Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ecotourism Assessment
15 February 2017
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Jakarta Office:
Manggala Wanabakti Building, Block 4, 5th Floor
Jl. Gatot Subroto, Senayan, Jakarta Pusat
T : +62-21 570 32 46 ext. 4016
F : +62-21 571 12 37
Author:
Phil Harman and
Wiwin Iswandi
Photo:
Phil Harman
Distributed by:
SICCR – TAC
The European Union is made up of 27 Member States who have decided to gradually link together their
know-how, resources and destinies. Together, during a period of enlargement of 50 years, they have built a
zone of stability, democracy and sustainable development whilst maintaining cultural diversity, tolerance and
individual freedoms.
The European Union is committed to sharing its achievements and its values with countries and peoples
beyond its borders.
Deutsche Gessellschaft
für Internationale
Zussamenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH
Ecotourism Assessment
The Support to Indonesia’s Climate Change Response –
Technical Assistance Component (SICCR-TAC)
GIZ International Services is implementing SICCR-TAC together with AHT and SNV under the auspices
of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, represented by the Directorate General of Climate Change.
The Government of Aceh, represented by the Aceh Provincial Environment and Forestry Office, is the
main local stakeholder.
The project has a large number of existing and potential partners. The consortium will works with the
provincial and district authorities in Aceh, other public bodies, as well as private sector actors, local
communities, universities and NGOs.
The focus of the project is on building the capacity of the Government of Aceh in its effort towards low-
carbon/low-emission economic development in the Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry sector.
One of the project’s main activities is strengthening Forest Management Units (FMU) as local units for
sustainable forest management in Aceh. The project promotes strategic alliances and sharing of lessons
learned on implementation of the REDD+ and climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies.
The project supports capacity development of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry’s Directorate
General of Climate Change at the central level, and to its regional offices (Balai PPI), particularly targeting
the Balai PPI Palembang, which covers the Province of Aceh.
This project is implemented by GIZ International Services, AHT and SNV. The views expressed in this
document do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Commission.
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Contents
1 Executive Summary 7
1.1 Introduction 7
1.2 Climate Change and Tourism 7
1.3 Indonesia Overview 7
1.4 Aceh Tourism Policies 8
1.5 Aceh Tourism Overview 8
1.6 Other Organisations Active in Tourism 8
1.7 Specific Destinations Assessed 8
1.8 Key Issues 8
1.9 Recommendations 9
Ecotourism Assessment 3
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
9 Key Issues 27
9.1 Certification of Local Guides 28
9.2 Benefitting from Cruise Tourism 28
10 Recommendations 29
10.1 Broader Policy Recommendations 29
10.2 Specific Recommendations 33
10.3 Sabang/Pulau Weh Recommendations 33
10.4 Takengon, Aceh Tengah Recommendations 34
10.5 Gayo Lues Recommendations 34
10.6 Ketambe, Aceh Tenggara Recommendations 35
10.7 Sampoiniet CRU Unit, Aceh Jaya District Recommendations 35
10.8 Trumon, CRU Unit, Aceh Selatan Recommendations 35
Annexes 36
Annex 1: Terms of Reference 36
Annex 2: List of Meetings 41
Annex 3: Specific Project Recommendations 42
Diagram
Diagram 1: Green Tourism Approach 11
4 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Images
Image 1: Unstaffed Visitor Information Centre 21
Tables
Table 1: Indonesia’s Tourism Competitiveness Factors 16
Ecotourism Assessment 5
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Abbreviations
Abbreviation Explanation
6 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
1. Executive Summary
1.1. Introduction
This ecotourism assessment in Aceh is being conducted under the EU funded “Support to Indonesia’s
Climate Change Response Technical Assistance Component” (SICCR-TAC). This is relevant to the third
project component which focusses on providing advice on new investments and economic development
initiatives that are compatible with low carbon, biodiversity and improving livelihoods. The assessment
team was from SNV and encompassed 40 days from the Senior Tourism Expert, Phil Harman and 50
days from the National Tourism Expert, Wiwin Iswandi.
The overarching objectives of this ecotourism assessment is to understand the current situation
including ecotourism policies, practices and products in the province of Aceh and gain insights into
existing and emerging tourism development potential whose realization can have positive effects on
the province’s climate change goals. The methodology included background research, discussions with
stakeholders and two field assessments.
The Ministry of Tourism has identified that nature accounts for 35% of travellers visiting Indonesia
including ecotourism, marine tourism and adventure tourism. Aceh is not one of the top 10 priority
areas for tourism development, although Lake Toba is which may provide opportunities through market
linkages. The key priorities for the National Tourism Ministry for Aceh are Halal tourism, marine tourism
and adventure tourism.
1 The Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2015, World Economic Forum.
Ecotourism Assessment 7
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
8 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
• Limited interpretation
• Energy use, renewable energy, and waste management
• Lack of capacity of Government and FMUs
• Human resources development
• Certification of local guides
• Benefitting from cruise tourism
• Capitalising on the new road linking the West Coast to Central Aceh
• Lack of production diversification
1.9. Recommendations
To promote low carbon growth and to protect biodiversity, if tourism can be developed in and around
the Leuser Ecosystem it would potentially provide the best return on investment given the projects
objectives. The area is challenging in terms of access and limited supporting tourism infrastructure but
given its unique flora and fauna, it certainly has potential. The key will be to work on the demand side
as it is unlikely there will be significant investment until tourism visitation increases from its low base.
Specific recommendations for areas such as Pulau Weh can help diversify product and highlight the
need to better manage natural assets but the environmental impact will be limited.
Recommendations are divided into broader higher level recommendations that could be taken up by
the GoA and the relevant departments as well as more specific recommendations that could potentially
be implemented almost immediately by the GoA or district governments, potentially with support of
the SICCR-TAC project or other donors where applicable. Outlines of specific projects that SICCR-TAC
could support are contained in Annex 3 and cover Aceh Adventure Trail, CRU Strengthening, Ecotourism/
Adventure Investment Attraction, Specific Nature Based Attraction Development in Sabang and support
for Gayo Lues in Ecotourism Development.
Ecotourism Assessment 9
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
10 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Livelihoods
Attractions Accomodation
Activities &
Access
Amenities
2 www.ecotourism.org/book/ecotourism-definition
Ecotourism Assessment 11
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
The key tasks that have been identified in the Terms of Reference (Annex 1) include:
• Identification of important tourism stakeholders
• Identification and evaluation of the region’s main ecotourism related policy documents
• Mapping ecotourism products and services
• Assessment of the region’s ecotourism competitiveness
• Identifying promising product development scenarios as well as prioritising the potential in the
target FMUs
The methodology that has been used for the assessment has the following components:
• Background data collection including broader tourism trends and ecotourism information at a
national, province and district level.
• Review of relevant tourism policies at a province level as well as in specific destinations.
• Initial one-one discussions in Jakarta with Ministry of Tourism and the peak tourism industry
association.
• Discussion with tourism industry stakeholders organised by the Aceh Province Tourism
Department held in Banda Aceh on 16 November 2016 and initial briefing of relevant government
and industry stakeholders organised by BAPPEDA, the Government of Aceh’s Planning Agency,
in Banda Aceh on 17 November 2016.
• Stakeholder discussion organised by BAPPEDA Sabang, 18 November 2016.
• Stakeholder discussion organised by BAPPEDA Gayo Lues, 23 November 2016.
• Field visit and site inspection including Banda Aceh, Lampuuk (Aceh Besar), Pulau Weh, Takengon
(Aceh Tengah), Gayo Lues, and Aceh Tenggara.
• One on-one discussions during field visit to Aceh.
• Additional discussions in Jakarta including the National Parks section of the Ministry of
Environment and UNESCO.
• Second field visit to CRU Sampoinet (Aceh Jaya), CRU Trumon (Aceh Selatan) and Singkil (Aceh
Singkil).
• Prepare draft report.
• A planned stakeholder workshop in Banda Aceh on January 26, 2017 to share findings and
seek feedback did not occur due to a competing meeting involving senior government officals
organised by the Government of Aceh.
• Finalise report.
Please see Annex 2 for full list of interviews conducted and discussion participants.
12 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Typically, the tourism industry, especially high end resorts and hotels as well as the transport sector, are
large users of resources including water and energy. The sector is responsible for an estimated 5% of
global greenhouse gas emissions, which is equivalent to its contribution to global GDP. However, some
other estimates for the tourism sector are much higher.3 An estimated 75% of GHG emissions come
from transport and a further 21% from accommodation.4 As aviation tends to be one of the biggest
contributors to GHG emissions, to a certain degree this is outside the control of a specific destination.
Studies in European hotels show that energy costs represent around 6% of turnover, while in best
practise establishments that have invested in better designs and renewable energy, the energy costs are
between 1.5-2.8%. This shows that there can be a relatively quick return on investment and should be
considered by the GoA in terms of policy and possibly incentives.5 Waste is another negative impact of
tourism with estimates that each international visitor generates up to 2 kg of solid waste per day. The
figure tends to be higher in more developed countries.6
Key opportunities to mitigate the effect of climate change can be focussed around:
• Reducing energy use
• Improving energy efficiency
• Increasing the use of renewable energy such as solar and biogas
• Sequestering carbon such as through off sets7
• Maintaining forest cover, peat lands and mangroves
Environmentally orientated tourism can also play an important role in maintaining areas of high
conservation value by raising awareness and helping local governments and communities understand
the economic benefits tourism can bring if natural attractions are maintained.8 This is highly relevant to
Aceh considering areas of high conservation values including marine areas and the Leuser ecosystem. If
well managed, tourism can be a much more environmentally sound use of land compared to alternative
uses such as expansion of palm oil, coffee or cocoa plantations – all of which are threats to the landscape
in Aceh. Globally, tourism has been identified as one of ten sectors that can play a key role in the
transformation to the green economy.9 The green tourism economy can be defined as being low carbon,
using resources efficiently and being socially inclusive.10
Ecotourism Assessment 13
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
It should be noted that tourism can have a severe negative impact on the environment such as through
the destruction of mangroves to build a new beach resort. Large scale tourism has other impacts
on biodiversity such as over fishing to feed tourists and destruction of coral reefs and rain forests
for construction material to build hotels. In dryer areas, construction of golf courses has had lowered
the water table negatively affecting flora and fauna. Not properly managing tourism development and
maintaining biodiversity is likely to have a longer term negative impact on the destination but often short
term profits are put before longer term economic sustainability.
Positively, consumers are becoming increasingly sophisticated and potentially due to pressure of daily life
and increasing urbanisation, ecotourism style holidays and more sustainable experiences are increasing
in popularity. There are also a percentage of the market that are willing to pay more for the experience.11
As the diagram below illustrates, the visitors that have a strong interest in ecotourism, the “dark green
tourists”, is a comparatively smaller market than the “light green tourists” that may only want to have
a natural experience as part of a holiday. However, visitors strongly engaged in ecotourism often stay
longer and travel more widely, hence spreading the benefits of tourism.
Ma
tou
rke
co
nE
tS
st i
ize
ere
Int
The growing interest in nature based tourism and the desire for a pristine environment becomes a
strong economic argument to properly manage a destination and to avoid new developments that are
not compatible with environmental sustainability.12 Globally, tourism is growing fastest in the world’s
biodiversity hot spots.13 There is also increasing evidence that more sustainable tourism has greater
economic multipliers due to increased local inputs and more of the money is spent in the local community.14
While tourism is largely driven by the private sector, the GoA can have a policy and planning framework
that influences how the tourism industry develops in Aceh.
14 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Tourism potentially has an important role to play in Aceh as it generates a significant number of jobs,
particularly for women and youth. Being labour intensive, it has relatively low barriers of entry for service
level jobs as well as micro and small businesses that service the sector.
Ecotourism Assessment 15
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
In 2015, Indonesia travel and tourism competitiveness index ranked 50th out of 140 countries.19 Currently,
Bali, Jakarta and Batam attract more than 90% of international visitors to Indonesia. With the growing
middle class, domestic tourism is a major factor underpinning the growth of the tourism industry with
Indonesians increasingly having the disposable income and interest to explore their own country. With
Indonesia’s rich natural and cultural attractions there is certainly also a significant potential for Indonesia
to attract a greater share of international travellers. Indonesia is ranked 19 out of 139 countries by the
World Economic Forum for natural resources competitiveness highlighting the potential ecotourism can
play in attracting international tourists.20 Indonesia’s ranking for mega biodiversity comes after only
Brazil and Zaire. However, as the following table demonstrates environmental sustainability is identified
as a major challenge in realizing Indonesia’s tourism potential from its natural resources, along with
tourism infrastructure and health and hygiene. These are also issues highly relevant to Aceh.
The Ministry of Tourism has identified that nature accounts for 35% of travellers visiting Indonesia with
ecotourism accounting for almost half of these visitors. While the picture is more complex than the below
table shows, it does highlight the considerable potential of nature based tourism to attract significant
number of visitors.
Nature
Ecotourism (45%)
(35 %)
Culture
MAIN PRODUCTS Culinary & Shopping Tourism (45%)
(60 %)
Man Made
Sports Tourism (60%)
(5 %)
19 The Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2015, World Economic Forum.
20 The Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2015, World Economic Forum.
21 Source: Data and Information Centre, Ministry of Tourism and Central Statistic Bureau, 2014.
16 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
The Ministry of Tourism in consultation with the Province of Aceh has developed a strategy to develop
ecotourism in the Province which covers attractions, accessibility, branding, advertising, selling,
destination management, community and industry. This is more of a practical action plan but it is unclear
if it will be implemented. The key priorities for the National Tourism Ministry for Aceh are Halal tourism,
marine tourism and adventure tourism.
The Master Plan also identifies a number of issues, many of which are consistent with the findings of
this assessment. These include:
• There is still not optimal for the construction and the development of tourism area/object in each
district/municipal.
• Maintenance of tourism facilities.
• Low community awareness of benefits of tourism.
• Limited tourism promotion, both at the regional, national and international level.
• Sub optimal use of ICT as a tourism marketing and promotion tool.
• Limited human resources development especially in services and tourism management.
• Less than optimal cooperation between the government and private sector.
Ecotourism Assessment 17
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Aceh Qanun No. 8 of 2013 on Tourism is also broadly supportive of ecotourism although it likes specifics.
Some of the key points include:
• One of the aims of destination tourism operations in Aceh is to preserve the tourist attraction
objects.
• To realize tourism development in Aceh, research and development activities need to be
conducted to determine the potential of natural resources and oriented to the preservation of
the environment.
• The Government of Aceh and District/City Government in the field of Tourism is authorized to
enact a tourist attraction, one of the natural tourist attractions.
• The Aceh Government and District/City to implement the tourism coaching in the form of the
settings, providing guidance and supervision of the operation of tourism directed to creating and
maintaining sustainability, integrity objects and tourist attraction, and its development as well as
providing an opportunity for the local community.
Aceh has been growing strongly as a tourist destination in recent years. The province attracted a little
over 1.7 million tourists in 2015, a 75% increase since 2011. International tourists comprise less than
2% of tourism arrivals totalling 25,000 in 2015. Malaysian visitors accounted for approximately 85% of
all international visitors with China, USA, Singapore, Australia, Germany, France, the United Kingdom,
Thailand and the Philippines other source markets.
18 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Currently Banda Aceh has direct daily flights to Jakarta and Medan and is serviced by the four largest
airlines in the country, Garuda, Lion, Batik and Citylink. Banda Aceh is also serviced daily by Air Asia and
Fire Fly to Kuala Lumpur and Penang by Firefly and Malaysian Airlines.
There are also some intra-province flights although they tend to have limited capacity. For example, Susi
Air with a capacity of seven passengers has a return flight to Gayo Lues from Medan on Tuesday and
Banda Aceh on Saturday.
Road access is relatively good in many parts of Aceh although travel times are still considerable to
areas such as Gayo Lues. There are relatively poor road conditions over the provincial border into North
Sumatra which is an issue for tourists needing to connect via Medan or travel via Lake Toba. There is
an issue with road connections through to potential attractions such as CRU Sampoinet that has an
unsealed road of the main highway which is not accessible to car traffic when there are excessive rains.
Ferry connections are particularly to Sabang from Banda Aceh but understandably less frequent to areas
such as Pulau Banyak which is emerging as a tourist destination.
There are 34 star rated hotels in Aceh and 377 non star rated properties. The occupancy rate for star
rated properties is 54% and an even lower 35% for non-star rated properties. In 2016, there were 474
certified tourist guides in Aceh.22
There are a number of tourism associations operating in Aceh, although there is a great deal of variety
in how active they are. As the table below shows, a number of associations are also active at the
district level as branches of national organisations. There are also district specific organisations. These
organisations obviously make a useful launching point for any tourism initiative as a way to consult and
engage with the private sector.
Ecotourism Assessment 19
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Aceh Province
HPI The Indonesian Tourist Guide Association
PHRI The Indonesian Hotel & Restaurant Association
ASITA Association of Indonesia Tours & Travel Agencies
ASPPI Association of Indonesian Tourism
Sabang
FTKP Sabang Tourism Governance Forum
WGT (LWG) Weh Green Tourism (Local Working Group)
HPI The Indonesian Tourist Guide Association
ASPPI Association of Indonesian Tourism
PHRI The Indonesian Hotel & Restaurant Association
Gayo Lues
HPI The Indonesian Tourist Guide Association
KSW Community Awareness Tourism
Aceh Tengah
HPI The Indonesian Tourist Guide Association
PHRI The Indonesian Hotel & Restaurant Association
ASITA Association of Indonesia Tours & Travel Agencies
20 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Ecotourism Assessment 21
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Sabang (Pulau Weh) has been designated as a Nature Tourism Garden with 1,250 Ha in land and 5,275
Ha marine with coral reefs and over 20 potential dive spots identified. In addition, there is protected
forested areas of 3,329 Ha according to the Ministry of Forestry. Situated at the convergence of the
Indian and Pacific oceans, the coral reefs around Pulau Weh are home to a great diversity of fish species,
like sea turtles, sharks, rays and dolphins.
Domestic tourists account for the largest number of tourists with over 623,000 visitors in 2015, up from
212,165 in 2012. The number of international tourists to Sabang has varied widely in the last few years
with 5,582 being recorded in 2015, however preliminary figures for 2016 indicate a doubling of arrivals
to 10,501.
22 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
In 2015, Aceh Provincial Department of Tourism recorded 819 rooms across 95 accommodation
establishments in the district. There is already an interesting mix of hotel and guest house accommodation
on the island with more under construction. There are eight dive centres on the island servicing both
local and international visitors. Particularly for international visitors, facilities such as restaurants or
shopping are extremely limited and there is potential to expand. Another challenge is that there tends to
be overcrowding on weekends and low occupancy during the week given the strong local and regional
market. Other challenges and opportunities to increasing tourism to Sabang include:
• Needing to diversify product
• Restructuring entrance to Balohan Port to make it more user friendly for tourists
• Improving public facilities and amenities
• Developing improved shore excursions for the cruise and yacht markets
• Improving promotion and marketing activities and information provision
In many ways Sabang is already becoming a mainstream tourism destination, however there is potential
to introduce new product which may help preserve the environment and increase the diversity of product
such a trekking routes and mangrove walks. There may also be potential in the future to link the volcano
and geothermal plant which is due for completion in 2018 as an educational tourism product. BPKS is
currently working on a tourism master plan that should be available in 2017 as well as a trekking route
plan.
The Conservation Response Unit (CRU) Sampoiniet located in le Jeureungeh village has the purpose of
managing conflict issues between wildlife, particularly elephants, and humans. The CRU currently has 13
staff. The CRU has the potential to develop as a tourist destination with an estimated 40-50 international
tourists visiting each year since the Unit’s establishment in 2010. This is despite limited amenities,
trained local guides or active promotion of the area. Visitors currently pay IDR 300,000 for trekking and
a donation if they just want to come and have a look around. There are four elephants that are housed
at the CRU which care used for elephant patrols and for taking tourists trekking. It is also possible to do
tubing nearby and the CRU has two basic rooms that can be used for overnight stays. The surrounding
area of the CRU is in a pretty location with a mix of crops including coffee and cocoa which could also
Ecotourism Assessment 23
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
be interesting tours for visitors in the future. The growth in commercial “voluntourism”, where travellers
pay for volunteer experience, may also be an interesting opportunity for CRU Sampoiniet as well as
other CRUs in Aceh. The access road into CRU Sampoiniet from the main coastal road is unsealed and
not able to be accessed by standard cars during times of heavy rain. Improving this road could be a
beneficial investment to underpin growth in visitors.
The lack of tourism facilities including accommodation, restaurants, and visitor information in the village
is impeding tourism development. The area would benefit from support in awareness raising of tourism
within the local community, training of the community and connections with the tourism industry.
The district is well known for the quality of its coffee. There is a fledgling coffee tourism industry
with some cafes providing visitors with a sense of the process from tree to espresso. With better
interpretation there could be much greater opportunity to attract larger numbers of domestic and
international tourists. One local business, Seladang, located approximately half an hour drive from
Takengon had a very atmospheric café surrounded by coffee trees where visitors can taste coffee and
learn about the process. A local roaster that was visited as part of the assessment was also potentially
interesting tourism product despite it not being geared specifically for tourists. The assessment team
while in Takengon came across a tour group of coffee roasters that were visiting from Europe – while this
was mostly business related it shows there is some potential to build on coffee as a tourism asset. A
speciality coffee event in the area could be of interest to a broad range of visors.
24 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
The Gayo people have strong cultural heritage which is particularly evident in their dancing. For example,
one Gayo dance, Saman, was recognised by UNESCO in 2011 as an intangible cultural heritage of
humanity in need of urgent safeguarding.
It has been identified locally that of the 11 sub-districts in Gayo Lues, eight have prime tourism potential,
especially for nature, culture and adventure. The identified districts are Tripe Jaya, Rikit Gaib, Pantan
Cuaca, Blang Kejeren, Blang Jerango, Pining, Plang Pegayon and Putri Betung. Currently Blang Jerango
has attracted a significant number of domestic and foreign tourists as Kedah is one of the major entry
points to Mt Leuser National Park. In addition, the Kedah trail is the most popular of the three hiking
routes to the peak of Mt Leuser. The 10-12 day trek is likely to enable hikers to see orangutan, honey
bears and birds endemic to Aceh. In addition, the river system offers rafting activities.
Ecotourism Assessment 25
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
2011 45 1,812
2012 65 1,978
2013 74 2,824
The district government is keen to grow tourism and has asked for support to develop its tourism
strategy including ecotourism and for helping to train community groups as well as branding/marketing.
The Forest Management Unit V, has ecotourism highlighted in its strategy. It sees potential for support
for tourism through carbon trading and payment for environmental services. Key planned activities in
the strategy include coaching of community groups and promotion. The owner of Kedah Rainforest
Lodge identified certification of guides as one of the most critical issues.
26 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Trumon CRU is located in the Trumon Wildlife Corridor which has 2,700 hectares acting as a buffer zone
and migration link of species between Singkil Swamp Wildlife Reserve Region with the Northern Forest
Area of Singkil and onwards to the Gunung Leuser National Park.
CRU Trumon can be reached in approximately 11 hours from the provincial capital Banda Aceh, 1 and
a half hours from district capital Tapaktuan and around 7 hours from Medan. Interestingly, Ketambe
can be reached in four hours by boat (around seven by car) which could be an attractive way to link
the destinations. Access to the corridor area can be reached from Trumon CRU by elephant and on
foot. Within the CRU there are four elephants that could be used for taking visitors and there are locally
trained guides.
CRU Trumon has simple accommodation consisting of five rooms for travellers lodging. If tourists
undertake trekking outside the camp CRU, the CRU can provide tents and camping equipment. Currently
the CRU is attracting the occasional international visitors but has had 30 school groups visiting in the past
year. While the current facilities are basic, the local community is supportive of developing ecotourism.
9. Key Issues
Through the assessment a number of key issues have been identified that may impact on the potential
to harness ecotourism in a way that promotes a low carbon tourism sector, protects the province’s
biodiversity and creates local jobs.
Local communities are not yet benefitting significantly from tourism in areas of high conservation
value: This is a critical issue as feedback from stakeholder workshops made it clear that local
communities felt that they were maintaining forested areas but not seeing any real benefits. A key factor
is that current visitation to Aceh is low so it is important to work on demand side factors to increase
visitation but then also make sure communities are benefitting from tourism in terms of local employment
and increased business. There is definitely potential to increase tourism to Aceh but it is important that
false expectations aren’t created by training local communities without providing support to market
and promote the destination. New investment also tends to be circular, increased tourism demand will
attract new investment and new investment will often increase demand due to the marketing channels
of the new business.
Low Awareness of Aceh as a Tourism Destination: Due to its recent history, there is a low awareness
of Aceh as a tourism destination. This is also due to limited marketing by both the public and private
sector and the relatively limited investment in tourism. There is the opportunity to both build on the
overall Cahaya Aceh brand as well as sub-brand destinations to capitalise on the growing popularity
of Sabang as a destination. There is also the opportunity to build the profile of specific destinations,
journeys or experiences within Aceh to help create awareness and counter any negative sentiments of
Aceh as a travel destination.
Limited investment in Tourism Sector: The lack of major hotel brands and new hotels and other
tourism services is potentially limiting growth in the sector.
Attitudes towards tourism: A general lack of community awareness of the benefits of tourism appears
to be limiting the sector’s growth. This is exacerbated by the idea that tourism has to develop along
the “Bali or Phuket” models. There is an opportunity to better articulate how tourism can be developed
consistent with the community’s Sharia principles. This can include the broad reaching benefits of
developing the sector if it is done in a manner that protects the environment, creates new jobs and
improves incomes.
Ecotourism Assessment 27
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Limited Interpretation: Interpretation even at key sites, such as the Tsunami museum was limited.
There is the need to improve interpretation of destinations in Aceh including natural attractions through
signage, brochures and local guides.
Energy Use, Renewable Energy and Waste Management: There was very limited evidence that
accommodation and other tourism establishments have put in place policies to reduce energy
consumption, utilise renewable energy or manage waste properly. Investment in energy efficiency and
waste management have demonstrated to show a good return on investment in a relatively short time
frame. There is a program, a clean Green Sabang program that had billboard advertising. There is a real
opportunity to reduce emissions in the accommodation sector as there is also generally cost savings
which improves the businesses bottom line.
Lack of Capacity of Government and FMUs: Within the FMUs and district governments, there is an
acknowledged limited understanding of the potential of ecotourism as well as tourism promotion and
marketing.
Human Resource Development: Industry and government have identified low skills as a constraint for
the sector. There is the need for both more formally trained staff as well as informal training to improve
the service quality and other skills of workers in the tourism sector. Many workers such as in non-star
hotel properties will not have formal training.
28 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
There is an opportunity to enhance the tour and shopping opportunities for cruise ships coming to Sabang
by working with the cruise companies, inbound operators and local businesses and communities.
Capitalising on the New Road Linking the West Coast to Central Aceh: Depending on the tourism
attractions along the new road to open up between Meulaboh, Beutung Ateuk to Aceh Tengah there
could be an opportunity to develop tourism. Access elsewhere in the province and in Indonesia, often
new roads open up exploitation of the natural resources and reduce the tourism potential.
Lack of Product Diversification: In all destinations including Banda Aceh and Sabang, there is the
need to diversify experiences which will encourage visitors to stay longer, spend more and return.
10. Recommendations
To promote low carbon growth and to protect biodiversity, if tourism can be developed in and around
the Leuser Ecosystem it would potentially provide the best return on investment given the projects
objectives. The area is challenging in terms of access and limited supporting tourism infrastructure but
given its unique flora and fauna it certainly has potential. The key will be to work on the demand side
as it is unlikely there will be significant investment until tourism visitation increases from its low base.
Specific recommendations for areas such as Pulau Weh can help diversify product and highlight the
need to better manage natural assets but the environmental impact will be limited.
The following recommendations are divided into broader higher level recommendations that could be
taken up by the GoA and the relevant departments as well as more specific recommendations that could
potentially be implemented almost immediately by the GoA or district governments, potentially with
support of the SICCR-TAC project or other donors where applicable. Outlines of specific projects that
SICCR -TAC could support are contained in Annex 3 and cover Aceh Adventure Trail, CRU Strengthening,
Ecotourism/Adventure Investment Attraction, Specific Nature Based Attraction Development in Sabang
and support for Gayo Lues in Ecotourism Development.
Ecotourism Assessment 29
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
• Encourage industry to have more efficient energy use and improved waste management in the
tourism sector through polices and government programs.
• Consider adopting the Global Sustainable Tourism Council Criteria for destinations in developing
tourism in the province.
Investment Attraction
For any destination, attracting new investments is critical. This is not only a source of capital, which is
often an issue in developing countries, but can also help with knowledge transfer and improved market
access. Particular strategies that the GoA can out in place to attract investment that promotes green
growth includes:
• Providing and packaging up information on tourism potential in Aceh.
• Pro-active outreach to get qualified investors - this could be one-on-one meetings or an investor
forum.
• Competitive tenders for high potential sites which have been well researched.
• Establishing strong partnerships with local tourism industry, local investors and land owners.
• Increasing tourism knowledge and contacts within relevant province agencies that cater to investor
inquiries.
• Solid data potentially with benchmarking data comparison with other destinations.
• Providing useful contacts for investors such as legal firms. The Aceh Investment and Promotion
Board has done some analysis of potential sites which this could be built on. It would be beneficial
to attract quality accommodation that can help build the image of Aceh. Quality hotels tend to
have a synergistic effect on a destination as they have their own marketing channels often raise
the quality of staff through in house training and also work with suppliers to improve quality. In
the longer term, it would be ideal to be able to attract an upmarket operator in addition to local
investors such as the Four Seasons lodges in Serengeti, Tanzania and Northern Thailand or the
type of lodges that feature in National Geographic Unique Lodges (www.nationalgeographiclodges.
com.) Building tourism assets near a national park can be a good investment due to certainty that
the national park will remain, however it is important to ensure community partnerships.
30 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Community Benefits
• Support the development of supply chains to the tourism industry so that communities benefit
through employment and increased income. This includes vegetable supply chains and local
handicrafts.
• Further develop and promote cultural attractions such as dances as it is of interest to visitors and
helps create local employment.
General Services
• Government needs to continue to invest in basic infrastructure and services that helps create a
thriving tourism industry and facilitates trade and movement of goods. This includes roads, port
facilities, and basic services such as toilets, shelters etc.
New Road
Assess the potential of having a tourism awareness program along the new road central Aceh to enable
local communities to benefit from the traffic flow and also highlight the need to protect natural resources.
Similar programs have been implemented elsewhere such as the ADB Route 9 linking Thailand, Laos
and Vietnam.
Kampung Iklim
The Programme Kampung Iklim operates under the Ministry of Forestry and Environment. It aims to
encourage and recognize active participation of local communities in implementing climate change
mitigation and adaptation activities which contribute to national greenhouse gas reduction targets and
increases community resilience. Aceh Province has been established as one of the pilot project areas
with four villages in Aceh, namely: Kampung Ule Lheu (Banda Aceh), Kampung Iboih (Sabang), Kampung
Saree (Aceh Besar) and Kampung Kelitu (Central Aceh).
Ecotourism Assessment 31
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
There is a potential to use the Kampung Ilkim project to support community awareness of ecotourism and
environmental management. Iboih in Sabang would be a good pilot area given its existing tourism base
and fragile ecosystem.
Destination Planning
• Destination management is critical to developing a low carbon tourism sector that protects
biodiversity.
• Establish a destination management training program in a key destination that others can be
invited to attend. This could include four modules with mentoring support in between.
Marketing
It is important to create an increased awareness of Aceh as a tourist destination for visitation to increase.
Given that the industry is made up of small players, both the provincial and district governments have
a role to play to work with the private sector to develop tourism. While budgets are limited, there are
a number of costs effective ways to increase awareness and visitor spend in the destination. These
include:
• Public relations activities such as media visits.
• Improve the provision of information including ensuring the visitor information centre at the
airport is staffed and has a more comprehensive range of information.
• Online marketing and train local businesses on how to use social media and capitalise on
marketing channels such as Tripadvisor and Air BnB.
• Branding of sub-destinations such as Sabang or experiences such as the “Aceh Adventure Trail”
concept to help cut through any negative perceptions of the Province as a whole.
Interpretation
• Improved interpretation of sites such as Tsunami museum.
• Training of community and professional guides.
Events
• Support the strategic development of events that help address seasonal peaks, attract publicity
and promote key brand strengths such as nature, coffee, Halal tourism and adventure tourism.
32 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Ecotourism Assessment 33
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
34 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
• Development of a travel package that connects the CRU Trumon - Singkil, Gayo Lues, and
Ketambe possibly as part of the “Aceh Adevnture Trail”.
• Promotion of the cooperation between the Gunung Leuser National Park, South Aceh District
Tourism Department and Tourism Department of Aceh Province.
Ecotourism Assessment 35
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Type of contract: One Senior Short Term Non-Key Senior Expert (NKE) and one Junior Short
Term Non-Key Expert (NKE).
Location: Aceh Province with some additional work and de/briefing at Jakarta level
Reports to: SICCR-TAC Team Leader
Languages Required: Bahasa Indonesia, English (working language of the project is English)
Duration of Contract: Up to 50 working days for Senior NKE and 50 working days for Junior NKE
within the period 15.9.16 – 15 12.16
Funding source: DCI/ASIE/2011/022-499
1. BACKGROUND
The ‘Support to Indonesia’s Climate Change Response – Technical Assistance Component’ (SICCR-
TAC) project, under the auspice of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry (MOEF) at central level
and the Government of Aceh (GoA) at provincial level, is implemented by GIZ (Deutsche Gesellschaft
für Internationale Zusammenarbeit) in consortium with AHT Group AG and SNV (Stichting Nederlandse
Ontwikkelingsorganisatie).
The project started in February 2016 and is part of a larger action including two civil society oriented
projects in Aceh and Papua concluded in 2016. In addition, results of four EU funded studies, carried on
in Aceh prior to the implementation of the SICCR-TAC, support project design and its implementation.
The overall objective of the SICCR programme is: “Indonesia achieves its climate change response
objectives in the LULUCF (Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry) sector through low carbon,
resource efficiency, biodiversity and livelihoods optimal development planning and implementation”.
While the national level is the main recipient of experiences gained, the locus of the project is in the
Province of Aceh, with the special autonomy status as well as its substantial natural resources.
The purpose of the Technical Assistance Component is: “Aceh province contributes in an effective
and coherent way to the national REDD+ Strategy (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest
Degradation) by designing and streamlining provincial REDD+ strategies with existing development
planning frameworks and by implementing and monitoring sustainable, participatory, transparent and
economically sound land-use decisions”.
Activities are focused on building the capacity of the GoA in its effort towards low-carbon/low-emission
economic development. The project promotes sharing of lessons learned among other provinces, with
experience on REDD+ and climate change mitigation strategies. At central level the project supports
36 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
capacity building within the Directorate General of Climate Change Control (DGCC) at the MOEF as well
as its “deconcentrated” regional office (Balai PPI) in Palembang, covering the whole of Sumatra.
In the context of achieving its third result in promoting new investments and economic development
initiatives compatible with low-carbon, biodiversity and livelihood concerns the SICCR-TAC will look
into the tourism sector of the region and the ways tourism in Aceh already supports or could be able to
support Indonesian’s climate change response and environmental vision and goals of Aceh.
While it is true that certain forms of tourism have a deep ecological footprint contributing to resource
depletion, disrupting social conditions and the alienation of local cultures, it is a widely shared view that
tourism can play an important role in supporting economic, social and ecological goals in a responsible
and sustainable way. Similarly, tourism can serve as an economic alternative for local populations with
positive effects on existing biodiversity and support achievement of low-carbon goals.
2. ASSIGNMENT
Objectives of the Assignment:
To provide understanding of the current situation of tourism and especially ecotourism policies,
practices and products in the province of Aceh and by gaining insights into existing and emerging
tourism development potentials whose realization can have positive effects on the province’s climate
change goals.
In order to achieve the above objective, the following approach will be used:
- Identification of important tourism stakeholders of the region, both public and private, and their
roles and responsibilities.
- Identification and evaluation of the region’s main ecotourism related policy documents, both on
provincial and district level.
- Identification of how these policies connect and support implementation of the National and
Provincial REDD+ strategy.
- Identification and mapping of the provinces’ main ecotourism products and services, past and
present.
- Assessment of the region’s ecotourism competitiveness, in terms of the status of its main
influencing factors (e.g. natural assets, cultural assets, infrastructure, accessibility, hospitality,
safety, special events, destination image etc.) and identification of existing and potentially
attractive market segments and competitors in the area of ecotourism products.
- Conclusions from the study on the importance of ecotourism for the region and for the national
and provincial REDD+ strategy implementation.
- Determination of development potentials for competitive ecotourism products and services, and
outlining of several promising product development scenarios as well as prioritising the potential
in the target FMUs.
- The research insights gained about opportunities in developing suitable ecotourism products
and activities goals should contribute to the provincial policy development including FMU
development.
Ecotourism Assessment 37
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
- Lead development of research approach and methods in consultation with the TA team and
project partners.
- Coordinate and conduct screening of available documents and media information about
stakeholders, policies, products, markets etc.
- Coordinate and conduct field research and evaluation of main ecotourism destinations and
locations within the region.
- Manage and conduct interviews and discussions with main stakeholders within the region including
public administrations, private ecotourism industry representatives and other stakeholders.
- Manage documentation and analysis of the results and produce draft report.
- Lead communication of the results among project partners, formulation of recommendations,
and next steps.
- Finalise the report based on comments received and conduct final briefing.
The consultant’s assignment will commence after 15st September 2016, and ends before 15th December
2016, with a maximum number of up to 50 (fifty) working days for the Junior NKE and 50 (fifty) working
days for the Senior NKE. Each consultant will have 5 days for preparation/reading documents, 25
working days in Aceh and 10 working days in Jakarta, 10 days for consultation and discussing project
results with project partners and initial de/briefings in Jakarta.
38 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Schedule of deliverables:
The consultant is expected to submit a report covering:
- The general state of affairs of the ecotourism sector including stakeholders, policies, products
and services (past and present) and its competitiveness, market segments and competitors;
- development potentials for competitive ecotourism products including promising product
development scenarios and connecting these to target FMUs;
- specific recommendations for project partners connected to implementation of the REDD+
strategies;
- proposal for follow up measures in the context of SICCR-TAC (mainstreaming, partnership
promotion, policy/strategy development etc).
The report will include the relevant materials, documents and data gathered during the assignment,
including working schedule and timesheet), as well as people and relevant institutions met during the
assignment.
Proposed schedule for submission of required deliverables (to be confirmed in the detailed workplan).
A detailed workplan with activities and timeframe will be elaborated with the Team Leader in coordination
with the Provincial Coordinator for Aceh within the first working days and presented to the partner. The
agreed workplan will be attached to the first deliverable of the assignment.
4. REMUNERATION
The consultant will be paid based on an agreed daily rate, plus day and night allowances for the time in
Aceh.
Tickets and other means of transportation will be provided by the project or reimbursed according to
project rules and regulations.
Ecotourism Assessment 39
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Qualifications
• University degree in one of the following fields: Ecotourism, Natural Resources Management,
Forestry or any other related areas
Professional experience
The Junior NKE hired to conduct the tasks outlined above is expected to have following qualifications,
requisite skills and experience:
Qualifications
• University degree in one of the following fields: Ecotourism, natural resources management,
forestry or any other related areas.
• Indonesian national.
Professional experience
• Willingness to travel to Aceh to meet and interview the project partners and beneficiaries.
• Good command of English language.
40 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Ecotourism Assessment 41
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Partners: Aceh Provincial Department of Tourism, District/Cities Tourism Offices, Aceh Adventure,
Association (HPI), Private Sector.
CRU Strengthening
Objective: To build capacity of the 7 CRUs in Aceh with a focus on interpretation, guiding, basic hospitality
and low cost marketing. There will be a primary focus on CRU Sampoiniet, with a secondary focus on
CRU Trumon. The other CRUs in Aceh will be invited to attend training activities.
Partners: Aceh Provincial Department of Tourism, District/City Office of Tourism, Center for Conservation
of Natural Resources (BKSDA), Forest Management Unit (KPH/FMU), tourism associations and the
private sector.
42 Ecotourism Assessment
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Total 20,000 14 42
Partners: Aceh Investment Board, Provincial Bappeda, Tourism Office, FMU, Aceh Adventure and
Tourism Associations.
Total 15,000 15 35
Ecotourism Assessment 43
Indonesia - SICCR - TAC
Partners: BPKS, Tourism Office, FMU, BKSDA, Association (HPI), Sabang Tourism Governance Forum
(FTKP), Local Tourism Working Group in Sabang.
Total 3,000 20 20
Partners: Bappeda, Provincial and District/City Tourism Offices, FMU and Tourism Associations.
44 Ecotourism Assessment
Support to Indonesia’s Climate Change Response
Technical Assistance Component (SICCR-TAC)
Deutsche Gessellschaft
für Internationale
Zussamenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH