Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
net/publication/13467765
CITATIONS READS
214 893
3 authors, including:
Heather Boon
University of Toronto
261 PUBLICATIONS 7,323 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Heather Boon on 08 January 2016.
P
atients’ use of alternative and complementary health services has created a need for phy-
sicians to become informed about the current literature regarding these treatments. Herbal
remedies may be encountered in psychiatric practice when they are used to treat psy-
chiatric symptoms; produce changes in mood, thinking, or behavior as a side effect; or
interact with psychiatric medications. English-language articles and translated abstracts or ar-
ticles (where available) found on MEDLINE and sources from the alternative/complementary health
field were reviewed. Each herb was assessed for its safety, side effects, drug interactions, and effi-
cacy in treating target symptoms or diagnoses. A synopsis of the information available for each
herb is presented. In many cases the quantity and quality of data were insufficient to make defini-
tive conclusions about efficacy or safety. However, there was good evidence for the efficacy of St
John’s wort for the treatment of depression and for ginkgo in the treatment of memory impair-
ment caused by dementia. More research is required for most of the herbs reviewed, but the in-
formation published to date is still of clinical interest in diagnosing, counseling, and treating pa-
tients who may be taking botanical remedies. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1998;55:1033-1044
It is currently estimated that alternative/ ticular relevance to psychiatry will
complementary medicine is used by 20% be discussed. The herbal remedies re-
to 30% of the general North American viewed herein will be divided into 3 sec-
population, and use appears to be most tions: (1) herbs that are commonly used
common in patients with chronic condi- to treat psychiatric symptoms (Table),
tions.1,2 It is estimated that North Ameri- (2) herbs that have psychotropic effects, and
cans spend more than $11 billion dollars (3) herbs that may interact with either psy-
for chiropractic, naturopathic, and chiatric illnesses or the drugs used to treat
herbal therapies not covered by health these illnesses.
plans each year,1,3 and the current annual Informationincludedinthisreviewwas
growth rate of the alternative/com- drawn from comprehensive MEDLINE
plementary medicine industry is esti- (1986-1997) searches, frequently cited or
mated to be 20%. 4 Patients’ growing landmark articles, sources commonly used
interest in alternative/complementary by the alternative health care community
medicine has created the need for accu- in North America (eg, The Canadian Col-
rate information that is accessible to phy- lege of Naturopathic Medicine reference
sicians. While this review cannot be library), and consensus reports from ex-
comprehensive, especially in covering pert committees (eg, The German Com-
remedies used in less developed coun- mission E5 and the European Scientific Co-
tries, the botanicals commonly encoun- operative on Phytotherapy). The efficacy
tered in North America that have par- of herbal interventions was rated accord-
ing to criteria derived from the 1994 Ca-
From the Clarke Institute of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto nadian Guide to Clinical Preventive Health
(Dr Wong), Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine (Mr Smith), and Faculty of Care by the Canadian Task Force on the
Pharmacy, University of Toronto (Dr Boon), Toronto, Ontario; and Centre for Studies Periodic Health Examination6 and the 1996
in Family Medicine, Department of Family Medicine, The University of Western Guide to Clinical Preventive Services by the
Ontario, London (Dr Boon). US Preventive Services Task Force.7 This
Quality of
Evidence Cautions/
Herb Common Usage Category† Adverse Effects Contraindications Drug Interactions
Black cohosh Menopause symptoms I
GI upset (rare), headaches, Pregnancy, lactation Hormonal treatments
PMS III
CV depression (theoretical)
Dysmenorrhea III
German chamomile Insomnia III Allergy (rare) Allergy to sunflower None reported
Anxiety III family of plants
Evening primrose Schizophrenia IV None reported Mania, epilepsy Phenothiazines, NSAIDs,
ADHD IV corticosteroids,
Dementia IV b-blockers, anticoagulants
Ginkgo “Cerebrovascular I Headache, GI upset Pregnancy, lactation, Anticoagulants
insufficiency” potential bleeding
symptoms (eg, PUD)
Dementia I
Hops Insomnia III Allergy, menstrual irregularity Depression, Sedative-hypnotics, alcohol
pregnancy, lactation (both theoretical)
Kava Insomnia III
Anxiety III Scaling of skin on extremities Pregnancy, lactation Benzodiazepines, alcohol
Seizures IV
Lemon balm Insomnia IV Thyroid disease, CNS depressants, thyroid
None reported
Anxiety III pregnancy, lactation medications
Passion flower Insomnia III Hypersensitivity vasculitis, Pregnancy, lactation Insufficient data
Anxiety III sedation
Skullcap Insomnia IV
Anxiety IV Sedation, confusion, seizures Pregnancy, lactation Insufficient data
Seizures IV
St John’s wort Depression I Photosensitivity, GI upset, CV disease, Drugs that interact with
sedation, anticholinergic pregnancy, MAOIs
lactation,
pheochromocytoma
Valerian Insomnia III
Sedation Pregnancy, lactation CNS depressants
Anxiety III
*PMS indicates premenstrual syndrome; GI, gastrointestinal; CV, cardiovascular; ADHD, attention deficit with hyperactivity disorder; NSAIDs, nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs; PUD, peptic ulcer disease; CNS, central nervous system; and MAOIs, monoamine oxidase inhibitors.
†Quality of evidence: I, evidence from at least 2 properly randomized controlled trials; II-1, evidence from well-designed trials without randomization; II-2,
evidence from well-designed cohort or case-controlled analytic studies, preferably from more than 1 center or research group; II-3, evidence obtained from
multiple time series with or without the intervention; dramatic results from uncontrolled experiments could also be regarded as this type of evidence; III, opinions
of respected authorities based on clinical experience, descriptive studies, or reports of expert committees; and IV, insufficient evidence to warrant conclusions
about efficacy or safety.
rating system was designed to pro- HERBAL REMEDIES A randomized study compar-
vide clinically relevant guidance re- COMMONLY USED TO TREAT ing a commercial product of C ra-
garding the use of these herbs by pa- PSYCHIATRIC SYMPTOMS cemosa (Remifemin) with conven-
tients. The ratings assigned to each tional hormonal therapy for the
herb, and the rating system, may be Black Cohosh treatment of ovarian insufficiency
found in the Table. symptoms showed comparable effi-
Many of the herbs discussed in Black cohosh (Cimicifuga racemosa cacy with both treatments (n = 60).16
this article have a variety of con- [L] Nutt) has a history of use among A randomized, double-blind, pla-
stituents and putative therapeutic North American aboriginal peoples cebo-controlled trial with the same
indications. Only the information as a treatment for the hot flashes, product (n = 80) found superior ef-
relevant to psychiatric illness, symp- anxiety, and dysphoria associated ficacy to placebo or conjugated es-
toms, or treatments will be consid- with menopause; as an analgesic; and trogen therapy for the treatment of
ered because of space limitations. to promote lactation and menses.10 both physical and mental meno-
This review focuses primarily on the Its putative action is on the gonado- pausal symptoms.17 The long-term
English-language literature. A fur- tropin system, through direct estro- benefits of postmenopausal hor-
ther caveat concerns the lack of stan- gen ligands that suppress luteiniz- mone treatment have not been com-
dardization, quality control, and ing hormone release, and through pared with those of C racemosa. The
regulation of commercial herbal nonestrogen ligands that appear to dose of black cohosh ranges from 40
products in much of the world.8,9 decrease luteinizing hormone secre- to 200 mg daily, and the onset of ac-
The studies cited herein report re- tion with long-term use.11 A variety tion is reported to be up to 2 weeks.18
sults of a wide range of herbal prepa- of uncontrolled studies have dem- Potential side effects include
rations, some of which may not be onstrated some clinical benefit in the gastric upset, throbbing headaches,
applicable to other preparations of treatment of ovarian insufficiency dysphoria, and cardiovascular de-
the same herb. symptoms.12-15 pression. Caution should be exer-