KMEA Module 1 • Introduction, Types of estimates, detailed estimate, revised estimate, supplementary estimate, maintenance estimate, approximate estimate. • Explanation of terms- Contingencies, work charged establishments, provisional sum, lump sum item. • Introduction to plinth area method, cubic rate method, unit rate method and bay method.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 2 Tri Angle Design Studio Introduction • One of the first questions asked by a client who wants a building or structure erected is ‘How much will it cost?’ • If the client is wise, the next question will be ‘How accurate is this figure?’ • The purpose of a pre-tender estimate is to provide an indication of the probable costs of construction. • This will be an important factor to consider in the client’s overall strategy of the decision to build. • The estimate will also provide the basis for his budgeting and control of the construction costs. • During the project’s development and construction phases this estimate may be reviewed and revised many times. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 3 Tri Angle Design Studio Introduction • Perhaps the single most important criterion of the estimate is its accuracy. • An early price estimate which is too high may discourage the client from proceeding further with the scheme, and so the potential commission is lost. • Alternatively, if the estimate is too low, it may result in an abortive design, dissatisfaction on the part of the client or even litigation. • It should be accepted, however, that early price estimates are an approximation and will therefore include some amount of uncertainty.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 4 Tri Angle Design Studio Introduction • Since estimating the costs of construction is a probabilistic activity, preference should be given to offering a range of estimated sums rather than a single amount. • Alternatively, if a single sum is desirable then confidence limits should also be given to provide an indication of its reliability
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 5 Tri Angle Design Studio Definition of Estimate • In construction activity, the two fundamental things involved are Quantity and Quality aspect. • Quantity aspects is governed by the study and analysis of drawings which are designed in respect to the design of the project. • Quality aspect is governed through specifications for materials and workmanship. Hence it decides the quantum of work involved in the construction and it helps in finding out the quantities of various material required as well as the labour required. • These two aspects governs the estimate of work.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 6 Tri Angle Design Studio Definition of Estimate • Estimate is a tool for planning and controlling the construction activity of any project with respect to the quality, time and finance. • An estimate is a forecast of its probable cost.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 7 Tri Angle Design Studio Purpose of Estimate • To ascertain the amount of money required by the owner to complete the proposed work. • For public construction works, estimates are required in order to obtain administrative approval, allotment of funds and technical sanction. • To ascertain quantities of materials required in order program their timely procurement. • To calculate the number of different categories of workers that are to be employed to complete the work within the scheduled time of completion. • To assess the requirements of tools, plants and equipment required to complete the work according to the program. • To invite tenders and prepare bills for payment. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 8 Tri Angle Design Studio Uses of an Estimate For proposed project To ascertain the probable time for contract To control expenditure during execution To estimate requirements of any controlled materials like cement and steel To frame tender document and arrange for the contract To manage the finance of the project To invite tenders and prepare bills for payment. To obtain administrative approval and technical sanction for the project. To prepare bills for interim and final payments
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 9 Tri Angle Design Studio Uses of an Estimate For proposed project To prepare construction schedules and program. To justify the investment To select most remunerative or economical alternative To work out material and labour requirements etc
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 10 Tri Angle Design Studio Uses of an Estimate For Existing structures To advice the client for the fixation of standard rent To furnish justification for claim in the arbitration proceedings To prepare tax schedules To value the property for sale, government taxes, purchase, mortgage, fire or other insurance etc.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 11 Tri Angle Design Studio TYPES OF ESTIMATE Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 12 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Preliminary or approximate or rough estimate Quantity estimate or quantity survey Detailed estimate Revised estimate Supplementary estimate Annual maintenance or repair estimate
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 13 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Preliminary or approximate or rough estimate • Approximate estimate is to find out an approximate cost in a short time and thus enables the authority concerned to consider the financial aspect of the scheme. • It is framed after knowing the rate of similar works and from practical knowledge in various ways for various types of works. • Preliminary Estimate is prepared by various ways for different structures as : Buildings Per Unit Basis – Per student for schools and hostels, per class room for schools, per bed for hospitals, per seat for cinema and theatre halls, per tenement for residential buildings. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 14 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Preliminary or approximate or rough estimate Plinth area basis Cubic content basis Appx. Quantity method Roads and Highways – Per km basis depending upon nature of road, width and thickness of metalling. Irrigation Channels Per km basis Per hectare basis (Area of land commanded)
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 15 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Preliminary or approximate or rough estimate Bridges and Culverts Per running meter of span depending upon type of structure, type and depth of foundation. Sewerage and Water Supply Project Per head of population served Per hectare basis (Area covered) Over Head water Tank Per liter or per gallon of tank depending upon type of structure and height of tank.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 16 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Quantity estimate or Quantity survey • A complete estimate or list of quantities for all items of work required to complete the concerned project. • In this type of estimate only bills of quantities are prepared for all necessary items and when they are priced, gives the complete estimate of the project.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 17 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate • Includes the detailed particulars, rates and costs of all the items involved for satisfactory completion of a project. • The best and most accurate estimate • They are mainly prepared for i. Execution process and ii. Obtaining technical sanction
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 18 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate • The preparation of detailed estimate consists of working out quantities of various items of work and then determine the cost each item. • This prepared in two stages: Quantity Estimate and Rate Analysis Abstract of Estimated cost
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 19 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate - Quantity Estimate • The complete work is divided into various items of work, such as Earthwork Excavation RCC Work Block Work Plastering etc., • The details of measurements are taken from drawings and entered in respective columns of prescribed pro forma. • The quantities are calculated by multiplying the values that are in numbers columns to Depth columns
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 20 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate - Quantity Estimate
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 21 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate - Abstract of estimated cost
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 22 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Detailed estimate • It comprises of a. Report b. Specifications c. Detailed drawings showing plans, different sections, key or index plan etc. d. Design data and calculations e. Basis of rates adopted in the estimate.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 23 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Revised estimate • A detailed estimate for the revised quantities • It is accompanied with a comparative statement abstract from showing the probable variations for the quantity, rate and amount of each item of work of the project as compared with the original estimate side by side stating the reasons of variations.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 24 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Supplementary estimate • Some times some changes or additional works due to material deviation of a structural nature from the originally approved design may be thought necessary when the work is in progress. • For all such items, a detailed estimate is prepared, which is known as a supplementary estimate.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 25 Tri Angle Design Studio Types of Estimate Annual maintenance or repair estimate • After completion of a work it is necessary to maintain the proper functioning. • An estimate is prepared for the items which require renewal, replacement, repairs etc. in the form of a detailed estimate.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 26 Tri Angle Design Studio TERMINOLOGY IN ESTIMATE
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 27 Tri Angle Design Studio Terminology in Estimate Lump Sum • While preparing an estimate, it is not possible to workout in detail incase of petty items. Items other than civil engineering such items are called Lump sum items or simply L.S. items. • The following are some of L.S. items in the estimate: 1. Water supply and sanitary arrangements. 2. Electrical installations like meter, motor, etc., 3. Architectural features. 4. Contingencies and unforeseen items. • In general, certain percentage on the cost of estimation is allotted for the above L.S. items. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 28 Tri Angle Design Studio Terminology in Estimate Contingencies • Indicates incidental expenses of miscellaneous character which cannot be classified under any distinct item. (3% to 5% of the estimated cost is provided to allow for contingencies) Work-charged Establishment • During the construction of a project considerable number of skilled supervisors, work assistance, watch men etc., are employed on temporary basis. • The salaries of these persons are drawn from the L.S. amount allotted towards the work charged establishment. • That is, establishment which is charged directly to work. An L.S. amount of 1.5 to 2% of the estimated cost is provided towards the work charged establishment. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 29 Tri Angle Design Studio Terminology in Estimate Tools and Plants • Normally contractor has to arrange tools and plants. (1% to 1.5% of estimated cost is provided) Centage charges or Departmental charges • Also known as Supervision charges for works. To meet the expenses of establishment, designing, planning, supervision etc. (10% to 15% of the estimated cost). When engineering department takes up work of other department. Sub-Head items of work • Works like earthwork, concrete work, brick work etc. Under each sub head there are different items of work.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 30 Tri Angle Design Studio Terminology in Estimate Sub-Work • Large project may consist of small buildings. Detailed estimate of each sub-work is prepared separately. Schedule of Rates • It is a list of rate of various items of works maintained by engineering department under the name “Schedule of Rates Book”. “Road Metal Rate Book” is also maintained by PWD. Administrative Sanction/ Approval • It is the formal acceptance by the department concerned of the proposal. After the approval, design, estimates etc. are prepared and thereafter execution of work.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 31 Tri Angle Design Studio APPROXIMATE ESTIMATE
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 32 Tri Angle Design Studio Approximate Estimate • Approximate estimate is worked out for Preliminary studies – it helps in earlier decision making. It gives fairly good idea of the project and also saves a good deal of labour and time required for preparing detailed estimate. Investment – it helps in the feasibility study. The probable net return after the completion of a commercial project can be worked out and with approximate estimate , justification on investment can be made. Financial aspect – it gives fairly good idea regarding the approximate cost of construction and suitable arrangements can be made prior to the commencement of construction work. Tax schedules 8/23/2016 Insurance Estimation, costing and specification 33 Tri Angle Design Studio Approximate Estimate • Approximate estimate is worked out for Tax schedules – For public utility projects, it can be used for working out of tax schedules. Insurance – it is used for fixing up the value of the project for the insurance requirements.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 34 Tri Angle Design Studio General Principles • The general principle of working out Approximate estimate is that multiplying the number of items or units in the proposed structure by the known cost of a similar item or unit in a similar existing structure. • It involves two operations. Fix up the unit and count the number of such units in the proposed work. Fix up the unit cost by studying the actual cost of similar existing structure constructed in near past.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 35 Tri Angle Design Studio Approximate Estimate Plinth area method Cubic rate method Unit rate method Bay method
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 36 Tri Angle Design Studio Plinth area method • In Plinth area method or Square meter method, area of each floor in the proposed building is worked out in square meters. (Approximate cost of = (Total area of x (Cost per square meter proposed building) all the floors) of a similar existing building) • For computing plinth area the measurements are taken out to out of walls and no deductions are made for each items such as stairways and other ducts unless their areas are more than 2 m2 • Factors affecting the accuracy of plinth area method Change of price level. Ceiling height. Type of construction – Framed or Load bearing, Finishes. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 37 Tri Angle Design Studio Plinth area method Shape of building – Rectangular or square or other shapes. Spacing of columns. Large openings. Location of buildings Nature of soil Number of floors Use of buildings Situation of buildings – buildings with frontage on main or narrow road
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 38 Tri Angle Design Studio Plinth area method- Problems Example : Prepare an approximate estimate of building project with total plinth area of all building is 800 sqm. and from following data. i) Plinth area rate Rs. 4500 per sqm ii) Cost of water supply @7½%of cost of building. iii) Cost of Sanitary andElectrical installations each @ 15% of cost of building. iv) Cost of architectural features @1% of building cost. v) Cost of roads and lawns @5% of building cost. vi) Cost of P.S. and contingencies @4% of building cost. Determine the total cost of building project.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 39 Tri Angle Design Studio Plinth area method- Problems Solution Data given: Plinth area = 800m2. Plinth area rate = Rs. 4500 per Sqm. ∴ Cost of building = 800 x 4500 = Rs. 36,00,000 Add the cost of the water supply charges @7½% = (36,00,000 x 7.5)/100 = Rs. 2,70000 Add the Cost of Sanitary and electrical installation @ 15% = 36,00,000 x 15/100 = 5,40,000 Add the cost of architectural features @1% = 36,00,000 x 1/100 = 36,000 Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 40 Tri Angle Design Studio Plinth area method- Problems Solution Add the cost of Roads Lawns @ 5%= 36,00,000 x 5/100 = 1,80,000 Add the Cost of contingencies @ 4% 36,00,000 x 4/100 = 1,44,000 Total Rs. 47,70,000 Assume Add supervision charges 8% on overall cost 47,70,000 x 8/100 = 3,81,600
Grand Total Rs. 51,51,600
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 41 Tri Angle Design Studio Cubic – metre method • The cost per cubic meter is used . (Approximate cost of = (Total cubical x (Cost per cubic meter proposed building) contents) of a similar existing building) • The measurements are taken as in the plinth area method and then it is multiplied by height of floor. • All the factors affecting the plinth area method, except the height of the building affects this method.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 42 Tri Angle Design Studio Service Unit or Unit rate method • Service unit indicates the most important unit in a structure. • For a school it will be classroom, for hospital it will be bed , water tank it will be a litre, in cinema hall it will be seat (Approximate cost of = (No. of service units x (Cost per service unit proposed building) in a structure) of a similar existing building) • The estimates may vary considerably according to the types of construction and standards of finish • The proposed structure should ressemble the existing structure practically in all aspects . • The change of price level of different items of construction should be taken into account. • It take least time to work out the estimate. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 43 Tri Angle Design Studio Typical bay method • Useful in case of buildings which has several similar bays. • A bay is a space from center to center of two successive columns. (Approximate cost of = (No. of bays ) x (Cost of one bay) proposed building) in the proposed building) • Necessary correction should be made or the end bay due to end walls and also in other bays, if there is any difference in framing. • Useful for factories and such similar structures. • More time required but reliable than other methods.
Estimation, costing and specification
8/23/2016 44 Tri Angle Design Studio Assignment- Theory • Write short notes on by referring any std. book on Estimation. ( Mention the book referred) Detailed estimate Revised estimate Supplementary estimate Maintenance estimate Approximate estimate. Contingencies Work charged establishments Provisional sum Lump sum item. Estimation, costing and specification 8/23/2016 45 Tri Angle Design Studio Assignment- Theory • Write short notes on by referring any std. book on Estimation. (Mention the book referred). Write advantageous and disadvantageous of these methods. Plinth area method. Cubic rate method . Unit rate method Bay method.