Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
College Admission Scandal: Unethical Ways Students are Obtaining Admissions into Elite
Siarrah N. Pryor
Abstract
This paper will give an analysis of the unethical behavior behind college admissions and the
ways wealthy families cheat the system. The paper will give information from colleges and
ongoing court cases. In addition, the author will provide research on how the media has changed
the way the issue is viewed and how even celebrities are involved in the scandal. Furthermore,
the author will break down the reasons people feel the need to use unethical behavior in order to
gain admission into top colleges and universities surrounding the largest college admissions
scandal.
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 3
College Admissions Scandal: Unethical Ways Students are Obtaining Admissions Into Colleges
Center for Education Statistics, 2019). Unethical and illegal behavior involving college
admissions or obtaining and using false information has become a prevalent and common issue
in the United States surrounding the college admissions process; however, not much is being
done to prevent it from continuing to happen. It is easy to say cheating is unethical and wrong;
however, even though people feel this way, there are plenty of real-life examples of wealthy
students having unfair advantages and being admitted to elite universities and colleges over
students who truly deserve to be admitted (American School and University, 2019).
More than fifty parents, school counselors, and other officials have been charged in “The
largest college admissions scam ever”(Berman, 2019). Almost twenty-five million dollars was
paid to counselor William Singer in order for wealthy children to be admitted into top colleges.
He was able to secure most students a spot because they were recruited as “athletes,” or they
were guaranteed admissions due to falsified test scores or falsified life stories (Berman, 2019).
Many companies tend to prey on the rich and elite for money in exchange for helping a
student have a better chance of being admitted into a top school. Many companies will give
students unfair advantages that aren’t available to other students for a hefty price. Wealthy
parents already have a better chance of having their child admitted to a better school; however,
many of these parents want to see their children at elite schools. It seems as if wealthy parents do
not mind paying for elite tutors, test prep, personalized study guides, or college consultants;
anything to get their child one step ahead of everyone else is the goal (Barnard, 2019).
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 4
Bribes
into a certain university. Students from wealthy parents have more resources and are more
prepared to attend college. Many rich families go to the extreme to get their children into good
colleges (Berman, 2019). For example, tech executive Jeffrey Bizzack paid over 250,000 for his
son to be admitted into the University of Southern California as a “volleyball recruit” (Bowden,
2019). Douglas Hodge, a former chief executive paid more than 500,000 to get two of his
children into the University of Southern California. Many other executives paid these bribes as
well, but they did not face additional criminal charges because they pled guilty to the accusations
Falsifying Information
Fake standardized test scores or fake athletic profiles give an advantage to wealthy
families (Bonagura, 2019). Leaks of exams or students having their peers take the test for them
give a big advantage to wealthy families and are being used by people with the means to do so.
Many people believe that as long as standardized test scores remain a factor in the college
admissions decision of elite schools, students and parents will find a way to cheat the system
(Vigo, 2019).
Rich families are doing anything they can to get their child ahead of everyone else and
receive a guaranteed admission. Some people even photoshop images in order to create profiles
and enter false information into a database. Many of these tactics have worked for years;
however, now many Americans are seeing what they are actually doing behind the scenes. Using
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 5
fake information to obtain admissions is illegal and takes away scholarships and opportunities
Falsifying Athletics
A company named “The Key,” run by William Singer, was used to help wealthy clients
come up with fake resumes for their children to submit to colleges. Students were seen as
recruits and falsely admitted into universities as players for college-level sports teams
(Bonagura,2019). Parents were paying to have their children staged playing sports and sending
Many college coaches and administrators were involved in the scandal and have helped
falsify information including test scores and athletics written on college applications (Bonaguara,
2019). College coaches would vouch for many undergraduates’ involvement on a sports team,
and they used fake photos and awards. Some parents have paid psychologists to have their child
receive a fake disability diagnosis allowing extra time on standardized tests and help with
Many wealthy families find loopholes and advantages in the college admission process.
For example, some parents have given up guardianship of their child, so they can qualify for
more financial aid or scholarships meant to be given to underprivileged children. Many high
school students from high-income families get to attend better schools and take personalized
SAT or ACT prep courses or have advantages to boost their resume not offered to everyone
(Jaschik, 2019). According to the Journal of Blacks in Higher Education (2019) many websites
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 6
allow students to look at admissions essays that got students into highly ranked schools. For a
price, students or parents can pay to research and review application essays from highly ranked
There are many other ways students can “legally” cheat. For example, donations can
make a huge difference in whether a student is admitted into a certain school. Over forty-two
percent of colleges take into account whether an applicant’s parent attended the school and have
a higher chance of being admitted if so. Even taking a costly trip to visit the campus can help a
student receive admission into the school. Students are more likely to be admitted if they apply
early decision or action which research shows favors white and wealthy students (Lombardo,
2019). Many scholarships for underprivileged children who do not have the same resources as
others are going to students with the means to pay for college through their family (Barnard,
2019).
Colleges
Since the College Admission Scandal has made its way across America, many
universities and colleges are reviewing their admissions policies. Many schools not involved in
the scandal are imposing rules such as banning gifts given to students or anything to motivate the
recruitment of a student onto a sport’s team. The CEO of the Common App held a panel of 40
enrollment leaders to talk about, “The systematic issues impacting students and families as they
navigate this process” (Jaschik, 2019). The people who attended talked about how unfortunately
they tend to “privilege the privileged” and want to try to reduce barriers students face when
Colleges are conducting case by case reviews for any students that may be connected to
college admission schemes. Many schools are looking into the profiles of young adults attending
who may be in connection with the scheme. Students involved may face expulsion or criminal
charges (Reilly, 2019). Yale is bringing in advisors to investigate and review the issue.
2019).
Many universities are facing huge fallouts and are being accused of giving wealthy
students unfair advantages to help them be admitted into the school. Universities and colleges are
trying to figure out how they can make the system fair for all students. Some colleges and
universities are trying to find and expose students involved in the scandal or fund scholarships
for underprivileged students. Colleges and universities are trying to crack down on violations and
find anyone involved in schemes to violate the college admissions process (Park, 2019).
In recent news, it has appeared as if wealthy families are favored by colleges for their
children to be admitted. Some colleges have been debating whether an admission lottery should
be used to admit students. In the lottery people in the same academic place would be accepted
into the school by chance. This would allow for schools and parents to save money on trying to
beat the next competitor. Colleges are trying to develop a matching system in order for
Media Involvement
The college admission scandal has been very prevalent in the news in the last few
months. Some parents accused of cheating are facing civil or even criminal charges. The media
is showing the harsh reality of what is going on behind the backs of many Americans. Many
people are blaming the “elite” because of how America as a whole tends to turn a blind eye when
wealthy citizens of a higher status act in a bad manner or do something against the law (Barnard,
2019).
Celebrities
The United States District Attorney has charged over 50 celebrities, including wealthy
businessmen, coaches, and television stars inside the longest nationwide college admission
scandal. The allegations include bribing college administrators, coaches, and bribing exam
officials (Friedman, 2019). Actress Lori Loughlin and over fourteen other parents have been
As a society, we are failing to educate children on the wrongfulness of cheating and how
it will affect them in the future. Each year colleges become more and more competitive and
harder to get into. Many scholarships that were funded for underprivileged children have gone to
the elite (Park, 2019). According to the New York Times (2019), some parents are using
deception and fraud to get their child into higher education institutions which is illegal because
the schools are profiting off of the students or even some companies are profiting off the wealthy
families (Smith, 2019). The influence of money has always been an issue in the college
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 9
admissions process; however, many of the events taking place right now are illegal and not just
According to Knowledge at Wharton Team (2019) the scandal is showing the problem of
higher education enabling privileged families to hold onto power. The college admissions
scandal is showing the world that money is a “universal solvent” and can be used to beat the
system. It is showing that wealthy families for years have been abusing the system illegally to
get their child into elite schools using large donations or fake information. It allows people to
determine if standardized test scores should have as much weight when deciding if a student
should be admitted. The media has lit a fire under elite colleges in order for them to do
something about the college admissions scandal and make sure every student has a fair chance.
Many parents don’t want their child to go to a community college or public university so they
use their entitlement in order for their child to obtain admission into a top university (Knowledge
Exposing wealthy people involved in the scandal has given people a sense of what reality
truly is and how the wealthy manipulates the system. The media is showing how many people
abuse the system and obtain false information all the time and how huge this issue is truly
becoming. The public gets to see how justice may never be served for some wealthy citizens and
how many wealthy privileged people never are held accountable for their actions (Jaschik, 2019).
Examples
There are many real-life examples of people cheating or obtaining an unfair advantage
surrounding the college admissions process. Some range from parents, students, administrators,
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 10
coaches, or even people involved in college prep for students. Many of these people are finding
ways around the system to help children become admitted into the school of their choice. While
there are laws in place against students receiving unfair advantages, many of these wealthy
citizens don’t follow the laws. In addition, some of the tactics used don’t have anything
specifically written to say it’s illegal; therefore, people are finding loopholes to use. More than
50 people have been charged with participating in the same college admission scandal including
bribery, money laundering, and fabricating documents to unfairly get certain students admitted
An executive based in Los Angeles paid over 400,000 dollars to have his child attend
Georgetown University as a tennis recruit and has been sentenced to four months in jail for his
actions surrounding the scandal. Many judges have given sentences below what prosecutors have
recommended for people involved in what is seen as the largest college admissions scandal ever
Gregory and Maria Abbott very wealthy citizens were sentenced to a month in jail each
for paying over 125,000 dollars in order for their daughter’s entrance exam test scores to be
changed which resulted in her obtaining admissions into Duke University. In addition, Devin
Sloane, a business executive from Los Angeles was sentenced to four months in jail for paying
250,000 dollars to William Singer for having his son admitted to the University of Southern
California as a water polo recruit. The harshest sentence involving the scandal has been given to
Agustin Huneeus, a vineyard owner in Napa Valley. Huneeus faked his daughter’s athletic
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 11
abilities and test scores and was sentenced to five months in jail with two years of court
Schools
T.M. Landry College Prep School gained recognition for sending black students to
prestigious universities. The Times found that the school had doctored and even invented
backgrounds for its students designed to appeal to Ivy League admissions officers looking for
inspirational stories, while also abusing and manipulating students. Most of the stories were
made up and used to help students gain unfair advantages (Green, 2018).
Many administrators and coaches from the University of Southern California have been
involved in the scandal such as the senior associate athletic director, the head women’s soccer
coach, the assistance women’s soccer coach, and the water polo coach. In addition, they have all
pled guilty to charges of having some involvement in the scandal (Shamslan, 2019).
More than 20 Atlanta public school administrators were charged with racketeering and
other charges surrounding changing test score answers for students. The defendants involved in
the scandal faced between five to twenty years for making false statements. More than 250,000
answers were changed to the correct answer. Many people involved in the scandal took plea
Cases
The College Admission Fairness Act (2019) was used to amend the Internal Revenue
Code of 1986. It helped come up with rules for charitable contributions to universities. It
prohibits admission decisions be made based on donations by families. Senator Ron Wyden
wants to introduce legislation to eliminate tax advantages. His plan will allow donations to the
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 12
school to be taxable if the donor’s child attends college (College Admissions Fairness Act,
2019).
Lori Loughlin is currently on trial in federal court over a college admission bribery
scandal. A college consultant called William Singer assisted children of wealthy parents to
acquire fake SAT or ACT scores and appear as athletes in order to get into top colleges in the
country. Loughlin and her husband Giannulli paid over 500,000 to get two of their daughters in
USC posed as crew recruits. They pleaded not guilty to money laundering and conspiracy to
commit mail and wire fraud. Nearly 50 people are currently being charged and 34 Americans
involved are parents. Loughlin was arrested and released on a one million dollar bond. Loughlin
Felicity Huffman donated 15,000 to an SAT proctor in order to have her daughter’s scores
changed. The bribe was disguised as a donation towards “educational programs” towards
disadvantaged youth. Felicity Huffman has been charged with committing mail fraud and
The college admissions process depends on the public in order for it to be effective and
successful. When elite families obtain unfair advantages it hurts the admissions process and
society as a whole. For every student unfairly admitted there is a qualified student who isn’t
admitted. Qualified students who deserved a spot on the team or admissions into that university
are not admitted due to bribery and corruption. Hardworking students who are denied admissions
and have their spot given to a wealthier student are the ones affected by the scandal the most
because many of these students will no longer attend college or get the financial aid they
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 13
deserve. Many schools don’t set up students from underrepresented backgrounds such as
(Lombardo,2019).
A report by the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights published last year concluded, "The
federal government must take bold action to address inequitable funding in our nation's
public schools." Schools in America remain largely segregated — and those serving
mostly students of color get $23 billion less than schools serving mostly white students,
though both have the same number of students, according to a recent report from the
Many parents have gone to extreme lengths in order to get their child admissions into a
top-ranked institution. Many parents feel they don’t want their child to “suffer” or experience
any hardships in life. In addition, parents want their children to succeed in life and feel attending
a top school is the way to do so while some parents just like the recognition their child will
receive from graduating from a better learning institution. Many wealthy families believe going
to an elite school will allow students to have more power in life and get a better job and
education. Wealthy parents have admitted to wanting their children to feel like they deserve to be
at one of the best colleges. Elite schools have shown that they don’t improve the outcomes for
their students. Many students end up in the same predicament and applying for the same jobs as
students from a public university unless they have an advantage after college (Calarco,2019).
counselors to verify the information of each student. They must make sure a student has met all
requirements and ensure all the specific requirements are met by a high schooler to attend a
certain school. Guidance counselors use a student’s transcript to verify all test scores and official
information. Many colleges or universities will call a school counselor to verify information
The college admission scandal is showing how competitive admissions to elite colleges
are for high schoolers. Many schools are getting more competitive to get into each year including
public colleges and more is being done to have guaranteed admissions. It seems as if the
application pool is increasing while the schools aren’t growing fast enough to accept more
students making them have to be more selective. For example, the University of Virginia has
received a 19% increase in the amount of application in five years; however, the first-year class
has only increased by eight percent over the last few years (Powell,2016).
Testing
The SAT and ACT are used in the college decision process by many schools and taken
into account when deciding whether a student will be admitted. Just the SAT and ACT test prep
course alone is a multi-billion dollar industry. Many parents hire consultants to help students
school the right things to do to get into certain schools. In addition, editors are hired to help high
Why Is It Wrong?
Many of what seems to be going on involving the college admissions system is not
defined as illegal by the law. As a result, an over 25 million dollar cheating ring was running
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 15
around behind the backs of many law-abiding citizens. For example, things like hiring college
admissions consultants, test prep tutors, and donations to universities aren’t specifically illegal
but definitely immoral and give an advantage to wealthier students. It’s been proven that colleges
favor the wealthy and discriminate against certain groups of students. The scandal has shown
United States citizens that privilege does truly benefit the wealthy and gives richer students an
unfair advantage in society. Hiring a tutor for test prep and having people lie on a student’s
behalf are definitely two different things; however, when abused it can be hard to distinguish
What Now
The recent college admission scandal has shaken up the public’s perception of college
admissions. Many colleges will need to conduct their business in a new way. They will have to
think about how much-standardized test scores matter and how to avoid anymore falsifying of
information. Parents will have to stop placing anxiety on their child over the college they decide
to attend and pay attention to what their child wants to do. The scandal is showing how much the
competition has gotten out of hand and the lengths people will go to get admitted into a certain
school due to the name or status of the particular school. The system of checks and balances will
have to be used in the admissions process to stop cheating from happening (Margaret,2019).
Conclusion
The scandal may discourage some parents from trying to “game the system”; however,
more parents may try to be more careful in covering their tracks. Many wealthy families may not
see anything wrong with some of the things they are doing and opt not to change their ways. In
order for real change to occur, we as a society would have to reduce the power of privilege and
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 16
money. In reality, many families cannot afford to pay for college for their children and many
underprivileged children rely on financial aid and scholarships in order to attend a college to
Offering a guaranteed standard of living for families and giving more school funding to
underrepresented schools would allow for more students to have an equal chance at attending
colleges and universities they deserve to go to. Having some elite schools use a lottery to admit
students will make it fairer for students to have an equal chance of being admitted. We need to
ensure that even when privileged people find loopholes and use unfair advantages to get ahead
there will be punishment and consequences they are unable to get out of (Calarco, 2019).
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 17
References
Almasy, S. (2015, April 14). Atlanta schools cheating scandal: 11 of 12 defendants convicted.
https://edition.cnn.com/2015/04/01/us/atlanta-schools-cheating-scandal/
Barnard, B. (2019, March 30). The college admission scandal: Voices of reason part one.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/brennanbarnard/2019/03/30/the-college-admission-scandal-
voices-of-reason-part-one/#21785da59b6c
Bonagura, K., & Murphy, D. (2019, March 12). College admissions scandal: Fake athletes,
alleged bribes and Aunt Becky. Retrieved November 4, 2019, from espn.com website:
https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/26240641/college-admissions-scandal-f
ake-athletes-alleged-bribes-aunt-becky
Bowden, E. (2019, June 28). Another parent busted in college admissions scandal. Retrieved
https://nypost.com/2019/06/28/another-parent-busted-in-college-admissions-scandal/
Calarco, J. (2019, March 22). When their kids don't make the cut. Retrieved December 19, 2019,
https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2019/03/22/cheating-college-admissions-plays-o
ut-several-different-levels-opinion
College Admissions Fairness Act, S. 1732, 116th Cong., 1st Sess. Retrieved from
https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/1732/text
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 18
https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/116/s1732/text/is
Edward, T., & S, J. (2006). Candor, confidentiality, and the college admissions of recovering
students. International Journal of Reality Therapy, 26( 1), 29-34. Retrieved from
4 more parents plead guilty in college admissions scandal. (2019, October 22). American School
& University, NA. Retrieved from Gale In Context: Global Issues database.
Friedman, Z. (2019, March). Hollywood celebrities charged in major college admissions scandal.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2019/03/12/hollywood-celebrities-charged-in
-major-college-admissions-scandal/#6de1fc081dc5
Green, E. (2018, November 30). Louisiana school made headlines for sending black kids to elite
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/30/us/tm-landry-college-prep-black-students.html
Jaschik, S. (2019, August 19). Has admissions changed since the scandal? Retrieved December
https://www.insidehighered.com/admissions/article/2019/08/19/has-admissions-changed-
scandal
Kiewiet, R. (2015). Cheating: An insider's report on the use of race in admissions at UCLA.
Public Choice, 162(1), 205-209. Retrieved from ProQuest Research Library database.
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 19
Knowledge at Wharton Team. (2019, March 15). The college cheating scandal: The biggest
website: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/college-admissions-scandal/
Krislov, M. (2019). Wealthy parents abuse of the college admissions process should produce 'an
honest reckoning'. Westchester County Business Journal, 55( 13). Retrieved from Global
Legatt, A. (2019, March 19). Is it moral and ethical to pay for an advantage in the college
https://www.forbes.com/sites/avivalegatt/2019/03/19/is-it-moral-and-ethical-to-pay-for-a
n-advantage-in-the-college-admissions-process/#455dfe2a4fac
Margaret, J. (2019, September 18). How has the recent college admissions scandal affected
https://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2019/09/18/how-has-the-recent-college-admissions-s
candal-affected-higher-education/#6a6c62d0b40e
Moser, D. (2019, August 27). Lori Loughlin and her husband are back in court in college
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/08/27/lori-loughlin-her-husband-are-ba
ck-court-college-admissions-scandal/
Ockerman, E. (2019, October 10). All the parents going to prison in the college admissions
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ne89vz/all-the-parents-going-to-jail-in-the-college-ad
missions-cheating-scandal
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 20
Olmstead, M. (2019, March 12). The most absurd details from the college admissions scandal
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/03/college-admissions-cheating-scandal-lori-lou
ghlin-felicity-huffman.html
Park, M. (2019, April 25). Here's what universities are saying about the college admissions
https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/14/us/college-admission-cheating-universities-react/index.
html
Patten, D. (2019, October 7). Lori Loughlin looking at "higher sentence" than Felicity Huffman
in college bribery scandal. Retrieved December 19, 2019, from deadline.com website:
https://deadline.com/2019/10/lori-loughlin-jail-time-college-bribery-scheme-trial-felicity-
huffman-us-attorney-andrew-lelling-interview-video-1202754615/
Powell, F. (2016, September 22). How competitive is college admissions? Retrieved December
https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/articles/2016-09-22/how-competitive-is
-college-admissions
The racial impact of essay peddling in college admission applications. (2010). Journal of Blacks
Reilly, K. (2019, March 15). Here's what could happen to the students involved in the college
https://time.com/5551752/college-admissions-students/
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 21
Shamslan, J. (2019, December 9). Here's the full list of people charged in the college admissions
cheating scandal, and who has pleaded guilty so far. Retrieved December 19, 2019, from
insider.com website:
https://www.insider.com/college-admissions-cheating-scandal-full-list-people-charged-20
19-3
Smith, P. (2019, April 22). The price of admission: An illegal scheme to buy spots at elite
schools is focusing attention on the role of money in college admissions. New York Times
Upfront, 151( 12), 12+. Retrieved from Gale In Context: Opposing Viewpoints database.
Svrluga, S. (2019, April 9). Lori Loughlin and 15 other parents face additional charges in college
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2019/04/09/lori-loughlin-other-parents-face-
additional-charges-college-admissions-scandal/
scandal. (2019, October 7). Crain's New York Business, 35(40), 0016. Retrieved from
UCLA professor charges university with cheating on admissions of unqualified black students.
(2008). Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, (61), 1-18. Retrieved from ProQuest
Vigo, J. (2019). Tech's role in the college admission scandal. Retrieved November 4, 2019, from
forbes.com website:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/julianvigo/2019/04/20/techs-role-in-the-college-admission-
scandal/#2bf096e65977
COLLEGE ADMISSIONS SCANDAL 22
Warikoo, N. (2019, March 13). College cheating scandal shows why elite colleges should use a
website:
https://theconversation.com/college-cheating-scandal-shows-why-elite-colleges-should-u
se-a-lottery-to-admit-students-113506
Winton, R. (2019, March 17). Fallout from college admissions scandal worsening for accused
https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-college-cheating-parents-fallout20190316-st
ory.html website:
https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-college-cheating-parents-fallout20190316-st
ory.html