Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Engineering Technical Practice
Engineering
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table of Contents
Page
Foreword ........................................................................................................................................ 5
1 Scope .................................................................................................................................... 6
2 Normative references............................................................................................................. 7
3 Terms and definitions........................................................................................................... 10
4 Symbols and abbreviations .................................................................................................. 11
5 Materials selection philosophy ............................................................................................. 12
6 Principles of materials selection ........................................................................................... 15
6.1 Materials selection for process side environment ...................................................... 15
6.2 Materials selection for external seawater environment.............................................. 19
7 Applications of corrosion resistant alloys and nonmetallic materials..................................... 20
7.1 General..................................................................................................................... 20
7.2 Austenitic stainless steel and nickel alloys ................................................................ 21
7.3 Precipitation hardening stainless steel and nickel alloys ........................................... 23
7.4 Duplex stainless steel ............................................................................................... 23
7.5 Nickel-copper alloys.................................................................................................. 23
7.6 Cladding and linings.................................................................................................. 23
7.7 Nonmetallic materials................................................................................................ 24
8 Wellheads and christmas trees ............................................................................................ 24
8.1 General..................................................................................................................... 24
8.2 Materials options....................................................................................................... 25
9 Piping, fittings, and connectors ............................................................................................ 27
9.1 General requirements ............................................................................................... 27
9.2 Additional requirements for piping............................................................................. 32
9.3 Additional requirements for fittings ............................................................................ 32
9.4 Additional requirements for connectors ..................................................................... 32
9.5 Additional requirements for internal CRA clad constructions ..................................... 32
10 Flowlines, pipelines, and risers ............................................................................................ 33
10.1 Flowlines and pipelines carrying production fluids..................................................... 33
10.2 Flowlines and pipelines carrying other products........................................................ 36
In the event of a conflict between this document and a relevant law or regulation, the
relevant law or regulation shall be followed. If the document creates a higher obligation, it
shall be followed as long as this also achieves full compliance with the law or regulation.
Page 2 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
List of Tables
Table 1 - Acceptable candidate corrosion resistant alloys for subsea applications ........................ 22
Table 2 - Maximum allowable hardness for stainless steels .......................................................... 22
Table 3 - Charpy V-notch impact energy requirements for high strength precipitation hardening
nickel alloy piping, fittings, and connectors .......................................................................... 23
Table 4 - Design temperature limits for hydraulic control and chemical injection tubing................. 27
Table 5 - Standards for seamless and welded pipe and fittings in carbon and low alloy steel ....... 29
Page 3 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table 6 - Standards for seamless and welded pipe and fittings in stainless steel and nickel alloys30
Table 7 - Standards for forged pressure retaining pipe components ............................................. 30
Table 8 - Charpy V-notch impact energy requirements for carbon and low alloy steel piping, fittings,
and connectors (1) ............................................................................................................... 30
Table 9 - Materials requirements for low alloy steel internally clad components for piping, fittings,
and connectors .................................................................................................................... 34
Table 10 - Typical acceptable materials for manifold and flowline/pipeline valves ......................... 42
List of Figures
Figure A.1 - Option 1: Fabrication of low alloy steel components and valve bodies with C-Mn
buttering layer, welded to C-Mn steel pup piece, with C-Mn butt weld.................................. 53
Figure A.2 - Option 2: Fabrication of low alloy steel components and valve bodies with C-Mn
buttering layer, welded to C-Mn steel pup piece, with alloy 625 butt weld ............................ 54
Page 4 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Foreword
This is a revised issue of Engineering Technical Practice (ETP) GP 36-20. This Group Practice (GP)
incorporates the following changes:
• Shared learnings and comments received from the Subsea Community of Practice,
including equipment vendors and contractors.
• References to relevant ETPs published since the first issue.
Changes to this document are indicated by a bar in the left margin.
Page 5 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
1 Scope
Page 6 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
2 Normative references
The following normative documents may, to the extent specified in subsequent clauses and normative
annexes, be required for full compliance with this GP:
BP
GIS 18-011 Welded Fabrication and Construction.
GIS 18-013 Integral Cladding, Weld Overlay, and Limited Loose Lining of Pressure
Vessels and Components.
GIS 18-015 Weld Deposited Overlay of Linepipe, Fittings, and Other Components.
GIS 18-041 Manufacture of Duplex Stainless Steel Fittings and Components.
GIS 42-103 Fabrication, Assembly, Erection, and Inspection of Pipework
(ASME B31.3).
GIS 43-311 Longitudinal or Helical Seam Submerged Arc Welded Linepipe in
Grades up to X80 (API 5L or ISO 3183).
GIS 43-312 High Frequency Induction (HFI) or Electric Resistance Welded (ERW)
Linepipe in Grades up to X70 (API 5L).
GIS 43-313 Seamless Linepipe in Grades up to X80 (API 5L or ISO 3183).
GIS 43-314 13% Chromium Seamless Linepipe (API 5LC).
GIS 43-315 22% and 25% Chromium Duplex Stainless Steel Seamless Linepipe
(API 5LC).
GIS 43-316 Manufacture of CRA Clad or Lined Steel Pipe.
GIS 43-317 Carbon Steel Induction Bends for Pipelines in Grades up to X80
(ISO 15590-1).
GIS 43-318 Carbon Steel Fittings for Pipelines in Grades up to X80 (ISO 15590-2).
GIS 43-319 Carbon Steel Flanges for Pipelines in Grades up to X80 (ISO 15590-3).
GIS 43-352 Subsea Pipeline Valves (EN ISO 14723).
GN 06-001 Erosion Guidelines.
GN 06-010 CO2 Corrosion Prediction Guidelines.
GN 36-001 Requirements for Alloy 718 Equipment.
GN 36-003 Nonmetallic Materials Selection.
GN 36-005 Guideline for avoiding gas decompression damage of elastomer seals.
GN 36-007 Guideline for compatibility testing of non-metallic materials within
subsea chemical delivery systems.
GN 36-009 Specification for Subsea Insulation and Buoyancy Materials.
GN 36-012 Specification for Titanium Risers and Forged Components for Use with
Workover, Top Tensioned, and Catenary Riser Systems: 110 and 135 ksi
SMYS Titanium Forgings.
Page 7 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 8 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
ASTM A352 Steel Castings, Ferritic and Martensitic, for Pressure-Containing Parts,
Suitable for Low-Temperature Service.
ASTM A358 Standard Specification for Electric-Fusion-Welded Austenitic Chromium
Nickel Stainless Steel Pipe for High-Temperature Service.
ASTM A403 Standard Specification for Wrought Austenitic Stainless Steel Piping
Fittings.
ASTM A420 Standard Specification for Piping Fittings of Wrought Carbon Steel and
Alloy Steel for Low-Temperature Service.
ASTM A453 Standard Specification for High-Temperature Bolting Materials, with
Expansion Coefficients Comparable to Austenitic Stainless Steels.
ASTM A694 Standard Specification for Carbon and Alloy Steel Forgings for Pipe
Flanges, Fittings, Valves, and Parts for High-Pressure Transmission
Service.
ASTM A707 Standard Specification for Forged Carbon and Alloy Steel Flanges for
Low-Temperature Service.
ASTM A789 Seamless and Welded Ferritic/Austenitic Stainless Steel Tubing for
General Service.
ASTM A790 Standard Specification for Seamless and Welded Ferritic/Austenitic
Stainless Steel Pipe.
ASTM A815 Standard Specification for Wrought Ferritic, Ferritic/Austenitic, and
Martensitic Stainless Steel Piping Fittings.
ASTM A860 Standard Specification for Wrought High-Strength Low-Alloy Steel Butt-
Welding Fittings.
ASTM A928 Standard Specification for Ferritic/Austenitic (Duplex) Stainless Steel
Pipe Electric Fusion Welded with Addition of Filler Metal.
ASTM A988 Standard Specification for Hot Isostatically-Pressed Stainless Steel
Flanges, Fittings, Valves, and Parts for High-Temperature Service.
ASTM A989 Hot Isostatically-Pressed Alloy Steel Flanges, Fittings, Valves, and Parts
for High Temperature Service.
ASTM B366 Factory-Made Wrought Nickel and Nickel Alloy Fittings.
ASTM B423 Standard Specification for Nickel-Iron-Chromium-Molybdenum-Copper
Alloy (UNS N08825 and N08221) Seamless Pipe and Tube.
ASTM B444 Standard Specification for Nickel-Chromium-Molybdenum-Columbium
Alloys (UNS N06625) Pipe and Tube.
ASTM B564 Nickel Alloy Forgings.
ASTM B705 Standard Specification for Nickel Alloy (UNS N06625, N06219 and
N08825) Welded Pipe.
Page 9 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
ISO 10423 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Drilling and production
equipment - Wellhead and Christmas tree equipment.
ISO 13628-1 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Design and operation of subsea
production systems - Part 1: General requirements and recommendations.
ISO 13628-4 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Design and operation of subsea
production systems - Part 4: Subsea wellhead and tree equipment.
ISO 14723 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Pipeline transportation systems -
Subsea pipeline valves.
ISO 15156-2 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Materials for use in H2S-containing
environments in oil and gas production - Part 2: Cracking-resistant
carbon and low alloy steels, and the use of cast irons.
ISO 21457 Petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries - Materials selection
and corrosion control for oil and gas production systems.
For the purpose of this GP, the following terms and definitions apply:
BP approval
Approval by the relevant BP materials/corrosion/welding engineer defined in Annex B.
Cladding
Metallurgically bonded corrosion resistant layer (e.g., as applied by roll bonding or fusion welding).
Coating
A material applied as a layer onto a substrate to provide corrosion protection.
Historically, BP considered pressures and temperatures above 690 barg (10 ksig)
and 82°C (180°F) to be HP/HT, but this has evolved to the above referenced
industry recommended practice definition.
Lining
Nonmetallurgically bonded corrosion resistant layer (e.g., as applied by cold hydraulic expansion).
PREw
Pitting resistance equivalent number (PREw = %Cr + 3,3 (%Mo + 0,5 %W) + 16 x %N).
Page 10 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
For the purpose of this GP, the following symbols and abbreviations apply:
CE Carbon equivalent.
CP Cathodic protection.
Page 11 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
PTFE Polytetrafluoroethylene.
TFEP Tetrafluoroethylene/propylene.
UV Ultraviolet.
a. Projects shall produce a single materials selection philosophy document, from which the
conclusions and recommendations shall be integrated into the project specific basis of
design.
b. Materials selection philosophy shall include:
1. Design and operating conditions.
2. An evaluation of corrosivity, which shall include:
a) CO2 content.
b) H2S content.
c) Hg content.
d) Content of oxygen and other oxidising species.
e) Design and operating temperature and pressure.
f) pH, including effects of organic acids.
g) Chloride (or other halide) ion concentration.
h) Velocity and flow regime.
i) Sand and other solids production.
Page 12 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
j) Microbiological activity.
k) Transient conditions (e.g., shutdown and startup).
l) Condensing conditions.
A gas is normally considered “dry” (i.e., no risk of free water) if the water dewpoint
at the operating pressure is always at least 10°C (18°F) lower than the operating
temperature for the system.
3. Approach to materials selection.
4. Application of national and international materials standards and specifications.
5. Compliance with regulations.
6. Requirements for materials and welding qualification testing.
7. Application of relevant GIS documents.
Project materials selection philosophy normally is developed during select and/or
define stage.
c. Materials for subsea equipment shall be selected to provide required levels of operational
integrity, taking into account:
1. Material availability in appropriate product forms.
2. Operations and maintenance strategy.
3. Weldability.
4. Project cost and schedule requirements.
5. Complexity and novelty of equipment manufacture and fabrication.
6. Internal and external damage mechanisms during:
a) Storage and transport.
b) Deployment.
c) Wet parking.
d) Hydrotesting.
e) Commissioning.
f) Operations (including shutdown and startup).
g) Decommissioning.
7. Internal and external in service damage mechanisms for normal and transient
conditions, including:
a) Corrosion (general and localised).
b) Environmentally assisted cracking.
c) Brittle fracture.
d) Plastic collapse, overload, or buckling.
e) Erosion and erosion-corrosion.
f) Fatigue and corrosion fatigue.
g) Hydrogen embrittlement.
8. Predicted changes in reservoir conditions over design life (e.g., souring).
9. Effect of contact with well treating and completion chemicals.
Page 13 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 14 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
6.1.1 General
The potential for exposure to raw or treated seawater (e.g., during installation, hydrotesting, and
commissioning) shall be assessed and materials with adequate corrosion resistance specified.
Unintended exposure to raw seawater can occur by leakage through mechanical
joints and seals during deployment and commissioning.
Page 15 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 16 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
6.1.5 Erosion
Erosion rates in subsea equipment and implications for materials selection shall be evaluated in
accordance with GP 06-14 and should follow the guidance provided in GN 06-001.
6.1.6 Chemicals
a. Materials selected for subsea systems shall have adequate resistance to the range of
expected chemical treatments.
It is important to understand how chemicals interact with materials they contact
(metals and elastomers) and how they behave with each other if mixed.
b. Compatibility between treatment chemicals shall be established before final selection and
use.
Potential incompatibility may result in neutralisation of one or more of product
active ingredients or in precipitation and blockage (i.e., “gunking”).
Refer to GP 78-11 for design guidelines for subsea chemical injection.
Chemical treatments are frequently adopted for flow assurance and/or control of
corrosion or scaling in subsea producing systems, such as:
Corrosion inhibition/pH modifier.
Scale inhibition.
Hydrate inhibition.
Wax control.
Asphaltene control.
Flow improvers.
c. Compatibility of nonmetallic materials with specific chemicals shall be demonstrated
following the guidance provided in GN 36-007.
Page 17 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
d. Produced hydrocarbon systems in carbon and low alloy steels should use welding
consumables that match parent steel.
PWC is a particular concern with carbon and low alloy steels and has been
experienced in systems handling produced hydrocarbons and seawater for injection.
In seawater injection systems, welding with consumables that nominally deposit 1%
Ni weld metal has been used extensively to avoid PWC. Several cases of PWC
subsequently have been reported, but, overall, it appears to have significantly
reduced the PWC risk.
In systems handling produced hydrocarbons, the current industry accepted
approach to avoid PWC is:
Use of weld consumables matching the composition of the parent steel.
Treatment with an appropriately selected corrosion inhibitor.
Care is needed to select the correct inhibitor and dosage to provide adequate
protection, or it can make the likelihood and rate of PWC more acute (refer to
EFC 39 for more detail).
PWC can be exacerbated by the presence of acetic acid/acetate and is particularly
critical in wet gas systems. For produced hydrocarbon systems, if the acetate to
bicarbonate ratio is favoured towards acetate, the greater the effect of acetate on
system corrosivity and, by implication, PWC.
Page 18 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
of stainless steel used for internal components are not resistant to localised pitting
and crevice corrosion in raw seawater (i.e., grades with PREw less than 40).
Generally, fresh hydrotest water (in accordance with GP 06-29) should be specified
in all cases other than systems designed for raw seawater duty. Prolonged durations
of hydrostatic test water remaining in equipment and pipework should be avoided.
Some assemblies, such as manifolds, can be deployed after filling with treated and
noncorrosive fluids. Venting should be adequate to minimise the volume of trapped
air, which promotes corrosion. Duration of exposure to these “transient” fluids
prior to commissioning should be minimised.
Page 19 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
7.1 General
a. Acceptable candidate corrosion resistant alloys for pressure boundary equipment should be
selected from Table 1. CRAs for valve stems, fasteners, and hydraulic control and
chemical injection systems should be selected by reference to 11, 1, and 14.
There is often a requirement for fasteners, valve stems, and tubing to be made from
different, usually more corrosion resistant materials than the parent equipment.
b. Use of CRAs for pressure boundary equipment other than those listed in Table 1 shall be
subject to BP approval.
c. Free machining grades shall not be used.
Free machining grades have relatively poor corrosion resistance, especially in
seawater.
d. Copper based alloys shall not be specified for pressure boundary equipment in hazardous
duty.
e. CRA forgings made to 0,2% proof strengths that exceed 827 MPa (120 ksi) shall be
qualified to mechanical, corrosion, and environmental cracking performance requirements,
subject to BP approval.
Page 20 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 21 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 22 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 23 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
b. CRA clad pipe shall conform to GIS 43-316. Supplementary requirements for induction
bending shall be subject to BP approval.
c. Options for clad pipe produced by internal weld overlay techniques may be proposed,
subject to BP approval (refer to GIS 18-015).
d. Mechanically lined pipe shall conform to GIS 43-316 but shall not be used for reeled
flowlines or pipelines.
e. Alloy 625 weld overlays shall have:
1. At least two passes.
2. Thickness of at least 3 mm (0,12 in) at the final finished surfaces, including machined
locations.
3. Iron content at the finished surfaces, including machined locations not exceeding
10%.
4. Iron content not exceeding 10% at the end of design life thickness, if erosion is
predicted, unless it can be demonstrated and documented by application specific
corrosion testing that higher iron content is adequate.
Greater finished clad thickness may be required to meet the maximum iron
requirement at the end of design life thickness (refer to 6.1.2e).
8.1 General
a. Materials shall be specified and selected to provide required levels of operational integrity,
taking into account predicted changes in duty of a subsea tree during its lifetime (e.g., from
production to injection).
Wellhead and christmas tree equipment can be used for hydrocarbon production
and seawater injection (raw and treated).
b. Materials for major components that are wetted by process fluids shall conform to
GP 36-25.
Page 24 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 25 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
injection. Even in those conditions, seat pockets and seal areas should be clad with
alloy 625, and trim should be a suitable grade of stainless steel.
Of materials listed in a., low alloy steel weld overlaid with alloy 625 represents the
lowest risk option for subsea. The preferred low alloy steel is ASTM A182 F22, since
this provides better through thickness hardenability in thick section forgings and is
considered the preferred material for critical equipment, such as block master
bodies, other than in exceptional circumstances.
b. Equipment rated above 689 bar (10 000 psi) shall be ASTM A182 F22 internally clad with
alloy 625.
Page 26 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table 4 - Design temperature limits for hydraulic control and chemical injection tubing
°C °F Bar psi
ASTM A269, TP 316L 60 140 689 10 000
ASTM B423, UNS N08825 80 176 No limit No limit
ASTM A269, UNS S31254 100 212 No limit No limit
ASTM B444, UNS N06625 180 356 No limit No limit
Page 27 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 28 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table 5 - Standards for seamless and welded pipe and fittings in carbon and low alloy steel
Page 29 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table 6 - Standards for seamless and welded pipe and fittings in stainless steel and nickel alloys
Page 30 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
3. If the MDT is lower than -46°C (-50°F), impact testing shall be performed at the
MDT.
Manifolds designed to ASME Code Section VIII Division 3 for high pressure
applications may require more onerous fracture toughness properties and testing.
API RP 6HP may impose similar requirements in the future.
4. Components in high strength, precipitation hardening nickel alloys shall conform to
7.3b.
5. Impact testing is not required for austenitic stainless steels or nickel base alloy piping,
components, or fittings. Weldments in austenitic stainless steels and nickel base
materials shall include impact testing as part of the welding procedure qualification in
accordance with GIS 42-103.
m. Individual components and valve bodies shall be designed in accordance with the
following:
1. Maximum wall thickness shall be minimised and shall not be substantially more than
necessary to conform to structural and pressure containment requirements.
2. Elbows shall not be manufactured from tee forgings, unless acting as target tees for
erosion control.
Target elbows are less flexible than radiused elbows, therefore adding to the
stiffness of the assembly.
3. Design of components and geometry of welding ends shall be such that ultrasonic
and/or radiographic examination may be performed on 100% of the component
during both manufacture and fabrication into the assembly.
4. Welding ends shall contain sufficient parallel length to ensure that the fabrication
weld can be subjected to ultrasonic scanning from both sides of the weld.
5. Thickness transitioning across welds shall not be used without BP approval.
This type of weld is difficult to NDE by ultrasonic testing. Thickness transitions
should be at least 100 mm (4 in) away from the edge of the weld preparation and
located in the parent material of the thicker component. Transitions should be
smooth with no sharp notches or contours, with length to depth ratio of at least 4:1.
6. Dissimilar welds using alloy 625 filler metal shall be inspected by both radiography
and ultrasonic testing or other qualified NDE methods approved by BP.
7. NDE regime shall maximise detection of both planar and volumetric defects,
especially in HP/HT designs, which may have smaller allowable defect sizes.
n. Qualification test
1. Individual component and valve body designs and vendors shall be qualified on the
basis of a manufacturing procedure qualification test.
2. Testing shall involve mechanical testing on a sacrificial component or forging
prolongation, as approved by BP.
3. The applicable size range for each manufacturing procedure qualification test shall be
subject to BP approval.
o. Coating and insulation systems shall not be used to prevent hydrogen assisted cracking.
Refer to GN 36-020.
p. Coating and insulation materials should follow the guidance provided in GN 36-020 and
GN 36-009.
Page 31 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 32 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
2. Low alloy steel piping components and connectors shall conform to Table 9.
Technical justifications should identify why C-Mn steels cannot be used. In most
situations, it should be possible to procure Grade X65/F65 C-Mn components at
thicknesses up to approximately 35 mm (1,4 in). Section size and strength
requirements may justify the use of more hardenable low alloy steel.
d. Maximum HAZ hardness of internally clad components and valve bodies shall be
325 Hv10.
e. Welding (including overlay cladding) and NDE procedures shall be qualified, either
specifically for the fabrication contract or by application of existing procedures, in
accordance with GP 18-01, GIS 18-011, and GIS 18-015.
Requirements for welding components and pipework are provided in GIS 42-103.
f. Heat treatment procedures for clad low alloy steels should include the maximum time at
temperature in addition to the specified minimum time.
Subsea flowlines, pipelines, and risers may be used to transport the following fluids:
Production fluids.
Injection or wash water.
Injection gas.
Chemicals.
Heating medium.
Service or displacement fluids (e.g., dead crude or diesel).
Material options in relation to fluid transported are discussed in 10.1.
10.1.1 General
a. Materials of construction for subsea production flowlines and pipelines shall be assessed
on a case by case basis using principles described in 5 and 6.
Production fluids in flowlines and pipelines may be gas, oil, or multiphase. Since
these fluids are untreated, they might contain condensed or formation water and
CO2. As such, they are likely to be corrosive to carbon steel. H2S and sand also may
be present.
b. Christmas tree to manifold flowlines
1. Christmas tree to manifold flowlines shall be of corrosion resistant construction.
2. Carbon steel may be specified for short service lives or for particularly benign
conditions, especially if the flowlines are relatively long.
Risk and economic factors will favour the use of CRAs for christmas tree to manifold
product flowlines. Flexible pipe also may be specified for these duties, especially for
short lengths. Refer to GP 65-75. Reservoir souring may preclude the selection of
martensitic, duplex, or super duplex stainless steels.
Page 33 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Table 9 - Materials requirements for low alloy steel internally clad components
for piping, fittings, and connectors
Forgings Materials
Low alloy steel components - preferred ASTM A182 F22
option
Low alloy steel components - non AISI 8630, 4140, 4130,
preferred grades and other low alloy high carbon steel forgings
Butt welds Fabrication sequence
Option 1 - Low alloy steel components Apply C-Mn (or low alloy steel) weld buttering to weld
and valve bodies with C-Mn buttering preparation on F22 forging.
layer, welded to X65/F65 C-Mn steel pup Apply alloy 625 cladding to F22 forging and stop
piece with C-Mn butt weld, subject to BP cladding on C-Mn butter weld.
approval.
PWHT F22 forging and buttered layer.
Weld F22 forging to X65/F65 pup piece using C-Mn
welding consumable.
Apply alloy 625 cladding to C-Mn buttering and
X65/F65 pup piece (no additional PWHT).
Refer to Figure A.1.
Option 2 - Low alloy steel components Apply C-Mn (or low alloy steel) weld buttering to weld
and valve bodies with C-Mn buttering preparation on F22 forging.
layer, welded to pre-clad X65/F65 C-Mn Apply alloy 625 cladding to F22 forging and C-Mn
steel pup piece with alloy 625 butt weld, butter weld.
subject to BP approval.
PWHT F22 forging and butter weld.
Weld F22 forging to clad X65/F65 pup piece using
alloy 625 weld consumable (no additional PWHT).
Refer to Figure A.2.
Option 3 - Low alloy steel components Shall not be used, except if Options 1 and 2 are
and valve bodies with alloy 625 buttering demonstrated as impractical.
layer, welded to pre-clad X65/F65 C-Mn Apply alloy 625 weld buttering to weld preparation on
steel pup piece with alloy 625 butt weld, F22 forging.
subject to BP approval.
Apply alloy 625 cladding to F22 forging and alloy 625
butter weld.
PWHT F22 forging and buttered layer.
Weld F22 forging to clad X65/F65 pup piece using
alloy 625 weld consumable (no additional PWHT).
Qualification of welding procedures should follow the
guidance provided in GN 36-020 (see Note).
Note:
A brittle fusion line can develop in CRA/low alloy steel substrate combinations. PWHT has been found to
exacerbate this problem. Several brittle failures at butt welds incorporating CRA buttering on low alloy steel
have been experienced in the subsea industry due to hydrogen embrittlement and cracking in the fusion zone.
Page 34 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 35 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
d. 13% Cr martensitic SS shall not be specified for flowlines or pipelines requiring cathodic
protection by directly fitted aluminium sacrificial anodes. Other options may be proposed
as alternatives, subject to BP approval.
Options include:
Internally clad spool pieces to attach the sacrificial anodes.
Diode controlled sacrificial anodes.
Soft iron anodes.
e. Designs that provide cathodic protection for martensitic stainless steel lines from remote
anodes may be proposed, subject to BP approval.
Additional guidance on application of weldable 13% Cr for subsea pipelines is
provided in GN 36-002.
f. Lined pipe shall not be specified for installation by reel barge or for induction bending.
g. Clad pipe may be proposed for reeling and induction bending, subject to qualification
testing, and BP approval.
Page 36 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
2. Carbon steel pipe clad or lined with stainless steel or nickel based alloy with PREw
greater than 40.
3. Titanium.
f. Spoolable, fibre reinforced, plastic composite flowlines that conform to API RP 15S may
be proposed, subject to BP approval.
10.3.1 SCRs
a. Project specifications for SCRs shall conform to GP 65-73 and GIS 43-313 and should
follow the guidance provided in GN 65-706.
SCRs are dynamic items with a design likely to be dominated by fatigue damage
considerations, especially if connected to floating production systems. Fatigue
damage mainly originates from vessel motions and vortex induced vibration and
may be exacerbated by internal slugging, pressure cycling, and installation.
Steel grade selection and specification is determined by strength requirements,
fracture toughness, fatigue performance, and sour service resistance, as applicable.
Most installed SCRs are API 5L X65 type steel.
Of particular relevance to achievement of adequate fatigue performance are:
Page 37 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 38 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 39 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
8. Density.
9. Fatigue resistance.
10. Friction.
11. Shear, tensile, and compressive properties.
12. Thermal expansion.
13. Thermal shock resistance.
14. Tg or HDT of resins.
15. Resistance to biological effects and UV.
e. Qualification of insulation systems shall be performed on factory coating and field joint,
and shall, as a minimum, include:
1. Simulated service test to confirm the heat transfer characteristics of the system.
2. Simulated installation tests (e.g., static bend test for reeling or tensioner simulation).
3. Cyclic bend tests for dynamic applications.
11.1 General
a. Considerations for materials selection for subsea valves shall include the following, as
applicable:
1. Service temperature and pressure ranges.
2. Corrosivity and erosivity of fluids contacting valve body and parts.
3. Abrasion potential of solids (wear on rubbing or sliding surfaces).
4. Impact potential of solids, such as frac’ing proppants (e.g., on brittle choke
components).
5. Likelihood of seawater ingress during deployment or operation.
6. Galvanic effects due to proximity of different materials.
7. Crevice corrosion resistance (e.g., at seal and flange faces).
8. Galling resistance for moving parts in contact.
9. Rapid gas (explosive) decompression, temperature, and chemical resistance for
nonmetallic materials.
Applicable standards include ISO 10423 (API Spec 6A), ISO 10433, ISO 13628-4
(API Spec 17D), ISO 13628-6 (API Spec 17F), ISO 14313, ISO 14723, and
GIS 43-352.
b. If materials not listed in reference standards are specified, there shall be a clearly defined
and recorded justification for pressure and temperature ratings being claimed.
Metallic materials for pressure boundary parts may be limited by the chosen design
or product standard, since pressure and temperature ratings are applicable only for
listed materials. For this reason, materials for christmas tree valves and manifold or
pipeline valves frequently differ.
c. Internally clad valve bodies shall conform to 9.5.
d. Typical generic and acceptable materials are shown in Table 10.
Page 40 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
e. Subsea manifold and flowline valve materials shall conform to ISO 14723, ASME B16.34,
and GIS 43-352. Other materials, such as nickel base alloys, are not precluded from use
and may be proposed, subject to BP approval.
f. Carbon and low alloy steel valves shall be specified, as a minimum, with alloy 625 weld
overlaid seat pockets and seal contact areas regardless of service.
g. Material requirements of ISO 10423 and ISO 13628-4 shall be complied with if:
1. Design is required to conform to ISO 10423 and ISO 13628-4.
2. Design pressure exceeds limits of ASME Class 2500.
h. If duplex or super duplex stainless steels are specified for pressure retaining parts and
design is in accordance with ISO 10423, allowable stresses shall be limited as specified by
GIS 43-352.
This is to avoid the phenomenon of “cold creep” that can occur at high stress levels.
i. Metal seals and seats shall be more noble than surrounding surfaces.
j. Base material specifications shall be controlled to give good weldability, as applicable. If
necessary, base material weldability trials shall be performed.
k. For carbon steel materials for welding, the following product limitations shall be specified:
1. Carbon - 0,23%, maximum.
2. CEIIW - 0,45, maximum.
11.3 Castings
For castings, assurance of adequate soundness and required mechanical properties shall be
achieved by incorporation of appropriate NDE and destructive testing and control of defect
repairs in material specification.
Cast construction for manifold and pipeline valves can offer advantages of weight
and cost savings, especially if operating pressures are high.
Cast valves for subsea applications are likely to have a high criticality rating and
high quality level in accordance with GP 32-15 and GP 32-17. This will mandate
additional NDE requirements for castings.
Page 41 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
11.5.1 General
A conservative approach towards the use of erosion resistant materials shall be adopted.
Presence of sand rarely can be predicted accurately, and all valves are required to
tolerate pipe scale. For most valves in these applications, wear resistance will be
more important than erosion resistance. Erosion resistance of materials will vary
widely due to local conditions (angle of impingement), but, as a rule of thumb, the
following materials have increasing erosion resistance in the order listed:
Cobalt alloy 6.
Cobalt alloy 1.
Page 42 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 43 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 44 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
12 Fasteners
12.1 Scope
Fasteners shall include:
a. Bolts and nuts for flanged connections (e.g., ASME, API, and compact).
b. Bolts threaded directly into components (e.g., for valve bonnets and instrument
connections).
c. Bolts for tightening clamps (e.g., hub connector clamps and pipe support clamps).
d. Cap screws, circlips, and similar items.
e. Bolts and nuts in lifting equipment or frames used in subsea deployment of permanently
installed items.
Page 45 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
g. Low alloy steel bolting shall be specified for threaded studs fitted directly into carbon or
low alloy steel components.
Safe use of low alloy steel bolting subsea is dependent on effective CP. A potential of
at least -800 mV (Ag/AgCl/ seawater) needs to be achieved on all points of the bolt.
Factors affecting this potential are:
Partial immersion - CP is effective only if bolting is fully immersed and there is
an electrical path through water between bolting and anode. Corrosion will
occur if immersion is not continuous (e.g., in splash zones or tidal conditions).
Geometry - Cathodic potential at any point is dependent on distance from
sacrificial anode, length and width of crevices, and design features causing
shielding of the current through the water.
Temperature - Increasing temperature will raise the cathodic current density
and reduce the achieved potential, particularly within crevices.
Coating - Effective external coatings will reduce overall anode current demand,
facilitating achievement of adequate negative potentials in the crevices.
However, thick noncontinuous coatings, such as disbonded thermal insulation,
can shield CP.
Parent material - Uncoated CRA materials will increase cathode current and
hinder achievement of adequate negative potentials in crevices.
Burial - Immersion of the connection in mud or silt will reduce the cathodic
potential and, if anaerobic conditions exist, may require more negative CP
potentials for protection (e.g., -900 mV versus Ag/AgCl/ seawater).
Anode type and water conductivity - Aluminium zinc indium sacrificial anodes
are almost universally used, giving an open circuit voltage of approximately
-1 100 mV (Ag/AgCl/ seawater). If anodes of different type are used or if the
potential is limited, the potential achieved in crevices may be reduced. Salinity
of water (e.g., lower in estuarine conditions) can affect the available cathodic
potential.
These factors should be considered before low alloy steel bolting is selected. If
conditions are outside previous experience, effectiveness of CP should be
investigated (e.g., by finite element analysis or direct experiment).
h. Thin metal coatings (sherardised, hot spun galvanised, zinc nickel electroplate, or zinc
chromate/phosphate) shall be specified to preserve the bolt surface prior to installation and
to aid assembly.
Metallic coatings promote electrical continuity and effectiveness of CP to protect
the fasteners.
i. Nonmetallic coatings shall not be used.
Such coatings (e.g., PTFE) may lead to loss of electrical continuity.
j. Cadmium plating shall not be used.
Corrosion will lead to toxic compounds being released into the sea.
k. If low alloy steel studs and nuts are used for bimetallic steel-titanium flanged joint, studs
shall be electrically isolated from the titanium by ceramic washers or ceramic coated nut
faces but shall be electrically continuous with the steel to ensure receipt of CP.
Page 46 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
13 Gaskets
13.1 General
a. Wet made joints shall have 6Mo or alloy 625 gaskets, unless approved otherwise by BP.
b. Metal to metal seals that may be exposed to the external seawater environment without CP
shall be specified in UNS R30035, UNS R30003, alloy 625, or alloy C276.
Page 47 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
c. Alloy 925 may be proposed for alloy 625 weld overlaid joint gaskets, if specified to be
softer than the overlay and subject to BP approval.
d. For non permanent gasket applications, lower grade CRAs may be proposed, subject to BP
approval.
e. Gaskets used in ring grooves overlaid with alloy 625 that may be assembled subsea shall
be specified in alloy 625 or 6Mo SS.
f. Gaskets for treated seawater injection shall be 6Mo SS or equivalent and subject to BP
approval.
g. Gaskets for raw seawater injection shall be compatible with the materials of construction
of associated equipment and shall be subject to BP approval.
h. If gaskets incorporate elastomer “secondary” seals, the elastomer material shall be
compatible with the intended service requirements following the guidance provided in
GN 36-003.
Design of metal gaskets for connections made subsea should have a verified design
that incorporates an elastomer secondary seal, in case hub damage or misalignment
causes problems in obtaining a successful seal after makeup.
13.4 Ring type joint (RTJ) gaskets and other metallic sealing rings
Page 48 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
c. If any gasket or metal sealing ring incorporates elastomer “secondary” seals, the elastomer
material shall conform to 13.3h.
14.1 General
a. Materials and their design temperature and pressure limits for hydraulic control and
chemical injection tubing shall be specified in accordance with Table 4.
b. Duplex and super duplex grades to ASTM A789 may be proposed, subject to BP approval.
Duplex stainless steels are not preferred due to susceptibility to hydrogen
embrittlement, given that tubing will be locally cold worked, will not be externally
coated, and will be subject to hydrogen charging from the CP.
Page 49 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
15 Umbilicals
Page 50 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 51 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 52 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Annex A
(Normative)
Fabrication sequences
Figure A.1 - Option 1: Fabrication of low alloy steel components and valve bodies with C-Mn
buttering layer, welded to C-Mn steel pup piece, with C-Mn butt weld
Page 53 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Figure A.2 - Option 2: Fabrication of low alloy steel components and valve bodies with C-Mn
buttering layer, welded to C-Mn steel pup piece, with alloy 625 butt weld
Page 54 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Annex B
(Normative)
BP approval
The need to gain BP approval or guidance for decisions that are beyond or outside specific
requirements contained in this GP but are relevant to its application should in the first instance be
addressed to the designated BP lead materials/corrosion/welding engineer for the job. Depending on
the nature of the request it may require final approval of the materials and corrosion or materials and
welding RPU or GPO TA, as appropriate. If a BP lead materials/corrosion/welding engineer is not
identified for the job then the request should be referred to the materials and corrosion or materials and
welding RPU or GPO TA, as appropriate. For deviations to this GP the approval procedure set out in
the latest version of SRP 5.0-0001, Section 4 – shall be followed.
Page 55 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Bibliography
BP
[1] GIS 18-012, Storage and Control of Welding Consumables.
[2] GIS 36-201, BP Global Subsea Standardisation Materials Rating Assessment and Qualification
Requirements.
[3] GN 06-006, Guidelines for Selecting, Testing and Applying Corrosion Inhibitors in Exploration and
Production.
[4] GN 36-002, Super Martensitic Stainless Steel Flowlines and Pipelines - Avoidance of Hydrogen
Induced Stress Cracking.
[5] GN 36-004, Best Practice for Selection of Materials for Downhole Equipment.
[7] GN 36-010, Recommended Practice for Subsea Insulation and Buoyancy Systems.
[9] GN 36-019, Guidelines for Selecting Downhole Tubing Materials for Injection Wells.
[10] GN 36-024, Test Methods/Protocols for Assessing Materials/ Production Chemicals Compatibility.
[12] GP 32-15, Quality Management, Inspection and Test Requirements for Purchased Equipment and
Materials - Valves.
[13] GP 32-17, Quality Management, Inspection and Test Requirements for Purchased Equipment and
Materials - Subsea Equipment.
[14] GP 36-15, Materials Selection for Surface (Topsides) Equipment in Oil and Gas Production Facilities.
[19] RD 78-001, Hydraulic Piping and Small Bore Fittings for Control Systems.
[20] RD 78-002, Identification, Traceability and Certification Requirements for Subsea Production System
and Umbilicals, Risers, and Flowlines Equipment.
[22] API RP 14B, Design, Installation, Repair and Operation of Subsurface Safety Valve Systems.
Page 56 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
[23] API RP 14E, Recommended Practice for Design and Installation of Offshore Production Platform
Piping Systems (ISO 13703).
[38] ISO 13628-6, Petroleum and natural gas industries - Design and operation of subsea production
systems - Part 6: Subsea production control systems.
[39] ISO 14313, Petroleum and natural gas industries - Pipeline transportation systems - Pipeline valves.
[40] ISO 15156-1 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Materials for use in H2S-containing environments
in oil and gas production - Part 1: General principles for selection of cracking-resistant materials.
[41] ISO 15156-3 Petroleum and natural gas industries - Materials for use in H2S-containing environments
in oil and gas production - Part 3: Cracking-resistant CRAs (corrosion-resistant alloys) and other
alloys.
Page 57 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012
Materials Selection for Subsea Equipment
Page 58 of 58 GP 36-20
8 February 2012