Sei sulla pagina 1di 120

RF Filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla


Associate Professor

Sindhudurg Shikshan Prasarak Mandal’s College of


Engineeering,
Kankavali
January 20, 2020

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 1 / 120


Filter Design

Filter design methods


Image Parameter Method
Insertion Loss Method

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 2 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Two Port Network.


I1 I2
+ " # +
A B
Zi1 V1 V2 Zi2
C D
− −

Zin1 Zin2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 3 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Zi1 = input impedance at port 1 when port 2 is terminated with


Zi2
Zi2 = input impedance at port 2 when port 1 is terminated with
Zi1 .
Both ports are terminated with matched loads.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 4 / 120


Image Parameter Method

At Port 1, the port voltage and current are related as


V1 = AV2 + BI2 , I1 = CV2 + DI2

The input impedance at port 1, with port 2 terminated in Zi2 , is


V1 AV2 + BI2
Zin1 = =
I1 CV2 + DI2
V1 AZi2 + B
Zin1 = =
I1 CZi2 + D
V2
Since, Zi2 =
I2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 5 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Similarly, at Port 2, we have


V2 = DV1 − BI1 , I2 = −CV1 + AI1

These are obtained by taking the inverse of the ABCD matrix


knowing that AD − BC = 1.
The input impedance at port 2, with port 1 terminated in Zi1 , is
V2 DV1 − BI1
Zin2 = =
I2 −CV1 + DI1
V2 DZi1 + B
Zin2 = =
I2 CZi1 + A
−V1
Since, Zi1 =
I1

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 6 / 120


Image Parameter Method

We desire Zin1 = Zi1 and Zin2 = Zi2


Zi1 (CZi2 + D ) = AZi2 + B
Zi1 D − B = Zi2 (A − CZi1 )

Solving for Zi1 and Zi2 gives


r
AB
Zi1 =
CD
r
BD
Zi2 =
AC

If the network is symmetric, then A = D and Zi1 = Zi2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 7 / 120


Image Parameter Method

A two-port network terminated in its image impedances and


driven with a voltage generator.
Zi1
I1 I2
+ " # +
+ A B
2V1 V1 V2 Zi2
− C D
− −

Zi1 Zi2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 8 / 120


Image Parameter Method

The output voltage at port-2 can be expressed as,


!
B
V2 = DV1 − BI1 = D − V1
Zi1

The voltage ratio is,


r
V2 B CD
=D− =D −B
V1 Zi1 AB
r
V2 D √ √ 
= AD − BC
V1 A

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 9 / 120


Image Parameter Method
Similarly, the current ratio is,
r
I2 A √ √ 
= AD − BC
I1 D

The factor D/A occurs in reciprocal positions in above


equations, so can be interpreted as a transformer turns ratio.
Apart from this factor, we can define a propagation factor for
the network as,
√ √ √ √
e −γ = AD − BC , e γ = AD + BC

The hyperbolic cosine function cosh γ is,


e γ + e −γ √
!
cosh γ = = AD
2
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 10 / 120
Image Parameter Method
Constant-k filter,
T network π network
Z1 /2 Z1 /2 Z1

Z2 2Z2 2Z2

ABCD Parameters: ABCD Parameters:


Z1 Z1
A= 1+ A= 1+
2Z2 2Z2
Z12 B= Z1
B = Z1 + 1 Z1
4Z2 C= +
C= 1/Z2 Z2 4Z22
Z1 Z1
D= 1+ D = 1+
2Z2 2Z2
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 11 / 120
Image Parameter Method
Constant-k filter,
T network π network
Z1 /2 Z1 /2 Z1

Z2 2Z2 2Z2

Image Impedance: Image Impedance:


r
√ Z1 Z1 Z2
ZiT = Z1 Z2 1+ Zi π =
4Z2 ZiT

Propagation constant: Propagation constant:


s s
Z1 Z1 Z2 Z1 Z1 Z2
eγ = 1 + + + 12 eγ = 1 + + + 12
2Z2 Z2 4Z2 2Z2 Z2 4Z2
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 12 / 120
Image Parameter Method
Constant-k low pass filter,
T network π network
L /2 L /2 L

C C /2 C /2

ABCD Parameters: ABCD Parameters:


Z1 = j ωL , Z2 = 1/j ωC Z1 = j ωL , Z2 = 1/j ωC

ω2 LC ω2 LC
A= 1− A= 1−
2 2
B = j ωL − j ω3 L 2 C /4 B= j ωL
C= j ωC C = j ωC − j ω3 LC 2 /4
ω2 LC ω2 LC
D= 1− D= 1−
2 2
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 13 / 120
Image Parameter Method
Constant-k low pass filter,
T network π network
L /2 L /2 L

C C /2 C /2

Image Impedance: Image Impedance:


#−1/2
ω2 LC
r r
ω2 LC
r "
L L
ZiT = 1− Zi π = 1−
C 4 C 4

Cutoff frequency: Cutoff frequency:

2 2
ωc = √ ωc = √
LC LC
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 14 / 120
Image Parameter Method
Constant-k low pass filter,
T network π network
L /2 L /2 L

C C /2 C /2

Image Impedance: Image Impedance:


s !2 !2 −1/2
ω ω 


ZiT = R0 1− Zi π = R0 1 −
ωc ωc


Where: Where:
r r
2 L 2 L
ωc = √ , R0 = ωc = √ , R0 =
LC C LC C
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 15 / 120
Image Parameter Method

Constant-k low pass filter,


T network π network
L /2 L /2 L

C C /2 C /2

Propagation Constant: Propagation Constant:


s s
2ω 2
2ω ω2
2ω 2
2ω ω2
eγ = 1 − + −1 eγ = 1 − + −1
ω2c ωc ω2c ω2c ωc ω2c

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 16 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k low pass filter.


√ Z1
cosh(γ) = AD = 1 +
2Z2
ω2 LC 2ω2
cosh(γ) = 1 − =1−
2 ω2c
2ω2
For ω < ωc : cos β = 1 −
ω2c
2ω2
For ω > ωc : cosh α = − 2
ωc
Since γ = α + j β

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 17 / 120


Image Parameter Method
For ω < ωc , ZiT , Zi π are real, |e γ | = 1, which imply a passband.
For ω > ωc , ZiT , Zi π are imaginary, e γ is real, −1 < e γ < 0 which
imply a stopband.
γ = α + j β, α is attenuation constant, and β is phase constant.

Passband and stopband characteristics of low pass constant-k filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 18 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k high pass filter,


T network π network
2C 2C C

L 2L 2L

1 1
Z1 = , Z2 = j ωL Z1 = , Z2 = j ωL
j ωC j ωC
r r r " # −1 / 2
L 1 L 1
ZiT = 1− Zi π = 1−
C 4ω2 LC C 4ω2 LC

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 19 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k high pass filter,


T network π network
2C 2C C

L 2L 2L

r  ω 2 "  ω 2 #−1/2
c c
ZiT = R0 1− Zi π = R0 1 −
ω ω
r r
L 1 L 1
R0 = , ωc = √ R0 = , ωc = √
C 2 LC C 2 LC

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 20 / 120


Image Parameter Method

High pass constant-k filter


√ Z1
cosh(γ) = AD = 1 +
2Z2
1 2ω2c
cosh(γ) = 1 − = 1 −
2ω2 LC ω2
2ω2c
For ω < ωc : cosh α = −
ω2
2ω2
For ω > ωc : cos β = 1 − 2c
ω
Since γ = α + j β

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 21 / 120


Image Parameter Method

For ω > ωc , ZiT , Zi π are real, |e γ | = 1, which imply a passband.


For ω < ωc , ZiT , Zi π are imaginary, e γ is real, −1 < e γ < 0 which
imply a stopband.
γ = α + j β, α is attenuation constant, and β is phase constant.

ω
ωc
ω

Passband and stopband characteristics of high pass constant-k filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 22 / 120


Constant-k band pass filter
2C 2C
L /2 L /2

L C

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 23 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k band pass filter


!
1
Z1 = j ωL −
ωC
1
j ωL
j ωC
Z2 =
1
j ωL +
j ωC
j ωL
Z2 =
1 − ω2 LC

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 24 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k band pass filter


Image impedance,
r
p Z1
ZiT = Z1 Z2 1+
4Z2
r
p L
R0 = Z1 Z2 =
C
s
2
(1 − ω2 LC )
r
Z1
1+ = 1−
4Z2 4ω2 LC

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 25 / 120


Image Parameter Method
Constant-k band pass filter
Image impedance,
r r
L Z1
ZiT = 1+
C 4Z2
s
2
r
L (1 − ω2 LC )
ZiT = 1−
C 4ω2 LC
v
u
u !2 2
ω 
u
u 
u
u 
u
u 1 −
ωc
r u 
L u
u
u
ZiT = 1−
u
t
!2
C ω
4
ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 26 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Constant-k band pass filter


The center frequency,
1
ωc = √
LC
Propagation Constant,
√ Z1
cosh γ = AD = 1 +
2Z2
!2  2
ω 


 1 −
ωc 

cosh γ = 1 − 

!2 

 2 ω 
ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 27 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Limitations of constant-k filter


The signal attenuation rate after the cutoff point is not very
sharp.
The image impedance is not a constant when frequency
changes.
Problem of impedance mismatch due variable image
impedance in pass band.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 28 / 120


Image Parameter Method

m-Derived filter
The m-derived filter is a modification of the constant-k filter
designed to overcome the problems of slow rate of attenuation and
variation of image impedance.
Constant-k filter m-Derived filter
Z1 /2 Z1 /2 Z10 /2 Z10 /2

Z2 Z20

Z10 = mZ1

Choose Z20 to obtain same image impedance ZiT


Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 29 / 120
Image Parameter Method

m-Derived filters s
Z12 Z 0 21
ZiT = Z1 Z2 + = Z10 Z20 +
4 4
s s
Z12 m2 Z12
Z1 Z2 + = mZ1 Z20 +
4 4
Solving for Z20 gives,

Z2 (1 − m2 )
Z20 = + Z1
m 4m

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 30 / 120


Image Parameter Method

m-Derived filter
Z10 /2 Z10 /2 mZ1 mZ1
2 2

Z2
m
Z20

1 − m2
Z1
4m

For m =1, m-Derived filter is act as a constant-k filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 31 / 120


Image Parameter Method

m-Derived low pass filter (T network)


1 (1 − m2 )
Z10 = j ωLm, Z20 = + j ωL
j ωCm 4m
j ωLm j ωLm

1
j ωCm

1 − m2
j ωL
4m

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 32 / 120


Image Parameter Method
m-Derived low pass filter (T network)
Propagation constant:
s
Z10 Z10 Z 01
!
γ
e =1+ + 1+
2Z20 Z20 4Z 0 2

Z10 j ωLm
=
Z20 1 (1 − m 2 )
+ j ωL
j ωCm 4m
!2
2ωm

Z10 ωc 2
= !2 , ωc = √
Z20 ω LC
1 − (1 − m2 )
ωc
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 33 / 120
Image Parameter Method
m-Derived low pass filter (T network)
!2 !2
ω ω
1− 1−
Z 01 ωc ωc
1+ = !2 = !2
4Z 0 2 ω ω
1 − (1 − m2 ) 1−
ωc ω∞
Z 01
For 1 + and e γ to be real, the m value is restricted
4Z 0 2
between 0 and 1 (0 < m < 1)
The stop band region began at ω = ωc .
The propagation factor e γ became ∞ at ω = ω∞ , where
ωc
ω∞ = √
1 − m2 s !2
ω
Image impedance: ZiT = R0 1−
ωc
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 34 / 120
Image Parameter Method

m-Derived low pass filter (T network)

Attenuation responses for constant-k, m-derived, and composite filters

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 35 / 120


Image Parameter Method

m-Derived low pass filter (π network)


1 − m2
C
4m

mL

mC /2 mC /2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 36 / 120


Image Parameter Method
m-Derived low pass filter (π network)
4Lm2
!

(1 − m2 )C
Z10 =
4m
j ωLm +
j (1 − m2 )ωC
1
Z20 =
j ωC

Image impedance:
!2
ω
1 − (1 − m2 )
ωc
r
2 L
Zi π = R0 s , ωc = √ , R0 =
!2 LC C
ω
1−
ωc
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 37 / 120
Image Parameter Method

m-Derived low pass filter (π network)


Image impedance:

Variation of Zi π in the pass band of a low-pass m-derived section for various values of m.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 38 / 120


Image Parameter Method

m-Derived high pass filter (T network)


m j ωL (1 − m2 )
Z10 = , Z20 = +
j ωC m j4mωC
2C /m 2C /m

L /m

4m
C
1 − m2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 39 / 120


Image Parameter Method
m-Derived high pass filter (T network)
Propagation constant:
s
Z10 Z10 Z 01
!
γ
e =1+ + 1+
2Z20 Z20 4Z 0 2
m
Z10 j ωC
=
Z20 j ωL (1 − m2 )
+
m j4mωC
!2
2ωc m

Z10 ω 1
=  ω 2 , ωc = √
Z20 c 2 LC
1 − (1 − m2 )
ω
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 40 / 120
Image Parameter Method

m-Derived high pass filter (T network)


 ω 2  ω 2
c c
1− 1−
Z 01 ω ω
1+ =  ω 2 =  ω 2
4Z 0 2 c ∞
1 − (1 − m 2 ) 1−
ω ω
Z 01
For 1 + and e γ to be real, the m value is restricted
4Z 0 2
between 0 and 1 (0 < m < 1)
The pass band region began at ω = ωc .
The propagation
√ factor e γ became ∞ at ω = ω∞ , where
ω∞ = ωc 1 − m2
r  ω 2
c
Image impedance: ZiT = R0 1−
ω
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 41 / 120
Image Parameter Method

m-Derived high pass filter (π network)


4m
L
1 − m2

C /m

2L /m 2L /m

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 42 / 120


Image Parameter Method
m-Derived low pass filter (π network)
4Lm2
!

(1 − m2 )C
Z10 =
m j4mωL
+
j ωC (1 − m 2 )
j ωL
Z20 =
m

Image impedance:
 ω 2
c
1 − (1 − m2 ) r
Zi π = R0
ω , ωc =
1
, R0 =
L
r  ω 2 √
c 2 LC C
1−
ω
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 43 / 120
Image Parameter Method

Composite Filters
Composite filter is realized by combining the constant-k,
m-derived sharp cutoff and the m-derived matching sections in
cascade.
Filter with the desired attenuation and matching properties can
be realized.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 44 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Composite Filters

The final four-stage composite filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 45 / 120


Image Parameter Method
Summary of Composite Filter Design
Low pass filter High pass filter

Constant-k T section Constant-k T section


L /2 L /2 2C 2C

C L

r r
L 2R0 L R0
R0 = L= R0 = L=
C ωc C 2ωc
2 2 1 1
ωc = √ C= ωc = √ C=
LC ωc R0 2 LC 2ωc R0
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 46 / 120
Image Parameter Method

Summary of Composite Filter Design


Low pass filter High pass filter

m-derived T section m-derived T section


mL /2 mL /2 2C /m 2C /m

mC L /m

1 − m2 4m
L C
4m 1 − m2

L, C Same as constant-k L, C Same as constant-k


section. section

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 47 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Summary of Composite Filter Design


Low pass filter High pass filter

m-derived T section m-derived T section


mL /2 mL /2 2C /m 2C /m

mC L /m

1 − m2 4m
L C
4m 1 − m2

1 − (ωc /ω∞ )2
p
1 − (ω∞ /ωc )2
p
m= for sharp-cutoff m= for sharp-cutoff
m = 0.6 for matching m = 0.6 for matching

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 48 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Summary of Composite Filter Design


Low pass filter High pass filter

Bisect π matching section Bisect π matching section


Lm/2 Lm/2 2C /m 2C /m

mC /2 mC /2
2L /m 2L /m

R0 R0 R0 R0
1 − m2 1 − m2 2m 2m
L L C C
2m 2m 1 − m2 1 − m2

ZiT ZiT

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 49 / 120


Image Parameter Method
Example: Design a composite high-pass filter by the image
parameter method with the following specifications: R0 = 75Ω ,
fc = 50 MHz, and f∞ = 48 MHz. Use CAD to plot the insertion loss
versus frequency.
Constant-k T section
2C 2C
ωc = 2πfc = 2 × π × 50 × 106 =
314 × 106 rad /sec
L

R0 75
L= = = 119nH
r 2ωc 2 × 314 × 106
L R0 1 1
R0 = L= C= =
C 2ωc 2ωc R0 2 × 314 × 106 × 75
1 1 C = 21.2pF , 2C = 42.4pF
ωc = √ C=
2 LC 2ωc R0
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 50 / 120
Image Parameter Method

Continue...

s
!2
m-derived T section f∞
m= 1−
2C /m 2C /m fc
s
!2
L /m 48
m= 1− = 0.28
50
4m
C
1 − m2
2C L
= 151pF , = 425nH
L, C Same as constant-k m m
section 4mC
= 25.8pF
1 − m2

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 51 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Continue...

Bisect π matching section


2C /m 2C /m

2C 2 × 21.2
2L /m 2L /m = = 70.7pF
m 0.6
R0 R0
2m
C
2m
C 2L 2 × 119
1 − m2 1 − m2
= = 397nH
m 0 .6
ZiT 2mC
= 39.8pF
1 − m2
m = 0.6

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 52 / 120


Image Parameter Method

Continue...
High Pass Composite Filter.
26.5pF 33.1pF 48.2pF

397nH 425nH 397nH

119nH

39.8pF 25.8pF 39.8pF

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 53 / 120


Image Parameter Method
Continue....
High Pass Composite Filter Response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 54 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
The insertion loss method uses network synthesis tech-
niques to design filters with a completely specified fre-
quency response.
The design is simplified by beginning with low-pass fil-
ter prototypes that are normalized in terms of impedance
and frequency.
Transformations are then applied to convert the pro-
totype designs to the desired frequency range and
impedance level.
Insertion loss methods of filter design lead to circuits us-
ing lumped elements (capacitors and inductors).
For microwave applications such designs usually must
be modified to employ distributed elements consisting of
transmission line sections.
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 55 / 120
Insertion Loss Method
Characterization by Power Loss Ratio,
In the insertion loss method a filter response is defined by its
insertion loss, or power loss ratio, PLR :
Power available from source Pinc
PLR = =
Power delivered to load Pload
P+ 1
PLR = + −
=
P −P 1 − |Γ|2
where,
P−
P = Pinc ,
+
P = Pref ,
− 2
|Γ| = +
P

1
Power gain = G = |S21 |2 =
PLR
The insertion loss (IL) in dB = 10 log PLR
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 56 / 120
Insertion Loss Method
First Order RC Low Pass Filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 57 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

First Order RC Low Pass Filter


!
1
V1 (s ) = R + I(s )
Cs
!
1
V2 (s ) = I(s )
Cs
1
V2 (s )
H (s ) = = RC
V1 (s ) 1
+s
RC
V2 (j ω) ωc 1
H (j ω) = = , ωc = , s = jω
V1 (j ω) ωc + j ω RC

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 58 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

First Order RC Low Pass Filter

ωc 1
|H (j ω)| = p = s
ω2c + ω2 ω
!2
1+
ωc
1 1
G (j ω) = |H (j ω)|2 = !2 =
ω PLR
1+
ωc
!2
ω
PLR = 1 +
ωc
where, G (j ω): Power Gain, PLR : Power Loss

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 59 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

N th Order RC Low Pass Filter


!2N
ω
PLR =1+
ωc
where, N is a order of filter.
 !2N 
 ω 
Insertion loss (IL) = 10 log PLR = 10 log 1 + [dB]
ωc 


Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 60 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Types of Low Pass filters


Maximally flat (or Butterworth, Binomial) Filter
Equal ripple or Chebyshev Filter
Elliptic Filter
Linear phase Filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 61 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
Maximally flat (or Butterworth, Binomial) Filter
!2N
2 ω
Power Loss: PLR = 1 + k , K = 1 for -3dB cutoff point.
ωc
Insertion Loss: IL = 10 log PLR [dB]
IL increases by 20N dB per decade in stop band.

Frequency response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 62 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Maximally flat (or Butterworth, Binomial) Filter


ω
Example: Find order ‘N’ of LPF for 30dB attenuation at = 1 .2
ωc
Solution: Attenuation = PLR = 30 dB ⇒ PLR = 1030/10 = 1000
!2N
ω
PLR =1+
ωc
!2N
ω
999 =
ωc
2N log (1.2) = log 999
N = 3/0.1583 = 18.94 ≈ 19

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 63 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal ripple or Chebyshev Filter


ω
!
Power Loss: PLR = 1 + k 2 TN2
ωc
TN (x ) = Chebyshev polynomial of order N.
N = Order of filter.
ωc = Cutoff angular frequency.
k = constant related to pass band ripple.
k 2 = 10Lr /10 − 1
L = Pass band ripple attenuation in dB.
r
ω −1 ω
! !
2
TN2 = cosh N cosh
ωc ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 64 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal ripple or Chebyshev Filter


Insertion Loss: IL = 10 log PLR
Generally, N is chosen to be an odd integer when the source
and load impedances are equal (two-sided filters).

Frequency response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 65 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal ripple or Chebyshev Filter Filter


ω
Example: Find order ‘N’ of LPF for 30dB attenuation at = 1.2,
ωc
ripple attenuation in pass passband is 1dB.
Solution: Attenuation = PLR = 30 dB ⇒ PLR = 1030/10 = 1000
Ripple attenuation Lr = 1 dB,

k 2 = 10Lr /10 − 1 = 101/10 − 1 = 0.2589


ω
!
2
PLR = 1 + k TN2
ωc
ω −1 ω
! !
2
TN2 = cosh N cosh
ωc ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 66 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal ripple or Chebyshev Filter Filter


Example(Continue)

ω
!
2 2 −1
k cosh N cosh = PLR − 1
ωc
 
0.2589 × cosh2 N cosh−1 1.2 = 999
 
cosh2 N cosh−1 1.2 = 999/0.2589 = 3858.6326
cosh (N × 0.6223) = 62.1178
N × 0.6223 = cosh−1 (62.1178) = 4.8221
N = 4.8221/0.6223 = 7.74 ≈ 8

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 67 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Comparison of order of Low Pass Filter

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 68 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Elliptic Filter
This type of low pass filter has an equi-ripple response in both
the pass band and the stop band.
It has a “faster” roll off than the previous two filters.

Frequency response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 69 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Linear Phase Filter


If it’s important that there be no signal distortion,
then the phase of the filter must be linear in the passband.
A linear phase characteristic can be achieved with the following
phase response:
 !2N 
ω
φ(ω) = A ω 1 + p
 
ωc 


where, φ(ω) is the phase of the voltage transfer function of the filter,
and p is a constant. A related quantity is the group delay, defined
as,
2N
 ! 
dφ ω
τd =
 
= A 1 + p (2N + 1)
ωc


Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 70 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

General Procedure for Filter Design


Filter specifications:
These includes cutoff frequency, the stop band attenu-
ation, the pass band insertion loss, pass band behavior
etc.
Design a low pass prototype circuit:
In such a prototype, R = 1Ω, ωc = 1 rad/s. Filter co-
efficients are require for low pass filter prototype circuit
design. Filter table is used for this step.
Scaling and transformation:
Frequency scaling and transformation techniques are
used to transform low pass filter to desired filter (i.e. Low
pass filter, High pass filter, Band pass filter, Band stop
filter).

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 71 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Maximally Flat Low-Pass Filter Prototype

Ladder circuits for low-pass filter prototypes

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 72 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Maximally Flat Low-Pass Filter Prototype


Element Values for Maximally Flat Low-Pass Filter Prototypes
(g0 = 1, ωc = 1, N = 1 to 10)

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 73 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Maximally Flat Low-Pass Filter Prototype

Attenuation versus normalized frequency for maximally flat filter prototype.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 74 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype


Element Values for Equal-Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype
(g0 = 1,ωc = 1, N = 1 to 10, 0.5 dB )

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 75 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype


Element Values for Equal-Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype
(g0 = 1,ωc = 1, N = 1 to 10, 3 dB )

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 76 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype

Attenuation versus normalized frequency for maximally flat filter prototype (0.5 dB).

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 77 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Equal Ripple Low-Pass Filter Prototype

Attenuation versus normalized frequency for maximally flat filter prototype (3 dB).

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 78 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Impedance Scaling:
XL0 = R0 XL = ω(R0 L ) = ωL 0
R0 1
XC0 = R0 XC = =
ωC ωC 0
Rs0 = R0 , RL0 = R0 RL
where,
L 0 = R0 L , , C 0 = C /R0

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 79 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Frequency Scaling: Low pass prototype to Low pass.
For series reactance,
ω
jXk = j ωLk = j Lk = j ωLk0
ωc
For shunt susceptance,
ω
Frequency scaling for jBk = j ωCk = j Ck = j ωCk0
low-pass response ωc
ω
Replace ω by Lk Ck
ωc Lk0 = , Ck0 =
ωc ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 80 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Frequency Scaling: Low pass prototype to High pass.
For series reactance,

ωc j
jXk = j ωLk = −j Lk = −
ω ωCk0

For shunt susceptance,

Frequency scaling for ωc j


jBk = j ωCk = −j Ck = − 0
high-pass response ω ωLk
ωc
Replace ω by −
ω 1 1
Ck0 = , Lk0 =
ωc Lk ωc Ck

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 81 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Frequency Scaling: Low pass prototype to Band pass.
For series reactance,

ω ω0
!
1
jXk = j ωLk = j − Lk
∆ ω0 ω

j ωLk j ω0 Lk
jXk = −
Frequency scaling for ∆ω0 ∆ω
band-pass response ! j
1 ω ω0 jXk = j ωLk0 −
Replace ω by − ωCk0
∆ ω0 ω
ω2 − ω1 √ L ∆
∆= , ω0 = ω1 ω2 Lk0 = k , Ck0 =
ω0 ∆ω0 ω0 Lk
Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 82 / 120
Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Frequency Scaling: Low pass prototype to Band pass.
For shunt susceptance,
1 ω ω0
!
1 ω ω0 at ω = ω0 , − =0
!
jBk = j ωCk = j − Ck ∆ ω0 ω
∆ ω0 ω
1 ω1
ω0
!
j ωCk j ω0 Ck at ω = ω1 , − = −1
jBk = − ∆ ω0 ω1
∆ω0 ∆ω
1 ω2 ω0
!
j at ω = ω2 , − =1
jBk = j ωCk0 − ∆ ω0 ω2
ωLk0
Note: 1) Series inductance is converted into
Ck ∆ series LC circuit.
Ck0 = , Lk0 = 2) Shunt capacitor is converted into parallel
∆ω0 ω0 Ck LC circuit.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 83 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Scaling and Transformation


Frequency Scaling: Low pass prototype to Band stop.

The series inductor converted


in to parallel LC,

∆Lk 1
Lk0 = , Ck0 =
ω0 ∆ω0 Lk
Frequency scaling for band
stop response The shunt capacitor converted
!−1 in series LC,
ω ω0
Replace ω by −∆ −
ω0 ω 1 ∆Ck
ω2 − ω1 √ Lk0 = , Ck0 =
∆= , ω0 = ω1 ω2 ∆ω0 Ck ω0
ω0

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 84 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

ω2 − ω1
!
Summary of Prototype Filter Transformations ∆ =
ω0

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 85 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Example:
Design a maximally flat low pass filter with cutoff frequency of 2GHz,
impedance of 50Ω, and at least 15dB insertion loss at 3GHz. Com-
pute and plot the amplitude response and group delay for f = 0 to
4GHz

Solution:
First find the required order of the filter to satisfy the insertion
loss specification at 3GHz. We have |ω/ωc | − 1 = 0.5. Re-
ferring to graph of attenuation for maximally flat low pass filter
prototype, we see the value N = 5.
Element values of the filter prototype are obtained using the
table of element values for maximally flat low pass filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 86 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
Continue...
g0 = 1, g1 = 0.618, g2 = 1.618, g3 = 2.000, g4 = 1.618,
g5 = 0.618, g6 = 1
Impedance and frequency scale elements are, Rs = g0 R0 =
50Ω, C10 = g1 /(R0 ωc ) = 0.984pF, L20 = (g2 R0 )/ωc = 6.438nH,
C30 = 3.183pF, L40 = 6.438nH, C50 = 0.984pF, RL = g6 R0 =
50Ω
Rs L20 L40

+
V C10 C30 C50 RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 87 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Example:
Design a 3dB, equi-ripple low pass filter with a cutoff frequency of 2
GHz, 50 Ω impedance level, and at least 15 dB insertion loss at 3
GHz.
The first step is to determine the order of the filter needed to
achieve the required IL at the specified frequency. For this filter
we chose N = 3 to meet the IL specification.
Element values of the filter prototype are obtained using the
table of element values for 3dB equi-ripple low pass filter.
Element values are: g0 = 1, g1 = 3.3487, g2 = 0.7117, g3 =
3.3487, g4 = 1.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 88 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Impedance and frequency scaled elements are, Rs = g0 R0 =
50Ω, C10 = g1 /(R0 ωc ) = 5.33pF, L20 = (g2 R0 )/ωc = 2.83nH,
C30 = 5.33pF, RL = g4 R0 = 50Ω
Rs L20

+
V C10 C30 RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 89 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Example: Design a 3rd order Chebyshev low-pass filter that has a


ripple of 0.5dB and cutoff frequency of 1 GHz.
Solution:
N = 3, Element values are: g0 = 1, g1 = 1.5963, g2 = 1.0967,
g3 = 1.5963, g4 = 1.
Impedance and frequency scaled elements are, Rs = g0 R0 =
50Ω, L10 = L30 = (R0 g1 )/ωc = 12.70nH, C20 = g2 /(R0 ωc ) =
3.49pF, RL = g6 R0 = 50Ω

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 90 / 120


Frame Title

Continue...
Rs L10 L30

+
V C20 RL

Rs = RL = 50Ω, L10 = L30 =


12.70nH , C20 = 3.49pF
Filter Response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 91 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Example: Design 3rd order band pass maximally flat filter at


frequency f0 = 100MHz and -3dB bandwidth of 20MHz.
Solution:
N = 3, Element values are: g0 = 1, g1 = C1 = 1, g2 = L2 = 2,
g3 = C3 = 1, g4 = 1.
Calculate ∆: ∆ = (f2 − f1 )/f0 = 20/100 = 0.2
Impedance and frequency scaled Rs and RL : Rs = g0 R0 =
50Ω, RL = g4 R0 = 50Ω
Using impedance and frequency scaling, shunt capacitor of low
pass filter prototype is converted into parallel LC circuit.
Using impedance and frequency scaling, series inductor of low
pass filter prototype is converted into series LC circuit.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 92 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
1st Parallel LC circuit:
L10 = (∆R0 )/(ω0 C1 ) = (0.2×50)/(2π×100×106 ×1) = 15.91nH,
C10 = C1 /(R0 ω0 ∆) = 1/(50 × 2π × 100 × 106 × 0.2) = 159.15pF
2nd Series LC circuit:
L20 = (L1 R0 )/(ω0 ∆) = (2 × 50)/(2π × 100 × 106 × 0.2) = 800nH,
C20 = ∆/(R0 ω0 L ) = 0.2/(50 × 2π × 100 × 106 × 2) = 3.18pF
3rd Parallel LC circuit:
L30 = (∆R0 )/(ω0 C3 ) = (0.2×50)/(2π×100×106 ×1) = 15.91nH,
C30 = C3 /(R0 ω0 ∆) = 1/(50 × 2π × 100 × 106 × 0.2) = 159.15pF

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 93 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
C20
Rs L20

+
V C10 L10 C30 L30 RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 94 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

3rd Order Band Pass Filter Realization

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 95 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

3rd Order Band Pass Filter Realization

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 96 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Limitations of Filter design using Lumped


components
Lumped element inductors and capacitors are available
only for a limited range of values.
Difficult to implement at microwave frequency range.

Solution
Distributed circuit such as short circuited or open
circuited transmission line stubs are used to
approximate ideal lumped elements.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 97 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Richards Transformation
Richards transformation: Ω = tan βl
Reactance of an inductor: jXL = j ΩL = jL tan βl
Suceptance of an capacitor: jBL = j ΩC = jC tan βl

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 98 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Richards Transformation
Inductor to a short-circuited stub

jXL ⇒ L jXL ⇒ Z0 = L SC

l = λ/8 at ωc
To obtain the cutoff of a low-pass filter prototype at unity frequency, the length must be λ/8. The
distributed circuit is act as a unit cell for Z0 = 1.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 99 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Richards Transformation
Capacitor to a open-circuited stub

jBC ⇒ C jBC ⇒ Z0 = 1/C OC

l = λ/8 at ωc

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 100 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Problem with Richards Transformation


Separation between two distributed components affects
the filter performance at microwave frequencies.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 101 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Kuroda’s Identities
Kuroda’s identities can be used to separate the filter
elements physically by using transmission line sections.
Kuroda’s identities use redundant transmission line
section to achieve practical microwave filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 102 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Advantages of Kuroda’s Identities


Physically separate the transmission line stubs.
Additional transmission line sections do not affect the
filter response.
Transform series stubs into shunt stubs, or vice versa.
Change impractical characteristic impedances into more
realizable values.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 103 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
Kuroda’s Identities (n2 = 1 + Z2 /Z1 )

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 104 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Kuroda’s Identities

Equivalent circuits illustrating Kuroda identity (a) in Table

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 105 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Low-Pass Filter Design Using Stubs


Eaxample: Design a low-pass filter for fabrication using
microstrip lines. The specifications include a cutoff
frequency of 4 GHz, an impedance of 50 Ω , and a
third-order 3 dB equal-ripple pass band response.
Solution:
From Table the normalized low-pass prototype ele-
ment values are g1 = 3.3487 = L1 , g2 = 0.7117 =
C2 , g3 = 3.3487 = L3 , g4 = 1.0000 = RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 106 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Lumped-element low pass filter prototype circuit is obtained.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 107 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Richards transformations is used to convert inductors and
capacitors to series and shunt stubs.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 108 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Unit elements are added at the ends of the filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 109 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
The second Kuroda’s identity is applied to convert series SC
stubs to shunt OC stubs.

n2 = 1 + Z2 /Z1 = 1 + 1/3.3487 = 1.299

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 110 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Impedance and frequency scaling are done.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 111 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Design and fabrication of actual low pass microstrip filter.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 112 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Low-Pass Filter Design Using Stubs


Eaxample: Design a low-pass, fourth-order, maximally
flat filter using only shunt stubs. The cutoff frequency is
8 GHz and the impedance is 50 Ω. Use CAD to plot the
insertion loss versus frequency.
Solution:
From Table the normalized low-pass prototype ele-
ment values are g1 = 0.765 = L1 , g2 = 1.848 = C2 ,
g3 = 1.848 = L3 , g4 = 0.765 = C4 , g5 = 1 = RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 113 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Rs L1 L3

+
V C2 C4 RL

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 114 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Apply Richards Transformation.

0.765 1.848

0.541 1.307

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 115 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
Continue...
Add unit elements (UE) at both ends.
Z1 = 0.765
Z2 = 1.000 Z1 = 1.000
n2 = 2.307 0.765 Z2 = 1.307
1.848 n2 = 2.307
UE UE

1 1

0.541 1.307

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 116 / 120


Insertion Loss Method
Continue...
Use second Kuroda’s identity on left and first Kuroda,s identity
on right.
Z1 = 1.848 Z1 = 1.848
Z2 = 0.567 Z2 = 0.567
n2 = 1.307 1.848 0.433 n2 = 1.307

0.567 1.000

1.765

2.307 0.541

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 117 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Use second Kuroda’s identity twice .

1 1.765 2.415 1.433 1

2.307 0.541 0.741 3.309

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 118 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Scale to 50Ω.
l = λ/8

50Ω 88.30Ω 120.8Ω 71.7Ω 50Ω


l

115.4Ω 27.1Ω 37.1Ω 165.5Ω

All lengths are λ/8 long at 8 GHz.

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 119 / 120


Insertion Loss Method

Continue...
Filter response

Mr. Sajeed S. Mulla RF Filter January 20, 2020 120 / 120

Potrebbero piacerti anche