Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Superior Scalability
of Single-Use Bioreactors
by Davy De Wilde, Thomas Dreher, Christian Zahnow, Ute Husemann,
Gerhard Greller, Thorsten Adams, and Christel Fenge
D
uring the past several years, Scale-up is an important and production processes (6). Typical
single-use bioreactors have potentially time-consuming step in the parameters of concern are oxygen
been gradually established in development of industrial processes. It transfer, mixing, and heat-transfer
modern biopharmaceutical involves much more than just doing characteristics as well as the generated
processes (1, 2). This adoption is the same at a larger volume. It requires shear forces.
directly linked to their unique ability the generation of solid process During the past 30 years,
to enhance flexibility and reduce understanding at different scales to stainless‑steel stirred-tank bioreactors
investment and operational costs. ensure consistent quality and titer have evolved as the gold standard,
Furthermore, production output can throughout scale-up from early clinical especially as a result of their
be increased, and time to market is trials to final production scale (6). straightforward scale-up. Multiple
shortened (3). Today a wide variety of Today, many companies use times, their well‑understood design
single-use bioreactors exists for the chemometric tools such as design of principles have proven successful in
cultivation of mammalian and insect experiments and multivariate data development and scale-up to safe and
cells (4), whereas only limited solutions analysis to establish critical process robust commercial processes.
are available for microbial cultures (5). parameter ranges that define the Furthermore, they enable users to
Typically, processes are established design space of a robust production implement their existing knowledge
and optimized in stirred-tank process. Especially during late-phase — especially with platform processes
benchtop bioreactor systems. One development of a commercial process, — into production processes of new
challenge during the development of a the availability of a properly drugs and to set-up experiments in a
robust cell culture process is the representative scale-down model of way that can shorten development
straightforward scale-up to final full production scale is essential to timelines.
production scale. This is especially allow efficient process development (7). However, many commercially
critical when using less-characterized Detailed understanding of available single-use bioreactors differ
bioreactor designs that deviate from bioreactor characteristics at different from this gold standard. Vessel design,
the well-known and understood scales significantly facilitates the stirrer design, and gassing strategy
classical stirred-tank principle. development and scale-up of robust especially may differ from the classical
Figure 1: ambr250, UniVessel SU, and BIOSTAT STR family; working volume ranges from 250 mL to 2000 L
ambr250 UniVessel STR 50L STR 200L STR 500L STR 1000L STR 2000L
SU 2L
Supplement, Preprint 12(8)s BioProcess International 1
Table 1: Summary of geometrical dimensions of the AMBR250, UniVessel SU, and BIOSTAT STR family
AMBR UniVessel SU BIOSTAT STR
0.25 2 50 200 500 1000 2000
Total volume (L) 0.36 3 68 280 700 1,300 2,800
Maximum working volume (L) 0.25 2 50 200 500 1,000 2,000
Minimum Working volume (L) 0.06 1 12.5 50 125 250 500
Vessel diameter D (min) 62.5 130 370 585 815 997 1,295
Vessel height H (mm) 126 240 666 1,055 1,467 1,800 2,330
Ratio H/D 2 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.8
Liquid height h1 (mm) 90 177 480 783 1,005 1,360 1,670
Ratio h1/D 1.44 1.36 1.3 1.34 1.23 1.36 1.29
Impeller diameter d2 (mm) 26 54 143 225 310 379 492
Ratio d2/D 0.42 0.42 0.38 0.38 0.38 0.38 0.38
Distance between impellers Δz (mm) 30 70 186 300 403 493 640
Size holes ring sparger part (mm) 2 0.5 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
Number holes ring sparger part 1 14 5 25 100 100 200
Size holes micro sparger part (μm) NA NA 150 150 150 150 150
Number holes micro sparger part NA NA 25 100 500 500 1,000
Table 2: Comparison of process engineering parameters suitable for scale-up from the BIOSTAT commonly considered important for
STR 50 to the BIOSTAT STR 2000; for scale-up, a CHO process performed at 50 L scale was assumed,
which was performed at 150 rpm equivalent to a tip speed of 1.1 m/s, a commonly used tip speed
simple and straightforward scale-up of
for cell culture applications a process (10). This is especially
critical as design changes across scales
Process Engineering Parameter N (rpm) Tip Speed (m/s) Re P/VL (W/m3)
might influence mixing behavior,
BIOSTAT STR 50 150 1.1 49,420 22.3
oxygen transfer, bubble dispersion,
Equal N for BIOSTAT STR 2000 150 3.9 605,406 293.1
and various other key parameters. On
Equal tip speed for BIOSTAT STR 2000 42 1.1 171,936 6.7
the other hand, a homogenous culture
Equal Re for BIOSTAT STR 2000 12 0.31 49,420 0.15
environment across scales — where
Equal P/VL for BIOSTAT STR 2000 63 1.6 254,270 22.3
important cultivation parameters such
as pH, oxygen partial pressure,
Figure 2: Combisparger for the BIOSTAT STR scale and beyond to facilitate process temperature, and nutrient supply are
2000L system
transfers to existing legacy production well controlled — is a key prerequisite
facilities. to establish a robust and safe
Ring Sparger Here we detail the different design production process. To characterize
aspects of those bioreactors and their bioreactor performance across scales
Micro sparger
impact on critical process engineering and govern scale-up, an appropriate
parameters such as power input per criterion should be defined and kept
volume, mixing time, and volumetric constant during scale-up. In general,
mass transfer (9). We compare the the power input per volume is used as
characteristics of the large scale scale-up criterion (10). Also, the tip
single-use bioreactor family speed or other shear-related
BIOSTAT STR to small‑scale single- parameters are often used, especially
stirred-tank design principles and do use bioreactor vessels such as the when using shear‑sensitive cells (11) or
not necessarily offer consistency and AMBR250 (250 mL) and the when growing cells on microcarriers.
geometrical similarity across scales (8). single‑use UniVessel SU 2L, which Based on the very well-
So the scale-up exercise might be are typically used during process characterized, reusable, stirred‑tank
complicated, and additional risk might development, optimization, and bioreactors, it is possible to assign
be added to the process transfer. characterization. relevant design criteria to single-use
To offer a solution for that, bioreactors for animal and microbial
Sartorius Stedim Biotech has Design Principles and cells. One such criterion is the height-
developed a range of single-use Suitable Scale-Up Criteria to-vessel-diameter ratio (H/D or
bioreactors from 250 mL to 2,000 L of Stirred ‑Tank Bioreactors aspect ratio), which should be kept
working volume. Its designs are Geometrical similarity of vessel design within a range of 1:1 to 3:1 for
entirely based on proven stirred‑tank (amongst others defined by the height- stirred‑tank reactors (10). A low value
bioreactor principles. This ensures to-diameter ratio and the for an H/D ratio results in an
straightforward scale-up to 2,000 L impeller-to-vessel-diameter ratio) is increased ratio of headspace surface to
BIOSTAT STR 50
rigid, central shaft. For agitation,
BIOSTAT STR 200
30 2 × 3-blade-segment impellers are
BIOSTAT STR 500 available. For the BIOSTAT STR, a
20 BIOSTAT STR 1000 combination of a six-blade-disk
BIOSTAT STR 2000 (bottom) and three-blade-segment
10 (top) impeller can be installed as an
alternative.
0
The study presented here focuses on
0.5 0.7 0.9 1.1 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.9 process engineering characterization of
Tip Speed (m/s) a configuration based on 2 × 3-blade-
segment impellers for different single-
use bioreactor volumes. Gas transfer
has developed a special microsparger For efficient, cost-conscious process has been characterized for a
design with 150 µm holes that development, highly automated, microsparger (hole diameter = 150 µm)
provides a uniform bubble swarm of single-use multiparallel bioreactors are or a ringsparger (hole diameter =
small bubbles for effective gas transfer. available at 250 mL scale (AMBR250) 0.5 mm for the Univessel SU or 0.8
Spargers with large holes have a (20). This high-throughput process mm for the BIOSTAT STR)
relatively low oxygen transfer but offer development bioreactor system allows positioned below the lower impeller.
improved performance for CO2 fast and effective establishment of The BIOSTAT STR is available with a
stripping because bigger bubbles optimal process conditions early in combisparger (Figure 2) — consisting
typically rise to the gas–liquid process development. With the of both a microsparger (0.15 mm holes)
interface and carry excessive CO2 classical stirred-tank design, and a ringsparger (0.8 mm holes). The
from the cell suspension to the straightforward scale-up is possible microsparger supports high oxygen
headspace. either directly for production of transfer, and the ringsparger enhances
At small-scale, CO2 stripping is material for toxicological studies or CO2 stripping. All single-use
less of a challenge. It is more critical through step-wise scale-up through bioreactors from 250 mL scale to
at larger volumes because of the higher 2 L scale using the UniVessel SU 2,000 L are equipped with
hydrostatic pressure and thus technology and 50 L scale using the precalibrated, single-use optochemical
improved solubility of CO2. Together BIOSTAT STR. With the UniVessel probes for pH and pO2 measurement.
with excessive foaming, that limits the SU 2 L model, conventional glass Alternatively, conventional probes can
efficiency of conventional 10 to 20 µm vessels can be replaced easily even be introduced if desired for scales ≥2 L.
microspargers for large bioreactor with already existing bioreactor All single-use bioreactors are available
volumes. controllers in development with standard digital control units.
laboratories. The UniVessel SU design
Sartorius Stedim Biotech is similar to its glass counterpart and Process Engineering
Single-Use Bioreactors Emulate the large-scale single-use BIOSTAT Characterization
Classical Stirred-Tank Design STR design, thereby enabling We performed in-house process
Most large-scale, single-use straightforward scale-up all the way engineering characterization of the
bioreactors do not rely on established from development to commercial UniVessel SU and BIOSTAT STR
design criteria of reusable bioreactors, production and offering a single-use bioreactors. For the AMBR250
which can add risk to scaling-up scale-down model for process system, we used data published by
processes. To overcome this, Sartorius characterization. Bareither et al. (20). The process
Stedim Biotech offers a range of The BIOSTAT STR has a engineering characterization of the
stirred single-use bioreactors (Figure cylindrical shape with an H/D ratio of UniVessel SU and BIOSTAT STR
1) based on classical, well-proven 2:1 and a semi-torispherical bottom family was performed at parameters
design principles. Different scales and top. The impeller-to-bag- typical for mammalian cell culture (tip
exist, allowing to work from 250 mL diameter-ratio is 0.38 with a distance speeds between 0.6–1.8 m/s). For the
to 2,000 L culture volumes. between both impellers of 1.3× the characterization of the AMBR250
30
BIOSTAT STR 200 micro (0.15 mm)
tip speed of 0.6 m/s and 8 s at a tip
BIOSTAT STR 500 micro (0.15 mm)
speed of 1.8 m/s. For 2,000 L scale,
20 BIOSTAT STR 1000 micro (0.15 mm)
mixing times of 20 s can be obtained.
BIOSTAT STR 2000 micro (0.15 mm)
Overall, it is possible to ensure mixing
10 times <30 s for all scales, from 2 L to
2,000 L, thus demonstrating the
superior performance of the UniVessel
0 SU and BIOSTAT STR family for
0.5 0.7 0.9 1.1 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.9 mammalian cell culture (9).
Tip Speed (m/s)
For the quantification of the
oxygen-transfer rate, we determined
the volumetric mass transfer coefficient
Bareither et al. used tip speeds number was determined by torque (kLa) using the gassing out method (21).
ranging from 0.27 m/s to 1.02 m/s, measurements (8). For 2 × 3-blade For most common cell cultures, kLa
which resulted in corresponding stirrer segment impellers, we calculated a Ne values of 5–10 h–1 are required. Figure
speeds from 200 to 800 rpm (20). of ~1.3. The fact that the Reynolds 6 shows the kLa characteristics for
Figure 3 graphs stirrer speed as a number (Re) is above 10,000 at the different tip speeds and scales of the
function of tip speed for the UniVessel chosen tip-speed range implies that BIOSTAT STR and UniVessel SU
SU and BIOSTAT STR systems. The turbulent flow conditions are present, bioreactors. Both ring and microsparger
increasing impeller diameters requires thus the Ne value is constant. elements were used for the BIOSTAT
lower stirrer speeds at increasing scale The power input per volume (P/V L ) STR system and a ringsparger for the
to maintain the same tip speed. is an important process engineering UniVessel SU and AMBR studies.
During in-house trials for the parameter and can be calculated based The kLa-values increase with
BIOSTAT STR and UniVessel SU on the experimentally determined increasing tip speed at any given scale
bioreactors, the Newton number (Ne) Newton number. Figure 4 shows the and configuration. As expected, the
was determined to characterize the power input per volume for the kLa values increase also with the scale.
different impeller types and BIOSTAT STR and the UniVessel That can be explained by the increased
configurations and to quantify the SU bioreactors. For the AMBR liquid height and the longer residence
power input per volume. The Newton system, Bareither et al. (20) reports a time of the gas bubbles in the liquid —