Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract. Business ethics becomes an important creative factor in everyday business life. Interest of the
enterprises on business ethics has fallen down at the recession, but it still remain as an integrated suite of
options, demonstrating how to create and achieve value for a long perspective. Though there are many re-
searches provided and books published on business ethics but the problems are not resolved finally. There
is no unambiguous definition as well as single range of segregated elements of business ethics. There are
only few attempts to construct model of business ethics and its influence for enterprise competitiveness
and very few attempts on modelling the business ethics by segregated elements as well as competitiveness
of enterprises by indicators. Thus in the article there is the attempt to compose the model of influence of
segregated elements of business ethics on competitiveness indicators. Research provided by the author in
2008-2009 in Lithuania discovered the main elements of organizational ethics that influence the main in-
dexes of organizational performance (in article presented in form of model). Research showed that the
purposive appliance of business ethics can contribute to competitive advantage of organization. The study
also showed that the quite many employees are faced with ethical problems in working environment.
Thus, each organization should create and follow its own ethics rules, constitutions or codes, discuss ethi-
cal issues that are legally and ethically addressed, to managers, colleagues and to the partners.
Key words: enterprise social responsibility, business ethics, elements of business ethics, model.
711
Č. Purlys
ently by different cultures religions in different Research problem, novelty and relevance. The
countries and regions of the planet and by philoso- article is addressed to business ethics and corporate
phers, economists, as well as different interest competitiveness provided as influence of segregated
groups, business owners and employees. When elements of business ethics to main competitiveness
Confucianism in South and East Asia relay mainly indexes of the enterprise. Data presented in the arti-
on the respect for elder, and Islam – on Koran req- cle are from the original study of the author on busi-
uisitions while Christianity – on 10 prescriptions of ness ethics in Lithuania accomplished in 2008-2009.
the God. The developed and developing European Financial data for analysis of the enterprises’ was
countries as well as both America’s Continent relay selected from the mass media and statistical sources.
on legislation because the main ethical require- The objective of research – to discover the influ-
ments are included into the laws. Differences in ence of the main elements of business ethics to main
culture and business ethics dictate the need for deep indexes of organizational competitiveness
knowledge of culture and business ethics of the Main tasks of research – to provide logical com-
countries. parative analysis of scientific literature, select im-
Many changes have been made in the world portant elements of business ethics and to construct
economy and business ethics in global market and the model of influence of business ethics on enter-
social issues over the past decades: international prise competitiveness.
competition has been intensified, the mass mergers Methodology of research – logic comparative
have spread, abrupt market downturn, and reces- analysis of scientific literature on business ethics,
sion have appeared. Organizations have lost the content analysis of publications in two Lithuanian
clarity on meeting the customer’s needs and expec- business magazines, analysis of researches of busi-
tations – they have to deal with new business prob- ness ethics at Lithuanian organizations, and the sur-
lems and create new competitive strategies. Busi- vey of experts at the enterprises by questionnaire.
ness, marketing and management ethics digresses The survey of 165 respondents covered experts of
to secondary problems. But it still remains as an different experience, qualifications, sex and duties
integrated suite of options, demonstrating how to of Lithuanian organizations. One hundred of them
create and achieve value for a long perspective. were correspondent students of Vilnius Gediminas
Though some problems of business ethics have Technical University.
been covered in scientific literature, but the re-
search of the problem still is far from maturity
2. Business ethics as a competitive force
stage. Just very few pilot researches have been
made in Lithuania on business ethics: mainly the The headwaters of business ethics as a factor of
research materials from the scientific books and efficiency and research subject relates to the corpo-
articles are used to demonstrate the problems. At rate social responsibility. Discussion on it began to
the recession, seeking for immediate profit organi- widespread in 80-ties of the last century after
zations have little interest in long-term future pros- Moskowich has published the article in the first
perity. But if the company tends to be successful in issue of Business and Society Review magazine
long run period it ought to have social responsible (Vance 1975) that the socially aware corporation
strategy i.e. know and use successfully the most possesses the special sensitivity that will enable it to
effective elements of social responsibility, organ- surpass competition. In second issue (fall 1972)
izational culture, business ethics, etc. Research after testing his hypothesis on research of 14 com-
provided by author discovers the main elements of panies with remarkable positive results and good
organizational ethics that influence the main ele- social responsibility credentials Moskowich corre-
ments of organizational performance, has presented lated corporate worth of those 14 corporations (as
as model in article. The investigation revealed that measured by stock market prices) with corporate
the business ethics compliance has a significant responsibility. According to investigation stocks of
impact on company performance. Correlation be- the companies were up 7.28 % in first six months
tween business ethics and competitive elements has („So far, so good“– concluded Business and Society
showed the dependence of business ethics and Review). Of course there has been an opposite
competetiveness indexes and how segregated ele- minds too. Stanley Vance (Stanislovas Ven-
ments of business ethics influence the competitive- slavičius – Lithuanian, by the way, 1975), president
ness of enterprises. The study also has showed that of American Management Academy in 1974 – ac-
the majority of the interviewees have been faced cented that research two years later of 50 major
with ethical problems in their work environment USA corporations, provided by the graduate stu-
and that the proper use of business ethics can help dents, discovered that with each increase by 1.00
to create competitive advantage of organization. point in the students rating of company social re-
712
INFLUENCE OF BUSINESS ETHICS FOR ENTERPRISE COMPETITIVENESS
sponsibility, the company stock market value can ity, low price, fast and professional service, and
be expected to decline by 18 %. maintained by business ethics, effective ethical
According to Koch (1998) 80/20 principle the marketing, and experts dealing ethically in different
great majority and firms 80 % of its profit gets from geographical areas and countries.
20 % of their clients. That‘s if enterprise want to Business ethics is a complex subject and its
out-execute its competitors it must communicate history is filled with distinct theories that are
clear strategies and values, reinforce all values in constantly opposed by competition theories. So
everything the company does, and allow people to that’s why the controversies in applying ethics to
act freely and with trust and the will to execute the specific practices of business are found. Ac-
consistent with the values (Gerstner 2002). cording to Hartley (2004) in theory there are
Business ethics problems has been investigated three different ways of deriving standards of
by Hoffman, Frederick (1995), Cava, West, Ber- business ethics: 1) attitude to business ethics
man (1998), Robbins (2003), Fifield (2007), Kuhn with regard to the profit motive; 2) business eth-
(1970), De George, (2009, 7’th ed.), Freeman ics constrained to following the legislation; 3)
(1992), Lennik, Kiel (2005), Fieser (2009), business ethics derived from general moral li-
Trevino, Nelson (2006), Nash (1993) and others. abilities. All of three ways are controversial too
Lithuanian authors: Razauskas (1994), Pali- and consist of strong and weak versions. Some
dauskaitė (2001), Beržinskas (2002), Misevičius theorists (Gerstner 2002; Trevino, Nelson 2006),
(2005), Paulavičiūtė (2004), Pruskus (2003), Vasil- and business people argue that there is symbolic
jevienė (2003), Vyšniauskienė, Kundrotas (1999) relation between ethics and business: ethics
and Zakarevičius (2002). arises from profit-oriented business. Weakness
Though there are many researches executed of that theory can be the opinion that good ethics
and books and articles published the problems of results in good business. According to that opin-
business ethics are not finally discovered. There is ion to be profitable means to make safe products,
no unambiguous definition as well as single range to respect employee privacy and to conduct good
of segregated elements of business ethics and there psychological climate. In the middle of the last
are only few attempts to construct model of busi- decade of 20-th century the discussion if busi-
ness ethics and its influence for enterprise competi- ness ethics ought to be on the range together
tiveness. The differences in definition of some au- with conditions and measures of success has
thors are provided in Table 1. flamed. And if it was not the case – it becomes a
Thus business ethics is a framework of re- trifling eclectic essay or empty preachy teaching.
quirements of society for morality norms in stake- And in opposite, as Nash (1993) stated, manag-
holders and employees behaviour, management ers have seen the high cost that corporate scan-
democracy at all management layers, communica- dals exacted: heavy fines, disruption of moral
tion fashion and social responsibility. routine, low employee moral, increased turnover,
Management theory states that success in internal fraud, and loss of confidence in the firm.
global markets is guaranteed by good product qual-
713
Č. Purlys
Fifteen years ago the „stakeholders theory“ has criminal penalties, tougher judges and more timely
flourished as an alternative way to understand the congressional action. It‘s all fits to Lithuania as
firm in sharp contrast to traditional models. Theory well.
states that „stakeholders“ plays a crucial role in en-
terprise activity and depicted managers in more sim- 3. Research technique and results
plistic terms (as dealing with employees, suppliers
and customers only). According to the theory the It is accepted that business ethics covers four
firm exists to make profits and serve the interests of main aspects: values, standards and norms, internal
one group, stakeholders only (Jones et al. 2002). environment, and external environment. Re-
According to Gardner et al. (2007), there is no searches of business ethics at Lithuanian organiza-
simple formula to identify work that is of excellent tions shows that business ethics become one of
quality, socially responsible and meaningful to the important factors in creating environment friendly
practitioners. More than 1200 Americans inter- for business. Researches provided by author (with
viewed in nine industry domains reviled that busi- assistance Bražiūnaitė and Luebcke) in 2004 and
ness ethics and corporate responsibility to be a pretty 2008-2009 shows that there are more problems
complicated challenge. with business ethics in public sector rather than in
As opposite of that, survey of large US corpora- private one. Research method used in authors re-
tions provided recently by ITHAKA (association of search was formalized content analysis of 159 arti-
1000 journals archives) (Weaver et al. 1999), cles and reports on business ethics published by
showed that 78 % of them had Codes of Ethics, magazines “ Verslo žinios“ („Business news“) and
51 % had telephone lines reporting ethical concerns, „Vadovo pasaulis“ (“The Manager’s World“) in
and 30 % had special offices created in different 2004. Main problems discovered were corruption
regions, two thirds of which were created in 1990s. and environment protection (Fig. 1).
American businesses are investing a lot in Ethic pro- As we can see the main problems discussed in
grammes, but it is not as match, as businesses need. magazines were corruption, environment protec-
According to Gilbert (1996), professor from Oxford tion, fraud, damping and lie. Research also discov-
University, business world is full of people behaving ered that often problems emerge only for protec-
unethically. They must be uncovered, and called to tion narrow private interests, but not for global
account for their shady deeds, we must get thought business environment improvement and business
with ethical violators and they must be stopped. ethics actualization problems. Research discovered
What we need are more codes of conduct, more that most non ethical cases were at public, not pri-
extensive investigative procedures, stiffer civil and vate sector. It is paradoxical as most researches on
business ethics were subject to public sector.
26
25
24
23
22
21
20
19
18
17
16
15
14
13
12 24.5
11
10
9
8 15.7
7
6
5
4 8.8
3 5.7
2 4.4 3.8 3.1
1
0
t
n
y
e
d
n g
ce
l it
Li
e n
io
a u
pi
p t
e n
ia
F r
n m
pi
ec
ru
am
or
ro
id
vi
om
D
of
C
E n
C
x
T a
Fig. 1. Main Business ethics problems discussed in magazines „Verslo žinios“ and „ Vadovo pasaulis“
714
INFLUENCE OF BUSINESS ETHICS FOR ENTERPRISE COMPETITIVENESS
Codes of ethics, rules instructions mostly also magazine “Verslo Žinios”. For the second – data
are prepared in public sector. Everybody can ar- has been collected from experts of the enterprises
gue – as stresses Nash – that most of all values – by questionnaire. Correlation between segregated
honesty, fairness, respect of others, service, prom- elements of business ethics and elements of com-
ise-keeping, prudence, and trustworthiness are a petitiveness has been conducted. In order to assess
important part of most managers education. How- correlation between those segregated elements two
ever it is an unfortunate fact that these common- indicators are used: the association and contin-
sense values, have frequently suffered meltdown gences.
in the marketplace. One of biggest problems dis- Association index was counted by using equa-
covered by our research is lack of preventive tion 1.
measures and articles published on subject of best ad − bc
practice against unethical behaviour. Publications K association = ; (1)
ad + bc
were mostly based on investigation of journalists.
Though during the last five year period a research In cases when some indicator in the Table 2 is
in Lithuanian private sector on business ethics has absent, the association rate index has been used as
flourished, this attempt was hidden by recession. 1, than preference was given to contingence coef-
The study on business ethics that affect the organi- ficient. Contingence coefficient is calculated by
zation competitiveness in Lithuania two researches equation 2:
accomplished by the author in 2008-2009 (inter- ad − bc
viewed 165 respondents) has discovered the main K contingence = (2)
elements of organizational ethics influencing the
(a + b )(b + d )(a + c )(c + d )
main elements of organizational performance. To For further research 10 most important ele-
do that segregated indexes of competitiveness and ments of business ethics, from 15 has been se-
segregated elements of business ethics has been set lected. Thus dependence between business ethics
to estimate correlations between the segregated elements and competitiveness indexes according to
elements mentioned above. For the first research contingence indexes for investigated Lithuanian
data on activity of enterprises 2005-2008 has been enterprises calculated as shown in the Table 2.
collected from reports of enterprises published in
Table 2. Correlation between segregated elements of competitiveness and elements of business ethics
Indexes of competitiveness
Activity Innovation im-
Elements of Business Ethics Company Company’s Market
Sales Profit- plementation
image Earnings growth
ability rates
Commitments Compliance 0.50 -0.19 0.66 0.04 0.00 0.58
Information Security Assurance
0.49 -0.09 0.20 0.06 -0.11 -0.45
Quick response to customer
0.29 -0.39 -0.31 -0.44 0.24 -0.14
needs
Honest competition
-0.39 -0.07 -0.63 -0.21 -0.57 -0.14
Compliance of Law enforcement
-0.41 0.26 -0.19 0.39 -0.26 -0.55
Eco-compliance
-0.13 0.12 -0.56 -0.64 -0.13 0.31
Infringement of Employees
0.15 0.15 -0.17 0.14 -0.08 -0.14
Rights
Secure products
0.01 -0.39 0.14 0.30 -0.23 -0.32
Leadership style
0.54 0.35 0.21 0.07 0.31 -0.06
Communication ethics
0.23 0.43 -0.37 -0.08 0.17 -0.04
715
Č. Purlys
As we see from the Table 2 the strongest impact 4. Model of influence of most important business
on competitiveness of the enterprise was the follow- ethics elements on enterprise competitiveness
ing ones: commitments compliance to the company’s
It is very complicated to make a decision which of
image (correlation coefficient 0.50) and leadership
the mentioned elements of business ethics will lead
style to the company’s image (0.54) and earnings
to more profit. Even if the leaders agreed on the need
(0.34); commitments compliance to sales results
to behave ethically such behaviour, as it is shown by
(0.66) and commitments compliance to innovations
the survey, may be too expensive. And that is the
implementation rates (0.58). Some elements has
strongest disincentive for business ethics implemen-
positive influence on four and five competitiveness
tation – especially now at recession. In order to con-
indexes (leadership style, commitment compliance,
duct business ethics elements to increase competi-
compliance of tax), while others have positive index
tiveness of enterprises, and maximize efficiency of
only on two of them (quick response to customer
key elements of business ethics the model was con-
needs, eco-compliance, compliance of law enforce-
structed (Fig. 2). To strengthen competitiveness of
ment). The worst situation is with the honest compe-
enterprises it is proposed to use those elements of
tition – all competitiveness correlation indexes are
business ethics, which has the greatest positive corre-
negative. Honesty in competition is costly and still
lation with competitiveness indexes
unusual in Lithuania.
To reach the strategic goals, enterprises must se-
Investigation showed that business ethics is not
lect the most effective elements or their combination.
direct but only auxiliary factor for the profit increase.
In our case the combinations would be as shown in
Though enterprise is profitable in general ethical
the model constructed (Fig. 2). If the strategic goal of
behaviour of the enterprise can be unprofitable. Re-
the enterprise is to increase earnings (as it is very
search confirmed the principle mentioned by Vance
important at recession) it ought to select combination
(1975).
of elements and to pay most attention as to: guaran-
Some elements of business ethics, e. g. quick re-
tee about reliable information, communication ethics,
sponse to customer needs, communication ethics and
and leadership style, compliance of tax and compli-
guarantee about the reliable sales information are
ance of law enforcement. But at the booming stage it
unprofitable for investigated enterprises. Most profit-
would be better to select the combination that affects
able elements of business ethics were the commit-
market growth i. e. combination from elements:
ment compliance and the secure products. Mean-
quick response to customer needs, leadership style,
while results show that the ethical behaviour of en-
communication ethics, promotion of innovation and
terprise more positively affects sales than profit.
compliance of tax (Fig. 2).
Company
Competitiveness
Fig. 2. Model of influence of most important elements of business ethics to competitiveness of an enterprise
716
INFLUENCE OF BUSINESS ETHICS FOR ENTERPRISE COMPETITIVENESS
717
Č. Purlys
718