Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
banana pseudostem, paddy (rice) or wheat straw compost and saw dust
(Jandaik, 1976b; Zadrazil, 1976). Zadrazil (1976, 1978) has described the
cultivation of different species of Pleurotus, viz., P. ostreatus, P. florida, P.
eryngii, P. cornucopiae, P. sajor-caju, Pleurotus salmoneo stramieus and
Pleurotus abalone. In addition to this, Jong and Peng (1975) and Han et al.
(1977) reported the cultivation of Pleurotus cystidiosus in Taiwan. In Nigeria,
some attempts were made to cultivate Pleurotus tuber-regium (Fr.) Sing, a
mushroom used as food as well as in folk medicine (Oso, 1977). Singh and
Rajarathnam (1977) introduced Pleurotus eous for artificial culture on rice
straw. Imbemon et al. (1983) reported the cultivation methods for Pleurotus
pulnionarius (Fr.) Quel, and Pleurotus columbinus. Ghosh and Chakravarty
(1986) successfully cultivated Pleurotus citrinopileatus using paddy straw as
substrate. Marimuthu et al. (1991) reported Pleurotus platypus (Cooke and
Massce) See. as a promising species for cultivation on pady straw. Among
these species of Pleurotus, P. sajor-caju is gaining importance in tropical
climate due to its higher yield potential (Chang et al., 1981). Although
Pleurotus has a fairly extensive history, it has gained prominance only
recently (Rajarathnam and Bano, 1987).
2.2. Substrate
Success of mushroom cultivation in a particular situation depends upon
the identification of proper substrate available locally. Pleurotus species have
a remarkable ability to colonize a wide range of natural ligjjo-cellulotic
materials, whether fermented or unfermented (Rajarathnam and Bano, 1987).
But it did not grow on preformed synthetic substrates like compost having
relatively high nitrogen content (Bano, 1967; Jandaik, 1976(a); Lelley, 1984).
Pleurotus has a characteristic ability to colonize plant wastes with low
nitrogen content (Jandaik, 1976).
Various cellulotic raw materials have been tried for the cultivation of
Pleurotus species. Decaying wood was found to be the natural habitat of
Pleurotus. Therefore, the earliest workers attempted to culture them on wood
(Falck, 1917; Passecker, 1959; Luthard, 1969; Vessey and Toth, 1970).
13
Cultivation of Pleurotus on saw dust was first reported by Block et al. (1958)
and then by Kedyk and SmoAtachova (1959). Recently, Kothandaraman et al.
(1991) reported the possibility of using rubber wood saw dust for the
cultivation of P. florida. Block et al. (1959) used compost for the cultivation.
Identification of straw as substrate for commercial cultivation of P. flabellatus
by Bano and Srivastava (1962) was another major break through. In their
trials the mushroom beds measuring 30 x 30 x 22.5 cm were prepared using
cut and soaked paddy straw on raised platform. Multilayered spawning
technique was adopted and the beds were watered twice a day. Schanel et al.
(1966) and Herzig et al. (1968) also used straw for the cultivation of Pleurotus.
Bhattachaijee (1974) and Delmus and Laborde (1974) reported the methods
for commercial cultivation of P. ostreatus and P. flabellatus using straw as raw
material. Park et al. (1975) tried different methods for P. ostreatus cultivation
on rice straw. In India, P. sajor-caju was experimentally cultivated on straw,
banana pseudostem and other cellulotic materials (Jandaik and Kapoor,
1974a, Jandaik, 1976b; Rangaswamy et al., 1975). Different substrate used
for cultivation of P. sajor-caju and the yield obtained in different parts of the
world are given in Table 1.
(Contd...... )
15
Platt et al. (1982) developed a method to utilise cotton straw for the
cultivation of P. ostreatus in Israel. In this method, chopped cotton straw was
soaked in water for two days and then pasteurized at 70°C for eight hours.
The moisture content in the substrate was 70%. The yield obtained was 600-
700 g per kg of dry substrate. Similar studies ware- conducted by Lavie (1988)
and- reported that after utilisation of lignin for mushroom growth^the spent
cotton straw could be used as digestible nutritive feed for cattle and sheep.
When barley and paddy straw were used for the cultivation of P.
cornucopiaef the mushroom yield was 20% of the wet weight of the substrate
(Delmus and Mamoun, 1982). Heltay (1987) also used barley straw for P
ostreatus cultivation.
pulp (Daniel et al., 1985). Martinez-carrera (1987) also reported the successful
cultivation of P. ostreatus, P florida and P sajor- caju on fermented coffee pulp
with a BE of 128.12, 159.95 and 175.8 per cent respectively. But when
unfermented coffee pulp was used for the cultivation of P. florida BE was 45%
(Pandey and Tiwari, 1991). They also reported 45% BE with tea waste from
factory.
To find out better and cheaper substrates than the conventional ones,
researchers evaluated the performance of different weed plants as substrates
for culturing Pleurotus. Lantana camara L. is a common, profusely growing
weed plant in most part of the tropical countries. Bisht and Harsh (1984) used
chopped Lantana along with waste paper as a substrate for P ostreatus
cultivation. In a similar attempt, Das et al. (1987) conducted preliminary
studies on the cultivation of P. flabellatus and P. sajor-caju on a substrate
prepared from weeds like Parthenium, Hysterophorus, Eupatorium and
Eichornia. In West Germany, Johannes (1987) established the successful
18
length were used for Agaricus cultivation. Fiber glass or flexible foamed
plastic was used to provide insulation over the outside of the asbestos
structure and that was covered with two layers of black polythene or roofing
felt. The black polythene roof was reinforced with coarse mesh netting or
cords to prevent the sheet being blown away by wind. Oil based aluminium
paint was used to paint the roof to reduce heat loss in winter and solar heat
gain in summer. End walls were built of bricks, concrete blocks or any other
conventional materials (Edwards, 1978).
houses were used for growing not only the common mushroom A. bisporusfiut
also the paddy straw mushroom and other kinds of edible fungi (Ho et al.,
1968).
A few types of houses were designed and used for Pleurotus cultivation
in different localities. Moorthy (1981) has described a Pleurotus mushroom
house provided with ventilation holes at the bottom and at the top. Wooden
racks were constructed inside the house to keep mushroom bags. Under each
rack a water channel of 15 cm width was provided to increase the relative
humidity to an optimum level of 80-90%.
capacity to hold 36 vertical beds with a central perforated pipe for support.
Another farm was designed for P. sajor-caju cultivation in the rural sector. In
this farm thatched huts made of bamboo and coconut leaves were used for
*
submerged cultures were also used as spawn, (Toren, 1967; Kligman, 1950;
Dijkstra et al., 1972). Go (1959) has experimentally cultivated paddy straw
mushroom using coffee pulp spawn. Lemke (1971) has introduced another
kind of spawn known as ‘Perlite spawn’, wherein mushroom mycelia were
grown over a substrate prepared by mixing perlite, wheat bran, gypsum, chalk
powder and water at suitable proportions.
Lemke (1972) modified the method for spawn preparation for Agaricus
reported by Stoller (1962). It was found that 50% moisture content in the
grains and a pH of 6.5 to 6.7 were ideal for the better development of
A. bisporus mycelia in spawn bottles. In this method, wheat grains were
boiled in water for 15 min and excess water was drained out. After cooling,
gypsum (CaSo42H20) and lime (CaC03) were added and mixed properly. Thus
mixture was filled in milk bottles and sterilized at 121°C for two hours. These
bottles were inoculated with grain spawn or with pieces of agar medium
colonised with mycelium. Studies were also conducted to evaluate the
suitability of various substrates for Pleurotus spawn production. Bano (1967)
evaluated different substrates viz., soft wood saw dust, hard wood saw dust,
ragi grain, jowar grain and chopped rice straw for P. flabellatus spawn
production and achieved higher yield with chopped rice straw. Hu et al. (1972)
also used paddy straw with amendments for spawn production. Successful
Pleurotus spawn production was achieved by using anaerobically fermented
Vv
wheat grains (Hunke et al., 1973). Szudyya et al. (1973) reported that the
* *>
grain spawn was superior to manure spawn in getting higher yield. Hunke
etal. (1973) reported an industrial method of spawn production based on
fermented substrate. However, wheat, barley, oat, jowar and ragi grains were
found to be the ideal substrates for P. sajor-caju spawn production (Jandaik
and Kapoor, 1974b).
substrate^has given about 50% of the yield produced by using fresh grain
spawn (Anonymous, 1975). Ravi et al. (1991) have also studied the feasibility
of using spent substrate^as an alternate ; cheap source of cereal based spawn.
■A
The study revealed that the mushroom production was significantly low, and
the time taken for mycelial run as well as for first harvest were more than
that of cereal based spawn.
spawn substrate for these three mushrooms (Kotwaliwale et al., 1991). But
Sivaprakasam and Ramraj (1991) reported sorghum grain with two per cent
calcium carbonate as the ideal spawn base.
Zadrazil (1980b) has explained an ideal container system for large scale
production of Pleurotus. The system involves a self supporting construction.
In this system, the substrate was filled into plastic sacks or forms with a
removable cover, thus forming a piller with a radius of about 30 cm and a
height of about 200 cm which,after permeation,was self supporting and carried
only by a central tube with a metal base. This central tube also helped to
remove heat from the centre of the cylindrical container. This pillar of
compost with relatively large surface,was found to be , ideal form as regards
volume and weight. It was also possible to hang the pillar to an overhead rail.
The other system explained by Zadrazil (1980b) was a high volume container
(30-40 x 220 x 120 cm) or a permanent construction, containing about 400 kg
of compost with solid walls which could be removed for the harvest period. „ A
similar method has also been adopted for P. sajor-caju cultivation wherein
long polythene sacks with a central supporting structure was used (Bano et
26
al, 1979a; 1979b; Bano and Rajarathnam, 1982). Sathe and Nagarkar (1983)
have explained a method of cultivation of P. sajor-caju wherein a perforated
bamboo stick was placed inside polythene bags.
Chakravarty and Sarkar (1978) used earthen trays, soil bed and nylon
nets to cultivate Pleurotus mushrooms. Polythene bag was found to be the
most convenient and cheap container for Pleurotus cultivation. This container
has been widely used in the cultivation of all species of Pleurotus (Bano and
Nagaraj, 1976; Leong, 1980; Shetty and Moorthy, 1980; Moorthy, 1981; Platt,
1982; Singh, 1983; Sivaprakasam and Ramraj, 1991).
Khanna and Garcha (1981) have used bamboo baskets as the container
for Pleurotus cultivation.
Pleurotus has the characteristic ability to colonize plant wastes with low
nitrogen content and to produce fruiting bodies of high nitrogen content. But
preparation of substrate into an ideal form, suited for mushroom growth is
important in mushroom cultivation (Rajarathnam and Bano, 1987).
While preparing cotton straw for the P. ostreatus culture Platt et al.,
(1982) have steeped chopped cotton straw for two days and then pasteurized
at 70°C for eight hours. The yield obtained was 600-700 g per kg of dry cotton
straw. Studies were also conducted on the effect of duration of autoclaving of
«
It has been reported that the yield of P. sajor-caju increased with the
increase in spawn inoculam from I to 4% on wet weight basis of paddy straw
substrate (Sivaprakasam and Ramraj, 1991). Tiwari (1991) also reported the
requirement of high dose of spawn (4%) during summer season whereas 2%
spawn dose was ideal during rainy and winter seasons.
dry straw in P. sajor-caju cultivation. But among the various organic and
inorganic amendments, soyabean meal or alfalfa meal treatments gave the
highest yield in this trial. The increase in yield by these two amendments was
to the tune of about 300% over the control, plain wheat straw. Chakravarty
and Sarkar (1978, 1984) also reported the positive effect of inorganic
amendments on the yield of P. sajor-caju. In this study, addition of a complex
fertilizer, NPK (15:15:15) was found to increase the yield. Based on their study,
they have recommended the use of fertilizer mixed substrate only for the lower
layers of the bed or bag.
Royse and Schisler (1987) reported that the addition of spawn mate-II,
a delayed release nutrient available in U.S.A., increased the yield of P.
sajor-caju. Among the three levels studied, viz., 0, 32 an 63 per cent (w/w) the
maximum yield was reported at 63% level. In subsequent studies, spawn
33
mate-II was used at much lower level when alfalfa was used in combination
with wheat straw at 20:80 (w/w) (Royse and Bahler, 1988).
Rao (1991) reported that P. florida yield was increased when paddy
straw was supplemented with 4% (on dry weight basis) rice bran or cashew
(Anacardium occidentale) apple waste or brewers grain. Addition of brewers
grain to paddy straw gave the highest yield (72% BE). The yield of P.
sajor-caju, P. sapidus and P. abalone was increased when paddy straw was
supplemented with wheat bran, rice bran, corn meal, soabean meal and oat
meal (Bahukhandi and Chamola (1991).
increased or did not significantly affect the total weight of the first flush crop.
Continuous exposure to 16°C delayed the time of harvest. Exposure to 16°C
for six days which resulted in higher yield than with four days or continuous
exposure was considered optimal (Flegg, 1980). However, such studies on the
possibility of temperature induced syncronization of fruiting body formation or
sudden exposure of the mushroom beds to low temperature for a short period
have not been conducted in Pleurotus cultivation.
2.8.2. Carbon dioxide and oxygen: It is a well known fact that bacteria,
yeast and moulds do require carbon dioxide for their growth (Valley and
Rettger, 1927; Hermann, 1963; Broon and Luca, 1973). Complete removal of
C02 from the ecosystem can cause decrease of growth of the microorganisms
(Lafferty, 1963).
for P. eryngii the limit for stimulation was 22%. On the other hand, a high
concentration of 37.5% (V/V) reduced the mycelial growth in all the three
Pleurotus species by about 40% as compared to that at 0.03%. In contrast to
the behaviour of Pleurotus species, the mycelial growth of Agaricus bisporus
was reduced with the rise in C02 concentration and at 32% (V/V), growth was
completely inhibited (Tschierpe, 1958, 1959, 1972). Many other
Basidiomycetes also exhibited the same behaviour as A. bisporus (Zadrazil and
Sehliemann 1974). High CO2 concentration in the substratum might be acting
as a shield for Pleurotus against the colonization of other microorganisms,
which either can not grow or die off at higher CO2 concentrations. To take
advantage of this character of Pleurotus, tunnel process could be utilised
wherein semi-anaerobic condition with 20% CO2 (V/V), can be created by the
addition of CO2. Thus non-resistant aerobic competitive micro organisms can
be excluded right from the initial stage of cultivation (Zadrazil, 1975).
80% in the substrate adversely affected the Pleurotus mycelial growth and
encouraged bacterial growth.
required for urban unit was estimated as 1750 m and for rural unit as
5000m2. The area of permanent type of building for urban unit was proposed
as 350 m2 and temporary huts for rural unit as 1680 m2. The total project cost
39
Cost per kg
Item Per cent
Rs. Ps.
Cost per kg
Item Per cent
Rs. Ps.
Table 4. Break down of production cost of one kg of oyster mushroom in 1986 at Bangalore
Cost per kg
Item Per cent
Rs. Ps.
Cost per kg
Item Per cent
Rs. Ps.
Cost per kg
Item Per cent
Rs. Ps.
in 1987 was estimated as Rs. 3.2 lakhs for urban unit and Rs. 1.25 lakhs for
rural unit. The cost of production per kg of fresh mushroom was Rs. 16.70 for
the urban unit and Rs. 13.97 for the rural unit. Of the different production
inputs, cost of labour formed the msgor part. It was 39% of the total cost in
urban sector and 47.7% in rural sector. The cost of raw material was less than
25% in both sectors whereas the capital input constituted 15.1% and 17.7% in
urban and rural sectors respectively.
Tiwari and Subramanian and Tiwari (1983) (1986) worked out cost of
production for P. sajor-caju cultivation at Bangalore. It was Rs. 6.61 per kg in
1983 and increased to Rs. 10.65 in 1986. Table-3 gives break-down of
production cost of P sajor-caju in 1986 at Bangalore. In this case, raw
material formed the major cost factor in the production followed by labour. In
1986 the cost of production of Agaricus at Bangalore was Rs. 17.41 per kg
wherein more than 50% of the cost was due to capital investments clearly
projecting the capital intensive nature of Agaricus production.