Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MANAGEMENT
ASSIGNMENT 1
Submitted By:
NITHYA N(PES1201802342)
SUJAN SHANKAR(PES1201802550)
AKSHITA GOPAL (PES1201802566)
ANJALI KS (PES1201802183)
DISON P.S (PES1201802310)
1. Briefly interview on phone an employee in his/her 20s, 30s, 40s and 50s, and 60s.
Determine what motivates employees from different generations and design
compensation plans for each generation that would result in high performance?
Solution:
This generation people are right on the heels of Millennials and, they're starting to enter the
workplace. They say that they are motivated by social rewards, mentorship, and constant
feedback. They also want to be meaningful and be given responsibility. Like their
predecessors, they also demand flexible schedules.
Other ways to motivate this generation is through experiential rewards and opportunities for
personal growth. They also expect structure, clear directions, and transparency. This is the
most diverse generation and many Gen Z workers are bilingual/multilingual. They are true
digital natives with short attention spans. They will not classify themselves. Nonetheless,
they are eager to work, motivated by job security, and they want to contribute to meaningful
work.
COMPENSATION PLAN:
Millennials value benefits choices, paid time off, ability to work remotely, control
over their schedules, and a great deal of flexibility.
They feel more comfortable asking employers for more perks and compensation
without planning to stick around very long.
According to recent survey by workplace coaching company Inside Out Development
32% of Gen Z’ers believe that they deserve a promotion within first six months of
working.
In most cases, they have no problem jumping from one organization to another.
They want to work in an environment where they can collaborate with others. Flexible
schedules, time off, and embracing the latest technology to communicate are also important
for Gen Y.
COMPENSATION PLAN:
Gen X workers are motivated by incentives tied to individual results, access to the best office
technology rather than the corner office, and work/life balance that includes a flexible
schedule. They work hard and play hard.
They say that they also want options in tasks, challenges, and new processes and freedom to
use their own resourcefulness to achieve success, too.
Gen Xers can be motivated by flexible schedules, benefits like telecommuting, recognition
from the boss, and bonuses, stock, and gift cards as monetary rewards.
COMPENSATION PLAN:
Gen Xers value salary level, a retirement plan with matching benefits, job security,
advancement within the company, and opportunities for work-life balance.
Gen Xers desire pay increases tied to their own performance, and personal rewards for
results.
They also expect coaching to be focused equally on improving both strengths and
weaknesses.
Boomers are often ambitious, loyal, work-centric, and cynical. They prefer monetary
rewards, but also enjoy nonmonetary rewards like flexible retirement planning and peer
recognition. Since Boomers are so goal-oriented generation they can be motivated by
promotions, professional development, and having their expertise valued and acknowledged.
Prestigious job titles and recognition like office size and parking spaces are also important to
Boomers.
They can also be motivated through high levels of responsibility, perks, praise, and challenge.
COMPENSATION PLAN:
Baby Boomers value salary level, health insurance, and a retirement plan.
Many baby boomers don't fight the system and will put up with bureaucracy and are
more willing to operate "status quo."
They look for job security.
AN EMPLOYEE OF AGE 60 (TRADITIONALISTS)
Since these people are 60 years of age, we don't see many of them in workplace. However,
they still impressively make up around three percent of the workforce.
This is the generation who firmly believes in an "Honest day's pay for an honest day's work."
They're extremely loyal and enjoy being respected for that. Since they're conformists, they
value most job titles and money.
COMPENSATION PLAN:
2. What are advantages and disadvantages of organizational policies that mandate pay
secrecy? Consider this question from the perspective of managers, employees and
owners. Is pay secrecy a good practice?
Solution:
Pay secrecy is simply defined as withholding information from the employees regarding the
compensations of all other company’s employees. Therefore, it can be said that pay secrecy
policy is applied when the management, in a systematic and planned manner, withholds from
the employees the information about the distribution of compensations within the company.
Pay secrecy usually includes withholding the information from employees on both the
salaries of other employees in the company, as well as of their incentive payments and other
benefits and perquisites
Advantages
Pay secrecy also has its advantages. It enables the management to exert a higher degree of
control over the organisational processes, and it also causes less conflict. Moreover, pay
secrecy enables managers to differentiate, to a larger extent, the employees showing good
from those displaying bad performances, and this is especially true in collectivist cultures
such as Serbian. Also, pay secrecy decreases the turnover of employees, which is a very
positive effect for a company. Finally, pay secrecy provides the management or company
owners with a more favourable position in negotiations with potential employees regarding
the conditions of their employment. it is clear that pay secrecy is conducive to more efficient
control of both the employees’ individual behaviour and interactions between them, and
through this it also leads to more efficient control of interpersonal processes in the
organisation. Secrecy of compensation distribution decreases or completely eliminates
conflicts inside the organisation.
Pay secrecy enables managers to employ compensation to differentiate the good from the
bad workers in a simpler and extensive manner. If we assume that the management is willing
to reward the best employees though compensation, and especially through incentive
payments, the logical obstacle to this is the negative reaction of all those who did not receive
a reward (or who even received a penalty). Managers can safely and without fear from the
employees’ reaction, reward the desirable behaviour and performance of the best workers. It
has been empirically proven that, in the absence of pay secrecy, managers show tendency to
narrow the salary spread between the best and the worst employees in order to avoid
conflicts.
No company management would implement pay secrecy policy if it did not bring some sort
of advantages to the company and its managers. Consequence of pay secrecy is negative for
the employees, because they are individually denied the opportunities to make optimal
decisions regarding their career choices, it is certainly positive for the company. If pay
secrecy is applied, the employer (owner or manager) can take full liberty to use his/her
negotiating skills to reduce the level of the employee’s compensation to the smallest possible
amount.
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of pay secrecy are numerous. The main negative effect of pay secrecy is the
misconception of compensation distribution in the company, which gives rise to negative
evaluation of distributive justice, decrease in employees’ motivation and job satisfaction,
diminution of the employees’ trust in the organisation and its management, and decline in
loyalty. Also, pay secrecy deprives the management of a very important tool for controlling
and guiding the employees’ behaviour, which in turn become less efficient. Pay secrecy
brings about the feeling of under appreciation and uncertainty in employees. It also
contributes to creating an authoritarian organisational culture and leadership style. Finally,
pay secrecy jeopardises the employees’ capacity to make rational decisions regarding their
job and career choices.
If employees feel that they are underpaid, even if their compensation is high, they will not be
satisfied because the compensation tells them that they are not appreciated, respected, and
recognised enough in their company. If the employees are uncertain of the bonus awarding
criteria in the company, then they will not have clear guidelines on how they are supposed do
their job and they will not know how they are expected to behave. Pay secrecy leads to
confusion and uncertainty regarding the way in which the employees should perform their
tasks. The logical consequence is that the employee starts to distrust the company. In addition
to this, absence of trust is the immediate cause of decrease in one’s loyalty to the company.
The management is then with mediocre employees who are comfortable with the situation in
which no one asks them for their opinions and where they simply follow instructions.
Is pay secrecy a good practice?
Pay secrecy is a very interesting and controversial element of human resources management
in modern companies. Pay secrecy offers advantages and disadvantages to both the
employees and also to the company and its owners and managers. Pay secrecy will be a good
solution when the workforce is highly educated and/or performs complex and creative tasks
by using sophisticated technology, when autocratic culture and leadership style are applied in
organisations, when the degree of the employees’ trust in and loyalty to the company are high
and when there is no history of conflicts between the employees and management, when
there were no recent dismissals and layoffs, etc.
3. Discuss the pros and cons of employee pay being fixed versus variable and dependent
on performance. How might such decisions impact recruiting, motivation and
retention?
Solution:
Pros and cons of employee pay being fixed versus variable and dependent on
performance
Encouraging Productivity
A potential advantage offering fixed wages instead of variable pay is that a variable pay
system can create unhealthy competition between employees. For example, if sales workers
work on commission, they may be less willing to share work with one another or help each
other make sales. This could result in sub-optimal distribution of work and an atmosphere
that does not encourage collaboration.
Workers who receive commissions do well when business is good, but they do poorly when
business is bad. In times of slow business, even top sales people might have difficulty making
enough sales earn a decent living. If a market is slow and commissioned workers can't earn
enough, they may look for other employment opportunities. In lean times, fixed wages can be
more effective at keeping employees from leaving for other opportunities.
Impact fixed versus variable and dependent on performance recruiting, motivation and
retention
Recruitment
Offering variable pay as part of a remuneration package to attract staff may be done for
offensive or defensive reasons when compared with fixed pay. Taking the latter, if bonuses or
profit sharing is the norm for that sector, occupation or salary level, then employers are
bound to offer the same so that they will not be at a disadvantage. Clearly, if it is not usual in
these circumstances, an organisation offering something more may gain competitive
advantage. The benefit from the employer’s view is that this extra element may, if properly
designed, be funded from extra income. In some circumstances, affordability might drive the
proportion of variable pay in the package and its nature. Many dot com companies could not
afford high wages and so offered shares linked to business performance instead.
If the reasoning behind the variable pay scheme is to emphasise inclusivity –all are part of a
common organisation – then the possibility of extra cash or shares may also have a symbolic
value. It may form part of the employer’s brand, a signal to the market of what the
organisation stands for.
Ex:
Royal Mail’s corporate bonus scheme. The Royal Mail’s ‘share in success’ scheme is, at the
time of writing, set to deliver a bonus of between £800 and £1,000 if the company’s profit
exceeds £400 million in the financial year to end March 2005.
A company spokesperson described the scheme as being ‘part of making Royal Mail a great
place to work and recognising the hard work everyone is doing to turn round the company’.
Critics have complained that though revenue targets may be met, service quality targets have
been missed.
Retention
Variable pay can put more money into the hands of the best performers when compared with
fixed pay, something that is increasingly important as organisations compete for the most
talented individuals. Highly differentiated performance-related pay schemes can do so by
giving bigger bonuses to the top performers and smaller (or no extra money) to the average or
merely ‘good’ performers. Companies can find a twin benefit in such an approach: the best
get more money and a signal that their contribution is recognised and valued. Channelling the
highest payments towards the best performers in this way helps to retain the most effective
people.
Motivation
Variable pay plans can motivate employees, which is one of the pros of this type of incentive
as compared to fixed pay. Although some employees aren't motivated by compensation and
benefits, a year-end bonus can prod many workers to a higher level of performance. In this
case, a variable pay plan is akin to dangling a carrot in front of workers who otherwise would
perform just satisfactory work rather than strive for excellent ratings come performance
appraisal time. High performance ratings are a boost for employees, but the challenge is to
sustain employees' job performance levels beyond the season when companies disburse
performance pay.
4. Visit the website http://www.salary.com. Click on “Salary trends” and then prepare a
brief report on the latest developments in compensation practice.
Solution:
10. Standalone AI won’t have a role in HR – AI will only work if it’s integrated into
workflows
As artificial intelligence becomes more common in HR applications, HR professionals will
need to determine which solutions will have the biggest impact on their business. In 2018,
focusing on AI that’s fully integrated into existing HR workflows will allow HR to capitalize
on their AI investment and easily integrate promising new technology into their daily tasks.
5. Should an organization that operates in different locations in India for different
sectors pay different salaries for identical work? Is cost of living a sufficient
explanation for an employee who senses inequity?
Solution:
Yes, it is necessary for an organisation that operates in different locations in India for
different sectors to pay different salaries for identical work, i.e., provide geographic pay
differentials (or location pay differentials) in their salary scales.
In a company with geographic pay differentials, an employee in an area that has higher
prevailing wage rates for comparable jobs, a higher cost of living and/or is in a work
environment prone to considerable risk will be paid more than peers elsewhere in the
company, all else equal.
Everyone brings unique skills and abilities to a job. And no two jobs are exactly alike.
Variations affect pay for jobs within the same occupation. Often, the more pronounced these
variations are, the bigger the wage difference.
Compensation is the price organizations pay for delivery of jobs or services, which add value
to the organization. Compensation for a specific job is primarily determined by Position
evaluation, Person assessment and Performance review (3P Factors).
An organisation that operates in different locations will have to pay different salaries as it
will have to cater to the following strategic compensation policy concerns:
The rate of pay within the organization and whether it is to be above, below, or at the
prevailing community rate.
The ability of the pay program to gain employee acceptance while motivating
employees to perform to the best of their abilities.
The pay level at which employees may be recruited and the pay differential between
new and more senior employees.
The intervals at which pay raises are to be granted and the extent to which merit
and/or seniority will influence the raises.
The pay levels needed to facilitate the achievement of a sound financial position in
relation to the products or services offered.
Cost of living, i.e., local housing & environmental conditions and also inflation could be one
of the factors justifying inequity in an employee’s salary, but not the sole factor. The other
factors affecting the wage mix include:
Internal Factors:
Compensation strategy of the organisation which is set to lead, lag or match
competitors pay.
Worth of the job based on the internal wage relationship among job & skill levels.
Employees relative worth, rewarding employee’s performance
Employers ability to pay on the basis of the resources & profits of the organisation.
External Factors:
Conditions of the labour market determined by the economy, government regulations
& policies and the presence of unions.
Area wage rates which is influenced by the other area employers for comparable jobs.
Collective bargaining that protects employees purchasing power.
Other prevalent legal requirements.
6. What are the key trends of the Total Reward System in the 21st Century?
Solution:
TREND 1: SENIORITY-CONTRIBUTION
The traditional reward system is mainly based on seniority or length of service. Jobs
have been defined in terms of tasks. That is, employees have to perform narrowly
defined functions. They need narrowly defined skills.
This kind of rewards system has come to be viewed as an entitlement and thus is not
capable of truly motivating or reinforcing employee behaviour.
To compete in today’s marketplace, growing numbers of corporations are seeking
new strategies to improve employee performance and development. The new trend in
reward systems is based on employees’ contributions, which includes competency and
performance.
Rewarding for competencies means that pay is strongly influenced by the
competencies required to perform both a role and run a company. Performance is
productivity and accomplishment. Rewarding for performance helps to hold workers
accountable for specific objectives and provides an incentive for exceeding the
objectives. Today, strategic human resource management ideas emphasize the total
contribution to the firm.
rend 2: Simplex–Multiplex
The traditional reward method just paid
money. However, people work for more than just
pay. A pay raise alone does not have sufficient
power to motivate with time. The modern reward
system embraces everything that is valued by
employees in the employment relationship.
Successful companies use a portfolio approach
to reward and do not rely on just one or two meth-
odds. Each method has a distinct purpose and
structure to encourage a set of actions or atti-
tudes. There is no single method that works in the
long run. Successful companies have achieved an
rend 2: Simplex–Multiplex
The traditional reward method just paid
money. However, people work for more than just
pay. A pay raise alone does not have sufficient
power to motivate with time. The modern reward
system embraces everything that is valued by
employees in the employment relationship.
Successful companies use a portfolio approach
to reward and do not rely on just one or two meth-
ods. Each method has a distinct purpose and
structure to encourage a set of actions or atti-
tides. There is no single method that works in the
long run. Successful companies have achieved an
rend 2: Simplex–Multiplex
The traditional reward method just paid
money. However, people work for more than just
pay. A pay raise alone does not have sufficient
power to motivate with time. The modern reward
system embraces everything that is valued by
employees in the employment relationship.
Successful companies use a portfolio approach
to reward and do not rely on just one or two meth-
odds. Each method has a distinct purpose and
structure to encourage a set of actions or attic-
tides. There is no single method that works in the
long run. Successful companies have achieved an
rend 2: Simplex–Multiplex
The traditional reward method just paid
money. However, people work for more than just
pay. A pay raise alone does not have sufficient
power to motivate with time. The modern reward
system embraces everything that is valued by
employees in the employment relationship.
Successful companies use a portfolio approach
to reward and do not rely on just one or two meth-
odds. Each method has a distinct purpose and
structure to encourage a set of actions or attic-
tides. There is no single method that works in the
long run. Successful companies have achieved an
TREND 2: SIMPLEX MULTIPLEX
The traditional reward method just paid money. However, people work for more than
just pay. A pay raise alone does not have sufficient power to motivate with time.
The modern reward system embraces everything that is valued by employees in the
employment relationship. The total reward system is defined here to include base
salary, variable pay, direct compensation, perquisites, benefits, performance
management, training, career development, coaching and other employee-related
policies. Combinations of variable pay, recognition and celebration and benefits are
essential to provide a total reward package.
The concept of the contemporary reward system is composed of four components:
total pay, attractive variable pay, benefits and recognition and celebration.
a) Individual growth: providing the training for workers to grow and learn during
their whole career.
b) Positive workplace: branding your organization so that people are excited about
coming to work.
c) Compelling future: making your company uniquely attractive to the people you
need.
d) Different reward methods are likely to have different effects on organizational
outcomes.
Adopting appropriate methods will enable employers to deliver attractive and relevant
rewards at a sustainable cost and help ensure that employees perceive they are
receiving appropriate value from the company in exchange.