Sei sulla pagina 1di 5

ISSN 1087-6596, Glass Physics and Chemistry, 2019, Vol. 45, No. 5, pp. 360–364. © Pleiades Publishing, Ltd.

, 2019.
Russian Text © The Author(s), 2019, published in Fizika i Khimiya Stekla.

Optimization of the Sample Preparation Technique


for the Gas-Chromatography Determining of Micro-Concentrated
2-Chlorovinyl Dichloroarsine Vapor in Air
E. A. Spetsova, * and L. A. Nefedovab
aSPS
Eurochim Ltd., St. Petersburg, 195267 Russia
b
JSC SZRC Concern VKO Almaz-Antey, St. Petersburg, 192012 Russia
*e-mail: evgenii.spetsov@gmail.com
Received February 14, 2019; revised May 27, 2019; accepted June 6, 2019

Abstract—In this work, a new method for preparing samples with 2-chlorovinyl dichlorosine is optimized: its
main difference from the prototype consists in the application of the combined adsorption–extraction pro-
cess instead of the method of absorption by bubbling. The optimization includes the selection of an adsorbent
and the sampling conditions (concentration of the analyzed substance vapors, composition of the eluent, and
rate of the vapor-air flow). The positive effect of the low specific surface of the adsorbent on the degree of the
extraction of the adsorbate is established. The optimal volume ratio of ethanol and hydrochloric acid is pro-
posed, which allows us to almost completely extract the reagent.

Keywords: 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine, sorption, gas chromatography, extraction


DOI: 10.1134/S1087659619050134

INTRODUCTION in the air, it is necessary to increase the sampling time


In accordance with the Convention on the Prohibi- (absorption of the substance from the analyzed gas–
tion of Chemical Weapons, in particular, 2-chlorovi- vapor mixture (GVM) into the absorption solution) or
nyl dichloroarsine (CVDCA) [1], the methods of ana- the volumetric rate of GVM upon bubbling, which
lytical chemistry aimed at accurately determining the increases the loss of the absorbent due to the drop car-
microconcentrations of this substance in the air of the ryover and, as a result, the total measurement error.
working zones of destruction facilities for toxic sub- The adsorption of CVDCA with its subsequent liq-
stances are being actively developed. uid extraction (elution) from the adsorbent layer rep-
Mobile gas detectors, for example, those of the resents a promising alternative method of sample
GSA-01F, GSA-KR, GSA/AIG, and SIP-1 grades are preparation prior to the gas chromatography analysis.
used on the territory of such facilities and in field con- Mathematical calculation demonstrated that this
ditions: strict demands are placed on their reliability in technique was promising due to the significant reduc-
the course of continuous operation in an environment tion of the sampling time to 0.10–0.15 h with the GVM
with low concentrations of vapors of potent poisons. volume flow rate of 360 to 600 dm3/h compared to the
Such devices are subject to periodic calibration using absorption method (at least 0.5 h at the maximum
the validated methods of quantitative analysis. The reli- possible flow rate of 60 dm3/h), while providing the
ability of the analysis for most of the substances nor- almost complete capture of CVDCA in an ergonomic
mally decreases near the lower concentration limit of absorption tube. The tasks of the study are to compare
detection, so that the measurement error increases. For the adsorption and desorption capacity of the main
CVDCA vapors in air, this limit is 2 × 10–4 mg/m3 [2]. types of industrial adsorbents; to select a high-perfor-
The same concentration value corresponds to the max- mance eluent for 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine; and to
imum permissible concentration for the working zone, determine the gas-dynamic conditions to ensure the
which is considered as the norm only when remaining optimal criteria for the maximum sampling rate and
in the contaminated atmosphere for a short period. compactness of the applied adsorption tube.
However, the procedures used to neutralize this poison
must be carried out around the clock. The objective of
the present study was dictated by the insufficient sensi- METHODS OF STUDY
tivity of the applied gas chromatography analysis, for The absorption capacity of the industrial adsor-
which this concentration of CVDCA represented the bents was investigated at temperature (28 ± 1)°С in a
lower detection limit. With a lower content of CVDCA gas-dynamic installation (GDI) made of glass (Pyrex)

360
OPTIMIZATION OF THE SAMPLE PREPARATION TECHNIQUE 361

and mounted in a thermostated box. The CVDCA was (Russian state standard no. 12083-78), cuvettes with a
dosed from a removable capillary cell by blowing it working length of 30 mm). The concentration of
with nitrogen at a volume flow rate of 18 dm3/h. There- CVDCA corresponding to the measured intensity in
after, the stream of nitrogen contaminated by 2-chlor- the sample and in air was determined according to the
ovinyl dichloroarsine was mixed with dry (dew point – preset calibration characteristic.
60°C) and moist airflows with volume flow rates of 162 The adsorbent loading weight was measured via the
and 180 dm3/h, respectively. The relative humidity of gravimetric method using a Shinko AF-R220CE lab-
the GVM was maintained at a level of (50 ± 5)% under oratory electronic balance (Japan) (accuracy class I
constant recording by a VIT-2 automatic psychromet- (spec.) with a measurement error of 10–4 g).
ric hygrometer (Russia).
When developing the conditions for the adsorption
of 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine on the experimental EXPERIMENTAL
sorbent samples, their weights were selected empiri- RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
cally so that the CVDCA breakthrough concentrations
behind the adsorbent layer were absent, which, in In order to compare the sorption properties, the
turn, was determined by the gas chromatography anal- following commercial adsorbents were selected: BAU-
ysis of the absorbing solution from the bubbler A and OU-A active carbons (Russia), ASK silica gel
installed after the mixture. (Russia), AOK-63-21 aluminum oxide for chroma-
tography (Russia), alkoxylated glass fiber (United
Sampling at the GDI outlet was carried out simulta- States), and a fine-fraction Tenax sorbent, linear poly-
neously through the absorbent using a Richter absorber n-2.6-diphenylphenylene oxide (United States) [4, 5].
(by bubbling through 10 cm3 of 0.1 N aqueous HCl Their main physical and textural characteristics are
solution); through the adsorbent poured into the glass provided in Table. 1.
tube with an internal diameter of 8 mm and using an At the first stage, the GVM was passed through the
aspirator (Technical Conditions (TU) no. 64-1-862- adsorbents and bubblers with the absorbent (0.1 N
82) with rotameters of the inhalation anesthesia appa- aqueous solution of HCl) indicated in Table 1, and the
ratus (Technical Conditions (TUs) no. 64-1-0801-256- resulting samples of the absorption solutions and
80) with the GVM volume flow in each line of 60 dm3/h extracts were analyzed for the content of CVDCA.
for 0.5 h. Technical rectified ethanol (Russian state standard
The GVM for the content of CVDCA, both no. 18300-87) and a 0.1 N aqueous solution of hydro-
selected in the absorption solution and extracted from chloric acid of 5.5 cm3 each were used as eluents for
the adsorbents, was analyzed using an Agilent 7890B sequential extraction. The experimental results are
gas chromatograph (United States) with a flame ion- provided in Table 2.
ization detector. The column filler (grade HP-5: Based on the data of Table 2, the highest degree of
length 30 m, diameter 0.32 mm), Tenax sorbent extraction of the sorbate was attained upon the elution
(USA); thermostat heating rate ranged from 40 to of CVDCA from sorbents such as Tenax, fiberglass,
170°С, 25°С/min; carrier gas rate (nitrogen), and BAU-A. In the course of the experiments, it
7.1 cm3/min; temperature of the detector, 160°С, that appeared that the mentioned active carbon (due to its
of the evaporator, 100°С (in Splitless mode at a flow low resistance to abrasion) and aluminum oxide (due
rate of 40 cm3/min for 2 min); gas flow rates: air, to the high degree of grinding during elution) were
300 cm3/min; H2, 30 cm3/min; N2 (blowing), partially transferred to the extract as a suspension. The
25 cm3/min. The retention time of acetylene (the actual concentration of 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine
product of the chemical reaction of CVDCA with in the extract could be underestimated, since the fine
sodium hydroxide) was (2.90 ± 0.05) min. Acetylene particles of the adsorbent, which were also inside it,
vapor was sampled (in a volume of 1 cm3) by a syringe were able to concentrate the analyzed component.
at a distance of 1 cm from the gas–liquid interface in the As a result of the experiments, it was established
closed tube immediately after elution of the sorbent. that only the fiberglass and the Tenax sorbent could be
A photocolorimetric method of analysis was considered as suitable materials for further research.
applied to calibrate the gas chromatograph. It con- The extraction capacity of the previously used eluents
sisted in the registration of changes in the color of the (11 cm3) was estimated for these materials; see Table 3.
indicator solution upon its contact with the CVDCA As seen from Table 3, a higher degree of CVDCA
decomposition product—acetylene [3]. To find the extraction was attained on the Tenax sorbent. How-
value of the change in the intensity of the monochro- ever, the additional experiments revealed some diffi-
matic light (wavelength 400 nm) passing through the culties associated with an increase of the hydraulic
indicator solution with the 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsin resistance of the layer of the fine-fraction batch mix-
sample relative to the reference solution not containing ture of the sorbent to the GVM flow upon the increase
the latter, a KFK-2 photoelectric photometer (Russia) of the volume flow rate of the latter. Because of the
was used (optical density measurement error ± 1% higher cost of this sorbent, the preference was given to

GLASS PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY Vol. 45 No. 5 2019


362 SPETSOV, NEFEDOVA

Table 1. Properties of the commercial adsorbents


Dimensions Shape Specific surface area Volume of pores
Grade
of granules, mm of granules/material of pores by BET, m2 g–1 by H2O, cm3 g–1
Tenax 0.18–0.25 Round-shaped, oval-shaped 18.6 ± 0.5 0.67
ASK 0.25–0.50 Sand 260 ± 10 1. 0
Fiberglass – Thread-like fiber 40 ± 2 –
AOK-63-21 0.10–0.16 Powder 60 ± 3 0.3
BAU-A 1.0–4.0 Irregular-shaped 750 ± 50 1.6
OU-A 1.0–2.0 '' >1200 2.0

Table 2. Comparison of desorption capacity of the commercial adsorbents in the extraction of 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine
from them sequentially by ethanol and HCl solution
Initial concentration of CDVCA Concentration of CDVCA Degree of extraction of CVDCA
Grade
10 4 mg m–3 after extraction 10 4 mg m–3 from the sorbent, %
Tenax 2.86 2.76 96.8
Fiberglass 2.30 1.65 71.8
ASK 3.01 1.87 62.1
BAU-A 2.71 2.11 78.1
OU-A 3.01 1.43 47.6
AOK-63-21 3.34 1.55 46.4

Table 3. Comparison of desorption capacity of ethanol and hydrochloric acid solution upon single-stage extraction of
2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine from the commercial adsorbents
Initial concentration Concentration of CDVCA Degree of extraction of CVDCA
Grade Eluent
of CDVCA 104 mg m–3 in the extract 104 mg m–3 from the sorbent, %
Tenax Ethanol 2.99 2.83 94.6
0.1 N of HCl (aq.) 4.31 1.60 37.2
Fiberglass Ethanol 5.41 1.76 32.5
0.1 N of HCl (aq.) 2.88 2.03 70.5

the glass fiber, which was used to further optimize the This enabled us to suggest that, upon sampling air with
sampling conditions. It was suggested that the maxi- target concentrations of CVDCA below 2 × 10–4 mg/m3,
mum degree of the CVDCA extraction from this sor- it will be possible to achieve the almost complete
bent (70.5% on extraction by diluted hydrochloric desorption of this sorbent.
acid) could be increased by selecting the optimal elu- The desorption capacity of CVDCA from the fiber-
ent and its composition. glass was investigated at variable linear rates of the
Upon elution from the glass fiber, sequential GVM and in two extraction modes: single-stage, by a
extraction was applied by dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO); 2.0 N ethanol solution in a 0.1 N HCl solution of the
and thereafter, with the solution of 0.1 N HCl, as well as total volume of 11 cm3, and two-stage, sequentially
one-stage extraction by a mixture of aqueous solutions with the same solutions of ethanol and HCl, of 5.5 cm3
of ethanol (5.5 cm3) and 0.1 N of HCl (5.5 cm3) at var- each. Each sample was prepared according to the
ious concentrations of alcohol. The results are provided scheme shown in Fig. 1 for 0.5 hours. The results are
in Table 4. shown in Table 5.
DMSO was characterized with a pronounced The data from Table 5 indicate that application of
extracting ability relative to the combined alcohol– the single-stage extraction of CVDCA from the glass
acid eluent. Note that it was possible to achieve its fiber by an aqueous acid–alcohol solution was slightly
almost complete extraction due to the application of more efficient than the two-stage extraction, i.e., at
the latter with the ethanol concentration of 2.0 N at the sequential application of the components—solu-
the initial content of CVDCA in the GVM of 4.37 × tions of ethanol and HCl. It was possible to almost
10–4 mg/m3. Apparently, with the CVDCA concentra- completely extract the adsorbed CVDCA even at the
tion increase in the GVM, its extraction from the glass linear flow rate of the GVM of about 13 cm/s (the vol-
fiber required increasing the volume of the eluent. ume flow rate of 368 dm3/h). This allowed reducing

GLASS PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY Vol. 45 No. 5 2019


OPTIMIZATION OF THE SAMPLE PREPARATION TECHNIQUE 363

Air 3

GVM 2

Nitrogen
1

4
4

Fig. 1. Scheme of the samples preparation from the GVM flow. (1) GDI; (2) sampling tube with the sorbent; (3) aspirator;
(4) Richter absorbers (bubblers).

the sampling time with the minimum amount of external surface area (glass fiber). The high sorption
CVDCA necessary for the GC-analysis from 30 (with capacity of silicon oxide, which was a component of
the absorption sampling method) to 5 minutes. the glass fiber, was of particular interest, because the
Apparently, CVDCA vapors can be completely other materials based on it could be of greater interest
absorbed not only by porous adsorbents (for example, than the glass fiber itself. The absence of pores, espe-
Tenax) but also by materials with high values of the cially fine ones, in a sorbent can contribute to its abil-

Table 4. Efficiency of the combined eluents in extraction of 2-chlorovinyldichlorosin from fiberglass


Initial concentration Eluent Concentration of CVDCA Degree of extraction of CVDCA
of CVDCA 10 4, mg m–3 (volume 11 cm3) in the extract 10 4 mg m–3 from the sorbent, %
3.01 DMSO, then 0.1 N of HCl (aq.) 2.17 72.1
5.71 3.0 N ethanol + 0.1 N of HCl (aq.) 4.74 83.0
4.37 2.0 N ethanol + 0.1 N of HCl (aq.) 4.37 100.0
5.41 5.08 93.9
5.64 4.64 82.3
6.56 4.84 73.7
6.61 4.11 62.1

Table 5. Change in the desorption capacity of the fiberglass with varying linear flow rate of the GVM and depending on the
extraction mode
Adsorbent layer parameters Volumetric flow rate, Concentration of Degree of extraction
Initial concentration 3 h–1/Linear rate,
dm CVDCA in the extract of CVDCA from the
of CVDCA 104,
weight, g diameter, mm cm s–1 of GVM through after one-/two-stage sorbent, % after one-/
mg m–3
the layer of adsorbent extraction 104 mg m–3 two-stage extraction
0.797 8.0 4.37 56.2/3.11 4.37/– 100.0/–
0.724 4.67 137.4/7.60 4.67/– 100.0/–
0.758 2.30 56.2/3.11 –/1.65 –/71.8
0.736 2.54 137.4/7.60 –/1.80 –/70.9
1.048 10.0 4.68 368.6/13.04 4.65/– 99.4/–
0.842 1.47 365.8/12.94 1.47/– 100.0/–
0.951 1.63 365.8/12.94 –/1.59 –/97.6
0.941 1.51 365.8/12.94 –/1.48 –/98.0

GLASS PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY Vol. 45 No. 5 2019


364 SPETSOV, NEFEDOVA

Table 6. Desorption ability of quartz sand on 2-chlorovinyl tion of chemical weapons and test sites, as well as for
dichloroarsine. Weight of the sorbent, 3.0 g; diameter, 10.0 mm; the calibration of measuring and alarming devices. An
linear rate of GVM, 13.0 cm/s; sampling time, 0.083 h important advantage of the new method lies in the
Initial The degree possibility of carrying out remote work on sampling in
Concentration an absorption tube with a solid sorbent while remain-
concentration of extraction of
of CVDCA in the ing in the contaminated atmosphere for a short period.
of CVDCA 104 CVDCA from the
extract 104 mg m–3 It has been methodologically and economically advised
mg m–3 sorbent, %
to use fiberglass or silica sand characterized with an
Single-stage extraction undeveloped texture for the sorption of 2-chlorovinyl
2.11 2.11 100.0 dichloroarsine vapor from (1.5–2.1) × 10–4 with up to
1.47 1.47 100.0 100% efficiency to ensure sample preparation for its
Two-stage extraction
quantitative analysis. These sorbents have allowed
sampling 2-chlorovinyl dichloroarsine vapor at a rate
1.63 1.47 90.2
of the analyzed airflow that is 6 times faster than the
1.51 1.36 90.1 existing method, which has reduced the operation
time from 30 to 5 minutes. The effective eluent that
allowed the complete extraction of the sorbed 2-chlor-
ity to regenerate, i.e., to improve the efficiency of the
ovinyl dichloroarsine from the surface of the investi-
adsorbate extraction process. Quartz is a low-cost
gated sorbents was made up of a mixture of aqueous
sorption material that is potentially effective with rela-
solutions of ethanol and hydrochloric acid in concen-
tion to polar molecules forming the vapor phase [6, 7]
trations of 2.0 and 0.1 N, respectively, with their vol-
and allows broad variations of its particles shapes and
ume ratio of 1 : 1.
sizes for actual hydrodynamic conditions.
The experiments were carried out on the
extraction of CVDCA from quartz sand (particle size REFERENCES
0.25–0.50 mm, specific surface area ((1.0 ± 0.5) m2) 1. Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Pro-
using the above-described two-stage extraction duction, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and
method (2.0 N aqueous solutions of technical ethanol, on Their Destruction, Treaty Series, Geneve, Switzer-
followed by 0.1 N of HCl) and the single-stage land: United Nations, 1992, vol. 1975, p. 45.
extraction (their mixture in equal volumes) under 2. Resolution of the Chief State Sanitary Doctor of the
constant hydrodynamic parameters. The results are Russian Federation of April 26, 2010 No. 31 “On ap-
provided in Table 6. proval of GN 2.2.5.2610-10, The maximum permissible
concentration (MPC) of poisonous substances of the
In the single-stage extraction (Table 6), the effi- skin-blister action in the air of the working zone. Hy-
ciency of the application of quartz sand for the gienic regulations, Bull. Regulations Fed. Executive Bod-
extraction of CVDCA from it was almost 100%, which ies, Moscow: Rospotrebnadzor, 2010, no. 23.
was in accordance with the efficiency of the glass fiber. 3. Demakhin, A.G., Eliseev, D.A., and Kuznetsov, N.N.,
In the two-stage elution method, this value was sig- Physico-chemical basis of the process of recovery of de-
nificantly lower—by approximately 90%, which was toxification products of lewisite into marketable prod-
probably due to the lower extraction capacity of the ucts, Zh. VKhO im. D.I. Mendeleeva, 2010, vol. 44,
hydrochloric acid solution compared to ethanol. no. 4, pp. 122–125.
The suggested method of sample preparation, the 4. Novikov, S.V., Tiunov, A.I., Goncharov, V.M., and
process of CVDCA elution, and the introduction of Egorov, I.V., Kolichestvennyi analiz otravlyayushchikh
the extrudate into the chromatograph evaporator veshchestv v ob’ektakh okruzhayushchei sredy (Quantita-
tive Analysis of Toxic Substances in the Environment),
implied application of the volumetric measuring Moscow: VARKhBZ, 2006.
devices—pipette (10 mL) and syringe dispenser (1 mL),
5. Novikov, S.V. and Egorov, I.V., Evaluation of the ther-
whose relative measurement errors were 0.5 and 1.0%, modynamic characteristics of the adsorption of organo-
respectively. The relative error of the chromatography phosphorus compounds by the tenax sorbent, Med-
method of measurement did not exceed 10%. line.ru, 2006, vol. 7, pp. 221–227.
6. Zhdanov, S.P., Water adsorption on quartz crushed un-
CONCLUSIONS der vacuum, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1957, vol. 115,
no. 5, pp. 938–941.
The investigated method of the sample prepara- 7. Aikhler, B., Domanov, V.P., and Zvara, I., Determina-
tion, including the process of adsorption of 2-chlor- tion of heat of adsorption based on thermochromato-
ovinyl dichloroarsine and its extraction into the bulk of graphic data. 1. Chlorides of metals. Quartz adsorption,
the eluent, can be applied as part of the existing gas JINR Preprint no. P12-9454, Dubna: JINR, 1976.
chromatography method for the quantitative analysis
of air in the working areas of facilities for the destruc- Translated by D. Marinin

GLASS PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY Vol. 45 No. 5 2019

Potrebbero piacerti anche