Sei sulla pagina 1di 8

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/230845980

Feeding habits of the diving beetle larvae Cybister brevis Aube (Coleoptera:
Dytiscidae) in Japanese wetlands

Article  in  Applied Entomology and Zoology · August 2009


DOI: 10.1303/aez.2009.447

CITATIONS READS

14 594

1 author:

Shin-ya Ohba
Nagasaki University
61 PUBLICATIONS   581 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Sexual selection of parental care in Belostomatidae View project

Conservaiton of aquatic insects View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Shin-ya Ohba on 30 May 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Appl. Entomol. Zool. 44 (3): 447–453 (2009)
http://odokon.org/

Feeding habits of the diving beetle larvae, Cybister brevis Aubé (Coleoptera:
Dytiscidae) in Japanese wetlands

Shin-ya OHBA*,†
Laboratory of Insect Ecology, and Laboratory of Evolutionary Ecology, Graduate School of Environmental Science, Okayama
University; Okayama 700–8530, Japan
(Received 4 February 2009; Accepted 1 April 2009)

Abstract
A number of descriptive reports suggest that Cybister larvae feed on tadpoles, fish, and aquatic insects; however, no
quantitative study on their feeding habits has been reported. In order to elucidate the feeding ecology of C. brevis
larvae, field observations and laboratory experiments were carried out. In the field, all C. brevis larvae fed on inverte-
brates, such as insects and isopoda, but did not eat vertebrates, such as fish and anuran larvae. A rearing experiment
demonstrated that all C. brevis larvae provided with tadpoles died. Larvae provided with Odonata nymphs had a
longer total body length than larvae reared with a mixture of tadpoles and Odonata nymphs. In addition, larvae of
C. brevis could search for and eat motionless Odonata nymphs, but all larvae died from starvation when they were
supplied with motionless tadpoles. These results suggested that C. brevis larvae mainly preyed upon invertebrate ani-
mals and did not eat vertebrate animals, such as tadpoles and fish.

Key words: Feeding habit; diving beetle larva; Cybister brevis; Culex

prefectures (Association of Wildlife Research &


INTRODUCTION
EnVision, 2007). Contributing factors, such as de-
In wetlands, diving beetles (Dytiscidae) are im- creasing amounts of suitable aquatic habitats, aban-
portant predators and are often at the upper end of donment of rice paddies, water pollution, pesticide
the food web in aquatic communities. The larvae of application, and invasion by alien species are of
some species are regarded as effective predators of great concern (e.g., Nishihara et al., 2006). More-
mosquito larvae (Bay, 1974; Berman et al., 2000; over, the population size of predatory invertebrates
Lundkvist et al., 2003). The genus Cybister, one of is limited by its food resources, as for many other
the Dytiscidae, is a relatively large species. Seven predatory insects (e.g., Lenki, 1984; Pearson and
Cybister species are distributed across the Japanese Knisley, 1985; Juliano, 1986). Thus, understanding
archipelago. the feeding habits of C. brevis in their natural envi-
Cybister brevis Aubé (20–25 mm in body length) ronment is significant for conservation efforts.
is distributed in China, the Korean Peninsula, and A number of descriptive reports (e.g., Ichikawa,
Japan, excluding Hokkaido and the Ryukyu Islands 1984, 2007; Tsuzuki et al., 1999; Uchiyama, 2005)
(Mori and Kitayama, 2002). They live in rice suggest that Cybister larva feed on tadpoles, fish,
paddy water systems and reproduce from May to and aquatic insects; however, no quantitative stud-
August in both rice fields and ponds (Saijo, 2001, ies on the feeding habits of C. brevis have been
2002). The numbers of C. brevis are declining in performed. In the present study, in order to exam-
some regions of Japan, and this species is desig- ine the feeding ecology of C. brevis, field observa-
nated in the Red Data List of species in 18 of 47 tions and laboratory experiments were carried out.

* E-mail: oobug@hotmail.com

Present address: Department of Vector Ecology and Environment, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Nagasaki University, Sakamoto, Nagasaki
852–8523, Japan.
DOI: 10.1303/aez.2009.447

447
448 S. OHBA

MATERIALS AND METHODS


Prey composition of C. brevis larvae in the
field. To investigate the dietary habits of C. brevis,
field censuses were conducted at intervals of 1 to 2
days in rice paddy water systems in eastern Shi-
mane, Japan, from 3 May to 28 July 2008. Cen-
suses were conducted along the ridges around rice
paddy water systems (about 100 m2) and irrigation
ponds (about 20 m2). In the daytime, observation of
the beetles was difficult because of the reflection of
sunlight on the water surface. Beetle individuals
were observed directly in the field using a flash-
light (11,000 lx) from 20:00 to 02:00. The flash-
Fig. 1. Third instar larva of Cybister brevis eating a
light did not interfere with the foraging behaviors nymph of a backswimmer, Notonecta triguttata.
of beetle larvae as they did not stop feeding or
hunting prey (S. Ohba, unpublished data). In con-
trast, it was impossible to observe the dietary com- gravel surface. Three water hyacinths Eichhornia
ponents of beetle adults because they disappeared crassipes (ca. 5 cm in stock diameter) and six nar-
into the water as soon as the investigator ap- row leaf Amazon swords Echinodorus amazonicus
proached. When beetle larvae were found, it was (ca. 10 cm in plant length) were planted in the
noted whether they were holding prey in their aquarium as oviposition sites.
mandibles (Fig. 1). The body widths of the prey Hatched larvae were reared individually in small
were measured as indices of prey body size, and plastic containers (6 cm6 cm sides, 5 cm height)
the head widths of C. brevis larvae were measured with 1 hole (5 mm diameter) in the bottom, and the
with calipers. After measurement, the C. brevis lar- tops were covered with a plastic board (Fig. 2a).
vae were released immediately at their point of The bottom hole in each plastic container was cov-
capture. C. brevis larvae were assigned to instars ered with net (3 mm mesh) and filled with a 1 cm
based on the head width data obtained from pre- thick layer of river gravel. To prevent the water
liminary survey (S. Ohba, unpublished data) as fol- quality from deteriorating and to maintain the same
lows: first instar, 1.4–1.6 mm; second instar, water quality in each small plastic container, all
2.3–2.7 mm; and third instar, 2.9–4.3 mm. Prey that containers were placed in large aquarium (63.5
had deteriorated by digestion were excluded from cm43.9 cm22.6 cm) kept at 29.30.07°C water
the measurements. The type of prey held in the temperature and a 16L8D light cycle. The aquar-
mandibles was recorded as a dietary component ium was filled with water to a depth of 15 cm, and
and preserved in 70% ethyl alcohol for later identi- aeration, one tube with one filtering device-airstone
fication. The prey was identified at the species level per air pump, was implemented (see Ohba, 2008).
if possible. Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient All plastic containers were fixed within the aquar-
was used to evaluate the association between head ium to keep the water depth at 3 cm (Fig. 2b).
widths of C. brevis larva and the body widths of Experiments were conducted separately for three
their prey (n58). prey treatments: tadpole, Odonata nymph, and a
Rearing experiment. Five male and five female tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture. The tadpole,
C. brevis adults were collected as breeding stock Odonata nymph, and tadpole-Odonata nymph mix-
from an irrigation pond in eastern Shimane, Japan, ture treatments were replicated 5, 16, and 12 times,
in April 2008, and kept in an aquarium (45 cm respectively. Because it is known that some insect
34 cm, 20 cm height) maintained at 27.40.11°C predators provided with mixture prey animals had
(SE) water temperature and a 16L8D light cycle. higher performance than those supplied with a sin-
River gravel was laid on the bottom of the aquar- gle type of prey (e.g., Sonoda et al., 1992; Zanun-
ium in a 20 cm thick layer, and dechlorinated tap cio et al., 2001), the tadpole-Odonata nymph mix-
water was added to a depth of 15 cm over the ture treatment was conducted. Prey animals in this
Feeding Habits of Cybister brevis Larvae 449

Fig. 2. Schematic drawing of the small plastic container (a) and large aquarium (b) to rear C. brevis larvae.

experiment were collected from rice fields and irri- diameter10 cm height) filled with peat moss in
gation ponds. Small damselfly nymphs (Platycne- order to confirm their pupation. The day when 3rd
mididae: Copera spp. and Lestidae: Lestes spp., instar burrowed into the peat moss was recorded as
15 mm), medium damselfly nymphs (same the last day of the larval period. New adults emerg-
species, 15–20 mm), and large dragonfly nymphs ing from the peat moss were examined to deter-
(Libellulidae: Orthetrum albistylum speciosum, mine their sex, and their total body length was
Sympetrum frequens, S. infuscatum; Aeshnidae: measured using calipers. After the above-men-
Planaeschnu milnei, and Anax parthenope, 20–30 tioned field censuses were finished, all beetle adults
mm) were provided as food to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd in- were released in the irrigation pond from which
stars, respectively. Small (7 mm in snout to vent beetles had been captured.
length), medium (10–20 mm), and large (20–30 To compare the survival rates of first instar
mm) tadpoles of the pond frog R. nigromaculata larvae of C. brevis, the c 2 test with sequential Bon-
were provided as food to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd instars, ferroni test was used among three prey treatments.
respectively. In the tadpole-Odonata nymph mix- Tadpole treatment was excluded from analysis of
ture treatment, the same number of tadpoles and the larval period and adult body size because all
Odonata individuals were provided. The density of 1st instar larvae died (see Results). To evaluate the
prey in each plastic container was kept constant (6 effect of prey type on the adult total body length,
tadpoles for tadpole treatment, 6 Odonata nymphs two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with prey
for Odonata nymph treatment, and 3 tadpoles and 3 (Odonata nymphs and tadpole-Odonata nymph
Odonata nymphs for tadpole-Odonata nymph mix- mixture) and sex was performed. The larval period
ture treatment). Prey density levels were set to sup- of C. brevis in the two prey treatments was com-
ply enough food for C. brevis larvae during their pared using repeated-measures two-way ANOVA,
development. To maintain a constant prey density with prey (Odonata nymph or tadpole-Odonata
in each larval stage, the number of prey was nymph mixture) and sex as the between-subject
checked each day and additional prey were pro- factors and larval stage (1st–3rd instar) as the
vided as necessary. Simultaneously, dead prey were within-subject factor. Because Mauchly’s test did
removed immediately from containers. Third instar not indicate a significant violation of the assump-
larva of all dytiscid beetles do not eat any prey just tion of sphericity in the analysis of the larval pe-
before pupation (Tsuzuki et al., 1999). Thus, 3rd riod (p0.07), significance levels for within-sub-
instar larva that did not eat prey within one hour ject effects were not corrected using the Green-
after it was provided were moved to a cup (10 cm house-Geisser method for the degrees of freedom
450 S. OHBA

(see Quinn and Keough, 2002). To determine the


diet choice of C. brevis larvae, the number of each
prey item consumed in tadpole-Odonata nymph
mixture treatment was recorded for each larval in-
star. The paired t-test was used to compare the
number of prey consumed between tadpoles and
Odonata nymphs for each larval instar. Log10 trans-
formations for exact values were made in order to
standardize and normalize the variances, if neces-
sary, to satisfy the assumptions of the ANOVA
model. Fig. 3. Correlation relationship between the head width of
Motionless prey. In the rearing experiment and C. brevis larvae and their prey (Spearman’s rank correlation
field census, C. brevis larvae hardly ever consumed coefficient).
tadpoles but they routinely ate Odonata nymphs.
This may have been caused by differences in es- Table 1. Types and percentages of dietary components
caping ability between tadpoles and Odonata consumed by C. brevis larvae in the field
nymphs. To examine the effect of each prey item
1st 2nd 3rd
on the development of C. brevis larvae when the instar instar instar
prey was disabled from escaping, motionless tad- (n10) (n11) (n46)
poles and motionless Odonata nymphs were used.
The base part of tadpole tails (R. nigromaculata, Insecta
ca. 10 mm) or the thorax of Odonata nymphs (Lestes Ephemeroptera
Baetidae nymph 30.0 45.5 —
spp. ca. 15 mm) was squeezed using forceps for 5 Odonata
seconds to immobilize them. A 1st instar larva of Aeshnidae nymph — 9.1 6.5
C. brevis and one motionless prey were put into a Libellulidae nymph — — 6.5
small, plastic container (Fig. 2a). Individual prey Damselfly nymph — — 4.3
were exchanged for new prey every day, and this Orthoptera
Gryllotalpa orientalis — — 2.2
process was continued until the beetle larvae be-
Heteroptera
came 2nd instar or died. Survival analysis was used Notonecta triguttata 20.0 — 69.6
to test for survival curve differences between mo- Appasus major — — 2.2
tionless tadpoles and motionless Odonata nymphs. Coleoptera
The Kaplan-Meier method of estimating survival Cybister brevis larvae — 27.3 —
function and the nonparametric Mantel-Cox log- Hyphydrus japonicus larva 10.0 — —
Hydrophilidae larva — 9.1 2.2
rank test were used. In this analysis, transforming Unknown — 2.2
to the 2nd instar was regarded as censoring. Statis- Diptera
tical significance was set at 0.05. All statistical Culex mimeticus larva 10.0 — —
tests were conducted using JMP software (JMP Chironomidae larva — 9.1 —
version 7.0, SAS Institute, 2007). Trichoptera
Molanna moesta larva — — 2.2
Unknown 10.0 — 2.2
RESULTS Isopoda
Asellus hilgendorfi 20.0 — —
Prey composition of C. brevis larvae in the field
A significant positive correlation was found Total 100 100 100
between the head width of C. brevis larvae and
their prey (rs0.489, p0.001, Fig. 3). All C. bre-
vis larvae fed on insects and isopoda but did not vae also fed on the larvae of Culex mimeticus
utilize vertebrates, such as fish and anuran larvae (Diptera). On the other hand, 3rd instar fed fre-
(Table 1). The 1st and 2nd instar fed primarily on quently on Heteroptera, including mainly back-
Ephemeroptera, and Ephemeroptera and Coleoptera, swimmer (Notonecta triguttata) and Odonata
respectively, including cannibalism. First instar lar- nymphs.
Feeding Habits of Cybister brevis Larvae 451

Rearing experiment nymph treatment (Survival analysis, Mantel-Cox


From the rearing experiment, the survival rate of c 25.41, p0.02). In motionless tadpole treat-
larvae up to emergence of the 2nd instar in the tad- ment, four larvae did not bite the tadpole, and all
pole treatment (0%, n5) was significantly lower larvae died from starvation after 3.250.50
than those in the Odonata nymph treatment (100%, (meanSD) days. In contrast, four larvae in the
n16) and tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture treat- motionless Odonata nymph treatment bit Odonata
ment (93%, n14) (c 2 test by sequential Bonfer- nymphs after detecting them. All individuals be-
roni tests, c 214.7, d.f.2, p0.05, for both). The came 2nd instar after 5.500.58 days.
effects of two prey diets, Odonata nymph and the
tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture, on the develop-
ment of C. brevis larvae, were evaluated using
adult total body length. Two-way ANOVA revealed
that prey and sex effects were significant but prey-
by-sex interaction was not significant (prey: F1, 22
9.89, p0.005; sex: F1, 226.48, p0.02; prey
sex: F1, 220.28, p0.60). In both sexes, individu-
als in the Odonata nymph treatment had longer
total body length than those in the tadpole-Odonata
nymph mixture (Fig. 4a).
For the larval period, repeated-measures two-
way ANOVA revealed that sex and larval stage ef-
fects were significant but the prey, larval stage-by-
prey interaction, and larval stage-by-sex interaction
effects were not significant (prey: F1, 242.34, p
0.14; sex: F1, 245.07, p0.034; larval stage: F2, 48
3.97, p0.03; larval stageprey: F2, 480.05, p
0.95; larval stagesex: F2, 481.39, p0.26 for
log-transformed data). Differences between the two
prey treatments were not found between sexes
(Table 2). In the tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture
treatment, the number of Odonata nymphs con-
sumed was significantly more than the number of
tadpoles consumed throughout all instars (paired t-
test, 1st: t1111.00; 2nd: t1113.35; 3rd: t115.23, Fig. 4. Total body length of C. brevis adults reared in
p0.0001 for all; Fig. 4). each prey treatment (a), and the number of tadpoles and
Odonata nymphs consumed by C. brevis larvae in tadpole-
Odonata nymph mixture treatment. For the total body length
Motionless prey (a), Mix., and Odo. indicate tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture
The survival rates of C. brevis larvae differed treatment and Odonata nymph treatment, respectively. Data are
between the motionless tadpole and Odonata the meanSD. * p0.05, paired t-test.

Table 2. Larval period in each instar

Larval instar (average daysSD (range))


Treatmenta Sex
n 1st 2nd 3rd

Odonata nymph Male 7 4.710.29 (3–5) 5.430.30 (4–6) 6.100.30 (5–7)


Tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture 5 5.000.45 (4–6) 5.600.60 (4–7) 7.401.00 (5–11)
Odonata nymph Female 7 6.140.51 (5–9) 5.570.20 (5–6) 6.570.37 (5–8)
Tadpole-Odonata nymph mixture 8 5.250.25 (4–6) 5.880.44 (4–8) 6.380.50 (4–8)

a
Tadpole treatment was excluded because all 1st instar larvae died (n5).
452 S. OHBA

Ohba, 2009). The different feeding habits might be


DISCUSSION
attributable to differences in the digestive enzymes
The present study examined the feeding habits between the species, as identified previously in
of larvae of Cybister brevis. The body size of prey predatory belostomatid bugs (Swart et al., 2006).
animals increased as the larvae of C. brevis grew, In conclusion, contrary to the views expressed
as for many other predatory insects (Cloarec, 1992; in previous commentaries (e.g., Ichikawa, 1984,
Perez Goodwyn, 2001; Ohba et al., 2008). All C. 2007; Tsuzuki et al., 1999; Uchiyama, 2005), C.
brevis larvae fed on invertebrates, such as insects brevis larvae preyed mainly on invertebrate ani-
and isopoda, and did not utilize vertebrates, such as mals but did not eat vertebrate animals. These re-
fish and anuran larvae (Table 1). From a prelimi- sults strongly suggested that environments with
nary survey, there were a number of loaches, Mis- abundant aquatic invertebrates were favorable for
gurnus anguillicaudatus, and tadpoles in the study maintaining the population of C. brevis.
sites; however, no C. brevis larvae ate these verte-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
brate animals. Like another dytiscid beetles,
Ilybius, Rhantus, and Agabus (Lundkvist et al., I wish to acknowledge the valuable comments of and dis-
2003), a 1st instar C. brevis larva is a potential nat- cussion with Dr. Fusao Nakasuji, Dr. Takahisa Miyatake, Dr.
Kenji Matsuura, Dr. Hiroshi Saijo, Maya Fukushima, and
ural predator of Japanese encephalitis vector mos- Yuuki Kamite. I thank Dr. Yukiko Higa for identifying the
quito Culex tritaeniorhynchus, because 1st instar Culex larvae. I also thank the owners of the rice fields at the
larvae ate mosquito larvae, Cx. mimeticus, at this study sites who kindly permitted this field work. This study
study site. On the other hand, 2nd and 3rd instar was partly supported by a grant from the Fujifilm Green Fund.
consumed higher order insect predators in the food
REFERENCES
web, such as Odonata nymphs and backswimmers.
From the rearing experiment, all C. brevis larvae Association of Wildlife Research & EnVision (2007) Search
provided with tadpoles died. Individuals in the system of Japanese red data. http://www.jpnrdb.com/
index.html
Odonata nymph treatment had longer total body
Bay, E. C. (1974) Predator-prey relationships among aquatic
length than those in the tadpole-Odonata nymph insects. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 19: 441–453.
mixture treatment (Fig. 4a) but the larval period Berman, E. H., P. Wright and J. E. Mashke (2000) Biology
was almost the same (Table 2). In the tadpole- of Agabus disintegratus (Crotch) (Coleoptera: Dytiscidae)
Odonata nymph mixture treatment, the number of in central Georgia with a description of its mature larva.
Odonata nymphs consumed was more than the Georgia J. Sci. 58: 208–216.
Brodie, E. D. and D. R. Formanowicz (1983) Prey size pref-
number of tadpoles for all instars (Fig. 4b). Al- erence of predators: differential vulnerability of larval
though larvae of C. brevis could search for and eat anurans. Herpetologica 39: 67–75.
motionless Odonata nymphs, all larvae died from Cloarec, A. (1992) The influence of feeding on predatory
starvation after being supplied with only motion- tactics in a water bug. Physiol. Entomol. 17: 25–32.
less tadpoles. These results suggest that C. brevis Ichikawa, N. (1984) Notes on breeding water beetles. In-
sectarium 21: 60–62 (in Japanese).
larvae do not consume tadpoles not because they
Ichikawa, N. (2007) Cybister Japonicus. In Endangered
cannot capture them, but because they dislike Species of the Waterside (R. Uchiyama, ed.). YAMA-
and/or cannot recognize tadpoles as prey animals. KEI Publishers, Tokyo, pp. 51–68 (in Japanese).
Thus, larvae in the tadpole-Odonata nymph mix- Inoda, T. and S. Kamimura (2004) New open aquarium sys-
ture treatment (3 tadpoles and 3 Odonata nymphs tem to breed larvae of water beetles (Coleoptera: Dytisci-
were supplied) ate only half the amount of prey an- dae). Coleop. Bull. 58: 37–43.
Johansson, A. and A. N. Nilsson (1992) Dytiscus latissimus
imals of larvae in the Odonata nymph treatment (6 and D. circumcinctus (Coleoptera, Dytiscidae) larvae as
Odonata nymphs were supplied). This may have in- predators on three case-making caddis larvae. Hydrobi-
duced the differences in adult body length between ologia 248: 201–213.
the two treatments. Interestingly, larvae of C. bre- Juliano, S. A. (1986) Food limitation of reproduction and
vis did not eat tadpoles, although the larvae of survival for Brachinus (Coleoptera: Carabidae). Ecol-
ogy 67: 1036–1045.
large-bodied diving beetles, Dytiscus beetles and
Lenki, R. E. (1984) Food limitation and competition—a field
Cybister japonicus, feed on anuran larvae (Young, experiment with two Carabus species. J. Anim. Ecol.
1967; Brodie and Formanowicz, 1983; Johansson 53: 203–216.
and Nilsson, 1992; Inoda and Kamimura, 2004; Lundkvist, E., J. Landin, M. Jackson and C. Svensson (2003)
Feeding Habits of Cybister brevis Larvae 453

Diving beetles (Dytiscidae) as predators of mosquito lar- mane Prefecture. Jpn. J. Ecol. 51: 1–11 (in Japanese
vae (Culicidae) in field experiments and in laboratory with English summary).
tests of prey preference. Bull. Entomol. Res. 93: 219– Saijo, H. (2002) The role of loach-farming paddy on the life
226. cycle of aquatic insects inhabiting lentic habitats. Jpn.
Mori, M. and A. Kitayama (2002) Dytiscoidea of Japan. Re- J. Ecol. 52: 155–165 (in Japanese with English sum-
vised ed. Bun-ichi Sogo Shuppan, Tokyo. 232 pp. (in mary).
Japanese). SAS Institute (2007) JMP ver. 7.0. SAS Institute, Cary,
Nishihara, S., H. Karube and I. Washitani (2006) Status and NC.
conservation of diving beetles inhabiting rice paddies. Sonoda, S., M. Muraji and F. Nakasuji (1992) The effects of
Jpn. J. Conserv. Ecol. 11: 143–157 (in Japanese with diet combination on the development and fecundity of a
English summary). semi-aquatic insect, Microvelia douglasi (Heteroptera:
Ohba, S. (2008) The number of tadpoles consumed by the Veliidae). Appl. Entomol. Zool. 27: 162–164.
nymphs of the giant water bug Kirkaldyia deyrolli under Swart, C. C., L. E. Deaton and B. E. Felgenhauer (2006) The
laboratory conditions. Limnology 9: 71–73. salivary gland and salivary enzymes of the giant water-
Ohba, S. (2009) Ontogenetic dietary shift in larvae of Cybis- bugs (Heteroptera: Belostomatidae). Comp. Biochem.
ter japonicus (Coleoptera: Dytiscidae) in Japanese rice Physiol. A 145: 114–122.
fields. Environ. Entomol. 38: 856–860. Tsuzuki, Y., A. Taniwaki and T. Inoda (1999) The Perfect
Ohba, S., H. Tatsuta and F. Nakasuji (2008) Variation in the Manuals for Breeding of Aquatic Insects. Data House,
geometry of foreleg claws in sympatric giant water bug Tokyo. 223 pp. (in Japanese).
species: an adaptive trait for catching prey? Entomol. Uchiyama, R. (2005) An Illustrated Reference Book of Life
Exp. Appl. 129: 223–227. in Rice Paddy Field. YAMA-KEI Publishers, Tokyo.
Pearson, D. L. and C. B. Knisley (1985) Evidence for food 320 pp. (in Japanese).
as a limiting resource in the life cycle of tiger beetles Young, A. L. (1967) Predation in the larvae of Dytiscus mar-
(Coleoptera: Cicindelidae). Oikos 45: 161–168. ginalis Linnaeus (Coleoptera: Dytiscidae). Pan-Pacific
Perez Goodwyn, P. J. (2001) Size selective predation by Be- Entomol. 43: 113–117.
lostoma oxyurum (Heteroptera: Belostomatidae) on Aedes Zanuncio, J. C., A. J. Molina-Rugama, J. E. Serrão and D.
aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae) larvae. Rev. Soc. Entomol. Pratissoli (2001) Nymphal development and reproduc-
Argent. 60: 139–146. tion of Podisus nigrispinus (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae)
Quinn, G. P. and M. J. Keough (2002) Experimental Design fed with combinations of Tenebrio molitor (Coleoptera:
and Data Analysis for Biologists. Cambridge University Tenebrionidae) pupae and Musca domestica (Diptera:
Press, Cambridge. 537 pp. Muscidae) larvae. Biocontrol Sci. Technol. 11:
Saijo, H. (2001) Seasonal prevalence and migration of 331–337.
aquatic insects in paddies and an irrigation pond in Shi-

View publication stats

Potrebbero piacerti anche