INTI International University

Faculty of Engineering & Quantity Surveying

Bachelor of Engineering (Hons) in Mechanical Engineering

MEE3223
ENGINEER
ING
THERMOD
YNAMICS
2
PROJECT
GROUP PROJECT REPORT: ASSESSMENT CRITERIA FORMS
August 2019 Session
Group No. :
Student
Names :

Project Title :

Excellent Good Adequate Inadequate SCORE

Criteria &
Considerations Group Project Report
80+ 70 - 79 50 - 69 0 - 49
(10% by weightage)

Broad and deep Broad knowledge

Limited and
understanding of and good
Fair knowledge of perhaps
field beyond understanding of
project inappropriate
Understanding of immediate project project area.
background. background
field of study/ requirement. Correct listing
Mostly correct material or cut-
literature survey/ Appropriate and and citation of a
listing and citing and-paste with
 / 100
citation extensive range fair range
of a range of little value added.
of quality sources (including some
sources. No citation within
correctly listed advanced)
the text.
and cited. sources.

Clear project
Innovative and The aim is stated
spec. & realistic
independent in & objectives
breakdown into Discernible but
Definition of formulating defined. A plan
measurable inadequately
project/ clarity of measureable breaking the task
objectives objectives and
objectives; a
into steps is
defined aims and  / 100
detailed objectives.
approach. Able to formulated and
appreciation of
adapt to changes. explained.
the challenge.

Selection / Solutions Thoughtful Alternatives are Inappropriate  / 100

justification of selected with selection from a considered. approach
appropriate rigorous range of Techniques are adopted with little
methodology consideration alternatives that selected with thought, and
from a wide are mostly some justification. without
range of standard options consideration of
imaginative or and with alternative
innovative justification of
alternatives, and method provided.
with evaluation of
alternatives &
 detailed
justification of
choices.

Rigorous, Methodical and

Appropriate
imaginative and highly competent
standard
extensive application to Limited attempt to
Application of techniques are
investigation, challenging tackle the
methodology
design aspects of the
routinely applied
problem.
 / 100
with moderate
development or problem with
success.
process. some adaptation.

Detailed, Sound analysis

thorough and and discussion, Appropriate Flawed analysis
Analysis and
imaginative with the ability to routine analysis or very limited
discussion of
results
analysis with address some and discussion of discussion of  / 100
insightful level of results. results.
discussion. complexity.

Succinct roundup
Detailed and Summary and
and some critical
comprehensive some reflection
Conclusions/ appraisal of Limited summary
evaluation and on outcomes
critical reflection
critical reflection
outcomes
addressing stated
of outcomes.  / 100
addressing all
on outcomes. objectives.
objectives

All objectives fully Very limited

All objectives fully The majority of
Attainment of met with outcomes despite
met with high expected work
objectives/ value satisfactory evidence of some
of work
quality outcomes
outcomes
completed
effort.
 / 100
demonstrated. satisfactorily.
demonstrated

Continue, next page…

Excellent Good Adequate Inadequate SCORE

Criteria &
Considerations Group Project Report
80+ 70 - 79 50 - 69 0 - 49
(10% by weightage)

Correct
Structured to well
preliminary
Report structure: suit material.
pages, logical
Title; Abstract; Well-balanced
sections/ sub-
Contents etc; sections, good Appropriate
sections,
Introduction; use of length and
references and
Logically appendices, reasonable
appendices.
sequenced body consistent sub- sequence of Some attempt to
Appropriate page,
of text; heading depth. sections. Largely conform to
section, sub-
Conclusions; Figures and correct use of expected
section, figure,
References; tables cross- page, section, structural
table and
Appendices; referenced in
equation
figure and table constraints, but  / 100
Page, Section, text. Correctly numbering and some important
numbering,
Figure generated captions. Mostly aspects are
headings and
Numbering & contents, list of consistent use of seriously flawed.
captions.
Captions; Well- figures etc. Clear fonts for body text
Consistent and
balanced and appropriate and headings, fair
appropriate
sections/ styles, advanced page layout.
typography,
subheading features. No
equations,
depth. widows/orphans
pagination and
etc
layout

Clarity of Complex ideas Clear, concise Reasonably Muddled and  / 100

language and are logically and correct use clear, largely difficult to follow
illustration; developed and of language. correct grammar/ with little or no
grammar, clearly explained. Good standard spelling if, e.g.,
spelling, clear &
rambling or
succinct Use of some
illustrations repetitious.
communication of complex or
liberally used to Appropriate use use of illustration.
complex ideas, insightful graphic
aid clarity. of reasonable
use of good methods
illustrations.
quality figures.

 TOTAL ( /
100%)