween the u-.s. and Pakistan. The real rea
Catherine Lamour and Michel Lamberti wrote son for the DEA's inability to prevent the
that: "The poppy is grown ••• along the flow of drugs from the Golden ere.scent is
whole length of the Pakistani border from, that the opium growing tribes are not to
J.alalabad in the north to the important be annoyed because of their opposition to
southern town of Kandahar; also in the Nu the Afghan government. There�ore, the DEA
ristan hills, and in the province of Ba decided to withdraw all of its agents from
dakshan on the Russian border." 19 In the Afghan-Pakistan border area. 23 At the
1972, Afghanistan �snot a major opium same time, the CIA, which is aiding these
exporter to the West. A certain amount was very tribes that grow the poppy for U.S.
smuggled into Iran and Egypt, but Afghani heroin, is expanding its operations. (In
stan and northwestern Pakistan were a July 1980, the DEA also closed its Paris
"source of opium as- yet virtually un office which'was coordinating DEA opera
tapped. II 20 tions in Europe and Southwest Asia.)
That was eight years ago. Now, this The Golden Crescent with its expanding
source has been tapped and heroin produced CIA presence,' produced an estimated 1,000
from Afghan opium flows abundantly into metri,c tons of 9pii.µn in 1979; 3 00 tons in
16 � Counterspy
Afghanistan, and some 700 tons in Paki 3) statement by the Afghan Revolutionary
stan, most of it in the border area. (In Council, as quoted in WP, 1/18/80, p.A-1.
contrast, Me�ico's production was 10 4) WP, 1/2/80, · p.A-4. -
tons.) The ,300 tons of opium produced in 5) WP, 9/13/80, p.A�l9.
Afghanistan translates roughly into 30 6) � quoted in Antiimperialistisches ,!E.::
tons of nearly pure heroin. Some 60 tons formationsbulletin,(West Germany), July
of pure heroin £�om the Golden Crescent August, 1980, p.9.
is now becoming available in the U.S. And 7) ibid.
for the first time, the Afghan opium is 8) ibid.
being exported in large quantities to the 9) WP, 9/5/80.
U.S., thanks to the CIA-supported tribes 10)1\P report from Washington, D.C., as
who are fighting the Afghan government. quoted in The Japan Times, 6/1/80, p.l
The war of. the Afghan "freedom fight 11) Hoag Levins, "The Kabul Connection",
·ers" is a strange "holy war". If you Philadelphia magazine, August 1980, p.196.,
liked the CIA's "secret" war in Laos with 12) ibid.
its resulting" hundreds of thousands of 13) ,ibid., p.114.
heroin addicts at home, you'll love the 14) Newsweek, 3/10/80, p.36.
CIA's "secret" war in Afghanistan. 15) cf supra, #11, p.202.
If you were outraged by Laos, you should 16) ibid., p.203.
cry out and demand immediate Congressional 17) Black Enterprise, August 1980, p.39.
investigation into the heroin. traffic from 18) WP, 9/28/80, p.A-9.
the Afghan-Pakistan border to the U.S. 19) catherine Lamour and Michel Lamberti,
And, ask your local newspaper editor for The International Connection, Pantheon,
the real story of the "holy war" in Af New York, p.191.
ghanistan. 20) ibid., p.177.
21) cf supra, #11, p.202.
FOOTNOTES 22) cf supra, #18.
23) cf supra, #11, p.202.
1) Washington Post (WP), 8/24/80, p.A-21.
2) ibid.
Chemical Warfare in
Afghanistan by Seamus O'faolain
and Dr. Mohanmed Sarkash*
Based on evidence gathered in Kabul and The intent of both these reports and
Washington, o.c., it now appears that a the supplying of chemicals to the "rebels"
branch of the U.S. government has covert - aside from their military use - seems
ly supplied chemical weapons - probably to be two-fold. First, repeated reports
of the type commonly classified as "rion of chemical warfare discredit the Afghan
lethal" - to the-so-called rebels in Af government and are easily blamed on the
ghanistan. The Afghan government has pro Soviet Union. They add substantial
vided photographs and details concerning strength to the anti-Soviet militarism
cannisters and grenades manufactured in growing in the U.S. today. Secondly,
the United States that have been found in these allegations of Soviet chemical war
battle zones in Afghanistan. fare have been used effectively to push
At the same time, the Western media has for enhancement of U.S. chemical warfare
been full of reports of Soviet atrocities, capabilities.
including the use of chemical weapons, in The latter consideration is no small
Afghanistan. As detailed below, U.S. gov matter. At the end of June, 1980 Congress-
ernmental spokespersons have_ done their
best to fuel these reports.
* Seamus O'Faolain and Mohammed Sarkash
are pseudonyms of a U.S. and an Afghan
writer, respectively.
Counte!'Spy - 1?
man Richard Ichord CD-Missouri) offered weapons in 1969. Thus the appropriation of
an amendment to the military construction $3.15 million for a new chemical weapons
bill to earmark $3.15 million for a facto pla,nt is a major breakthrough.
ry to produce a new generation of s�phis
ticated nerve gas weapons. Basing his de THE CHEMICAL WEAPONS RUMOR MILL
fense on reports that the Soviets were
using chemical weapons in Afghanistan and
that they had the best-equipped chemical As early as December 29, 1979 the New
arsenal in the world, !chord passed the, � Times reported that, according to Af
amendment through the House Armed Ser ghan rebels, "the Russians have already
vices Committee with virtually 'no opposi used gas in some attacks." A few weeks
tion. Some ten weeks later, by a 337 to later, on January 23, United Press Inter
22 vote, it passed the full House. national carried a report that "soman, a
The $3.15 million will be used to bu:j.ld · nerve gas first prepared in N�zi Germany
a new binary nerve gas facility in Pine in 1944, had beeb deployed against rebel
Bluff, Arkansas. Binary chemical weapons positions near the northeast cities of
·are so named because they employ two sepa ·Faizabad and Jalalabad and in central
rate agents of relative low toxicity in a -Bamiyan and northern Takhar province. The
,projectile. When the projectile explodes, information was attributed to anonymous
the t�o agents combine and form a highly U.S. intelligence sources", who, in turn
lethal nerve gas. �ccording to the plan had learned about it from a "defecting
envisoned by supporters of-this new binary Afghan Army officer and other'refugees."2
gas program, the Pine Bluff factory will Columnist Jack Anderson, in his March
"produce 155-millimeter artillery rounds 5, 1980 column, had a lot to add to
containing the gas by late 1983 or early stories-of "Soviet invaders••• attacking
1984. Programs for 8-inch rounds, due in guerillas with deadly nerve gases .that
1985 and the 'Bigeye' aircraft-massive even Adolf Hitler balked at using." Ac
bomb, being developed jointly by the Navy cording to Anderson, "Russians are using
and the Air Force for production in 1986, gases to flush the fierce mountain men
,will follow." 1 out of the caves and crevices where they
The chemicals to be produced; Sarin and are holed up." Anderson's sources are of
GB, ·are devastatingly lethal. A quart of "high" quality: "intelligence specialists
GB at its maximum effect" could kill ,one ••• a U.S. dip+omat••• the Defense Intel
million persons. ligence Agency••• Pentagon sources••• in
telligence feports••• a key intelligence
"The current U.S. _stock:pi-Ze of chemical, source•••• intelligence agencies••• a top
weapons includes three million artille-ly secret CIA analysis••• one top secret CIA
)
shells, a few thousand aerial bombs and publication, the Weekly -S:urveyor •••"
several hundred thousand land mines. On April 7, 1980, Secretary of Defense
Mo;t of these are fiUed with G nerve Harold Brown decided to contribute to the
agents, an organophospoorous compound chemical rumor mill. In a speech in Los
that is od.orless, invisible and devas , Angeles,'he stated that "there is mo�t
tatingly lethal. A microscopic dt>o� ing evidence that the Soviets are using
landing on a person's body will, within incapacitating gas - and some reports
fifteen minutes, cause conaentration of that they may be using lethal gas - in ,
the pupils, headaches, vomiting, uncon the Afghan countryside." 3 As time went
t11dlled defecation and urination, musau on, it lbecame more·and 1 m,ore obvious that
Zar convulsions, coma, and shortly af neither �he CIA, the·Pentagon, nor the
te!'I.Jards, death." (The-Nation, ?/5/80, state l)eparttnent had any convincing evi-,'j
. , dence that So'V'iet ttoops were using chem
p.12) .
"The U.S. AT'rrty today possesses about ical weapon;s in Afghanistan-. Said a CIA • ,
300,000 tons of gas, two-thirds of it spokespeirWn>,: "There is no firm scientif
nerve agents." (The Progressive,. Sept. ic evidehce-1 "t�at t Soviet troops) used L .J
that lethal chemical agents had been using U.S. chemical weapons and there are
used." However, if these reports were some incidents which add substance to the
true, the State Department "would regard claims that u.s.-supplied chemical warfare
such use as outrageous and inhumane." 5 is taking place.
Addressing the State Department's con On June 6, 1980 the water supply of two
tinuing reports of that kind, Julian Kabul schools was poisoned. Later in June,
Perry Robinson of Sussex University, a a gas was released in a Kabul girls'
world authority on chemical warfare, school which left a number of students
said: "It is not clear why the State De unconscious for several hours in Kabul
partment should have referred to a plural hospitals. Chemical analysts identified
ity and persistence of reports." 6 the gas as a herbicide capable of causing
The New Statesman added: "Such reports severe damage to the human body. The "reb
certainly have one effect: once launched els" blamed the attacks on the Soviets and
the smear story is difficult to deflect, the Afghan government blamed them on the
and these allegations are likely to cause "tebels".
Moscow deep embarrassment, particularly in
its relations to developing countries. But EVIDENCE OF U.S. CHEMICAL WARFARE
equally important is the impact they have ---- - -- ---- ----
on publ�c and official opinion in the
west," In a press conference on June 3, 1980
As Counterspy goes to press, the State the Afghan government displayed a number
Department and the CIA have yet to come up of weapons it said were captured from the
with concrete evidence of Soviet use of "rebels". Among these weapons were several
any sort of chemical weapons in Afghani chemical bombs marked "CDS 517, Made in
stan. It is important to note too, that U.S.A.". In this press conference tele
the Carter administration still feels that vised in Western Europe, the Afghan gov
their evidence is insufficient to merit ernment also showed chemical cannisters
pressing formal charges against the Soviet recovered from the fighting which were
union. Nevertheless, the State Depart made in the U.S. The French newspaper
ment's assertions continue. In a 124-page L'Humanite reported on August 25, ·1980
August 1980 report the St�te Department that after fighting in the town of Ghazni,
stated: "In Afghanistan, we regard it as "Afghan soldiers recovered chemical ae
highly likely that Soviet forces have used vices labeled �Mll2' and bearing the in
some form of chemical agents in their ef structions: 'Beware, poison. Do not heat.
forts to suppress Afghan resistance. And Releases poison gases.'" lO L'Humanite
there are a number of refugee reports that also notes that "at the beginning of April
the Soviet forces have used i�capacitant the Afghan forces also discovered two an
and lethal chemical agents." ti-tank bombs which on detonation dis
undersecretary of State Uatthew Nimetz persed poison gases. They were made in the
found the ideal wording for State Depart United States and carry the label RKT
ment P'1rposes. According to him, "the 83 mm heat blindicide Ml2." 11
chances are about even that lethal agents The cannisters that the Afghan govern
have or have not been used by Soviet ment displayed in its press conference in
forces in trying to suppress the Afghan early. June 1980 carried the imprint: "Made
resistance." 9 in U.S.A. Federal Laboratories, PA", and
Accounts about the use of chemical weap contained a tear gas type substance. (In
ons in the Afghan coU'lltryside have, so discussing chemical warfare, it is impor
far, come almost exclusively from Afghan tant to note the distinction between le
refugees in Pakistan. The refugees have thal chemical weapons and so-called "ir
not been able to provide any hard evidence ritants" which are lethal only in high
- e.g. shells containing chemicals or doses. It seems that most of the weapons
traces of chemicals. United Nations offi labeled "Made :!..n U.S.A." were not of the
cials and other organizations working with kind commonly called "lethal".)
the refugees likewise have not come up Located in Saltsburg, Pennsylvania, Fed
with any evidence. eral Laboratories, Inc. is a subsidiary of
In contrast, the Afghan government has Breeze Corporation of Union City, New Jer
been very careful in its attempt to pro sey. Federal Laboratories, which has a Py
vide documentation that the "rebels" are rotechnics Division where it produces am-
CounterSpy - 19
"At a glance, I can smell where And riots mean money for Federal Labo
trouble's brewing in the world ••• In my ratories. That was evident in good sales
business, that's important," said Harry during the 1960's and early 1970's when
Wells of Federal Laboratories to Wall tear gas was in high demand by U.S. po
Street Journal reporter George Get'sc'how. lice in their clashes with demonstrators.
In an August 2, 1978 article, Getschow · When.the war was over, more austere
writes that whenever Wells learns of a times began for the canpany.
"signiCicant new trouble spot, he dis Canmented Frank MacAloon, editor of
patches a sales man to the area to sniff the police trade publication Law and Or
out the new business." der, "When peace came to the u.s.;-t�
Federal Laboratories' plant in Salts tear gas business pretty much dried up•••
burg "is secluded along a winding road It's like cockroaches - if you don't
in the foothills of the Allegheny Moun have them, you don't need roach killer."
tains, about 40 miles fran Pittsburg. (In the early 1970's, Federal Laborato
Surrounded by barbed wire fence and ries also encountered other difficulties
armed guards, the 150 acre complex re when it was ordered by a court to pay
sembles a military outpost. $240,000 in damages to a South carolina
"The plant consists of 70 tiny, tin prisoner who was blinded in both eyes by
roofed buildings widely scattered on a Federal's high quality tear gas.)
hillside to lessen the effect of any ex By now, however, the tear gas business
plosion. Included are research laborato seems to be recovering. In his 1979 �
ries and a training center where lawmen !!!:!!!. Report � � Shareholders , Breeze
come to learn about the latest in chemi corporation President Joseph J. Mascuch
cal weaponry••• Security is tight. Fed reported a 56 percent increase in the
eral wouldn't allow a reporter to tour net income of Breeze as a whole and, as
the factory." fas as Federal Laboratories is concerned:
In an interview with Ge.orge Getschow, "Sales of our Pyrotechnics Division at
Wells was optimistic about business op Federal Laboratories, Inc. were down
portunities in the future, as far as do from last year's peacetime record be
mestic sales of tear gas are concerned. cause of changes in the world demand•••
"I can see us heading into another peri and some difficulties in obtaining ex
od like the 1960's••• People may not be port lidenses for military and police
' starving, but right now there is 20% un pyrotechics. Although the profit-to-sale
employment in some urban areas, and ratio fell off slightly, Federal Labora
that's a damn good ingredient for a tories still maintained healthy gross
riot." and net margins."
munition, also lists among its products Wells, Vice President, did not want to
"tear gas, police equipment, bullet proof talk about that or anything else, was
vests, organic chemicals, and metal de nasty, and hung up. Federal Laboratories,
tectors." 12 incidentially, has been conducting train
Seymour Hersh, in his 1968 book Chemical ing courses for police officers, private
!!!2. Biological Warfare says Federal Labo security firms, and U.S. intelligence of
ratories is a "chemical company" now han ficers. 15
dling CBW (chemical-biological weapons) In response to a written question in
procurement contracts with the Department the April, 1980 House of Representatives
of Defense, l3 and the Pentagon's list of hearing on chemical weapons, Undersecre
prime contractors• for fiscal year 1979 tary of State Nimetz noted:
registers Federal Laboratories as having "The United States categorically denies
contracts with the Department of the Army that it has ever supplied any type of
worth $326,000. As of 1978, Federal Labo chemical weapon or agent to any of the
ratories was the world's largest producer parties in the Afghan conflict. In the
of tear gas. 14 past, the united States supplied to
The telephone receptionist at Federal governments with which it has had secu
Laboratories upon hearing of our interest rity relationships non-lethal agents of
in chemical weapons from Federal Labora the type widely used in the world for
tories in Afghanistan, saids "You have to maintaining public order. Many such
talk with Mr. Wells about that." Harry agents are also readily available can-
BO - Countel'Spy
radar sites and the qeployment of ground ry; they say that "there is no reason why
and air forces", which "could e�plain the there should not be friendly relations be
surprise achieved by Iraq in the first air tween the two countries once the ayatol
raids on Tehran and the armored thrusts lah's regime falls. This would be the in-·
toward Abadan and Khurremshahr." However, evitable result of defeat by Iraq." 8
"there is no evidence that they have Similar estimates have appeared in the
formed a combat force", according to these U.S. press; David Hirst, for one, wrote in
sources.4 the Christian Science Monitor about the
The London generals, on the other hand, same time that a victory for Iraq would
claim that Oveissi "commands over 5,000 severely discredit the ruling clerics\
Iranian dissident troops fighting in West among almost all segnfents of the Iranian
ern Iran ag�inst forces loyal to Ayatollah population and surely drive them from
Khomeini." ·They claim, for example, that power.
"the Kurdish town of Qasr-e-Shirin ••• has Iran claµns that the U.S. has been se
fallen to the advancing Iraqi and Iranian cretly involved in the war. U.S. officials
dissident troops." 5 An article in the themselves have suggested a partial ex
West German weekly Stern claims that planation for these claims that is very
Oveissi's operations are even larger: revealing but appears only in a few press
"Some 45,000 soldiers who deserted are now reports. Unnamed U.S. officials said on
being trained for the hour X in about 20 September 22 that "many Iranian opponents
camps along the Iraqi border." The Iraqi of Ayatollah Khomeini are known to have
government has been widely reported in the traveled between Iraq and the United
past to be supporting such camps. stern States." 9 A related, but even more sig.:.
reports that another 25,000 soldiers are nificant, and, if true, more damning
waiting in Bahrain and Qnan, and another charge has been made by Iranian President
3,000 in �gypt. 6 Bani Sadr. He told the Le Mende correspon
Plans appear to be imminent for a move dent in Iran that the Iranian government
by these forces. On July 7 it was reported had purchased a document detailing a meet
that when "asked about the·timetable for ing in Paris among Iraqis, Iranian exiles,
action, virtually all opposition figures and U.S. and Israeli military experts at
agreed that the blow must fall within a which planning for the attack on Iran took
matter of months if the rising wave of place. Flora Lewis cited Bani Sadr's
communism in Iran is to be quelled." 7 charge in her October 10, 1980 column in
Stern reports that an attack is scheduled
by Oveissi's forces on October 26. And
-----
the New York Times.
On June 12, 1980 the New York Times re-
the London generals, "under the leadership ported that GenE:ral Gholam Oveissi "was
of Field Marshall Aryana, a former Chief able to visit the United States recently,
of Staff of the Iranian armed forces under seeking to unify Iranian exile groups
the Shah", were reported on September 26 here." lO But only by reading the Farsi
to be setting up a committee "with the aim language Name-Ye Ruz, published in Paris
of making contingency preparations for (or the July 22, 1980 Foreign Broadcast
what they see as the imminent collapse of Information Service, in which a transla
the Islamic Republic in Iran. The generals _tion appears), does one learn that Oveissi
••• are confidently predicting the visited the U.S. "after a trip to Bagh
Khomeini regime in Tehran will be toppled dad." 11 On July 9, 1980 the Atlanta con
in a military coup within 48 hours. As stitution reported that Oveissi "fled to
part of their plans, they are considering the United States after his ouster in
chartering an aircraft to fly them to Teh 1979. Since then, he has relocated his ex
ran." These plans seem to indicate a ile field command in Paris••• But he has
great deal of advance planning with the. frequently returned to the United States,
Iraqis. most recently in June •••" The Constitution.
The analysis of the war given by the also reports that Oveissi "is known to
Bakhtiar people is th.at there are "no es have visited Iraq", and the suggestion is
sential differences" between Iran and that he has done so numerous times. As re
Iraq, and "that it was largely because the cently as September 26, five days after
ayatollah had been seeking to expor� his the start of heavy fighting between Iraq
Islamic revolution across the border that and Iran, the London Times reported that
the troubles had started. " Bakhtiar' s . Oveissi "has just returned from the United
people have an interest in an Iraqi victo- States to Iraq." Recall that th� � York
_
Counterspy - 23
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Time• places him in Iraq just.prior to "were reluctant to_ talk about these dis
this time. Thus he would have been in the cussions/'. 14 And AI).drew Whitley, writing
' u.s., having come from Iraq, .a few days in the July 30 Financial Times, claimed
before or at the time of the outbreak,of that the Carter administration has had
the fighting, which he seems to have beeri contacts with the Bakhtiar faction. Henry
involved in planning. It has not been re Eason�eported that th�re is "evidence of
ported who he met with in the U.S. at this some discussion between Western govern
time, although it is known that he met ments and the opposition leaders, but none
with carter administration people in June that Westerners.would acknowledge." He
1980. (See below.) also said that "no outward evidence of
It must be kept iri mind·that on April 7, Western assistance to the counterrevolu
1980 President carter issued sanctions tionaries could be confirmed,�though it
against Iran that included the revocation was reliably learned that some Western
of all American visas held by Iranian na governments maintain open lines of commu
tionals. Thus Iranians could not enter the nication with opposition camps." 15
U.S. unless they came under one of three However, the distinction between ass�s
categories of exceptions: those applying tance· and non-assistance is not so easy to
for and receiving political asylum in the make, especially given recent events. At
U.S.; those with close relatives in the · the time of OVeissi's June visit to the
U.S.; and those needing emergency medical U.S., American officials achnowledged that
treatment. An additional exception was the Carter administration has allowed the
made for the Shah's family, under an exile groups to .operate within the U.S.
agreement reached between the U.S. govern and has '\not sought to discourage polit
ment and the Shah before he 1eft the U.S. ical activities '', while having "backed
for Panama in January, 1980. off from offering any support for Gener,1
How then has Oveissi been permitted to OVeissi or other exiles", but only "for
enter the U.S. after April 7, and why? fear of antagonizing Tehran and further
The New York Times reported that it was jeopardizing the lives of the 53 American
because"iie"°applied for political asylum hostages there." 16 Geoffrey Godsell obs
w�en he left Tehran in early 1979 for Par served that the continued detention of the
is, where·he now lives", 12 but this hostages is viewed by the Iranian feaders
wo�ld not be a suff�cient reason under as serving as a degree of control against
Carter's regulations. Perhaps more to the any U.�.-backed coup attempt. 17
pcp-nt is Henry Easton's report in the�� Along the same line, Andrew Whitley
lata Constitution that. according to "State wrote in tpe Financial Times on July 10,
Department officials, Iranians who can 1980: "With the-fate of the 53 1\merican
demonstrate that they are truly fleeing -hostages in Iran very much in the balance
from persecution in their homeland or · Washington will want to move with cautio_n
those whose-presence would be in the na in its dealings with the embryonic opposi
tional interest are often given visas to tion movement. Depending on how the inter
live and work in ttre United States ••• nal dynamics of.Iran work themselves out
'We're not letting people in just for this summer and autumn, this posture may
their convenience, ' one State Department change." Already on July 30, however,
official said." 13 Since Oveissi has been Whitley was able to disclose that American
living in Paris, he is not "Weing from contacts had been ·established with the
persecution"; and if it is not for his OV_eissi f�ction
-. \
and the
- Bakhtiar -faction
"convenience" that he is allowed to enter,'• (tlje two.;main groups of Iranian exiles or---
it �ust be ,for some U.S. interest. ganizing �o qverthrow the_Islamic Repub
OVeissi said at the time of his June lic), altllg1,1gh he reports that "this does
visit that'"he did not plan t9 meet.with not mean :�a:t1 ,those groups have been re
any Carter Administration aides ,during his cogniied �-J: ;,t.h�t help has been extended
current visits." Carter aides had repeat directly ·to them °'" Yet he 1 adds: "On the
edly denied contac_ts with the Iranian op other hand, they would be considered much
position. However, the New York Times re more credible.and therefore deservinq more
portecl that in Washington, "officials con- serious attention if, somehow, the two ri
firmed that they had met with aides of vals were to join forces. That message has
General Oveissi on what one called 'a pe:ir already been put acro1:1s."
sopal basis'" although these officials The message from U.S. officials was ap-
,
/
24 - Counterspy
Originally, U.S. officials had predicted make a point-blank denial, but described
that Iraq's objectives would be limited; the initial report as "irresponsible and
Christopher's statement expressed "concern misleading." 28 It is reported that the
that the••• conflict was spreading beyong broadcasts "indicated support" for
original estimates." 20 Bakhtiar and "included a call for 'libera
Among the nations that would probably tion of lran', a description of Ayatollah
support Bakhtiar's "government-in-exile" Khomeini as 'racist and fascist' and an
would be Egypt. Given U.S. ties to Egypt, appeal to Iranians to 'take guns into your
this fact is important for the understand hands' in-preparation for action."
ing of U.S. involvement. In addition to It is also known that the CIA has been
the Stern report about Oveissi's soldiers involved with another attempt to discredit
there, it is reported that Egyptian Presi the Khomeini regime. It arranged for the
dent Anwar Sadat met with Oveissi in mis-translation and publication of a book
May, 21 and a number of exiled officers by Khomeini on Islamic government. The
are known to live in cairo and to have book was translated into English to make
left there for Baghdad in the weeks prior Khomeini's views appear more extreme than
to the war. (see above). Of course, the they are; people who have read both the
late Shah and his associates lived in original:. and the ttanslation say that the
Egypt; Sadat and the Shah consulted regu parts of the latter bear little resem
larly; Sadat gave him a state funeral; and blance to the former. Excerpts of the book
the Shah's trip to Egypt from Panama was were syndicated in a number of newspapers
arranged at least in part by the U.S. 2? throughout the u.s. early in 1980.
On September 25, Sadat told reporters These two covert operations by them
"that the fighting between Iraq and Iran selves completely discredit carter admin
was a perfect opportunity for the Iranian istration denials of involvement in ef
Army to overthrow the Tehl!an regime of forts to destabilize the Khomeini govern
Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and he said ment. They become even more important,
that the United States should support such moreover, when placed alongside the con
a takeover." 23 tacts with opposition forces, contacts
The U.S. State Department disassociated which the administration has also denied
itself from Sadat's remarks, questioning or downplayed, especially given the heavy
only the means.and not the end: "We oppose involvement of these forces in the Iraqi
the violent overthrow of any government, war effort and its aim of unseating the
including the Khomeini regime," a spokes Iranian government.
person, Jack cannon, said. 24 (It has to
be added here that the U.S. government has
nothing in principle against coups; just
several weeks before the White House had
given its approval to the coup staged by FOOTNOTES
the Turkish military several days before
it occurred. 25) Sadat's statements
surely reflect certain top-level thinking; 1) see Foreign Report, 7/16/80; and The
his mistake was to say it publicly. Middle East, August 1980, p.24.
Jack cannon's remark is further ironic 2) New� Times (NYT), 9/ 27/80, p.4.
in light of the disclosure that the CIA is 3). FT, 9/20100, p.:r:-
"responsible for clandestine radio broad 4> cf supra, #2.
casts aimed at undermining the Iranian 5) The Times (London), 9/26/80.
rule" of Khomeini and originating fr.om 6) Stern (West Germany), 9/25/80.
transmitters in Egypt, "one believed to be 7) Atlanta constitution (AC), 7/_7/80, p.l.
8) The Times (London), 9/24/80, p.7.
near Alexandria and th·e other near the
Suez canal." 26 The broadcasts originated 9) NYT, 9/23/80, p.l.
with a "White House request" to Sadat, and 10)mT, 6/1 2/80, p.1 2.,
_he agreed. It is reported that a "senior 11) �e-Ye Ruz (Paris), 7/ 21/80, as
official" even tacitly confirmed that quoted in Foreign Broadcast Information
Americans were involved by commenting that Service, 7/22/80.
the Iranian authorities "haven't come to 1 2)cf supra, #10.
us yet about it. If they do, we would do 13) AC, 7/10/80, p.llA.
26 - Counterspy
WARRICK, James M.
b. 10/31/37
Warrick has served in Kenya, Malawi and
Senegal.
New Hebrides:
Independent at Last by Konrad· Ege
A new nation was born on July 30, 1980: called the New Hebrides. Eventually, they
The Republic of Vanuaatu, formerly the New decided on an unprecedented settlement:
Hebrides, a chain of some eighty islands the islands would become a "condominium"
in the South Pacific. The significance of - a joint colony of Britain and France.
Vantaatu's independence is comparable to The colonial powers crushed the last re
the importance Grenada's revolution has sistance of the original Melanesian in
for the Caribbean. Vanuaatu's independence habitants and set up two colonial systems:
was achieved only after a long struggle a French and a British commissioner ,' two
and considerable oppositior from the colo police forces, two educational systems,
nia� French government, French settlers, two legal systems, two immigration author
and' a group of rightwing o.s. citizens ities, etc.
connected to the U.S. Libertarian Party After the French colony of Algeria
who wanted to transform the New Hebrides gained its independence in 1962, several
into a tax haven with a laissez�faire hundred former French-colonists from Alge
economy. ria who opposed the independence, moved to
over the last centuries the people of the New Hebrides. Many of them belonged to
the New Hebrides have experience� a tre or were connected with the Secret Anny Or
mendous amount of suffering. An::ijstimated ganization (OAS}, a rightwing terrorist
original. population of one mill,l:on was group which had fought General de Gaulle's
almost wiped out by slave txcil;d,e,il massa decision to negotiate Algeria's indepen
cres, and foreign diseases to w}tich the dence after years of war. The OAS members
islanders had no resistance. Missionaries were soon to find a renewed pretext to re
cmd French and British colonists moved in sort to terrorist activities when indepen
and settled on the islands. dence "threatened" in the New Hebrides.
At first, the two colonial powers - who In 1�71, the National Party (NP} was
had already divided up the Pacific islands formed in the New Hebrides. Its goal was
into their respective holdings - couldn't independence within six years. In 1975,
agree who was to get the prize that they the French and British governments agreed
Counterspy - 2?
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
to general elections. In spite of its 59 ritu Santo and per.haps· sOllle other islands
_percent share of the votes, the NP did not which could be used as a tax haven. More
gain a'majority in the Representative As concretely, they were interested in form
sembly1 because of a neo-colonial provision ing the first Libertarian state.
which reserved a certain number of seats This effort was spearheaded by Michael
1
for busin�ss groups and white residents. Oliver, a real estate millionaire -of
In 1977 the NP, then renamed Vanuaaku Pati carson City, Nevada. Oliver had made two
(VP) established the People's Provisional previous attempts to establish Libertari
Government and boycotted renewed undemo an states. The more promising had been in
cratic elections. The ,VP called on the the Bahamas in 1973 which were on the
people to resist the colonial authorities, verge of independence. With the help of
take over plantation�, stop paying taxes, some discontented white settlers, Oliver
and refuse the colonial officials entry attempted to split the island of Abaco
into their villages. from the Bahamas, and an "Abaco Indepen
The strategy, succeeded, 1 and forced new dence Movement" (AIM) was formed. Oliver
elections in November 1979. Even though teamed up with Mitchell Livingston
the'French coloniali�ts tried to buy votes WerBell, a firearms dealer from Georgia,
again�t the VP, the party won two-thirds who was described in Esquire �agazine as
of the seats in the Assembly and 63 per- a "friend of dictators and CIA agents
C'ent of the votes. · Cand] manipulator of the luck of srg,all
After these elections had made abundant �ations •••" According to the 1975r
ly clear that the majority of the peopl� Esquire arti�le, Oliver and WerBell also
in the New Hebrides suppbrted the nation worked with former CIA pgents and set up
alist VP, the French government b�gan to a high powered radio stiation on Abaco.
move towards "postponementtt of indepen "Independence activists" were given para
dence� Clearly, the French were worried military training courses on WerBell's
abdut the rest of their colonial holdings Georgia facilities.
in the Pacific: New caledoni�, a 7)400 In the end, the planned Abaco state
square mile island to the southwest of the never materialized. The Bahamas govern
- New Hebrides which contains one of the ment banned AIM, barred Oliver and his
world's biggest nickel deposits, and Poly friends from entering the country, and
nesia, where France has_ its prized test seized a cargo of arms being smuggled to
zone for nuclear weapons. Abaco. Oliver's plans received no support
"At stake for France .is mere than simply from the U.S. government either: the ex
national pride," the Melbourne � com isting government of the Bahamas was
mented on April 28, 1980. "!!'he over-riding quite satisfactory for U.S. purposes.,
realistic fear is that independence in New Back in 1971, Oliver had bought land in
Hebrides will spell the beginning of the the New Hebrides_. There, he got together
end of that Franch Pacific empire, and all with Jimmy Stevens and Hawaiian land de
that involves economically and strategi veloper Eugene Peacock, who had bought
call;{." land there to settle 4,000 U.S. veterans
On several of the islands, the French in what was to become a "New Hawaii".
OAS began to mount an anti-independence Stevens was provided with a radio sta
terror campaign. French settlers (who tion, and through the Phoenix Foundation
owned 80 per cent of the arable land) hundre�s of thousands of dollars were
staged a rebellion on the island of Espi channeled to Stevens' group. The �hoenix
ritu Santo and intimidated VP supporters Foundation is headed by Oliver, his law-
· with virtual impunity as the French colo ·yer Thomas Eck, and Dr. John Hospers, a
nial police stood by. The settlers were professor at the University of califor
supported by a few hundred Melanesians on nia.who ran for U.S. President in 1972 on
the northern island of Espiritu Santo led the Libertarian Party ticket. According
by Jimmy Stevens, and on Tanna island in to Thomas Eck, the Phoenix Foundation "is
the'South. Stevens had been claiming for there to help anyone who wants to secede
_years that he was the legitimate tradi in a libertarian manner." (Tribune,. Lon-·
tional leader of several islands, even don, 6/13/80)
though his parents were immigrants. Oliver went so far as to provide
Stevens became involved with a number of Stevens with a ready-made constitution for
people from· the U.S. w.hose singl,e interes.t the new country based on his 1968 book A
was to form a secessionist state on Espi- � Constitution for!. N�w Country, which
, 2 8 - Coun teroSpy .
Hand Bank in Los Angeles was Guy Pauker, According to The Australian, the Nugan
an Asia specialist for the Rand Corpora- Hand Bank was also used as "a secret slush
tion with strong ties to the CIA. 18 fund organization to channel CIA money in-
Given this incredible line-up of person- to pro-American political parties in Eu
nel, it is no surprise that the Nugan Hand rope••• Millions of dollars were secreted
Bank was involved in a number of CIA-con- into the bank's Australian operations be
nected projects, including the resettle- fore being sent to Europe." The Austra-
ment of Indochinese refugees in Latin lian goes on to say that the Christian
America and the caribbean. In arranging Democratic Party in Italy was one of the
this project, Nugan got in touch with recipients of the money. 19 (One of
high-ranking U.S. government officials. William Colby's initial CIA assignments
The Tribune reported on August 27, 1980: was providing money to the Italian Chris-
"Frank Nugan met (lrimml) carter {}:hen a tian Democrats in the April, 1948 elec
presidential candidattil on September 26, ,tions.) Other reports indicate that the
1976. The meeting was arranged by John CIA channeled covert founds to Southeast
Golden, a close friend of top carter Asia through the Nugan Hand Bank. 20
aide Hamilton Jordan. (Later on,] a re- According to an unnamed "former Nugan
tired general, Earl Kocke, sold the Hand executive", the CIA also transferred
White House a Nugan Hand plan to take $2,400,000 to the Australian Liberal Party
over a former U.S. naval base in the in 1973 through a mining company associat-
caribbean: Grand Turk Island. Nugan ed with Frank Nugan. At the time, the
Hand planned to use it as a transit Nugan Hand Bank was just being formed.
camp for resettling Meo refugees from William Colby was Director'of the CIA, and
Laos. The White House agreed to the the CIA was very upset about what was go-
plan in February (1980] - after Frank ing on in Australia at the time: the Labor
Nugan's death. The collapse of Nugan government of Prime Minister Whitlam had
Hand Bank killed the plan. The transit come to power in December 1972. Unlike the
camp on Grand Turk Island was part of a previous Liberal (that is, conservative)
larger CIA plan to resettle the Meo in Party government, the Labor Party sub-
Latin America. The Meo, traditional jected Australia's intelligence agencies
opium growers from the Laos hills, were and the CIA's activities in Austr�lia to
used as mercenaries by the CIA in the scrutiny. On November 11, 1975 the Whitlam
Laos war." government was dismissed by arch-conserva-
tive Governor General John Kerr, who used
The Nugan Hand Merchant Bank was not an "archaic constitutional power never be
the only CIA-connected bank reg�stered fore exercised." 21 The dismissal came on
in a tax haven island in the caribbean. ly three days after the CIA served an ul
Another such bank was Castle Bank and timatum to ASIO (Australian Security In
Trust in Nassau, Bahamas. In a copy telligence Organization, the CIA's coun
righted article on April 18, 1980, the terpart in Australia) that it would break
Wall Street Journal reported that dur links if public discussion continued on
ing the early 1970's the Castle Bank CIA funding of conservative political
was being investigated by the Internal parties in Australia.
Revenue Service (IRS) and the Justice James•Jesus Angleton, who retired from
Department in what was likely to become the CIA in December 1974 after 31 years of
"the single biggest tax-evasion strike" service� was asked by Australian Broad
in IRS history. Uno.er pressure from the casting Company reporter Ray Martin on
CIA, however, the Justice Department June 12, l977 whether the CIA had ever
and the IRS dropped the investigation funded Au'stralian political parties.
because - according to the Wall Street. Angleton evaded a direct answer, but con
Journal - castle Bank "was the conduit ceded that such activities, if undertaken
for millions of dollars earmarked by would have been "coordinated with the
the CIA for the funding of clandestine chief of Australian internal security." 22
operations against Cuba and for other Although all of the above information
covert intelligence operations". And, has already been made public, the Nugan
some of the anti-Cuban operations were Hand affair (or "Nugangate", as it is re
carried out "by CIA operatives working ferred to in Australia) has yet to come to
from Andros Island (_Bahamas] ••• be an end. On the orders of Australian Prime
tween 1964 and 1975."
32 - Counterspy
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Approved F_or Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Minister Malcolm Fraser, a joint commis 4) Sydney Morning Herald, 8/23/80, p.3.
sion of federal and New South Wales state 5) cf supra, #1
police are presently conducting an inves� 6) Weekend Australian, 8/16-17/80, p.l.
tigation. But the question is how hard 7) Tribune, 8/6/80, pp.1,2.
they are looking. so far; most of the in 8) Wall Street Journal, 5/1/80, p.31.
formation has been uncovered by courageous 9) cf supra, ,#1.
Australian investigative journalists. With 10) cf supra, #3.
their continued work, the truth of the 11) ibid.
Nugan Hand affair will be told. 12) ibid.
13) ibid.
14) ibid.
FOOTNOTES 15) cf supra, #2.
16) cf supra, #3.
17) The Australian, 9/1/80, p.l.
1) London Sunday Times, 8/31/80, as 18) cf supra, #3; Tribune, 8/27/80, p.2.
quoted in Boston Sunday Globe, 9/7/80, 19) cf supra, #17.
p.42. 20) cf supra, #1.
2) Tribune, 7/30/80, p.8. 21) Denis Freney, The CIA's Australian
, 3) National Times (Australia), 8/10-16/80, Connections, Sydney;-197.7, p.26.
pp. 1,31. 22) ibid., p.29.
ORDER NOW
CounterSpy
SPECIAL PAPERS
�Penetration�� Police Depart
ments ( $2. 00)
•
•11111 11111- ■ • !ill
•
:'.: ·1• 'l■■ "' lilll!i
iU111 ■ • i■•il'S-lil
llllll!iil 11H·1n!!1 · •
Add 15% for postage.·Prepaid orders
AGAINST THESample
WALL
i j :C II
Iii.al
' ··- · only.
ll.[ ..,.
------
Please sel'NI me additional Information.
University Microfilms
International
300 North Zeeb Road . A magazine of sett-liberation and voluntary
Dept. P.R.
$�
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106 alternatives.
U.S.A.
18 Bedford Row
Dept. P.R.
London, WC1R 4EJ
_____________________
England AGAINST THE WALL
P.O. Box 444, Westfield, NJ 07091
,._
Name ________
lf:'Stltutlon _______
Street ___�-----'--
City ________ Mkat --------------------
State _____ Zlp __
City _______ s_ _______ Ziili,-----
Counter-Spy - 33
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
, Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
SIGN
in Wilmington junkyard: GUARANTEED DESTRUCTION OF CONFIDENTIAL RECORDS
though beautiful to know,you
in the biblical sense
and then some
coming down
from thoughts of you
my eyelids-insides
warm my cornea
but shut out light,
as more heat than, kept us warm
in our emotional drawing together
personal romantic in the cold war
relationship darkness which
justifying for pushing
its conflagation up through
i love you it did not
goodbye provide the light
though
i will still - cry
at thoughts f
of you gone
and the sun
comes up on your face
later
i'm touching country
N.H.
it 1 s invoking you
in anti-CIA
Afghanistan to Mississippi
me
now i'm in Princeton
still
your thread continues - \
you see
we'll walk
the beach
for it's where
anti-trivialists
past present
abide
to bring future
into now all else being trivial
than we'll deep six into sleep
to hear ourselves away from
elephantine sounds of Lilliputian minds
still, it all cbines out
to Geo,rge Jackson's assassination l_
despite our innocence
it's hard to love
knowing it happened
and Richard Helms said he did it: "out of the goodness of my heart."
when he trained Chicago cops who murdered_Hampton and Clark.
by John Kelly
"I may want to commit a crime someday, In time the "confusion" was resolved,
and I understand that a criminal is sup and Ambrogio entered the country where he
posed to leave fingerprints at the scene." edited an antifascist Italian language
This was my explanation to the young woman newspaper, useful to the war effort. But
in the polic� station when she asked why I the.day I was in the Justice building on
wanted a set of my prints. his behalf I didn't get out before I saw
The officer gulped. For a moment I what I assumed was a stage prop left os
thought she was.going to call for rein tentatio�sly on a desk I would have to
forcements, but on the off chance that I pass. It was a fat folder, and lettered on
might be the harmless white-haired old man it was "Frank Folsom".
I looked to be, she tried again. Was the Justice Department or the FBI
"Why do you really want them?" (She accustomed leaving folders about citizens
smiled soothingly as she asked.) lying around this way? I doubted that it
I told her. "Although the FBI has long was standard operation procedure. Possib
had my prints, they don't seem to feel hap ly the folder was filled with blank paper,
py about them and have asked for my help." bulking it �ut so it looked impressive.
"Why does the FBI want them?" But then it occurred to me that perhaps
"I've asked for my FBI file under the some fellow whose name resembled mine
Freedom of Information and Privacy Acts. might have had his file enlivened with
The Bureau apparently isn't sure I am who sinister material about me.
I claim to be, even after I sent them all In due course I found there was such a
my past addresses, plus a sworn notarized possibili.ty. At the very time I was in
statement saying I am who I say I am." the Justice building, one Frank Folsom
That glimpse of comforting red tape gave was serving as chief procurement officer
the young officer the �ense of·security for the Navy Department. The FBI might
she needed, and she proceeded to besmudge have been asked to take a look at someone
herself and me and record the fingerprints who had massive government funds to spend,
without which the FBI was immobilized. particularly if the FBI was inclined to
I had debated whether or not to comply get him mixed up with Franklin Folsom. I,
with the request for prints. But so far as after all, was pretty obviously a danger
I am aware, I have not· in seventy-two ous character. From 1937 through 1942 .I
years done any harm to my fellow Amerioans served as Executive Secretary of the
nor am I known to be wanted for any crime League of American Writers whose 800 mem
I did not commit. So I decided to send the bers had prodded the government to do
prints in and thus remove the latest pre this or that, even during the two years
text for evasion in the J. Edgar Hoover when Franklin D. Roosevelt and Katherine
Building in Washington. Chapin, the wife of Attorney General
But perhaps the FBI really doubted that Francis Biddle, were among the 800.
I was the Folsom I claimed to be. I remem The possibility that Frank Folsom and
ber visiting the Department of Justice Franklin Folsom could occasionally be
Building about the time the United States ,mistaken for one another seemed more
entered the war against Fascism. My mis likely some time later when Frank had
sion was to persuade the Department to re risen in the world and was head of the
lease from �llis Island one Ambrogio Radio Corporation of America (RCA), and I
Donini, a distinguished professor of com had sunk to being a free-lance writer. A
parative religion at the University of letter, somewhat as follows, came one day
Rome. He was being held on the pretext to my home:
that he had a brother ii the Fascist Ital "Dear Mr. Folsom, It is our privilege
ian Navy. The charge was true - as far as to remind you that your annual contribu
it went. Ambrogio Donini did,have a Fas tion of $5,000 to the Boy Scouts is now
cist brother, but Ambrogio was thoroughly payable." '
antifascist. Five thousand dollars was about what I
Counterspy - 35
ear"ned in a whole year of writing - that perhaps for ceremonial purposes in con-,
is, a good year. nection with his duties as a Knight of the
But back to my request for� �I file. Sovereign order-of Malta.
One day I did receive a sample of what I The file reveals that it was "Confiden
might expect if I persisted. It included tial Infotlnant T-2", ,a ·person "of unknown
little of interest, and on many of the reliability" who originally put the name
pages alJ!lost every line had been blacked Benjamin Webster into my recofd - where it
out with a marking pen - to protect "na is late}: repeated as a fact to be rel-ied
tional defense" or the identity of in on without any reference to its dubious
formants. However, I did persist. ::,rigin.
Finally I received word that the FBI had My file also registers, and no doubt
got its act together. But :ii,.rst it seems about this, that I lived exactly where my
the law required the Bureau to notify me printed stationary and the telephone di
that the file it had assemble� consisted rectory said i: lived. How much this in
of "more than 25 pages". There was no in formation cost the tax payer, no one will
dication whether it ran to 26 pages, or ever know. Many different informants, pos-
260, or 26,000. I hau heard what happened ,sibly copying each other, but surely
to Corliss Lamont when he asked for his drawing different.pay checks, .came up with
file. The FBI included a lot �f photo the same data. Here was one fact the FBI
copies of books and pamphlets he had had straight.
written and published. At least 30 "Confidential Informants",
In a panic I insisted that I not be ·some identified by such symbols as "N" or
billed for photocopies of the 44 books I "200" and others as "T-1 11, "T-2", and so
had published. Also I wanted excluded from on through "T-25", sent in reports about
my file a�l the considerable material I me to supplement the researches of an un
had written, edited, and distributed for determined number of Special Agents. Here
the League of American Writers. is a tidbit from a 1953 report by one of
More delays. the Special Agents: "Subject's ca;_. was ob
I like to think it took•time for the FBI served parked in front of the New Bruns
to whittle down my file by eliminating' wick Theological Seminary." I was there
such things as books for third-graders _ all right, attending a meeting of people
about cowboys and Indians. But finally a_ interested in stopping the war in Korea.
bill came for $29.70. After I sent a check At least the FBI had evidence that I my
for this amount, and not before, I got 297 self attended a meeting I had done · my ·
photocopied pages. A quick glance told me damndest to publicize.
that much material was being withheld. Not only did I find such records about
There was·altnost nothing, for instance, myself, but I also got at least one start- ,
about the years when I was Executive Sec ling'bit of news about my wife of more
retary first1of the League of American than forty years. She, it seems - totally
Writers, then of the New Yark Council of without my knowledge or her own - had
American So�iet Friendship. It was because taught for three years (one informant said
I held these jobs that I was listed in the five years) in the Communist Workers
, FBI's Set:urity Index as a "Key Figure". I School. Clever woman.
complained to the Bureau about its inat Another discovery really mc\._de me look 1n
tention to a matter of such obvious impor the mirror. The FBI was afraid of me!
tance according to the FBI scale of values, J. �dgar Hoover ordered his Special Agents
and a few more pages dribbled in, this not ta interview me, saying, "Because the
time without a bill. subject is.self-employed as a writer, au
From what I have received so far I have thority�to interview the subiect is de
learned much about myself that I did not nied." At least eight later time;; agents
know. For instance, that I sometimes go - were o�dered not to interview me. Because
under the name Benjamin Webster. (Had some I am a 'writer-.-
one heard that I wrote several children's - And-because I was.an official 1 of a writ
books under the name Benjamin Webster ?) I 1 ers' organization I was dubbeci a "Key Fig
am also known to the FBI, although to no ure". I have hesitated_ about drawing at
one else, as Fred Franschi. I must remem- tention to this classification because
ber to write the family of the late Et;'ank persons really fam;liar with the Communist-
Folsom and as,k if he ever used those names, Party will smile at the notion that I was
36 - Counter>Spy
a "Key Figure" in the revolutionary move Five days after I was marked "Tab for Det
ment. A keen participant certainly, but com", orders came through not to tab me
equally certainly, not key. Unless, of for 1Detcom - whatever that was.
course, I underestimated the FBI's regards One thing I learned will be of great in
for writers. Many of the best in the coun terest to the earnest Republican who owns
try belonged to the antifascist organiza tourist cabins on th� ranch adjoining the
tion I served. site of my home in Colorado. The FBI
There is no doubt about the fear. My thinks that I made at least part of my
file even provides evidence about it in living by pocketing the rents paid by ten
connection with other word merchants. For ants in his cabins. Writing is a bad way
example, I find strict instructions that to make a living, but not that bad.
Special Agents should not interview my old Now comes a memorandum dated 11-1-63
Boy Scout Master (a newspaperman who had from SAC Newark (does that mean Special
been guilty of association with me since Agent in Charge, Newark?) to "Director
1923) "because he is a professor of jour FBI" (I know what that means) about
nalism". Franklin Brewster Folsom. A diligent re
So, writers, take heart. There are those searcher has dug up my middle name (from a
who know your worth. rare copy of Who's Who in America?) but
But apparently the FBI did investigate the body of the memor'i"ndum dispenses with
my scout master without interviewing me. this frill. It's about Franklin Folsom,
For some reasons my file reveals that he and it's a "reliability memorandum regard
"appears to have been a friend of Anna ing subject", meaning me. Moreover, there
Louise Strong, pro-Chinese Communist". were apparently seven copies of it deemed
What had happened was this: My friend was "suitable for dissemination". Dissemina
not pro-Chinese, or pro-Russian or pro tion to whom? How reliable is this "reli
Communist of any kind. He was merely pro ability memorandum"? Does it include data
University of Colorado where he taught. about Frank Folsom, and if so which
There, as a favor to a campus lecture bu Frank? There is no way of telling from
reau, he and another professor taxied the file in front of me. The "reliability
Anna Louise Strong from Denver to the memorandum" itself is missing.
campus to give a talk. Much P.arlier, May 18, 1950 (the files
The one time that Special Agents did ap arrived in no discernible order and cer
proach me (it was around 1942) they sought tainly not chronological order) Louis
information about several students who had Budenz in an interview with the FBI iden
been among the 3,000 who had attended the tified me as a "concealed Communist". He
Writers School run by the League of Ameri presumably got paid for this testimony. On
can Writers. I said I would answer in February 5, 1951, Budenz deleted the name
writing any proper question put to me in of Franklin Brewster Folsom from� list
•writing or put to me in the presence of captioned "400 concealed communists re
my attorney. No pair of agents ever reap vealed by Louis Budenz". No doubt Budenz
peared on my doorstep. drew his pay for work on February 5. Then·
Although the FBI avoided me (and my in June he was back at the same stand. He
wife, also a writer), it did muster • identified Franklin Folsom as one of
enough courage in 1955 to interview my these "concealed communists". Later, per
non-writer mother, then 76. I must· ask haps on the same day, perhaps on another -
her at her 102nd birthday party, which this is not clear - Budenz, reinterviewed,
comes up soon, what she told the agents. "was unable to satisfy himself of the iden
On with my file. I find a note dated tity of-Folsom and his Communist affilia
2-27-55 that I am marked "Tab for _Detcom". tions". Another paycheck.
(All applicants for their FBI files should And how about this entry, still earlier ?
ask the Bureau to supply a glossary with Confidential Informant "N" reported April
the files.) Does Detcom refer to those 28, 1942 that I was talking to a reliable
deemed suitable for placement in detention informant - a Communist Party member. (The
camps for communists ? Attorney General FBI considered such a person reliable ?)
Biddle in 1943 ordered Hoover to do away This reliable informant told the Confiden
with his Detention Index. But I under.stand
Hoover was adept at evading such orders.
tial Informant that I was the "Party wit"
of the Leagµe of American Writers. Party
'
He simply changed the labels on his files. wit - that's a nice touch. A kind of coun-
Counterspy - 8'1
ter-court jester? Could this hearsay of lish that I really was a member of the
hearsay really mean that someone thought I Communist Party when I had sworn that I
was the Party "Whip" - no doubt scourging had been in a statement I filed with the
Party ·writers who did not toe the Party Department of Justice at the time I became
line? a staff writer for Tass, the Soviet news
I must note before I leave Confidential agency? To hold this job I had to regis
Informant "N" and apparently other infor ter as an agent of a foreign power and to
mants who were no more observant, that in answer questions about my political affil
1936 (one of the several dates on which iations. I simply told the truth. I now
the file says I joined the Party) I col tell it again when I say that I engaged in
laborated on a paperback book with a man no political activity of any kind as long
whose name was Frederick Engels·Menaker. as I worked for Tass. And, perhaps sur
And the title was The Life£!_ the Party. prisi�gly, the FBI does not contend that I
More observant than the FBI, Joseph did. That task was left to the Senate In
Friedman, then editor of the Communist ternal Security Subcommittee which may
magazine� Masses, saw our paperback on have tried, through me, to link the U.S.
a newsstand. Expecting to find some meaty Communist Party, Tass, and - hold tight -
political matter, Joe bought a copy. He the Rhodes Scholarships, in a remarkable
was furious when he realized that he had conspiracy.
invested in a collection of parlor games It was my schooling that fascinated the
for adults. But perhaps here I do the FBI subcommittee:
an injustice. Someone in the Bureau may "Mr. Morris (subcommittee counsel). Now
have read the book, found out what it was, what has been your education?
and sagely left mention of it out of my "Mr. Folsom. I decline to answer that
file. Whether it was the FijI or not I question for the reasons stated.
don't know, but a book buyer did order "Mr. Morris. You mean you refuse to tell
from University Microfilms a Xerox copy us where you went to school?
of this long-out-of-print publication. A "Mr. Folsom. You have my answer.
few years ago I received a check for the "Mr. Morris. Because you might possibly
royalty due on a single copy. be giving testimony against yourself?
At the end of 1946 there was a kind of "Mr. Folsom. Yes.
summary report on me for the year. On "Senator Johnson. Did you finish any col•
page 9 of this report I am reminded that lege?"
a real estate agent obtained a tenant for Neither the senator nor Mr. Morris could
the summer for my New York apartment. The understand why I wouldn't say anything on
tenant, I learned after the lease was such an innocent subject, if indeed it was
signed and I couldn't do anything about innocent. The reason, of course, was that
it, was a very close friend of the Ital if I gave testimony on that or any other
ian Fascist Marshall Badoglio. He, the la subject, I would lose my protection under
dy assured me, was at that moment in the the Fifth Amendment, which I pleaded, as
United States under an alias - although well as pleading the -writers' amendment -
many antifascist refugees were being de the First. If I surrendered the protection
nied entrance. My file would have been of the Constitution, the Senate Subcommit
much more interesting if it had thrown tee could probe freely into my personal
some light on how Badoglio got into this beliefs - which it had no business doing.
country - and whether he used my apartment. It could demand that I give names of asso
Whoever let him in may know the full story, ciates whose efforts to achieve a better
but can this someone also explain why my world I thought demanded respect, not ha
apartment was ankle deep in talcum powder rassment. Since I wouldn't discuss my pol
at the end of the hot summer? I was left itics except where and when I chose to do
to speculate that Countess Mariella de so, and since I wouldn't inform on decent
Pisa, as the lady in question liked to be people, I availed myself of the First
called, was not familiar with the use of Amendment for the purpose for which it was
the shower. intended - to protect the innocent weak
Time and again my file suggests tanta from those who misused power.
lizing questions like this, then provides I didn't suspect what the committee
no answer. For instance, why did the FBI might have been fishing for until later
continue to spend money trying to estab- when Courtney Smith, American Secretary of
38 - Counterspy .,.
Sf8lling 'Folsom• ) ha_s a hook on it, but States action, in Tonkin Gulf. In my canmu
all t�e other 'a's in his correspondence nication I requested space in the Times
do not have this hook." Apparently it not only as an American visitor, but also
never entered the head of the CIA gra- ' as a graduate of a British university.
• iphologist that English might be a second One day a letter arrived from the editor
language fqr Kazakevich and that on occa -in-chief of the Times. With it was the
s�on he might lapse into Russian habits letter I had written to him. He said he
�f selecting vowels and shaping them as was returning it "for my own good". Very
he wrote longhand. But I suppose that if kind.
you are in the spy-and-conspiracy busi Did the "dispatch", which the.CIA admi�s
ness, you think everybody.else might be relates to me, also relate to word th� CIA
too. received from the Times ? The CIA knew
But that•is not all. The CIA has given very well that I had just come from six
me photocopies of �hese letters, thus ·weeks in the U.S.S.R. where I had been
providing me absolute proof that an im gatheril'\i,,aaterial for a kids' book on
portant branch of the United States gov that coun'try. They even knew I had a con
ernment violated my constitutional rights. tract with a leading Bible publisher
Under separate cover I am billing Rhodes (Thomas Nelson) to do the book. Had I,
Scholar Stansfield Turner, Director of while visiting a children's camp in the
the CIA, for damages. I shall do this in Pamir Mountains, near the SQviet-Chinese
the wake of a 1978 decision by Federal border, received instructions to write
Court Justice B. Weinstein of the Eastern just such a letter ? Or had I simply re
District of New York. Justice Weinstein membered the Maine ?
awarded Corliss Lamont $2,000 for letters It will surprise no one that the CIA
of his that had been opened by the CIA, ' "dispatch", which I take to be about the
and he also awarded $1,000 each to Tonkin Gulf incident, does not appear in
Victoria Wilson and Rodney Driver and the Pentagon Papers, but I can't help won
Stanley Faulkner whose mail had been sim dering if it ever crossed the desk of Dean
ilarly tampered with. How the judge ar
• J
Rusk wno did his share to heat up the
rived at his figure for damages is not 'as Vietnam War. And if Secretary of State
clear_ as his · den unciation of the CIA. Rusk did see the dispatch about a perverse
This leaves me in a quandary about how peacenik, I wonder if he noted that it
much to charge Turner. Perhaps $1,000 a concerned an American contemporary of his
letter would be a good figure, and if I at Oxford - a young man who ignored tech
get more than $2,000 I'll give the dif nical niceties of citizenship one day and
ference to the National Emergency Civil joined a large number of English under
Liberties Committee of which Corliss graduates and wore a white feather in his
Lamont'is Chairper�on. lapel·? That feather-was an answer to �r
·From:' material telated to the Soviet propaganda of another era. It said clearly
Union, my CIA file jumps to heavily "sani to all Oxonians, "I will: not fight for
tized" (their word} stuff having other King or country".
connections. Here is an entry: "Dispatch In addition to this myste,rious "dispatch"
is withheld in its entirety.'.' What could withhel� for "security" reasons, page af
this mean ? The date is August 20, 1964. I ter page of my file i� almost completely
t>egin to · remember. My wife and I were on blacked out. There is no telling, for in
the coast of Wales living in a cottage stance, if reports sent to Washington from
lent us by an old Ox,ford friend. Mexico refer to me or to,the head of R.C.A.
I recall more. This was the month of the or to some other Frank Folsom. I certainly,
Tonkin Gulf "incident". When I first heard have been to Mexico several times. While I
of thi.s caper, I was dead ce�tain that it was there, I did look up several of the
was designed as a pretext for military ac good people who had fled the United States
tion against North Vietnam. But the Times during the Mccarthy period, but I spent
of London thought otherwise. That journal ·much mo�e time visiting archeological
�cepte9 the official U.S. account of ,the sites and museums than I did chatting with
affair. old Lefties. l
For the August Times to acquiesee so I even did some work on children's ·books,
meekly seemed undignified, and I wrote a and in the course of this activity I was
le�ter saying s� atid protesting the United photographed twice in the State Department-
40 - Counterspy
supported Benjamin Franklin Library in possible date·." And I was promptly de
Mexico City. It happened this way: I had ported, but not on a ship. That slow
left my name at the Embassy where I had means of transportation was reserved for
gone hoping that their business library G.I. • s desperately wounded at the Bat.tle
would have the name of the new editor and of the Bulge. I was hastened out of Brit
the new address of one of my publishers. ain by plane.
Not finding what I needed, I walked to the Back to my FBI file. I notice my finger·
. Benjamin Franklin Library to make a second print card again. Something on the re
try. There, immediately after my arrival, verse side catctes my eye. I missed it
the reference librarian snapped a picture first time around. It is a stamped nota
of me once in the stacks and a second time tion that reads: "No arrest record. Sept.
in front of the circulation desk. With the 21, 1977 • II
ink scarcely dry on my signature at the Em Can it be that the FBI does not know
bassy and two snapshots to go with it, the about two occasions when I was arrested,
spooks ought to feel pretty sure who it was tried, convicted and fingerprinted? I
they were spooking. ijut where are these will help the Bureau, since it obviously
photos? They don't turn up in my file. Was needs help. On one occasion I was sen
the CIA still worried it might be sending tenced to ten days or ten dollars (that
me a photo of the head of R.C.A •. ? was a lot in 1934) for "littering and
There is no way of knowing how the tax using loud and abusi...te language" wh�n I
payers.' money was being spent on surveil helped strikers on the Fifth Avenue Bus
lance of me in Mexico, but it is a safe line by passing out leaflets. On another
guess that there, as elsewhere, the govern occasion I got well beaten up by police,
ment's finger men were all thumbs. Perhaps then arrested and sentenced to thirty
I should try to find out more of what was days because I protested when I saw cops
going on from that fellow Philip Agee who beating up a man who lay helpless on the
flitted in and out of Mexico be�ore he pavement.
wrote his book about the CIA. Apropos police, J. Edgar himself got
• Now let's see what my Naval Intelligence really excited, according to my file, when
file reveals. The FBI files show that Naval his office was asked to check the accuracy
Intelligence was duly informed about when I of a juvenile book The First Book of�
entered the U.S. Maritime Service. But Na lice. The woman who wrote it.chose to sign
val Intelligence apparently has no record it Jay Campbell. J. Edgar wanted to know
of my service. That t s a pity, because I am if this was the same Jay Campbell whom he
�urious about an episode in which that had listed as a Communist. And was it my
agency might have taken an interest. I wife who used the name Jay Campbell? ·crt
was in the U.S. Army Hospital in Scotland most certainly was not.)
with a broken �eg on which an operation But why is a sheaf of papers about this
h�d to be performed. A young woman, who Jay Campbell in � file? It must be be
cheered up the merchant seamen being cause of guilt by association. I was asso
cared for in this hospital along with mil ciated with my �ife. She (and I) used the
itary personnel, offered to get me any same literary agent who handled the Jay
newspapers I might want. I requested the Campbell book. And we both had books pub
conservative Times of London, the liberal lished by Franklin Watts who brought it
Manchester Guardianand the Communist Dai out. You can't be too careful.
!1_ Worker. Enough about my files.
The young lady fled, and an hour later Consider how much money was wasted on
two British security officers appeared me, and I am just one of 26,174 names
and demanded my passport. When they re Hoover had in his Security Index. How
turned it the next day, I was on a many among these represented any threat
stretcher in the corridor outside the op to national security? Any threat of any
erating room. The operation was cancelled, kind that could not be taken care of at
and I found in the back of my seaman's the polls, if the voters so desired?
passport, written in ink that has lasted And if I was a threat, why did the FBI
well to this day, "The United States War wait until 1966 to notify the Secret
Shipping Administration is responsible Service "in connection with Presidential
for removing the bearer of this passport Protection" to look out for me as "po
from the United Kingdom at the earliest tentially dangerous"?
Counterspy - 41
Come to think of it, I wonder if. �his that this was not so, a lot of Special \
notification explains the presence of a Agents, and Confidential Informants, and
self-described Secret Service Agent in a CIA spooks, and upper lev,el administra
class in writing for chil�ren_ that my tors would have\to look for honest. work,
wife and I taught one summer at Colorado and jobs in that line are hard to find in
Women's College. This agent was absent a society which already has illions unem-
from class the day President Nixon's mo ployed. i
torcade drove by the college. I didn't Finally comes a sheet from the FBI
go to the windoy to see· it, but if I had marked "revised 1/10/79 1' which apparently
gone, I might have caught a glimpse of has something to do with the birthdays of
our student, and her husband who was forty or fifty people. Their names are all
�lso in the Secret Service, out there in carefully arranged in months, and they are
the crowd making sure that the likes of identified as being in "teams".with labels
me did nothing to harin the man who had such as "6th team 2", "28th team l". To
done so much harm to this . country·. I dis figure this out I. need the help of a
approved of just about everything'Nixon cryptanalyst - one sma,rter than whoever
did - and this was before Watergate - but labored over Ka�akevich's handwriting.
�arm him?,';he only people who suggest What the hell is this birthday sheet all
.that kind of thing are either desparate about? And �everal other sheets that fol
damn fools or police agents. low and have just as little to do with me
. � ·But, they say, if a lie is big enough, or with anyone whose name I recognize? Is
people will believe it. Certainly that it a schedule for jolly parties for teams
appears to be true of the FBI. But the of Special Agents? The best conclusion I
question of belief aside, it pays the FBI can come to is that a batch of sheets got
,to base much of its operation on the myth into my file by mistake. This gives me a
that adv09ates of spcialism are also ad pause. What from my file may be in somebody
vocates of violence. If word got around else's? And I don�t mean any file labeled
Frank Folsom.
ColOnia Dign!dad:
New Revelations by Konrad Ege
(Ed. note: The foZZowing artiaZe is an after the West G�rman section of Amnesty
'update of "CoZonia Dignidad - West Gemian International (AIL published a 60-page
Conaentration Camp in Chile" whiah ap- boo'Jclet entitled "Colpnia Dignidad - Ger-
peared in Counterspy voZ.3 no.3. For rea- man Model Farm in Chile - a Torture camp
·sons of aZarity, some of the infomiation of the DINA" in March 1977. The booklet
provided in that artiaZe is repeated here.)
·
charged that Colonia Dignidad, located
400 km. south of Santiago, Chile near
In the beginning the case seemed to be t6wn of Parral, was (or is) being used as
an ordinary libel suit. By now, it has a conc�ntratlon camp by the Chilean se-
�urned into a major affair involving pub- cret police DINA (now renamed CNI). Colo
lie figures like the West German ambassa- nia Dignidad officials charge the booklet
dor to canada, Erich Straetling; Gerhard is a complete fabri�ation.
Mertins, the director of the scandal-rid- - Coloriia. Dignidad was founded in 1961 by
den arms tra�ing company Merex; a number west Germans coming from the town Qf
of West German Christian Democrats; and Siegburg near Bonn. They belong to a
possibly even Franz Josef Strauss, West small sect whose ideology is a mixt,,re of
Gl:!rman candidate for chancellor,. presi- fundamentalist "Christianity" and, a Nazi-
dent of the conservative Christian so- · type political belief. Today there are
cial Union (CSU) and governor of Bavaria. over 250 p�ople, almost ail West German
This libel suit began just a few weeks citizens in Colonia Dignidad, and· a few
\
"'
.42 - Counterspy
sect.members have remained in Siegburg. "plann�d event": "It might sound ridicu
According to various reports, including lous", he says, "but compared to Colonia
testimonies from the few members who have Dignidad, Villa Grimaldi (another DINA tor
been able to leave the group, members are ture center where he had been kept before)
suppressed by the leadership of .the sect was a place to relax."
through a rigid system of surveillance zott managed to es�ape the fate of per
and control under the pretext of reli haps hundreds of prisoners who have been
gious obedience. The leaders administer killed in Colonia Dignidad and was taken
beatings and drugs, among other things, from there to yet another detention center.
to keep the people quiet. _Eventually, he was released and had to
T})e United N?tions Economic and Social flee his country.
Council describes Colonia Dignidad as "a On October 30, 1979, zott was called
large agricultural and cattle farm•••• again to tEstify in the court in Bonn. He
which includes land in the Andean moun. recognized the second person in the wit-
tains right up to the Argentinian border. ·ness stand right away. He was Samuel
••• According to one source of informa Fuenzalida Devia - the same person who had
tion, many of the people of the list of been one of his 'DINA guards in Villa
119 prisoners who have disappeared were in Grimaldi. As it turned out, Fuenzalida's
Colonia Diqnidad and it is possible that testimony provided vital confirmation of
they are still there." (Report E/CN.4, Amnesty International's case against.Col
para.129,. 4/4/1976) onia. Dignidad. For he, unlike the fre
Another UN report suggests that Colonia quently blindfolded and tortured prison
Dignidad also serves as a laboratory de ers had wiBnessed operations there from a
signed to perfect the "science" of torture. p�ivileged perspective of a DINA officer.
"Prisoners have allegedly been subjected After a tour of service in the 1\rmy,
to different 'experiments' without any in Fuenzalida had joined CINA in November
terrogation; to 'tests' of the limits of 1973 and was welcomed into his new job by
resistance to different methods of torture; General Manuel Contreras himself. To pre
to 'experiments' to drive detainees crazy pare him for se�vice Fuen�alida attended
through administration of drugs•••" (Pro three months course of study on the "meth
tection of Human Rights in Chile, A31/253, ods of repression" in Las Rocas de Santo
para. 171, p. 97, 10/8/1976) Domingo.
These two UN reports are but a small Once trained, Fuenzalida was cons"ider"ed
part of the evidence offered by Amnesty In a full member of the DINA and assigned to
ternational. However, a West German judge, the Brigada de Inteligenc�a Metropolitana
Dr. Fuchs decided that AI "could not prove (BIM, a sul::x:1epartment of the DINA) under
their accusations sufficiently", and the command of DINA general, Manuel
granted a temporary injunction which for Manriquez. There, in Fuenzalida's own
bade AI to state.that Colonia Dignidad was words, "I was to practice what I had
a torture camp and banned the distribution learned: psychological warfare, combating
of 'the booklet. (In'terestingly enough, the .the guerillas, infiltration of the popula
same Dr. Fuchs.was a member of the Nazi tion. We had also been trained in hand-to
Party under Hitler.) hand combat." First Fuenzalida was sent
Since this original injunction in April, to.#90 Marcoleta Street, DINA general
1977, courts in Bonn have held a number of headquarters in Santiago. Later he was
sessions and heard witnesses testifying on transferred to the headquarters qf opera
behalf of Amnesty International. Among tion, officially called IITerra Nova", but
them were seven Chileans, who say they better known as Villa Grimaldi.
were tortured in �lonia Dignidad. Fuenzalida's first inside view of the
One of them is Erick zott. In January Colonia was in Jul.y 1974. With a Captain
1975 he was arrested by the DINA and tak.en of the DINA, Fuenzalida first went to the
to.various detention centers, where he was detention center CUatro Alamos to fetch a
severely tortured. At one point, he was prisoner who went by the name of ,"Laro
transferred. to "The Germans", as his guards .Matias". Tlle son of a Department of De
called it. "The Germans", zott found out, fense official, "Laro Matias" was a member
lived in Colonia Dignidad. He was h�ld qf the MrR (Movimiento Izquierda Revoluci
there for several days and tortured in a onaria - Left Revolutionary Movement). His
way he describes as "scientific", "much real name is Alvaro Modesto Vallejas
worse th.an anything before", and as 'a Villagran •. He is listed as one o£ the more
Counterspy - 43
dad", which has taken on the task of de- time, quite a few questions abou.t the
fending the Colonia. real nature of Colonia Dignidad are still
other persons �ho have visited Coloni� unanswered.
Dignidad and praised it as a "Gernia� mod According to several reports, including
el farm" are represe�tati.ves of the state an article in the Washington� in Feb
government of Bavaria and officials fran ruary this year, Colonia Dignidad has .a
the CSU-controlled Hanns Seidel Stiftung man·sion in Santiago "filled with elec
(foundation). Another supporter of the tronic. equipment. The house has high
Christian Democrats, Gerhard Mertins of walls and an unlisted telephone, some
Merex, received a vary favorable iJJlpres thing that is normally prohibited by
sion of the work of.the Colonia Dignidad Chile's -military government." Washington
people. He prais�d the camp as a very im Post reporter Charles Krause was threat
·portant factor in its geographical area. eneci' with arrest by undercover police of
In general, Mer.tins supports tlie govern ficers when he tried to enter Dignidad,
ment of General Pinochet and says it is and his film was taken away.
improving the social situation of the According to Nazi-hunter Simon Wiesen
Chilean people "day by day". thal as well as the FBI there is evidence
Wolfgang Vogelgesang, another CSU offi that Josef Mengele, who is r�sponsible·
cial, ·was invited by Colonia Dignidad for the deaths of hundred thousands of
leaders to visit for a few days in late Jews in the Nazi period, was hiding in
1979. He enjoyed his time there and wrote eoionia Dignidad. This charge has been
after his return that Colonia Dignidad is denied vehemently by q>lonia Dignidad
"hope for Germany. People there live from leaders.
the past, and think like Franz Josef How long can Colonia Dignidad hold out
Strauss•••• " against the mounting evidence against itl
Strauss• mouthpiece,. the right wing Ba One reason it has been able to hold out
yernkurier also defends Dignidad and sees so far is certainly its friendship t;,tith
in it a "benefactory institution, clean the Chilean government (including Gener•
liness, order. And much love and a moth al .�inochet who visited the yamp in 1974)
erly atmosphere." and high ranking and prominent West Ger
The trial in Bonn continues,,and man politicians and diplomats. One won
chances have increased that the judges ders, however, when they will get cold
will be forced to reverse 1 their decision -feet. After all, it's not good publicity
and allow distribution of the Anu'lesty In to be known as a friend of people who run
ternational l.,ooklet again. In the mean- a torture camp for the Chilean military
dictatorship.
union Zeaders and training them, this is union� have taken, or are considering tak
beyond my i'rragination." ing, positions opposing the political use
of AIFLD; the AFL-C�O reaction to'the
Santa Clara County Labor Council resolu1
June 26 to July 3, 1980 are cited as ex tion will be an indicato� of the relative
amples of such violations. The.AIFLD strength of the minority of progressiv:es
"has not condemned the$e violations of·· on the AF�CIO Executive Council.
human and workers' rights," according to
the resolution•
. This is possibly the fi�st t�e � lsraefs
AFL-CIO Central Body has made such a Pentagon Papers
strong recommendation en the AIFLD to
the AFL-CIO Executive Council. Neverthe Israel's S�aed Terrorism
less, AIFLD has stirred sdme controversy "a valuable service ..·. to those who are
within the labor movement generally at lnterested in discovering the real world
that lies behind 'official history.'•.,
least since· the 1973 overthrow pf the
-from Noam Chomsky's lnll'Oduclion
democratically elected government of.
Salvador Allende in Chile� It is well Moshe Shareu, -brael's first foreign mir.iister and prime minister
known there has.been serious·discussion from 1955 to 1955, kept a personal diary-a day-to-day candid
record of how key Israeli policy decisions were made.Long kept
of AIFLD within several AFL-CIO unions · wipublisbed, the diary reveals how Israel's "security establish
in· recent years due to t�e development ment," men like David Ben-Gurion, Arik Sharon and Moshe
of information on the political use of Dayan, sought to destabilize neighboring Arab �� untries
through covert military operations and terrorist acuvlly, and
AIFLI1·by agencies of the,u.s. government plotted the takeover of South Lebanon, the West Bank a�d Gaza.
and the feeling by some tha� an agency Italian journalist Livia . Rokach's thoughtful analysis of the
_
that has representatives of many of the Sharell diary and other key documents shatters longstanding
myths about Israel and its security needs. Israel's Sacred
major multi-nationals with interests in Terrorism lays bare the political trend in Israel that, in the words
Latin America and the caribbean on its
.- �H
of a troubled Moshe Sharett, raises terrorism and "revenge" to a
Board of Directors. (as AIFLP does) might "moral .· .. and even sacred principle."
r:iot be truly interested in."free trade Order from:
Association of Arab American University Graduates
uni9nisin". "ri".- 556 Trapelo Road, Belmont, MA 02178 (617) 484-5485
I ,e Prepaid orders only. Add $.40 for postage,
'!'he publication in 1974 of information � Free catalogue of publications available upon r«-quest.
linking the AIFL� to the CIA and to the
overthrow of the 'Al+ende government in
spired the Central tabor Council of Santa
46 - Counter>Spy . I
(Ed. note: This Open Letter was pre ers, public employees, teachers, students,
sented as a background paper for the reso�· small merchants, and unidentified persons
lution on AIFLD which was adopted by the were assassinated from Jan. 1 to Auu.11 of
Central Labor Council/of Santa Clara Coun this year, ad, of them directly.by the
ty AFL-CIO as described in the preceding armed £orces of the junta and the rest by
story. It refers to an article by Roy right-wing paramilitary groups supported
Prosterrnan and Mary Temple in the AFL by the junta ? Shouldn't American workers
CIO's Free Trade Union News defending know chat neither the State Department nor
u.s.-inspired "land reform" in El Salva the AFL-CIO have protested this.massive
dor. violation of human rights ? Shouldn't
Richard Hobbs is a delegate to the American workers know that the British La
Central Labor Council of Santa Clara Coun bour Party, �he West German Social Demo
ty, and a member of the International cratic Party, and the three largest Ita
Brotherhood of Teamsters, Local 6?9 as lian trade union federations have pro
well as COPE Chairperson of the Executive tested these tactics of terror of the Sal
Board, American Federation of Teachers, vadorean junta ?
Local 95?.) Shouldn't American workers know that at
/ the time the Prosterman-Temple article was
The June 1980 article written by RDy written, Amnesty International (in its
Prosterman and Mary Temple for the AFL-CIO June 24 letter to Secretary of State
Free Trade Union News represents an at- Edmund Muskie) protested that "Since the 3
'tempt to confuse American workers on the January 1980 resignation of much of the
question of El Salvador through a careful Salvadorean government -- on human rights
selection of one-sided data and arguments. grounds -- at least 2,000 Salvadoreans
Not only is the blood on the hands of the have been killed or 'disappeared' while in
salvadorean junta cleansed and its undemo the hands of conventional and auxiliary
cratic 1\ature absolved by the thrust of security forces in El Salvador. Many were
the Prosterman-Temple article, but wild tortured and savagely mutilated -- arms
insinuations and doubtful representation lopped off, flayed, beheaded." ? Shouldn't
of facts interspice the presentation on American workers know that (according to
"Land Reform il'l El Salvador". Amnesty International) "in the cities,
Evidence available at the time of the membership of a union, a neighborhood as
writing of the Prosterman-Temple article sociation, a church group or a political
and more evidence accumulated since then party••• makes one liable to detention and
suggests that the AFL-CIO should disasso murder••• " ? Shouldn't American workers
ciate itself from the AIFLD program in El know that on the very day in March that
Salvador. the agrarian reform was decreed by the
Why the facade ? Shouldn't American governing Salvadorean junta, all civil
workers know that since December 1931, liberties were suspended, and Salvadorean
during 49 arduous years for Salvadorean workers continue to live under a State of
workers, no free elections have been held? Siege ? Shouldn1t American workers know
0
Shouldn't American workers know that the that,dozens of trade union halls have been
present military members of the junta destroyed since the junta took power less
were part of the same.armed forces that in than a year ago ? Shouldn't American work
1973 and 1977 committed gross electoral ers know,that the AIFLD consultant in El
.fraud ? Should't Am�ri'can workers know Salvador Roy Prosterman is known for his
that according to the Legal Aid Office of role in the South Vietnamese agrarian pac
the Archdiocese of San Salvador (whose ification program called "The Land of the
claims have never been refuted by the jun Tiller" ? None of this is mentioned in the
ta), 3,425 farmworkers, industrial work- Prosterman-Temp�e article.
Counterspy - 47
Instead, Temple and Prosterman leave In terms of the agrarian reform itself,
American workers with the unambiguous con the AIFLD material for the Con?ressional
clusion that the AIFLD rural program in El Record (5/12/80) states that "••• within a
Salvador is "crucial to the development of year El Salvador wiil begin to experi�
a broadly supported democratic government" ence an economic miracle with the poten�
and without it, we will have "the probable tial to become the Japan of Central Ameri
victory of a far left so extreme the com ca". The Prosterman-Temple· article also
parison with Pol Pot's reign in Cambodia alludes to "new Japan-style economic de
would not be far-fetched.u velopment" in El Salvador and clearly in
The late Archbishop of San Salvador, sinuates that El Salvador's agrarian pro
Msr. Oscar Romero, who was mysteriously cess can follow the same path as the u.s.
assassinated by members of a rightwing Homest.ead Act of 1862.
paramilitary group while under watch by Aside from the fact that neither Japan
the Salvadorean arm�d forces, character nor the U.S. were strapped with the need
1
ized the agrarian reform promoted by the to pay a high percentage of debts to the
junta 1 and the AIFLD as one of "reform and International Monetary Fund {IMF) in ex
repression", since 90 farmworkers were I port earnings {in this sense, the Peruvian
killed in the week following the March 6 land reform failure with its present as
an�ouncement of the reform. In the middle tronomical inflation rate and high indebt
of that bloody week, a leading member of edness to the IMF' represents a much more
·the Christian Democratic Party who had likely' example of the proba,bly outcome o.f
been a member of the junta, Hector Dada the Salvadorean reform), the following
Hirezi, resigned from the junta, stating, three sets of quotations from a U.S. Gov
"How is the present process going to be ernment Memorandum dated August 8, 1980
successful if farmwor1<ers are repressed should shed some light on the possibility
daily for the sole crime of organizing ? of the "Japanization" of El Salvador:
How is this process going to be possible a) ··Phase III {the "r..and for· the Tiller"
if the organizations that contain thou phase) of the land reform "presents the
sands of farmworkers haven't even been most confusing aspect of the reform pro
consulted, and if on the contrary, the gram, and it could prove especially
daily ai{d mounting repression of these or troublesome for the U.S. because it was
ganizations makes dialogue impossible with decreed without advance discussion,. ex
them ? How is this.process, which the cept in very limited government circles,
{Christian Democratic) Party conceived as and, we are told, it is considered by key
democratic, going to be possible if it is Salvadorean officials as misguided and
being carried out under a state of siege?" U.S. imposed initiative.
How can the AFL�CIO Free Trade Union "It may not fit the situation in the
News leave American workers with the in countryside, where there are many differ
sinuation that the present governI!'�nt is ent kinds of landlords, including some
either "broadly supported" or "demccrat very poor ones; when the land is divided
ic 11 , when tens of thousands of organized _into tiny parcels and shifting field ag
workers are not consulted but repressed,· riculture practices are required beca�e
not free to organize but under a state of of the quality of the soil; and where
·siege ? And upon what basis can Temple there is, in the best of times, serious
and ProstJrman honestly engage in the confusion and conflict over land bound
speculative characterization of the Revo- aries and rights."
·lutionary Democratic Front, which' unites b) Don Kanel and William Th.tesenhusen ·
the overwhelming majority of Salvadorean of the University of Wisconsin's Land
unions, slum-dweller associations, and Tenure Center warned:
political parties, and which according to "In some cases owners of small 4 to 5
Robert� Cuellar of the Legal Aid Office of manzana tracts leave their plots and
the Archdiocese of San Salvador {in a houses in the hands of other landles's
speech given in San Jose, CA on July 12) people during the dry season so.that they
mainta"ins the active support and sympathy can watch it. The owners, in turn, search
of 80% of the Salvadorean people, as "so for dry season employment. Are the lands
extreme the comparison with Pol Pot's of these people to be expropriated?
reign in Cambodia,would not b� far "In some cases school teachers or other
fetched ?" members of the lower middle class have
48 - Counterspy
Excuse the polemical and at timeq rhe dor. The simplest of trade' union princi
torical style used in this letter, to ples require that we break relations with
which I hope you will respond. I am upset the AIFLD program in El Salvador, as the
by what is happening in El Salvador and I National Council of Churches has called
feel our trade union dues and taxpayers for, and that we condemn the anti-union,
money should in no way back up what is oc- anti-life strategies of the current Salva
9urring in the little country of El Salva- dorean regime.
Rightwing Terror
in Guatemala by John Clements
(Ed. note: John CZements works for news was published of a further crackdown
PeopZe'a TransZation Service and writes on the trade unions by the Guatemalan
for Newsfront International,.) military�
Another recent event -- which has yet to
Guatemala� undoubtedly, is an area of be reported by the U.S. press -- adds sub-
mounting concern for U.S. policy makers. stantial detail to Villagran's accusations
It is located close to the oilfields in of deep government involvement in the sys
Mexico, it borders civil war-torn El Sal- tematic terrorism which the Guatemalan
vador, and, until recently, was regarded Commission on Human Rights says leaves
as a country with a stable, pro-u.s. gov- eight to twelve mutilate� bodies along the
ernment. Today, the fabric of that au� .streets and roads of Guatemala each day.
thoritarian government is unraveling. It The Guatemalan lnterior Ministry's Press
is important to know why the Guatemalan Secretary, .Elias Barahona y Barahona, dis-
military is losing its hold on the popu- closed at a press conference in Panama, on
lation ••• why the majority Indian popu- September 4, 1980 that he had been an in-
lation -- after centuries of induced pas- filtrator for the Gu�rilla Army of the
sivity and decades of military dictator- Poor (EGP), an armed leftist organization.
ships -- is joining factory workers and The press conference was reported by Inter
students to take up arms in increasing Press Service, a Third World news agency,
numbers with the goal of overthrowing the distributed in the U.$. by Interlink-Press
government. Service. The former confidant of high gov-
Guatemalan Vice-President Francisco ernment leaders in Guatemala's military
Villagran Kramer's resignation early Sep- regime told the IPS Panama City correspon-
tember, 1980, while not unexpected, has dent .that he had taken the job in the In-
injured the government's legitimacy both' terior Ministry with the approval of the
at home and abroad. When he announced his le,adership of the EGP in order to "tell
resignation (from Washington, D.C. out of the world" what is going on in his country
rear for his life) Villagran pointed to He makes the following accusations: Four
cpntinued and massive human rights viola- years ago, _when �e began his work in the
tions as his reason for leaving. The for- Interior Ministry, under instructions from
mer Vice-Pres�dent, considered a moderate the �inister of Interior, Cqlonel Donaldo
in Guatemala, frequently had accused the Alvarez Ruiz, Barahona savs he wrote com-
military government of General Romeo muniques the "Secret Anti-Communist
Lucas Garcia of killing off its political Army" (ESA), using ESA letterhead station--
opposition. In March of this year ary. Alvarez also showed him letterhead
Villagran told the press "there are no stationary from the "Squadron of Death",
political prisonars in Guatemala, only the other main rightist group. These two
politic al murders.". Amnesty International groups, says IPS's Arqueles Morales, are
has made the same accusation a..number · of responsible for some 2,000 deaths over the
times. Former Vice-President Villagran past three month�.
announced his�resignation shortly after Barahona says that the leadership of the
Counterspy - 51
�,-.· 1P63 coup in Ir-an, the White House lJJeapons ·were my,t,rtousty dztopped from
4"4. ths CIA wezte riunning 48 Tfl(J.Jor covert unmarked planes. Al'bems irn,i.sted they
�ji,ona� David PhiZUps was on·the team came from provooateurs trying to dis-
that overth,r,ew the govemmt!lnt of Guate- credit him. SmaZZ bands.of zeebeZs were
�la in .i954." provided arms· by the CIA. The leader of
()al)i4 Phil Zips: "The Cold War was· ' the opposition forces �ii ·said to have.
vel'f:(, very hot indeed. There was no ,only a few hund!'ed fottOuJers, but CIA
que,tum about what American poZiaymak- broadcasts announced that Zarge rebeZ
si,a 1Janted 'in the world. And they saw · , forces were·conver-qing on Guatemala
-something that frightened them in Cen- City. It was the big Zle, and it' wrked.
tNZ America, and that was the asce�- President Al'bena panicked.· He resigned
4¥ Qf a man - a Marxist-oriented, not a and {Led the country. rt
�lffl'IUnist - leader in·that country, and David PhiZtips:' "Sq a government was
thfy Jelt, as Eisenhower put it, there --¥:ihanged, and I think there's consider
�utd be a Soviet .beachhead. It was de- able room for debate as to whether our
aided - a decision was made that the country should do tnat sort of thing or,
fi:J�ign policy would be to, using clan- not. 'In that particular case, f]Veryone
, dfafine operations, to change that gov- approved thoroughly, I can pPomise you."
t.,,.,,,,,ent • .,, , . Ed Bmdtey: "Ever-yone� in this case,
· id �ley: "Was that the-z:r only con- was. Pl'esident Eisen'hotJer cu,d Secr-etary of
a•m i.n Guatemala, the Russi.ans?" Stat;e John Foster DuUes." .
PaVjd PhiZZips: "Ed, it would be dis.. David PhitZips: "it was the easy way to
"!"nest for �yone u1ho 's spent 25 �ears do things ,, How much. more co�venient for a
i.n the corri.dors of secl'et opemti.ons to u.s. President to.do something quietly,
say that there aren't always othel' eon- without -having.to have the appPovaZ of
si,d,er.at�ons.. Th�pe wel'e •considerations, the public anci the appl'oval · the r:on-
of
cf Am�ri.can busi.ness. Thaf:.'s been one of gress."
·
the . things t1zat inteZZi;Jence. has been _ Ed Bl'adZey: "Aftel' ths coup in Guatema-
4itaaked for. These- thi.ngs do .make. a Za, a mi'lital'y .junta took oVel'. Death
dtfferaenae." . - . squads eUmina.ted the opposition. Xoday,
.· �d Bl'adley: "The CIA .. u10u.Zd be used to that oountry is e,ti,1,Z. cme 0,f the most l'e-
g•t rid of President Al'benz of Guatema- pressive and unstable in Latin America."
t4. Al'benz had legalized the Co�ist
' Pariy, taken over an American-owned Return � � · ClA, as broadcast over �he
lht:lted Fl'Uit Company plantation, and he. CBS Television,Network, 6/14/80; 10 PM,
1'(li moving towards Zand reform. Anti EDT, produced by 'ces NeWi9 •
..U-bens demonstl'ators suddenly fiZZed
Raul Alvarez Baltatan told me that Presi- that, in his presence, Alvarez and Foreign
dent Lucas Garcia ordered him to allow Minister Rafael Castillo Valdez each had
{the 2,000 Nicaraguan nationals) to assume their secretary lie to the Spanish Ambas
Guatemalan citizenship and join the Guate- sador to Guatemala, Maximo cayal y Lopez,
malan Army." Barahona further asserts that who tried to reach them from the Embassy.
the Guatemalan government and army are the cajal was told on several occasions.that
linchpin of a plan whose first stage will the two ministers were out of their of-·.'
be intervention in El Salvador but which fices. In fact, the two of them conferred
is strategically aimed at Nicaragua. in the Interior Ministry, again, Barahona
He also says the terrorist organizations says, in his presence, deciding along with
under the control of the Guatemalan gov- President Lucas Garcia, to have the uni
ernment, financed by some 250 plantation formed police force attack the Embassy.
owners, have trained some 5,000 mercenar- 39 people died in that attack which left
ies in their battle•against "subversion". the Spanish Embassy in ashes. Blaming the
200 elite Guatemalan officers, trained in fire on the peasants, Alvarez later told
counterinsurgency, have been deployed to the press that Spanish Consul, Jaime del
the Guatemalan-Salvadoran border to work Arbol, who died in the blaze, had autho:
ing to Barahona.
' .
with the Salvadoran Army as well, accord- rized the attack. According to Barahona,
Interior Minister Alvarez told him, laugh-
Interior Minister Alvarez, says Barahona, ing, that "del Arbol can't deny it because
told him that President Lucas Garcia has he's dead."
received guarantees from the United States Elias Barahona y Barahona, age 37, was
that "if a critical situation develops in head of his journalists' union when he
El Salvador, Guatemala can depend on dis- took on the Interior Ministry job, four
creet material, economic and logistic sup-_ years ago. Serving as press chief in the
port for intervention in that country." Ministry all .that time, he must have won
Through an agreement with the U.S., he the trust of the country's leaders as he
says, Israel is supplying military equip- said he did but we may never get indepen-
ment to make up for U.S. aid which has dent verification of these very serious
been cut off. Barahona claims personal charges. However, a look at press accounts
-knowledge of So',000 rifles, 1,000 machine from all sides tends to support the gener
I
guns, a million rounds of ammunition and al thrust of what he says. Even·the con
several aircraft and helicopters which servative press in Honduras and Guatemala
the Israelis have supplied to Guatemala. have quoted various military leaders from
"The goal", he says, "is to have people those two countries and from El Salvador.
believe that the United States is n� lon- to the effect that the U.S. military was
ger the dominant force in Guatemala be- working behind the scenes to support "the
cause of the apparent withdrawal of mili- war against subversion"; Salvadorean op-
tary aid and technical assistance; but position leaders have long accused Israel
this is not the case." Barahona quotes of.supplying arms to that country's mili-
former Guatemalan Defense Minister, Gener- tary-civilian junta; Israeli military aid
al otto Spiegler, who said publicly that to the deposed government of Anastasio
the Guatemalan Armed Forces "receive in- Somoza has been documented by the Sandi
directly technical and military aid from nista government in Nicaragua; and former
the United States." Another part of indi- Guatemalan Vice-President Villagran and
rect U.S. aid is, Barahona says, �ilitary Amnesty International have repeatedly
and police training. for several hundred pointed the finger a.t the same generals
Guatemalan offii::ers in Chile and Argenti• fhO Barahona definitively names as "the
na. leaders of the rightist terrorist organi-
On January 31, 1980f a peasant and stu- zations."
dent occupation of the Spanish Embassy in Barahona depicts a conspiracy with solid
Guatemala City began. According to . -- .i.f discreet -- connections to Washing-
Barahona, when Interior Minister Alvarez ton. If his accusations are true, in spite
informed President Lucas Garcia that a of the carter administration's official
group of peasants and students had taken hands-off policy, the Guatemalan people
over the Embassy, the President's response have �ne more reason to fight their gov
was"Get them out of there, we can't allow ernment and the U.S. government in order
focal points of agitation." Barahona says to achieve freedom from oppres�ion.
Counterspy - 53
CIA � in Guatemala
The foliowing Guatemalan police offi 72); Jose Antonio Dardon Sosa (3/67-10/67); Euler
c.ers received special, CIA directed Bernardo de Leon Diaz (ll/72-3/73)1 Oscar Rene de J:,eon
Portillo (6-10/70); Mariano Efrain de Leon Rodriguez
training in the U.S. from 1963 to 1974. (8-i2/72); Jacinto de Leon Sanchez (8-12/69);
Their Office of Public Safety courses .in Jorge Fidel de Leon Sanchez (11/73-3/74); Carlos
Enrique de Leon-Mena (4-6/74); Humberto de Paz
cluded classes and training in Police In �ortillo (4-8/69); Eulalia Antonio del Cid Chinchilla
telligence, Counterinsurgency Intelli (8-12/71); Silverio del Cid Cruz (5-9/67); Alejandro
gence, Planning for Riot Control, Targets Diaz de la Cruz (10/69-2/70); Carlos Humberto Diaz
Nurnberg (3-7/68); Marcello Alfonso Diaz:Munoz (4-8/
of I�surgency, Chemical Munitions, Explo 72); Rodolfq Diaz (10-12/72); Miguel Angel Eguizabal
sives and Demolitions, Planning for Roit Orellapa '(10/70-4/71); Adolfo Elizondo (4-7/63); Jose
c·ontrol, and Crowd and Mob Psychology. Antonio Escobar Catu (1-�/69); Santiago Espana-.
Portillo (10/69-5/70); Ahal Esquivel Arana (�-9/67);
In addition, for the CIA, the Office of. Tito Rene Esquivel Garcia (12/67-4/68)1 Francisco'
Public Safety.program served as an excel Estrada Arriaza (10/68-2/69); Carlos Fernando Estrada
lent field for recruitment and for ex Cabrera (12/�8�4/69);. Gilberto·Estrad� Castillo (6-10/
69); Vidal Estrada Cobar (1-5/69);
tending the CIA infrastructure in Guate Alejandre Estrada Herrera (4-7/63); Angel Mario
mala •. Estrada Herrera (8-10/71); Enrique Estrada Navas (5-9/
Victor Manuel Abadia (9-12/70); Ruben Dario Aguilar 67); Rigoverto Estrada Salas (8-12/71); Julio Cesar
Cifuentes (5-9/67)1 Jose Arnoldo Aguilar Flores (2-6/ Fernandez Cuellar (10/69-3/70); Carlos Francisco
72); Jorge Adolfo Aguilar OValle (4-7/63); Rene Prado Figuerda Gomez (1-5/71); Miguel Flores Giron (6-9/73)1
Aguillar (8-10/71); Oscar Annando Al.arcon Oscar Armando Flores Zuniga (3-7/70); Carlos Humoerto
castellanos (1-5/72); Leocadio Alvarado Barrios (5/ Franco Mejia (1-4/63)1 Gregorio Saturnina Fuente
73); Domingo Alvarado cabrera (11/73-3/74); Emilio Godfnez (11/73-3/74)1 Candido casimiro Fuentes
Alvarad� Chamale (2-6/72); Jose Luis Alvarado Garcia Navarro (1-2/63),; Luis Arturo Fuentes, (2-6/74) 1 Ramiro
(12/68-4/69); Mario Raul Alvarado Juarez (4-8/67); Galvez Aquino (8-12/69); Julian Gamez Urizar (12/68-4/
Obispo Vidal Alvarado Reyes (12/68-4/69); Genaro 69); Romeo Gregoria Garcia Aguilar (11/68-2/69); Jorge
Alivarado Robles (9-10/71); Miguel Angel Alvarado David Garcia Cabrera (6-9/72); Eliseo Garcia Hernandez
Rosales (8-11/69) ; ·Miguel Angel Alvarado y Alvarado (1-5/71); Landelino Gar�ia Mayen (10/69-2/�0)1 Alfonso
(3-7/70); 'Jose Felix Alvarez Arevalo (2-6/73); Garcia O�tiz (10-12/72)1
·Leopoldo Alvarez Morales (4-7/63); Enrique Huinberto Ramiro Garcia Pernillo (2-6/13); Antonio Eristelio
Anton Gordon (4-8/7l)i Adan Archila Martinez (8-12/69); Garcia (1-5/70)1 Jesus Raneo<Gil-Perez (4-8/74)1
Carlos Rene Arellano (8-10/71); Conr,do Anibal Simeon Giron Herrera (10/68-2/69)1 Mario Giroh Mata (1
Argueta Duarte (4-8/67); Manuel Argueta Sagastume (8- -5/74); Cesar Efr•in Giron Rossell (2-6/72); Jose
12/67); Jose Cris.anto Arreaga Garcia (6-10/68); Jose Ernesto Giron (3-6/71)1 Jorge Haroldo Gomez del Cid
Et'rain Arriaga Vargas (1-5/69)1 l.l!.l,go Armando Arteaga (10/68-2/69)1 Jorge. Alperto Gomez Lopez (5-9/74)1
Aceituno (6-10/72); Ricardo Barrayo Chamo (12/70- Abraham Gomez-Quevedo (4-6/74); Victor Modesto Gomez
4/71); ·Marcelino Barrientos Grijaiva (6-10/73); Elmee (�-9/71); Marco Aurelio Gonzalez Archila [12/68-4/69)1
Avily Barrios Argueta (l-5/73i; Martin Barrios Cabrera Gabino Gonzalez Figueroa (10/69-2/70); Carlos
(5-,-9/67)'; Carlos Enrique Barrios CUevas (l-2/63); Jose Arnulfo Gonzalez Hernandez (3-7/68)1 Jorge Mauricio
Higinio Barrios Meza (5-9/71); Gregorio Barrios Gonzalez· Motta (5-8/74); Natividad de Jesus Gc.nzales
Rabanales (6-10/68).; Jose 'Luis Batres Gonzalez (4-7/ (3-7/70); Marco Tulio Granados Serrano (8-12/69);
63); Jose Luis Batres Gonza+ez . (8-12/68); Manuel de Jose Benedicto Guerra Duate (1-5/71); Octavio Guerra
Jesus Beleton (12/67-4/68); Hector Enrique Beltran Mejia (8-12/69);
Giron (10/69-3/70);. Carlos Humberto Biruna (6�10/69); Miguel Angel Guerra Obando (11/68-2/69); Jose,Miguel
Rodrigo Blanco Herrarte (6-9(72); Guerra Sagastumg (7-11/67); Eduardo Antonio Guevara
Cesar Antonio Bonilla' Rivera (10/69-2/70); David Baylon (6-12/69)1 Onaldo Arturo Hernandez Chinchilla
Rene Cabrera Cruz (6-10/70);'0scar Annando Calderon (B-10/70); Oscar David Hernandez Recinos ,(8-12/72);
M.ijangos (l-4/63); Edgar Amilcac Calderon Morales (6- Miguel Mgel Hernandez (6-10/69); Indalecio Herrera
9/70); Monico Antonio cano Perez (3-7/68)1 Jose Bran'(ll/73-3/74); Venancio Herrera Romain (10/71-2/
Rigoberto Carcamo Sa�doval (8-�l/71); carlos·Humberto
Cardona F.eyes (8-10/71); Jorge Cardona (1-5/73);
72); Rudy Manolo Herrera y Herrera (12/67-4/68);
l\iltonio Hi Puac (6-9/72); Rudyalidio Hurtarie Pivarai
Humberto Carpio Lacanal (4•1/63); Guillermo Carrera 4-7/63); Gabriel Izem Sierra (1-4/63); 'Pedro Jimenez
Dardon (6-10/70); Luis Ernesto Castellan Pelen (1-5/ Barrios (3-7/71); Luciano Jo Avalos l?-ll/67);
74); Jorge Abraham_ Castellanos Rodriquez (10-12/72) 1· Venancio Juarez Albizurez (7-11/70)1 Dario Juar�z·
Jose Angel Castillo Aguirre· (1-5/69); Gamaliel Izaquierre (6-10/70); Mauro Juarez Noriega (5-9/74);
Castillo Calderon (6-9/72); Edwin' Rene Castillo ; Jorge IDrenzo Juarez Perez (10-12/72)1 Raul Antonio
Cardenas ·(lJ./72-3/73); Max;imUiano Castillo Pineda (3 Lemus Martinez (8-10/70);
-7/71); Jose Roberto Castillo y Castillo (1-5/73); J�rge Luis Lemus (l-2/63)1 Juan Orlando Lemus (6-10/
Jus.t9 Rufino Castro Gonzalez (4-8169)1 Jorge OVidio 68)1 Ruben de Leon camacho (12/67-4/68); Octavio
Chacon Barahona (4-8/72); Augusto de Leon Mll!'IOZ (6-10/69); .Sergio Roberto Lima
Jose Lino Chacon Valdez (7-6/74); Pedro Claver Morales (5-6/71); Alberto Felix Lopez Arango (8-12/72);
Chinchilla Asencio (6-10/68); Francisco Chun; Romeo Augusto Lopez Carrillo (8-10/70)1 Arturo Manuel Lopez.
Enrique Cifuentes Santos (3-7/70); Juan Florencio Cifuentes (10/69-2/70)1 Virgilio Lopez Cobon (l-5/69)1 •
Claudio-Sosa (4-6/74)1 Rodolfo Contreras Garcia (10/ Santos Fabian Lopez Garcia (8-i2/73)1 Jorge Arturo.
62); Alfonso Contreras Marroquin (6-10/73); Elmer Lopez Gonzalez (10/71-2/72); Cirilo Lopez OlivarH ,(6
·eontreras Ramos (8-12/72); Romulo Cordova Gonzalez -9/72); Cecilio Humberto Lopez Robl'ea (12/68-4/69)1
(1-5/71); Miguel Angel Cordova l-teneses (5-9/71); Jose Bernardo IDpez Tanchez (10/69-2/70)1 Jo•• Vootor
Marco Guillermo Cordova Perez (l-5/70)i Jesus Crus Lopez y Lopez (l-5/72)1,Napoleon Lopez Zambrano (1-5/
Fuentes (7-11/70); Armando Cruz Rodriguez (10/71-2/ 70);'Raul Mancilla Pineda (4-8/72'>1 Jose Cesario
I
Mangandid Florian (10/68-2/69)1 Roberto Mariscal (12/
54 Co7+nterSpy
\ \ .
�pproved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Approved For Release 2010/06/03: CIA-RDP90-00845R000100150001-0
Counter>Spy - 55
PLEASE RENEW YOUR SUBSCRIPTION to Coun- o vol.3 no.l (on Larry McDonald's
terS�y if your label reads R4,4 or t44. spying on the left, COINTELPRO,
Counterspy can be an important tool in CIA in Portugal,' u.s.-south Afri
your political work, and we need your can intelligence collaboration)
. support. 66 pages, $2
o vol.3 no.2 (on DINA, the Argentine
,i � 1Q. renew � subscription to Coun and Uruguayan police, U.S. opera
terSpy for one year and enclose tions against Jamaica, Thailand,
o $lq (individual, U.S. and Canada) .Namibia; U.S. war crimes in Indo
O $20 (institutions, libraries) china} 74 pages, $2.00
O .$25 (foreign, air mail) O vol.3 no.3 '(on CIA in the Middle
O $75 -(U.S. government a�encies)
1
............................
istan, CIA food study, CIA and.the
1965 coup in Indonesia,' u.s� intel
ligence in Norway) 48 pages, $2.00
I enclose an9ther $10. Please send�� o vol.4 no.2 (on CIA in Afghanistan,
terSpy � to Riggs Bank and apartheid, CIA and
..................................�.....
Labor in Turkey, CIA domestic ope,r
, , ations, U.S.-Australian role in
East Timer) 48 pages, $2.00
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •1• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • O vol.4 no.3 (on counterinsurgency in
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Thailand, MOSSAD, South Korea, U.S.
bases in 'nl,rkey, Ghana and multina
tion�ls, U.S. p�opaganda in Colom
l � � order the following back is bia, CIA in Argentina, Afghanistan,
,, � (*available only in xeroxed form) Sweden}' 48 pages, $2
o vol.l no.l (o:n FBI and the·paramil;.. O vol.4 no.4 (SP�CIAL ISSUE on 1953
itary right in the u.s., intelli CIA coup in Iran) 6 pages, $.SO
gency operations against progres
sive organizations in the U.S.} * · Add $.SO for each copy and $,20 for each
24 pages, $2.50 additional copy (postage, handling). In
o vol.l no.2 (on the CIA'.s Ehoenix __ quire about bulk rates. Add $1.00 for
program} * 28 pages, $3.00 each overseas, airmail copy, and $.75 for.
o vol.I no.3 (on U.S. covert opera each _additional copy.
tion in Cambodia, the trial of the
Gainesville Eight} * 28 pages, $3�oo 1. want� become!. Counterspy sustainer
O vol.I no.4 (on COINTELPRO, U.S. Af and enclose O $10; o $25; 0 $50;
rica Policy, Symbionese Liberation 0 $100; 0 $••••;
Army} 32 pages, $2.00
o vol.2 no.l (on undercover agents, o I want to support Counterspy by pro
counterinsurgency at Wounded Knee, moting it in my area, clipping newspa-.
AFL-CIA} * 52 pages, $5.50 pers, etc.
O vol.2 no.:>. (on CIA and the 1/Jornen' s Contact Counterspy for details.
Movement, CIA infrastructure abroad,
CIA-labor operations in Latin Ameri
ca} * 58 pages, $6.00 counterspy magazine
o vol.2 no.3 (on Data Banks, �bup P.O. Box 647
in Chile, CIA labor operations in Ben Franklin Station
Africa} * 66 pages, $6.50 Washington, D.C. 20044
O vol.2 no.4 (on SWAT, CIA drug trade, U.S.A.
spying on the U.S. left) 64 pages,
$2.00