Sei sulla pagina 1di 74

AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 1

TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN


ENGLISH SUBJECT

CHAPTER 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction

Teaching and learning are the two sides of a coin. The most accepted decisive

factor for measuring good teaching is the amount of student learning outcomes.

Students in their point of view, rate their teachers higher when they learned well.

A teacher’s effectiveness is again about student learning.

The 4 macro skills in teaching English such as listening , reading, speaking, and

writing has many ways that teachers can present or make possible techniques to enhance

students learning.

Students can sense if the method selected by their teacher was the best and

effective teaching method or just “a method” or simply the method with which the

teacher was most comfortable.

Research indicates that students are the most qualified sources to report on the

extent to which the learning experience was productive, informative, satisfying, or

worthwhile. While opinions on these matters are not direct measures of instructor or
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 2
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

course effectiveness, they are legitimate indicators of student satisfaction, and there is

substantial research linking student satisfaction to effective teaching.

Research on student evaluation of teaching generally concludes that student

ratings tend to be reliable, valid, relatively unbiased and useful (Murray, 1994).

Over the years students’ evaluation of the teaching methods and techniques used

by their teachers are used to contribute for the development and improvement of the latter

teaching skills.

Today, student ratings of instruction are widely used for the purpose of making

personnel decisions and faculty development recommendations. For administrators, the

information derived from ratings aids them in making both summative and formative

judgments dealing with faculty retention, tenure, and promotion, hiring, selecting faculty

for teaching awards and honors, and in assigning teachers to courses.

It is suggestively that the school administrations must use the data formatively to

develop and improve their teachers’ teaching effectiveness.

Centra (1993), defines effective teaching as “that which produces beneficial and

purposeful student learning through the use of appropriate procedures.” Students learning

outcomes depends on the teachers’ effectiveness in teaching. The effectiveness of the

teachers teaching depends on his or her methods and techniques. If his or her methods

and techniques is not suitable and hasn’t given a good impact to the students, teaching

will be worthless as well as learning will be illogical.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 3
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Students are both rational and reliable sources of evidence, while in class;

students are exposed to all sorts of instructional experiences (lectures, instructional

materials and aids, readings, exams). They are in effect experimental consumers—able to

discern quality, relevance, usefulness, and instructor interaction with students.

Students are certainly qualified to express their satisfaction or dissatisfaction with

the experience. They have a right to express their opinions in any case, and no one else

can report the extent to which the experience was useful, productive, informative,

satisfying, or worthwhile.

Through evaluations students are given a chance to examine and appeal whether

the teaching is unproductive which will help to make a good recommendations or

suggestions to the improvement of the teaching methods and techniques of the teachers

for the betterment.

Background of the Study

Methods are processes by which a task is completed or ways of doing something.

Techniques are systematic procedures, formulas, or routines by which a task is

accomplished. Typically, these keywords are used by teachers to teach effectively.

Methods and techniques serve as set of procedures in doing the task of teaching.

The idea of using methods in teaching is not new; these enable to determine the

different knowledge level of a learner. However, the idea of using techniques in teaching

helps the students to develop their skills, feel comfortable in social situations, and be

aware of socially accepted behavior.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 4
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

In this paper, we focus on the analysis of the effectiveness of methods and

techniques in teaching the four macro skills in English subject. In virtually every country,

English is an essential part of business, research, commerce, technology, politics, news

and many other fields in which the exchange of ideas is essential. As a result, methods

and techniques in teaching are potentially of great value to students and teachers in an

English class.

Theoretical Framework

This study is based on the teaching strategies of Multiple Intelligence theory

which opens the door to a wide range of teaching strategies that can be easily

implemented in the classroom. In many cases, they are strategies that have been used for

decades by good teachers. In other cases, the theory of multiple intelligences offers

teachers an opportunity to develop innovative teaching strategies that are relatively new

to the educational scene. Multiple Intelligence theory suggests that no one set of teaching

strategies will work best for all students at all times.

All children have different proclivities in the eight intelligences, so any particular

strategy is likely to be highly successful with one group of students and less successful

with other groups.

This study also is based on the theory of constructivism which focuses the type of

its learning and its impact to teaching methods. Constructivism is a learning theory found

in psychology which explains how people might acquire knowledge and learn. It
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 5
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

therefore has direct application to education. The theory suggests that humans construct

knowledge and meaning from their experiences. Constructivism is not a specific

pedagogy. Piaget's theory of Constructivist learning has had wide ranging impact on

learning theories and teaching methods in education and is an underlying theme of many

education reform movements. Research support for constructivist teaching techniques has

been mixed, with some research supporting these techniques and other research

contradicting those results. It is the theory of development that will be the focus here

because it is the major foundation for cognitive constructivist approaches to teaching and

learning. One important generalization of Piagetian theory is role of the teacher. In a

Piagetian classroom an important teacher role is to provide a rich environment for the

spontaneous exploration of the child. A classroom filled with interesting things to explore

encourages students to become active constructors of their own knowledge (their own

schemas) through experiences that encourage assimilation and accommodation.

There are two key Piagetian principles for teaching and learning:

Learning is an active process: Direct experience, making errors, and looking for

solutions are vital for the assimilation and accommodation of information. How

information is presented is important. When information is introduced as an aid to

problem solving, it functions as a tool rather than an isolated arbitrary fact.

Learning should be whole, authentic, and "real": Piaget helps us to understand

that meaning is constructed as children interact in meaningful ways with the world

around them. Thus, that means less emphasis on isolated "skill" exercises that try to teach
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 6
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

something like long division or end of sentence punctuation. Students still learn these

things in Piagetian classrooms, but they are more likely to learn them if they are engaged

in meaningful activities (such as operating a class "store" or "bank" or writing and editing

a class newspaper). Whole activities, as opposed to isolated skill exercises, authentic

activities which are inherently interesting and meaningful to the student, and real

activities that result in something other than a grade on a test or a "Great, you did well"

from the computer lesson software, are emphasized in Piagetian classrooms.

Within the field of educational computing, the best-known cognitive

constructivist theoretician is Papert (1993), who characterizes behavioural approaches as

"clean" teaching whereas Constructivist approaches are "dirty" teaching. The contrast

emphasizes the differences between approaches that isolate and break down knowledge

to be learned (clean) versus approaches that are holistic and authentic (dirty).

Papert's idea of clean and dirty learning gives us a somewhat fuzzy feel for the

differences between behavioral and constructivist visions for teaching and learning.

Copley's (1992) contrast of the two approaches to instruction -- didactic (behavioral) and

constructivist -- provides a bit more detail. Constructivist approaches to technology in the

classroom are not yet commonplace. However, a number of promising approaches exist

within this theoretical framework.

Conceptual Framework
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 7
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

The variables to be tested in this study are the teaching methods and techniques

used in teaching the four macro skills in the English subject namely: a) Project Method;

b) Demonstration Method; c) Lecture Method; d) Question and Answer Method; and e)

Reporting Method.

To test these variables, the researchers will use survey questionnaire and personal

interview to the respondents in order to come up with the desired results in making

outputs.

After processing the variables, the researchers come up with several proposals

suggested by the results to make changes in effective teaching in teaching the four macro

skills in the English subject.

The researchers had constructed the following figure to represent the analysis

among the variables used in the current study.

Teaching Methods
and Techniques
-Project Method -Questionnaire Propose additional
new methods and
-Demonstration -Personal Interview techniques in
Method teaching English
-Lecture Method subject.
-Question and
Answer Method
-Reporting Method
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 8
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Statement of the Problem

The purpose of this study is to analyze the teaching methodology of secondary

high school teachers teaching English subject in Taguig Science National High School

during the year 2013-2014.

Specifically, it will answer the following questions:

1. What is the profile of the student respondents in terms of the following variables?

a) Age

b) gender

c) section

2. How do the respondents perceive on the effectiveness of methods and techniques

used in teaching English subject areas as:

a) Listening

b) Speaking

c) Reading

d) Writing

3. Is there a difference between the perception of the students on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of their class

section?
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 9
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

4. What is the Implication of the findings to the methods and techniques used in

teaching four macro skills in English subject?

Hypothesis

There is no significant difference between the perception of the students on the

effectiveness of methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of

their class section.

Significance of the Study

Students. They can benefit from this study in a way that they will know what

methods and techniques should be expected in learning a specific skill in English subject.

Furthermore, the students individually will realize the efforts of their teachers in teaching

them effectively.

Teachers. They will be inspired to make their teaching methods and techniques

effective and conducive to learning. Moreover, the teachers as individuals would do their

best for the sake of their job as a mentor for learning.

Citizens/Curriculum Makers. They will be benefited for being good organizer

of the learning process for the teachers and students. In addition, they would likely

become a good worker through enhancing or developing the curriculum for good

education.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 10
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

School Administrators. They will be more knowledge-able regarding the aim of

the school to familiarize the students with the important techniques and methods of the

four macro skills.

Scope and Limitations

The research will include the way of how the four macro skills in English subject

are taught and its effectiveness. It is focused on the teaching methodologies and

techniques on the four areas, namely: a.) Listening, b.) Speaking, c.) Reading and d.)

Writing used by the high school teachers in Taguig Science National High School as a

subject for the research.

The survey is conducted in Taguig Science National High School with the total

population of 207 students’ Fourth year High School.

The research includes the perceptions of the students with regard to the

effectiveness of methods/techniques which the teachers use in teaching four macro skills

in English subject. The perceptions were worthwhile used in analyzing the effectiveness

of methods and techniques used in Taguig Science National High School during the

school year 2013-2014.

The research does not cover any other subjects that do not use methods and

techniques in teaching four macro skills in English subject. This research was limited to

Taguig Science National High School in Taguig. The findings may or may not apply to

other subjects and schools.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 11
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Also, this research was limited to the perceptions of currently enrolled fourth year

high school students at Taguig Science National High School. It is limited to the

researchers’ semi-structured questionnaire format, to the answers provided by

respondents.

Definition of Terms

The following Terms used in the study are hereby defined in their operational

meanings.

 Effectiveness- it is a quality of being equipped and prepared for action.

 Evaluation- It is the analyzing or assessing thing through following standards.

 Learning- It is the acquisition of knowledge and skills through experience or

study or by being taught.

 Listening- A skill which process the receiving, constructing of meaning form,

and responding to spoken or nonverbal language.

 Methods- It is systematic procedure for accomplishing a given task.

 Reading- a skill in which decoding symbols in form of oral.

 Speaking- a skill which is use in communicating verbally.

 Teaching- sharing knowledge and educating others usually made by teachers.

 Technique- it is a way of carrying out particular task. The execution of given

work.

 Writing- a skill or the ability to express ideas and thought in written language.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 12
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

CHAPTER 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

This chapter reviews the existing literature and research studies here in local and

in foreign countries that were of interest and value to the researchers, especially those

that are about teachers task, professional or educational background, experiences and the

like that contribute to the conceptualization of this research. This guided the researchers

to gain insights to view the problem in proper prospect.

Related Literature

We live here on earth to experience life and the love God give to us. In everyday

of our life we experience to be in a particular situation. Through those experiences we

feel either enjoyment or disappointments. Most enjoying experiences are experienced by

the lucky teachers. Teacher can have experiences like discovery of inactive or hidden

talent in a student, to awaken his interest, to see the pleasure he gets from his new found

capacities and to participate in the development of his talent. This is a unique reward to

the field of teaching. Teachers are models of values, whether conscious of them or not,
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 13
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

values are exhibited implicitly and explicitly value, connote standards, code of ethics and

strong beliefs.

(Salandanan, et. al. 2013)Professionalism is highly treasured in the teaching

profession. Teachers are adjudged professional if they are knowledgeable, skilled and

value. Laden in addition to competence in teaching, they must have internalized the

edicts of the profession, thus exhibit ethical and moral conduct. Upright and exemplary in

behaviour they earn respect and high esteem from students, colleagues. They catch

students’ attention and keep them focused on the topic, to soothe their feelings away from

tension and to develop a sense of humour among them.

Skill is important in teaching a lesson. Skill may be defined as any refined pattern

of performance; skill is the correct use of habit or the result of reaction. To understand

the learners, teachers need to correctly use what they have learned or acquired from the

years they studied for their profession. Pleasant feelings are said to be a part of making

teaching and learning successful. If we promote pleasant feelings in class, there is

assurance that we can have positive outcomes.

Presentation of lesson in a skilful manner is really conducive to ultimate pleasant

feelings. Once a teacher used her special skills in teaching, the whole class’ atmosphere

will be positive. Good learning outcomes of students are probably the indicator that the

teacher made his or her job of teaching a lesson well. Accurate and state-of-the-art

presentation of lesson from teacher leads to success of the whole educative process.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 14
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

As time goes by, changes in all fields of human endeavour are pressure to those

developing countries especially in education. Education grows with the growth of

humanity like human history in which it is applied, education is a continuous process and

is never completed. Education is a continuous process because its source is life.

Philippine Educational System aims to provide solution to the many problems of our

country’s society. The teacher’s work in the learning situation is that of a guide or leader,

rather than a director or dictator. The learning situation should be a cooperative

undertaking under intelligent leadership of the teacher, but one in which the class

exercises initiative in planning and in carrying on the various learning activities. In other

words, teachers who will lead the teaching-learning process must have good features

rather than knowledge.

Ecudemic.com mentioned a few important components of a teacher’s arsenal.

The best modern teachers must be patient and direct – flexible in their areas but confident

in their decisions. A good teacher is a mentor and a guide. The best modern teachers – the

ones who consistently show the most learning gains among their students – are the ones

who go beyond their degree and develop some other very important skills.

All mentioned literatures are related to the present study because it accompanies

and discusses the relevance of skilful teachers to teach a subject matter. It is important to

review these literatures because theses can help in analyzing the concerns of this

research.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 15
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Related Studies

An effective teacher has been defined as “the one who conducts effective teaching

which produces beneficial and purposeful student learning through the use of appropriate

procedures.”(Diamond; 1998 cited in National Board for Professional teaching

standards, 2008). Additionally, Kyriakides, Campbell, and Christofidou (2002) point out

that effective teachers need to possess adequate quantity of instruction, organize, and

manage the classroom, environment, effectively use instructional time, structure

instructional materials, give students practice and application opportunities, provide good

classroom climate, and have enough subject knowledge, knowledge pedagogy, teaching

beliefs, and teacher’s self-efficacy.

Neil (1991) states that defining an effective teacher involves two important

components in teaching and learning process called “teacher knowledge of the subject to

be taught” and “skill in how to teach that subject.” It is intuitively obvious that effective

teachers must possess a professional knowledge base and exhibit knowledge of the

subject matter. Successful teachers have a lot of instructional strategies and techniques

voluntary activity, the teacher’s job to sell ideas to students that the topic is important.

From the definitions, an effective teacher displays a wide range of skills and

abilities that lead to creating a learning environment where all students feel comfortable

and are sure that they can succeed both academically and personally. An effective

language teacher is not characterized merely by the factors of knowledge or teaching

skills, but also the communication skills and the relationships the teacher has with
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 16
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

students. Qualities of effective Teachers: Lowman (1997) describe two main dimensions

of effective college teaching that come up in his study. According to his model, teaching

effectiveness is a product of two distinct dimensions. The first is the instructor’s ability to

stimulate intellectual excitement in the classroom. Fundamental to his ability is the clarity

of lectures and their emotional impact on students, as well as the instructor’s knowledge,

organization and flexibility. The teacher has to provide students with intellectual

excitement (enthusiasm, knowledge, inspiration, humour, interesting viewpoint, clarity,

and organization). Perhaps usually significant in terms of teacher effectiveness is the use

of psychology in the classroom. It is related to interpersonal concern/effective motivation

such as concern, caring, availability, friendliness, accessibility, helpfulness,

encouragement, and challenge. An effective teacher is the one who promotes positive

student emotions by fostering critical thinking and creativity, showing sensitivity to

students’ feelings about the course material, and promoting an atmosphere of respect.

Teacher quality is defined as teachers engaging in education tasks, with certain

characteristics, and being able and qualified to conduct teaching activities, arousing

student’s interest in learning, and enhancing students’ learning achievements.

Ko (2003) believed that teacher quality is a general term for teacher cultivation,

professional qualification and abilities. Peng (1999) believed the content of teacher

quality can be categorized into: (1) common quality, (2) professional knowledge and

abilities, (3) professional beliefs and attitude, (4) personality and (5) professional subject

accomplishment. Wu (2003) divided the aspect of superior teacher quality into three
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 17
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

categories: (1) knowledge, (2) abilities and (3) morals. Jian (1997) considered high

school quality teachers as teachers possessing:

(1) knowledgeable cultivation,

(2) teaching techniques and experiences,

(3) ability to improve students’ learning achievements and

(4) promoting school effectiveness (Wright, Horn & Sandlers, 1997)

Summarizing the results from documentary analysis, it is concluded that, in this

research, teacher quality should cover;

(1) professional competence

(2) personality,

(3) performance responsibility,

(4) teacher-student interaction and

(5) student problem handling.

The research direction chosen for teacher teaching effectiveness includes two

concepts: “teachers’ self-effectiveness” and “teachers’ effective teaching.”

Teachers; self-effectiveness” is a sense of teachers subjectively evaluating their

own teaching abilities, with influences on students’ learning effects and expecting

students to reach certain education goals (Feng, 2000). “Teachers’ effective learning” is
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 18
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

defined as teachers making use of their knowledge and abilities at work, being particular

about teaching methods, getting familiar with teaching materials, encouraging students,

creating affine learning environment and atmosphere, and helping students to achieve

performance excellence in study (Lin, 2001; Korthagen, 2004; Borich, 1994). This is the

direction chosen for this research.

It was found from related documentation that the categorizations differ with

researchers’’ points of view. Medly (1979) believed that the teachers with effectiveness

should possess the following characteristics:

(1) have a satisfying personality,

(2) implement teaching methods efficiently,

(3) create a fine learning atmosphere,

(4) be proficient on all kinds of teaching abilities and

(5) know when to use each kind of teaching ability (Flanders, 1970).

Ryan (1989) pointed out that effective teaching should include”

(1) planning strategies,

(2) teaching strategies,

(3) evaluation methods and

(4) activity management.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 19
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Moreover, teaching effectiveness can also be classified into:

(1) content of systematic teaching materials,

(2) diversified teaching techniques,

(3) effective use of teaching time,

(4) harmonious teacher-student relationship and

(5) fine classroom atmosphere.

Or into: (1) teaching plans and preparation, (2) teachers’ professional knowledge,

abilities and teaching techniques, (3) classroom management, (4) teaching outcomes and

evaluation and (5) students’ learning performance.

Or into: (1) teaching plans, (2) teaching strategies, (3) classroom atmosphere

management and (4) teaching outcomes (Chen, 1997; Tsai, 2001; Lu, 2004).

In this research, according to the research purposes and the research summarized

by scholars, teachers’ teaching effectiveness is categorized into:

(1) effective teaching behaviour,

(2) teaching strategy,

(3) teaching outcomes and

(4) classroom atmosphere management, as the basis from which to

construct a scale.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 20
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

An empirical study exploring factors related to teacher quality found that there is

a positive relationship between teachers’ performances in teaching and their scholastic

ability. Furthermore, it was found that teachers’ teaching assessments are positively

related to teaching quality. A study about teachers’ teaching effectiveness found

significant differences in all the aspects of teaching effectiveness and overall

effectiveness for teachers of different seniorities, educational backgrounds, school sizes,

school locations and job functions. Positive relationships were found overall teachers’

professional growth and all its aspects and teaching effectiveness, and teaching

development and individual development can predict teaching effectiveness (Hellfritzch,

1945; LaDuke, 1945; Skinner, 1947).

Marsh and Roche (1993) examined students’ evaluations of teaching effectiveness

as a means of enhancing university teaching. Ryan and Harrison (1995) investigated how

students weight various teaching components in arriving at their overall evaluation of

teaching effectiveness. Most recently, Ralph (2003) conducted a study on teaching

effectiveness using how well students learn as the criterion. This study took place in

Canadian university and the students represented four different instructional settings:

Business, Sociology, and Physical Education. The students were given 32 hypothetical

instructor profiles and were asked to rank nine selected teaching factors developed by

Marsh (1991). In that study Ralph identified five attributes of effective instructors:

commitment to learners; knowledge of material; organization and management of the

environment; desire to improve; and collaboration with others. Ralph concluded that

exemplary university teaching is discernable and the quality of components that define it
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 21
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

can be assessed. Similar studies provided students with a set of characteristics from

which to choose.

Clark (1995) identified cognitive and affective goals of effective teaching

at the university level. He developed a questionnaire covering a wide range of teaching

activities associated with effective instruction and the achievement of cognitive and

affective objectives. The questionnaire, administered at the University of Winnipeg,

Manitoba, identified qualities of effective university teaching determined by the

researcher. These included four cognitive components: knowledge, organization of

instruction, clarity of expression, and quality of presentation. In addition, there were four

affective components: student interest; student participation and openness to ideas;

interpersonal relations; and communication and fairness. Many course evaluation

questionnaires administered at university campuses across Canada, including Memorial

University, include these qualities. Students are asked to identify how each

course/instructor ranks in each of these qualities.

Devlin (2002) examined the strengths and weakness of a survey used at

the University of Melbourne to identify students’ perceptions of their learning

environment. The Perceptions of Learning Environment Questionnaire (PLEQ) was first

used in 1994 and was developed as part of a larger project, Teaching and Learning in

Tertiary Education at Queensland University of Technology.

Devlin argues that the PLEQ fails to sufficiently identify student

perceptions in depth. The design of the PLEQ forces students to focus on and comment
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 22
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

on the behaviour of others, and “does not allow them to communicate their views on how

they themselves are contributing to their learning” (p. 209). Devlin suggests that this

approach is contrary to the PLEQ design to report on good teaching and contains none of

the “…constructivist knowledge for themselves” (p. 290). Traditional course evaluation

questionnaires, she argues, assumes the “student as listener-follower” point of view and a

transmission model of delivering courses. While students may have been aware in the

past of their own behaviour and how it helped or hindered learning, the standard course

evaluation questionnaires simply did not provide the means to demonstrate or express

that awareness.

A teaching truism states that there is not one best strategy or approach to teach

anything to anyone. This implies that the teacher must be ready to bring about a learning

experience for the students through a carefully selected learning/teaching strategy, from a

reservoir of strategies the teacher has been equipped with. It is therefore necessary to

offer the science teacher an adequate pool of these strategies relevant to the development

of the subject of and values in focus.

For values formation in science and technology, varying strategies may be used in

the school, in the classroom, and outside the school. Values learned in school must be

related, enriched and extended to the home and to the community. As such, the students’

valuing experiences inside the classroom are continuously and consistently followed up

outside the school through the provision of projects/activities that the students may do
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 23
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

individually or in groups. Some of the strategies that have been used by the participating

countries are indicated below:

In-School Approaches

Experiential and Participatory Approach

This is a learning approach that maximises involvement and participation of the students

through carefully planned activities prepared by the teacher. Some programmes call these

activities ‘structured learning experiences’ which allow all the students to participate in,

through individual or group activities.

The prepared learning activities put the students into some kind of experience, direct or

simulated, for them to do their own introspection/reflection, to feel or react, or to

determine consequent actions or decisions relevant to the learning situation. The

experiential activity gives each student an opportunity to go through a process of valuing,

understanding his feelings and thoughts about the situation and committing himself to a

consequent action. Values, therefore, are not directly taught nor imposed, but the students

are guided to ‘catch’ the values on the learning experiences.

Individual experiences in the activity may be shared with a small group for further

clarification and understanding of their earnings. Thus, within a specific lesson, each

student would have been given an opportunity to be active either, on his own or with the

group.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 24
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Integrated Approach

If values are to be infused with a subject content, strategies for integrating both the lesson

content (e.g., science), and the values relevant to the content, are necessary. This

approach calls for a flowing together of both the cognitive dimension of the lesson and

the effective aspect of the values to be integrated. Some educationists call this the

‘confluent approach’. It is aimed to develop simultaneously the two domains of learning

in order to affect the third domain, which is the action, the actual manifestation of the

learner’s values.

This strategy has been reported by a member country (i.e. Philippines), as the ACES

Strategy (Affective Cognitive Experiences for Self-integration). Values integration is

done purposively (not accidentally) and systematically (not sporadic) in order to develop

simultaneously the cognitive content of the lesson and the affective/value component.

The ACES strategy basically follows on the inductive or discovery methodology. It goes

through four faces of learning: activity, analysis, abstraction and application. Basically, it

makes use of the experiential learning approach and makes use of the strengths of the

major approaches cited in the succeeding section.

Value Learning Strategies

In carrying out the first two listed approach, there is a host of value learning strategies

which were identified by the participants to be useful for values integration in science and

technology. These included the following:


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 25
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

a) Values Clarification Strategies which aim to let the learner clarify their positions,

thoughts and feelings about certain situations by going through the valuing processes of

choosing, prizing and acting.

Learning activities for the valuing experiences may be in the form of group dynamics,

cooperative learning, discussions, guided imagery, role playing, and many more.

Group dynamics and co-operative learning has been found to be very effective in

encouraging students to lean openness, sharing, collaboration, self-expression, conflict,

management, team building, group evaluation, leadership/followership, collective

decision making, brainstorming skills, communication skills, group reporting, and group

synthesizing, among others. These values are enhanced on top of the content of the lesson

being developed.

Guided imagery or fantasy trip are techniques that allow the students to visualize or

imagine scenarios, with all the sounds, smells, colours of things related to the learning

activity.

This visualization technique is fast gaining ground because of its potency to stimulate

creative thinking. It is considered one of the strategies aimed at developing the power of

the right brain. In Science and Technology where more often than not, the left brain is

stimulated, this strategy may be necessary for an initial development of a sense of

aesthetics and the values of curiosity, harmony, peace and transcendence.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 26
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

b) Moral Development Strategies are premised on the theory that the values developed

are based on the moral reasoning level or judgement of the person. Decision for action

therefore, is a function of the level at which the person judges whether the actions is right

or wrong.

This strategy engages the students to study the pros and cons of certain possible actions

and their corresponding consequences before he/she makes any decision for the final

action.

(…) learning events. It is more appropriate to use issue-based activities involving local

situations so as to allow for immediate and more meaningful experiences of the learners.

c) Values Analysis is a problem solving type of strategy where the students identify a

problem or purpose of the learning activity, gather evidence for positive and negative

positions about the situations, and then make inferences and conclusions that will

represent their convictions about the value-learning situations.

Individual or group analysis of news materials, local issues/situations, speeches, science

reports, collages, etc., are corresponding learning events.

d) Values Inculcation is a known to be the oldest and most commonly used strategy. It is

a direct teaching method through the use of lectures, reinforcement techniques, stories,

poems, songs, games and simulation techniques. Multi-media (film-showing, tapes and

slides) are identifies to be very effective in inculcating/transmitting values concepts in

Science and Technology.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 27
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

There are many science concepts and values that can be directly taught from the lives of

scientists. This can be presented to project the scientists as normal human beings who

succeeded because of their qualities and values which they have developed through their

hard work, persistence, devotion and genuine commitment.

Direct teaching through moralizing, however, is recognized to have limitations especially

for adolescents who by nature are indifferent or react negatively to techniques of

prodding, nagging and pure lecturing. Values inculcation strategies may be used more

effectively, if these are preceded or accompanied by meaningful experiential and

clarifying activities.

Face-to-Face Interaction with Resources Persons

In a subject like Science and Technology, there are many yearnings, both for content and

values, which may be achieved via community human resources. Community members

involved in different occupations related to the lesson at hand may be tapped to provide

the students a face-to-face interaction with them. Also, scientist available in the in the

community would be able to give up-to-date information about a particular science

lesson.

Questioning Techniques

In values development, processing questions are helpful in making the students

understand better their feelings and thoughts about the value being developed. These are

effective processing questions asked by the teacher that relate to the personal
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 28
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

experiences, observations, attitudes or personal feelings than cognitive questions such as

the what, how, or why of the concept. This is purposely done to appeal to the student’s

effective state to lead him to a certain commitment to characterize a certain value.

Modelling and the Silent Approach

Role modelling is accepted to be an excellent strategy. The teacher’s personable ways,

patience, devotion, guiding and accepting ways, often or non-verbal, get across to the

students easily and effectively.

Structures, rules regulations or school policies are all forms of ‘silent teachers’ that

encourage the students to develop values of discipline, respect, prudence responsibility

and the like. These are training situations for them to live harmoniously in a macro-

system, i.e., society.

Out-of-School Strategies

Outside the school, values learning may be enhanced with the use of stimulating and

creative science activities.

Action Learning Strategies

These are activities that serve as enrichment or application of the value concepts learned

in the classroom. Students may work in groups to plan together; (i) the purpose of the

activity; (ii) things they need, people, involved; (iii) task assignments; (iv) implementing

mechanism; (v) getting support from outside; (vi) evaluating the activity and reporting. It

is important to note that whatever the science activity/project may be, the teacher sees to
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 29
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

it that he/she focuses on cognitive, effective and behavioural components in the planning,

execution, and evaluation of the activity.

These activities may be in the form of:

a) Community Reach-out – such as a visit to under-privileged, depressed areas or to

orphanages, places with victims of calamities, etc.

b) Social Action or Volunteer Work – which encourages students to assist in the hospitals,

clinics or rural health centers, census work, health and nutrition projects.

c) Research and Project Work – on topic like honesty of vendors and their weighing

scales in the markets, or projects involving greening backyards, cleaning rivers or

experimental researches related to class lessons, projects on superstitious beliefs and

scientific truths, projects on collections (e.g. insects, leaves, shells, flora and fauna).

d) Site Exposures or Field Trips – visiting polluted areas, factories, denuded forests,

science parks, museums and science exhibitions.

e) Media Awareness Education, Peace Campaigns and the Like – such as conducting

assemblies, forums, and lectures aimed to raise the community’s level of media

awareness and to enjoin others to rally behind good and responsible media. Peace

campaigns may also be done through poster-making, parades in the community, and

essay writing contests.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 30
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Parent-Teacher Activities

In any form of learning, it is crucial to involve the parents who play a vital role in the

learners’ development. There is a meaningful learning atmosphere when the students

know that their parents are concerned about their activities in the school. Guidance,

support and direction help in reducing, if not eliminating, value confusion on the part of

the students.

Science Club Activities

Science clubs may be encouraged to add value-laden activities through games; creative

expression such as painting, drawing, drama productions; leadership training; camp outs;

co-operative learning; team building, big brother/sister supportive relationships, science

quizzes, exhibitions and fairs debates and symposiums.

Materials for Further Learning

Students may be oriented to supplementary reading materials in science for the

enhancement of their learning in school. Structured modules (e.g. Malaysia’s) may be

designed for self-learning or with the help of the parents or with specific groups (e.g.

Learning Action Cells – LAC in the Philippines) as supplementary to what has been

taken up in the classroom.

Teaching Training Strategies

Admittedly, values development and values integration in science and technology,

require special teaching competencies in addition to the normally required skills of the
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 31
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

science teacher. The teacher needs to recognize the significance and the crucial need for

these programmes as demanded by the times.

Cognizant of this demand, teachers must be encouraged to take positive steps in updating

themselves with the needed competencies in order to meet the demands.

The following are suggested for consideration in teacher training;

Teachers’ Values Oriented Information

Teachers’ value awareness level must be enhanced. They must understand their

significant role in the values development of their students.

They must learn to direct themselves towards the values worthy of emulation by

themselves.

Self-development with a direction to raise themselves to the higher level of values is the

primary aim of these sessions. Consequently and naturally, commitments to act for the

common good (for the family and others, concern for national and global value issues)

are necessary components that may be included in this phase of teacher training.

Training in Learning Teaching Strategies

Rather than leaving the teachers to select the strategies, it is important that they are made

to understand the ethical and psychological principles that go with specific strategies

previously described. Equally important is their ability to be flexible, resourceful, and


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 32
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

creative in the use of those strategies so that they may be able to adapt them appropriately

in classroom settings.

It may be helpful to employ process-based training modalities so that they are made to

understand the ethical and psychological principles that go with specific strategies

previously described. Equally important is their ability to be flexible, resourceful, and

creative in the use of these strategies so that they may be able to adapt them appropriately

in classroom settings.

It may be helpful to employ process-based training modalities so that the teachers learn

the trade as they experience the processes that go with what is being learned.

Participative learning is one effective strategy to actualize the maxim ‘learning by doing’.

Teachers are known to have rich reservoir of experiences that can be shared and taken as

good resources of new Earnings. Learning can be proceed in a psychologically pleasant

atmosphere with the values of openness, trust, acceptance, respect, sincerity elicited by

learning activities such as group dynamics and other experiential training strategies.

Training in Materials Development

In the preparation for classroom teaching, there are instructional materials that the

science teacher may need to help him/her in a more systematic and purposive values

integration.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 33
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Unit plans in Science and Technology may be studied carefully to identify entry points

for values integration and to determine which core values or related values may be

integrated in specific topics.

Exemplar lesson plans for values integration may also be developed as one strategy to

equip the teachers with skills/competencies to integrate values in their science lessons.

Activity sheets, stimulus materials for learning and structured learning episodes may be

prepared. During the training, possible sources for these materials may be cited and

strategies for creation, modification, and adaptation may be illustrated to teachers so that

they can think of ideas for developing good indigenous materials for value integration.

Training in Evaluation Strategies

The importance of evaluation cannot be overemphasized. If there is a need for training in

cognitive assessment, more so with effective behaviour evaluation, this is because of the

qualitative nature of the variable measured. Practicable techniques for classroom

evaluation may be introduced to the teacher and other helpful strategies for validating

classroom evaluation may be introduced to the teacher and other helpful strategies for

validating classroom assessment may be added. Observation outside the classes,

triangulating assessment techniques (parents, peer, and teacher) may be workable. There

are many non-traditional strategies for evaluation that the teacher can choose from,

depending on the purpose of evaluation.

Training Strategies
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 34
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Certainly, the problem of equipping the teacher with the aforementioned competencies

cannot be settled by traditional seminar lectures only, without coupling them with more

dynamic training methodologies such as the following:

1. Use of multi-media techniques;

2. Group dynamics, group discussions, consensual decision-making, group workshops;

3. Sharing of teaching experiences and student observations;

4. Micro teaching/simulations;

5. Workshops seminars;

6. Observation of teaching demonstrations; and

7. Participatory/andragogical sessions for self-development.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 35
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

CHAPTER 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Method

This study used the descriptive survey method of research to determine the

effectiveness of methods and techniques used in teaching the four macro skills in English

subject. It utilizes the questionnaire as the foremost instrument to gather the data needed.

The descriptive method is something more and beyond just data-gathering; the

latter is not reflective thinking and not research. The true meaning of data collected

should be reported from the point of view of the objectives and the basic assumptions of

the project under way. This follows logically after careful classification of data. Facts

obtained may be accurate expressions of central tendency, of deviation, or of correlation;

but the report is not research unless discussion of those data is carried up into the level of

adequate interpretation. Data must be subjected to the thinking process in terms of

ordered reasoning. A research report may be an example of good exposition in acceptable

English form of well classified material, but it may not rise above the level of rather

monotonous discussion of the details of data presented. The generalization, which appear
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 36
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

as summation figures in the tables, as trends or surfaces of frequency in figures, and so

on, are not recognized in terms of adequate explanations and pertinent conclusion. They

are not interpreted.

Description of the Respondents

The respondents are the 187 sample from 207 4th year high school students of

Taguig Science High School. They were selected through the use of stratified sampling

technique.

Sample and Sampling Techniques

The researchers will use Stratified Sampling. Stratified sampling is a probability

sampling technique wherein the researcher divides the entire population into different

subgroups or strata, then randomly selects the final subjects proportionally from the

different strata.

The most common strata used in stratified random sampling are age, gender,

socioeconomic status, religion, nationality and educational attainment.

Stratified random sampling is used when the researcher wants to highlight a

specific subgroup within the population. This technique is useful in such researches

because it ensures the presence of the key subgroup within the sample.

Researchers also employ stratified random sampling when they want to observe

existing relationships between two or more subgroups. With a simple random sampling
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 37
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

technique, the researcher is not sure whether the subgroups that he wants to observe are

represented equally or proportionately within the sample.

With stratified sampling, the researcher can representatively sample even the

smallest and most inaccessible subgroups in the population. This allows the researcher to

sample the rare extremes of the given population.

With this technique, you have a higher statistical precision compared to simple

random sampling. This is because the variability within the subgroups is lower compared

to the variations when dealing with the entire population.

Because this technique has high statistical precision, it also means that it requires

a small sample size which can save a lot of time, money and effort of the researchers.

To determine the sample size from a given population size, the slovin’s formula

was used. Below is the Slovin’s Formula:

n= N/ (1+(N*E^2)) Solution:

where: n= N/ (1+(N*E^2))

n= number of samples n= 207/ (1+(207*0.052))

N= total population n= 207/ (1+(207*0.0025)

e= margin error (5%) n= 207/ (1+0.5175)

n= 207/1.5175

n= 137
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 38
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Below is the tabulation of the sample out of the subgroups of the entire population:

Section/Subgroups: Number of students: Sample

Aristotle 42 38

Einstein 41 37

Galileo 41 37

Newton 42 38

Oersted 41 37

Total 207 187

Instrumentation

There would be a set of survey questionnaire for the students. The questionnaire

contained four Macro Skills in English; they are a) Listening, b) Speaking, c) Reading

and d) Writing. Each skill contains different methods and technique which teachers use in

their teaching. The respondents was requested to mark a check corresponding to each of

teaching techniques under such Macro Skills used by the teachers regarding the degree of

their effectiveness in learning through those methods.

Data Gathering Procedures

The researchers will seek first the permission of the principal of Taguig Science

High School for a “go signal” in conducting the survey. Also, they will ask permission
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 39
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

from the English administrator of the said school involved in the study before the actual

survey.

The researchers themselves personally will administer the questionnaires to the

respondents. They will do this to insure a prompt and outright retrieval of all the

questionnaires.

Data Collection Techniques

To study the effectiveness of teaching methods and techniques the researchers

used data gathered from the answers of the students to our given questionnaire. The

questionnaire is divided in two parts: the first collects information on the students’

characteristics (age, gender and section; the second consists of 73 general items about

teacher methods and techniques used in English subjects. Response is measured on a

four-point scale ranging from 1 (not effective) to 5 (very effective).

The data set used in this study consists of 207 questionnaires regarding all

sections of Fourth year high school students in Taguig Science National High School

covering the Academic year 2013-2014.

Research Locale

The respondents of this study were the students of Taguig Science High School.

The Taguig Science High School (TSHS) is a public specialized secondary

science high school located at C.P. Tiñga Sports Complex, Hagonoy, Taguig City. It is

formerly known as a Science Special class and establishment was made possible by the
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 40
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

City Mayor Hon. Sigfrido R. Tiñga in collaboration with the Department of Education

(Philippines) – Division of Taguig and Pateros.

It started in school year 2002- 2003 with two sections having 35 students each

section housed at Signal Village National High School.

In June 21, 2004 the visionaries of program transferred the class into its new

house due to the increasing population that entailed increase in classroom, teachers and

facilities. That paved its way into the speedy conversion into a Science High School

under Municipal Ordinance No. 104-2003, with the untiring support of the local

government and the effort extended by the Division Science Supervisor, Mrs. Leticia E.

Andor, the school has finally been granted permit on September 14, 2004.

Statistical Treatment

To describe the effectiveness of the methods and techniques used by the

teachers in teaching four macro skills in English, the researchers will use the frequency

distribution.

Frequency Index Limit

Very Effective 4 3.75-4.0

Effective 3 2.50-3.74

Less Effective 2 1.75-2.49

Not Effective 1 1.0-1.74


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 41
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

The statistical tool/measure applied to solve the problem on what the perceptions of

students and teachers are on the effectiveness of the methods and techniques used in

teaching Macro Skills in English subject such as Listening, Speaking, reading, Writing

was the mean The responses for each category were multiplied by each weight, then

summed up to get the weighted scores in everyitem. The total weighted score was divided

by the number of respondents to get the mean. This mean showed the relative position of

respondents’ perceptions of each item on the degree of effectiveness of methods and

techniques along the four areas.

x
x̅ =
N

Where:

x̅ = symbol of the mean;

x = the sum of the weighted scores &

N = number of cases

The ANOVA Formula was employed to test the null hypothesis formulated in this

study which states that there is no significant difference between the perceptions of

students and their teachers in the effectiveness of the methods/techniques used in

teaching the four Macro Skills in English subject.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 42
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

(∑ 𝑥𝑇 ) 2
∑ 𝑥𝑇2 −
𝑁𝑇

Where:

∑ 𝑥𝑇2 =Total score multiplied to itself

(∑ 𝑥𝑇 ) 2
= Summation of scores

N = Number of cases

The Statistical measure used to test the null hypothesis which states that there is

no significance difference between the perception of the students on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of their class section

is ANOVA. The formula is used to determine if there is a significant difference to the

level of effective of the Macro Skills between sections.

With the use of F table of critical values we will know if the researchers may

accept or reject the null hypothesis. If the computed value is greater than the tabulated

value the researchers will accept the null hypothesis. In the other hand, if the computed

value is less than the tabulated value the researchers will reject the null hypothesis.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 43
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

CHAPTER 4

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter covers the presentation, analysis and interpretation of the data

gathered toanalyze the teaching methods/techniques used by the Taguig Science High

School teachers in teaching, as perceived by the students.

The Table 1.1, 1.2 &1.3 shows the Profile of the student respondents next to its

interpretation; the Table 2.1 shows the presentation of the perceptions in methods and

techniques under Listening skill follows to its interpretation; the Table 2.2 shows the

presentation of the perceptions in methods and techniques under Speaking skill follows to

its interpretation; Table 2.3 shows the presentation of the perceptions in methods and

techniques under Reading skill follows to its interpretation; Table 2.4 shows the

presentation of the perceptions in methods and techniques under Writing skill follows to

its interpretation; the Table 3.1 and 3.2 shows the summary of mean perception scores;
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 44
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Table 4.1 shows the difference between the perception of the class section on the

effectiveness of methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of

weighted mean; and Table 4.2 shows the equivalent verbal interpretation of the Table 4.1.

The profile of the student respondents used in data gathering is classified

according to the variables age, gender and section.

TABLE 1.1 THE STUDENT RESPONDENTS CORRESPONDING TO ITS AGE.

Age Range No. of Student

14-16

17-19

20-22

23-25

TOTAL:

Table 1.1 shows that most of the respondents of this study were aging 14-16 years

old. Only few of them were 17-19 years of age.

TABLE 1.2 THE STUDENT RESPONDENTS CORRESPONDING TO ITS GENDER.

Gender No. of Student

Male 72

Female 115
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 45
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

TOTAL: 187

The gender of the respondents of this study were dominated by Female as it is

clearly shown in the Table 1.2

TABLE 1.3 THE STUDENT RESPONDENTS CORRESPONDING TO ITS CLASS

SECTION.

Section No. of Students

Aristotle 38

Einstein 37

Galileo 37

Newton 38

Oersted 37

TOTAL: 187

The Table 1.3 shows the number of the students corresponding to its class section.

It can be seen that each sections have nearly the same number of population.

Perceptions of Students on the Effectiveness of Methods and Techniques

Used in Teaching

The mean was used to determine the effectiveness of methods and techniques

used in teaching the four Macro Skills. Also, the mean was used to find the relative
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 46
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

position of the relative position of the students on the degree of effectiveness for each

item of the techniques of each method utilized in teaching the subject.

On Listening. All methods and techniques under this skill are respectively

described as “Effective” as perceived by the student respondents.Table 2.1 shows the

tabulation of the results of the mean score and interpretation per methods and techniques

of Listening Skill.

In Project Method, the following techniques are described as effective: Conducts

story telling with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.16, and Assigns students to listen in radio

news and make a written report with a rank of 2 and a mean of 2.78. The overall mean of

2.97 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

The following techniques in lecture method are described as effective: the

techniques are the Speaks in a modulated voice that can be heard even at the last row of

the students with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.68, Discuses the lesson clearly with a rank

of 2 and a mean of 3.56, Asks the students to take notes with a rank of 3 and a mean of

3.29, Invites resource person to speak a topic on a class with a rank of 4 and a mean of

3.25, and Uses audio materials for better lecturing with a rank of 5 and a mean of 3.07.

The overall mean of 3.37 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

In demonstration Method, the following techniques are described as effective:

Demonstrates how to pronounce the words correctly with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.55,

and Presents audio-visual films that are related to the topic with a rank of 2 and a mean of

3.52. The overall mean of 3.56 is qualitatively described as “Effective”.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 47
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

In Question and Answer Method, the following techniques are described as

effective: Recalls students to their previous lesson with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.37,

and Conducts a story telling and ask students to make her point of view with a rank of 2

with a mean of 3.55. The overall mean of 3.36 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

PERCEPTION OF MEAN SCORES OF STUDENTS ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF

METHODS AND TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN

ENGLISH SUBJECT

TABLE 2.1 Listening Skill

A. LISTENING MEAN INTERPRETATION


1. Project Method
a) Assigns students to listen in
radio news and make a 2.78 Effective
written report about it.
b) Conducts a story telling 3.16 Effective
OVERALL MEAN 2.97 Effective
2. Lecture Method
a) Speaks in modulated voice
that can be heard at the last 3.68 Effective
row of the students.
b) Invites resource person to
3.25 Effective
speak on a topic on a class.
c) Discusses the lesson clearly. 3.56 Effective
d) Asks the students to take
3.29 Effective
notes.
e) Uses audio in reporting. 3.07 Effective
OVERALL MEAN 3.37 Effective
3. Demonstration method
a) Demonstrates how to
pronounce correctly the 3.55 Effective
words
b) Presents audio films that are
3.52 Effective
related to the topic.
OVERALL MEAN 3.56 Effective
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 48
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

4. Question and Answer Method


a) Asks students to recall what
3.37 Effective
have been discussed.
b) Conducts a story telling and
ask students to make her point 3.35 Effective
of view.
OVERALL MEAN 3.36 Effective

On Speaking.All the techniques employed are perceived by the students as

effective.

The overall mean of 3.22 is described as effective. So, the techniques used in

project method are very educationally qualified to use in teaching and managing the

subject. This is shown in Table 2.2.

On the demonstration method, the following techniques are described effective;

shows visual aids, like objects, actual items, models or drawings of the topic to students

which has a mean of 3.65; Illustrates topic using personal stories and examples with a

mean of 3.56; and presents and demonstrates speech topics to students step by stop which

gets a mean of 3.52. The overall mean of 3.51 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

This finding tends to show that English teachers are professionally good and have

mastery of the subject matter methods and techniques broad enough to give their students

competitive knowledge.

On lecture method, all techniques are perceived as effective. The techniques

present basic information for introducing a subject and uses public address system to

ensure that all students can hear ranks as top two highest with 3.46 and 3.36 means
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 49
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

respectively. The overall mean of 3.34 is described as effective. This findings, seems to

imply that students learn enough with the teaching techniques used in lecture method.

Similarly on the question and answer method, all the techniques employed

are effective. So, the overall mean of 3.30 is also enough to teach those techniques in the

English subject education.

TABLE 2.2 Speaking Skill

B. SPEAKING MEAN INTERPRETATION


1. Project Method
a) Conducts a role play and give
some tips about ways to carry 3.47 Effective
them out effectively.
b) Assigns projects on an
3.29 Effective
increasing scale difficulty.
c) Compares the workmanship
of finished projects and the 2.9 Effective
like among students.
OVERALL MEAN 3.22 Effective
2. Demonstration Method
a) Uses PowerPoint picture and
3.39 Effective
figure slide sheets.
b) Presents and demonstrates
speech topics to students step 3.52 Effective
by step.
c) Shows students how to do
3.45 Effective
speech activities step by step.
d) Shows visual aids, like
objects, actual items, models
3.65 Effective
or drawings of the topic to
students.
e) Illustrates topic using
3.56 Effective
personal stories and examples.
OVERALL MEAN 3.51 Effective
3. Lecture Method
a) Presents basic information for
3.46 Effective
introducing a subject.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 50
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

b) Presents facts or ideas in a


3.27 Effective
relatively short time.
c) Uses public address system to
ensure that all students can 3.36 Effective
hear.
d) Supplements material from
other sources or information
3.29 Effective
difficult to obtain in other
ways.
e) Allows a large number of
students to receive
3.34 Effective
information from real experts
in a subject.
OVERALL MEAN 3.34 Effective
4. Question and Answer Method
a) Conducts question and answer
3.48 Effective
method in teaching conversation.
b) Provides the students with a
kind of formula that he follows in 3.39 Effective
constructing his answer.
c) Uses action-chains in
3.36 Effective
teaching.
d) Involves a great number of
loosely related questions ask in a 2.98 Effective
rapid-fire manner.
OVERALL MEAN 3.30 Effective
5. Reporting Method
a) Chooses a topic that is
3.63 Effective
interesting to students.
b) Clarifies the purpose of
3.45 Effective
reporting.
c) Catches student’s interest
with a question, a dramatic tale,
3.58 Effective
or a personal experience that
relates the topic.
d) Shares information in
3.47 Effective
organized way.
e) Makes eye contact. 3.42 Effective
OVERALL MEAN 3.51 Effective
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 51
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On Reading.The techniques that the student perceived to be effective are; Lets students

to choose a meaningful quote from a text that they are reading which has a mean of 3. 41,

ranking as 1, creating crossword puzzle in order to review the definitions of challenged

vocabulary words has a mean of 3.36, ranking as 2 and discussing questions beforehand

which have to be approved by the teacher has the mean of 3.25, ranked as the lowest

among the project method.

The overall mean of 3.34 is described as effective. This result seems to indicate

that the methods and techniques the teachers are implementing is effective to the growth

of the learners as stated on the Table 6 having an effective result.

On the demonstration method, the techniques that was described to be very

effective is provides students with the picture first without words, as a way of focusing

their attention on the visual. It has the mean of 3.52 falling on the rank 1. The techniques

that are perceived as effective are; working with the students to analyse advertisement

and political cartoons and commentary which has a mean of 3.42, ranked a 2 and using

the rhetorical trinity of ethos, pathos, and logos as tool has the mean of 3.32, ranking as

the last. The overall mean of 3.42 suggest that the methods and techniques is as perceived

by the learners. It sums that demonstration in the skill of reading shows that the learners

are acquiring knowledge.

On the lecture method, all the methods and the techniques employed are effective.

So, the overall mean of 3.40 is also very educationally qualified to teach with a

background broad enough to handle the lesson.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 52
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On the question and answer method; the following strategies are perceived to be

effective using prior knowledge to answer different type of questions is interpreted as

very effective, which has the mean of 3.54 and ranked as 1; clarifying how students

approach the tasks of reading texts and answering questions has the mean of 3.45 and

ranked as 2; formulating questions about the content of reading which has the mean of

3.44 and ranked as 3; and asking questions to be answered in reading which has the mean

of 3.35 and ranked as 4. The overall mean of 3.55 and interpreted as effective expresses

the usefulness of these methods and techniques to the learners.

On the reporting method, all the techniques are described to be effective. Having

the overall mean of 3.32 and interpreted as effective conveys the efficiency of the

methods and techniques in the reading skills.

TABLE 2.3 Reading Skill

C. READING MEAN INTERPRETATION


1. Project Method
a) Discusses questions
beforehand and have this 3.25 Effective
approved.
b) Creates crossword puzzle to
review definitions of
3.36 Effective
challenging vocabulary
words.
c) Lets students choose a
meaningful quote from a text 3.41 Effective
that they are reading
OVERALL MEAN 3.34 Effective
2. Demonstration Method
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 53
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

a) Works with students to


analyze advertisements and
3.42 Effective
political cartoons and
commentary.
b) Uses rhetorical trinity of
ethos, pathos, and logos as 3.32 Effective
tool.
c) Provides students with the
picture first without the
3.52 Effective
words, as a way of focusing
their attention on the visual.
OVERALL MEAN 3.42 Effective
3. Lecture Method
a) Gives students a rich and
rewarding educational 3.49 Effective
experience.
b) Gives students a proper set of
3.35 Effective
notes.
c) Gives students some
3.39 Effective
problems to solve.
d) Gives clear enough guidelines
3.41 Effective
for action.
e) Gives lecture without making
any demands for extra 3.34 Effective
resources.
OVERALL MEAN 3.40 Effective
4. Question and Answer Method
a) Asks questions to be
3.35 Effective
answered in reading.
b) Formulates questions about
3.44 Effective
the content of the reading.
c) Clarifies how students
approach the tasks of reading
3.45 Effective
texts and answering
questions.
d) Uses prior knowledge to
answer different types of 3.54 Effective
questions.
OVERALL MEAN 3.45 Effective
5. Reporting Method
a) Provides focus assistance on
3.32 Effective
the learner’s understanding of
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 54
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

a text and their language


output.
b) Provides a momentary pause
3.35 Effective
in the lesson.
c) Provides reporting
3.42 Effective
formats/templates.
d) Chooses large and varied
3.19 Effective
range of materials as possible.
OVERALL MEAN 3.32 Effective

On Writing.In Project Method, the following techniques are described as

effective; invites students to write what they know-themselves and their lives with a rank

of 1 and a mean of 3.37, and helps students create guidelines for writing biographies with

a rank of 2 and a mean of 3.35. The overall mean of Project Method is 3.36 which are

qualitatively described as “Effective”.

The following techniques in Demonstration Method are described as “Effective”

with an overall mean of 3.43: Provides a “clear picture” of a task that must be learned on

the first rank with a mean of 3.52; Provides individual guidance and evaluation on the

second rank with a mean of 3.47; Appeals to more than one sense on the third ran with a

mean of 3.43; and Emphasizes proper sequence on the last rank with a mean of 3.3. The

overall mean of Demonstration Method is 3.43which is qualitatively described as

“Effective”.

In Lecture Method, the following techniques are described as “Effective” with an

overall mean of 3.41; Helps students clarify and illustrate ideas and Supplements other

methods of instruction on the first rank with a mean of 3.47; Provides effective use of
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 55
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

time and manpower on the second rank with a mean of 3.44; Uses questions to achieve

active participation on the third rank with a mean of 3.42; and Presents facts and

principles orally on the last rank with a mean of 3.27.

The following techniques on Question and Answer Method are described as

“Effective” with an overall mean of 3.35: Allows students enough time to think about and

give an answer on the first rank with a mean of 3.49; Acknowledges all answers to ensure

incorrect or vague answers are clarified on the second rank with a mean of 3.47; Asks

questions to promote thinking in students and get them involved on the third rank with a

mean of 3.43; Distributes questions in random on the fourth rank with a mean of 3.24;

and Avoids frequent group or choral responses on the last rank with a mean of 3.13.

In Reporting method, the following techniques are described as “Effective” with

an overall mean of 3.31: Collaborates with students in class discussion about different

writing tips on the first rank with a mean of 3.4; Shares guidelines in technical writing on

the second rank with a mean of 3.37; Assigns students topics to be reported on the third

rank with a mean of 3.33; Assigns group activities to discuss writing lessons and report

the facts gathered by members in class on the fourth rank with a mean of 3.31; and

Assigns students to interview a writer and share to the class what they knew by reporting

on the last rank with a mean of 3.16.

TABLE 2.4 Writing Skill

D. WRITING MEAN INTERPRETATION


1. Project Method
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 56
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

a) Helps students create


guidelines for writing 3.35 Effective
biographies.
b) Invites students to write what
they know-themselves and 3.37 Effective
their lives.
OVERALL MEAN 3.36 Effective
2. Demonstration Method
a) Provides a “clear picture” of a
3.52 Effective
task that must be learned.
b) Appeals to more than one
3.43 Effective
sense.
c) Emphasizes proper sequence. 3.3 Effective
d) Provides individual guidance
3.47 Effective
and evaluation.
OVERALL MEAN 3.43 Effective
3. Lecture Method
a) Presents facts and principles
3.27 Effective
orally.
b) Uses questions to achieve
3.42 Effective
active participation.
c) Provides effective use of time
3.44 Effective
and manpower.
d) Supplements other methods
3.47 Effective
of instruction.
e) Helps students clarify and
3.47 Effective
illustrate ideas.
OVERALL MEAN 3.41 Effective
4. Question and Answer Method
a) Asks questions to promote
thinking in students and get 3.43 Effective
them involved.
b) Distributes questions in
3.24 Effective
random.
c) Allows students enough time
to think about and give an 3.49 Effective
answer
d) Acknowledges all answers to
ensure incorrect or vague 3.47 Effective
answers are clarified.
e) Avoids frequent group or
3.13 Effective
choral responses.
OVERALL MEAN 3.35 Effective
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 57
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

5. Reporting Method
a) Assigns students topics to be
3.33 Effective
reported.
b) Assigns students to interview
a writer and share to the class 3.16 Effective
what they knew by reporting.
c) Assigns group activities to
discuss writing lessons and
3.31 Effective
report the facts gathered by
members in class.
d) Shares guidelines in technical
3.37 Effective
writing.
e) Collaborates with students in
class discussion about 3.4 Effective
different writing tips.
OVERALL MEAN 3.31 Effective

TABLE 3.1 SUMMARY OF MEAN PERCEPTION SCORES ON THE

EFFECTIVENESS OF METHOD AND TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR

MACRO SKILLS IN ENGLISH SUBJECT

Method Used Mean Interpretation

A. Listening

a. Project Method 2.97 Effective

b. Demonstration Method 3.37 Effective

c. Lecture Method 3.56 Effective

d. Question and Answer


3.36 Effective
Method
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 58
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

B. Speaking

a. Project Method 3.22 Effective

b. Demonstration Method 3.51 Effective

c. Lecture Method 3.34 Effective

d. Question and Answer


3.30 Effective
Method

e. Reporting Method 3.51 Effective

C. Reading

a. Project Method 3.34 Effective

b. Demonstration Method 3.42 Effective

c. Lecture Method 3.40 Effective

d. Question and Answer


3.45 Effective
Method

e. Reporting Method 3.32 Effective

D. Writing

a. Project Method 3.36 Effective

b. Demonstration Method 3.43 Effective

c. Lecture Method 3.41 Effective

d. Question and Answer


3.35 Effective
Method

e. Reporting Method 3.31 Effective


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 59
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

TABLE 3.2 SUMMARY OF MEAN PERCEPTION SCORES ON THE FOUR MACRO

SKILLS IN ENGLISH SUBJECT

Macro Skills Mean Interpretation

A. Listening 3.32 Effective

B. Speaking 3.38 Effective

C. Reading 3.39 Effective

D. Writing 3.36 Effective

OVERALL 3.36 Effective

As we can see in the table 3.2, Listening Skill is perceived by the students as

“effective”. The mean for them is 3.32. This finding simply means that students

perceived the method based on how much they have acquired knowledge from it.

On Speaking Skill, the mean score for the student is 3.38 respectively. The

interpretation is “effective”. This finding implies that students believed that the methods

and techniques used in teaching speaking skill were appropriately chosen for the lesson

presented.

On the Reading Skill, the perceptions mean score of students is 3.39. The

interpretation is effective.

Similarly on Writing Skills the mean scores of students which are 3.36 have

qualitative interpretation as “effective”. This finding implies that students perceived the
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 60
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

methods and techniques to be effective which could have been attributed to the fact that

teachers of English subject work out to make teaching-learning process effective.

TABLE 4.1 THE WEIGHTED MEAN OF THE DIFFERENCE OF PERCEPTIONS OF

STUDENT RESPONDENTS ACCORDING TO THEIR CLASS SECTION

Weighted Mean Macro Skills

Class Section Listening Speaking Reading Writing

Aristotle 3.33 3.39 3.36 3.39

Einstein 3.30 3.36 3.37 3.31

Galileo 3.38 3.42 3.37 3.39

Newton 3.44 3.48 3.49 3.45

Oersted 3.25 3.5 3.30 3.37

The perception of the students is clearly stated on the table 4.1 and 4.2. Based on

the computed weighted mean, each section comes up with the same results. It falls on the

criteria as an effective methods and techniques for the learners itself.

On the Listening Skills, Newton is the highest among the other section and ranked

as 1 with the mean of 3.44. Falling on the ranked 2 is the Galileo having the mean of

3.38. Aristotle ranking as 3 has the mean of 3.33 It clearly shows how the students learn

best from the certain skills other that the other section and falls into the interpretation as

an effective method shown on the table 4.2


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 61
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On the Speaking Skills, Newton is the highest among the other section all over

again having the mean of 3.48. Galileo is ranked again on the same spot as 2 with the

mean of 3.42, while Aristotle is on the same rank as 3 having the mean of 3.39. It visibly

states that the section understand the methods and techniques and perceived to be

effective as shown on the table 4.2.

On the Reading Skills, Newton is still on the rank 1 with the mean of 3.49.

Einstein and Galileo are both on the rank 2 with the mean score of 3.37. Aristotle is

ranked as 3 with its mean score of 3.36. The result shows how the student differs from

one another by their understanding of the methods and techniques. Stated on the table

4.2, the results are all effective.

In the same way on the Writing Skills, Newton is still leading on its rank having

the mean score of 3.45. Aristotle and Galileo are on the same rank with the mean of 3.39.

Oersted is ranked into 3 for its mean score of 3.37. The results are all effective as shown

on table 4.2.

TABLE 4.2THE VERBAL INTERPRETATION OF THE DIFFERENCE OF THE

PERCEPTIONS OF STUDENT RESPONDENTS ACCORDING TO THEIR

CLASS SECTION

Interpretation Macro Skills

Class Section Listening Speaking Reading Writing

Aristotle Effective Effective Effective Effective


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 62
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Einstein Effective Effective Effective Effective

Galileo Effective Effective Effective Effective

Newton Effective Effective Effective Effective

Oersted Effective Effective Effective Effective

CHAPTER 5

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 63
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

Summary

The purpose of this study is to analyze the teaching methodology of secondary

high school teachers teaching English subject in Taguig Science National High School

during the year 2013-2014. The researchers identified the profile of the student

respondents in terms of the following variables: age, gender, and section. Also, the

researchers classified different techniques commonly used by the teachers in teaching the

four macro skills in the English subject into: Project Method, Demonstration method,

Lecture Method, Question and Answer Method, and reporting method. This study shows

how the respondents perceive on the effectiveness of methods and techniques used in

teaching English subject in: Listening, Reading, Speaking, and Writing. Also, this study

revealed the Implication/s of the findings to the methods and techniques used in teaching

four macro skills in English subject.

The researchers wanted to prove their null hypothesis which states that there is no

significant difference between the perception of the students on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of their class section.

The respondents are the 187 4th year High School students of Taguig Science

High School out of the total population of 207. Stratified sampling was utilized to get the

needed information for the study.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 64
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

This study used the descriptive survey method of research to determine the

effectiveness of methods and techniques used in teaching the four macro skills in English

subject.

To determine the sample size from the given population size, the researchers used

the Slovin’s formula. To describe the effectiveness of the methods and techniques used

by the teachers in teaching four macro skills in English, the researchers used the

frequency distribution.

The Statistical measure used to test the null hypothesis which states that there is

no significance difference between the perception of the students on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of their class section

is ANOVA. The formula is used to determine if there is a significant difference to the

level of effective of the Macro Skills between sections.

Findings:

Perception of Students on the effectiveness of Methods and Techniques used:

On Listening, the following techniques in Project Method are described as

effective: Conducts story telling with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.16, and Assigns

students to listen in radio news and make a written report with a rank of 2 and a mean of

2.78. The overall mean of 2.97 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

The following techniques in lecture method are described as effective: the former

techniques are the Speaks in a modulated voice that can be heard even at the last row of
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 65
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

the students with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.68, Discuses the lesson clearly with a rank

of 2 and a mean of 3.56, Asks the students to take notes with a rank of 3 and a mean of

3.29, Invites resource person to speak a topic on a class with a rank of 4 and a mean of

3.25, and Uses audio materials for better lecturing with a rank of 5 and a mean of 3.07.

The overall mean of 3.37 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

In demonstration Method, the following techniques are described as effective:

Demonstrates how to pronounce the words correctly with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.55,

and Presents audio-visual films that are related to the topic with a rank of 2 and a mean of

3.52. The overall mean of 3.56 is qualitatively described as “Effective”.

In Question and Answer Method, the following techniques are described as

effective: Recalls students to their previous lesson with a rank of 1 and a mean of 3.37,

and Conducts a story telling and ask students to make her point of view with a rank of 2

with a mean of 3.55. The overall mean of 3.36 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

On Speaking, All the techniques employed are perceived by the students as

effective.

On the demonstration method, the following techniques are described effective;

shows visual aids, like objects, actual items, models or drawings of the topic to students

which has a mean of 3.65; Illustrates topic using personal stories and examples with a

mean of 3.56; and presents and demonstrates speech topics to students step by stop which

gets a mean of 3.52. The overall mean of 3.51 is qualitatively described as “effective”.

This finding tends to show that English teachers are professionally good and have
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 66
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

mastery of the subject matter methods and techniques broad enough to give their students

competitive knowledge.

On lecture method, all techniques are perceived as effective. The techniques

present basic information for introducing a subject and uses public address system to

ensure that all students can hear ranks as top two highest with 3.46 and 3.36 means

respectively. The overall mean of 3.34 is described as effective. This findings, seems to

imply that students learn enough with the teaching techniques used in lecture method.

Similarly on the question and answer method, all the techniques employed

are effective. So, the overall mean of 3.30 is also enough to teach those techniques in the

English subject education.

On Reading, The techniques that the student perceived to be effective are; Lets

students to choose a meaningful quote from a text that they are reading which has a mean

of 3. 41, ranking as 1, creating crossword puzzle in order to review the definitions of

challenged vocabulary words has a mean of 3.36, ranking as 2 and discussing questions

beforehand which have to be approved by the teacher has the mean of 3.25, ranked as the

lowest among the project method.

The overall mean of 3.34 is described as effective. This result seems to indicate

that the methods and techniques the teachers are implementing is effective to the growth

of the learners as stated on the Table 6 having an effective result.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 67
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On the demonstration method, the techniques that was described to be very

effective is provides students with the picture first without words, as a way of focusing

their attention on the visual. It has the mean of 3.52 falling on the rank 1. The techniques

that are perceived as effective are; working with the students to analyse advertisement

and political cartoons and commentary which has a mean of 3.42, ranked a 2 and using

the rhetorical trinity of ethos, pathos, and logos as tool has the mean of 3.32, ranking as

the last. The overall mean of 3.42 suggest that the methods and techniques is as perceived

by the learners. It sums that demonstration in the skill of reading shows that the learners

are acquiring knowledge.

On the lecture method, all the methods and the techniques employed are effective.

So, the overall mean of 3.40 is also very educationally qualified to teach with a

background broad enough to handle the lesson.

On the question and answer method; the following strategies are perceived to be

effective using prior knowledge to answer different type of questions is interpreted as

very effective, which has the mean of 3.54 and ranked as 1; clarifying how students

approach the tasks of reading texts and answering questions has the mean of 3.45 and

ranked as 2; formulating questions about the content of reading which has the mean of

3.44 and ranked as 3; and asking questions to be answered in reading which has the mean

of 3.35 and ranked as 4. The overall mean of 3.55 and interpreted as effective expresses

the usefulness of these methods and techniques to the learners.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 68
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On the reporting method, all the techniques are described to be effective. Having

the overall mean of 3.32 and interpreted as effective conveys the efficiency of the

methods and techniques in the reading skills.

On Writing, the following techniques in Project Method are described as

effective; invites students to write what they know-themselves and their lives with a rank

of 1 and a mean of 3.37, and helps students create guidelines for writing biographies with

a rank of 2 and a mean of 3.35. The overall mean of Project Method is 3.36 which is

qualitatively described as “Effective”.

The following techniques in Demonstration Method are described as “Effective”

with an overall mean of 3.43: Provides a “clear picture” of a task that must be learned on

the first rank with a mean of 3.52; Provides individual guidance and evaluation on the

second rank with a mean of 3.47; Appeals to more than one sense on the third ran with a

mean of 3.43; and Emphasizes proper sequence on the last rank with a mean of 3.3. The

overall mean of Demonstration Method is 3.43which is qualitatively described as

“Effective”.

In Lecture Method, the following techniques are described as “Effective” with an

overall mean of 3.41; Helps students clarify and illustrate ideas and Supplements other

methods of instruction on the first rank with a mean of 3.47; Provides effective use of

time and manpower on the second rank with a mean of 3.44; Uses questions to achieve

active participation on the third rank with a mean of 3.42; and Presents facts and

principles orally on the last rank with a mean of 3.27.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 69
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

The following techniques on Question and Answer Method are described as

“Effective” with an overall mean of 3.35: Allows students enough time to think about and

give an answer on the first rank with a mean of 3.49; Acknowledges all answers to ensure

incorrect or vague answers are clarified on the second rank with a mean of 3.47; Asks

questions to promote thinking in students and get them involved on the third rank with a

mean of 3.43; Distributes questions in random on the fourth rank with a mean of 3.24;

and Avoids frequent group or choral responses on the last rank with a mean of 3.13.

In Reporting method, the following techniques are described as “Effective” with

an overall mean of 3.31: Collaborates with students in class discussion about different

writing tips on the first rank with a mean of 3.4; Shares guidelines in technical writing on

the second rank with a mean of 3.37; Assigns students topics to be reported on the third

rank with a mean of 3.33; Assigns group activities to discuss writing lessons and report

the facts gathered by members in class on the fourth rank with a mean of 3.31; and

Assigns students to interview a writer and share to the class what they knew by reporting

on the last rank with a mean of 3.16.

Between the results of the teaching methods and techniques under the Four Macro

Skills, the Researchers found out that the methods and techniques used by teachers in

teaching Reading Skill ranks 1 with a mean of 3.39, in teaching Speaking Skill ranks 2

with a mean of 3.38, in teaching Writing rank 3 with a mean of 3.36, and in teaching

Listening Skill with a mean of 3.32. This finding attest that all methods and techniques

under the Four Macro Skills are effective yet among this, Reading excels.
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 70
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

On the difference between the perceptions of the student respondents in terms of

their class section, the researchers found out that there is no big difference in the results

on how they perceive their teachers teaching methods and techniques in teaching four

macro skills. Each section comes up with the same results. It falls on the criteria as an

effective methods and techniques for the learners itself.

The Researchers have proven their null hypothesis which states that there is no

significant difference between the perception of the students on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching four macro skills in terms of their class section

is correct.

Conclusions:

Based on the findings the researchers arrived at the following conclusions:

A. The perception of the students on the effectiveness of methods and techniques

used in teaching macro skills in English subject are as follows:

On Listening

1. Project Method and its techniques are effective;

2. Demonstration method and its techniques are effective;

3. Lecture Method and its techniques are effective;

4. Question and Answer Method and its techniques are effective.

On Speaking

1. Project Method and its techniques are effective;

2. Demonstration method and its techniques are effective;


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 71
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

3. Lecture Method and its techniques are effective;

4. Question and Answer Method and its techniques are effective;

5. Reporting Method and its techniques are effective.

The Methods and techniques used in teaching speaking are generally “effective”.

On Reading

1. Project Method and its techniques are effective;

2. Demonstration methodand its techniques are effective;

3. Lecture Method and its techniques are effective;

4. Question and Answer Method and its techniques are effective;

5. Reporting Methodand its techniques are effective.

The Methods and techniques used in teaching reading are generally “effective”.

On Writing

1. Project Method and its techniques are effective;

2. Demonstration method and its techniques are effective;

3. Lecture Method and its techniques are effective;

4. Question and Answer Method and its techniques are effective;

5. Reporting Method and its techniques are effective.

The Methods and techniques used in teaching listening, speaking, reading, and

writing are generally “effective”. Yet these results tend to shows that the students are
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 72
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

not yet satisfied with the methods and techniques used by their teachers in teaching

the skill of Listening though they assessed the methods and techniques as effective.

B. The perception of the students according to their class size on the effectiveness of

methods and techniques used in teaching macro skills in English subject are as

follows:

On Listening

Aristotle, Einstein, Galileo, Newton and Oersted assessed the methods and techniques

under Listening as effective.

On Speaking

Aristotle, Einstein, Galileo, Newton and Oersted assessed the methods and

techniques under Speaking as effective.

On Reading

Aristotle, Einstein, Galileo, Newton and Oersted assessed the methods and

techniques under Reading as effective.

On Writing

Aristotle, Einstein, Galileo, Newton and Oersted assessed the methods and

techniques under Writing as effective.

The Class sections namely Aristotle, Einstein, Galileo, Newton and Oersted assessed

the methods and techniques under the Four Macro Skill as effective. This finding tends to
AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 73
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

imply that the Class sections do not differ on how they perceive the effectiveness of the

methods and techniques. Also, it tends to implies that teachers do not changes their style

in using this methods and techniques in alter sections that they are teaching.

Recommendations

Based on the conclusions drawn from the findings of this study, the researchers offer the

following recommendations:

1. Since the perceptions of students on the effectiveness of methods and

techniques used by English teachers are dominated by effective and some are very

effective, it is recommended that the methods as project method, demonstration

method, lecture method, question and answer method, and reporting method must

be maintained to be used in teaching the English subject and since it is concluded

that students are yet satisfied with the effectiveness of the methods and

techniques, it is suggested that teachers must engage additional methods and

techniques in teaching the four macro skills.

2. Teachers mustn't stick to one style/strategy barely in teaching the methods. They

must know and vary their teaching styles with accordance to the learning styles of

the student/s as a class.

3. It is suggested and recommended that teachers must give their self a time to

attend seminars, workshops, symposium and the like, related to their field of

specialization to upgrade and develop continually their teaching competencies.


AN ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF METHODS AND 74
TECHNIQUES USED IN TEACHING FOUR MACRO SKILLS IN
ENGLISH SUBJECT

4. Teachers must practice to put into hobby reading latest books of specialization

in their leisure time that will, and a must, help them in updating their methods and

techniques in their respective fields.

5. In addition to the given sets of methods and techniques prepared by the

researchers, it is also suggested and recommended that the administration of the

school where this study is being conducted is ought to provide additional sets of

methods and techniques that will be implemented in order to achieve a satisfying

results both in learning outcomes and the effectiveness of the methods and

techniques used in teaching four macro skill in English subject as well as in

others.

6. Similar studies must also be conducted.

Potrebbero piacerti anche