Ifc Check & Revise Record - Cbd-Cuc-E01-El-001

CHECK & REVISE RECORD
No.: CBD-17-E01-EL-001
Package No. P17 Discipline EL Reviewed by BEN
Design
Tower No. E01 FD Total pages. 17
Stage
Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

General 1. Please provide the design report.
2. Please provide the ELV system
drawing, such as: CCTV system
drawing, access control system
drawing, FA system drawing, and
communication system drawing.
E18066- There are drawings, but the list are
0105D-FD- missing.
17-E00-EG-0-
00-010-0
E18066- Missing all drawings for ELV system in

0105D-FD- the drawing list.
17-E00-EG-0-
00-011-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-0-
GN-010-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-0-
GN-011-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-5-
GN-001-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-5-
GN-002-0
Page 1 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-5-
GN-003-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-5-
GN-004-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E00-EG-6-
GN-002-0
E18066- 1. Air terminations shall consist of
0105D-FD- horizontal conductors (Tinned bare
17-E01-EG-1- copper tape 30x10 mm2)…..
R0-000-0
According to BS EN 62305-3, the
dimensions are at least equal to 50 mm2
for air terminations.
Note 8: If thermal and

mechanical considerations are
important, these dimensions can be
increased to 60 mm2 for solid tape
and to 78 mm2 for solid round.
Please make calculation sheet or

recheck.
2. There are about 10 m high

Aluminum Louvers and steel
structure on the parapet.
They can be considered as natural
Page 2 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

air-termination.
3. According to calculation sheet,
Radius of rolling sphere is 60 m. Air-
termination need not installed on
part of parapet.
4. According to structure design report,

local basic wind speed is 33 m/s.
Please recheck.
E18066- Same as above
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-1-
R0-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-1-
R0-002-0
E18066- 1. Please provide the rated voltages
0105D-FD- U0/U of cable for the System voltage
17-E01-EG-6- 11 kV.
00-001-0 Please provide the System category.
According to SPC, The insulation

class of MV cable shall not be less
than 18/30 (36) KV.
2. Please provide the System earthing

for the 11 kV system.
3. There is no capacitor bank for 11 kV

System. Power factor is about 0.87
for chiller without capacitor.
Please recheck.
4. There are no calculation sheet of

load for 11 kV System. The
requirement of 11KV switchgear
(1250A/31.5kA) maybe change and
lower.
Page 3 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

5. Reduce the number of 22/11 KV
transformers, increase the capacity
of the transformer, and change the
power supply of the refrigeration
unit, as shown below:
This is one proposal to improve the

system's operation.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-6-
00-002-0
E18066- 1. BUSWAY FTAS23 is 4000A, but
0105D-FD- BUSWAY FATS21 is 2000A. Please
17-E01-EG-6- recheck.
00-004-0 2. BUSWAY FTAS23 is fed from
Generator plant to DCP. Part of
busway is outside. So, cable is
better than busway.
E18066- Increase the number of 22/0.4KV
0105D-FD- transformers, reduce the capacity of the
17-E01-EG-6- transformer, and change the power
00-005-0 supply of the pump, as shown below:
Page 4 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage
This is one proposal to improve the

system's operation.
E18066- Same as above.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-6-
00-006-0
E18066- 1. ‘PF-01’ and ‘PF-02’ are FANs used
0105D-FD- for fire fighting, and load is too small.
17-E01-EG-6- So, recommended to remove the
GN-010-0 VFD.
2. Please provide the material of all the

cables in this drawing.
Page 5 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage
3. There are no PURGE FAN ‘PUF-01’,

‘PUF-02’, ‘PUF-03’ in HVAC drawing
E18066-0105D-FD-17-E01-MH-6-
GN-002, but there are power supply
circuits for them.
Please recheck.
4. The Rated voltage of EXHAUST

FAN ‘EX.F-01’ and ‘EX.F-02’ is
220V in HVAC drawing E18066-
0105D-FD-17-E01-MH-6-GN-002,
but their power supply circuits are
three phase.
Please recheck.
Page 6 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage
E18066- 1. There are no single line diagrams for

0105D-FD- the CONDENSOR WATER
17-E01-EG-6- FILTRATON SYSTEM in HAVC
GN-011-0 drawing E18066-0105D-FD-17-E01-
MH-6-GN-002.
Please recheck.
Page 7 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage
E18066- 1. There are no single line diagrams for

0105D-FD- SECONDARY PUMPS S/P 1-6 and
17-E01-EG-6- COOLING TOWER VRIABLE
GN-012-0 SPPED FANS in HVAC drawing
E18066-0105D-FD-17-E01-MH-6-
GN-002.
Please recheck.
Page 8 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-7-
00-001-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EG-7-
00-002-0
E18066- 1. Please provide the average
0105D-FD- illuminance levels for every room.
17-E01-EL-1- 2. Please provide the installation of the
B1-001-0 TYPE M light fixture.

0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
GR-000-0
0105D-FD-
Page 9 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

17-E01-EL-1-
GR-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
GR-002-0
E18066- 1. Same as above.
0105D-FD- 2. Please provide the installation of the
17-E01-EL-1- TYPE B light fixture.
01-000-0

0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
01-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
01-002-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
M1-000-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
M1-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
M1-002-0
Page 10 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

E18066- The installation height of the wall
0105D-FD- mounted light fixture is higher than
17-E01-EL-1- parapet.
R0-000-0 Please recheck or make detail.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
R0-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EL-1-
R0-002-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
B1-001-0
E18066- Please provide the enough socket for
0105D-FD- the workshop room according the
17-E01-EP-1- furniture layout.
GR-000-0

0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
GR-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
GR-002-0
E18066- NONE.
Page 11 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
01-000-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
01-001-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
01-002-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
M1-000-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
M1-001-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
M1-002-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
R0-000-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
R0-001-0
E18066- NONE.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-EP-1-
R0-002-0
E18066- 1. Please provide the installation height
0105D-FD- of the cable ladder.
17-E01-ER-1- 2. Please provide the support
B1-001-0 information of the cable tray, cable
Page 12 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

ladder and Busway such as: the
quantity of the supports, the
installation location of the supports,
the support detail drawings.
E18066- 1. Please provide the installation height
0105D-FD- of the cable tray.
17-E01-ER-1- 2. Please provide the dewatering pump
B1-002-0 feeder routing system layout
drawing
E18066- 1. If the cable tray are more than two
0105D-FD- layers in the same horizontal
17-E01-ER-1- position, please give detail.
GR-000-0
2. The location of the chiller is different

between this drawing and HAVC
drawing E18066-0105D-FD-17-E01-
MH-1-GR-000, the cable ladder
route is not correct.
Please recheck.
3. Please provide the specification and

location of the UPVC conduit.
Page 13 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
GR-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
GR-002-0
E18066- 1. Please provide the support
0105D-FD- information of the cable tray, cable
17-E01-ER-1- ladder and Busway such as: the
GR-003-0 quantity of the supports, the
2. Please provide the installation height
of the cable tray.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
GR-004-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
GR-005-0
M1-000-0 quantity of the supports, the
of the cable tray.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
M1-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
Page 14 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

M1-002-0
E18066- 1. The location of the chiller is different
0105D-FD- between this drawing and HAVC
17-E01-ER-1- drawing E18066-0105D-FD-17-E01-
01-000-0 MH-1-GR-000, the cable ladder
route is not correct.
Please recheck.
2. The cable ladder cross the Elevator
shaft, Please recheck.

0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
01-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
01-002-0
01-003-0 quantity of the supports, the
of the cable tray.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
01-004-0
Page 15 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
01-005-0
E18066- 1. If the cable tray are more than two
0105D-FD- layers in the same horizontal
17-E01-ER-1- position, please give detail drawing.
R0-000-0
2. Please provide the support

information of the cable tray, cable
ladder and Busway such as: the
quantity of the supports, the
of the cable tray.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
R0-001-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
R0-002-0
R0-003-0 quantity of the supports, the
Page 16 / 17 22-Apr-20
Design
Stage

of the cable tray.
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
R0-004-0
0105D-FD-
17-E01-ER-1-
R0-005-0
Reviewer Reviewer’s Recheck
Date Date
Page 17 / 17 22-Apr-20

Ifc Check & Revise Record - Cbd-Cuc-E01-El-001

Caricato da

Informazioni sul documento

Titolo originale

Copyright

Formati disponibili

Condividi questo documento

Condividi o incorpora il documento

Opzioni di condivisione

Hai trovato utile questo documento?

Questo contenuto è inappropriato?

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

Ifc Check & Revise Record - Cbd-Cuc-E01-El-001

Caricato da

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

CHECK & REVISE RECORD

Package No. P17 Discipline EL Reviewed by BEN

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- Missing all drawings for ELV system in

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

Note 8: If thermal and

Please make calculation sheet or

2. There are about 10 m high

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

4. According to structure design report,

According to SPC, The insulation

2. Please provide the System earthing

3. There is no capacitor bank for 11 kV

4. There are no calculation sheet of

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

This is one proposal to improve the

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

This is one proposal to improve the

2. Please provide the material of all the

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

3. There are no PURGE FAN ‘PUF-01’,

4. The Rated voltage of EXHAUST

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1. There are no single line diagrams for

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1. There are no single line diagrams for

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- Same as above.

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- Same as above

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- Same as above.

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. The location of the chiller is different

3. Please provide the specification and

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- Same as above.

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. Please provide the support

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

Potrebbero piacerti anche