MONSOON SEMESTER’ 19 CASE LIST

Legal Intention
1. Balfour vs Balfour
2. Errington vs Wood
3. Jones vs Padavatton
4. Merritt vs Merritt
5. Snelling vs John G Snelling
6. Parker vs Clark
7. Simpkins vs Pays
8. Coward vs Motor Insurance Bureau
9. Rose & Frank Co. vs J.R.Crompton & Bros.
10. Baird Textiles Holdings vs Marks & Spencers

Offer and Invitation

11. Carlil vs Carbolic Smoke Ball Factory
12. Queen’s defendant v Demer’s
13. Morris Lefkowitz vs Great Minneapolis Surplus Store
14. Ankit Sharma vs Punjab Technical University, Jalandhar
15. Madhya Pradesh State Road Tranportation vs Manoj Kumar

16. Ghaziabad Development Authority v UOI

Acceptance & Communication

17. Felthouse vs Bindley
18. Butler Machine Tool Co. Ltd. vs Ex-Cell-O Corporation [England] Ltd
19. Trimex International vs Vedanta Aluminium Ltd.
20. Bhagwandas Kedia vs Girdharilal
21. Hollwell Securities vs Thomas Hughes
22. Jawahar Lal Burman vs Union of India
23. Union of India & Ors. vs M/s Bhim Sen Walaiti Ram
24. D. Wren International v. Engineers India Ltd.
25. M/s Rickmers Verwaltung vs Indian Oil CoHigh Trerp. Ltd.
26. M.R. Engineers vs Som Dutt Builders
27. P.R Transport Agency v. Union of India
28. Entores v Miles
29. Ramji Dayawala and Sons v. Invest Import

Implied Terms
30. B.P. Refinery vs The President Councillors & Ratepayers of the Shire of
Hastings
31. The Moorcock Case
32. NHAI v. Gwalior Jhansi Expressway
Consideration ( sec 23-25)
33. McArdle vs McArdle
34. Chapell vs Nestle (Court of Appeal and House of Lords)
35. Lampleigh vs Braithwaite
36. L.E. Godfrey vs Parbati Paluni
37. Esso Petroleum Ltd. vs Income Tax Commissioners
38. Samuel Pillai vs Ananthanatha Pillai
39. District Board of Ramnad v. D k Mahomed Ibrahim Sahib
40. Combe vs Combe (King’s Bench Division and Court of Appeal)
41. P. Balamba v. K Krishnayya

Privity of Contract
42. Dunlop Pneumatic Tyres vs Selfridge
43. Essar Oil v. Hindustan Shipyard
44. M.C.Chacko vs State Bank of Travancore, Trivandrum

Promissory Estoppel
45. Central London Property Trust vs High Trees House
46. Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills vs State of Uttar Pradesh
47. Hughes vs Metropolitan Railways
48. Manuelsons Hotels v State of Kerala

Capacity to Contract ( sec 11-12)

MINOR
49. Leslie vs Shell
50. Mohori Bibi vs Dharmodas Ghose
51. Mathai Mathai v. Joseph Mary
52. Manik Chand v. Ramachandra
53. Dadasaheb Dasrathrao v. Bai Nahani
54. Proform Sports Management vs Proactive Sports Management
INSANITY
55. Monosseh Jacob Monosseh vs Shapurji Hormusji Harver
56. Imperial loan Co. vs Stone
57. Nilima Ghosh vs Harjeet Kaur & Ors.
58. S.Basavaraj vs V.N. Adilakshmamma
59. Charanjit Singh vs Chattaranjan Pal & Others
60. Chacko v. Mahadevan
61. Dunhill v. Burgin

Coercion (sec 15)

62. Chief Engineer General vs Sai Suraj Construction
63. Bansraj Das vs Secretary of State
64. P. Rengaswami Pillai vs Srirangam Municipal Council
Economic Duress
65. CTN Cash and Carry v Gallaher
66. Sara International v Rizhao Steel Holding Group

Undue Influence ( sec 16)

67. Sita Devi vs Prithi Chand & Ors.
68. Poosathurai v Kannapa Chettiar
69. Mohanlal v. Kashiram
70. Lingo Bhimrao Naik vs Dattatraya Shripad Jamadagni
71. Subhash Chandra Das Mushib vs Ganga Prasad Das Mushib
72. Ladli Prasad Jaiswal v Karnal Distillery Company
73. Parbhu v Puttu and Others
74. Royal Bank of Scotland v Etridge
75. Dai-chi Karkaria vs ONGC (Economic Duress)
Standard form of Contract
76. Central Inland Water Transport Corp. vs Brojo Nath Ganguly (unconscionable
bargain)
77. M/s Interglobe Aviation Ltd v N. Satchidanand

Fraud ( sec 17)

78. Barclays Bank v O’Brien
79. Laidlaw vs Organ
80. R.C. Thakkar vs Bombay Housing Board
81. Sorabshah Pestonji vs The Secretary Of State For India
82. Bhaurao Dagdu Paralkar vs State Of Maharashtra
83. David Birkett v Acorn Business Machines
84. Trojan & Co. Ltd vs Rm. N. N. Nagappa Chettiar

Misrepresentation ( sec 18)

85. Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Mardon .
86. With vs O’Flanagan
87. Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd
88. Derry v Peeke

Mistake ( sec 20)

89. Smith v Hughes
90. Bell v Lever Brothers Ltd
91. Chwee Kin Keong vs Digilandmall(snapping up)
92. Shogun Finance vs Hudson
93. Raffles v Wichelhaus
94. Dhulipudi Namayya v Union of India
95. Kalyanpur Lime Works Ltd vs State Of Bihar

Non-est Factum
96. Saunders v Anglia Building Society
97. Gallie v Lee .
98. Prem Singh v Birbal

Consent ( sec 13)

99. Tarsem Singh v Sukhminder Singh

Public Policy- Unlawful Consideration and Object (sec 24 )

100. Taylor vs Chester
101. Sundara Gownder v Balachandran.
102. Teegula Babiah v Mohammad Abdus Subhan Khan
103. Surasaibalini Debi vs Phanindra Mohan Majumdar

Agreements in Restraint of Trade (sec 27)

104. Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v Coca Cola
105. Percept D’ Mark v Zaheer Khan
106. Superintendence Company of India v Shri Krishan Murugai
107. Association of Medical Super Speciality Aspirants and Residents & Ors. v
Union of India and Ors.

Agreements in restraint of legal proceedings (sec 28 )

108. Manohar Singh And Sons v Raksha Karamchari Coop. GR. H. SOC. And
another
109. National Insurance Company Limited v Sujir Ganesh Nayak and Company
and Anr

Uncertainty (sec 29 )
110. Pawan Kumar Dutt v Shakuntala Devi
111. Hillas v Arcos

Wagering Agreements ( sec 30 )

112. Gherulal Parekh v Mahadeodas
113. Subhash Kumar Manwani v State of MP

Contingent Contracts (sec 31-36)

114. HPA International v Bhagwandas Fateh Chand Daswani and Others
115. Gian Chand v Gopala and Others
116. Smt. Deokabai v Uttam
117. Energy Watchdog v Central Electricity Regulatory Commission
118. Om Builders v Anil Chinubhai Kilachand
119. Steel Authority of India v Tycoon Traders
120. Dhanrajamal Gobindram vs Shamji Kalidas And Co.

Performance (Section 37-67)

121. Jagannath Patnaik v Sri Pitambar Bhupati Harichandan Mohapatra (Personal
Contracts)
122. I. K. Sohan Singh v State Bank of India(S.46)
123. Mukanchand Rajaram Balia v Nihalchand Gurrmikhrai (s.47)
124. Mohammed v Pushpalatha (S.51)
125. Bolton v Mahadeva (Substantial Performance)
126. Cutter v Powell (Substantial Performance)
127. Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Substantial Performance)
128. Benode Behari Das Gupta v Benoy Bhusan Choudhury (S.51 Reciprocal
Promises)
129. Nathulal v Phoolchand (Reciprocal promises)
130. State of Orissa v Harekrishna Mahatab and Others
131. Chanakya and Company and Others v Kay Aar Decobuild Pvt Ltd
132. Pannalal Jankidas v Mohanlal and Anr.

Time as (or not as) an essence of the contract ( sec 46)

133. The Food Corporation of India v M/s. Anupama Warehousing
Establishment
134. Nevilal Rohita Construction Private Limited and Another v State of Bihar
and Others
135. Saradamani Kandappan and another v S. Rajalakshmi and another
136. KS Vidyanadam v Vairavan

Refusal to accept performance (Section 38)

137. Startup v Macdonald
138. Balwan Singh Raghav v. Dalip Kumar
139. Ismail Bhai Rahim and Others v Adam Osman and Others
140. P. L. S A. R. S. Arunachallam Chettiar v Krishna Ayyar and Others
141. Guna Krishna Gauns and Another v Antonio Joao Braganza And Antush
Braganza and Others
142. Barber Maran and Another v Ramana Goundan and Another (Joint
CREDITORS)

Frustration
143. Ms. Gwalior Rayon Silk Manufacturing (Wvg.) Company Limited v Shri
Andavar and Company
144. Naihati Jute Mills v. Khyaliram Jagannath
145. Mugneeram Bangur and Co. v Sardar Gurbachan Singh
146. Satyabrata Ghose v Mugneeram Bangur

Apportionment of Payments (Section 59 to 61)

147. Cory Brothers and Company Ltd. V Owners of the Turkish Steamship
148. Clayton’s Case ( Devaynes and ors v Noble and ors.)
149. Ouseph Lukka v Ananthanarayana Iyer Ramakrishna Iyer
150. ICDS Ltd. V Smithaben H Patel and Others

Decretal case
151. Chaganlal Shrilal v Gopilal Choturam

Novation, Alteration and Rescission of Contract

152. UOI V Kishorilal Gupta (Arbitration Clause)
153. Rankanidhi Sahu v Nandkishore Sahu a
154. Pachkodi Gulab v Krishnaji (Material Alteration) a
155. Murlidhar Chatterjee v International Film Company
156. Chunnamal Ram Nath v Moolchand Ram Bhagat r
157. M/s Young Achievers v IMS Learning Resources Pvt. Ltd. (Arbitration
Clause) n
158. Mulheim Pipecoatings Gmbh v Welspun Fintrade Ltd and Another (Also,
doctrine of separability)
159. Heyman v Darwins
160. Lata Construction and Others v Dr Rameshchandra Ramniklal Shah
161. K.M.P.R.N.M. Firm Merchants vs P. Theperumal Chetty A Merchant
162. Payana Reena Layana Chetty v Pana Lana Pana Lana Palaniappa Chetty
163. Nathu Lal v Mussamat Gomti Kaur(Material Alteration)
164. State of Bihar v Ram Ballabh Das Jalan and Another
ACCORD AND SATISFACTION
165. Morris v Baron
166. New Standard Bank Ltd. V Probodh Chandra Chakravarty
ASSIGNMENT
167. Khardah Company v Raymon & Co

Recession (S.63)
168. MS Shoes East Ltd. V Munak Chemicals Ltd
169. All India Power Engineer v Sasan Power Ltd.
170. Jagad Bandhu Chatterjee v Nilima Rani and Others

Restitution (Section 65)

171. Kuju Colleries v Jharkhand Mines Ltd
172. M/s Alopi Prashad v UOI (Quantum Meruit)
173. Puran Lal Shah v Sate of UP (Quantum Meruit)
174. Harnath Kaur v Inder Bahadur Singh
175. Uttamchand v Mohandas

Unjust enrichment [Section 68-72]

176. Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd. And Another
Section 68
177. Nash v Inman
178. P.E.R.M Annamalai Chetty v Satyavadivel Muthuswami
Section 69
179. Govindram Gordhandas Seksaria v The State of Gondal
180. Musammat Munni Bibi alias Ambika v Trilokinath
181. Boja Sellappa Reddy v Vridhachala Reddy
182. Mothooranath Chuttopadhyaya v Kristokumar Ghose
Section 70
183. Mulamchand v State of Madhya Pradesh
184. UOI v Sitaram Jaiswal
185. Sri Sri Gajapati Kistna v P Srinivasa Charlu
186. State of WB v BK Mondal and sons
187. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd vs Tata Communication Ltd
Section 72
188. Mahabir Kishore and Others v State of MP
189. Sales Tax Officer v Kanhaiya Lal
190. Sri Shiba Prasad Singh v Maharaja Srish Chandra Nandi
191. Mafatlal Industries v. Union of India

Damages [Section 73]

192. Hadley v Baxendale
193. Victoria Laundry v Newman Industries
194. Murlidhar v Harishchandra
195. Lachia Shetty v Coffee Board
196. Jarvis v Swans Tours Ltd
197. Melachrino v Nickoll
198. Millett v Van Heek & Co.
199. Dunlop v Lambert
200. Funnell v Aadams & Remer
201. Frederick Thomas Kingsley v Secretary of State India
202. Quinn v Burch Bros Ltd
203. Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd
204. VL Narasu v PSV Iyer and Others
205. Maharasthra State Electricity Distribution Company Ltd v. Datar Switchgear

Section 74
206. Fateh Chand v Balkishan Das
207. Maula Bux v UOI
208. M/s Kailash Nath Associates v Delhi Development Authority and Another
209. Steel Authority of India Ltd v Gupta Brother Steel Tubes Ltd
210. ONGC v Saw Pipes
211. V Venkataramaiah Pillai and Another v PV Subramania Pillai
212. Anand Construction Works v State of Bihar
Anticipatory Breach & Mitigation
213. Ramgopal v Dhanji Jadhavji Bhatia
214. Albert Hochster v Edgar Frederick de la tour
215. White and Carter v McGregor