Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Table II. Femoral and tibial fractures according to stability always used at the beginning of the rehabilitation pro-
gramme.
Femur Tibia Patients presenting with symptoms suggestive of deep
vein thrombosis were allowed to stand and walk only after
Unstable in rotation 21 22 full symptomatic resolution. Sedentary workers returned to
Unstable in rotation- 50 39
work 45 days ( f 6, range 35-53 days) after the operation,
compression
and heavy labourers 105 days ( f 13, range 88-124 days)
Total 71 61
after the operation.
Swimming was encouraged after skin healing. Cycling
was allowed when the patient could walk without aids.
Non-contact sports training was allowed after 6 months, if
FURC would have less than 50 per cent of the available the patients were completely asymptomatic. Contact sports
cortical bone intact, regardless of its location. It generally training was allowed 8 months after the operation, and
corresponds to types 3, 4 and 5 of Winquist et al. (1984). competition 12 to 15 months after the beginning of training.
However, no type 5 fractures of Winquist et al. (1984) were Dynamization was performed at 9 to 12 weeks post-
included in this study. operatively. Four fracture/nail configurations were not
Patients younger than 16 years, patients in whom another dynamized due to extensive comminution at the fracture
long bone of the lower limb needed internal fixation, and site.
patients with signs of ligamentous knee instability were
excluded from the study. Table III. Assessment system
A total of 132 patients satisfied the above criteria, and
underwent ILN of their fractures. Of these patients, 71 Pain (30 points)
Walking
sustained femoral fractures, and the remaining 61 tibial None 15
fractures (T&Z I and Tabk U). Mild 10
Moderate 5
Surgical management Severe 0
All patients were operated on within 24 h of admission,
At rest
except patients with grade I and II open fractures (seven None 15
femoral and 10 tibial) (Miiller et al., 1979), who were treated Mild 10
within 6 h of admission. Patients with grade III open tibial Moderate 5
Severe 0
fractures (three cases) were operated on after their skin
lesions resolved (2-3 weeks). In these latter cases, length Function (17 points)
and alignment were maintained using a calcaneal Steinmann Walking
Walking and standing unlimited 12
pin. 500 mt. standing > 30 min 10
Surgical technique was strictly the one described by 100-300 mt, standing 15-30min a
Grosse et al. (1978), Kempf et al. (1976), Kempf et al. <lOOmt 4
(1978a), Kempf et al. (1978b) and Pintore (1987). The Unable to walk 0
operative procedures were performed with the patient in the Stairs
supine position by surgeons of differing experience, ranging Unlimited 5
Supported 2
from resident to senior staff surgeons. A standard image
intensifier was used to insert the interlocking screws using a Range of motion (45 points)
jig. The medullary cavity was not washed out after reaming Ankle (for tibia1 fractures only)
40% 10
it l-1.5 mm more than the diameter of the nail, and a suction 50% 11
drain was used only for femoral fractures. The patients’ 60% 12
positioning time and operating time were recorded. 70% 14
The length of the nail to be used in each case was Full 15
determined preoperatively by measuring the length of the Knee
contralateral uninjured bone on radiographs, and sub- 40% 10
50% 11
tracting 2 cm for both the femur and the tibia. The range of
60% 12
length of the nails used was 38-42 cm for the femur, and 70% 14
3(F-34 cm for the tibia. Of the nails, 92 per cent were 13 mm Full 15
in diameter. Hlfor femoral fractures only)
Immediately after the operation, each patient was 10
examined by the surgeon in the operating theatre to check 50% 11
for deformity and stability of the fracture site. Rotatory and 60% 12
70% 14
angular deformity and leg length discrepancy were evalu-
Full 15
ated comparing the operated with the non-operated side.
Subtraction
Postoperative management One cane 1
In some patients, a plaster-of-Paris back slab was applied One crutch 2
Two crutches 3
after the operation, and maintained for 24 h after nailing. Full
weight bearing was allowed to FURS on the second Deformity (5”= 1 point)
Varus
postoperative day. FURCs were allowed immediate weight Valgus
bearing of up to 10 per cent of their body weight for 2 weeks Recurvatum
after operation. According to their clinical and radiological Flexion
appearance, they gradually progressed to full weight bear- Excellent: 72 or more; Good: 49-71; Fair: 40-46; Poor: 39 or less.
ing 6 to 8 weeks after operation. Sticks and crutches were
Pintore et al.: Interlocking nailing of femur and tibia 383
Nail removal was performed routinely at an average of 21 ning of the study were always significantly longer than at
months for the femoral fractures, and 23.2 months for the the end (I’< 0.03) for both the femur and the tibia. It took 1
tibial fractures after the primary operation. year to reduce significantly, and maintain constant, the
above variables in the femur. Two years were necessary to
Clinical assessment
reduce patients’ positioning time and operating time in tibial
Patients were seen as outpatients 4 weeks after discharge.
fractures.
They were subsequently reviewed at 3, 6 and 12 months
Tibial fractures were found to be technically more
after the operation, and at 6-monthly intervals thereafter
demanding than femoral fractures. The clinical results are
until full healing of the fracture and of the bony screw holes.
summarized in TubkN. Closed reduction was always
More frequent or longer follow-up was because of the
achieved intraoperatively.
patient’s clinical status, or the surgeon’s request. On each
appointment, a formal prearranged assessment was carried Intraoperative complications
out by a resident (Ekeland et al., 1988) (TubleIIT). Radio- In three cases, the drill bit broke in the popliteal fossa. The
graphs of the operated bone in two views were taken at each drill was removed through a small incision in the posterior
visit, and assessed by a radiologist who was given no clinical aspect of the knee after turning the patient at the end of the
details other than ‘operated on.. . (date)‘. Healing was operation.
defined clinically as full painfree range of motion of all the In two femoral fractures, excessive arm traction was
joints of the operated limb and painless full weight bearing. applied when trying to reduce the fracture. This resulted in
Radiographic healing was defined when mature callus was C5-C6 bra&al plexus neurapraxia resolving in less than 1
present, bridging across the fracture. week.
A malunion was defined as shortening greater than 2 cm, In two patients aged 80+, the perineal post caused
or angular deformity greater than IO”, or rotational deform- pressure sores on the operating table.
ity greater than 15” (Alho et al., 1990). Results were graded In one further case, the nail perforated the femoral cortex,
as excellent, good, fair or poor. and had to be re-routed.
Operative results
The average time between a patient’s entrance to the
operating theatre and skin incision was 35 f 6.8 min for Table V. Overall results
femoral fractures and 41 f 11.3 min for tibial fractures
Femur Tibia
(P= NS). The average duration of the operative procedure
was 5 I f 14 min for femoral fractures and 73 f 22 min for
Excellent 20 16
tibial fractures (P= 0.04). At the end of the study, patients’ Good 39 35
positioning time and the operating time of the first ten Fair 9 6
operations of each of the 4 calendar years of the study for Poor 3 4
both the femur and the tibia were compared using ANOVA. Total 71 61
Patients’ positioning time and operating time at the begin-
384 Injury: the British journal of Accident Surgery (1992) Vol. 23/No. 6
Figure 1. a, The only case in which a nail broke. This occurred in an uncooperative, mentally
retarded patient. b, The proximal fragment was removed, and fib&r osteotomy and tibial plating
performed. Valgus deviation and posterior displacement resulted.
tive month. In one case of open Grade II tibial fracture, a four cases of shortening were due to early dynamization,
compartment syndrome of the leg developed. It was treated and we are now more cautious in dynarnization in type 4
with extensive fasciotomy. Finally, in two cases with fractures. Some fractures are never dynamized.
subtrochanteric fractures, one being a pathological fracture, According to Grosse and Kempf, ILN can be applied to
consolidation occurred with a varus deformity. any fracture of the lower limb provided that at least 3-4 cm
of bone is intact proximally and distally to the fracture site
Clinical assessment
(Kempf et al., 1976; Grosse et al., 1978; Kempf et al., 1978a;
The results of assessment are given in Table I/. Over 80 per
Kempf et al., 1987b; Kempf, 1986).
cent of the patients were found to have at least a good result.
Many of the reported malunions were due to dynamic
In only seven cases was there a poor outcome.
locking of unstable fractures (Thorensen et al., 1985).
A secondary ANOVA of the 22 fair and poor .vs the
Unfortunately, at the beginning of the study we dynamized
excellent and good results was performed using age, delay
some of the fractures too early. In these cases, the callus was
between injury and operating time, time between operation
probably not mature enough to bear the full body-weight,
and full weight bearing, and time between operation and
and shortening occurred. At present, we statically lock all
dynamization of the nail as covariates. A non-statistically
nails in comminuted fractures to start with, and dynamize
significant trend towards greater age and longer time
them only when radiographic findings of mature callus are
between operation and full weight bearing was identified.
unequivocal.
The patients who showed a poor or fair result were 16 per
cent of the total, which is higher than that found by other
Discussion authors (Winquist et al., 1984; Thorensen et al., 1985;
ILN of fractures of the long bones of the lower limb has Court-Brown et al., 1990; Wiss et al., 1990). This could be
proved to be an excellent method of treatment. In the tibia, due to the stringency of the selection criteria applied, to the
knee pain seems to be the main problem associated with the inclusion in the study of all the patients operated on from the
technique (Court-Brown et al., 1990) and is generally very first moment the technique was introduced in the
experienced with kneeling. Its incidence is significantly department, when the technique was not properly standard-
higher than in the femur. In several cases, it may require ized, and to surgeons at different stages of training perform-
removal of the nail, but it rarely interferes with work. The ing the operation.
present series compares favourably with recent ones (Court- Statistical analysis revealed a non-significant trend of
Brown et al., x990), both for its incidence and for the need to these patients to have been allowed full weight bearing after
remove the hardware. In the femur, ILN may be associated the operation only after a longer time than the patients in
with a high rate of complications, especially in elderly the excellent and good result groups. Whether this is due to
patients (Moran et al., 1990). their greater age, to underlying medical conditions or to the
Most of the complications in the present series were not complexity of the surgery performed is not clear, but
directly related to the nailing, but reflected more general rehabilitation programmes should probably take this issue
problems. However, the great majority of the patients were into consideration.
provided with immediate stable fixation, early mobilization,
rehabilitation and return to work.
Acknowledgements
The great majority of technical problems were encoun-
tered in the initial phase of the learning curve, when errors Many thanks are given to Drs J. Dayez and G. Melere,
have a high prevalence. More recently, as the technique has Chirurgiens Orthopedistes et Chefs de Service, Centre
been well standardized, and the experience acquired Hospitalier d’Annecy, Services de Chirurgie Orthopedique
matured, very few complications have occurred. When this et Traumatologique, Annecy, France, for allowing us to
happened, they were largely unavoidable and largely report on patients under their care.
unpredictable. Given the technical expertise achieved after 4 Mr C. Blakeway FRCS, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon,
years of application of ILN, we feel that the procedure has Poole General Hospital, England, gave us precious advice
become safe in our hands and, given the proper support, when writing this report.
relatively easy to perform. This is shown by the significant Dr Gabriella N. M. Giudici helped greatly in preparing
reduction in patients’ positioning time and operating time the manuscript.
between the beginning and the end of this study.
Recently, Brumack et al. (1988a, 1988b) have published
their experiences using the classification of fractures
developed by Winquist et al. (1984). We have outlined
References
above a classification scheme which allows a rapid therapeu- AlhoA., Ekeland A., Stromsoe K. et al. (1990) Locked intramedul-
tic plan, based on the morphological appearance of the lary nailing for displaced tibia1 shaft hactures. J Bone]oinf Surg.
fracture site and its location. 72% 805.
In stable fractures, an unlocked nail will suffice. In FURCs Beck G. (1985) Locked intramedullary nailing for femoral and tibial
static ILN is recommended. In FURS, dynamic ILN will be fractures with comminution or bone loss. American Association
performed, as rotation is by definition well controlled by of Orthopedic Surgery Annual Meeting. Las Vegas, January
proximal or distal locking, and there are no risks of 1985, paper 60.
shortening with nail migration (Kempf et al., 1976). The Brumback R. J., Reilly J. P., Poke A. et al. (1988a) IntrameduIIary
classification is also indicative of a strategy to adopt in the nailing of femoral shaft fractures. Part I: decision-making errors
postoperative management of these patients. Grosse and with interlocking fixation. J. BoneJoinf Surg. 70A, 1441.
Kempf proposed dynamizing all statically locked fractures Brumback R. J., Uwagie-Ero S., Lakatos R. P. et al. (1988b)
between the 9th and the 12th postoperative week (Grosse et Intramedullary nailing of femoral shaft fractures. Part II:
al., 1978; Kempf et al., 1985; Kempf, 1986). At the beginning fracture-healing with static interlocking fixation. J Borz Joint
of our experience, we followed this practice. However, the Sutg. 70A, 1453.
386 Injury: the BritishJournalof Accident Surgery (1992) Vol. 23/No. 6
Christie J., Court-Brown C. M., Kinnimonth A. W. G. et al. (1988) Klemm K. and Schellmann W. D. (1972) Dynamysche und Statisch
Intramedullary locking nail in the management of femoral shaft Verriegelung des Marknagels. Monafschr. Unfallchir. 75,568.
fractures. 1. Bone]oinf Surg. 7OB, 206. Kiintscher G. B. (1983) Prucficeof lnfrumedulkay Nailing. Illinois:
Court-Brown C., Christie J. and McQueen M. M. (1990) Closed Charles C Thomas.
intramedullary tibial nailing. Its use in closed and type I open Kiintscher G. B. (1968) Die Marknagelung des Trummerbrude.
fractures. j. BoneJoint !%rg. 72B, 605. lungebecks Arch. Chir. 322, 1063.
Delefortrie G., Taglang G., Mahieu C. et al. (1986) Apport de Leland W. (1988) SYSTAT: the Sysfem for Sfafisfics. Evanston, Ill:
l’enclouage verrouille dam le traitment des pseudarthroses Systat Inc., l-989.
diaphysaires aseptique du membre inferieur. Acfu Orthop. Ii&. Moran C. G., Gibson M. J. and Cross A. T. (1990) Intramedullary
52,651. locking nails for femoral shaft fractures in elderly patients.
Donald G. and Seligson D. (1983) Treatment of tibia1 shaft j. Bone]oinf Surg. 72B, 19.
fractures by percutaneous Kiintscher nailing: technical diffi- Miiller M. E., Allgiiwer M. and Sneider R. (1979) Manual of Infernal
culties and a review of SO consecutive cases. Clin. Orfhop. Rel. FFrafion. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
Res. 17864. Pintore E. (1987) Principi, tecniche ed indicazioni dell’enclouage
Ekeland A., Thoresen B. O., Alho A. et al. (1988) Interlocking verrouille (chiodo bloccato) in chirurgia ortopedica e traumato-
intramedullary nailing in the treatment of tibial fractures. A logica. Specialization in Orthopaedics Thesis, First Medical
report of 45 cases. Clin. Orfhop. Rel. Res. 231,205. School, University of Naples.
Folleras G., Ahlo A., Stromsoe K. et al. (1990) Locked intramedul- Schellmann W. and Klemm K. (1979) The treatment of pseudar-
lary nailing of fractures of femur and tibia. Injury 21,385. throsis with interlocking nails. III: Klemm K., ed. Psardarthrosesof
Grosse A., Kempf I. and Lafforgue D. (1978) Le traitment des the 7&a: Treufmnf. Stuttgart: George Thieme Publishers.
fracas, pertes de substance osseuse et pseudarthroses du femur Schvingt E., Jacquemaire B., Babin S. et al. (1976) L’enclouage
et du tibia (a propos de 40 cas). Supplement II. I&n. Chir. Orfhop. d’alignement des fractures dyaphisaires du femur. Application
64, 33. originale de la methode de Kiintscher. A propos de 44 cas. Rev.
Hausen S. T. and Winquist R. A. (1979) Closed intramedullary Chir. Orfhop. 62, 137.
nailing of the femur. Ktitscher technique with reaming. Clin. Thorensen B. O., Alho A., Ekeland A. et al. (1985) Interlocking
Orfhop. l&l. Res. X38,56. intramedullary nailing in femoral shaft fractures. A report of
Hindley C. J., Evans R. A., Holt E. M. et al. (1990) Locked forty-eight cases. 1. BoneJoint Surg. 67.4, 1113.
intramedullary nailing for recent lower limb fractures. Injuy 2 I, Wiiquist R. A., Hansen H. Jr and Clawson D. K. (1984) Closed
239. intramedullary nailing of femoral fractures. A report of five
Kempf I. (1986) Enclouage centro-medullaire des OSlongs. Cahiers hundred and twenty cases. 1. Eone]oinf Surg. 66A, 529.
d’enseignement de la S.O.F.C.O.T. Conference d’enseignement Wiss D. A., Brien W. W. and Stetson W. B. (1990) Interlocked
211. nailing for treatment of segmental fractures of the femur. 1. Bone
Kempf I., Grosse A. and Beck G. (1985) Closed locked intramedul- ]oinf Surg. 72A, 724.
lary nailing. Its application to comminuted fractures of femur. 1. Zucman J. and Mauer P. (1971) Primary medullary nailing of the
Bonejoint Surg. 67A, 709. tibia for fractures of the shaft in adults. Injury 2, 84.
Kempf I., Grosse A. and Lafforgue D. (1976) L’enclouage avec
bloccage de la rotation ou ‘clou bloque’. Principes, techniques,
indications et premiers resultats. Communication a la Joumee
Paper accepted 16 December 1991.
d’Hiver de la S.O.F.C.O.T.
Kempf I., Grosse A. and Lafforgue D. (1978a) L’apport du
verrouillage dans l’enclouage centro-medullaire des OS longs.
Rev. Chir. Orfhop. 64, 635.
Kempf I., Jaeger J. H., Clavert J. M. et al. (1978b) Enclouage Rsqtcestsfor reprintsshouti be addrd to: N. Maffulli, Department of
centro-medullaire avec alesage. Critique theorique et experi- Orthopaedics, Newham General Hospital, Glen Road, Plaistow,
mentale des principes de Kiintscher. Rev. Chir. Orfhop. 64,629. London El3 8RU, UK.