16/02/2020 The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians: what it is and why it needs updating

Academic rigour, journalistic flair

The Melbourne Declaration provides a national vision of what education in Australia should be for. www.shutterstock.com

The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young

Australians: what it is and why it needs updating
December 4, 2018 10.57am AEDT

Federal Education Minister Dan Tehan has announced the government will update Author
the Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians. This
document sets out the agreed national purposes and role of schooling in order to
deliver high-quality education regardless of cultural, linguistic and economic
background. Don Carter
Senior Lecturer, Education, University of

It also aims to ensure schooling contributes to a socially cohesive society that Technology Sydney

continues to strengthen Australia as a democracy. The Melbourne Declaration is an

important document nationally because it provides the basis of the Australian
Curriculum.

As a nation, we face a range of national and international challenges such as mobile populations, so-
called “fake news”, youth radicalisation, religious fundamentalism and a decline in public confidence
in political and social institutions. A rigorous and quality education will provide students with the
skills and knowledge to make sense of these and other challenges.

Read more: What sort of people do we want young Australians to be?

https://theconversation.com/the-melbourne-declaration-on-educational-goals-for-young-australians-what-it-is-and-why-it-needs-updating-107895 1/5
16/02/2020 The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians: what it is and why it needs updating

Four key changes could be made to help develop students into the skilled, knowledgeable and rational
individuals Australia needs. These are:

a greater emphasis on the development of soft skills

a rethink of the ways teachers assess student learning in the classroom
a strengthening of critical thinking skills
closer attention to the language we use when talking about education.

What it’s about

The Ministerial Council on Education, Employment, Training and Youth Affairs issued the Melbourne
Declaration in 2008. It was preceded by the Hobart and Adelaide Declarations.

The then education minister, Julia Gillard, led the development of the Melbourne Declaration. Simon Mossman/AAP

As the overarching vision for Australian education, the document articulates two main goals:

1. the promotion of equity and excellence in Australian schools

2. that all young Australians become successful learners, confident and creative individuals and
active and informed citizens.

These two goals are intended to ensure all students get high-quality schooling free from
discrimination so they develop into knowledgeable, capable and articulate citizens.

Criticisms

A number of education experts have criticised the Melbourne Declaration. One, for example, argues a
main driver behind the Melbourne Declaration is the promotion of education as a commodity,

https://theconversation.com/the-melbourne-declaration-on-educational-goals-for-young-australians-what-it-is-and-why-it-needs-updating-107895 2/5
16/02/2020 The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians: what it is and why it needs updating

competing with other commodities in a global market. As a result, other important aims related to the
development of students’ personal attributes as communicative, respectful and thoughtful individuals
are not fully targeted in the document.

Similarly, other experts argue the document advocates a new type of education promoted by the
OECD, which requires creative thinking, the ability to work flexibly and the ability to adapt to changes
in the workplace and wider society. They argue the document is couched in language that promotes
the economic aims of education and the economic prosperity of the nation over student well-being,
environmental sustainability and democratic participation.

How can it be improved?

The scope for improvement in the Melbourne Declaration lies in the second goal, which focuses on the
development of soft skills. The Melbourne Declaration needs to clearly require curriculum and
educational policy across Australia to be geared towards developing students who are highly literate
and numerate, able to solve problems (especially in the workplace), communicate effectively and
develop and maintain positive relationships within and beyond the family unit.

Second, we need to rethink how we assess student learning in the classroom. Rather than being
geared towards classmate-versus-classmate competition through tests and examinations, it should
acknowledge and reward achievement in an ongoing way. For example, a student may try to write a
narrative early in the year and then, following further learning and practice, re-attempt the writing
activity. The teacher may identify specific features to track over the two attempts and provide
feedback on the quality of those features.

Students should be encouraged to compete with themselves, not their peers. from www.shutterstock.com

https://theconversation.com/the-melbourne-declaration-on-educational-goals-for-young-australians-what-it-is-and-why-it-needs-updating-107895 3/5
16/02/2020 The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians: what it is and why it needs updating

This approach to assessment is called ipsative assessment. A student’s performance is not measured
against their peers’ performance, but against their last attempt at a similar task. This approach
eliminates competition with peers and the potential negative consequences of such competition.

It’s similar to approaches outlined in the Gonski 2.0 report. The Melbourne Declaration includes
advice on approaches to assessment, but the inclusion of ipsative assessment would be a good option
for schools.

We also need to be mindful of the language we use in education. In recent decades, education has
increasingly been seen and talked about as a commodity. The language of the marketplace has
infiltrated education with terms such as “agile”, “nimble”, “flexible” and “innovative” appearing in
policy documents. These words narrow the goals of education to the development of workplace skills
and little else.

An example of this is the New South Wales Stronger HSC Standards Blueprint, which states
curriculum reform needs to be “agile and flexible”. This document as a whole is an example of the
heavy emphasis on workplace skills and aptitudes at the expense of the development of individual,
interpersonal skills.

We need to be mindful of the terms we use – education is more than a product to be consumed.

Read more: Gonski 2.0: teaching creativity and critical thinking through the
curriculum is already happening

We live in a era of information saturation and overload. In an important Australian study, the Digital
News Report: Australia 2018 found that 65% of Australians grapple with what’s real and what isn’t in
the news. Another study found only 34% of young Australian respondents said they can identify fake
news stories from real ones. Some 32% said they are unable to do so.

A revised Melbourne Declaration needs to emphasise critical thinking. This is the capacity to spot
faulty arguments, generalisations and unfounded assertions.

Highlighting critical thinking will help equip students with the tools to identify how language can be
used to persuade, compel and deceive. This capacity is increasingly important in democracies in an
era of “fake news”, social media platforms and information saturation.

 Schools Democracy Education policy Melbourne Declaration School education Dan Tehan Fake news You
might
also like
Teachers use violence against children in Uganda: we set out to find out more

https://theconversation.com/the-melbourne-declaration-on-educational-goals-for-young-australians-what-it-is-and-why-it-needs-updating-107895 4/5
16/02/2020 The Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians: what it is and why it needs updating

We made deceptive robots to see why fake news spreads, and found a weakness

Why the demise of specialist reporters is a loss for any democracy

How local journalism can upend the ‘fake news’ narrative

https://theconversation.com/the-melbourne-declaration-on-educational-goals-for-young-australians-what-it-is-and-why-it-needs-updating-107895 5/5