Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In the design of machine, tools, and working environment, a proper database of anthropometry is
Received 21 June 2015 needed. The objective of this study is to redesign workplace in Indonesian Sundanese roof tile industries
Received in revised form based on anthropometry approach and to develop corresponding anthropometric database for Indone-
28 February 2016
sian Sundanese worker. Six hundred and sixty Sundanese workers were measuredd411 male and 249
Accepted 5 March 2016
female. A set of 17 static anthropometric measures (8 and 9 dimensions in standing and sitting positions
Available online 24 March 2016
respectively) was measured for each participant. Redesign of workplace of roof tile industries in
Indonesia is then discussed.
Keywords:
Anthropometry
© 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Indonesian
Workers
Redesign
Workplace
1. Introduction Indonesia account for over 99% of all firms in Indonesia and
employing more than 99 million people. The small industries also
As a fast growing developing country, industries in Indonesia account for 57% of Indonesian Gross Domestic Product (USAID,
have been growth in numerous number. However, the increase of 2013).
the number of industries has been coupled with increasing number Various studies related to incident and accident in Indonesian
of incident and accident in those industries. Various accident and industries have pointed out the main causes of those accidents. One
incident has been reported for years. For example, a study con- of the causes is the absence of proper anthropometry data of
ducted by Sutalaksana et al. (2010) found high injury and accident Indonesian workers which in turn develops dimensional mismatch
in coal mining due to size mismatch between the dimensions of in man-equipment system in operation. This eventually affect well-
heavy equipment imported from abroad and local Indonesian being, health, comfort, and safety of the workers (Sutalaksana et al.,
workers anthropometry. Another study reported the existence 2010; Yassierly et al., 2013).
cumulative trauma disorder among workers tools in oil and gas One small industry in Indonesia that faces serious problem with
company due to man and equipment lack of fitness (Yassierly et al., dimensional mismatch in man-equipment system is roof tile in-
2013). dustries. In these industries, the mismatch can be found
Furthermore, high accident rate in workplace could not only be throughout all the stages of the roof tile process. Three of the stages
found in medium and large industries, but also in small industries. are described here and are the subjects of dimensional redesign
For example, back pain has been frequently reported due to based on anthropometry data the to be develop in this research.
awkward postures during work (e.g., bending) because of tools The first is on the activities in the beginning of the process. After
position is lower than hand position of worker (Sutalaksana et al., being dwelled from dump truck, raw clay is fed to a press machine
2002). With regards of small industries in Indonesia, attention to produce compacted clay bars. In the existing condition, see Fig. 1,
has been given by Indonesian government since small industries in the workers must work in awkward position, i.e., squatting, which
expose the workers to high risk in low back pain.
Secondly, concerning the trimming process. Here, the already
pressed and folded clay which already have the roof tile form, have
* Corresponding author. Department of Industrial Engineering, Bandung Institute to be trimmed for some surface imperfections. Female workers
of Technology, Ganesa 10, Bandung 40135, Indonesia.
E-mail address: widyanti@mail.ti.itb.ac.id (A. Widyanti).
usually perform this particular task. They sit in the long bench with
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ergon.2016.03.002
0169-8141/© 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
300 I.Z. Sutalaksana, A. Widyanti / International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 53 (2016) 299e305
Fig. 1. Awkward position of worker during fed of raw clay into the press machine.
leg folded for almost 8 h a day as can be seen in Fig. 2. Reason for
folding their leg is because the bench is too high for them so that
their leg would hang when they sit normally on the bench. Also
because the trash from this process is to be dumped below the
bench. In this position, the workers are exposed to high low back
discomfort and injuries.
Finally the drying process. All of the roof tiles which are still wet
must be dried by passing them through a burning process as can be
Fig. 3. Height of burning process area.
seen in Fig. 3. In this process, all tiles are placed in shelf. The po-
sition of the shelf are from floor height to a particular height based
on preference of the owner of the roof tile industries. In this
existing condition, tall workers must bend their body during their
access to this roof burning area. This bending position posed them
to low back pain problems.
From the three unergonomic drawn from the roof tiles industry,
it can be seen that redesigning the workplace to fit the workers may
need proper anthropometry data to provide safer and more
comfortable working condition. This implies the availability of
anthropometry database is particularly very important.
Anthropometry, defined as the science of measurement and the
art of application that establishes the physical geometry, mass
properties, and strength capabilities of the human body (Pheasant,
1998), plays an important role in the design of domestic and in-
dustrial environment. With regards to domestic, daily goods and
environment, anthropometry is crucial for example in the design of
school furniture (Al-Ansari and Mokdad, 2009) and design of cloth
(Zakaria, 2010). In addition, Boyles et al. (2003) underlined the role
of anthropometry in the design of scissors for hairdressing for
safety reason. An absent of anthropometry consideration would in
most cases result in uncomfort design for the targeted users and
worse, unsafe and unhealthy conditions.
In industry, anthropometry is needed in the design of machines,
tools, and work environment in order to improve well-being,
health, comfort, and safety (Pheasant, 1998). The importance of
matching anthropometry data to the worker in the design of tools
and workplace has been recognized for years. For instance, with
Fig. 2. Working position of women workers in correcting surface imperfections of roof
regards to design of workplace, Reis et al. (2012) described the role
tile.
I.Z. Sutalaksana, A. Widyanti / International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 53 (2016) 299e305 301
of anthropometry on meat packing plant in particular for the pre- 2.2. Procedure and equipment
vention of shoulder joint injury. In addition, Wang et al. (1999)
reported a design of anthropometric work environment for The survey was conducted by a team from Institute Technology
Taiwanese workers to promote safety and health in the workplace. Bandung involving 3 faculty members as senior researchers and ten
In the context of design of machine and tools, Gadheri et al. (2014) research assistants aged 20e22 years. A three days session of
explained how design of combine harvester seat should consider theoretical and technical knowledge of anthropometry measure-
anthropometry data to increase safety. Hsiao et al. (2005) and ment was given as refresher to the assistants in order for them to
Victor et al. (2002) also stressed the importance of considering have the proper skill in anthropometry measurement in addition to
anthropometry data in the agricultural machinery design. their several years of experience in our laboratory. This training
Furthermore, Chang et al. (2003) showed that incorporating session is also intended to minimize inter-observer error (Kouchi
anthropometry in the design of a utility cover removal operation et al., 1996; Mislihah, 2004). In a pilot study in a laboratory
brought the effect of increase safety to the worker. setting, we instructed observers to measure anthropometry of 2
A valid and reliable anthropometric database is therefore crucial participants based on similar procedure as well as similar tools and
in the design of machine, tools, and work environment. To ensure equipment. If ANOVA shows no significant differences among ob-
validity and reliability of anthropometry data, the variability of servers' result, then it showed that inter-observer error has been
anthropometry data must be carefully considered since, as a matter minimized. To ensure reliable measurements and recording,
of fact, anthropometry data vary as it is influenced by various fac- random inspection was conducted by three senior researchers. The
tors. Among the influencing factors are ethnicity (for example see inspections was included calibration of the measurement tools and
Widyanti et al., 2015; Yap et al., 2001; Ball et al., 2010; Yokota, 2005; inspection of data recording to enable measurement accuracy until
Jahanshahi et al., 2008; Lin et al., 2004), gender and age (for 1 point decimal. The whole survey was completed in 3 months.
example see Hu et al., 2007; Jurgens et al. 1990; Huang and You, Seventeen anthropometry dimensions of Indonesian workers
1994; Iseri and Arslan, 2009; Jarosz, 1999; Pennatur and Dowling, were measured with eight dimensions measured in standing po-
2003; Wang et al., 2002; Kothiyal and Tettey, 2000) and occupa- sition and nine dimensions measured in sitting position. During
tion (Hsiao et al., 2002). This underlined the importance of measurement in standing position, participants were instructed to
anthropometry data that is specific for particular population. stand barefooted on a flat surface with their body erect while heels,
Whereas in many countries efforts have been made to establish buttocks and shoulders touched the wall. During measurement in
an anthropometric data base for different population groups, in sitting positions, participants were instructed to sit in the anthro-
Indonesia, anthropometry database is very limited due to many pometry chair with their torso vertically erected and their back
restrictions (e.g., cost and resource restrictions). Limited studies touched the backrest of the chair.
have been conducted in Indonesian anthropometric data, for The measurement was conducted using traditional anthropo-
example studies which reported Indonesian student anthropo- metric tools and equipment as they are quite simple, portable,
metric data (Widyanti et al., 2015; Chuan et al., 2010); anthropo- inexpensive, reliable, and accurate (Al-Ansari and Mokdad, 2009;
metric study of farm workers (Wibowo et al., 2012; Syuaib, 2015); Ghoddousi et al., 2007; Widyanti et al., 2015). Simple tools are
and anthropometry for Indonesian elderly population (Setiati et al., needed in this study since there should be a knowledge transfer
2010). from ITB to personnel of the Office of Indonesian Ministry of Health
The purpose of this study is to redesign workplaces at Indone- in West Java. Portability of tools are crucial since anthropometric
sian roof tile industries based on anthropometry approach. Since measurement in this study was conducted in different cities and in
there is a need of anthropometry data for specific population due to various scattered place depending on the location of the industries.
various factors that influence anthropometry data as described In addition, price was also a consideration since three-dimensional
above, anthropometric data of Indonesian workers is therefore scanner is expensive and not commonly used in a field study.
measured in this study. In addition, we also compare the anthro- A portable weighing scale was used to measure body weight.
pometry data of Indonesian workers with Indonesian students data Martin type anthropometer, a widely used anthropometric device
to learn the influence of occupation in anthropometry data. for measuring heights, breadths and depths between points on the
body and standard reference surfaces in a standing posture
(Kroemer and Grandjean, 2005) were used. Anthropometry chair
used in the data collection was a taylor made chair that can be
2. Method adjusted for sitting height and arm rest height measurements using
metric scale. Both Martin type anthropometer and anthropometric
2.1. Subjects chair used in this study can be seen in Fig. 4.
All the equipment used were calibrated against standards. In the
Six hundred and sixty nine Indonesian Sundanese workers beginning of data collection session, the subjects were informed of
(mean age ¼ 27.5 year, SD ¼ 12.3 year, 249 female) residing in West the purpose of the study, equipment, measurement procedure, and
Java, were participating voluntarily in this study. No other ethnic possible application of the data to be collected. Due to cultural and
was involved to avoid complication from anthropometric differ- religious reasons, male subjects were measured by male research
ences among different ethnics in Indonesia (Widyanti et al., 2015). assistants and female subjects were measured by female research
The workers were recruited from small groups of industries in West assistants.
Java (in Purwakarta Perfecture, Sukabumi Perfecture, and Sume-
dang Perfecture), as a part of a project, a cooperation between 2.3. Body dimensions
Indonesian Ministry of Health and the Laboratory for Work System
Design and Ergonomics of Bandung Institute of Technology, The eight anthropometry dimensions measured in standing
Indonesia. Participants were chosen based on convenience sam- position are stature, elbow height, waist height, hip height, knee
pling method. The sample reflected the Indonesian Sundanese height, lower arm length, forward grip reach, and vertical arm
worker composition by age and gender in West Java, based on data reach. Whereas the 9 anthropometry dimensions measured in
from the office of Ministry of Health in West Java. Permit has also sitting position are sitting eye height, sitting shoulder height,
been obtained from the owners of the home industries. sitting elbow height, backrest height, shoulder breadth biacromial,
302 I.Z. Sutalaksana, A. Widyanti / International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 53 (2016) 299e305
3. Results 5. Discussion
A separate descriptive statistics of anthropometry data for Redesign of workplace of Indonesian roof tile industries has
Indonesian workers according to gender can be seen in Table 1 for been proposed in this study and seventeen body measurements of
standing position and Table 2 for sitting position, respectively. Indonesian workers were summarized which consist of eight and
A comparison has been conducted by comparing anthropo- nine dimensions in standing and sitting position respectively. This
metric data of workers with available anthropometric data for anthropometry data is valuable for the designing of workstations,
Indonesia Sundanese students (n ¼ 157, Widyanti et al., 2015). The tools and protective equipment for Indonesian population, in
result can be seen in Table 3. particular for roof tile industries' workers.
Related with redesign of workplace in Indonesian roof tile in-
dustry, longitudinal study is needed in order to observe the
improvement in performance and system efficiency in the work-
4. Application of anthropometry approach in the design of place of roof tile industry after the redesign. However, from the
workplace in Indonesian roof tile industries preliminary study in the roof tile industry, the workers support the
redesign of the workplace due to uncomfort position during work
Considering the mismatch between design of tools and equip- and some negative symptoms they have suffer for years related
ment with the anthropometry of workers which eventually affect with work. The expected improvement after redesign of workplace
well-being, health, comfort, and safety of the worker in industries in Indonesian roof tile industry is in line with a study conducted by
in Indonesia, some efforts need to be performed. Below are ex- Anema et al. (2004), in which in their two years study they proved
amples of applying anthropometry in the redesign of three work- that the use of anthropometry in design system has reduce human
places in the roof industry mentioned earlier. error and hazard in workplace and improve system efficiency.
Table 1
Anthropometry data of Indonesian workers in standing position.
Table 2
Anthropometry data of Indonesian workers in sitting position.
Sitting eye height 70.38 5.89 60.68 76.72 65.93 3.24 61.00 71.15
Sitting shoulder height 54.67 3.53 48.30 60.50 53.97 32.70 46.20 57.00
Sitting elbow height 24.45 9.49 17.12 51.00 22.41 3.40 17.74 28.43
Backrest height 40.36 5.93 27.00 48.44 37.22 9.20 23.00 48.75
Shoulder breadth biacromial 17.93 3.62 13.00 26.00 18.47 17.09 14.00 20.40
Hip breadth 31.37 3.14 26.00 36.00 31.88 2.87 27.00 37.10
Popliteal height 40.74 2.20 37.18 44.00 38.97 2.49 36.00 42.50
Buttock popliteal 42.56 2.77 38.00 46.50 40.99 2.46 37.75 45.75
Buttock knee 51.95 3.19 45.80 56.62 49.00 3.24 44.00 54.00
Table 3
Anthropometric differences between Indonesian workers and students.
With regards to the influence of gender in anthropometry data, Differences between Indonesian workers and students' anthro-
results of this present study are in line with other anthropometric pometric data due to different occupation can be explained from
study in this case, there are differences between male and female different socio economics status as well. The student participants
data (see Chuan et al., 2010; Widyanti et al., 2015 for example). As have, in general, relatively high socio economics status, as in
expected, Indonesian male workers are in general bigger and taller Indonesia, less than 10% of Indonesian citizens could pursue their
than Indonesian female workers. With regards to the occupational study to university level due to financial reasons. Average income of
differences in Indonesian anthropometry data, a comparison with the parents of university students are higher than Rp. 5.000.000,-
Indonesian student anthropometry data (Widyanti et al., 2015) (US $ 450) per month (BPS, 2014). In contrast, workers participants
shows that for 16 of 17 dimensions (94% of all dimensions), male in this have in general, monthly income less than Rp. 1.000.000,-
students have larger dimensions than male workers. In the case of (US $ 100). Higher socioeconomic status implies higher income and
female workers, similar picture has been found also in 16 of 17 is associated with better education, better nutrition, better child
dimensions. In this study, we compare Indonesian workers and care, and better medical and social services (see Iseri and Arslan,
Indonesian students' anthropometry data, with comparable age 2009; Widyanti et al., 2015 for a review).
and ethnicity. Differences between Indonesian workers and stu- This present study has limitation in term of limited number of
dents' anthropometric data found here are primarily related with subjects and unbalanced number between male and female
occupational differences. Whereas student mostly involve in study participant, since convenience sampling was conducted in col-
activities, worker must perform heavy work such as lifting and lecting the data. Regarding the limited number of subjects, the
lowering heavy materials and face exposures in dangerous envi- statistical power of sample size is very high, since calculation of
ronment and awkward position such as squatting, all are hazards sample size using a ¼ 0.05 and confidence level 95% results in
with high risk of low back pain. Since the worker usually start to required sample size is less than number of data which has been
work in the beginning of their maturity, it is likely that the skeletal collected for all anthropometry dimensions measured. Another
development have been suppressed during their activities. Even- limitation is that participants of this study are limited to Sundanese
tually, it makes the anthropometry dimension shorter than it could ethnic living in West Java province. Based on Widyanti et al. (2015)
be. This is in line with a study conducted by Hsiao et al. (2002) who found that there are ethnic differences in Indonesian anthro-
which explained that one role of occupation in anthropometry pometry data, anthropometry of Indonesian workers from ethnics
data is related with job effect. For instance, mining children which other than Sundanese should be measured as well. Furthermore,
have long periods of exclusion from ultra-violet radiation have concerning the fact that the participants in this present study are
suppressed skeletal development, thus shorter than they could be. restricted to small home industries with low socio economic status,
304 I.Z. Sutalaksana, A. Widyanti / International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 53 (2016) 299e305
Fig. 6. The proposed dimension and design of the bench based on anthropometry criteria.
I.Z. Sutalaksana, A. Widyanti / International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 53 (2016) 299e305 305