Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
School of Engineering
and Mathematical
Sciences
Dissertation Guide
Please read this Guide in conjunction with the Programme Handbook and the
School Student Handbook.
Dissertation Guidelines at a Glance
You
You have
have passed
passed the
the DON’T KNOW The programme administrator will
NO
You cannot start your project until you taught modules
taught modules contact you, but if you are
have completed and passed - 6 core reasonably sure of meeting the
and 3 elective modules. YES preconditions (section 4) start
Find looking for a project now.
Find aa project
project (Section
(Section 3)
3)
Sort
Sort out: what , where,
out: what , where, who,
who, when
when (section
(section 4)
4)
Submit
Submit Project
Project Proposal
Proposal (section
(section 6)
6)
YES
NO Your
Your Project
Project Proposal
Proposal isis approved
approved DON’T KNOW
Act on the feedback Email the programme office after 2
weeks of submitting your project
proposal
You
You understand
understand roles
roles and
and
responsibilities
responsibilities (section
(section 7)
7)
YES
(Refer
(Refer to
to section
section 77 for
for how
how to
to manage
manage your
your project,
project, section
section 88 for
for how
how to
to
organise
organise your
your dissertation,
dissertation, and
and section
section 99 for
for submission
submission format.)
format.)
SUBMIT
SUBMIT your your dissertation
dissertation for
for examination.
examination.
You
You are
are asked
asked to
to defend
defend you
you work
work byby oral
oral
Your
Your dissertation
dissertation has
has passed
passed subject
subject to
to presentation
NO YES presentation and
and interview
interview (see
(see section
section 10)
10)
consideration by Board of Examiners
consideration by Board of Examiners
Refer to sections 5.4 and 5.5 NO YES
1
Presenting your Dissertation Checklist
The following information should be on the front cover (in gold) On the spine (also in gold) should be:
2
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
1. Introduction
The dissertation is a major part of your MSc (it is worth 50 credits out of the overall
180 credits). A well-written project1 (dissertation) can be a career milestone and an
excellent indicator of the type and quality of work, of which you are capable. It is
your opportunity to investigate a substantial problem and demonstrate you ability to
tackle an independent piece of work.
The purpose of this guide is to help you complete your project successfully. It gives
you information about finding a suitable project, carrying out you project and writing
up your project into a dissertation, so that it can be presented for internal and
external examination. The guide also describes the roles and responsibilities of
both students and supervisors and pitfalls to avoid.
What is a suitable topic for an MSc project? Each project is different and we want
to give you maximum flexibility to tackle a project that fits with your interest and
career plans.
The starting point (and foundation) can come from the topics covered in the taught
modules, but the investigation for your dissertation needs to go well beyond this.
Typically, the MSc topic is a problem/issue, which is common across the maritime
industries or specialist industries servicing maritime operations and management.
It could be:
1
In this guide the terms ’project’ and ‘dissertation’ are interchangeable. Essentially what you are doing is a
project but at Masters Level the written output of the project is called a dissertation.
3
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
The initial energy and drive must come from you, but this is not something you can
do on your own. It is important that you are proactive in working with your
supervisor.
Your topic should enable your to demonstrate critical awareness of complex,
incomplete or contradictory areas of knowledge. Your supervisor will help you
discard inappropriate ideas, and advise you on the feasibility of your project before
you start.
The project approval process (see section 4) is a safeguard. It will prevent your
from embarking on an inappropriate project.
3. Finding a Project
4
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
kind of project, but more offer you need to take the initiative, make your case,
and present your ideas.
4. You might opt for a library/internet based research project where you undertake
a significant review, critical analysis, and/or survey. In this case, your work
must incorporate an applied dimension either as case studies or as scenario
applications. It is your responsibility to find a supervisor with expertise in the
topic either from City University or an external tutor or expert.
Consider your personal interest and career objectives in the earliest stages of
thinking about your project. As soon as you can write a half page summary of
preliminary ideas or enthusiasms, these however tentative, will be useful for
identifying project areas, possible organisations and suitable project supervisors.
This is what must happen before you start your project. If you ignore any of the
preconditions, there is a risk that your dissertation will be disqualified, or fail.
Before you can start your project, you must achieve an overall MSc Level in the
taught part of the programme. Whether you were registered initially for the
Diploma or for the MSc course, the programme administrator will contact you when
you have completed 6 core and 3 elective modules and achieved an overall MSc
level pass in this taught part of the programme. At this stage, (and only at this
stage), if you wish to complete the qualification for the Masters Award, you must
undertake an approved project.
You will know when you are nearly at this milestone and can start preparing to
submit your project proposal form.
Projects can come together in various ways but essentially, you cannot proceed
until all of the following are resolved: what you will investigate; where your project
will be based; who will supervise; and when you will submit your project for
examination.
The onus is on you to resolve the logistics and the details and signal that you are
ready to start you project by submitting a project proposal. You will find a project
proposal form in Appendix I, and guidelines for preparing your proposal in section
6.
The programme administrator will notify you when your proposal is approved, or if
your proposal is not approved you will be given feedback. (See section 6)
5. Academic Requirements
Senior managers need to apply their expertise to the analysis of complex situations
and to report their views and opinions in a clear and concise manner. In your
dissertation, you are expected to describe, analyse and report upon a technical,
economic, or management situation or a combination of such situations and to
develop appropriate conclusions.
You will need to score 50% to pass your dissertation. Your dissertation should
demonstrate that you have undertaken a combination of the learning outcomes in
table 1.
5
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
5.3. Assessment
Two internal examiners will examine your dissertation, (the 1st marker will be your
supervisor). The external examiner sees all assessed dissertations.
The pass mark is
Purpose of Oral Presentation / 50%. If your
Interview
dissertation meets the
to ensure plagiarism has not taken required standard, you
place
in cases where marks fall on the
borderline between grades
6
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
maybe asked to give an oral presentation, which will be examined by two or more
examiners.
You dissertation and oral presentation should demonstrate the learning outcomes
for this part of the course (section 5.1).
Table 2 shows allocation of marks against assessment criteria. Performance will
be differentiated against each of the criteria listed.
If absence, illness or other problems outside of your control, affect your work, and
are likely to prevent or hinder you in meeting your completion deadline, please
write to the programme administrator immediately. This is your responsibility and
under no circumstance wait until the deadline is past.
Students unable to complete their dissertations within the allotted course period (1
year), may be granted, at the discretion of the Board of Examiners, an extension of
three months without charge.
Subsequent extensions, also at the discretion of the Board of Examiners, up to a
maximum of one year may be granted but a fee will be charged. Extensions
subsequent to this may be granted only in exceptional circumstances.
5.5. Referrals
A referral means that the dissertation scored below the 50% pass mark. The
dissertation will be returned to the student with feedback.
To indicate the scale of the problem the dissertation will be placed in one of three
categories:
7
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
The student will be invited to discuss the way forward but please be aware that a
dissertation that is referred can be resubmitted only once.
This document will be used to ensure (as far as possible) that your proposal is
relevant and possible. It is at this stage that some obvious pitfalls can be avoided.
For example in cases where the problem is too simplistic and undemanding, or too
large to be completed within the project timescale; you will be advised on how to
extend or restrict the scope of your project. At this stage, you will also be alerted if
the problem is outside the scope of relevance to the degree, or the project scope is
valid but access to necessary data/information will be too restrictive.
The main task of the supervisor will be to advice you on the validity of the proposed
scope of the investigation - the aims and objectives, and the appropriateness of the
methodologies employed to achieve these aims. You must therefore maintain
contact with your supervisor on a regular basis and keep him/her informed about
every aspect of the research from planning to presentation of the dissertation. If
you fail to keep in touch or fail to heed your supervisor’s advice, then you could
place the outcome of your studies at risk.
Your supervisor is your main guide and mentor, but you are expected to show
initiative and independence, the dissertation is after all your own work. Your
supervisor is required to write a report to the examiners. In this report s/he will
indicate the amount of assistance given.
Please refer to section 5.2 for information on timescale and planning. In general
your contact with your supervisor will take the form of tutorials, and written
feedback. The meetings can be face-to-face, by telephone or any appropriate
Internet conferencing or email facility.
8
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
A typical pattern is one meeting every two weeks (or equivalent part-time) in the
first half of the project, followed by two weekly cycles of feedback on dissertation.
Supervisors can offer a maximum of 12 tutorials and will read your final (complete)
dissertation once.
When a supervisor has contributed to the research it is customary to acknowledge
this, (and City University), in any publications that may follow.
If absence, illness or other problems outside your control affect your work, then it is
your responsibility to let your supervisor know. Remember, however, that your
supervisor cannot grant extensions to the deadline for submitting your dissertation.
This can only be done by submitting a written request (with supporting evidence),
to the Programme Administrator.
You many have met with your supervisor before preparing your project proposal
but your first project-working meeting will be after your project proposal has been
accepted.
The purpose of your first meetings with your supervisor is to discuss your ideas and
refine your research proposal in the light of their advice and the practical
constraints that you face. This means that you can adapt the research described in
your project proposal. Nevertheless, it is expected that you will stick broadly to the
aims, objectives and methods described in your proposal.
At this meeting, you will agree on a regular contact format. This might be a face-to-
face meetings or you might agree to sent a weekly progress report to which your
supervisor responds in writing. The contact might take the form of a telephone
conversation or a lunchtime chat. Whatever you decide your supervisor will keep a
record of progress and so should you.
7.2. Your Role and Responsibilities
9
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
10
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
8. The Dissertation
Every dissertation contains three elements – the introductory chapters that set the
scene and justify the investigation, the middle chapters that record the
Title Page
Declaration
Dedication (if any)
Acknowledgements
Abstract
Contents
(where appropriate include:
List of Tables
List of Figures
List of Appendices)
Symbols and abbreviations
(if appropriate)
Introduction
Literature Review
Methods
Results/Analysis/Discussion (subdivided as
appropriate)
Conclusions
Bibliography
Appendices
11
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
investigation, and the closing chapters that present, analyse and interpret the
findings.
In addition to this academic content, the dissertation also contains other sections
e.g. a signed statement indicating that the work is your own and that it is not being
submitted elsewhere for a degree.
Although the nature of the particular project will determine the actual structure of
the thesis and the number of chapters included, the pattern shown in the inset is a
typical example:
The actual titles and numbers of chapters will be determined by the area of
investigation. It is good ideas to rewrite the heading so they fit the investigation.
The list of content is an invaluable roadmap it should be a continuous progression
from the introduction to the conclusion so that the reader can follow the logic of the
project from browsing the structure of the content.
Methods In the methods section you should describe justify and explain the
methods of enquiry adopted. Indicate the parameters that you have imposed on
the study and the practical, engineering, scientific, or other reasons for this. You
should also explain how these parameters might restrict your ability to extrapolate
from the results.
In addition, you should outline the restrictions on the study that are beyond your
control. For example, limited time and resources may mean a restricted access to
data. Again, state the specific issues and the consequences for your research.
The methods and procedures should be presented in sufficient detail to enable the
reader to replicate the research process or follow the rationale of your investigation
strategy.
Remember that you may need to ensure confidentiality for participants in your
study including any references to them in the appendices, references to named
people and other sources.
At the end of the dissertation, you need to evaluate your investigation methods,
analysing where they worked well and where not. This is an important part of the
process.
Findings/Analysis The results section is about your findings. Here you are
describing the outcome of your investigation in a way that is accessible to your
reader, using tables, diagrams and graphical representation where appropriate.
The analysis section is your interpretation of the finding. Your supervisor may
advise you to combine your results and analysis if this makes your work easier to
read and present. When deciding which issues are important, remember to look for
any that you may have missed.
You should explain how significant your findings are for the general class of
problems, and specific problems and justify any generalisation where appropriate.
Be careful not to claim absolute truths or to over state the significance of your
findings.
The discussion section should discuss the implications of your results in relation to
your problem/research questions and demonstrate how your conclusions are
derived logically from your investigation.
A considered and reflective interpretation of the results should be offered here.
You could identify supporting literature, or other evidence for your interpretations.
In better dissertations, an analysis is presented of studies or evidence that tend to
conflict with the interpretations, with some discussion of the reasons which may
account for the apparent conflict.
The purpose of this section of the Dissertation is to relate your work to other
research and innovative practice in the Maritime industries.
Conclusions In the last section of your thesis you should re-examine your initial
aims and objectives. To do this you should relate your findings and conclusions to
your initial aims and objectives. Include suggestions for how your investigation
could have been improved. You should point out how the findings may be limited
by problems that were encountered.
Critically evaluate your work and indicate the extent to which your conclusions may
be considered valid and reliable, briefly summarise the lessons from the research,
and discuss the implications for further research and change in industrial practice.
Your task is straightforward; you must pre-empt significant criticisms of your study.
You have to convince the reader that you are an mature professional who can
13
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
investigate a real problem and can make sound balanced judgement, based on
evidence and argument.
Bibliography In your Bibliography you must take care to acknowledge all papers
and books cited or used in the preparation of your dissertation. (Do not cite any
papers that you have not read and understood). You must double check the final
copy to ensure that they are accurate.
Avoiding Plagiarism
There is a standard form used in all
journals for listing these and you can Learn how to cite in text
finding tutorials on how to reference at: Use quotation marks for verbatim quotes
and reference correctly
Teat unpublished sources as if they are
published
Cite lectures as Blogs (personal
communication) date
Make sure any collaboration is authorised
by your supervisor
Acknowledge external help
http://www.city.ac.uk/library/research_support/citation.html
In the Acknowledgements section you should acknowledge any help provided
by your Dissertation supervisor, colleagues, participants in your study and other
appropriate people.
8.2. Plagiarism
Your dissertation is marked on the assumption that it is your own work. This means
the words, diagrams, figures, tables, ideas and arguments should all be your own.
However much of the work will be based on that you have read and heard and it is
important to show and knowledge that your work is indebted to other sources.
Heavy use of particular sources, obtaining help and reliance on others is possible
without plagiarism. Plagiarism can be completely avoided by reworking material
and acknowledging sources.
Please read the sections on plagiarism in the Programme Handbook. You could be
asked to submit your project in electronic format and this will be processed by
plagiarism software and scanned for instances of plagiarism.
14
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
Once the intellectual work of your dissertation is complete, it is time to get the
format right so that your work conforms to the requirements in table 3.
1. General Presentation
i. A4 paper must be used, one side only.
ii. all type should be in black, size 12 ariel
iii. use double line spacing or one and a half (1.5) line spacing.
iv. indented quotations should be single line spaced.
v. the left hand margin should not be less than 3.8cm.
vi. the right hand margin should not be less than 2cm.
vii. all tables should be numbered sequentially and be given a suitable heading.
viii. all drawings, graphs and charts should be given a figure number, together with
a suitable heading.
2. Specific Layout
i. on opening the dissertation, the first page should contain the title, your name,
the name of your supervisor, your sponsoring company (if any), the name of the
University, and date
ii. the second page is the declaration page (see example).
iii. next should be the abstract, followed by acknowledgements, a contents page, a
list of appendices together with lists of tables and figures.
3. Page one is the first page of chapter one. All pages before should be numbered with
small Roman numerals, e.g. (i), (ii), (iii), (iv).
When you are satisfied your dissertation is ready to be examined, have the
dissertation bound.
An original and two copies should be prepared: the original and one copy to be
submitted to the Programme Office and one (or more) copy/copies to be retained
by you. The original and copy submitted to the Department must be in a City
University thesis binder, available in 2 sizes: up to 99 pages and 100+ pages.
When you collect your dissertation from the bindery it is just as well to check that all
spellings and dates on the covers are correct, that the correct details are printed on
the spine and that all the pages are present and in the correct sequence in all
copies.
Remember that your Supervisor and Programme Director must approve your final
dissertation title. Both you and your Supervisor must sign both copies of the
dissertation in the spaces provided for that purpose.
Finally, hand in to the MSc Programme Office.
You will be notified of the result by the University please do not ask your supervisor
or any other member of staff or examiner to comment before you are officially
contacted. If your dissertation meets the required standard (subject to
15
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
consideration by the Exam Board) you will be invited to give an oral presentation
(see section 10)
A note of warning. If you owe course fees, library fines or residence fees to the
University, then the Department will not send your dissertation to an external
examiner until the outstanding fees are paid.
Once you have submitted your dissertation there will be a period of waiting while
your work is marked. If your dissertation meets the required standard, you will be
invited to give an oral presentation, which will be examined by two or more
examiners (see section 5.3).
From time to time the school and the Programme will run networking events in
which you maybe asked to present your work to current and prospective students
and
people
Presentation Information in brief from
Expect a maximum of 10 people in the Industry.
audience You will
Come with copies of the abstract to normally
handout to your audience be asked
Use visual aid e.g. data projector, or OHPs
to make
(email the programme administrator if
you want t a practice session) a
Plan to talk for 15 minutes
Expect to answer questions for 10 minutes
16
MSc in Maritime Operations and Management: Dissertation Guide
Prepare your presentation and practice your delivery as if you are applying for a
job, and be sure to include acknowledgments.
Once you have completed the Programme and graduated you might like to
consider publishing your work online or as a article for a professional or academic
publication.
17
Appendix I
School of Engineering and
Mathematical Sciences
1. Your details:
Name(s)
Have you been notified that you have achieved an overall pass in the taught part of the programme? Yes/No
Name(s)
Organisation/Affiliation
5. Project Proposal
Please attach a statement on 2 sides of A4. You should describe the problem you intend to investigate and
explain why it is a problem. Define your aims and objectives as far as possible at this stage. Please include: (1)
a content list to show how your dissertation will be organised and what will be include under each section , (2)
an outline your plan of action with milestones. Please also say what you think are the main risks and barriers to
success completion of your goals.
6. Confirmation of information
Name__________________________________________________
Signature_______________________________________________ Date________________
7. Proposal Approved
Signature___________________________________________ Date________________
Comments
18