Sei sulla pagina 1di 12

American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

AACP CURRICULAR CHANGE SUMMIT SUPPLEMENT


Preparing Pharmacy Graduates for Traditional and Emerging
Career Opportunities
Gayle A. Brazeau, PhD,a Susan M. Meyer, PhD,b Michele Belsey,c Edward M. Bednarczyk, PharmD,a
Sanela Bilic, PharmD, MBA,d Julie Bullock, PharmD,e Gary E. DeLander, PhD,f E.F. Fiese, PhD,g
Stephen L. Giroux, BS,h Danny McNatty, PharmD,i Ruth Nemire, PharmD,j
William A. Prescott Jr. PharmD,a and Andrew P. Traynor, PharmDk
a
School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, University at Buffalo
b
School of Pharmacy, University of Pittsburgh
c
Rite Aid Corporation, Camp Hill, PA
d
Novartis Pharmaceuticals, Florham Park, NJ
e
Food and Drug Administration, Silver Spring, MD
f
College of Pharmacy, Oregon State University
g
Pfizer, Inc, Groton, CT*
h
Modem-Giroux, Inc/Middleport Family Health Center, NY
i
College of Pharmacy, Midwestern University
j
Touro College of Pharmacy – New York
k
College of Pharmacy, University of Minnesota-Duluth

Educational programs in pharmacy must focus on educating pharmacists of the future who are prepared
to serve as competent and confident health care ‘‘providers’’ whose ‘‘practice’’ can occur in any
number of current and future settings; and whose expertise is essential to an interprofessional health
care team. Graduates must be able to incorporate a scholarly approach to their practice in identifying
patient care problems; practicing in an evidence-based manner; and ensuring safe, effective, and
appropriate use of medications. It is time for colleges and schools of pharmacy to implement contem-
porary teaching and assessment strategies that facilitate effective and efficient student learning that is
focused at the graduate professional level, to evolve the content around which the curriculum is
organized, and clearly articulate the abilities graduates must have to function effectively in the myriad
professional roles in which they may find themselves.

INTRODUCTION (PharmD) to be the first professional degree; the respon-


Pharmacy education has a long, proud tradition of sibility of pharmacy educators for scholarship, graduate
educating future pharmacists who are ready to meet the education, fellowships, and postgraduate education and
needs of the profession. Educators have and continue to be training; and the need for pharmacy educators to maintain
forward thinking in advancing educational programs to their commitment to the preparation of graduates capable
meet the changing pharmacist’s role in a diverse variety of of providing pharmaceutical care in an evolving health
health care settings.1 The background papers written in care environment.2-6
the late 1980s through the mid-1990s by the American The mission of pharmacy education evolved from
Association of Colleges of Pharmacy (AACP) Commis- educating pharmacists with a product focus, involving
sion to Implement Change provided the academy with the the safe and effective preparation and dispensing of med-
essential missions of pharmacy practice and education; ications, to educating pharmacists to provide patient-
the curricular outcomes, content, and educational pro- centered care and integrate and provide services for safe
cess; the recommendation for the doctor of pharmacy drug preparation and distribution, collaborative drug ther-
apy management, medication therapy management, and
medication reconciliation. The 2004 Center for the Ad-
Corresponding Author: Gayle A. Brazeau, PhD. School vancement of Pharmaceutical Education (CAPE) Educa-
of Pharmacy, University at Buffalo. tional Outcomes provided the necessary framework to
E-mail: gbrazeau@buffalo.edu assist colleges and schools to transform their curriculums
*Dr. E.F. Fiese is retired from Pfizer, Inc. to support the education of practitioners to deliver
1
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

these advanced patient care services.7 Furthermore, the reports.10-11 The nature and structure of health profes-
Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education (ACPE) sions education is being refocused on patient-centered
Standards 2007 reflects these expanded and expected care, interprofessional teams, evidence-based practice,
professional competencies.8 Yet, there is much more we quality improvement, and use of informatics.11
can do to enhance the education of future pharmacists. As The volatility of today’s national and global economic
AACP President Yanchick stated in his 2008 address, climate has impacted upon all aspects of health care ser-
we must transform pharmacy curricula away from a vices. Pharmacy graduates will practice in a dynamic
baccalaureate-level focus to a professional doctoral- health care and economic environment. Health care deliv-
level focus.9 To achieve this goal, pharmacy education ery is increasingly focused on economic models that opti-
programs must focus on educating pharmacists who are mize patient-centered evidence-based care, increase access
prepared to serve as competent and confident health care to care, reduce disparities in health care availability and
‘‘providers’’ whose ‘‘practice’’ can occur in any number quality, and seek to minimize costs at all levels. There is
of current and future settings; and whose expertise is es- an increasing emphasis on the importance of broad and
sential to an interprofessional health care team. They must sweeping reforms in the health care system. Yet, it remains
also incorporate a scholarly approach to their practice in to be seen if and how healthcare reforms will be imple-
identifying problems, utilizing the literature for the best mented. This environment represents an enormous oppor-
evidence-based practices, and analyzing, synthesizing, tunity for pharmacists to become further engaged as health
and applying this information to ensure safe, effective, care providers. Pharmacy graduates need to understand and
and appropriate use of medications by their patients.9 be able to adapt the scope and nature of their practice to the
A consistent element in the doctor of pharmacy edu- changing economic and health care environment.
cational program is the foundation of the pharmaceutical
and biomedical sciences. Contemporary pharmacy edu- PREPROFESSIONAL EDUCATION AND
cation has also been strengthened by the growth and en- CURRICULUM CONSIDERATIONS
hancement in the clinical, and social and administrative Preprofessional educational requirements provide the
sciences. Successful future practitioners must have the foundation for building the capabilities of professionals.
fundamental knowledge, skills, and attitudes/values in The breadth and depth of preparation, perhaps more than
the pharmaceutical, biomedical, clinical, and social and any other factor, enables or limits the extent to which
administrative sciences, in conjunction with the practice professional students are able to accept personal re-
proficiency gained through experiential learning in phar- sponsibility for their education and consequently their
macy educational programs. The goals of this paper are to potential as health care providers. There are several sig-
provide: (1) an analysis of the economic and health care nificant questions that need to be addressed if pharmacy
climate impact on professional education and practice; (2) graduates, future pharmacists, are to advance professional
an overview of contemporary issues related to the scope practice:
of education, from preprofessional preparation to the out- d How will preprofessional and professional prep-

comes, content, and processes of the professional degree aration in the foundational sciences expand to
program; (3) a discussion of the provider and professional encompass new areas of knowledge necessary
activities of graduates; and (4) recommendations for con- to maintain pharmacists’ role as scientific ex-
sideration by AACP and its member institutions. perts in drug action, delivery, and discovery?
d Should students in professional programs be-

come ‘‘educated persons’’ through inclusion of


IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC AND HEALTH liberal studies12-13 or should they arrive at pro-
CARE CLIMATE fessional programs as ‘‘educated persons’’?
As it did during the transition to the PharmD as the d Will professional programs require of candidates

first professional degree in pharmacy, it remains essential a level of maturity that can only be gained
for pharmacy programs to constantly monitor changes in through a full range of educational and personal
the economic and health care climate and be agile, if experiences?14 Does completion of a bachelor’s
necessary, to modify educational outcomes to meet the degree help to establish a common denomina-
needs of graduates and, importantly, the evolving health tor for a familiar background and a thoughtful
care needs of society. The focus on improved health care decision process needed to enter professional
by improving quality, enhancing information technology, education?
and adding value has been linked to health professions The requisite knowledge, skill sets, and maturity
education through a series of Institute of Medicine (IOM) obtained during preprofessional years and needed for
2
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

success in professional education must be aligned with the key components for students to learn how to think as
anticipated roles and competencies for which future prac- future pharmacy practitioners. Learning style differences
titioners will be educated. Preprofessional preparation and methods to enable learning must always be consid-
determines which students are accepted into pharmacy ered in the design and structure of educational programs.
school, the level of academic rigor and complexity at Expansions of communication technology will im-
which faculty members can engage students, and the ca- pact pharmacy education. Professional clinical and sci-
pability of new graduates to become change agents for the entific organizations are increasingly reaching out to
profession and the health care system. promote global educational opportunities. Distance-
learning opportunities are becoming the norm as entire
Professional Practice Outcomes: Core Generalist vs. courses, lectures, and symposium proceedings are being
Specialist Educational Outcomes offered globally in synchronous, asynchronous, and var-
Practice entry expectations, the nature and scope of ious hybrid formats. These represent unique opportunities
educational programs to prepare a generalist practitioner, for students, pharmacists, and scientists to learn from the
and the role of postgraduate education and training in the experts across the globe. Pharmacy graduates will need to
preparation of specialists within the profession have been have the skills to learn from these diverse educational
the subject of numerous discussions and committee de- opportunities during their formal education and through-
liberations. The CAPE Educational Outcomes, developed out their professional careers.
in 1994 and revised in 1998, provided educators with To develop future pharmacy practitioners who have
a framework for the design of a PharmD curriculum and the competencies outlined in the CAPE Educational Out-
outlined the professional knowledge, skills, attitudes, and comes and who can successfully practice in a changing
values, organized by general abilities and practice-based health care environment, we must find efficient ways to
abilities, for those graduating from PharmD programs.15 integrate and strengthen the following into the PharmD
Revised in 2004 to blend general and ability-based out- curriculum: (1) informatics and information technology,
comes, the CAPE Educational Outcomes document out- (2) simulations, (3) interprofessional education, (4) self-
lines the outcome abilities of a new generalist pharmacist assessment and reflection, (5) community and pro-
practitioner in 3 areas: (1) providing pharmaceutical care fessional engagement, (6) leadership development and
at the patient and population level, (2) effectively manag- advocacy, (7) global health, (8) scholarly activities, (9)
ing and using resources and systems, and (3) enhancing personal development and entrepreneurism, and (10) con-
public health by promoting health improvement, well- tinuing professional development.
ness, and disease prevention.7 The confluence of the
CAPE Educational Outcomes with the ACPE standards Informatics and Information Technology
and guidelines for the PharmD curriculum further empha- Informatics and information technology represent an
sizes the role of colleges and schools of pharmacy in the area of major evolution and transition within the phar-
education of generalist practitioners.7,8 While colleges macy curriculum. Previously, this area would be comfort-
and schools have been able to successfully transition to ably grouped under the concept of drug information, with
the PharmD degree, it is time now to advance towards an an emphasis on the broad range of tertiary sources of in-
education that is truly at the professional doctoral level to formation and an approach to a systematic and critical
enable graduates to be competent in today’s health care review of the primary literature based on an understand-
and economic environment. The role of residency train- ing of study design and biostatistics. With continuing
ing, fellowship training, and graduate studies in develop- advances in technology, how pharmacists, other health
ing specialist practitioners and scientists will be briefly care professionals, and the public access health and
discussed in a later section of this paper. medication-related information continues to change. Ad-
ditionally, the types of information readily accessible are
Curricular Activities: What Should be the Core also changing. The curriculum must evolve to prepare
Educational Approaches Needed for Successful graduates not only to use technology to access informa-
Future Practitioners? tion to facilitate their work, but also to help patients and
The PharmD curricula must include a wide variety of the public interpret the health-related information so read-
educational approaches to achieve the desired core pro- ily available.
gram learning outcomes. Active-learning strategies (eg, The ability to organize, combine, and analyze complex
discussions, small groups, and audience response sys- data sets is emerging as a critical skill for future graduates.
tems), hands-on laboratory experiences, self-directed Health information technology has the potential to signif-
learning, and pharmacy practice experiences must remain icantly transform the tools with which pharmacists provide
3
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

care. Graduates must have the skills to manage technology knowledge while improving their confidence in caring for
tools to effectively access, interpret, and use patient infor- patients.25-28
mation to improve the quality of care provided, prevent
medication and medical errors, reduce health care costs, Interprofessional Education
and increase access to care.16 Much attention is being given to interprofessional
education as a strategy to prepare future health care prac-
Simulations titioners to achieve the goals of effective, patient-
Simulation-based learning (SBL) allows students the centered, timely, efficient, and equitable health care.30
opportunity to apply what they learn in the classroom. Pharmacy graduates’ repertoire of abilities must include
Integration of SBL into pharmacy education has been not only the provision of pharmaceutical care, manage-
endorsed by the ACPE8 and several types have been ment of resources and systems, and promotion of health
employed in pharmacy education including computer- and disease prevention, but also how they will fulfill these
based learning simulations,17-20 virtual patients,21 simu- roles as members of teams of health care professionals.
lated and/or standardized patients,22-24 and high-fidelity Thus, training pharmacy students to work collaboratively
human patient simulators (HPSs).25-28 and communicate effectively with physicians, nurses, and
Computer-based patient case simulation, online inter- other health care providers is imperative and has been
active prescription simulations, multimedia case-history endorsed by the ACPE.8
programming to simulate case-history taking, and the use
of virtual patients have been well received by pharmacy Self-Assessment and Reflection
students.17-20 Virtual reality has not been studied within Graduates must learn how to be reflective practi-
pharmacy education, but its ability to enhance perceptual tioners, specifically as reflection relates to self-assessment
variation while allowing students to practice rare and/or of their professional strengths and weaknesses.31,32 Time
critical skills make it a potentially useful educational tool must be allowed for pharmacy students to reflect on how
in the future, particularly if costs can be substantially re- they learn in order to enhance their skills as life-long
duced. Standardized patients portraying patients with spe- learners. Furthermore, graduates must be able to deter-
cific medical conditions and health concerns, personal mine their self-efficacy or what they are able to do or not
characteristics, and communication styles are an effective to do in their professional practice.33 Self-efficacy is
and commonly used method of SBL in pharmacy educa- the confidence to perform or accomplish specific tasks
tion. While minimizing patient risk and harm, standard- in one’s professional practice. Self-assessment and self-
ized patients are used to teach and practice patient care efficacy will be requisite qualities/abilities in PharmD
skills and afford students the opportunity to better com- graduates as they embrace the importance of develop-
municate with and better understand the psychosocial ing an individualized plan for continuous professional
needs of patients.22-24, 29 development.
A novel method of SBL uses HPSs controlled by
computer programs with the capacity to realistically por- Community and Professional Engagement
tray a variety of medical conditions and demonstrate An area of exciting promise for professional pro-
physiologic responses to drug administration. The use grams and future graduates is community engagement.
of HPSs is becoming a valuable resource in pharmacy Implementing and increasing the role of the community-
education, allowing students to actively assess and engaged pharmacist will require educational programs to
treat a simulated patient in a safe, immersive, controlled provide students with the mentoring, tools, time, and con-
environment, under the direct supervision of a faculty fidence needed to engage in these activities. Defining
member who can provide immediate feedback and facil- community engagement is hard, not because it is a small
itate repetition of the exercise as needed to achieve com- matter, but because community engagement can be an
petence.25-28 Human patient simulators have been elusive concept with respect to how activities are incor-
employed in pharmacy curriculum to teach blood pres- porated into existing curricular elements. The Centers for
sure assessment, critical care, and cardiovascular pharma- Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) defines commu-
cotherapeutics, and interprofessional team skills in an nity engagement as ‘‘the process of working collabora-
emergency department setting.25-28 The use of SBL with tively with and through groups of people affiliated by
HPS is highly beneficial in furthering pharmacy student geographic proximity, special interest, or similar situa-
comprehension of the therapeutic principles and skills tions to address issues affecting the well-being of those
taught within the conventional didactic setting, allowing people.’’34 Gelmon and colleagues defined community
students to practically apply and reinforce their learned engagement as ‘‘applying institutional resources (eg,
4
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

knowledge and expertise of students, faculty and staff, dents to enter into the practice of pharmacy and to
political position, buildings and land) to address and solve function as professionals and informed citizens in
challenges facing communities through collaboration a changing health care system. It also encourages students
with these communities.’’35 Either of these definitions to take active roles in shaping policies, practices, and
can apply in professional programs; however, in order future directions of the profession.2 The changing health
to simplify even further for the purposes of this paper care system and need for advocacy represent constants
community engagement is students and faculty members around which we must shape leadership development.
working collaboratively with their community to achieve The current need for rational medication use has been
mutually beneficial health outcomes. well articulated. Pharmacy practice and education have
There is broad support for community engagement evolved to embrace a patient-centered approach. Yet,
from national and global organizations such as the IOM practices that provide medication therapy management
and Community-Campus Partnerships for Health. Orga- are not commonly seen in job descriptions for currently
nizations such as the Carnegie Foundation for the Ad- available positions. Often, these roles are created in orga-
vancement of Teaching, the Centers for Disease Control nizations by individuals with an ability to lead and man-
and Prevention, and the World Health Organization all age change in their practice. Equipping students with the
support the practice of community engagement. In addi- ability to advocate on multiple levels and lead change
tion, ACPE recommends the inclusion of community- successfully is paramount in graduates from programs
based activities in the pharmacy curriculum.8 Each of at the professional doctoral level.
these organizations has recognized the importance of The addition of more core and elective experiences in
community engagement, through provision of research leadership skills development must be considered in cur-
funding, the development of guidelines and tools, or ricular planning and evaluation. Core topics that foster an
creation of networking opportunities. This recognition understanding of leadership principles, the leader’s role in
creates a sense of importance, and perhaps urgency, in change, and the process for leading change are essential
higher education for faculty and student involvement in elements for leadership development. In addition, phar-
communities. macy graduates must understand organizational decision-
The role of social and physical environments, life- making processes and the advocacy necessary to navigate
styles, and behaviors and their relationship to health have the systems in which they may work. Elective topics to
been clearly articulated by the IOM.36 Graduates must develop leadership skills further should be considered and
have the skills and knowledge as pharmacists to become include self-directed and experiential activities in leader-
actively involved in the prevention of disease and pro- ship to garner confidence.
motion of wellness as a key components of their practice. With the focus of pharmacy education on preparing
These broadly educated and skilled pharmacists can have generalist practitioners, leadership development for all is
a dramatic effect on the lifestyle and health of patients.37 inferred and must be applicable to practitioners regardless
Embracing their role as community leaders, pharmacists of their position or practice setting. Demand for and short-
can work to decrease health disparities and improve age of pharmacists in specific leadership positions, such
health literacy by changing their practice behaviors and as health-system pharmacy departments, has been clearly
influencing others’ behaviors. Colleges and schools of articulated.39 Pharmacy education, in the future, must
pharmacy must incorporate into their culture the desire be cognizant of such specific needs in the practice
to (1) support community engagement in teaching and environment, and the PharmD curriculum must be agile
scholarship, (2) develop or implement available tools to and flexible enough to enable students to develop their
document ongoing activities, and set goals for improve- knowledge, skills, and abilities to be successful in these
ment by faculty and students across professional activi- positions. The development of generalist leadership knowl-
ties, (3) recognize faculty members and students who edge, skills, and attitudes is applicable to a variety of set-
actively engage in their community, and (4) develop tings and can be applied regardless of their position or title.
existing or innovative partnerships and opportunities that The core material taught must be combined with additional
enable engagement with communities. elective, postgraduate, and continuous professional devel-
opment opportunities to prepare those students who choose
Leadership Development and Advocacy to pursue leadership positions in pharmacy.
As AACP Past-President Wells counseled, ‘‘All of us
have a responsibility to develop leadership abilities in Global Health and Health Professions Education
ourselves, in our colleagues, and in our students.’’38 Phar- Health care services and health professions education
maceutical education is responsible for preparing stu- will not be immune to the dramatic changes in the global
5
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

market place associated with a ‘‘world-is-flat’’ environ- comes, standards, and guidelines develop graduates with
ment characterized by increased expectations for access the tools and skills needed to be the agents of change to
to health care. Advances in information technology will advance current and innovative professional practice? An
enable better communication between health care profes- entrepreneur spirit combined with the scholarly passion
sionals and enhance health professions education around and willingness to take risks does not seem to be promoted
the globe with the focal point of global improvement in in the professional curriculum given the demands for in-
patient care. As such, pharmacy education programs must creased core competencies and experiential requirements.
incorporate increased global cultural competence (eg, Curriculums have become so packed with courses needed
health beliefs and behaviors, caring for underserved pop- to meet standards and guidelines that students have little
ulations, etc), and global health issues (eg, geographic or no time to explore scholarly activities, engage in prac-
impacts on disease prevalence, epidemiology, surveil- tice-based research, or develop new practice ideas or con-
lance, drug distribution and marketing, and global health cepts that could form the foundation for advancing their
economics). practice roles.

Scholarly Activities Continuing Professional Development


The majority of students enters PharmD programs In spite of the increased emphasis on postgraduate
with an intellectual curiosity and drive to learn about training that has been advanced by many professional
medications and how they can utilize medications to pro- organizations within pharmacy41 and by colleges/schools
vide optimized patient care. However, by the time they of pharmacy, only a minority of students are seeking res-
graduate, many students have lost their intellectual curi- idency training, fellowship training,42 and graduate stud-
osity as well as their desire to advance science, pharmacy ies. This may be influenced in part by the increased cost of
practice, and the profession, and simply want to ‘‘make education, making many students eager to seek full-time
money and pay off their loans.’’ The increasingly intense employment to reduce their educational debt. While this
nature of PharmD programs may limit the time these in- is somewhat mitigated by the ability to defer loan pay-
dividuals have to develop scholarly pursuits or profes- ments, increased scholarship funds, and alternative loan
sional activities needed to stimulate further their payback programs for those seeking postgraduate training
intellectual curiosity and enthusiasm. To what extent (similar to that offered by the NIH for those pursuing
and how often do PharmD programs provide time to en- careers in research43) may be required as the costs of
able students to work with faculty members and other a pharmacy education continue to rise. The interest to
professionals to tackle interesting questions or problems? require postgraduate training residencies for positions is
What are PharmD programs doing to promote a passion in being hampered by the current shortage of practitioners.
graduates to become the future leaders/agents of change However, as the shortage of practicing pharmacists eases
in their profession? It seems pharmacy educational pro- over the ensuing decade44,45 and employment becomes
grams have become so prescriptive in nature and focused more competitive, postgraduate education may be needed
only on successfully completing a set of courses and phar- for pharmacists to attain entry-level or clinical specialist
macy practice experiences that students’ intellectual cu- positions. Apart from these external forces related to man-
riosity and time to pursue scholarly interests have been power issues and clinical practice, students should be in-
limited. Although a study found that the majority of col- troduced to the value of postgraduate training through
leges/schools of pharmacy surveyed taught research exposure to current trainees in colleges and schools of
skills, 75% did not require their students to conduct a re- pharmacy or through collaborations with other health care
search project.40 Engaging in a scholarly activity often organizations in our community. This could be accom-
provides the needed spark in students, as well as the con- plished at multiple points (didactic teaching, laboratories,
fidence and drive, to pursue postdoctoral studies. Specif- and recitations) but may be more effective in introductory
ically, what are educators and administrators doing in pharmacy practice experiences (IPPE’s) or question-and-
pharmacy programs to stimulate the intellectual curiosity answer sessions for students. This should not be limited to
of graduates? information regarding clinical or academic positions.
Nearly all positions in the pharmaceutical industry re-
Personal Development and Entrepreneurism quire skills gained during postdoctoral residencies and
Pharmacy curriculums have been extremely success- fellowships combined with on-the-job training, or through
ful in educating excellent clinicians as evidenced by the further graduate education. Colleges/schools must take
ability of graduates to care for their patients in a diverse a more active role in providing information on the unique
array of health care settings. However, do the above out- opportunities available to pharmacy graduates and the
6
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

additional education and training these positions may re- US population continues to age. Pharmacy graduates who
quire. The profession must be prepared to redirect or ex- serve in the United States Public Health Service, the
pand training opportunities should market forces and Armed Forces, and as federal pharmacists in other capac-
student interests shift. Even given the relative modest ities will be the essential link to enhancing access and
number of students seeking residency training, the current reducing disparities in the provision of quality affordable
number of applicants exceeds the number of positions health care for underserved individuals in our communi-
available. ties across the country and around the world. As these
pharmacists develop innovative practice settings, they
must be the drivers for expansion in the scope of phar-
PROVIDER AND PROFESSIONAL macy practice at the community, state, and national
ACTIVITIES FOR PHARMACY levels. Pharmacy educators must ensure that graduates
GRADUATES have the requisite knowledge, skills, attitudes/values,
Success in achieving a professional doctoral level and practice experiences, as well as the confidence, drive,
degree will provide pharmacists with the knowledge, skills, and entrepreneur spirit, to be agents of change to facilitate
and attitudes/values necessary to be well prepared to pur- these and other advances in the scope and type of com-
sue any of the vast array of provider opportunities, as well munity pharmacy practice.
as have the ability to successfully transition into one or
more other areas during their professional career. Sir Pharmacist’s Role in Inpatient Care in the Acute
Francis Bacon reminded us that ‘‘a wise man will make and Long-Term Setting
more opportunities than he finds.’’ As we reflect on what As it continues to transition from a centralized
pharmacy students will do immediately after graduation, distribution-based model to a decentralized model, in-
we must also anticipate future roles for these pharmacists. patient pharmacy practice enables pharmacists to provide
care within an interprofessional team based upon
Pharmacist’s Role in Community Care their expertise to ensure safe and cost-effective use of
Pharmacists must view themselves as essential health all medications. Pharmacy graduates must be willing to
care providers who can utilize their clinical expertise in provide key clinical services and care. Seven clinical
a variety of community settings. Pharmacists will always pharmacy services reduce mortality in the inpatient set-
be an essential health care provider given their availabil- ting: drug-use evaluation, in-service education, adverse
ity to patients through community pharmacy settings. drug reaction management, drug protocol management,
This specific provider role must never be diminished participation on the cardiopulmonary resuscitation team,
as it serves critical patient needs (eg, dispensing and participation on medical rounds, and admission drug his-
counseling for medications, expertise in nonprescription tories.46 At minimum, these services should be provided
drugs, compounding, immunizations, and the use of med- by pharmacists for every patient in the inpatient setting.
ication administration or monitoring devices) that are not However, inpatient pharmacists have the opportunity to
being met by other health care providers. However, this provide care in other novel and innovative settings as
would not preclude pharmacists serving as providers in well.
alternative, innovative settings such as ambulatory clinics Novel roles for the pharmacist are emerging, in-
located inside pharmacies and other retail environments; cluding the pharmacist case manager (PCM), antibiotic
in independent practices focusing on medication therapy stewardship pharmacists, and medication safety pharma-
management, medication reconciliation, or pharmacoge- cists.47-49 Inpatient pharmacists are increasingly contrib-
nomic drug counseling; in a community agency or orga- uting their expertise through participation on pharmacy
nization where they are responsible for integrating and and therapeutics committees and pharmacist-led medica-
advocating for patient care across many other health care tion safety teams or serving as clinical researchers in these
providers to promote continuity of care; or in organiza- organizations. Inpatient pharmacists also could focus on
tions that coordinate research to enhance practice through the transition and care of patients from inpatient to long-
pharmacy practice-based research networks. Pharmacy term care facilities, or coordinate novel clinical services
providers must seek out opportunities to engage in inter- responsible for optimizing patient care based upon con-
professional patient care activities where and when they tinued advances in pharmacogenomics and pharmacoge-
occur or as they develop in communities. For example, netics testing and screening and its role in safe and
alternative modified practice could center on providing effective use of medications. Opportunities for innovative
pharmacy and wellness services to adult and retirement inpatient care also can be driven by those pharmacists in the
communities given the increasing number of these as the Armed Services who provide care to military personnel
7
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

and their families, as part of humanitarian efforts, and nance organizations, pharmacy benefits management,
during war-time operations. pharmacy consultant organizations, and Medicare and
Pharmacy graduates will need to pursue postgraduate Medicaid Services.
training to advance their provider skills if they desire to
take on these more specialized, novel roles for inpatient Pharmacist’s Role in the FDA and Other
pharmacists within the health care system. The American Regulatory Agencies
Society of Health-System Pharmacists (ASHP) and the The integration of pharmacists into regulatory work
American College of Clinical Pharmacy (ACCP) are sup- within the FDA has evolved over time along with the
portive of this movement.41,50 However, the balance be- changes in pharmacy education. The broad therapeutic
tween entry-level and specialized practitioners to meet knowledge gained in our programs is instrumental in
patient needs will require resolution by the academy and allowing pharmacy graduates to be an integral part of
practitioners and based always on optimizing patient care. the drug approval and regulatory process. Although phy-
sicians compose the majority of the clinical reviewers for
Pharmacist’s Roles in the Pharmaceutical Industry investigational agents, pharmacy graduates who have
Pharmacy graduates with broad scientific knowledge strong clinical backgrounds and knowledge of drug de-
and laboratory skills in optimizing dosage form develop- velopment can easily step into these roles. While phar-
ment and drug delivery have and can be viewed as an macy is the only profession that focuses primarily on
entry-level formulator in the pharmaceutical industry. A pharmaceuticals, the biomedical and pharmaceutical sci-
strong educational background in biomedical, pharmaceu- ences in the PharmD curricula may not prepare graduates
tical, and clinical sciences, and completion of residencies, for the many additional opportunities within the drug
fellowships, or graduate studies with advanced course approval and regulatory arena. Residencies, fellowships,
work in biostatistics, experimental design, pharmacokinet- clinical experience, graduate studies, or combined de-
ics, and pharmacodynamics, can enable PharmD graduates grees (eg, PharmD/JD) can provide the foundation needed
to collaborate or lead project management teams in clinical for those who want to assume positions dealing with mon-
pharmacology, clinical trials, and pharmacokinetic/phar- itoring drug safety within the regulatory framework.
macodynamic analysis.51,52 Pharmacy graduates also are Pharmacy graduates could also become engaged in the
well situated to take leadership roles in investigating the activities within the Environmental Protection Agency
role of pharmacogenetics and pharmacogenomics in opti- or Occupational Safety and Health Administration given
mizing drug therapy. Alternatively, pharmacy graduates their strong scientific background in pharmacology, drug
are well positioned to engage in entry-level regulatory af- delivery, and pharmacokinetics.
fairs and assume medical ethics positions, particularly if
they took appropriate elective courses while completing Pharmacist’s Role in Local, State, and National
their PharmD degree. Marketing and sales are 2 other areas Government Structures, Policy Making,
that play to the strengths of pharmacy graduates, particu- and Advocacy
larly those who enter our programs with business or man- Pharmacy graduates can play an important role in
agement degrees or complete a combined PharmD/MBA shaping health care policy and legislation that advances
degree program. Educators must ensure that pharmacy patient care at the local, state, and national governmental
graduates understand the vast array of professional roles levels. PharmD degree programs, which provide a strong
available at large pharmaceutical organizations, as well as scientific and clinical foundation, combined with devel-
those roles available in smaller contract research organiza- opment of written and oral communication skills, leader-
tions or niche companies. ship, and advocacy skills, could provide graduates with an
excellent foundation for assuming positions as legislative
Pharmacist’s Role in Managed Care Pharmacy and committee staffers or in advocacy roles for profes-
The increased emphasis on accessible, high-quality, sional organizations. The skills needed for these practice
and cost-effective health and pharmacy care services roles could be expanded through elective course work,
combined with a focus on reducing health disparities will elective practice experiences, and/or specialized joint-
require more of our graduates to assume roles in managed degree programs or postdoctoral programs.
care pharmacy. PharmD graduates have the knowledge
and skill sets to advance and lead in critical areas such as Pharmacists’ Role in Academic Pharmacy and
drug utilization review and formulary development, out- Other Health Care Professions
comes and practice-based research, integration of health Career activities in academic pharmacy and other health
care data and disease state management in health mainte- professions education should be promoted to pharmacy
8
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

students. Furthermore, pharmacy faculty members should to collaborate with engineers, computer scientists, and
be encouraged to participate in interprofessional educa- biomedical engineers in developing the next generation
tional programs.10 The need for well-qualified individuals of technologies. Pharmacy students must be encouraged
to meet the faculty and staff requirements for an increas- to consider these types of positions and roles in arenas that
ing numbers of colleges and schools of pharmacy is well may or may not be directly related to pharmacy. Concur-
documented.53 rently, pharmacy educators and administrators must con-
The instructional focus of our professional programs tinuously scan the horizon outside of pharmacy and reach
has increasingly reflected a need for opportunities to ap- out to these alternative future employers to learn how
ply what is learned in the classroom through laboratories, PharmD graduates could contribute to their organiza-
simulations, or experiential learning, thus necessitating tions’ missions and goals.
different types of faculty and staff positions to meet these
educational demands. Innovative types of faculty and
Pharmacist’s Role in the Environmental Health
staff positions with greater attention to teaching or prac-
and Green Movement
tice and less responsibility for traditional research have
Graduates with a strong background in pharmacol-
emerged in PharmD programs and we must encourage
ogy, toxicology, and pharmacokinetics are well posi-
pharmacy graduates to pursue these roles. Concurrently,
tioned to engage in issues related to environmental
we must encourage PharmD graduates to pursue gradu-
health and the rapidly expanding green movement. This
ate degrees at the masters or doctor of philosophy level
is particularly true due to the increased concern for pro-
or advanced research-based fellowships to become the
moting a green or environmentally friendly marketplace
next generation of faculty members providing the foun-
for the use of prescription and nonprescription medica-
dation for and research in the biomedical, pharmaceutical,
tions. Pharmacy graduates can play a key role in the
clinical, and administrative sciences within pharmacy
evolving ‘‘Green Pharmacy Program’’54 or other pro-
programs.
grams addressing the disposal of medications or medica-
What is being done specifically in the academy and
tion delivery devices. These programs being developed
health professions educational programs to promote these
across the country help communities safely dispose of or
career opportunities to pharmacy students? Pharmacy ed-
perhaps reutilize expired and unused medications. On the
ucators need to become more engaged in developing spe-
industrial side, safe disposal of waste streams from syn-
cialized educational opportunities to prepare the next
thesis facilities and the environmental impact of medici-
generation of faculty and staff members and reconsider
nals in human and veterinary waste have prompted
the types and nature of faculty and staff positions in our
expensive efforts to protect the environment. All these
institutions in order to attract graduates to become in-
efforts to promote and protect the environment represent
volved in the academy. Pharmacy graduates also should
potential innovative practice environments for pharmacy
be encouraged to explore potential roles in other health
graduates that could be addressed through PharmD/MPH,
science educational programs given the increased empha-
PharmD/MS, PharmD/PhD, or other novel integrated de-
sis on interprofessional teams in health professions edu-
gree programs.
cation being essential to high-quality patient care.

RECOMMENDATIONS
Pharmacists’ Role in Advancing Pharmacy and We must continue to advance the focus of pharmacy
Information Technologies education programs towards a professional doctoral level
With the demand for improvements in technology of instruction in order to enable our graduates to be com-
accompanying the increased emphasis on providing safe petent providers in today’s health care and economic en-
and effective care that minimizes errors, pharmacy grad- vironment. The majority of graduates should and will
uates have the potential for engaging in the innovative remain centered on providing patient care in community
design and development of new technologies for the dis- and institutional practice. Yet, the strong educational
tribution and dispensing of pharmaceuticals and informa- background and clinical experiences at the professional
tion systems to facilitate communication with other health doctoral level enables PharmD graduates to pursue many
care providers and patients. PharmD graduates can bring alternative and potentially unlimited professional prac-
their educational perspectives to challenges involved with tice roles. Pharmacy graduates must be encouraged to
integration of the drug distribution process with the es- seek these opportunities or to envision future practice
sentials needed to help patients to optimize the use of roles that may not exist. The responsibility of educators
medications. As such, graduates would be well positioned and practitioners is to continuously scan the economic and
9
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

health care environment for these possibilities and pro- our communities within and outside of pharmacy
vide the requisite support and mentorship to those who issues.
seek these alternative career paths. Furthermore, we must d Pharmacy graduates must be leaders and advo-
be ready to prepare our alumni through continuing edu- cates, regardless of their position or title, for
cation/professional development programs with the tools pharmacy and for advancing the diverse provider
and skills needed to transition to alternative or innovative roles that pharmacists can offer to our commu-
provider roles as they encounter new frontiers, chal- nities.
lenges, and opportunities in their careers. The list below d Pharmacy graduates must be culturally compe-
provides the recommendations for consideration by tent in the provision of their care and seek to
AACP and its member institutions as we look towards reduce health care disparities.
the future of pharmacy education to assist our graduates d Pharmacy graduates must embrace a global fo-
to make more opportunities than we see: cus and seek to comprehend global health issues
d Pharmacy educational programs must respond and their relevance to patient care.
quickly to opportunities that develop in a chang- d Pharmacy graduates must assume the responsi-
ing health care and economic climate. bility to address society’s needs and advance our
d Pharmacy graduates must accept the responsibil- knowledge through research on medications and
ity that they are health care ‘‘providers’’ whose their uses in patient care.
skills allow them to provide care in a variety of
environments.
d Pharmacy graduates must make health care more REFERENCES
beneficial and cost effective through the appro- 1. Bradberry JC, Droege M, Evans RL, et al. Curricula then and now:
an environmental scan and recommendations since the commission
priate use of all medications (prescription, non- to implement change in pharmaceutical education. Report of the
prescription, dietary supplements, and other drug 2006-2007 Academic Affairs Committee, http://www.aacp.org/
classes) and medication use tools. governance/COMMITTEES/academicaffairs/Documents/
d Pharmacy graduates must embrace information 2006-07_AcadAffairs_FinalReport.pdf. Accessed September 22,
technology and employ it to provide care and 2009.
2. AACP Commission to Implement Change in Pharmaceutical
interact with a diverse and widespread audience
Education. Background paper I: what is the mission of
of patients, educators, other health care profes- pharmaceutical education? Am J Pharm Educ. 1993;57(4):374-376.
sionals, managers, executives, and regulators. 3. AACP Commission to Implement Change in Pharmaceutical
d Pharmacy graduates must have the skills and Education. Background paper II: Entry-level, curricular outcomes,
confidence to be adaptable and flexible to curricular content and educational process. Am J Pharm Educ.
changes they will encounter during their profes- 1993;57(4):377-385.
4. AACP Commission to Implement Change in Pharmaceutical
sional careers and embrace life-long learning as Education. Entry-level education in pharmacy: commitment to
essential to their role as a provider of pharmacy change. Am J Pharm Educ. 1993;57(4):366-374.
knowledge, services, and care. As such, they will 5. AACP Commission to Implement Change in Pharmaceutical
embrace their role as an agent for change and be Education. The responsibility of pharmaceutical education for
willing to take risks and experiment to advance scholarship, graduate education, fellowships, and postgraduate
professional education and training. Am J Pharm Educ.
new practice roles.
1993;57(4):386-399.
d Pharmacy graduates must take responsibility
6. AACP Commission to Implement Change in Pharmaceutical
for their continuous professional development Education Maintaining our Commitment to Change - Background
through mastery of self-assessment and self- Paper 5. http://www.aacp.org/resources/historicaldocuments/
efficacy. They will embrace the potential for Documents/BackgroundPaper5.pdf. Accessed September 22, 2009.
postdoctoral educational pharmacy opportu- 7. Center for the Advancement of Pharmaceutical Education,
Educational Outcomes 2004. http://www.aacp.org/resources/
nities to advance their continuous professional education/Documents/CAPE2004.pdf Accessed September 22, 2009.
development. 8. Accreditation Council for Pharmaceutical Education, Revised
d Pharmacy graduates must be willing to work PharmD Standards Adopted: January 15, 2006, Released: February
collaboratively, including taking leadership 17, 2006, Effective: July 1, 2007, Available at http://www.acpe-
roles, in a variety of existing or future settings accredit.org/pdf/ACPE_Revised_PharmD_Standards_Adopted_
Jan152006.DOC Accessed September 22, 2009.
with other health care professionals and individ-
9. Yanchick VA. Thinking off the map. Am J Pharm Educ.
uals. 2009;72(6):Article 4.
d Pharmacy graduates must engage their commu- 10. Committee on Identifying and Preventing Medication Errors,
nities to help define and solve challenges facing Board on Health Care Services, Institute of Medicine of the National

10
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

Academies, Preventing Medication Errors, Aspden P, Wolcott JA, 28. Seybert AL, Laughlin KK, Benedict NJ, Barton CM, Rea RS.
Bootman JL, Cronenwett LR, Editors, Institute of Medicine of the Pharmacy student response to patient-simulation mannequins to teach
National Academies, National Academies Press, 2006. performance-based pharmacotherapeutics. Am J Pharm Educ.
11. Committee on Health Professions Education Summit, Board on 2006;70(3):Article 48.
Health Care Services. Institute of Medicine report-health professions 29. James D, Nastasic S, Horne R, Davies G. The design and
education: a bridge to quality. Greiner AC, Knebel E, editors. Institute of evaluation of a simulated-patient teaching programme to develop the
Medicine of the National Academies, National Academies Press, 2003. consultation skills of undergraduate pharmacy students. Pharm
12. Broedel-Zaugg K, Buring SM, Shankar N, et al. Academic World Sci. 2001;23(5):212-16.
pharmacy administrators’ perceptions of core requirements for entry 30. Institute of Medicine Committee on Quality of Health Care in
into professional pharmacy programs. Am J Pharm Educ. America. Crossing the Quality Chasm. Washington, DC: National
2008;72(3):Article 52. Academy Press; 2001.
13. Chalmers RK, Gibson RD, Schumacher GE, Sorby DL, Zografi 31. Eva KW, Regehr G. Self-assessment in the health professions:
G. Liberal Education – A Key Component in Pharmacy Education, a reformulation and research agenda. Acad Med. 2005;80(10
Report of the 1986-87 Argus Commission. Am J Pharm Educ. Suppl):S46-S54.
1987;51(4):446-450. 32. Asadoorian J, Batty HP. An evidence-based model of effective
14. DeLander GE. Optimizing professional education in pharmacy: self-assessment for directing professional learning. J Dent Educ.
are the ingredients as important as the recipe? Am J Pharm Educ. 2005;69(12):1315-1323.
2005;69(2):Article 35. 33. Bandura A. Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral
15. Bruce SP, Bower A, Hak E, Schwartz AH. Utilization of the change. Psych Rev. 1977;84(2):191-215.
Center for the Advancement of Pharmaceutical Education 34. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2009) Community
educational outcomes. Revised version 2004: Report of the 2005 Engagement: Definitions and Organizing Concepts from the
American College of Clinical Pharmacy Educational Affairs Literature. http://www.cdc.gov/phppo/pce/part1.htm. Accessed
Committee. Am J Pharm Educ. 2006;70(4):Article 79. September 22, 2009.
16. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Health 35. Gelmon SB, Seifer SD, Kauper-Brown J and Mikkelsen M.
Information Technology for the Future of Health and Care. http:// Building Capacity for Community Engagement: Institutional Self-
healthit.hhs.gov/portal/server.pt?open5512&objID5 Assessment. Seattle, WA: Community-Campus Partnerships for
1136&parentname5CommunityPage&parentid510&mode5 Health. 2005 Available at http://www.depts.washington.edu/ccph/
2&in_hi_userid510741&cached5true Accessed September 22, pdf_files/self-assessment-copyright.pdf. Accessed November 23,
2009. 2009.
17. MacKinnon III GE, Pitterle ME, Boh LE, DeMuth JE. Computer- 36. Committee for the Study of Future of Public Health, Division of
based patient simulations: Hospital pharmacists’ performance and Health Care Services, Institute of Medicine. The future of public
opinions. Am J Pharm Educ. 1992;49(11):2740-2745. health. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1988.
18. White CM, Schlesselmann L. Instructing pharmacy students with 37. Calis KA, Hutchison LC, Elliott ME, et al. Healthy People 2010:
interactive clinical cases. Am J Health-Syst Pharm. Challenges, opportunities, and a call to action for America’s
2008;65(17):1598-1599. pharmacists. Pharmacotherapy 2004;24(9):1241-1294.
19. Wellman GS, Larson R. Using web-based prescription 38. Wells BG. Why leadership? It’s all about patients. Am J Pharm
simulations as an active learning tool in an integrated practice skills Educ. 2003;67(4):Article 104.
laboratory. Am J Pharm Educ. 2002;66(4):411-415. 39. Report of the ASHP Task Force on Pharmacy’s Changing
20. Chaikoolvatana A, Goodyer L. Evaluation of a multimedia case- Demographics. Am J Health-Syst Pharm. 2007;64(12):1311–1319.
history simulation program for pharmacy students. Am J Pharm 40. Fuji K, Galt K. Research skills training for the doctor of pharmacy
Educ. 2003;67(1):Article 16. in US schools of pharmacy: a descriptive study. Int J Pharm Pract.
21. Orr KK. Integrating virtual patients into a self-care course. Am J 2009;17(2):115-121.
Pharm Educ. 2007;71(2):Article 30. 41. Murphy JE, Nappi JM, Bosso JA, et al. American College of
22. Gallimore C, George AK, Brown MC. Pharmacy students’ Clinical Pharmacy’s Vision of the Future: Postgraduate Pharmacy
preferences for various types of simulated patients. Am J Pharm Residency Training as a Prerequisite for Direct Patient Care
Educ. 2008;72(1):Article 4. Practice. Pharmacotherapy. 2006;26(5):722-733.
23. Austin Z, Gregory P, Tabak D. Simulated patients vs. 42. The Research Agenda of the American College of Clinical
standardized patients in objective structured clinical Pharmacy. Pharmacotherapy. 2007;27(2):312–324.
examinations. Am J Pharm Educ. 2006;70(5):Article 119. 43. NIH Extramural Loan Repayment Programs (LRP), Available at
24. Westberg SM, Adams J, Thiede K, Stratton TP, Bumgardner MA. http://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT-OD-08-083.html
An interprofessional activity using standardized Patients. Am J Accessed September 22, 2009.
Pharm Educ. 2006;70(2):Article 34. 44. Lacey JL, Crosby O. Job outlook for college graduates. Occup
25. Fernandez R, Parker D, Kalus JS, Miller D, Compton S. Using Outlook Q. Winter 2004.
a human patient simulation mannequin to teach interdisciplinary team 45. Liming D, Wolf M. Job outlook by education 2006-16. Occup
skills to pharmacy students. Am J Pharm Educ. 2007;71(3):Article 51. Outlook Q. 2008;52(2):22-29.
26. Seybert AL, Barton CM. Simulation-based learning to teach 46. Bond CA, Raehl CL. Clinical pharmacy services, pharmacy
blood pressure assessment to doctor of pharmacy students. Am J staffing, and hospital mortality rates. Pharmacotherapy.
Pharm Educ. 2007;71(3):Article 48. 2007;27(4):481-493.
27. Seybert AL, Kobulinsky LR, McKaveney TP. Human patient 47. Carter BL, Farris KB, Abramowitz PW, et al. The Iowa continuity
simulation in a pharmacotherapy course. Am J Pharm Educ. of care study: background and methods. Am J Health-Syst Pharm.
2008;72(2):Article 37. 2008;65(17):1631-1642.

11
American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education 2009; 73 (8) Article 157.

48. Jack BW, Chetty VK, Anthony D, et al. A reengineered hospital 51. Cohen JL. The PharmD investigator in clinical pharmacology:
discharge program to decrease rehospitalization. Ann Intern Med. supply and demand. Clin Pharm Ther. 2008;84(4):445-447.
2009;150(3):178-187. 52. Figg WD. The PharmD investigator in clinical pharmacology:
49. Dellit TH, Owens RC, McGowan JE jr, et al. Infectious Diseases supply and demand. Clin Pharm Ther. 2008;84(4):526-529.
Society of America and the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of 53. Beardsley R, Matzke GR, Rospond R, et al. Factors influencing
America guidelines for developing an institutional program to enhance the pharmacy faculty workforce. Am J Pharm Educ. 2008;72(2):
antimicrobial stewardship. Clin Infect Dis. 2007;44(2):159-177. Article 34.
50. American Society of Health-System Pharmacists. ASHP policy 54. The Teleosis Institute’s Green Pharmacy Program. Available at
position: education and training. Available at www.ashp.org/s_ashp/ http://www.teleosis.org/gpp-program.php. Accessed November 23,
doc1c.asp?CID5512&DID57319#0701. Accessed September 22, 2009. 2009.

12

Potrebbero piacerti anche