Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
OPERATIONS
GUIDE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION TO OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT .................................................................................. 3
1. FORECASTING ............................................................................................................................................... 5
3. PRODUCTION STRATEGIES........................................................................................................................ 13
4. PROCESS SELECTION................................................................................................................................... 15
6. SCHEDULING ................................................................................................................................................. 22
8. QUALITY MANAGEMENT..........................................................................................................................…27
It involves ensuring that the business operations are efficient and effective.
Few examples are:
OPERATIONS
INPUT MANAGEMENT
OUTPUT
Goods are physical items which include raw material, parts, sub-assemblies and
final products. Ex: Automobile, Computer, Shampoo
Services are activities that provide some combination of time,
location, form or psychological value. Ex: Air travel, Education, Haircut
Scope of Operations Management:
Forecasting
Product/Service design
Capacity planning and scheduling
Inventory management
3|Page
Quality Assurance
Location/Layout Planning
Decision Making:
Decision making is the selection of a course of action among available
alternatives. Some factors which affect decisions are:
Cost
Quality
Environmental issues
Capacity
Employee skill set
Productivity
Safety
Vendor Relations
The primary function of the operations manager is to guide the system by
taking the right decisions.
4|Page
1. DEMAND FORECASTING
Forecasting is estimating or predicting the future based on the analysis of past
and present data. Forecasting is used in operations to match the supply and
demand. A demand forecast is essential to determine the supply/production
to match the demand.
Categories of forecasting methods:
Qualitative
Time series
Causal
Simulation Models
5|Page
Qualitative method:
This method is appropriate when requisite past data is not available. These are
subjective or judgemental and are based estimates or opinion of experts. Ex:
Phasing out subsidies on LPG can raise questions about the validity of past data
for future LPG sales prediction. Popular qualitative methods are
1) Grass Roots - It is a method which base on the concept of asking the people
who are close to the eventual consumer, such as sales person, each member
of the sales force report the trends of their own region, until the entire
forecast is built up, therefore it also call “Sale Force Forecast”. For eg., an
overall sales forecast can be delivered by combining the inputs from each
sales person who is closest to his/her territory.
2) Market Research – Set out to collect data in a variety of ways (surveys,
interviews and so on) to test the hypotheses about the market. This is
typically used to forecast long-range and new product sales.
3) Panel Consensus – Free open exchange at meetings. The idea is
discussion by the group will produce better forecast, than one individual.
Participants may be executives, salespeople, or customers.
4) Historical Analogy – Ties what is being forecasted to the similar item.
It is important in planning demand forecasts of new products.
5) Delphi Method – In this method a group of experts respond to a
questionnaire. A moderator then compiles the results, refines forecasts
and conditions, and again formulates a new questionnaire that is
submitted to the group. Usually, this process is repeated thrice before
satisfactory results are achieved.
6|Page
moving average can be useful in removing the random fluctuations for
forecasting.
The longer the moving average period, the more the random elements are
smoothed (which may be desirable in many cases). But if there is a trend
in the data – either decreasing or increasing – the moving average has
the adverse characteristics of lagging the trend.
7|Page
Forecast error:
Difference between forecast value and actual value.
Causal methods:
Identifying the factors that influence the forecasted variable. Ex: Making use of
weather report to predict the sales of umbrella. Regression analysis is the
most common causal method. This may contain multiple variables.
8|Page
Simulation Models:
Dynamic models, usually computer based, that allow the forecaster to make
assumptions about the internal variables and external environment in the
model. Depending on the variables in the model, the forecaster may get the
effect of changes like increase in price, decrease in recession, etc.
Here are four primary causes of forecast error:
9|Page
Evolution of Forecasting:
Forecasting is not a recent concept and it has proved its existence since early
ages. Read about its evolution over years and how it advanced from
rudimentary intuition to a high technology machine learning based concept.
Link:http://www.supplychain247.com/images/pdfs/ToolsGroup_The_Evoluti
on_o
f_Forecasting.pdf
10 | P a g e
2. PRODUCT AND SERVICE DESIGN
Activities and responsibilities of product and service design include:
1. Translate customer wants and needs into product and
service requirements
2. Refine existing products and services
3. Develop new product and/or services
4. Formulate goods quality
5. Formulate target costs
6. Construct and test prototypes
7. Document specifications
12 | P a g e
Product Cycle with 4 Ps
11 | P a g e
Product Life Cycle vs. Service Life Cycle:
In simple terms, the product life cycle indicates the revenue amount generated by a
product over a period of time, right from its inception to its discontinuation. There are five
common stages that make up a product cycle. These are
1. Development/planning
2. Introduction/initiation
3. Execution/sales
4. Maturity/growth
5. Decline
A service organization will have to handle a service life cycle as opposed to a product life
cycle. What does the management of a service life cycle entail? It is essentially a strategy
which offers support to service organizations, helping them realize their gross revenue
potential. The service life cycle management typically includes these critical elements:
1. Administration of workforce
2. Planning/forecasting of components
3. Organizational asset management
4. Knowledge administration
5. Reverse logistics
6. Management of repair and returns
7. Contract management
What is Common?
While the product life cycle and service life cycle may be managed differently in an
organization, they are both determined by the time period for which they can be marketed.
For instance, the life cycle of TV CRT (cathode ray tube) has come to an end since a greater
number of flat screen TVs are being bought by people today. Similarly, the era of VoIP
(voice-over internet protocol) telephone services is now in its growth phase with more and
more people showing an inclination to try it out. Hence, the service life cycle of traditional
phone lines is slowing coming to an end.
When you have awareness regarding where your service of product is in the life cycle
stage, you are better able to determine adjustments or refinements that need to be made so
that they are kept aligned with the already developed vision, goals and strategy.
12 | P a g e
3. PRODUCTION STRATEGIES
14 | P a g e
4. PROCESS SELECTION
Process selection is deciding the way production of goods and services will
be organized.
Major implications:
Capacity Planning
Facilities Layout
Equipment
Work Systems Design
Process selection criteria (Product-Process Matrix):
15 | P a g e
Variety – How much
Flexibility – What degree
Volume – Expected output
Process Types:
Job shop – Small scale, high customization and low volume. Ex:
Appliance repair
Batch – Moderate volume, narrower range of products and lesser
customization. Ex: Bakery
Repetitive/assembly line – High volume and standardized product.
Ex: Automatic car wash
Continuous – High volume and non-discrete goods/services. Ex: Oil
Process automation:
16 | P a g e
Robot – A mechanical agent guided by electronic circuitry or computer
program
Manufacturing cell – Machine sets grouped by parts or products they
produce
Flexible manufacturing system (FMS) – Allows flexibility in case of
predicted or unpredicted changes
Computer integrated manufacturing (CIM) – A system for linkingbroad
range of manufacturing activities through an integrated computer
system
Line balancing:
Line Balancing is levelling the workload across all processes in a cell or value
stream to remove bottlenecks and excess capacity. A constraint slows the
process down and results if waiting for downstream operations and excess
capacity results in waiting and no absorption of fixed costs.
17 | P a g e
5. FACILITY LAYOUT
Arrangement of machinery, equipment and other industrial facilities
with the aim of achieving production in least possible time and cost.
Factors determining layout:
Ease of future expansion
Output needs
Space Utilization
Shipping and receiving
Safety
Types of layout:
Product layout: Machines arranged in one line depending on sequence of
operations. Ex: Paper mill.
Process layout:
Grouping of similar machines into one department. Ex: Grinding
machines, painting shop, etc.
18 | P a g e
Fixed position layout:
Men and machine are moved around to build a bulky product. Ex: Ship
assembly.
19 | P a g e
Combination layout:
Combination of product and process layout. Ex: Supermarket
20 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 5
21 | P a g e
6. SCHEDULING
The process of determining the job order on some machine or in some work
centre is known as sequencing or priority sequencing. Some of the priority
rules for obtaining a job sequence on single machine are:
1) First Come First Serve (FCFS) – Orders are run in the order they arrive
in the department.
2) Shortest Operating Time (SOT) – Run the job with shortest
completion time first, next-shortest time second, and so on. This is
sometimes also referred to as SPT (shortest processing time).
3) Earliest Due Date (EDD) – Run the jobs with the earliest due date first.
4) Slack Time Remaining (STR) – This is calculated as the time remaining
before the due date minus the processing time remaining.
Gantt Charts
It is a bar chart that plots tasks against time. Gantt charts are used for
project planning as well as to co-ordinate a number of scheduled activities.
22 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 6
23 | P a g e
7. CAPACITY PLANNING
Capacity planning process determines the production capacity an
organization needs to meet with change in demand for its process.
Maximum capacity -> Maximum amount of product a company is
capable of producing
Effective capacity -> Maximum amount of product a company is
capable of producing due to constraints
24 | P a g e
Match strategy – Match strategy is adding capacity in small amounts in
response to changing demand in the market. This is a more moderate
strategy.
25 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 7
26 | P a g e
8. QUALITY MANAGEMENT
The act of overseeing all activities and tasks needed to maintain a desired level of
excellence. This includes creating and implementing quality planning and
assurance, as well as quality control and quality improvement.
Determinants of Quality
Design
Conformance to Design
Ease of Use
After Sales Service
Costs of Quality
Failure costs: Costs incurred by defective parts/products or faulty
services
Appraisal costs: Costs of activities designed to ensure quality or
uncover defects
Prevention costs: All TQ training, TQ planning, customer assessment,
process control and quality improvement costs to prevent defects from
occurring
Total Quality Management
A philosophy that involves everyone in an organization in a continual effort
to improve quality and achieve customer satisfaction.
27 | P a g e
9. SIX SIGMA
Six sigma is a disciplined, data driven approach and methodology to help
eliminate defects in a process, from manufacturing to transactional, and from
product to service. Six Sigma is:
A Philosophy
Make fewer mistake in all that we do
A statistical measure
Help gauge adequacy of the product, process and service.
A metric
A measuring system
A business strategy
28 | P a g e
Seven basic tools of quality
29 | P a g e
Process Capability
Once a process has been determined to be stable, it is necessary to determine if
the process is capable of producing output that is within an acceptable range.
Tolerances or specifications
Process variability
Natural or inherent variability in a process
Process capability
30 | P a g e
Is Six Sigma Killing Your Company's Future?
Six Sigma and other efficiency seeking approaches can dramatically reduce
variance and inefficiency in an organization. But if you’re not careful,
innovation and growth may be swept away in the process.
Credit for coining the term “Six Sigma”, the ubiquitous quality improvement
model, goes to an engineer named Bill Smith who helped Motorola realize an
estimated $16 Billion in savings in the 1980s as a result of standardizing core
processes. Six Sigma is effectively a means for identifying and eliminating
variance, and companies around the world have built entire cultures upon this
foundational concept.
Variance is the very characteristic that dictates the rate at which evolution in
nature occurs. Consider the countless number of times that your cells divide
to make you who you are. Now consider that each time a cell replicates, it
must copy and transmit the exact same sequence of 3 billion nucleotides to its
daughter cells. Inevitably, errors occur—and much more often than you might
expect. Yet it is these errors in DNA replication that have allowed single-cell
organisms to evolve into the unimaginably complex beings that we are today.
Listen to any CEO these days, and at first glance, they would seem to be the
opposite of this variation-averse type – leading organizations that are built for
innovation and entrepreneurship. But there's an older, efficiency-driven part
of the culture that fights like hell to defend the status quo.
31 | P a g e
10. LEAN OPERATION
Greater productivity
Lower costs
Shorter cycle times
Higher quality
Some terms:
32 | P a g e
Heijunka – Workload levelling
33 | P a g e
7 Types of Waste (Muda):
Defects
Overproduction
Inventories
Over processing
Unnecessary movement
Unnecessary transport and handling of goods
Waiting time
34 | P a g e
11. TOYOTA PRODUCTION SYSTEM
7 Principles of Toyota
Production System:
Quality at source
Equipment maintenance
Pull system
Supplier involvement
Andon (Signboard):
Mura:
Muri:
35 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 11
36 | P a g e
12. INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory:
The raw material, work in progress and finished goods that are considered to be
a portion of business’ assets that are ready or will be ready for sale.
Inventory management:
Inventory costs:
Holding/carrying cost – Cost to carry an item in inventory for lngth of
time, usually a year
Ordering cost – Cost of ordering and receiving inventory
Safety stock:
Stock held in excess of expected demand due to variable demandand/or
lead time. Safety stock depends upon:
Average demand rate and average lead time
Demand and lead time variability
Desired service level
39 | P a g e
Economic Order Quantity (EOQ):
Fixed order quantity that will minimize total annual inventory costs
Demand rate
Lead time
Extent of demand and/or lead time variability
Degree of stock out risk acceptable to management
Reorder point = d x LT
D -> demand rate
LT -> lead time
Methods of inventory analysis:
Pareto analysis:
40 | P a g e
80% of stock movements are for 20% of our products
41 | P a g e
Vendor Managed Inventory (VMI):
Advantages of VMI:
Example: Walmart
42 | P a g e
13. THEORY OF CONSTRAINTS
TOC states that a supply chain is no stronger than its weakest link.
The weakest link is called bottleneck.
The purpose of TOC for an organization is to continuously increase
value for its stakeholders in the present and in future.
TOC identifies the weakest link and thereby improves the productivity
of the entire supply chain.
43 | P a g e
Drum is the rate or pace of production set by system’s constraint
Link: http://www.tocinstitute.org/theory-of-constraints.html
44 | P a g e
13. SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
45 | P a g e
Supply chain management (SCM)
46 | P a g e
Supply chain performance metrics:
Bullwhip effect:
47 | P a g e
Applications of a Supply Chain Management System:
Point-of-Sale Synchronization
When all facets of the supply chain have the same data at the same time, the
increased efficiency of information removes data lags and saves costs. The
textile firm Milliken & Company was one of the first companies to use point-
of-sale data from retail outlets to link up to their manufacturing facilities.
Before the synchronization efforts, the company would take 18 weeks to fill
an order from retailers. The increased data efficiency allowed Milliken to cut
that time down to three weeks.
Web-Based Supply Chain Management System
The U.S. Department of Agriculture developed a Web-based solution for
farmers and ranchers seeking to communicate with distributors and
wholesalers. The Web-Based Supply Chain Management System consists of
commercially available software packages that provide an integrated system
to purchase, track and order agricultural products. The Internet-based system
allows all the participants in the supply chain to obtain the information they
need.
Supply Chain Failiures
When the supply chain management system fails, every entity in that chain
feels the effects. In 1999, retail giant Toys"R"Us promised to deliver all online
orders placed before December 10 by Christmas. The company's Internet
servers were not equipped to handle the traffic and thousands of orders went
unfulfilled. The company received thousands of angry emails and telephone
calls, and some employees worked seven straight weeks without a day off to
fill orders. As a result, Toys"R"Us outsourced its order fulfillment to
Amazon.com.
48 | P a g e
14. LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT
Logistics Models
First Party Logistics (1PL) Concerns beneficial cargo owners which
can be the shipper (such as a manufacturing firm delivering to
customers) or the consignee (such as a retailer picking up cargo from a
supplier). They dictates the origin (supply) and the destination
(demand) of the cargo with distribution being an entirely internal
process assumed by the firm. With globalization and the related
49 | P a g e
outsourcing and offshoring of manufacturing, distribution services
that used to be assumed internally tend be contracted to external
service providers.
Second Party Logistics (2PL) Concerns the carriers that are providing
a transport service over a specific segment of a transport chain. It
could involve a maritime shipping company, a rail operator or a
trucking company that are hired to haul cargo from an origin (e.g. a
distribution centre) to a destination (e.g. a port terminal).
Third-party logistics (3PL) are firms that perform most or all of
thelogistics functions that manufacturers, suppliers and distributors
would normally perform themselves. They are:
Freight forwarders
Courier companies
Other companies integrating & offering subcontracted logistics and
transportation services
Fourth Party Logistics (4PL) differs from third party logistics in the
following ways;
4PL organization is often a separate entity established as a joint
venture or long-term contract between a primary client and one or
more partners
50 | P a g e
Reverse Logistics:
A process of reclaiming recyclable and reusable materials, returnsand
reworks from the point of consumption or sue for repair,
remanufacturing, redistribution or disposal.
Intermodal Transportation:
Freight forwarders:
Firms that accumulate small shipments into larger lots and then hire a
carrier to move them, usually at reduced rates.
Lead time:
Lag from ordering an item until it is received and ready for use
or sale. Also called order cycle time or replenishment time.
Intermodal transportation:
51 | P a g e
The 7 Trends Shaping the Future of the Logistics Industry
In today’s society, technology has been changing at an unprecedented pace.
Logistics industry trends have also not been left behind in the move towards a
more technological future.
Link: http://cerasis.com/2016/12/16/logistics-industry/
52 | P a g e
15. PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Objectives:
Make strategic business decisions
Control the minute detail that is necessary to finish projects
Understand current resource demands, set priorities and evaluate
long term staffing requirementsUse skilled resources effectively
Reorganize projects
Dimensions of project planning:
53 | P a g e
4 stages or phases of project:
1. Initiation:
the project objective or need is identified
response to the need is documented
Feasibility study is done
2. Planning:
project solution is further developed in as
much detail as possible
team identifies all of the work to be done
Schedules are prepared and costs are
estimated
54 | P a g e
3. Execution :
project plan is put into motion
Communication is focused upon as well as control
4. Closure:
Emphasis is on releasing the final deliverables to the customer
Milestone:
End of a stage that marks the completion of a work package/phase
Signals the completion of a key deliverable
Project monitoring done based on milestones
Critical path:
55 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 15
56 | P a g e
16. MRP and ERP
The MRP system provides the user with information about timing and
quantity, generates new orders and reschedules existing orders as necessary
to meet the changing requirements of customers and manufacturing.
MRP Inputs:
Next step in the evolution that began with MRP and evolved into MRP II
Represents an expanded effort
57 | P a g e
ERP systems are composed of a collection of integrated modules
58 | P a g e
17. Service Operations Management
59 | P a g e
3) Perishability - Because a service cannot be stored, it is lost forever if it is
not used. The full utilisation of service capacity is a challenge due to
customer demand variations.
4) Intangibility - Services are Ideas and concepts which follows that any
service innovation is not patentable.
5) Heterogeneity - Due to the intangibility & participation of the customer,
the service delivery system varies from customer to customer.
60 | P a g e
3) Relationship with Customer
61 | P a g e
Quick Reads – Chapter 17
Service Operations:
Services operations often encounter different opportunities and challenges
than tangible goods, and thus require unique operational considerations.
Link: https://www.boundless.com/business/textbooks/boundless-business-
textbook/operations-management-10/introduction-to-operations-
management-69/service-operations-329-1656/
62 | P a g e
18. Emerging Technology in Supply Chain Management
Innovation is altering traditional, linear supply chains into ones that are more
connected, intelligent, scalable, and nimble. The emerging technologies are
creating what is called as an “always-on” supply chain which is an integrated
set of supply chain networks characterized by continuous, high-velocity flow
of information and analytics, creating predictive, actionable decisions that
better serve the customer. Sensors are enabling data collection, advancements
in computing power have improved predictive analytics, and supplemental
tools – such as automation and wearables – are creating digital, continuously
operating supply chains and unified networks of supply chain workers.
1) IoT (Internet of Things)
63 | P a g e
Predictive Maintenance: predictive maintenance utilizes sensors and
connected devices to monitor and react to issues. IoT allows companies to
manage products remotely by fixing sensors on the product which helps
monitor consumption conditions to decide timely repair and up gradation
activities. This self-diagnosis capability can detect a potential issue before
there’s a failure, order a replacement part and even schedule maintenance to
avoid costly downtime.
2) Artificial Intelligence
Artificial intelligence can be defined as the use of computers to
simulate human intelligence, specifically including learning – the
acquisition and classification of information, and reasoning – finding
insights into the data. At the core of artificial intelligence is the ability to
recognize patterns across the 3Vs of big data (volume, velocity and variety)
and find correlations among diverse data.
Ai in manufacturing and supply chain automation: Siemens in its
“lights out” manufacturing plant, has automated some of its production
64 | P a g e
lines to a point where they are run unsupervised for several weeks.
The demand and order information would automatically get converted
into work orders and be incorporated into the production process.
AI in supplier management and customer service: IPsoft’s AI
platform, Amelia automates work knowledge and is able to speak to
the customers in more than 20 languages. A global oil and gas
company has trained Amelia to help provide prompt and more
efficient ways of answering invoicing queries from its suppliers.
AI in logistics & warehousing: DHL uses autonomous vehicles such
as forklifts to support 24x7 operations in high-volume warehouses
driving higher service levels and immediate signaling of inventory
movements.
The next step would be driver less autonomous vehicles undertaking
goods delivery operations.
AI in procurement: The procurement spend data is automatically
classified by AI software and is checked for compliance and any
exceptions in real time. The AI algorithm analyzes HR and finance data,
procurement requests, tender approvals, workflows, and vendor
employee to identify potentially corrupt or negligent practices.
3) Blockchain
65 | P a g e
ledger as transactions that would identify the parties involved, as well
as the price, date, location, quality and state of the product and any
other information that would be relevant to managing the supply
chain. The public availability of the ledger would make it possible to
trace back every product to the very origin of the raw material used.
The decentralized structure of the ledger would make it impossible for
any one party to hold ownership of the ledger and manipulate the data
to their own advantage. And the cryptography-based and immutable
nature of the transactions would make it nearly impossible to
compromise the ledger.
66 | P a g e
All of these technologies can either be a source of competitive
advantage or a source of disruption for supply chains. They can deliver
massive economic and environmental rewards or threats. They can
boost productivity and sustainability, drive new markets, and
encourage innovation, resulting in exponential change for industry and
society as a whole.
67 | P a g e
19. GST and Supply Chain
Under GST inter-state sales transactions between two dealers would be cost
equivalent compared with stock transfers / branch transfers. According to the
proposed model, centre would levy IGST which would be CGST plus SGST on
all interstate transactions of taxable goods and services. The inter-state seller
will pay IGST on value addition after adjusting available credit of IGST, CGST,
and SGST on his purchases. Similarly the importing dealer will claim credit of
IGST while discharging his output tax liability in his own State. This will result
in inter-state sales transaction becoming tax neutral when compared to intra-
state sales. India would become one single common market no longer divided
by state borders.
Warehouse Engineering
68 | P a g e
Logistics
69 | P a g e
20. E-Way Bill
The E-way bill, short form for electronic way bill, is a document to be
generated online under the GST system, when goods of the value of more
than ₹50,000 are shipped inter-State or intra-State. The E-way bill must be
raised before the goods are shipped and should include details of the goods,
their consignor, recipient and transporter. The transporter has to carry the
invoice and the copy of E-way bill as support documents for the movement of
goods. He can also carry the E-way bill number, mapped to an RFID (radio
frequency identification device).
GST laws flexibly allow any of the parties to a transaction — the consignor or
the recipient — to generate the E-way bill, provided they are registered.
Whether goods are transported on one’s own or hired conveyance, by air, rail
or road, the E-way bill has to be generated. Where the goods are handed over
to a transporter for conveyance by road and neither the consignor nor the
consignee has generated the E-way Bill, the transporter becomes liable to
generate it.
When the consignor or transporter generates the E-way bill, the recipient for
the consignment has to either accept or reject it on the portal. If no action is
taken by the recipient in 72 hours, it shall be taken as accepted.
70 | P a g e
Why should you care?
The LPI Survey by World Bank in 2014 put logistics costs at 14 per cent of the
total value of goods in India, while it is only 6-8 per cent in other major
countries. The GST E-way bill combination was expected to trim logistics costs
by 20 per cent.
Both the GST levy and the E-way bill were expected to root out such transit
delays, while at the same time plugging tax evasion. Every E-way bill
generated by a sender or buyer of goods is to be automatically updated in the
outward sales return (GSTR1) of the supplier, leaving little scope for tax
evasions on shipments.
71 | P a g e
21. REVERSE ENGINEERING AND ITS IMPORTANCE IN NEW
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
Two decades back, CAD/CAM was a new domain in the field of new product
development (NPD), and the manufacturing industry started using this
technology mainly used to reduce product design cycle after it was universally
accepted and people trusting this technology.
A decade later, many of them realised that new product development is
essentially 60% to 70% of derivatives from the existing products available in
India as well as abroad. Then what is the need to reinvent the wheel when it is
already there? This was the stage where the role of Reverse Engineering came
into play. Nowadays, the early technology adopters have started using
terminologies such as 3D digitising, white light scanning and laser scanning
which are predominantly used for copying the available product as it is.
Today, CAD/CAM has become an essential and integral part of NPD and
people have started looking for the advances in this domains such as
Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) to validate product development as also
to reduce design cycle time and so reverse engineering techniques have
started picking up effectively.
This is the decade of 3D printing, conventionally popular as Rapid
Prototyping. Even as this technology has been creating waves globally for the
last two decades, it is witnessing a rapid change and today is not only
restricted to plastics and polymers resins, but has spread its wings in metal
printing, ceramic printing and pattern, jewellery design, titanium etc. Even
some bio-compatible materials can also be fitted into a human body with the
help of this technology.
72 | P a g e
The basic input for 3D printing is steriolithography (STL) file which can be
obtained from your CAD i.e. 3D solid modelling. As the usage of CAD,
particularly 3D animation, 2D drafting to get an engineering drawing and CNC
programming for usage on CNC milling, turning and wire cut machine, is
increasing by the day, the requirement of CAD modelling is huge compared to
the available resources. Hence alternative methods such as reverse
engineering is easy and fast besides it reduces the overall design cycle time.
In the conventional method of NPD, the concept was jotted down on sketch
mode with designer and after getting the approval from marketing
department, it is dimensionally constrained by the engineer. Later, a mock up
or handmade prototype or even a clay model used to be prepared. This
process is very long and prone to lot of errors in the manufacturing process.
Instead of this conventional method, the CAD/CAM usage along with reverse
engineering and 3D printing gives the prototypes faster and more accurate.
The quality of the product can also be enhanced by doing more and more
validity iteration on the same model.
72 | P a g e
Top Supply Chain Innovations to Look Out For
73 | P a g e
4) Workplace Safety – Using Wearable Devices to Protect Workers in
Extreme Environment
North Star BlueScope Steel, a steel producer for global building and
construction industries, is taking part in a research project that uses
Internet of Things (IoT) technology developed by IBM Watson to
protect workers in extreme environments. The research project aims
to identify potentially troublesome conditions by collecting data from
various sensors that continuously monitor the worker’s skin body
temperature, heart rate, galvanic skin response and level of activity,
correlated with sensor data for ambient temperature and humidity.
74 | P a g e
drones cannot create any spark even if they were to crash. The use of
drones is cost-effective as there can be high costs for on-board delivery
of small parcels, filled with urgent spare parts or mail. Costs for a barge
are on average $1,000 and can be higher. Drone use with the current
payload could bring potential savings of $3,000-$9,000 per vessel per
year.
75 | P a g e
are ready to go to the next work area within Itamco’s manufacturing
facilities. Each forklift is linked to Itamco’s ERP system through its GPS
and an application on a smart tablet mounted in the forklift. Forklift
operators are notified via their smart devices when they’re needed.
Itamco has seen a 10% reduction in the time it takes to get material
ready for the next operation.
76 | P a g e
Case Study: Domino’s India Logistics Management
Introduction
In early 2000, Pawan Bhatia (Bhatia), the CEO of Domino's Pizza India
(Domino's) was a man in a hurry. Ever since Bhatia took over as the CEO of
Domino's in November 1999, he had been frantically reworking the pizza
chain's India strategy. Bhatia was planning to open 150 new outlets by the end
of 2002 covering 23 cities,1 including Bhubaneshwar (Orissa) and Jamshedpur
(Bihar). In late 1999, Indocean Chase, the private equity fund bought a 25%
stake in Domino's operations in India from the Delhi-based industrial family,
the Bhartias, who held Domino's franchise in India. Domino's told investment
bankers at the fund that it planned to go in for an initial public offering (IPO)
in the next two years. Indocean Chase advised Domino's to go beyond its 16
outlets in Delhi to exploit the potential in the pizza delivery business. Unless a
well-thought-out expansion plan was put into place, the IPO was unlikely to
find too many takers.
As part of its expansion plans Domino's revamped its entire supply chain
operations, from sourcing raw materials to shipping them for processing at a
central location to delivering it to the customer's.
Analysts felt that Domino's had to rethink its supply chain operation because
it was the biggest area of costs. Since 75% of Domino's customers ordered
either from office or home, it did not have to lease large plots of land in prime
locations to attract traffic. Instead, it needed an efficiently managed call centre
to bring better returns.
77 | P a g e
In the late 1950s, Dominick De Varti (Varti) owned a small pizza store named
DomiNick's Pizza on the Eastern Michigan University campus in Ypsilanti,
Michigan. In 1960, two brothers who were students of the University of
Michigan - Thomas S. Monaghan (Thomas) and James S. Monaghan (James) -
bought the store for US$900. In 1961, James sold his share of business to
Thomas.
The pizza business did well and by 1965, Thomas was able to open two more
stores in the town - Pizza King and Pizza from the Prop. Within a year, Varti
opened a pizza store in a neighborhood town with the same name, DomiNick's
Pizza. Thomas decided to change the name of his first store, DomiNick's Pizza,
and one of his employees suggested the name Domino's Pizza (Domino's). The
advantage of this name Thomas felt was that it would be listed after DomiNick
in the directory. Domino's philosophy rested on two principles - limited menu
and delivering hot and fresh pizzas within half-an-hour. In 1967, it opened the
first franchise store in Ypsilanti, and in 1968, a franchise store in Burlington,
Vermont.
However, the company ran into problems when its headquarters (the first
store) and commissary were destroyed by fire. In the early 1970s, the
company faced problems again when it was sued by Amstar, the parent
company of Domino Sugar for trademark infringement. Thomas started
looking for a new name and came up with Red Domino's and Pizza's Dispatch.
However, there wasn't any need for it because Domino's won the lawsuit in
1980.
78 | P a g e
segment also. Little Caeser was eating into Domino's market share with its
innovative marketing strategies.
By 1989, Domino's sales had reduced significantly and cash flows were
affected due to the acquisition of assets. In 1993, Thomas took measures to
expand Domino's product line, in an attempt to revive the company and tackle
competition. The company introduced pan pizza and bread sticks in the US. In
late 1993, Domino's introduced the Ultimate Deep Dish Pizza and Crunchy
Thin Crust Pizza. In 1994, it rolled out another non-pizza dish - Buffalo Wings.
Though Domino's did not experiment with its menu for many years, the
company adopted innovative ways in managing a pizza store. Thomas gave
about 90% of the franchisee agreements in the US to people who had worked
as drivers with Domino's. The company gave ownership to qualified people,
after they had successfully managed a pizza store for a year and had
completed a training course. Domino's also gave franchises to candidates
recommended by existing franchisees. Outside the US, most of Domino's
stores were franchise-owned. Domino's was also credited for many
innovations in the pizza industry and setting standards for other pizza
companies. It had developed dough trays, corrugated pizza boxes, insulated
bags for delivering pizzas, and conveyor ovens.
79 | P a g e
there was a delay in delivery. For the first 4 years in India, Domino's
concentrated on its 'Delivery' strategy.
Thus in early 2000, Domino's came out with its own logistics model. It began
at the point Domino's purchased wheat for making the pizza dough. Domino's
first decided the procurement strategy for its key raw materials: wheat, baby
corn, tomatoes and spices.3 For instance, wheat was cheapest in Jalandhar's
(Punjab) wholesale markets. Domino's refrigerated trucks got the wheat back
to the commissary in Delhi. Commissary processed the wheat and prepared
the pizza dough.
The pizza dough and other items prepared in commissaries were then sent to
the retail outlets again in refrigerated trucks. The temperature inside the
truck was fixed based on the distance between the retail outlets and the
commissaries. This was to set the dough at a particular level when it reached
the outlets. The retail outlets had to use up the processed dough within three
days of delivery. If they failed to do so for some reason the entire quantity was
discarded. To get to Jalandhar, the trucks had to pass Chandigarh. Chandigarh
with a cosmopolitan population, was a potential market for Domino's
products.
80 | P a g e
Therefore, Domino's opened an outlet there. The cost of entry was low
because there was no additional costs incurred on transportation of products.
Domino's opened an outlet in every potential market, which fell enroute
between the commissary in Delhi and Jalandhar, it prime sourcing base. The
same logic was extended to Shimla. Shimla was just a three-hour drive away
from Chandigarh; it had a large market, especially in the tourist season. On the
way back to Delhi, the trucks could pick up cheese from Karnal, a town on the
Chandigarh-Delhi highway, and transport it to its commissaries across the
country.
Earlier, if Domino's had to open a new outlet, the commissary in Delhi would
have to process the raw material and send it to the outlet. The truck would
return empty. With the revamped supply chain, Domino's was able to leverage
its fleet much better (Figure I explains how Domino's new hub-and-spoke
model worked. There were two hubs in the northern region—the commissary
in Delhi and the principal sourcing area in Jalandhar. The spokes were Shimla
and Chandigarh).
Bhatia planned to extend the model to other parts of the country as well. The
commissary was to be located near the largest market in that region. Bhatia
said, "Our roll-out began only after we mapped out our procurement
strategy." Based on the agricultural map of India, Domino's looked for the best
product at the lowest cost. Thus, tomatoes would come from Bhubaneshwar,
spices from the south, baby corn from Nepal (where it's 40% cheaper than in
India) and vegetables from Sri Lanka (Refer Table I). Similarly, Domino's India
planned to extend its operations to Nepal, Sri Lanka and Dhaka. The company
planned to establish a commissary in Sri Lanka.
81 | P a g e
to all the other commissaries. Similarly, the northern commissary had to
deliver pizza bases. This way, Domino's minimized duplication as well as the
dangers of perishability. Once the new model was formalized, Bhatia planned
to use Domino's 25 refrigerated trucks4 to transport products for other
companies on the same route. For instance, if an operator in Kochi (Kerala)
needed to transport specialty cheese, he could use the Domino's fleet to
transport his products.
Said Bhatia, "Not too many people have refrigerated trucks in the country.
And we can offer them quality service because we will be giving them
standards we use for ourselves." Company sources said that enquiries from
clients for such transport facilities had started coming in. Bhatia said he was
in the process of selecting a person to head the logistics operation, which
would be spun off as a separate profit centre. Bhatia seemed confident that
the profit centre had the potential to bring in Rs 10 bn by 2006. However, he
said the profit center would not be allowed to impede the growth of the pizza
business, Domino's core operation. Only those deliveries that did not delay or
deroute the truck would be considered.
Table I
Outsourcing the Ingredients
Jalandhar
Wheat
(Punjab)
Cheese Karnal, Haryana
Bhubaneshwar,
Tomatoes
Orissa
Spice South India
Baby Corn Nepal
Exotic
Sri Lanka
Vegetables
Pepperoni Australia
Jalapeno Spain
Domino's hoped to lower its prices by saving from the logistics model and
third-party transportation. In April 2000, Domino's announced a cut in pizza
prices to Rs 49. Domino's was also targeting large corporate offices, railway
stations, cinema halls and university campuses for faster growth. It had
already established an outlet at Infosys corporate office in Bangalore and at
three cinema halls - PVR in Delhi, Rex in Bangalore and New Empire in
Kolkata.
82 | P a g e
Domino's also classified its outlets into Super stores, Express stores and
Regular stores. Super stores were those, which generated high traffic and
therefore had more counters than the regular outlets (the outlet in
Churchgate, Mumbai).
Express stores were those where people were expected to walk in and order
rather than ask for home delivery (university campuses, offices or cinema
halls).
Questions for Discussion
1. Why did Domino's decide to revamp its supply chain operations in India?
How was the new logistics model superior than the old model? Briefly explain
the benefits Domino's derived after the revamp.
2. Analysts felt that Domino's took a cue from McDonald's supply chain model
in India. Compare the supply chain models of both companies. Why do you
think Domino's model was considered more complicated?
83 | P a g e
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Procure to Pay, also known as P2P, is the process of obtaining the raw
materials needed for manufacturing a product or providing a service,
and making payment for these. Every manufacturing concern or service
provider needs to run this cycle efficiently if they are to continuously
manage their cash flow, build goodwill with suppliers and make profits.
With the Procure to Pay process being fraught with the possibility of
risk and inefficiency, which would have an adverse impact on the
business in a competitive market, many companies are now finding
ways of streamlining the procure-to-pay process. Outsourcing key tasks
in the Procure to Pay process allows managers to maintain tighter
control over the system, and save cost by reducing manpower and
closing down redundant and wasteful role.
13. Why would you choose Rail over Road transportation and vice versa?
Transporting Goods via Road Freight
Mumbai’s 5000 plus Dabbawalas are world famous for their impeccable
service standards. They pick up lunch boxes/ tiffin carriers from over
2,00,000 homes/ apartments, deliver them to some 80,000 destinations
and again ensure their safe return to those homes/ apartments – all on
the same day with each lap of journey en route accomplished within the
specified time limits.
The people at work are not from any high academic background; rather
many of them are almost illiterate. They face the same crowded
pavements, on-road dense vehicular traffic and overloaded suburban
trains, which normal office goers often give excuses for their late
comings. No matter how perfect a process is, no product/ service will
come conforming to exact targeted specifications. It would always vary.
However, when it varies within certain Lower Specification Limit (LSL)
and Upper Specification Limit (USL) as acceptable/ agreed to or
specified by the customers, then it is considered to be defect free or
quality product/ service. Mumbai Dabbawala’s error is 1 in 16 Million.
21. Explain Make to Stock and How Dell revolutionized the PC business?
24. What is Slack time? How it can be used to predict critical path?
Try to avoid labels. Some of the more common labels like progressive,
salesman or consensus, can have several meaning or descriptions
depending on which management expert you listen to. The situational
style is safe, according to the situation, instead of one size fits all.