Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
George GRIGORE"
This paper consists of t\\O main pans. The first part deals \\ ith general characteristics of
thirteen-centu1) Mongol aggression on Mar<lin. constituted into a representati\e target or im aswn of
the Islamic 'L:1111110 by the e,temal forces. non-Islamic ones. In these condition;,. in the period of the
blamic Art11qid dynast)-. \ a;,sal to the Mongol Empire of Iran. the t0\\ n of l\1ardin bec:une the object
of a \ ery famous jmH·ii gi, en by the theologian lbn TaymiyYa (661 1263 - 72X 1328 l regarding the
religious status of l\1ardin. The sernnd part of the p:iper deab \\ ith the clarification of cen:iin term~
used in the ·:tmidi of Mardin", on which lbn Taymi 1)a centered his assertion that: ·'l\1ardin ts a
count1:, neither of peace (balad si/111). nor of\\ [lr (hulud horh): but it has a composite (11111rakkuh)
status"
345
l.~t INTl:.RNATIONAL MARDI:--. HISTORY SYMPOSll.JM
heretical inno\ations in religion \\ hich ,,ere \\ icle spread during his time all o,er the Muslim \\Orld.
e~pecially certain acb and beliefs of some mystical order:,. liJ...e saint worship and , isiting saints'
tombs. and rn) sties throw ing the1me h es in the fire. His at tacJ... on the ideas of such orders caused him
a lot of trouble,, ith the authorities ,, hose leaders were under the influence of certain S11/1 thinkers.
Belonging to the HanbalT School. lbn Tay miyya ,, ould follo\, the line promoted b) that trend
in the bitter fight against those seen as enemies of Islam. If the traditionalist (u/-11111lwddi1h) Ahmad
bin Hanbal (d. 855). ,,ho founded in Baghdad the abme-rnentioned school (9th century ). initiated the
· fight against the Shiites. his successor Ibn Tay mi) yah \\Ould fight on t,,o le\els: an internal one.
represented by the rny~tics and the people who followed the heretical inno, ation (hilta): and an
external one. represented by the Tataro-Mongols who attacked the Musli m w-orld and almost reached
Damascus. The people of Syria sent him to Eg) pt to urge the Mameluke Sultan. the Sultan of Egypt
and Syria (i.e.. the Mameluke dynast) reigned in Egypt and Syria from 1250 to 1517) in order to lead
his troop~ to Sy ria to sa, e it from the im ading Tataro-Mongols. Seeing that the Sultan declined his
request. he told him rather openly --if you turn )Our bacJ... on Syna ,,e "ill appoint a Sultan 0\er it.
,,ho can defend it and enjo 7 11 at the time of peace... He ,,as presem at the battle of Shaqhab near
Dama:,cus against the Tataro-Mongols. "hich took place during the fa:,ting month of Ramad,111 and
gm e a far.,·u to the army to breaJ... their fast in order to help them against their enemy. as the Prophet
Muhammad did durmg the battle of the liberation of ~1akJ...a. The Musli1m tu rned to be the winner:, in
the fight against the Tataro-Mongob and dro, e them away from Damascus and entire S) ria. lbn
Tay mi)) ah's courage ,\m, e:-.pressed ,, hen he "ent ,, ith a delegation of '11/wnu · to talk to Mahmud
Ghazan (also Qazan ). the Khan of the Tataro-Mongols. to stop his attack on the Muslims. Not one of
the ·utamll · dared to :,ay any thing to him e:-.cept lbn Taymiyah ,, ho :,aid:
.. You claim that you are a Muslim and you ha,e \\ith you 11111·addi11:,. j udges. /1110111 and
sheikh but ) ou in,aded us and reached our country for\\ hat? While your father and 7our grandfather.
Hulagu. were non-belieH·rs. they did not attacJ... the land of !slam. rather. they promised not to attac k
and the) J...ept their promise. But you promised and broke your promise.. (lbn al-Ka1Tr. t. VII. part l-l.
91-92).
In despite of all his gihad agai nst the enemies of blam . the authorities imprisoned him many
times until he died in jail becmhe of his daring and free progressive opinions on many legal and social
is:.ues. \\ hich angered his opponent •ufama ·. the follo,\ ers of the Orthodox Schools of la\\.
The famo us historian al-.QahabT considered him one of the greatest scholars of Islam of all
time. \\riting of him: " l ne,er sa\, anyone faster at recalling the Qur·anic \erses dealing\\ ith subjects
he v. as discussing. or an 1one v. ho could remember lwdith texts more , i\ id!)·· (al-.QahabT. t. VI 11.
213 ). AI-.QhahabT estimates that his legal opinions on various subjects amounts to three hundred or
more \O]umes.
lbn Ta1 m1nah died in jail in Damascus on the night of 26-27 September 1328 C.E. His
doctrine spread in Arabia in the 18th century
346
l.ULUSLARARASI MARDiN TARiHi Sl:.MPOZYUMU
caliphate affected the entire subsequent history of Islam. Hulagu conquers Damascus also. but his
.n ant-garde is defeated mo year:, later in Palestine by the Egyptian Mamelul-es defeated in the
bJtt le of· Ayn Galut near azareth in 1260. thereby recO\ ering S) ria. main I) becau:,e. it is said. the
\1amelul-e:, horses \\Ore :,hoe:,.
Hulagu recei\es in his po~er the kha11ar of Iran, where he founds the llkhanid dynasty that
_,,'lled bet\, een l 256-1353. \\ ith the capital at Tabriz. then at Sultaniyya. Initially shamanist and
oupble to Christianity and Buddhism. the llkhanid dynasty changes its religious orientation at the
er J of the 13' 11 century when one of the Buddhist descendants of Hulagu. Mahmud Ghazan ( 1271-
- 4 ). after ha\ ing re-conquered Jerusalem ( 1292). declared Sunni Islam the official faith. thus putting
end to the rumour accord ing to which he was going to give the Holy Land to the Christians.
- -claiming Islam as an official rel igion of the llkhanid state would allo\, a better understanding
\\een the Iranian subjects and the Mongol conquerors. At the time of establishing the Mongol
I am. the IIIJrnns ,,ere controlling a ,ast territory. spread from the Indus to the Amu-Darya. from the
I uphrates to Georgia. and extended then in a protectorate O\er Asia Minor. the Cilician Kingdom and
t e Lesser Armenia.
In 1243. hi:, descendants defeated and made the Seljul-id their , assal in Anatolia. When in
l.30~ the Seljuk id fell. the greatest part of Anatolia was under the pO\\ er of the governors appointed by
tl e 111-hans and subject to their general governor in Anatolia. The Turi-men Princi pates (Be_1 liks).
· aring the whole Western Ana tolia. as well as the territories bordered ,, ith the Black and
1 editerranean Seas. ,, ere entire!) subjected to the 111-hanid Sultans. The :,rune was the situation of the
\rtuqid kings (m11/iik) in Mard in and the A)-) ubit 1-ings in Hisn-K.ey f. In 1344. the llkhans
J1,appeared completely from the scene of the history. \\ hile the Anatolian principates became
1<lepcndent.
In their capitals. the llkhans reach to a gorgeous Iranian-Mongolian cultural synthesis - in
•chitecture. in the scientific life. in miniature. de,eloping at the same tune. the trade bet\,een Ea:,t
nd Europe.
347
1.,t l'\JTl:.R A TIO'\J.-\L MARDIN HISTORY SY1\1POSIUM
gi1111 that 10\·ed us and \\ ho made ,1 ith the Tatar Turl-.s something ,imilar to \\ hat I did to them ,, he11
they came in Dama,cus: I im ited them to become Muslim, and ,, hen one of them uttered the t\\ o fa1th
professions I ga,e them something to eat. The gi1111 acted in front of that emir that way I had acted
Thus he \I anted to honour me b: making that emir belie, e that it" as I that treated him that way" ( Ibn
Taymiy:,a. MF. t.Xl l l. p. 92-93).
348
I.ULL,SLARr\RASI MARDi N TARIHi SH1POZYLl!\IL,
;pocrite (1111111t1/icJ) \\ ho doe~ not belie, e 111 blamic rel1g1on in lb inner forum Vi ul-hc1ti11). but the
ce on 11 . or the bad one~ from the innO\ators (u/,/ al-hie/') (lbn Ta) miy)a. MF. l. X:\\'111. 520).
lbn Ta) min a. starting off from the Qur"anic , erse '"Is it a judgement of the time of (pagan)
rsim:e that the) are seeking") \\'ho is better than Allah for judgement to a people " ho ha\e
nt) ( in their belief)? .. (Al-Qur"an. \ ': 50) does not make an) difference bemeen those \\ ho no
~er ,1ppl) ,, hat God bestowed upon His prophet Muhammad. regard ks:, of,, ho they ma) be. and
Luaro-Mongob. E\en if embracing the Islam. the Tataro-1\longols follO\\, t\\O faith~ (1ukalla11111 bi
- • ,1Jara_rn). Islam and }Cl\a. the code of Genghis-Khan (lbn Ta)mi)y:t. MF. t. :\:\\'Ill. 509).
1.. , er. it wa, ob, ious to some l\1u;.lim:- that the Tat:1ro-l\1ongob \\ ere not folio\\ ing the (wTa .
..,,c l3\\,. although they had comened to blam. Instead. the Tataro-Mongob per;.isted in fol km ing
_ ,reat }(Ila ofGenghi;.-K.han. In thi:, the) \.\ere' as bad a, the prc'-blamic pol)the1::-b. the klifir,.. the
1e, eb. And in the /0111·11 of Mardin. lbn Ta) miy) a fore,, Jrns the inhabitants of Mardm about the
f ,upporting those ,, ho lea\e hlam: '"Helping tho,e "ho k,I\ e the L3\, ( (urT'o) of Islamic
- •'-'n i~ forbidden as well. ,, hether it is about the inhabitants of Marc.Jin or other~·- ( lbn Ta 1 mi:,) a.
F X:\\'111. 2-tO).
Genghi;.-Khan's Great raw (see The ) (/\lf 011 cu/d,ibl'riu) - no original cop) of
..:, 1,ts. on!:, fragments written in the L' ighur :,,cript. but it has been m.:onsuucted b) the efforts of
"' ,chobrs \\Us a faith. a ,,a) or life. a social order. The Great }wa (lir >u,w1) embodies in fact
\. ,pie:, taken 0\ er from \ ,uious religions -,uch as Judai'>m. Christi,Lnll 1 . blam. Zoroastriani;.m.
Jt 1,-,111. Animi:,m and Shamanism and others. establishing practical regulations about the
=- 'Tlentmion and beha\ iour of the l\1ongol arm:,. rules about the conduct of the hordes. the mounted
l'.h . tho,.e sv,·ift archer;, "'ho conquered more :,,edemar) peoples. but most llf the rules ha\ e to do
the way Tataro-\longob arc to treat other people: but a 101 ofthcse rules contained a set or,:dues
- pnnc1ples in direct contrast to the la\.\,-, of Islam: condemn the" id-ed: respect all people: shO\\ no
~ erencc to an) ~eel or religion: do not belong 10 ,lll) religion: folio\\ no creed: do not put one faith
e another: the penalt) for murdering a l\luslim is fort) gold coins [hu/T(] - \\ hich conflict~ "1th
hL.tmi<.: lt11\ according to lbn Ta) mi:i, ya in the /mu·11 of I\ lanlnr ··The blood of th<.' l\1uslim and their
•nging,-, rtrl.' considered untouchable (11111hal'l'w11) ,, hc1-c\ er the) arc. \\ hcther in Mar<lin or
~ • here (lbn Ta::,mi)ya. l\.1F. t. :\X\.'111. 2-+0)'": do not ,laughter animals in the i\1u~lim fo!>hion b)
ng thcir throah. but open their brcasb and ,quecLe their hearts: it 1s forbidden to sa) that an) thing
t bo0: nothmg is unclean: alcohol ands\\ me flesh are not forbidden.
nder thi'> S) :,tern of go, ernance there ,, ere \ el') fc\\ and di tfrrent puni,hme111, for\ iolation of the
'- , de of la\\ s that he decreed. the Great l'a,u. The main puni,hment e,pected for an:, infr,1<.:tion \\ as
Jeath. great I) :,implif) ing the l:m . and making the offender quit.: grateful ,1 hen puni.,hment \\a,
,11 carric'd out.
lhn Ta)-ml))U considers (\IF. t. XX\' 111. 520) that Tataro-l\longol\. despite of ha\ing been
~, ened to blam. practice a ,urfoce Islam and fulfil but to a :,hon e,1ent the cult obligations ,uch a;.
: mg (su/(ll). f;hting (saHm) . pa,ment of aim,-, ta, (::ak<1l). -l.bo. the pilgrimage to ;'\lakka i, not
- lied e\ en b) tl10:,e \\ ith appropriate material Clindition,.
For their leaders (lbn Ta)mina. ~1F. l. XX\ Ill. 520). according to the Great }mu. the
f1.15h m i-.. placed on the same k, el as the pol) 1he1,b. .le,,,. and Chri-..tia11:,. "hich i, unacceptable for
L111111u. ;'\ln1e,nw. lbn Ta:,.mi:,ya , h,1\\s (MF, t. X:\\"111. 52:::) that Genghis-Khan ·, successors.
C'\ . n 1f the:v pretend 10 be Mu,lim,. the) place the prophet Muhammad on the s:1me le\ el as Genghi,-
han . and the Qur"an on the ,ame level\\ 1th the Great fow .
.\II the,e matters made lbn Ta:, 1111)) a to i,,ue a /tllmi against the Taturo-Mongob.
lbn Ta)mi~ya consideb that the '.\lu,lim in Mardin. in that compo,ite el1\ ironment. if unable
..,,-..!ctice ( 'ic1ci11w) his religion. ,hould emigrate to the countrie, Llf blam. Other\\ i,e. meaning if he
. practice hi, religion. the emigration is prefc'rable but 1101 compul,or:,: ··1 f he" ho Ii, 6 in Mardin
riable to practice ( 'iq£i111u) hi,. religion. it is an ,ibligauon to him to emigrate. If thi:, i, not the c,1se.
emigration ,-,till remains preferable but not compulsor) ·· (lhn Ta) 111i))a. \IF. t. X:\\1111. 2-+0).
It i:, preferable for the~e people not to "'help the enem:, of Mu,lim Jirectl:, or through their
on;mg, ( ... ). When im pos,ible to do it othen, ise than emigrating, than emigration i, imp,hed to
h tlfthem·· ( lbn Ta1 mi) ya. l\1F. t. X\'111. 2-tO).
The question one ma:, ask him i, not qui te hard to imagine: ho"' could the:, be obliged to
an _;rate. to set for l,igl'u. ,ince the Prophet said: hi hi,gm1u hu 'da al-fu1/,i ··'\o more emigration after
L◊n quest"· (al-BulJ1iirI. t. Ill. 15).
349
I.st INTERNATIONAL MARDIN HISTORY SYMPOSIUM
By this anti-Mongol (m11·0 of lbn Taymiyya. Mardin will have a marked place in the history of
Islam up to the present. as no few are the political or religious instances faced by the contemporary
Islamic countrie~. which are considered similar to the situation faced by Mardin in the llkJ1anid period.
and the solutions gi\ en by lbn Taymiyya in this respect represent a benchmark for the nowadays
drifting blamic societies.
350
I.ULUSLARARASI MARDiN TARiHi SEM POZYUMU
References
al-Bukhari. Muhammad. 1893-1895. al-SahTh. 9 tomes. Cairo: Bulaq.
al-.Qahabi. Muhammad Sam!> al-DTn. 1996. Siyar ·a '/iim al-1111balii'. 19 tomes. Editor: Muhibb
al-DTn al- 'Amra\, i. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
al-MisrT. Ahmad bin Na4Tb. 'Lmdm as-Scilik with the English \ ersion "Reliance of the
Tra\el ler" by ~uh Ha Mim Keller.
AI-Qur 'Zin AI-KarTm; The Glorio111 Qur '[111. Translation by Marmaduke Pickthal. Istanbul:
(agn Yaymlan.
Ciocaltan. Virgil. 1998. ,\fongolii ~i Morea .Veagrii in secolele Xlll-X.11 ·. Bucharest: Editura
Enciclopedica.
lbn al-Ka1Tr. 1988. al-Bidii_1·a 1rn al-11ilu~rn. 14 tomes. Cairo: Dar al-Rayyan li-l- tura1.
lbn Taymiyya. 1980. AI-Mas[J "ii A/-Af[Jrc/T11i_1:1·a. Editor: M. H. Al-Fiqi. Cairo: Maktabat al-
Sunnat al-Muhamadiy) a.
lbn TaymiyYa. 1981. ,\fag.mii. al-jau1wa. (MF). 37 tomes. Editor: "Abd Al-Rahman bin
Muhammad bin Q:.isim. Rabat: Maktabat al-ma·arif.
lbn Ta1 miyya. 200-t ,\lardin: lh;gire. j11i1e du p,hhe el « de111e11re de I ·1,!a111 ». Te.\te:,
traduits de l'arabe annotes et presente!> en re lation a certains textes modemes par Yahya Michot:
Preface de James Pi:,catori. Beirut: Les Editions AIBouraq.
Kazimirski. A. de Biberstein. 1860. Dictiomwire arabe~/ranrais. Paris : l\1aisonneu, e et C'".
Michot. Yah) a. 1996. Lei i111er111.Jdiaires e111re Dit!11 e1 ho111111e (Risalat al-wasTta bayna al-
kJialq wa al-haqq). Traduction franpise sui, ie de Le Shay/../, de I ·11/0111 lb,, Taymirrn: chro11iq11e
d'11111: l'ie de 1/,Jvlogie11111ili1w11. Paris : A.E.1.F.
Miquel. Andre. 1990. L ·1,/c1111 er su ci1·iliw1iv11 ( I "ff-.'L\' .,iec/e). Paris: Annand. Colin.
SumaysanT. H. 1987. JfadTnar Mdrdin min a/~/lllh al- ·arahT i/u sa11a1 I515. Beirut: ·tiJam al-
Kitab.
The Yaw of Chi11gis Khan. A Code of l,onvr. dignify and ercellmcc.
\.
35 1