Sei sulla pagina 1di 10

Special Report

Problems associated with diabetes care


in India

Vijay Viswanathan*1 & V Narayan Rao1


Practice Points

„„ Developing countries such as India face a huge burden of diabetes and its complications.

„„ Several issues in delivering diabetes care prevail in these countries, including socioeconomic factors and
problems with medical infrastructure.

„„ Appropriate monitoring and follow-up of diabetic patients is routinely not carried out by general
physicians in India.

„„ Proper access to healthcare needs is lacking in several parts of India, in addition to a lack of requisite
medical facilities.

„„ The financial burden of diabetes both on the patient and the nation’s economy is extremely high, which
might hinder efficient care.

„„ Presence of economic disparities owing to major differences in diabetes care delivery in the government
and private sectors is an additional burden.

„„ Nonadherence to recommended guidelines by some of the government institutions results in


inappropriate diabetes care.

„„ Effective strategies and policies to tackle these problems involved in diabetes care are needed to reduce
the prevailing burden of diabetes.

SUMMARY More than 61 million people with diabetes live in India, a country that is
already facing challenges such as malnutrition, poverty and socioeconomic burden caused
by communicable diseases. The main reasons for the ever-increasing diabetes epidemic
are population growth, urbanization, unhealthy food habits, obesity and lack of physical
activity. Diabetes also causes other complications, including cardiovascular disorders,
diabetic retinopathy, diabetic nephropathy and peripheral neuropathy, which are
responsible for severe morbidity and mortality. Treatment of diabetes and its complications
is a major challenge in India owing to several issues, including sociocultural factors, lack
of appropriate facilities for diabetes care, an inadequate health system, poor monitoring
and follow-up of patients, and problems in implementing effective management and

1
MV Hospital for Diabetes & M Viswanathan Diabetes Research Centre, WHO Collaborating Centre for Research, Education & Training in
Diabetes, No 4, West Mada Church Street, Royapuram, Chennai 600 013, Tamil Nadu, India
*Author for correspondence: Tel.: +91 442 595 4913; Fax: +91 442 595 4919; drvijay@mvdiabetes.com part of

10.2217/DMT.12.62 © 2013 Future Medicine Ltd Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1), 31–40 ISSN 1758-1907 31
Special Report  Viswanathan & Rao

educational strategies. Healthcare professionals and policymakers have to come together


to address these problems in diabetes care and design appropriate preventative and
management strategies.

Diabetes was previously considered to only diabetes, lack of better healthcare facilities dedi­
affect more affluent communities and societies. cated towards diabetes care, a poor economy,
Developing countries, which are already crip­ nonadherence to treatment and diet advice, and
pled with infectious diseases such as tubercu­ sociocultural factors are some of the challenges
losis, AIDS and malaria, were considered to be in diabetes care in India. Tackling these prob­
almost immune from diabetes. Nevertheless, lems requires a concerted and multidisciplinary
the situation has been changing in recent years, approach from various stakeholders and profes­
and chronic noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) sionals involved in diabetes care. Effective pre­
such as diabetes, hypertension and cardio­ ventive and educational programs/campaigns
vascular disorders have become the most serious have to be implemented by govern­ mental
health concerns in both developed and develop­ and/or private organizations to increase the
ing countries [101] . It has been estimated that the awareness about the risk factors of diabetes and
largest increase in the number of people with its complications.
diabetes will occur in the regions comprising the
developing countries [1] . Global burden of diabetes
The main risk factors for the high preva­ The global prevalence of diabetes was reported
lence of diabetes include high familial aggrega­ to the world when the 5th edition of the
tion, obesity, insulin resistance and metabolic International Diabetes Federation (IDF) Atlas
syndrome, lifestyle changes such as increased was released during World Diabetes Day,
consumption of saturated fats, sugars and sed­ 14 November 2011 [1] . The number of people
entary behavior as a result of urbanization, and with diabetes was approximately 366 million
gestational diabetes [2] . Moreover, Indians are in 2011, and by the year 2030 this number has
more prone to developing diabetes and coro­ been predicted to increase to 552 million. It is
nary artery disease, owing to the prevalence of also estimated that approximately 80% of peo­
the so-called ‘Asian-Indian phenotype’, which ple with diabetes live in the low- and middle-
consists of increased insulin resistance, higher income countries, which are designated as the
waist circumference despite lower BMI, lower developing economies in the world. China and
adiponectin and higher high sensitive C-reactive India will bear the major burden of diabetes,
protein levels [3] . with an estimated 129.7 and 101.2 million cases,
Unlike in the West, where older populations respectively, by 2030. The largest age group cur­
are mostly affected, the burden of diabetes in rently affected by diabetes is the 40–59 years age
Asian countries is disproportionately high in group, and by 2030 this is expected to move to
young- to middle-aged adults [4,5] . Furthermore, the 60–79 years age group [1] . In addition, there
diabetes-related complications such as nephrop­ will be a doubling of prevalence of diabetes in
athy are also a huge burden in developing the Middle East, north Africa, south Asia and
countries. The WHO Multinational Study of sub-Saharan Africa. More than 1 million people
Vascular Disease in Diabetes showed that pro­ die due to diabetes each year, two-thirds of these
teinuria was associated with an increased risk are in developing countries [8] . Undiagnosed dia­
of death from chronic kidney disease or cardio­ betes accounts for 85% of those with diabetes in
vascular disease, as well as death of any cause studies from South Africa, 80% in Cameroon,
[6] . Foot-related complications such as chronic 70% in Ghana and more than 80% in Tanzania
nonhealing ulcers and amputations cause severe [102] .
morbidity and mortality [7] .
This ever-increasing epidemic of diabetes Burden in India
and its complications could have long-lasting In India, as in other low- and middle-income
adverse effects on a nation’s health and econ­ countries, diabetes and other NCDs are rela­
omy, especially in a developing country such tively overshadowed by the persistent burden of
as India, which has several socioeconomic and communicable and nutrition-related diseases.
political barriers in the management of diabetes. While these diseases are still present – although
Problems such as lack of proper awareness about slowly decreasing – the rise of NCDs has been

32 Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1) future science group


Problems associated with diabetes care in India  Special Report

rather fast. According to the World Health neuropathy was reported to be 26.1% [20] .
Report 2005 [9] , NCDs already contribute to Results from CUPS show that coronary artery
52% of the total mortality in India and this is disease was observed in 21.4% of diabetic sub­
expected to increase to 69% by the year 2030 jects and peripheral vascular disease in 6.3% of
[10] . Therefore, countries such as India are cur­ diabetic subjects [21,22] .
rently facing an epidemiologic transition with a
‘double burden’ of disease. As per the latest IDF Problems involved in diabetes care
atlas, there were approximately 61.3 million peo­ in India
ple with diabetes in India, which will increase to Management of diabetes and its complications
more than 100 million by 2030 [1] . in India is a huge challenge owing to several
There is a bit of controversy regarding the problems, including a lack of general awareness
prevalence of diabetes in India, since most of about diabetes and its complications among the
the available data are derived from a few scat­ population, and scarcity of healthcare person­
tered studies conducted in different parts of the nel, monitoring equipment and even drugs,
country. Few multicentric studies are available, especially in remote areas. All of these issues
those published include: the Indian Council significantly contribute to delayed presentation
of Medical Research (ICMR) study conducted and missed diagnosis, which further increases
during the 1970s, which reported a prevalence the existing burden of diabetes.
of 12–19% in urban areas and 4–10% in the
rural areas of India [11,12] ; the National Urban Awareness of diabetes in India
„„
Diabetes Survey (NUDS), which reported a Patients’ lack of knowledge about diabetes can
prevalence of more than 12% among urban hinder their ability to manage their disease.
Indians [13] ; the Prevalence of Diabetes in India Several studies have looked at the awareness
Study (PUDIS) that reported a prevalence of levels of diabetes among both patients and
5.9 and 2.7% among urban and rural subjects, healthcare providers. CURES reported that
respectively [14] ; and the WHO-ICMR NCD nearly 25% of the population was unaware of
Risk Factor Surveillance study, which reported diabetes and only 22.2% of the population and
greater than 11% prevalence of diabetes among 41% of known diabetic subjects felt that diabetes
urban Indians [15] . Hence, there has been no could be prevented [23] . The study also reported
national study that has looked at the prevalence that awareness levels increased with education,
of diabetes in India as a whole, covering all the although only 42.6%, comprising mainly post­
states of the country or even in any single state graduates, medical professionals and lawyers,
with comprehensive urban and rural representa­ knew that diabetes could be preventable. The
tion. Nevertheless, the available data certainly knowledge of risk factors of diabetes was even
provide at least some relevant information on lower, with only 11.9% of study subjects report­
the prevalence of diabetes in India. For exam­ ing obesity and physical inactivity as the risk fac­
ple, a recent multicentric study reported the tors; 23% knew that diabetes could lead to foot
overall prevalence of diabetes to be 10.4% in problems; and only 5.8% knew it could cause
Tamil Nadu, 8.4% in Maharashtra, 5.3% in heart attack [23] . Another population-based
Jharkhand and 13.6% in Chandigarh, with a study reported that only 41% of adult Indians
significantly high prevalence rate in the urban aged over 20 years were aware of the risk of dia­
settings compared with the rural areas in these betes and almost all diabetic patients (92.3%)
states [16] . Another study in the Ernakulam sought the help of a general practitioner for treat­
district of Kerala reported 20% prevalence [17] . ment instead of a diabetic specialist [24] . Hence,
Regarding the prevalence of diabetic complica­ there is a pressing need to improve the awareness
tions, there are several clinic-based and a few of diabetes among the general population as well
population-based studies. Chennai Urban Rural as diabetic patients in India. This is important as
Epidemiology Study (CURES) and Chennai better patient self-management ability is strongly
Urban Population Study (CUPS) provide pop­ related to improved diabetes control.
ulation-based data from India on virtually all
complications of diabetes. CURES reported an Diagnosis & access to treatment for
„„
overall prevalence of 17.6% diabetic retino­pathy diabetes
[18] , 2.2% overt nephropathy and 26.9% micro­ One of the foremost aspects of diabetes care and
albuminuria [19] . The prevalence of peripheral management is timely diagnosis and adequate

future science group www.futuremedicine.com 33


Special Report  Viswanathan & Rao

treatment, in the absence of which complica­ INR1837.3 billion ($38.0 billion) in the year
tions and morbidity due to diabetes can increase 2010 [31] . Presence of complications further
drastically. In India, Type 2 diabetes remains increases the cost of treatment; for example, a
un­detected for many years and the diagnosis recent study reported that the cost of diabetes
is often made from associated complications care for a patient with foot ulcers was more than
or incidentally through an abnormal blood or four times higher (INR19,020; US$409) than
urine glucose test. This results in more than half that for a patient without foot ulcers (INR 4493;
of the diabetes population being undetected [25] . US$97) [32] .
Diab-Care Asia, a multicountry study in Asia, The patient bears the excessive cost and the
reported that diagnosis of diabetes among economic loss due to lost workdays or lost eco­
Indian subjects was determined at a delayed nomic opportunity. In general, the absence of a
stage, with the mean age being 43.6 years, and significant or credible social security system in
that 50% had poor diabetes control, as measured India requires the patient to depend on family
by HbA1c, and 54% had late severe complica­ support. This means that if the breadwinner of
tions [26] . In another study, it was observed that the family suffers a chronic illness, it would have
approximately 70% of diabetic patients were a significant effect on the whole family. It may
diagnosed by general practitioners and diag­ force other nonworking members to start work,
nostic tests for complications were prescribed often prematurely at lower wages, cut short chil­
for only a few patients – 17.6% for ophthalmic dren’s education with long-term financial conse­
examination, 5.6% for kidney function tests and quence for them and the family [33] . In the study
4.2% for lipid tests [27] . by Tharkar et al., it was observed that more than
Another important aspect is the availability of 60% of the low-income group had to borrow
and access to diabetes drugs. An estimate based or mortgage property for their diabetes treat­
on sales of antidiabetic pharmaceutical agents ment costs and approximately 70–80% of the
showed that, on average, only 10–12% of people high income group spent most of their personal
with diabetes received modern pharma­­­­cological savings on treatment [31] . Hence, it can be said
treatment in India [28] . The availability of glib­ that the financial burden borne by people with
enclamide in public health facilities varied from diabetes and their families depends on their eco­
100 to 3.8% in the states of Karnataka and nomic status and the social insurance policies of
West Bengal, respectively [29] . Although insulin the country.
therapy is accepted as one of the most effective In the poorest countries, people with diabetes
and dependable treatment option, barriers to its and their families bear almost the whole cost
use were identified in the IMPROVE Control of medical care. In India, a situation prevails
India study [30] . In most patients, insulin was in which individuals with limited financial
delayed until it was absolutely necessary or resources continue to spend a major proportion
when the HbA1c levels had deteriorated further of their income on diabetes management [34] .
to approximately 9%. Moreover, this study also This situation is a major financial burden to
observed several other problems in the manage­ people in India, owing to poor economic condi­
ment of diabetes, such as lack of standardization tions, unlike in developed nations. Moreover,
in laboratory techniques and irregular monitor­ the presence of associated complications further
ing of diabetes status [30] . Therefore, problems increases their financial burden. A study from
such as the uncertainty of availability of diabetic south India reported the increasing expenditure
medicines and lack of pricing control over the by patients with diabetic complications in both
private sector result in poor compliance with rural and urban settings (Figure 2) [34] . The total
medication. annual cost to treat diabetic patients in India
(including direct and indirect expenses) was esti­
Financial constraints
„„ mated to be $420 per capita. If that per capita
Diabetes care, including treatment of its asso­ expenditure were to remain constant, the total
ciated complications, often requires expensive estimated cost of treating the disease would
healthcare resources such as hospitalization reach $30 billion by 2025 [103] .
charges, laboratory tests and drugs (Figure 1) . A The concept of medical reimbursement in the
study from India showed that the total annual form of insurance policies is still not put into its
cost of diabetes care varied from 1230 bil­ full use by the majority of developing nations.
lion Indian Rupees (INR; $25.5 billion) to In an analysis using data from 35 low- and

34 Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1) future science group


Problems associated with diabetes care in India  Special Report

middle-income countries, such as Kenya,


Vietnam, Bangladesh, Mali, Ethiopia, Pakistan Disposables (3%)
and India, included in the World Health Survey
[104] , Smith-Spangler et al. reported that health
insurance had a meager role in reducing the Other drugs (11%)
medical expenses of diabetic individuals [35] .
Studies in India reported that only 6.4% of
Hospitalization (35%)
the urban low-income group received medical
reimbursement, whereas this was 21.3% in the Antidiabetic drugs (17%)
high-income group [34] . This implies that even in
urban settings, the concepts of health insurance
and mediclaim policies seem better understood
and are only utilized by the high-income group.
Monitoring and
Health resources in India and other devel­ laboratory tests (22%) Doctor visit (12%)
oping countries are very limited with only 5%
of gross domestic product (GDP), being spent
on healthcare [105] . The majority of healthcare
expenditure was private (4% of GDP) with
only 0.9% of GDP spent on public healthcare.
Therefore, careful planning based on health
economic assessments is necessary in order to
maximize the use of funds for the treatment and
Figure 1. Distribution of direct costs in diabetes care.
prevention of diabetes [33] .
Data taken from [33].
Social barriers
„„
Apart from financial constraints, there are some diseases such as tuberculosis and AIDS in India.
sociocultural barriers that can be a stumbling Therefore, the allocation of financial resources
block for the proper management of diabetes. towards diabetes or cardiovascular diseases is
In some developing countries, youngsters who much less when compared with those allocated
have been newly diagnosed with diabetes some­ to infectious diseases [101] .
times do not reveal their condition and most In India, there is a wide disparity in the
probably do not take insulin or medications due healthcare facilities available in rural and urban
to the social stigma attached to the condition areas due to the nonuniformity of the health­
when finding spouses, in addition to the exces­ care system. Healthcare delivery is shared by
sive cost spent and the chance of being excluded the institutions run by the state (where medical
from certain jobs or turned down for insurance care is free or offered at subsidized rates), pri­
or mortgage products [101] . Diabetes care in such vate institutions (where patients have to pay for
cases becomes difficult and physicians may face services) and a large number of medical practi­
a challenge in advising these patients appropri­ tioners. People do not have any restrictions in
ately. Moreover, although the majority of dia­ utilizing any of the available medical facilities
betic cases in India are diagnosed and managed and they can access any level of care depend­
by general practitioners, including cardiologists, ing on their economic feasibility, proximity and
neurologists and nephrologists, there is a lack knowledge about the facility. Individuals who
of regular monitoring and patient education for can afford it are able to attend the private centers
these patients. This situation implies that general for their diabetes care [36] . Nevertheless, there
physicians need to understand and update their is a considerable variation in the quality and
knowledge on diabetes education and prevention cost of care from place to place, depending on
aspects, and monitoring of patients to prevent the available resources, the physician’s skill and
complications. interest in diabetes, and the patients’ capability
to spend. The hospital services are provided by
„„Economic disparities in the healthcare government hospitals, including district hospi­
system tals and medical college hospitals. Treatment
NCDs such as diabetes have not received in government hospitals is provided free or at
enough medical attention as communicable a nominal charge depending on the person’s

future science group www.futuremedicine.com 35


Special Report  Viswanathan & Rao

and essential drugs). Some nongovernmental


30,000
organizations offer free healthcare facilities for
Urban the low economic classes, but again these are less
Rural utilized due to lack of awareness, poor education
25,000
and occupational problems.
Hence, long-term prognosis of diabetes is
Expenditure incurred (INR)

20,000
affected due to lack of adequate facilities (in
the government sector) and capacity to pay
(in the private sector). When uniformly good
15,000 quality care is accessible to all, the disease out­
come is at least not predetermined by individu­
als’ socio­economic standing. The prevailing
10,000 poverty, ignorance, illiteracy and poor health
consciousness further adds to the problem [33] .

5000 Adherence to recommended guidelines


„„
Suboptimal knowledge of or improper adher­
ence to the recommended guidelines is an issue
0 present in India, which leads to delay in diagno­
0 1 2 sis and improper management of blood glucose
Complications (n)
levels, resulting in an increase in other compli­
cations. In the IMPROVE Control India study,
Figure 2. Expenditure incurred by urban and rural subjects in relation to the it was observed that although most physicians
number of complications. agreed that HbA1c testing is crucial, it was only
INR: Indian Rupees. prescribed in 79% of the patients, whereas fast­
Reproduced with permission from [34]. ing and postprandial glucose tests were admin­
istered for 97 and 96% of patients, respectively.
income; however, due to scant and limited Many physicians felt that standardization of gly­
resources and poor infrastructure, government cated hemoglobin (HbA1c) in laboratories is not
care focuses mainly on acute pressing illnesses, reliable and, therefore, preferred the fasting and
rather than diabetes. Therefore, on the whole, postprandial glucose measurements [30] . Another
the quality of diabetes care is low. recent study by Tharkar et al. observed that most
The scenario in the private sector is quite of the recommended clinical guidelines for dia­
different, where treatment is based mainly on betes care, such as performing HbA1c tests,
monetary resources. Those seeking private med­ advising about self-monitoring of glucose and
ical care have to pay for everything themselves diabetes education were not being adhered to
as there is limited or no reimbursements, and in most of the government healthcare centers
here too, the infrastructure for chronic care is in India [37] . Even among the private institu­
limited. In the past few decades, several high- tions, only 31.7% of specialty clinics prescribed
tech corporate medical facilities have arisen HbA1c tests. Professional advice and counseling
in India, which aim to provide sophisticated regarding healthy lifestyle, diet modification and
healthcare, although only affluent people can physical activity methods was given only at spe­
have access to it. This increases the expectations cialized diabetes centers, while such advice was
of the poorer sections of society, who anticipate almost absent in the government hospitals [37] .
the same services from government institutions Nonadherence to recommended guidelines may
[36] . Although private healthcare facilities are lead to poor glycemic control, which can directly
sought after, it is likely that many patients may raise the risk of complications and increase the
cross over to public healthcare facilities due to cost burden.
financial burdens.
In the rural areas, health facilities that are Need to strengthen the existing
„„
based on primary health centers and subcent­ healthcare infrastructure
ers need more attention, because these are not Despite the steep growth in the Indian econ­
well appreciated due to inadequacy of facilities omy, there has been a lag in the growth of
(lack of staff, equipment, laboratory facilities India’s healthcare infrastructure, which is quite

36 Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1) future science group


Problems associated with diabetes care in India  Special Report

inadequate to meet today’s healthcare demands. among the general population in Chennai city
While India has several centers of excellence in of Tamil Nadu, India [38] . Diabetes education
healthcare delivery, these facilities are limited was imparted to the population through public
in their ability to drive healthcare standards education, media campaigns, general practitioner
because of the poor condition of the infrastruc­ training and community-based ‘real life’ preven­
ture in the vast majority of the country. Of the tion programs. One of the major outcomes of the
15,393 hospitals in India in 2002, roughly two- PACE project was that there was approximately
thirds were public. After years of under-funding, a 6% increase in the number of people reporting
most public health facilities provide only basic that they knew about diabetes. There were also
care. With a few exceptions, public health facili­ significant increases in the awareness levels of
ties are inefficient, inadequately managed and risk factors, such as family history of diabetes,
staffed, and have poorly maintained medical obesity, stress and hypertension, among the pop­
equipment. The number of public health facili­ ulation of Chennai. Increases in the knowledge
ties is also inadequate. For example, India needs levels of diabetic complications such as nephrop­
74,150 community health centers per million athy, retino­pathy and foot problems were also
people, but has less than half that number. In observed in this study. In addition, nearly 46%
addition, at least 11 Indian states do not have of the people realized that diabetes could be
laboratories for testing drugs, and more than prevented after attending the PACE program [38] .
half of existing laboratories are not properly Another recent study was carried out to assess
equipped or staffed. The principal responsibil­ whether a short messaging service through
ity for public health funding lies with the state mobile phones could motivate patients to adhere
governments, which provide approximately 80% to treatment prescriptions, which included
of public funding. The central government con­ enhanced physical activity, diet modifications
tributes another 15%, mostly through national and the use of drugs [39] . It was observed that
health programs [103] . Hence, there is an urgent the majority of patients with access to a mobile
need to improve the existing medical infrastruc­ phone and knowledge of the English language
ture in order to strengthen the healthcare needs preferred to receive messages on all aspects of
of the people. diabetes care. The messages consisted of instruc­
tions on diet, physical activity, reminders for
Prevention of diabetes following drug prescriptions and healthy liv­
One of the fundamental aspects in the preven­ ing habits. Patients who received the messages
tion of diabetes and its complications is impart­ showed significant reductions in their glyce­
ing appropriate education to the community and mic levels compared with the control group of
at-risk population. An effective educational pro­ patients who received the same diabetes care
gram insisting on physical activity, consuming a with the exception of the message service [39] .
healthy diet, avoiding alcohol and smoking, and Studies on awareness and education for dia­
leading a stress-free life could be very effective in betic foot complications have shown promising
reducing the burden of diabetes. Every diabetic results in preventing and reducing the burden
clinic and hospital must ensure that a patient of foot ulceration and amputations. A research
receives the proper diabetes education at every study from India had shown the beneficial
visit. Implementation of all these strategies may effects of foot care education, which involved
not be practical in a country such as India, which simple foot care management advice to patients,
is slowly emerging out of poverty and still strug­ such as daily examination of feet, how to per­
gling with problems such as unemployment. In form a pedicure and usage of proper/therapeu­
this situation, healthcare organizations have a tic footwear. Foot care education was effective
significant role in promoting diabetes education in healing foot ulcers in more than 80% of the
and management through community-based patients. A higher number of patients (26%)
campaigns at the community level. who did not adhere to foot care advice devel­
oped newer foot problems and required surgical
Diabetes education programs
„„ procedures, compared with those who followed
The Prevention, Awareness, Counselling and the advice (14%) [40] . Moreover, those who regu­
Evaluation (PACE) diabetes project was a suc­ larly wore the prescribed therapeutic footwear
cessful venture undertaken to increase awareness showed significant reductions in reoccurrence of
about diabetes, its risk factors and complications foot ulcers [41] . Approximately 60% of patients’

future science group www.futuremedicine.com 37


Special Report  Viswanathan & Rao

ulcers healed and they remained ulcer-free over poses several challenges that have to be critically
a 34‑month period of observation. Recurrence of met with for the proper management and care
healed ulcers occurred in only a sixth of patients of diabetes. Problems such as lack of appropri­
and amputation was required in 1% of subjects ate infrastructure and health personnel, poor
[41] . These studies demonstrate that it is possible updating of knowledge about diabetes among
to reduce the burden of foot problems by educat­ general practitioners, poor access to diabetes
ing patients on foot care and using appropriate drugs and healthcare facilities, economic dis­
footwear. parities in the healthcare system, and the socio­
Nevertheless, large-scale programs have to economic burden on the patient are the main
be effectively implemented to cover the whole obstacles in diabetes care.
nation, for which both the public and private Effective management of people with diabetes
sectors need to work together. The National offers only part of the solution for the problem
Rural Health Mission has launched a new pilot of diabetes, which means that other aspects of
National Programme for Prevention and Control care important from the perspective of diabetes
of Diabetes, Cardiovascular Disease and Stroke, control may be difficult to provide within the
which could offer opportunities for improving health system itself. Aspects related to diet and
care for diabetes and other NCDs through ser­ the amount of physical activity undertaken will
vice provision at the primary and secondary lev­ be influenced by an interplay of various sectoral
els of care [42] . Guidelines for the management policies and forces. In India, several rural areas
of diabetes in the Indian context have also been are still facing the problem of undernutrition
developed through a joint consultation by the and are unable to access better food products.
ICMR and WHO [43] . Dietary restriction advice for diabetic patients in
Diabetes education, awareness and improving such areas becomes difficult, which means that
motivation for self-care improves care, reduces national or state policies for food procurement,
complications and may reduce the overall eco­ pricing and marketing have to be implemented
nomic costs of diabetes. Lifestyle modifica­ for a sustained availability of inexpensive and
tions such as weight control, increased physical accessible dietary substitutes in the market.
exercise and smoking cessation are potentially Population-based strategies for health promo­
beneficial in preventing diabetes mellitus [44] . tion and risk reduction, along with surveillance
Prevention of diabetes must essentially aim at of trends in disease and risk factors, are equally
targeting two main groups of population: the important components in any public health
high-risk group that includes individuals with approach for diabetes control.
a family history of diabetes who carry a genetic The health system in India, as in other coun­
susceptibility, individuals with impaired glu­ tries, is traditionally designed to focus on acute
cose tolerance, aging individuals, sedentary illnesses and maternal and child health prob­
individuals and the obese; and the general lems. This means that there is still a lack of
population, for whom strategies to lower the appropriate infrastructure and healthcare per­
mean risk level of diabetes can be implemented sonnel to meet the raising demands of NCDs,
by advising them to engage in regular aerobic which require the availability of trained cli­
physical activity, improve their diet and reduce nicians, investigational facilities and drugs.
obesity. Several studies of community-based Recently, owing to several community-based
NCD prevention projects have attempted to research studies, the importance of primary pre­
prevent the onset of diabetes through lifestyle vention through promotion of healthy lifestyles
modifications, a reduction in obesity or through and risk reduction has been recognized as the
pharmaco­logical means. Such projects have also most cost-effective intervention in resource-poor
clearly demonstrated a significant reduction of settings. Therefore, the health system in India
risk factors by following a healthy lifestyle [106] has to strengthen the standard of diabetes care
and maintaining normal body weight (BMI: at all levels, along with nationally accepted man­
18.5–24.9 kg/m2) [2] , which could in turn bring agement protocols and regulatory framework,
a huge benefit to the community. which can help in tackling this challenge.
In conclusion, strong and effective preven­
Conclusion & future perspective tive measures addressing all these problems
The overwhelmingly increasing number of have to be framed by the government, other
people with diabetes in a country such as India stakeholders and policy makers, and ensure that

38 Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1) future science group


Problems associated with diabetes care in India  Special Report

they are implemented and followed up success­ Financial & competing interests disclosure
fully, in order to tackle the problems involved The authors have no relevant affiliations or financial
in diabetes care in India. In addition, health­ involvement with any organization or entity with a finan-
care professionals have a big role to play in this cial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter
regard, as they must always maintain up-to- or materials discussed in the manuscript. This includes
date knowledge required for the diagnosis and employment, consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or
treatment of diabetes, and they should stress options, expert testimony, grants or patents received or
the need for effective education on all aspects pending, or royalties.
of diabetes care for the patients as well as the No writing assistance was utilized in the production of
general population. this manuscript.

13 Ramachandran A, Snehalatha C, Kapur A Epidemiology Study (CURES-45). Diabetes


References
Papers of special note have been highlighted as: et al. High prevalence of diabetes and Care 30, 2019–2024 (2007).
impaired glucose tolerance in India: National Study carried out to determine the
n
of interest n n

Urban Diabetes Survey. Diabetologia 44(9),


of considerable interest
n n prevalence of diabetic nephropathy among
1094–1101 (2001).
1 International Diabetes Federation. urban Asian-Indian Type 2 diabetic subjects.
14 Sadikot SM, Nigam A, Das S et al. Study subjects were selected from Chennai
International Diabetes Federation Atlas
The burden of diabetes and impaired glucose Urban Rural Epidemiology Study (CURES).
(5th Edition). International Diabetes
tolerance in India using the WHO 1999
Federation, Brussels, Belgium (2011). 20 Pradeepa R, Rema M, Vignesh J, Deepa M,
criteria: Prevalence of Diabetes in India
2 Yadav R, Tiwari P, Dhanaraj E. Risk factors Deepa R, Mohan V. Prevalence and risk
Study (PODIS). Diabetes Res. Clin. Pract. 66,
and complications of Type 2 diabetes in factors for diabetic neuropathy in an urban
301–307 (2004).
Asians. CRIPS 9, 8–12 (2008). south Indian population: the Chennai Urban
15 Mohan V, Mathur P, Deepa R et al. Rural Epidemiology Study (CURES-55).
3 Mohan V, Sandeep S, Deepa R. Epidemiology Urban rural differences in prevalence of Diabet. Med. 25, 407–412 (2008).
of Type 2 diabetes: Indian scenario. Indian self‑reported diabetes in India – the
J. Med. Res. 125, 217–230 (2007). WHO‑ICMR Indian NCD risk factor
n n
Conducted to determine the prevalence of,
4 Chan JC, Malik V, Jia W et al. Diabetes in surveillance. Diabetes Res. Clin. Pract. 80, and risk factors for, diabetic neuropathy in
Asia: epidemiology, risk factors, and 159–168 (2008). south Indian Type 2 diabetic subjects.
pathophysiology. JAMA 301, 2129–2140 Subjects were recruited from CURES.
16 Anjana RM, Pradeepa R, Deepa M et al.
(2009). Prevalence of diabetes and prediabetes 21 Mohan V, Deepa R, Shanthirani CS,
5 Ramachandran A, Wan Ma RC, (impaired fasting glucose and/or impaired Premalatha G. Prevalence of coronary artery
Snehalatha C. Diabetes in Asia. Lancet 375, glucose tolerance) in urban and rural India: disease and its relationship to lipids in a
408–418 (2010). Phase I results of the Indian Council of selected population in South India. J. Am.
Medical Research–India Diabetes Coll. Cardiol. 38, 682–687 (2001).
6 Hossain P, Kawar B, El Nahas M. Obesity and
diabetes in the developing world: a growing (ICMR–INDIAB) study. Diabetologia 22 Premalatha G, Shanthirani CS, Deepa R,
challenge. N. Engl. J. Med. 356, 213–215 54(12), 3022–3027 (2011). Markovitz J, Mohan V. Prevalence and risk
(2007). n n
Reports the results of the first phase of a factors of peripheral vascular disease in a
national study to determine the prevalence selected south Indian population – the
7 Vijay V, Satyavani K. Pattern and causes of
of diabetes and prediabetes in three states Chennai Urban Population Study (CUPS).
amputation in diabetic patients – a
Diabetes Care 23, 1295–1300 (2000).
multicentric study from India. J. Assoc. and one union territory in India, using a
Physicians India 59, 148–151 (2011). stratified multistage sampling design. The n n
Chennai Urban Population Study (CUPS) is
prevalence rates were assessed by an epidemiological study involving two
8 Narayan KMV, Zhang P, Williams D et al.
How should developing countries manage measurement of fasting and 2‑h residential areas in Chennai in south India.
diabetes? CMAJ 175(7), 733 (2006). post-glucose load capillary blood glucose. The purpose of this study was to determine
17 Diamond J. Diabetes in India. Nature 469,
the prevalence and risk factors of peripheral
9 World Health Report 2005. WHO, Geneva,
478–479 (2011). vascular disease among south Indians.
Switzerland (2005).
18 Rema M, Premkumar S, Anitha B, Deepa R, 23 Deepa M, Deepa R, Shanthirani CS et al.
10 Roglic G, Unwin N, Bennett PH et al.
Pradeepa R, Mohan V. Prevalence of diabetic Awareness and knowledge of diabetes in
The burden of mortality attributable to
retinopathy in urban India: the Chennai Chennai – the Chennai Urban Rural
diabetes: realistic estimates for the year 2000.
Urban Rural Epidemiology Study (CURES) Epidemiology Study [CURES-9]. J. Assoc.
Diabetes Care 28, 2130–2135 (2005).
Eye Study-1. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 46, Physicians India 53, 283–287 (2005).
11 Ahuja MMS, Sivaji L, Garg VK, Mitroo P.
2328–2333 (2005). 24 Murugesan N, Snehalatha C, Shobhana R,
Prevalence of diabetes in northern India (Delhi
19 Ranjit UI, Rema M, Pradeepa R et al. Roglic G, Ramachandran A. Awareness,
area). Horm. Metab. Res. 4(5), 321–324 (1974).
Prevalence and risk factors of diabetic about diabetes and its complications in the
12 Gupta OP, Joshi MH, Dave SK. Prevalence of general and diabetic population in a city in
nephropathy in an Urban South Indian
diabetes in India. Adv. Metabolic Disord. 9, southern India. Diabetes Res. Clin. Pract. 77,
population: the Chennai Urban Rural
147–165 (1978). 433–437 (2007).

future science group www.futuremedicine.com 39


Special Report  Viswanathan & Rao

25 International Diabetes Federation. 33 Kapur A. Economic analysis of diabetes care. 41 Vijay V, Sivagami M, Saraswathy G et al.
International Diabetes Federation Atlas Indian J. Med. Res. 125, 473–482 (2007). Effectiveness of different types of footwear
(4th Edition). International Diabetes n
Highlights several important issues such as insoles for the diabetic neuropathic foot.
Federation, Brussels, Belgium (2010). A follow-up study. Diabetes Care 27, 474–477
cost of diabetes care in India, factors
(2004).
26 Raheja BS, Kapur A, Bhoraskar A et al. influencing costs of care, sources of funding,
Diabcare Asia – India Study: diabetes care in and complications and quality of care. 42 National Rural Health Mission. Framework
India – current status. J. Assoc. Physicians India for Implementation. Ministry of Health and
34 Ramachandran A, Shobhana R, Snehalatha C
49, 717–722 (2001). Family Welfare. Government of India, New
et al. Increasing expenditure on health care
Delhi, India (2005).
27 Bjork S, Kapur A, King H, Nair J, incurred by diabetic subjects in a developing
Ramachandran A. Global policy: aspects of country. Diabetes Care 30, 252–256 (2007). 43 Guidelines for Management of Type 2 Diabetes.
diabetes in India. Health Policy 66, 61–72 Indian Council of Medical Research, New
35 Smith-Spangler CM, Bhattacharya J,
(2003). Delhi, India (2005).
Goldhaber‑Fiebert JD. Diabetes, its
28 Kapur A, Shishoo S, Ahuja MMS, Sen V, treatment, and catastrophic medical spending 44 Leung GM, Lam KS. Diabetic complications
Mankame D. Diabetes Care in India: in 35 developing countries. Diabetes Care 35, and their implications on health care in Asia.
Patient’s Perceptions Attitudes and Practices 319–326 (2012). Hong Kong Med. J. 6, 61–68 (2000).
(DIPPAP-1 Study). Int. J. Diab. Dev. Websites
„„
36 Ramachandran A. Socio-economic burden of
Countries 17, 2–12 (1997).
diabetes in India. J. Assoc. Physicians India 55, 101 The Economist Intelligence Unit Report.
29 Kotwani A, Ewen M, Dey D et al. Prices and 9–12 (2007). The silent epidemic: an economic study of
availability of common medicines at six sites diabetes in developed and developing
37 Tharkar S, Devarajan A, Barman H,
in India using a standard methodology. Indian countries (2007).
Mahesh U, Viswanathan V. How far has
J. Med. Res. 125, 645–654 (2007). http://viewswire.eiu.com/report_dl.
translation of research been implemented into
30 Joshi SR, Das AK, Vijay VJ, Mohan V. clinical practice in India? Are the asp?mode=fi&fi=1882281973.PDF&rf=0
Challenges in diabetes care in India: sheer recommended guidelines adhered to? Int. 102 World Diabetes Foundation. Diabetes facts.
numbers, lack of awareness and inadequate J. Diabetes Mellitus doi.org/10.1016/j. www.worlddiabetesfoundation.org/
control. J. Assoc. Physicians India 56, 443–450 ijdm.2011.01.002 (2011) (Epub ahead of print). composite-35.htm
(2008). (Accessed 30 March 2012)
38 Somannavar S, Lanthorn H, Deepa M,
31 Tharkar S, Devarajan A, Kumpatla S, Pradeepa R, Rema M, Mohan V. Increased 103 PriceWaterhouseCoopers. Healthcare in
Viswanathan V. The socioeconomics of awareness about diabetes and its India. Emerging market report (2007).
diabetes from a developing country: complications in a whole city: effectiveness of www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/healthcare/pdf/
a population based cost of illness study. the “Prevention, awareness, counseling and emerging-market-report-hc-in-india.pdf
Diabetes Res. Clin. Pract. 89(3), 334–340 evaluation” [PACE] Diabetes Project (Accessed 9 April 2012)
(2010). [PACE-6]. J. Assoc. Physicians India
104 WHO. World Health Survey: current status
Population-based study conducted to assess 56, 497–502 (2008).
n

of the World Health Survey (2011).


the annual healthcare expenditure for a 39 Shetty AS, Chamukuttan S, Nanditha A, www.who.int/healthinfo/survey/en/index.
patient with diabetes. Retrospective data for Raj RK, Ramachandran A. Reinforcement of html. (Accessed 2 April 2012)
the last 12 months on direct costs through adherence to prescription recommendations
105 Peters DH, Yazbeck SA, Sharma RR, Ramana
records, indirect cost through human capital in Asian Indian diabetic patients using Short
GNV, Pritchett LH, Wagstaff A. A better
approach and intangible cost by contingent Message Service (SMS) – a pilot study.
health systems for India’s poor: findings
valuation method were collected and J. Assoc. Physicians India 59, 711–714 (2011).
analysis and options (2002).
analyzed. 40 Vijay V, Sivagami M, Seena R, Snehalatha C, www.worldbank.org/publications/
32 Satyavani K, Hemalatha K, Shabana T, Ramachandran A. Amputation Prevention pdfs/15029overview.pdf
Vijay V. The costs of treating long term Initiative in South India. Positive impact of (Accessed 2 April 2012)
diabetic complications in a developing foot care education. Diabetes Care 28,
106 WHO SEARO. Integrated community-based
country: a study from India. J. Assoc. 1019–1021 (2005).
prevention of major NCD in SEAR. Report
Physicians India (2012) (In Press). n
Reported the beneficial effects of intensive of an informal consultation (2003).
n
Highlights the direct cost estimates and treatment and education strategies in www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/Non_
economic burden of treating severe long-term preventing diabetic foot problems in diabetic Communicable_Diseases_NCD-59.pdf
diabetic complications in Indian patients. patients with high-risk diabetic foot disease. (Accessed 11 April 2012)

40 Diabetes Manage. (2013) 3(1) future science group

Potrebbero piacerti anche