1.

RAW DATA
Constructability
Economic Constraint
Design Constraint (Duration in
(Cost)
days)

Reinforced Concrete
Design - (Normal 108127800 420
Weight Concrete)

Structural Steel 149421806.8 345

Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Frame and Steel
Moment Resisting
Frame

2. Normalized data
Constructability
Economic Constraint
Design Constraint (Duration in
(Cost)
days)

Reinforced Concrete
Design - (Normal #VALUE! #VALUE!
Weight Concrete)

Structural Steel #VALUE! 10

Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Frame and Steel #VALUE! #VALUE!
Moment Resisting
Frame

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Design 1 (PC1)
Nomalization
((900000-900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =

Table 3
 Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight
Concrete)

Economic Constraint
0.4 7.98
(Cost)

Constructability
0.3 1
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
0.2 1
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.1 7.64
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.456

Table 4

Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight
Concrete)

Economic Constraint
0.38 7.98
(Cost)

Constructability
0.28 1
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
0.22 1
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.4492

Table 5

Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight
Concrete)
Economic Constraint
0.35 7.98
(Cost)

Constructability
0.15 1
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
0.38 1
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.2398
 Stuctural Context

Risk Assessment
Sustainability Constraint
Constraint (Lateral Design
( Life Span)
Displacement)

Reinforced Concrete
50 76 Design - (Normal
Weight Concrete)

47 65 Structural Steel
Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Frame and Steel
Moment Resisting
Frame

Risk Assessment
Sustainability Constraint
Constraint (Lateral Design
( Life Span)
Displacement)

Reinforced Concrete
#VALUE! #VALUE! Design - (Normal
Weight Concrete)

#VALUE! #VALUE! Structural Steel

Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
#VALUE! #VALUE! Frame and Steel
Moment Resisting
Frame

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Design 1 (PC1)
Nomalization
((900000-900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =

Table 3
 Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Structural Steel Project Constraint
Frame and Steel Moment
Resisting Frame

Economic Constraint
1
(Cost)

Constructability
10
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
10
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
10 Constraint (Lateral
Displacement)
6.4 #VALUE! Weighted Sum

Table 4

Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Structural Steel Project Constraint
Frame and Steel Moment
Resisting Frame

Economic Constraint
1
(Cost)

Constructability
10
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
10
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
10 Constraint (Lateral
Displacement)
6.58 #VALUE! Weighted Sum

Table 5

Combined Steel
Eccentrically Brace
Structural Steel Project Constraint
Frame and Steel Moment
Resisting Frame
 Economic Constraint
1
(Cost)

Constructability
10
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability
10
Constraint ( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
10 Constraint (Lateral
Displacement)
6.85 #VALUE! Weighted Sum
 1. FINAL DATA
Constructability Risk Assessment
Economic Constraint Sustainability Constraint
Constraint (Duration in Constraint (Lateral
(Cost) ( Life Span)
days) Displacement)

61,001,703.12 514 50 15.23

85,447,953.48 420 47 5.76

2. Normalized data
Constructability Risk Assessment
Economic Constraint Sustainability Constraint
Constraint (Duration in Constraint (Lateral
(Cost) ( Life Span)
days) Displacement)

#VALUE! 1 #VALUE! #VALUE!

#VALUE! 10 #VALUE! #VALUE!

#VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =
 Combined Steel
Reinforced Concrete
Eccentrically Brace
Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight Structural Steel
Frame and Steel Moment
Concrete)
Resisting Frame

0.4 7.98 1

0.3 1 10

0.2 1 10

0.1 7.64 10

4.456 6.4 #VALUE!

Combined Steel
Reinforced Concrete
Eccentrically Brace
Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight Structural Steel
Frame and Steel Moment
Concrete)
Resisting Frame

0.38 7.98 1

0.28 1 10

0.22 1 10

0.12 7.64 10

4.4492 6.58 #VALUE!

Combined Steel
Reinforced Concrete
Eccentrically Brace
Weight (%) Design - (Normal Weight Structural Steel
Frame and Steel Moment
Concrete)
Resisting Frame
0.35 7.98 1

0.15 1 10

0.38 1 10

0.12 7.64 10

4.2398 6.85 #VALUE!

 Transporta
1. RAW DATA

Constructability Sustainability
Economic Constraint
Design Constraint (Duration Constraint
(Cost)
in days) (Life Span)

Shunting Bay 273,200.00 14 7

Composite Design 276,400.00 30 10
Saw Tooth Bay 271,600.00 7 5

Normalized data

Constructability Sustainability
Economic Constraint
Design Constraint (Duration Constraint
(Cost)
in days) (Life Span)

Shunting Bay 7.00 7.26 6.4

Composite Design 1.00 1 1
Saw Tooth Bay 10.00 10 10

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Shunting Bay
Nomalization
((276400-273200)/(276400-271600))*(9)+1 = 7

Table 3
Composite
Project Constraint Weight (%) Shunting Bay
Design
Economic Constraint
0.4 7 1
(Cost)

Constructability
0.3 14 30
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint
0.2 7 10
( Life Span)
Risk Assessment
0.1 93,321.28 156,980.60
Constraint (Safety Cost)

Weighted Sum 9340.528 15709.46

Table 4
Composite
Project Constraint Weight (%) Shunting Bay
Design
Economic Constraint
0.38 7 1
(Cost)

Constructability
0.28 14 30
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint
0.22 7 10
( Life Span)

Risk Assessment
0.12 93,321.28 156,980.60
Constraint (Safety Cost)

Weighted Sum 11206.67 18848.65

Table 5
Composite
Project Constraint Weight (%) Shunting Bay
Design
Economic Constraint
0.35 7 1
(Cost)
Constructability
0.15 14 30
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint
0.38 7 10
(Life Span)

Risk Assessment
0.12 93,321.28 156,980.60
Constraint (Safety Cost)

Weighted Sum 11205.76 18846.32

 Transportation Context

Risk Assessment Economic Constraint

Design
Constraint (Safety Cost) (Cost)

93,321.28 Shunting Bay 16,584,408.80

156,980.60 Composite Design 9,050,095.36
57,430.64 Saw Tooth Bay 8,491,177.12

Risk Assessment Economic Constraint

Design
Constraint (Safety Cost) (Cost)

6.76 Shunting Bay 1.00

1 Composite Design 9.38
10 Saw Tooth Bay 10.00

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Design 1 (PC1)
Nomalization
((900000-900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =

`
Table 3
Saw Tooth Bay Project Constraint Weight (%)

Economic Constraint
10 0.4
(Cost)

Constructability
7 0.3
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint (
5 0.2
Life Span)
 Risk Assessment
57,430.64 0.1
Constraint (Safety Cost)

5750.164 Weighted Sum

Table 4
Saw Tooth Bay Project Constraint Weight (%)

Economic Constraint
10 0.38
(Cost)

Constructability
7 0.28
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint (
5 0.22
Life Span)

Risk Assessment
57,430.64 0.12
Constraint (Safety Cost)

6898.54 Weighted Sum

Table 5
Saw Tooth Bay Project Constraint Weight (%)

Economic Constraint
10 0.35
(Cost)
Constructability
7 0.15
Constraint (Duration)

Sustainability Constraint (
5 0.38
Life Span)

Risk Assessment
57,430.64 0.12
Constraint (Safety Cost)

6898.13 Weighted Sum

 1. FINAL DATA

Constructability Sustainability Risk Assessment

Constraint (Duration Constraint Constraint (Safety
in days) (Life Span) Cost)

14 7 93,321.28
30 10 156,980.60
7 5 57,430.64

2. Normalized data

Constructability Sustainability Risk Assessment

Constraint (Duration Constraint ( Life Constraint (Safety
in days) Span) Cost)

7.26 6.4 6.76

1 1 1
10 10 10

max-min))*(9)+1

Composite
Shunting Bay Saw Tooth Bay
Design

1 9.38 10

7.26 1 10

6.4 1 10
 6.76 1.00 10.00

4.534 4.352 10

Composite
Shunting Bay Saw Tooth Bay
Design

1 9.38 10

7.26 1 10

6.4 1 10

6.76 1.00 10.00

4.63 4.18 10.00

Composite
Shunting Bay Saw Tooth Bay
Design

1 9.38 10

7.26 1 10

6.4 1 10

6.76 1.00 10.00

4.68 3.93 10.00

 Stuctural C
1. RAW DATA

Constructability Sustainability
Design Economic Constraint (Cost) Constraint (Duration Constraint ( Life
in days) Span)

Reinforced
Concrete Design -
108127800 420 50
(Normal Weight
Concrete)
Structural Steel 149421806.8 345 47
Steel Bracing

2. Normalized data

Constructability Sustainability
Design Economic Constraint (Cost) Constraint (Duration Constraint ( Life
in days) Span)

Reinforced
Concrete Design -
#VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!
(Normal Weight
Concrete)
Structural Steel #VALUE! 10 #VALUE!
Steel Bracing #VALUE! #VALUE! #VALUE!

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Design 1 (PC1)
Nomalization
((900000-900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =

Table 3

Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Structural Steel
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.4 7.98 1
Constraint (Cost)
 Constructability
Constraint 0.3 1 10
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.2 1 10
Span)
Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.1 7.64 10
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.456 6.4

Table 4

Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Structural Steel
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.38 7.98 1
Constraint (Cost)
Constructability
Constraint 0.28 1 10
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.22 1 10
Span)
Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64 10
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.4492 6.58

Table 5

Reinforced Concrete
Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal Structural Steel
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.35 7.98 1
Constraint (Cost)
Constructability
Constraint 0.15 1 10
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.38 1 10
Span)
Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64 10
Displacement)
Weighted Sum 4.2398 6.85
 Stuctural Context
1. FINAL DATA

Risk
Assessment Constructability
Constraint Design Economic Constraint (Cost) Constraint (Duration
(Lateral in days)
Displacement)

Reinforced
Concrete Design -
76 61,001,703.12 514
(Normal Weight
Concrete)
65 Structural Steel 85,447,953.48 420
Steel Bracing

2. Normalized data

Risk
Assessment Constructability
Constraint Design Economic Constraint (Cost) Constraint (Duration
(Lateral in days)
Displacement)

Reinforced
Concrete Design -
#VALUE! #VALUE! 1
(Normal Weight
Concrete)
#VALUE! Structural Steel #VALUE! 10
#VALUE! Steel Bracing #VALUE! #VALUE!

Normalization for PC1

((max-actual)/(max-min))*(9)+1

Design 1 (PC1)
Nomalization
((900000-900000)/(900000-700000))*(9)+1 =

Table 3

Reinforced Concrete
Steel Bracing Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.4 7.98
Constraint (Cost)
 Constructability
Constraint 0.3 1
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.2 1
Span)
Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.1 7.64
Displacement)
#VALUE! Weighted Sum 4.456

Table 4

Reinforced Concrete
Steel Bracing Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.38 7.98
Constraint (Cost)
Constructability
Constraint 0.28 1
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.22 1
Span)
Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64
Displacement)
#VALUE! Weighted Sum 4.4492

Table 5

Reinforced Concrete
Steel Bracing Project Constraint Weight (%) Design - (Normal
Weight Concrete)

Economic
0.35 7.98
Constraint (Cost)
Constructability
Constraint 0.15 1
(Duration)
Sustainability
Constraint ( Life 0.38 1
Span)
 Risk Assessment
Constraint (Lateral 0.12 7.64
Displacement)
#VALUE! Weighted Sum 4.2398
 Risk
Sustainability Assessment
Constraint ( Life Constraint
Span) (Lateral
Displacement)

50 15.23

47 5.76

Risk
Sustainability Assessment
Constraint ( Life Constraint
Span) (Lateral
Displacement)

#VALUE! #VALUE!

#VALUE! #VALUE!
#VALUE! #VALUE!

Structural Steel Steel Bracing

1
 10

10

10

6.4 #VALUE!

Structural Steel Steel Bracing

10

10

10

6.58 #VALUE!

Structural Steel Steel Bracing

10

10
10

6.85 #VALUE!