Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
W
IE
A DISSERTATION
Submitted to the faculty of
EV
The Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago
PR
In partial Fulfillment
Of the requirement for the Degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
By
Copyright 2009 by
Luvis Nunez, Agustina
INFORMATION TO USERS
W
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy
submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and
photographs, print bleed-through, substandard margins, and improper
IE
alignment can adversely affect reproduction.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
EV
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized
copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion.
PR
UMI
UMI Microform 3353869
Copyright 2009 by ProQuest LLC.
All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against
unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code.
ProQuest LLC
789 E. Eisenhower Parkway
PO Box 1346
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346
W
IE
EV
Copyright 2009 Agustina Luvis -Nunez
All Rights Reserved
PR
-11 -
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
W
My gratitude is to all those in whose company I have walked this challenging and
illuminating journey of theological studies.
IE
Thanks for stand besides me upon my path and held out a hand when I stumbled.
I appreciate the solidarity and care of each of these people, who were willing to open
EV
doors and helped me to see my dreams come true.
PR
-m-
ABSTRACT
W
challenging and revisiting, again and again, the so called "Pentecostal gender
paradox," until gender justice is achieved.
Pentecostalism as a Christian movement has not attempted to develop a
IE
theology of the church. However from that does not follow the absence of such
doctrine. Pentecostals conceive the church as a community gifted by the Spirit to
EV
proclaim God's good news in Jesus Christ, to the whole world.
In spite of the fact that, quantitatively speaking, women represent the vast
majority of the Pentecostal membership, women have been systemically
PR
excluded from the decision making process of defining the very nature of the
church. Therefore, the kairos has come to stop invisibilizing and silencing
women's voice, and instead of that, to start thinking and walking, hand in hand,
men and women, en conjunto (in togetherness), in order to built a democratic
church.
By reclaiming the ecumenical Nicene Creed and particularly its
traditional "Marks of the church": One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic,
alternative visions of being church will become apparent. In doing that, the
dialogue has been broadened to include female interlocutors who talk the talk in
the academia and walk the walk in the congregations.
This study proposes that the gifts of the Spirit are signs of the church as
well. The concept of the notes of the church is not a common one among the
- IV -
Pentecostal tradition; nevertheless this notion is a very useful theological key
from which we can depart in order to articulate an ecclesiology that pretends to
be ecumenical. In addition, the gifts of the Spirit alongside with the marks of the
church will enrich the different denominations within Christianity.
Methodologically, this research approaches the topic of "Notes towards a
Puerto Rican Pentecostal Ecclesiology" from the theological and ethnographical
angles. It highlights the contributions of Caribbean Pentecostal women and at the
same time invites to the discussion table Hispanic and non Hispanic feminists
who have already made relevant contributions to the doctrine of ecclesiology. As
a result of this dialogue with several partners, notes towards a Puerto Rican
Pentecostal ecclesiology have been ventured.
W
The study concludes asserting that there is continuity with the
affirmation that the gifts of the Spirit are marks of the church as the traditional
IE
notae. Such declaration is based on the truth that both approaches are oriented to
praxis of love to our neighbor and consequently, the result will be a more
inclusive, ecumenical, ecological, contextual, healing, and liberating community,
EV
which is in the last analysis, a definition of what a community of the Spirit stands
for.
PR
-v-
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Copyrights ii
Acknowledgements in
Abstract iv
Introduction 1
Methodology 7
Design 10
Participants 11
W
Chapter 1 IE
Pentecostal Ecclesiology 17
Pentecostalism's Historical Background 18
Hispanic Presence 25
EV
Hispanic Pentecostalism's Origins 26
Women's Role in This "His"-tory 32
Pentecostal Contributions in the Area of Ecclesiology 39
Hispanic Pentecostal Contribution 52
Pentecostal Church Strengths 57
PR
Chapter 2
Feminist Ecclesiology 64
Christian Feminist Voices in Ecclesiology 65
Feminist Theological Anthropology: The Starting Point 82
A Little of History 84
Pentecostal Women and Gender Issues 92
Spirituality: A Point of Encounter 97
Elements of Feminist Spirituality 104
An Assessment of these various Insights in Pentecostalism and
Feminist Spirituality 113
Chapter 3
Latina Ecclesiology-State of the Question 120
Hispanic/Latina Theology Developments 121
Latina Feminist and Mujerista Theology 130
Other Voices in Hispanic/Latina Theology 135
Marks of the Church 138
Chapter 4
Pentecostal Latina Women's Voices:
A Puerto Rican Perspective 148
W
Caribbean Theology 157
Latina Pentecostal Women's Voices 168
Articulating Our Ecclesiology 179
IE
EV
Conclusions 183
Appendix
A 203
B 204
Al viento delEspiritu que se llevo,
en Pentecostes, los prejuicios,
los interesesy el miedo de los apostolus
y abrio de par en par laspuertas del cendculo,
para que la comunidad de los seguidores de Jesus
fuera siempre abierta al mundo
y litre en su palabra
y coherente en su testimonio
e invencible en su esperanza.
Al viento de su Espiritu
que se Ileva siempre los nuevos miedos de la Iglesia
Pedro Casaldaliga1
INTRODUCTION
W
My thesis is that Pentecostal women in the past and in the present continue to
challenge the "Pentecostal gender paradox,"2 namely that even when women are
IE
seldom allowed to become pastors and there are usually restrictions on their
EV
participation in the leadership of the ministry of the Word, as well as strict regulation
controlling dress and bodily adornment. However, from that does not follow that
women are mere spectators. No. Women are especially favored with spiritual gifts in
PR
a movement which is after all, expressly constituted around the gifts of the Spirit.
[To the Spirit's wind which took awayJ in Pentecost, prejudices,/ the Apostles' interests
andfears,/ and wide opened the dinning room doors,/ so that Jesus' community of followers/ were
always open to the world/ andfree in their word/ and coherent in their witnessing/ and unbeatable in
their hope./ To the Spirit's wind/ which always takes away the new fears of the church. ] Pedro
Casaldaliga, Fuego y Ceniza Al Viento (Brasil: Mato Grosso, 1983), 1.
2
This phenomenon is described by some analysts as the "Pentecostal gender paradox":
Starting with Elizabeth Brusco's pioneering study- research on Pentecostals in the developing world,
has repeatedly found that women are advantaged in new and crucial ways by the movement. See
Elizabeth Brusco,'The Reformation of Machismo: Ascetism and Masculinity among Colombian
Evangelicals," in Rethinking Protestantism in Latin America, eds. Virginia Garrard-Burnett and
David Stoll (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1994): 143-158.
- 1-
2
church that follows the traditional "marks of the church" as well as the note of being a
renewal within Christianity at the beginnings of the twentieth century. People who
participate in this renewal share an emphasis on life in the Spirit, subjective religious
experience and spiritual gifts, miracles, signs and wonders -including a language of
experiential spirituality rather than of theology - while strictly rational, scientific and
W
Veli-Matti Karkkainen argues that this form of being church opposes the
traditional concept of the church, that sometimes forces us to choose between being a
IE
free or an historical church. This alternative way of being church confronts us to
estimation, far from forcing us to decide between one and another mode of being
that there are different understandings of faith exist in new expressions in life and
that the proliferation of Pentecostal church bodies emerges from practical rather than
3
Veli-Matti Karkkainen, An Introduction to Ecclesiology: Ecumenical, Historical and
Global Perspectives (Downers Grove: Intervarsity Press, 2002).
3
ecclesiology.5 Despite this fact some theologians question this absolute affirmation.
In the case of the Church of God, a classical Pentecostal church, for example, there is
an extensive debate about the nature and purpose of the Church within its early
history.6
within the Hispanic7 Pentecostal Church. According to Justo Gonzalez, some relevant
factors may explain why the Protestant Hispanics in general have inherited a theology
W
in which ecclesiology does not play a primary role. First is the fact that Hispanics
while denying the need of the church for salvation. Fourth, it was an anti-hierarchical
PR
Protestantism in which the Church was considered an external entity apart from its
4
Frank Macchia, "Theology, Pentecostal," in International Dictionary of Pentecostals and
Charismatic Movements, ed. Stanley Burgess and Eduard Van Der Maas (Grand Rapids: Zondervan,
2002), 1137.
5
This lack of written reflections has been explained due to the strong oral and testimonial
tradition of Pentecostals and to the Pentecostal emphasis on being more "doers" than "thinkers" of
their faith and community life as well. Nevertheless, any study of the Pentecostal contribution to
ecclesiology must take into consideration the writings of Donald Gee, specifically his editorials in
Pentecost from 1947-1966; the work of John Lancaster, The Spirit-Filled Church (Springfield, MO:
Gospel Publishing House, 1987). W.G. Hathaway, The Gifts of the Spirit in the Church, 1963; R.P
Splitter, The Church, 1977; and the recent work of Miroslav Volf, After Our Likeness: The Church
as The Image of the Trinity (Grand Rapids, MI: WB Eerdmans Publishing Co. 1998).
6
Dale M. Counter, "The Development of Ecclesiology in the Church of God (Cleveland,
TN): A Forgotten Contribution?" Pneuma: The Journal of the Society for Pentecostal Studies
29(2007): 59-83.
7
1 will use interchangeably both terms Hispanic and Latino.
4
people. Fifth, and specifically in the Pentecostal Church the emphasis on the freedom
fact that Pentecostalism is not a monolithic movement. There are many categories of
work to the native and indigenous Pentecostalism, which emerges from particular
Hispanic context.
W
The intention of my study is to suggest a Pentecostal ecclesiology from the
make the greatest contribution in defining the nature of the Christian community.
EV
Long back, Simone de Beauvoir, a pioneer reflecting from a women's perspective
argued that "representation of the world, like the world itself, is the work of men;
PR
they describe it from their own point of view, which they confuse with absolute
truth."10 I would add that reflection on the topic of the church is also the work of
men, specifically in the Pentecostal context, even though history reveals that since the
beginning of the movement women were not bystanders or merely supporters. On the
contrary, they were committed and involved in every facet of ministry, despite
restrictions that had found their way into the Pentecostal movement in its earliest
stages.11
developing alternative visions of being church that are consistent with the debate
the Church is enabled by the Spirit for the transformation of the existing church and
society structures.13
W
considers the church as the "gifted community" where the gifts of the Spirit could be
in the last analysis my definition of what a "community of the Spirit," stands for.
EV
To be sure, the idea of "marks of the church" is not a common one among
important goal in my examination of this topic is to explore the way these "marks of
the church" present themselves within the context of the "charismata" of the Spirit in
perspective in the context of Puerto Rican society. This enterprise would increase
11
Estrelda Alexander, The Women ofAzusa Street ( Cleveland, Ohio: Pilgrim Press
Publishing Co., 2005).
12
1 am referring to the traditional marks of the Church: Unity, Holiness, Catholicity and
Apostolicity articulated in the Nicene Creed.
13
Among them: Letty Russell, Rosemary Radford Ruether, Elizabeth Schussler Fiorenza,
and Ada Maria Isasi-Diaz.
6
awareness of being part of the larger Christian tradition, which is lacking among the
ecclesiological debate by highlighting the role of the gifts of the Spirit for
W
taking into consideration the contributions of Pentecostal voices of the academia,
their diversity of perspectives, emphases and limitations. The second chapter will
IE
focus on the feminist debates about reconstructions or conceptualizations of the
church, their theological methods, critical theories and suggestions for a constructive
EV
transformation in the Church. Given the fact that "theological reflection works out of
14
specific contexts rather than working with generic truths," chapter four will give
PR
primarily from my cultural, social and geographic context. Finally, in the last chapter
venture to articulate the relevant features of a proposal for a Pentecostal Puerto Rican
ecclesiology.
14
Robert Kinast, What Are They Saying about Theological Reflection? (New
York/Mahwah, N.J.:Paulist Press, 2000), 1.
7
Methodology
women in the arena of ecclesiology, analyzing their proposals and reflecting on its
W
possibilities for a Hispanic Pentecostal ecclesiological proposal from women
perspective. Third, I will incorporate the cultural and ethnic dimension, grasping the
IE
work of Hispanic theologians and historians in the theme of ecclesiology.
EV
The historical and theological method will also help me to retrieve what the
Pentecostal church might learn from its Hispanic female population, not only
ordinary Pentecostal women and their experiences. For this purpose, I will conduct
interviews. 17
15
Semi-structured interviews are conducted with a fairly open framework which allow for
focused, conversational communication. They can be used both to give and receive information. Not
all questions are designed and phrased ahead of time. Some of questions are created during the
interview, allowing both the interviewer and the person being interviewed the flexibility to probe for
details or discuss issues. See Jim McMillan and Sally Schumacher, Research in Education: Evidence
Based Inquiry, 6th ed. (Lebanon, Indiana: Addison-Wesley, 2005).
16
.Even when I did not work immersed inside a specific culture other than my own, I
decided to be guided by ethnographic principles based on the fact that this methodology allow me to
present these women insights with the less mediation possible.
17
See Appendix A for the interview model.
8
researcher and his [sic] informants."18 To recover the voices and reflections of
women within the Pentecostal church, I will conduct these interviews through
conversation and dialogue as well as explore the contribution of women within the
Through these interviews, women will express their thoughts and visions of
what it means for them to be a church and how they articulate the activities of the
church in terms of: the proclamation of God's news (kerigma), the work of the people
as praise and worship of God (leitourgia), the self-giving of the church in service to
W
those in need (diakonia) and the fellowship of the church that welcomes all
"to learn from people, to be taught by them." They also make it possible to hear many
PR
18
James P. Spradley, The Ethnographic Interview (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
1979), 4.
19
The Pentecostal tradition is characterized by the predominant place that occupy orality in
their articulation of their faith, specifically in worship, through preaching, testimony, songs and so
on. But also for their capacity to serve, where other Christian traditions are not present and for the
weight of communal affection. For this reason diakonia, leitourgia, koinonia and kerigma are
relevant when Pentecostals try to explain their concept of church. These features have their
background in the biblical testimony of Acts that describes the beginnings of the church. (Acts 2:44-
47).
20
Isasi-Diaz is an exponent of Mujerista theology, which is described by her as a liberative
praxis-reflective action that has as it goals the liberation of Hispanic women. This theology brings
together feminist theology, cultural theology and liberation theology. Isasi-Diaz utilizes the
ethnography and meta-ethnography as two qualitative research methods to gather the voices and
lived experience of Hispanic women and to elaborate mujerista theology.
21
Ada Maria Isasi Diaz, En la Lucha: Elaborating a Mujerista Theology (Minneapolis:
Fortress Press, 1993), 66.
9
also theologians. When we talk about what it means to be church for women it is
necessary to listen to them and to observe them, but also to allow them to become our
teachers. The ethnography22 is a qualitative tool that allows the researcher to see
through the eyes of the one being researched. In other words, this methodology
W
that knowledge of all cultures is valuable.23 This acknowledgement has been
reflection of life in the light of their faith.24 I argue that the voices of Pentecostal
EV
Hispanic women need to be present in the theological discourse that articulates what
it means to be church today, and that they need to be considered equally valid with
PR
the dominant voices. Taking the voices of women into consideration, part of my
Hispanic Pentecostal women understand the church and its mission, to document the
existence of a concrete reality and to describe this reality in its own terms.
method of doing research is the role of participants. Usually, these participants are
22
Ethnography has been defined as " the work of describing a culture," which essential core
is the concern with the meaning of actions and events to the people we seek to understand. See James
P. Spradley, The Ethnographic Interview (USA: Wadsworth, 1979).
23
Ibid., 10
24
Clodovis Boff, Teoria delmetodo teologico (Mexico, D.F.: Ediciones Dabar, 2001).
10
approach with naive ignorance. I prefer to call them colleagues. My study is an effort
to describe and propose what it means to be the church from the perspective of
Pentecostal Hispanic women. Toward that aim, and contrary to responses to a survey
W
local theology is often set out as a project and not carried beyond the first couple of
steps. The questions are addressed to the Christian faith but there is no time to
IE
continue the dialogue. Second, due to concerns on identity, the ethnographic approach
can often overlook conflictive factors for the sake of maintaining harmony and peace
EV
in the community. There also exists the possibility to fall into a type of cultural
romanticism, leading to inability to see people own shortcomings and the sins of their
PR
historical experience. Finally, much of this analysis can be done by experts, while
Design
My research to the theological literature reveals that there has only been
modest theological work done by Pentecostals on ecclesiology, and all the work that
has been done by male theologians, who address questions that are of interest to this
population. For this reason my study can be classified as exploratory. This study
25
Robert Schreiter, Constructing Local Theologies (Maryknoll, New York: Orbis Books,
1999), 14.
11
intends to be a departing point for other works in this area. The focus will be
with the interview. This interdisciplinary methodology will allow me to hear the
voices of history but also to give voice to the ones that have never been heard.
Participants
women between 21 and 66 years old. These women are active member of various
W
Hispanic Pentecostal Churches: classical, charismatic, native, or neo-
Every interview started with a greeting and word of appreciation for the
EV
collaboration in this work. I informed each participant about my research, its aims,
responsibility to safeguard their rights, interests, and sensitivities. All agreed to have
the protection of saying things "off the record" and to decide what they did not want
Classical Pentecostals refers to those who trace their Pentecostal origins to a revival that
began on January 1st, 1901 at Charles F. Parham's Bethel Bible School in Topeka, Kansas and
William J. Seymour, a black Holiness preacher and the "outpouring of the Holy Spirit" started at
Azusa St. in Los Angeles, California on 1906, which initial evidence is speaking in tongues.
27
Charismatic refers to those Pentecostals that emerge from the Charismatic renewal
movement in the Roman Catholic Church in 1967 and other renewal transdenominational movements
among Protestants who emphasize a "life in the Spirit" and the importance of exercising
extraordinary gifts of the Spirit, including but not limited to glossolalia.
28
Native Pentecostals refers to those indigenous Pentecostal churches that grow from native
initiatives and share the emphasis in the Holy Spirit and the exercise of the gifts of the Spirit.
29
Neopentecostals is a catch-all category that comprises around 19.000 independent, non-
denominational, post denominational denominations and groups that cannot be classified as either
classic Pentecostal or charismatic but share a common emphasis on spiritual gifts, the Holy Spirit and
Pentecostal-like experiences, signs and wonders and power encounters. (See the New Dictionary of
Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements, xx)
12
compensation.30
I gave them a detailed explanation about the interview, how the questions
were going to be asked, and the language expected to be used and answered any
interest in the participant's answers, and at the same time expressed a kind of "naive
ignorance," to make them feel open and collaborative. Sometimes I repeated what
W
they expressed, and restated the participant's terms, incorporating them. The
interview atmosphere was a friendly one. These interviews are much more a
IE
conversation, a dialogue. As Spradley describes it, in this method, "the goal is to learn
from the people, to be taught by them."32 It is through their experience that the
EV
researcher can grasp what they believe and how their beliefs impact their daily life.
The interviews were conducted in the setting of the women's specific churches, at
PR
of shifts in perspective with regard to what theology is and what theologians talk
about. The Enlightenment place human beings and their experience on the intellectual
"objective" science, but had to account adequate for its "subjective" dimension. This
aperture to a new epistemology joined to an emphasis now upon context and the role
of communal experience in theological reflection created the space to hear the voices
Doing theology has to do with the lived experience of people. For this reason,
these interviews intend to look more closely at the life and experience of these
women and to take into consideration what has been overlooked for many years,
particularly their understanding of what the church must be. Today, the dominant
understandings and practices considered significant arise from the experience of men
in the Church. As Isasi-Diaz points out, "by using the lived experience of women as
W
the source of theological reflection, gives us the opportunity to be self-defining, to
give fresh answers, and, what is most important, to ask new questions."33 Vitor
IE
Westhelle affirms that "justice begins here; it begins not in fulfilling the requirements
of the prevailing regimes, but by setting other conditions, other parameters."34 In the
EV
last decades, women studies have undergone many changes that had an impact on the
feminist methodology and epistemology. The women's experience has become the
PR
to be in contact with women of faith who spend much of their lives working, serving,
worshipping and being deeply involved in the life of the church. All of the
participants in this study are known to me and had the confidence and the openness to
Rican Pentecostal women from different backgrounds, age, social status, and so on.
Then, I wrote down, their specific characteristics to be sure that the sample would be
the most representative as possible. The next step was to make appointments and to
proceed with the interview. I made written notes of their answers and their questions
as well, being conscious not to translating what they expressed. I used the insights of
these women to articulate a conception of being church that is born from their
experience.
W
In the opinion of many analysts, Pentecostalism is an expression of the
popular religion of the marginalized communities. Orlando Espin,35 who has worked
IE
on popular Catholicism, has identified this religious expression as one of the most
history in the medieval age, in the pre- reformation Spanish Christianity and the pre-
PR
Tridentine ages. In the Hispanic community it has been a response to the imposition
of beliefs of the hierarchical and patriarchal church, which in the name of God and in
the name of the evangelization of the New World tried to eradicate any sign of the
kidnapped African people from their homelands to use them as instruments of forced
Christianity came into being when native indigenous people and enslaved African
people adopted Christianity in a native and African way. Espin points out that popular
35
Orlando Espin and Roberto S. Goizueta, The Faith of the People: Theological Reflections
on Popular Catholicism (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1997).
15
religion is popular because is one created, practiced and lived by the marginalized
people.
struggle. Their fiestas, celebrations, family concept, community, and prayers give
people the strength, faith and hope to their daily struggles and also help them to voice
W
and to act their own spirituality. Sometimes it represents the only vehicle available for
them to express their understanding of themselves, the world or the Divine. Espin
IE
affirms that Hispanic popular religion has theological significance, pastoral
alternative religious response for the Hispanic community. Even while Latino
PR
Pentecostalism rejects many medieval and colonial Catholic symbols and practices, it
has managed to hold on to the very "sacramental," symbolic ethos and worldview that
Catholic Charismatic movements among U.S. Latinos has to do with the crucial role
Orlando Espin, The Faith of the People: Theological Reflections on Popular Catholicism
(Maiyknoll, N.Y: Orbis Books, 1997).
16
reflection.
W
IE
EV
PR