Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
com
DISTRICT COOLING
REFERENCE E-BOOK
“A guide to different technologies
for District Cooling based on
our extensive experience”
INTRODUCTION TO DISTRICT COOLING
District Cooling refers to the centralized production and distribution of cooling energy. The cooling energy is produced in a
central cooling plant as chilled water and is distributed to consumers in a closed piping circuit, also referred to as a reticulation
system.
District Cooling is being implemented worldwide by many different organizations, both private and public. There is also an
extensive variety of consumers (Residential, Hotels, Offices, Retail Stores, Hospitals, etc.).
2
BENEFITS OF DISTRICT COOLING
The District Cooling market has been expanding continuously in recent years because it has been demonstrated to be beneficial
for the Owner and the Consumer. DC can be regarded as another utility, such as power generation, water or natural gas, but with
the product being cooling energy in the form of chilled water that is produced by the DC Plant Owner who in turn meters it and
sells it to the consumer.
3
BENEFITS OF DISTRICT COOLING
Typical Peak Power Demand for Different Cooling Solutions
District cooling can cut peak electrical demand that typically occurs in the late afternoon – reducing strain on the grid and
avoiding expensive peak power costs. The following graph illustrates the difference in consumption between a District Cooling
plant and a traditional air cooled building system with the same cooling demand. The difference between them may reach more
than half during the peak power demand.
1.75
Peak Power Demand (kW/TR)
1.5
1.25
0.75
0.5
0.25
0
Air Cooled Building District Cooling District Cooling (Electric District Cooling (100%
Systems (Electric) with TES) Gas-fired)
4
GREEN BUILDINGS
Green building (also known as green construction or sustainable building) refers to a structure that is designed, constructed and
operated using processes that are environmentally responsible and resource-efficient.
Efficient District Cooling Systems contribute to the Green building as the total electrical consumption of the building is reduced.
LEED Certification (Leadership in Energy & Efficient Design), which is recognized across the world as the premier standard for
Green buildings, recognizes the use of DC systems as a significant contributor towards achieving a highly efficient building. This is
a point based system that categorizes Green buildings into four different levels – Certified,
Silver, Gold and Platinum.
5
DC PLANT SIMULATION & DESIGN CRITERIA
The first stage is to design the DC Plant as efficient as possible, in this regards studying the simultaneity
of the cooling demand of the different buildings/consumers can result in a great optimization of the
system. Not all consumers have their peak cooling load at the same time. As an example, offices
will have their maximum consumption during the working hours while the maximum consumption for
FIRST the hotels will be in the afternoon.
STAGE
Studying the simultaneity of the different buildings/consumers will determine the peak of the connected
cooling load of the entire DC system. The cooling plant in order to be efficient shall be designed
according to this peak of the connected cooling load and maximize energy production.
100%
Residential
90%
80%
70%
Offices
Loads % of Peak
60%
50%
40%
Hotel
30%
20%
10%
Retail
0%
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
6
DC PLANT SIMULATION & DESIGN CRITERIA
A simulation of the District Cooling for a complete year will be very useful in order to evaluate the
different technologies and select the optimum solution for every case. The simulation will estimate the
Hourly Cooling Demand based on the following factors:
16,000,000 16,000,000
Cooling Demand
10,000,000 10,000,000
year)
Water Cooled Chillers Consumption (kW·h) Air Cooled Chillers Consumption (kW·h) Cooling Demand (TR·h)
Once the cooling demand is simulated, the cooling plant consumption will be also evaluated using
local costs for energy and water. The optimum solution will depend on the Owner’s criteria:
7
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
THERMAL ENERGY
STORAGE TANK
HEAT REJECTION
TECHNOLOGIES
CONSUMPTION
PUMPS
HIGH-EFFICIENT PRODUCTIONS
INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS PUMPS
8
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HIGH-EFFICIENT INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS
When designing the cooling plant the chillers selection play an important role for lowering the energy consumption. ARANER´s
chillers are robust industrial grade machines designed and manufactured to improve the District Cooling plant efficiency,
reducing the total water and electrical consumption in the plant.
ARANER’s chillers are designed in order to reduce the total plant energy consumption. Energy consumption is one of the
major concerns worldwide in these days. Lowering energy consumption not only results in big savings in operation cost but also
contributes to the environment by reducing the CO2 footprint. Furthermore, the tailor-made chillers developed by ARANER are
very flexible and will be suitable despite the project specifications and site conditions:
9
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HIGH-EFFICIENCY INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS
The common practice to produce the cooling energy in District Cooling Plants is by means of vapor compression chillers. Other
technologies can be applied depending on the project conditions and cooling requirements.
CENTRIFUGAL CHILLER
Centrifugal compressors are a non-positive displacement type and therefore more sensible to a pressure differential lift between
evaporation pressure and condensing pressure
• Centrifugal chillers are designed with fewer moving parts and straightforward with efficient
engineering, and have proven durability records in hospitals, district cooling systems, and
in other applications where minimal downtime is a crucial concern
• High strength aluminum-alloy compressor impellers feature backward curved vanes for
high efficiency. Airfoil shaped pre-rotation vanes minimize flow disruption for the most
efficient partial load performance
• The advantage of centrifugal compressors is their high flow rates capability and good
efficiency characteristics
SCREW CHILLER
Screw compressor or positive displacement compressors encase a quantity of refrigerant in
a decreasing volume during the compression process. They provide excellent lift characteristics
• They are low speed machines with less wear and so, long trouble free life with less
maintenance.
• Screw compressors are able to accommodates the pressure lift increasing performance
for different conditions (day/night, Summer/winter)
• ARANER screw machines have an extra improved efficiency for the oil injection system
10
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HIGH-EFFICIENCY INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS
ABSORPTION CHILLER
Absorption chillers, instead of using electricity, use ‘heat’ as the energy source, a
low grade energy. The energy source may be steam or hot water, or it may even be
waste heat like in exhaust gases from an engine (gas or oil based). ARANER offers
a wide range of solutions for each of these energy sources, all of which represent a
major advance in Absorption Refrigeration Technology.
ARANER absorption chillers use tested components and procedures for industrial
refrigeration applications. Their main characteristics are:
11
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HIGH-EFFICIENT INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS
REFRIGERANT
CYCLE
Evaporator Evaporator
12
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HIGH-EFFICIENT INDUSTRIAL CHILLERS
Refrigerant selection
Ammonia is probably the most suitable refrigerant for DC systems, and is used as a refrigerant in a large number of
industrial facilities worldwide, providing high efficiency performance. The most important characteristics to be
achieved during the refrigerant the selection are:
Ammonia (NH3) has by far the best characteristics in thermodynamic terms. Because of its agricultural,
industrial and commercial use, the world ammonia production is huge and both price and availability
are much more favorable than for any other refrigerant.
With increased regulation being placed ammonia is becoming an alternative refrigerant for new installation.
Ammonia has an Ozone Depletion Potential of 0.00 and a high latent heat of vaporization (9 times greater
than R-12). In addition, ammonia in the atmosphere does not directly contribute to global warming. These
characteristics result in a highly energy-efficient refrigerant with minimal environmental problems, for
that, ammonia should be always selected, when possible, for industrial refrigeration installations.
For those cases in which R717 is not preferred, ARANER has extensive experience in the use of other
refrigerants, especially in R134a facilities.
13
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HEAT REJECTION TECHNOLOGIES
The heat energy absorbed by the chillers shall be rejected to the environment. There are several technologies for heat rejection
to the environment.
Water-Cooled Condenser
The most common practice is to reject the condenser heat by means of cooling towers. In cooling towers, water is sprayed
and evaporated over an air stream flow. The coolant fluid is the water which will evaporate at ambient wet bulb temperature
which usually is way lower than ambient temperature, reducing the condensing temperature. The benefits of this technology are
relatively low CAPEX, compact size and high efficiency since it allows for lower condensing pressures.
14
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
HEAT REJECTION TECHNOLOGIES
Air-Cooled Condenser
With this technology, heat is rejected to the ambient air. Air fans are
installed in order to circulate the proper air flow through a finned tube
heat exchanger. The dry bulb temperature of ambient air is higher than
the wet bulb temperature so condensing temperature and pressure will
be higher when compared with water-cooled technology which adversely
affects the efficiency of the DC system. The advantage of this solution
is that water consumption is ZERO, so air-cooled condensers are the
preferred technology for areas with scarce water supply (remote areas,
dry areas).
15
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
THERMAL ENERGY STORAGE TANK (TES TANK) FOR DISTRICT COOLING
TES Tank is a thermal accumulator that allows the storage of chilled water or ice produced during off-peak time. This energy
is later used during on-peak time. A TES tank reduces refrigerant plant capacity and operational cost, producing chilled
water when demand is low, which usually coincides with the night, when ambient temperature is low and chillers have better
performance.
DISTRICT COOLING LOAD PROFILE AND TES TANK OPERATION
60,000 200,000
160,000
excess
Refrigeration Load, TR
120,000
designed for average loads and not for peaks 30,000 100,000
periods. 20,000
60,000
0 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Hour of the Day
16
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT COMPONENTS
THERMAL ENERGY STORAGE TANK (TES TANK) FOR DISTRICT COOLING
In District cooling plants with TES Tank, the refrigeration capacity of the chillers will be lower due to the cooling energy already
accumulated in the tank during the previous hours. In other words, a smaller refrigeration system can be used to satisfy an
specified peak demand. Therefore, ARANER engineers put a great effort to design the most efficient Thermal Energy Storage Tanks
for District Cooling Plants.
In Thermal Energy Storage Tanks, a proper diffuser geometry helps the water volumes to stratify uniformly inside the tank, via
water velocities and densities, and thus provide the District Cooling System with the required cooling capacity
STRATIFIED T
CHILLER 1
STORAGE T
TANK
PRODUCTION CHILLER 1
PUMPS
From consumer
From consumer
T
P
To consumer
T LOAD
CHILLER 2
To consumer
LOAD PUMPING
P T
GROUP
From consumer
From consumer
CHILLER 2
CONSUMPTION
PUMPS
T To consumer
T To consumer
LOAD LOAD
• The overall cost of the installation is lower due to the reduction of the refrigeration plant installed capacity. The refrigeration
equipment size is smaller because it is designed for average loads and not for peaks
• The operational cost is reduced in comparison with an online cooling system because peak consumption can be avoided
during high electrical tariff periods
• The environmental impact is reduced because of the reduction of CO2 storing the energy and improving operating efficiency
with the thermal energy storage tank helps to reduce even more the CO2 emissions of a district cooling system
• The plant dimension of the refrigeration system could be reduced. This is given by the fact that the refrigeration capacity of
energy to be produced by the plant will be lower due to the energy already accumulated in the tank. Therefore, a smaller
refrigeration system can be used
18
CONTROL SYSTEM FOR DC
Integrated Control System
Different components of the District Cooling system need to operate and perform all together as a single and fully integrated
system. The best practice is to integrate into one single Control System all the information regarding the main equipment (chillers,
pumps, heat rejection devices) and the Energy Transfer Stations (ETSs). Even Preventive maintenance management system and
ETSs Consumption billing system can be integrated in the same Control System
ARANER designs and integrates our own control systems. With a very intuitive
and easy-to-use Human Machine Interfaces (HMI) and SCADA’s, full
control and plant integration are achieved. ARANER built a manage control
system architecture utilizing redundant EtherNet/IP as their communication
backbone, as well as other common industrial communication protocols
such Modbus, Profinet or BacNet. As a result, they can seamlessly integrate
with other automation systems and software platforms.
Control solutions used by ARANER allows our customers to improve their process and become agiler by simplifying integration,
streamlining commissioning and providing increased operational flexibility and performance.
19
COOLING LOADS CALCULATIONS
When sizing a District Cooling plant, cooling load calculations play a critical role. This is a complex process; calculate the
cooling demand and the plant performance for thousands of different ambient conditions involves great efforts and resources.
With ARANER’s conscientious and experienced, clients can be sure of getting a District Cooling system that will serve perfectly for
many years. ARANER opts to use the more strenuous and reliable complex simulation method because its high accuracy helps
predict the energy performance of a District Cooling system with minimal errors.
We recognize that the cooling equipment may not operate at maximum capacity throughout the day, leave alone the month or
year. That is why we use powerful computer software to determine the ideal cooling load profile. Instead of picking one hour per
day, we consider real weather data hour-by-hour for a complete year. This means that the cooling demand and the cooling plant
performance is calculated for 8,760 different points.
Our collection of data is straightforward, but thorough at the same time. The most important thing about our detailed cooling load
profile is that it describes the variation of the load within time. Some issues may affect this profile and they include:
60,000 200,000
180,000
• Hours of operation of a facility
50,000
160,000 • Climate of plant’s location
• Base loads- computer rooms, telecom closets, etc.
Refrigeration load (TR)
30,000 100,000 It is clear, therefore, that this profile simulation leans towards
80,000 a clearer picture of a complete cooling plant performance.
20,000
60,000 For the best results in District Cooling design and decision-
40,000 making process, a detailed cooling load profile simulation
10,000
20,000 is essential. Only Detailed Cooling Load Profile calculations
0 0 can guarantee that the resulting District Cooling system is
0:00 2:00 4:00 6:00 8:00 10:00 12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00
optimally energy efficient, comfortable and satisfactory.
Time 0:00 4:48 9:36 14:24 19:12 0:00 4:48
20
STUDY OF CHILLED WATER NETWORK
The recently constructed District Cooling plants, especially
in Middle East, have a total cooling capacity of several dozen
thousands of Refrigeration Tons. These high capacities result in
large chilled water flows which require a thorough analysis of
the water pipe network:
• Water Analysis. The water is studied to prevent corrosion in pipes and equipment.
With this data we make a properly selection of equipment materials, required chemical
products and water treatments
• Water Hammer Analysis. Water hammer is a pressure surge or wave caused when
a fluid in motion is forced to stop or change direction suddenly. This pressure wave can
cause major problems, from noise and vibration to pipe collapse. We make simulations
in the design phase to avoid these problems during operation
21
Potential DC Failures: low delta-t syndrome
Low Delta T Syndrome is a quite common problem in chilled water cooling plants in general. For different reasons, the Delta T
of the actual chilled water flow (supply water temperature minus return water temperature) is lower than the Design value. As
the water flow needed is inversely proportional to the Delta T, low Delta T results in higher required water flow and increase in
the required pumping energy, which adversely affects system efficiency. The Low Delta T phenomenon can be found on both the
Cooling Plant side and Developers/Buildings (consumers) side of the water circuit. The most common causes of low Delta T are:
22
RELIABLE DISTRICT COOLING REFERENCE
As reference in the District Energy Sector, ARANER has designed and implemented the District Cooling application (80,000 m3)
with the World Largest Thermal Energy Storage with stratified water in Middle East. This iconic project is projected to be
a reference in the Middle East for similar developments not only because of its aesthetics but also because of its sustainability.
23
RELIABLE AND EFFICIENT COOLING ENERGY PRODUCTION
DISTRICT COOLING PLANT Scrubber
Water Type
THE PROJECT DIRECT CONDENSATION SOLUTION VFD in ventilation fans
to regulate the air flow
Abdali is Amman's new downtown that provides the Jordanian Due to the water restrictions in Jordan, ARANER developed a solution with ZERO
capital with the central business, social and residential water consumption but with several improvements in order to achieve a yearly
destination it needs as a regional business and tourism hub. efficiency similar to a DC plant with cooling towers. These improvements are as
Plenty of modern and luxury building, towers, residences, follows:
business centers and commercial area have been developed with R717 Condensers
Forced Air Cooled Dry type
a total value of more than 5 billion USD. - Direct Condensation Stainless Steel Tubes transformers
- Industrial grade high efficiency chillers Aluminium finned
The relationship beteen ARANER and Abdali started in 2009 with - Long term storage tank
the installation of a temporary District Cooling Plant with a - Natural and efficient refrigerant Oil Type
capacity of 2,500 TR. Afterwards a new phase of the plant has Transformers
been implemented with a total cooling capacity of 31,500 TR;
and a second phase will be developed in the near future with a
total capacity of 52,000 TR.
Low Voltage
T
To consumer
CHILLER 2 CHILLER 1 PRODUCTION
PUMPS
and Medium
T
From consumer
CHILLER 3
Voltage Rooms
CHILLER 4
T
ETS2
P T
To consumer
CHILLER 6 CHILLER 5
T
P From consumer
CHILLER 8 CHILLER 7 ETS3
T T
To consumer
From consumer
STRATIFIED STORAGE
ETSn
CONSUMPTION T
To consumer
PUMPS
BOILER 5MW
From consumer
ETS1
BOILER 16MW T
To consumer
BOILER 16MW
From consumer
ETS2
BOILER 16MW T
To consumer
BOILER 16MW
From consumer
ETS3
T
BOILER 16MW To consumer
1.20
1.10
Plant Efficiency kW/RT
1.00
0.90
0.80
0.70
0.60
0.50
20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42
Water Pumps
Ambient Temp ºC
4 on Duty + 1 Standby
Total Flow: 1,560m3/h
©2017 ARANER
Printed in Madrid. Revised January 2017
www.araner.com