PEER EVALUATION SHEET (CONCEPTUALIZATION AND DESIGN PHASE)

Name: ___________________________________ Group No. ____________________ Section: ____________________

Group Member#1 (self): ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.

Group Member#2: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.
Group Member#3: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.

Group Member#4: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.
Group Member#5: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.

Group Member#6: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.
Group Member#1: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.

Group Member#2: ________________________________________________

5 4 3 2 Score

Participation She was present and She was present and She was present but She was absent and not
(30%) participative in all of participative in most of not participative in participative in most of
the group the group most of the group the group
meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions. meetings/discussions.

Contribution She was able to actively She was able to She was able to She was not able to
(30%) contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and contribute ideas and
shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about shared opinions about
the group’s topic most the group’s topic only the group’s topic only the group’s topic.
of the time. when it is needed. when being asked.

Diligence She was able to She was able to She was able to She did not do any
(30%) perform all the tasks perform all the tasks perform some of the tasks assign to her.
assigned to her and assigned to her but did tasks assigned to her
voluntarily helps with not voluntarily or but did not voluntarily
other tasks of the express concern to help or express concern to
group. other members of the help other members of
group. the group.

Communication She was able to She was able to She was out of reach She was not able to
(10%) communicate with her communicate with her most of the time with communicate with her
groupmates most of groupmates but only her groupmates. groupmates.
the time. when needed.
RESSEARCH PLAN PROPOSAL

Names: _________________________________________________________________________________________
Topic: ________________________________________________________________________________________
Group No. ____________________ Section: ____________________

5 4 3 2 SCORE
Presentation All of the members All of the members Only some of the Only some of the
(30%) in the group were in the group were members in the members in the
able to discuss able to discuss group were able to group were able to
their Research Plan their Research Plan discuss their discuss their
Proposal Proposal Research Plan Research Plan
confidently and confidently and Proposal Proposal clearly
clearly. Their clearly but there confidently and but were not
presentation are some details in clearly. Some confident. Some
reflects their actual their presentation details in their details in their
paper. that are not presentation that presentation that
included in their are not included in are not included in
actual paper. their actual paper. their actual paper.
Content The Research Plan The Research Plan The Research Plan The Research Plan
(50%) was approved and was approved but Proposal was was not approved.
had very minimal there were approved but
revisions. multiple revisions there were major
and revisions and
recommendations. recommendations
Peer Evaluation
(20%)

Group Members:
________________
________________
________________
________________
________________
________________
________________

Comments: