PACINO DOES
‘MERCHANT,’ p. 17
Volume 1, Number 18 FREE
Art from the underground
The Underbelly Project, a hidden collection of street art in an abandoned Brooklyn subway station, has recently
been getting publicity — and at least 20 people sneaking in to see it have been arrested. See Page 13 for more
photos.
After Pei protests N.Y.U. plan,
supermarket site is new focus
BY ALBERT AMATEAU
After New York University
announced last week that it was with-
drawing its Landmarks Preservation
Commission application to build a
40-story fourth tower on the super-
block site of three I.M. Pei-designed
residential towers, Village neighbors
and preservation advocates were wait-
ing for the other shoe to drop.
What comes next is the N.Y.U. as-of-
right alternative to build on the northwest
corner of the superblock on the Morton
Williams supermarket site — which is
not protected by landmark designation.
Because the supermarket site has a
larger footprint, the building would be
East and West Village, Lower East Side, Soho, Noho, Little Italy and Chinatown
broader and shorter, 17 to 20 stories,
about 200 feet tall; but it would have
roughly the same total 250,000 square
feet of space proposed for the abandoned
project, which is the same square footage
of each of the three existing buildings.
Nevertheless, neighborhood and
preservation-advocacy opponents vowed
last week to fight the alternative. The
Greenwich Village Society for Historic
Preservation and the Community Action
Alliance on NYU 2031 are holding a
town hall meeting at 6:30 p.m. Wed.,
Dec. 1, in the basement hall of Our
Lady of Pompei Church, at Carmine
and Bleecker Sts., to explore the impli-
cations of the change.
145 SIXTH AVENUE • NYC 10 013 • COPYRIGHT © 2010 COMMUNITY M E D I A , L L C
November 25 - December 1, 2010
NYCHA’s repair
system is broken,
tenants charge
BY ALINE REYNOLDS
Lower Manhattan, the
world’s financial capital
where tremendous fortunes
are made and lost, is also
the site of 30 public hous-
ing developments where
low-income tenants live in
shoddy and unhealthy condi-
tions. These residents look to
the New York City Housing
Authority for much-needed
repairs to their decaying
apartments.
But NYCHA, short on
funds and, some say, inef-
fective, cannot seem to keep
up with the escalating work
orders. NYCHA promises it
is devising a master plan
to improve the repairs sys-
Photo by The Anonymous Photographer tem, but whether the new
approach will make a differ-
Tea Party’s brew
doesn’t go down
well Downtown
BY LINCOLN ANDERSON
It was the week after
the election and a longtime
reader of this newspaper,
This week, Alicia Hurley, N.Y.U. a lifetime Village resident,
vice president for government affairs called to say she was won-
and community engagement, said the dering why the paper hadn’t
university will file a uniform land use reported the results of the
review procedure, or ULURP, applica- local Downtown races. Sure,
tion next year for development on both she said, probably all the
the south Silver Towers superblock same people won, just like
where the Pei buildings are located, as usual, as they’ve been doing
well as the north Washington Square for years — but still... .
Village superblock. She was right. There
“The ULURP will also cover the weren’t any surprises —
block east of Washington Square Park and there weren’t any com-
between Waverly Place and Washington petitive races, either. Local
Place, not for a change in F.A.R. [floor Democrats faced little-
area ratio] but for retail uses,” Hurley known, token Republican
challengers, and, in each
Continued on page 11 case, solidly whupped them.
ence is yet to be seen.
Nadya Martoral, who has
lived for two decades in the
Alfred E. Smith Houses, near
the entrance to the Brooklyn
Bridge on the Lower East
Side, is unemployed and
takes care of her 11 children
on her own.
As if that were not
hard enough, she has a
host of unfixed appliances
in her apartment, some of
which jeopardize her fam-
ily’s health and darken
their mood. Floor tiles are
cracked, windows are bro-
ken, and the plaster from
her kitchen and bathroom
ceilings is falling off.
Martoral has made sev-
Continued on page 6
Local assemblymembers
coasted to re-election, with
Deborah Glick getting 87
percent of the vote, Richard
Gottfried garnering 82 per-
cent and Brian Kavanagh,
84 percent.
Sheldon Silver, the pow-
erful Assembly speaker, won
re-election uncontested.
In the state Senate, Tom
Duane took 85 percent of
ballots cast, while freshman
senator Daniel Squadron
was voted back into office
with 86 percent.
Incumbent Democrats
dominated in local congres-
sional races, as well. Veteran
Continued on page 4
2 November 25 - December 1, 2010

%ODFN)ULGD\
EHJLQVRQ
:HGQHVGD\
DW

6MM 6MM *SVZLV\[

(U`4HJ 3H*PL9\NNLK :WLJPHS
RUOHVV .)4VIPSL  P4HJ
6MM /HYK+YP]L 2QO\
(U`4HJ 2QO\ DIWHUGLVFRXQW
RUPRUH
HUKTVYL¯

(]VPK[OL)SHJR-YPKH`Y\ZO
5V]¶5V][O Photos by J.B. Nicholas

JSVZLKMVY;OHURZNP]PUN
Leaving some art behind
&
Members of the Free Art Society installed paintings and did performance art along

<
1 FRP
E. Second St. between Avenues A and B in the early hours of Nov. 8, in an effort
to brighten residents’ Monday morning. The project is part of the artists collective’s


7 UYH
ongoing effort “to reclaim public space for the people.”
6

H
V
   5 '
WHN

 

 :


7YPJLZNVVK5V]LTILY[OYV\NO[O^OPSLZ\WWSPLZSHZ[
 November 25 - December 1, 2010 3

BROADWAY PANHANDLER
Has a Gift for Cooking SCOOPY’S created such huge, 20-foot-high, bubble letters? we won-
dered. Billy Leroy, he of the antiques-and-props tent next
door, explained, “That’s a legal tag. It’s a tribute to Dash

30-50% OFF*
Enameled Cast Iron
4.5 Qt Rnd
$164.98
Sugg. Rt. $280

5.5 Qt
Rnd
NOTEBOOK Snow. They used a fire-extinguisher technique. One of Barry
McGee’s pals did it. The new mural starts tomorrow. The
artist’s name is Kenny Scharf. He is from L.A. but has been
a New Yorker since 1980.” Ah yes, Billy knows all.
Made in France $18 4.938 15
MCNALLY PULLS OUT: In September, we reported that
g. Rt. $
Sug superstar restaurateur Keith McNally was retooling his plans for SOMETHING TO SCRIE’M ABOUT : There’s more
Come in for nd a new eatery at Greenwich Ave. and W. 10th St. after neighbors good news for Ray of Ray’s Candy Store on Avenue A. He’s
Qt R
SALE prices on 7.25 4.98 objected to having a Pulino’s Cafe at the location. At the time, got his Ansul system, he’s got his lease renewal, he got his,
1
other shapes & sizes $2gg. Rt. $3
70
Su
we were hearing McNally had agreed instead to make the place well, a B+++ on his Sanitary Inspection Grade, though he’s
— the fire-gutted, former Village Paper Party Store — a more obsessed with getting an A. (Hey, two out of three ain’t bad.)
*Mfg sugg. retail, in-store only, while supplies last thru 12/31/10
upscale (read “sophisticated and subdued”) Balthazar Cafe, a Now, he’s also finally got his SCRIE, or Senior Citizen Rent
Support Your Local Family Owned Shops spinoff of his popular Soho bistro on Spring St., rather than an Increase Exemption, which means his apartment rent will drop
This Holiday Season offshoot of his new Pulino’s Bar & Pizzeria (read “younger and
65 East 8th St. (off B ’way) • 212- 966-3434 noisier”) on the Bowery. But now there’s not going to be any Continued on page 16
Mon- Sat 11-7 • Thurs ’til 8pm • Sun 11-6 offshoot, spinoff or anything else there by McNally. “McNally
has withdrawn the application and is no longer considering that
location,” Richard Stewart, vice chairperson of Community
Board 2’s S.L.A. Licensing Committee, tells us. “But I can tell
you that Carlos Suarez of Bobo restaurant [at 181 W. 10th St.]
has taken the lease and has just finalized an agreement with the
neighborhood association, and C.B. 2 has approved his applica-
tion for a beer-and-wine license.” Suarez actually initially had
the inside track on the one-story building, and even sweetened
the pot by saying he’d have a rooftop garden for use by students
from nearby P.S. 41 — but he was then bumped by McNally.
As for why McNally withdrew, Stewart said, “He claimed there
was too much community opposition, though stipulations [on
the restaurant’s operation] had been agreed on by the neighbor- Serving the West Village for 15 years
hood association.” Proprietor Eve Crenovich invites you for
IN THE HEART OF GREENWICH VILLAGE
— Recommended by Gourmet Magazine, Zagat, Crain’s NY, Playbill & The Villager — SORRY, ED: In other eatery news, we hear some action is Breakfast, Lunch, Exciting Dinners
“Gold Medal Chef of the Year”. — Chefs de Cuisine Association
“brewing” at the former Joe Jr. burger joint location at Sixth Weekend Brunch and Catering
.ORTHERNITALIAN#UISINEs#ELEBRATING/VER9EARS
Ave. and W. 12th St., specifically, that a Brazilian coffee-
69 MacDougal St. (Bet. Bleeker & Houston St.)   s   and-sandwich shop will be opening there shortly on Dec. 1.
Don’t forget our famous Cupcakes!
/PEN-ON 3AT PMsWWWVILLAMOSCONICOM
We have this information from a well-placed source, but it’s
hard to confirm, she said, because the place’s windows are
covered with newspaper. The main question is will the new
shop be able to survive the late Ed Gold’s curse — his wish
Happy that his former beloved “headquarters” remain empty for
Thanksgiving! eternity, to spite the landlord for prohibitively raising Joe Jr.’s
rent? Only time will tell.

ED PEGGED IT: Speaking of Ed Gold, at his memorial

the other week, Community Board 2 Chairperson Jo Hamilton,
in her remarks, recalled how she always dreaded his annual
“New Year’s Wishes” talking points in this newspaper — the
ones in which he astutely skewered local leaders in a sort of Home of the NFL Sunday Ticket,
written roast. She said in one such year’s-end column a few
years ago, Gold pointedly penned that she should “sit down
College Football, Premier League
and have lunch with Andrew Berman.” Remarked Hamilton Soccer, MLB Playoffs + World Series
with a smile, “I’m still waiting for that phone call.” Translation: Private Party Room avail. / happy hour 4 -7 Mon. - Fri.
Hamilton and the Greenwich Village Society for Historic 63 Carmine St., Greenwich Village.
Preservation director need to mend some serious fences. Tel. 212 - 414 - 1223 • www.MrDennehys.com
Berman wasn’t at Gold’s memorial, since G.V.S.H.P. had pre-
viously scheduled for the same time an open-house loft tour
of the Westbeth Artists Residence, at which 23 artists’ apart-
ments, along with Westbeth’s public spaces, were on view. Told
 'R\RXQHHGD1DQQ\
of Hamilton’s comments, Berman responded it was the first %DE\1XUVH
he’d heard them. “Not having heard it firsthand, I don’t have a
comment on it,” he said. “But I think one should really focus on +RXVHNHHSHURU
remembering Ed when talking about his memorial service, and +RPH+HDOWK$LGH"
not any extraneous issues.” So, we asked, will he call her? He’s
not telling — at least not us. “Since I didn’t hear this comment, :HKDYHWKHSURIHVVLRQDOIRU\RX
it would be inappropriate to respond in the press,” he said.
x/LYH,Q/LYH2XW
EVER-EVOLVING WALL: Passing by the “graffiti wall” x)XOO7LPH3DUW7LPH
on East Houston St. by the Bowery on Tuesday we did a
double take when we saw it apparently had been “bombed”
x&DULQJDQGKLJKO\VNLOOHG
by taggers yet again, now covered with giant silver bubble OLFHQVHGDQGERQGHG
letters. (Just last week we had a photo of the wall on the
East Villager’s front page when it was still covered with
Barry McGee’s piece of scores of legendary graffitists’ tags
3ULQFH$JHQF\
written in red.) More to the point, how could a tagger have 3ULQFH(PSOR\PHQW#DROFRP
4 November 25 - December 1, 2010
+DUU\+DQVRQ
 #


Downtown likes its Dems,

 not ‘Tea’; Incumbents coast
Continued from page 1
Congressmember Carolyn Maloney — after
fending off a tough primary challenge by East
Villager Reshma Saujani — was returned to
Washington with 75 percent of the vote,
the same percentage that Congressmember
Jerrold Nadler got. Topping them both, how-
ever, was Congressmember Nydia Velazquez,
who won re-election with a whopping 93
percent of the vote.
In short, the “Tea Party revolution” defi-
nitely did not take hold Downtown, as the
Republicans, as usual, went down to defeat
again.
“I think we are very fortunate to have a
very well-informed and involved constitu-
ency that has the capacity to express concern
and disagreements in a rational and thought-
ful manner,” observed Glick. “Therefore,
it is not a surprise to me that the hysteria
fomented by the Tea Party did not find fertile
ground [here].
“My somewhat partisan view,” Glick con-
tinued, “is that the Republican Party has
not offered up programs or ideas that are
broadly supportive of people, and have gen-
erally sat back and said, ‘No.’ The Tea Party
+$1621
DGYHUWRULDO
had people saying, ‘I don’t want government
$W+DQVRQ)LWQHVVWKHDJLQJSURFHVVLV
to touch my Medicare’ — totally uninformed
EHLQJVORZHGGRZQ1HVWOHGULJKWLQ\RXU
RQILWQHVV
and stupid. The Democratic Party, histori-
EDFN\DUGWKHHLJKWKZRQGHURIWKHZRUOG cally, is the party that offered support for
LVWKULYLQJLQ7KH:HVW9LOODJH middle-class and working-class people, since
the days of Franklin Roosevelt.
:DONRQ3HUU\6WUHHWDQG\RXFRXOGPLVVLW7KLVXQGLVFRYHUHGJHPLV
“The Tea Party’s message was that they
WKH SODFH ZKHUH 1HZ <RUNHUV RYHU  FUHDWH LQGLYLGXDO OLIHVW\OHV WR were very angry. They wanted smaller govern-
HQMR\OLIHWRWKHIXOOHVW ment and fewer taxes,” Glick noted. “Where
+DQVRQ )LWQHVV LV D VLPSOH VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG \HW KLJKO\ HIIHFWLYH the Republicans won they were marginally
H[HUFLVH GLHW DQG PRWLYDWLRQDO SURJUDP  7KH +DQVRQ )LWQHVV PRGHO Democratic areas.” In some of these cases,
Democrats had won these seats in 2008 in
HGXFDWHV DQG PRWLYDWHV \RX WR H[HUFLVH VDIHO\ SURGXFWLYHO\ DQG
areas that were typically Republican.
IUHTXHQWO\HQRXJKWRORVHIDWVWUHQJWKHQPXVFOHVDQG³VFXOSW´WKHERG\ Glick, who represents Greenwich Village,
WRDOHDQHUKHDOWKLHUDQG\RXQJHUORRNLQJERG\,WVWULYHVWRPDNHWKH has been in the Assembly 20 years, which
SDLQSDLQOHVVDQGWKHH[HUFLVHVXVHUIULHQGO\ might seem like a pretty long time. However,
+DQVRQ )LWQHVV KHOSV \RX ZRUN \RXU OLIH QRW \RXU OLIH LQWR H[HUFLVH Gottfried, who was elected when he was a
23-year-old Columbia law student, has held
1RERG\LVWRRRXWRIVKDSHWRPDNHWKHQHFHVVDU\FKDQJHVWRLPSURYH
his Chelsea seat for 40 years — an Assembly
ILWQHVV DQG VHOIHVWHHP  7ZR PDMRU FRPSRQHQWV RI +DQVRQ )LWQHVV¶
record.
VXFFHVVDUHHQFRXUDJHPHQWDQGYDULHW\7KHYDOXHRIHQFRXUDJHPHQW “Staggering,” Glick noted of Gottfried’s
FDQQRW EH RYHUHVWLPDWHG  $QG YDU\LQJ H[HUFLVH URXWLQHV W\SH longevity. She said her colleague’s record is
Club,” he noted, adding he did later go to
the Sheraton Hotel where the statewide
Democratic candidates convened after their
wins.
Gottfried hasn’t faced a Democratic pri-
mary challenger since ’92.
He said he knew very little about his
Republican candidate in this past race and
had never met him.
“I did know who he is. His name is
Michael Chan — from Hong Kong,”
Gottfried offered.
“In my area, almost anyone running
on the Democratic line would be a strong
candidate,” he added. “I think the fact that
Manhattan Democratic officials rarely have
primaries and rarely have election contests
is a testament to the fact that Manhattan
residents are very vocal and active and keep
their legislators on their toes. A candidate
that is up to that is going to be a strong
candidate. Being held to that standard keeps
‘“A politician loyal to a
party cannot be trusted.”’
Randy Credico
(quoting Charles Sumner)
you in good shape.
“I think Manhattan residents have
very solid, progressive values by and
large,” Gottfried noted. “I think the eco-
nomic and social diversity of Manhattan
has to do with that. There’s also a cer-
tain amount of self-selection — most
Manhattanites chose to come here and
live, or chose to stay here and live. If you
live in New York City, you see on a daily
basis how important government is in our
lives — from mass transit and hospitals to
educational institutions.”
Not surprisingly, Gottfried is not a believ-
er in term limits for state legislators.
UHSHWLWLRQ DQGRU LQWHQVLW\ ZLOO NHHS \RX PRWLYDWHG LQWHUHVWHG DQG LQ not at risk from her, noting, “I can say one
DFWLRQ thing for sure — 20 years from now, I will
not be in the Assembly.”
6SHFLDO2IIHUIRU5HDGHUVRI
2))
Gottfried said his margin of victory in
7KH9LOODJHUDQG7KH(DVW9LOODJHU this year’s race, 82 percent, equals what he
got in 2008, and that it’s his all-time high
RQWKHILUVWZRUNRXWIRU)LUVW7LPH8VHUV
for whenever he’s faced a Republican can-
“I think term limits ought to be in the
hands of voters every two years,” he said,
referring to the length of state legislators’
terms and the power of constituents to vote
them in or out of office.
Asked for comment on his own re-election
and Democrats’ firm hold on Downtown

+$1621),71(66
didate. So, “at 40,” he’s the strongest he’s Manhattan, Silver said, “New Yorkers are
ever been. progressive to the core. Whether it’s protect-
“I’m quite happy,” he said of his win. ing affordable housing, expanding access
“I really get an enormous amount of sat- to healthcare or fighting for civil rights, I

QG isfaction out of my work. I’m just always believe that government has a real role to
:HVW9LOODJH3HUU\6W± )O1<&  delighted when I’m rehired.” play in making people’s lives better.”
WK
6R+R*UHHQH6W± )O1<&  Gottfried is long past celebrating his Asked if he was concerned about some
QG
8QLRQ6TXDUH%URDGZD\± )O1<&  now-routine Election Day romps with post- early rumors that Governor-elect Andrew
 election parties and bubbly. Cuomo might be angling to stage a coup
+DQVRQ)LWQHVVȓYHUL]RQQHW_ZZZ+DQVRQ)LWQHVVFRP “I had a slice of pizza and a glass of Diet
Coke at the Chelsea Reform Democratic Continued on page 16
 November 25 - December 1, 2010 5

Shop The East Village

For Info contact Francesco Regini at 646-452-2496 or Francesco@thevillager.com

GET YOUR DOG READY FOR WINTER

Mid
Certified All Breed Century
Dog Grooming
Furnishings
Keeping EV/LES
beautiful since 1993
by appointment only Shop
Where The
304 East 5th Street, New York, NY 10003 • 212-598-5956 Dealers Do
FREE TOOTH BRUSHING WITH THIS AD www.whitetrashnyc.com

 



  Five Star Parking @ Waterside Plaza
—JeTcfCTa\a\f
2500 FDR Drive - East 3rd Street Service Road
—FT_TW5Te—6bĺXX5Te
24HourMonthly NewAccountsOnly
—@XW\gXeTa\TaC_TggXef
FTiX$#balbhe6TgXe\aZbeZebhcbeWXej\g[g[\fTW



 
 
 

 


$
250
PerMonthͲ18.375%TaxIncluded

OfferValidforFirst6Months



  

Park&LockOnly Call Now to
CallNowto
%$% %)# )#'# 


 

CCTVThroughoutGarage ReserveaSpace
Robin, Wanda & Francis
%$% %)# )##+ 



 On-Site Management to Serve Your Parking Needs NoSUVSurcharge(6'2"Clearance) (212)340Ͳ4228













SO-HAIR
“Expert staff pays special
"-
0*

.#

 

/+&
0
'(+"'& attention to the client... ect.”
/$$&+
"&) )+&
()()+"'& - NY Magazine



















 

 
304 E 5th Street (bet. 2nd Ave & 1st Ave)
Bellevue South Nursery School
New York, New York 10003

+)*"
$1

+!
*+)+
&
+!

)"- Finest Salon
...*&,)*)0*!''$') (212) 226-9222 in the East
$$



 
Village
')
%"$
*&* '$'%
')
%')
"&')%+"'& Monday - Saturday 11:30am - 7:30pm

FINELINE
TATTOO NYC
The Longest Continually Running
Tattoo Shop In Manhattan
21 FIRST AVENUE, NYC 10003
Phone: (212) 673-5154
www.finelinetattoo.com
6 November 25 - December 1, 2010

The Housing Authority’s repair system is broken,

Continued from page 1
eral repair requests to NYCHA, to no avail.
“I call and say, ‘Listen, I need this… ’
They give [ticket numbers] to me, and they
never come over here.”
Most recently, a NYCHA operator sched-
uled a repair for Sept. 23. Martoral said she
waited all day, but no one came.
“I feel like that’s abuse, because I can’t
live like that. I understand I owe money,” she
said in broken English. “But they have to do
the job in housing, too.”
Her daughter Jubilee Domenech, 16,
recently injured the nails on her big toes
on broken floor tiles on the entryway to the
bathroom. She was forced to give up her
spot on her high-school basketball team
this fall because, she said, it’s too painful
to play.
“I can’t play no more until my toenails
come off,” she said.
Jubilee visited the doctor the day of the
accident, but she was too scared to go back
and get her nails removed. Her goal of earn-
ing a basketball scholarship at a state univer-
sity is now on the line.
“My toes are bothering me,” she said,
“and they’re making me think twice about
what I want to do.”
The apartment’s cracked floor may pose
other health problems, as well. Dr. Warren
Licht, chief medical officer at Downtown
Hospital, said asbestos could still be pres-
ent in the floors of older NYCHA buildings,
such as Smith Houses, which was built in
1953.
“It’s usually found in floors and hallways,”
Licht said. “The more you are exposed to it,
the more likely you are to get lung cancer 20
years from now.”
Only days after Jubilee hurt herself on
the tiles, a broken window in one of the
bedrooms fell forward onto her arm.
“I got up to look at my sister’s closet, and
the whole window came off on my arm,” she
explained.
A handyman showed up a few days later
to repair the window, but didn’t finish the
job.
“He was here for 10 minutes, tops,” she
said. “He just left this piece here with a
bunch of screws.”
The window is still broken.
“Don’t touch it,” her mother warned
Jubilee, fearful that it could hurt her daugh-
ter’s arm again.
The pipes above the toilet leak intermit-
tently, causing water and plaster to rain
down.
“When we flush the toilet, it goes crazy,”
Martoral said.
She has filed a complaint for that, too,
but doesn’t have a scheduled appointment.
Jubilee, in the meantime, wears a sweater Photo by Aline Reynolds
Alfred E. Smith Houses tenant Nadya Martoral showed her work-order list — with
Continued on page 7 about 10 pending items — for her apartment.

STATE SENATOR NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLY SPEAKER COUNCIL MEMBER

DANIEL SQUADRON SHELDON SILVER MARGARET CHIN

and THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK

invite you to a

CUNY COLLEGE
INFORMATION FAIR
FOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS, COLLEGE STUDENTS, ADULT LEARNERS

SEWARD PARK EDUCATIONAL CAMPUS | 350 GRAND ST. (LUDLOW STREET) | MANHATTAN

SUNDAY DECEMBER 5, 2010 11 A.M. - 2 P.M. REFRESHMENTS WILL BE SERVED

 November 25 - December 1, 2010 7

say frustrated tenants

Continued from page 6
in the house to protect her arms against the
falling plaster.
Aixa Torres, president of the Smith
Houses Tenant Association, established a
grievance committee last spring to document
tenants’ complaints and to assist those who
don’t speak English. Earlier this month, she
conducted a training session to teach resi-
dents how to set up an appointment through
NYCHA’s Centralized Call Center.
Torres is fed up with the repairs system,
which she said is proving futile. Based on
the repairs schedule, her ceiling fan isn’t sup-
But the renovations will not come anytime
soon.
In the meantime, they face health risks.
According to Dr. Licht, “Mold has spores,
and spores act as allergens,” often leading to
asthma and other respiratory conditions.
As a short-term fix, Cody sprays her walls
with Lysol, putting a towel over her nose to
avoid inhaling the mold.
“I run out of the bathroom and close the
door, so when I go back inside all those black
mold spots are off the wall and the ceiling,”
she said.
Long-term inhalation of mold can lead
to an inflammation of the lungs, according
to the National Institute of Health. Indeed,

HOLIDAY
posed to be fixed for two years. Cody reported that her allergies have gotten
“I’m just, like, done with them,” she said. progressively worse over the years.
“If we have to do litigation, we’re going to “I’ve taken more allergy medicine this

go that route.”
Dorothea Cody, her husband, Roland,
and their seven children have lived since
2003 in the Rutgers Houses development
on the Lower East Side, just north of the
Manhattan Bridge. Their crumbling bath-
room causes constant leaks in the apartment
next door, occupied by the elderly Mrs.
Chen.
“She gets flooded every time we take a
shower.” Cody said. “After we shower, she’s
mopping up a quart of water.”
Chen wasn’t available for comment, but
Cody described her neighbor’s conditions:
“The wall is so damp, it feels like cardboard.
All of the tile on her floor is up — it’s not
puckering, it’s up. And her hallway wall is
tilting forward. She just had new tiles laid
again. It looks horrible.”
The Codys have their own maintenance
problems to deal with. Moldy plaster from
the ceiling and walls falls on them when they
flush the toilet in their main bathroom.
“There’s a busted pipe in the wall — they
constantly fix the bricks over and over, and
get the same result in less than six months,”
she said.
NYCHA has visited three or four times
since the spring.
“They come in and have a look and they
say, ‘Oh, that’s the plasterer’s job,’ ” she said.
“And it’s never done.”
“The unions have rules the workers have
to abide by, so they can’t always call in a
plumber and then a plasterer in the right
order,” explained Victor Bach, a policy ana-
lyst with the Community Service Society, a
nonprofit advocacy and research organiza-
tion for low-income New Yorkers.
According to the Codys, there was a time
when NYCHA’s repair system was more
efficient.
“If they came in and saw what needed
to be done, it was fixed right away,” said
Dorothea Cody. “Now, when you call, they
contradict one another. No one is consis-
tent.”
Finally, an inspector from the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban
Development, which has a role in regular
oversight of all NYCHA properties, visited
the site a few weeks ago.
“They said the mildew conditions were
unsafe, and we put in an order,” Cody said.
HAPPENINGS
year than any year ever,” she said, noting
‘I’m just, like, done with
them. If we have to do
litigation, we’ll go that
route.’
Aixa Torres
that it’s the first year she has taken prescrip-
tion drugs for her symptoms.
The Codys had another appointment with
NYCHA for plastering scheduled for Nov.
15, but they feared it would just be another
temporary fix, if that. Getting the affected
area painted will be a much longer wait, with
a date scheduled for sometime in 2013.
By now, Cody and her family’s patience
has been pushed to the limit.
“I pay too much rent for my bathroom
to be looking like this, for so many years,”
Cody said.
In NYCHA’s Seward Park Extension, just
south of the Williamsburg Bridge approach
ramp, Mary Sing, 89, lives in an apartment
that is filled with dust. But that’s the least of
her problems. Part of her living-room wall
is ripped wide open, exposing the building’s
rotting interior.
“They were supposed to fix it,” said her
daughter, Mattie Luther, 70, whose full-time
occupation is taking care of her mother.
“The minute they fixed it, it started cracking
— and they left it like that.”
The mother and daughter got so frus-
trated they called 311, which directed them
back to NYCHA’s call center.
Sing has nightmares of the ceiling caving
in on her. She constantly spits into a bucket
to get rid of phlegm that collects in her
mouth and throat.
“She’s been doing that for four years, since
I’ve been here,” Luther said.
A few months ago, Luther herself was diag-
nosed with a throat infection.
Continued on page 8
Holiday Toy Drive
M O N DAY, D E C E M B E R 6 , 2 0 1 0
U N T I L T H U R S DAY, D E C E M B E R 1 6 , 2 0 1 0
NYU’s Office of Government and Community Affairs and the Administrative
Management Council are collecting new, unwrapped toys to be donated to
over 1,500 children from the Lower East Side. If you would like to make
a donation, please call the Office of Government and Community Affairs
at 212.998.2400. Your gift will be distributed at the 9th Precinct Community
Council Holiday Party.
Washington Square Park Tree Lighting
T U E S DAY, D E C E M B E R 7, 2 0 1 0 AT 6 : 0 0 P M
Gather by the arch in Washington Square Park for the annual lighting of
the Christmas tree. Sing Christmas carols along with song leader Mary
Hurlbut accompanied by the Rob Susman Brass Quartet and await a special
visit from Santa! The Washington Square Association will provide compli-
mentary songbooks.
Washington Square Music Festival Holiday Concert
F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 8 , 2 0 1 0 AT 8 : 0 0 P M
St. Joseph’s Roman Catholic Church, 371 Sixth Avenue
Don’t miss this free holiday concert directed by Lutz Rath and featuring
guest artists Stanley Drucker and Naomi Drucker, clarinetists.
Winter Choral Concert
F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 1 7, 2 0 1 0 AT 7 : 3 0 P M
Frederick Loewe Theatre, 35 West Fourth Street
Mark your calendar for this annual Winter Choral Concert presented by
Music and Performing Arts at NYU Steinhardt. For more information
and ticket reservations, pelase call 212.352.3101 or visit www.nyu.edu/
ticketcentral/calendar. Admission is $10 general; $5 students and seniors.
Christmas Eve Caroling in Washington Square Park
F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 2 4 , 2 0 1 0 AT 5 : 0 0 P M
Meet by the arch in Washington Square Park for caroling on Christmas Eve!
The Rob Susman Brass Quartet will lead revelers in singing holiday favorites.
The Washington Square Association will provide complimentary songbooks.
NYU’s Office of Government and Community Affairs
212.998.2400 • community.affairs@nyu.edu • www.nyu.edu/ogca
8 November 25 - December 1, 2010

New repair call center comes under fire; Lack of

Continued from page 7
“There was nothing wrong with my throat
until I came here,” she said, suspecting it is
related to the conditions.
Eliana Colon, another Seward Park
Extension resident, won’t step foot into her
kitchen, sickened by a putrid smell coming
from a gaping hole above the cabinets. The
stench comes from mold caused by a leak that
has persisted for months.
Eliana’s son Alfredo, who often stays over-
night to care for her, said, “We called [the
emergency hotline]. The first time they came,
they make a little hole to investigate the leak.”
That was last February.
Another handyman visited in June, making
an even bigger hole in an attempt to stop the
dripping.
“The guy took a look and said, ‘Oh my
God’ — then he went upstairs and never came
back,” Alfredo said.
Fungus is now growing in the cabinets, and
the wall below it is soaked in water, making
cooking in the kitchen no longer an option.
“I have to buy takeout food for her,”
Alfredo said.
The Colons’ next repair appointment is
scheduled for June 2011. In the meantime,
Eliana is considering withholding rent as she
and her son continue to endure the horrible
odor that pervades the apartment.
“She can’t breathe with the smell some-
The floor tiles in Nadya Martoral’s kitchen, above, and hallway in the Smith Houses
have been in disrepair for years, despite her pleas to NYCHA for repairs.
times,” Alfredo said of his mother, who has
been hospitalized for asthma.
“Anything that stays damp creates an
environment for mold to grow,” Dr. Licht
said. “People who are affected most are the
Photo by Aline Reynolds
very young and the very old, and people
who already have a diagnosis of asthma.”
According to NYCHA, a lack of funding
is a major problem, affecting the agency’s
ability to keep up with repairs on its 344
developments throughout the city.
Annual underfunding “adds to our
structural deficit and hampers the author-
ity’s ability to meet the maintenance needs
of our aging housing stock,” explained
Michael Kelly, NYCHA’s general manager,
at a recent public hearing.
In 2005, the Housing Authority antici-
pated a $7.5 billion need for apartment
repairs. Today, however, only one-fifth of
those funds is available — not nearly
enough for the thousands of work orders
the agency receives each year. Since 2005,
repair requests have continued to soar,
reaching 250,000 last year, while NYCHA’s
budget was further battered by the reces-
sion. The authority currently has a backlog
of 107,000 work orders, some of which are
scheduled for 2012 and 2013.
Tenant advocates, such as Judith
Goldiner, supervising attorney at the Legal
Aid Society, also believe the problem is
compounded by NYCHA’s mismanagement
of the funds it does have. The authority is
spending excessively on job training, social
services and sanitation, Goldiner said, while
neglecting fundamental maintenance of the
developments.
“They’re required to provide decent
housing. All the rest of it is kind of window
dressing,” said Goldiner. “There’s a lot of
ways that they could save money in their
Continued on page 9

There’s so much you want to see

Your daughter’s wedding
Your son’s children
Tonight’s sunset

Your eyes are a precious gift.

Don’t trust their care to just anyone.

Dr Grace Sun provides comprehensive ophthalmic services at New York Downtown Hospital in
Lower Manhattan.
Her specialties include the medical and surgical care of the eye: comprehensive/general eye care, cataract,
cataract surgery, glaucoma, diabetic eye disease, corneal disease, blurry vision/decreased vision, dry eyes,
red eye, and conjunctivitis.
As a member of Weill Cornell Eye Associates, Dr. Sun offers a range of ophthalmic services including
complex cornea and external disease, retinal and vitreous disorders, glaucoma, pediatric ophthalmology,
oculoplastics, and neuro-ophthalmology. Dr. Sun is on the faculty of Weill Cornell Medical College.
Dr. Sun is fluent in English, Mandarin Chinese and Spanish.
To schedule an appointment with Dr. Sun, please call (212) 312-5250.

New York Downtown Hospital – closer to you!

8 3 Gold Stre e t,, Ne w Yor k , NY 1 0 0 3 8
T e le phone : (2 1 2 ) 3 1 2 - 5 0 0 0
w w w.do wntownho s pital.or g

funds is biggest problem
Continued from page 8
budget and redirect it toward what really
needs to happen here.”
Kelly announced at the hearing that
NYCHA is trying to do just that: He said
the agency is looking into re-appropriating
$7 million in capital funds for repairs and
re-evaluating its capital program.
But it can be a vicious cycle: The less
the authority invests on its developments’
aging infrastructure, the greater the need
for individual repairs.
“The serious repair needs are coming
from the backlog of unmet capital improve-
ments,” explained Victor Bach, a housing
policy analyst at the Community Service
Society. “With that kind of backlog, you
have accelerated deterioration.”
In 2005 NYCHA created a centralized
call center to streamline repair services
across the city. The center operates from 6
a.m. to midnight on weekdays and has an
electronic ticketing system that schedules
repairs based on urgency.
Major emergencies, such as gas leaks,
elevator outages or floods, are typically
attended to within 48 hours. But the tenant
still has to schedule a follow-up appoint-
ment through the call center for patch-
up work on the walls or for a floor job.
Residents of several Lower East Side devel-
opments believe the system is inefficient.
“They just pass the buck from one work-
er to another, and nothing ever gets done,”
said Rutgers Houses tenant Dorothea Cody,
who has had a leak in her bathroom for
years.
Tenants at Smith Houses and the other
Lower East Side developments are filling
out report cards that ask them to assess
NYCHA’s operations. So far, the call center
has received an “F” for timeliness and a “C”
for overall reliability.
A shortage of union tradesmen is also
making the situation worse. The total num-
ber of painters, carpenters and plasterers
available to NYCHA dropped from 805
in 2005 to 765 this year, according to a
NYCHA report obtained by this newspa-
per.
Meanwhile, the number of individual
lawsuits against NYCHA over repairs has
escalated in the last six months, according
to the Legal Aid Society. And some tenants
are withholding rent, or threatening to do
so, until NYCHA fixes their apartments
— which could jeopardize their housing
status.
“It’s a dangerous situation because when
you do that, you really risk getting evicted,
and you also risk being blacklisted” by
BIG FUN! SMALL BUCKS!
Sun. $3.50 Screwdrivers & our famous Bloody Mary’s,
Neighborhood
$2.50 Miller Lite Drafts & Bud Bottles
Fusion! Mon. $4 Mojito’s all flavors Tues. $2 Margarita’s
CHEAP-EEZ COCKTAILS (except Fri. & Sat.) - Coors & Pabst Cans $3,
Rootbeer Floats $3, Sloe Gin Fizz $2, Tom Collins $3,
“One of the 63 best bars
in NYC” — Time Out, 2009 Whiskey Sours $3, Rum Lime Ricky $3
281 W 12th St @ 4th St. NYC 212-243-9041
November 25 - December 1, 2010 9
landlords outside of NYCHA, Goldiner
explained.
Last March, NYCHA got a welcome
infusion of roughly $1 billion from
President Obama’s American Recovery and
Reinvestment Act of 2009 that, starting this
fall, is being distributed to the developments
for basic repairs over the next 15 years. The
authority also received a separate allocation
of $423 million from the U.S. Department
of Housing and Development for capital
expenses, including elevator repairs, boiler
replacements and energy efficiency projects
in developments across the five boroughs.
Now, each development will get its
slice of the stimulus money since 21 devel-
HOLIDAY
opments, previously owned and operated
by the city and state, including Rutgers
Houses, were federalized earlier this year.
‘NYCHA has been plagued
by underfunding, poor
HAPPENINGS
Holiday Toy Drive
M O N DAY, D E C E M B E R 6 , 2 0 1 0
management and lack U N T I L T H U R S DAY, D E C E M B E R 1 6 , 2 0 1 0
of political will.’ NYU’s Office of Government and Community Affairs and the Administrative
Management Council are collecting new, unwrapped toys to be donated to
over 1,500 children from the Lower East Side. If you would like to make
Daniel Squadron
a donation, please call the Office of Government and Community Affairs
at 212.998.2400. Your gift will be distributed at the 9th Precinct Community
Council Holiday Party.
“All developments were hurting before,
Washington Square Park Tree Lighting
because there was less money for each
T U E S DAY, D E C E M B E R 7, 2 0 1 0 AT 6 : 0 0 P M
development,” explained state Senator
Daniel Squadron. Gather by the arch in Washington Square Park for the annual lighting of
But the stimulus alone may not be the the Christmas tree. Sing Christmas carols along with song leader Mary
final fix, according to Squadron, who co- Hurlbut accompanied by the Rob Susman Brass Quartet and await a special
launched the campaign for federal support visit from Santa! The Washington Square Association will provide compli-
and has been working with the tenant asso- mentary songbooks.
ciations of the various Downtown develop-
ments to expedite repairs. Washington Square Music Festival Holiday Concert
“The easy solution is always money,” F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 8 , 2 0 1 0 AT 8 : 0 0 P M
Squadron said. “But money is never enough. St. Joseph’s Roman Catholic Church, 371 Sixth Avenue
NYCHA has been plagued by three chal-
Don’t miss this free holiday concert directed by Lutz Rath and featuring
lenges: underfunding, poor management
guest artists Stanley Drucker and Naomi Drucker, clarinetists.
and a lack of political will.”
Kelly reported at the hearing that
NYCHA is making a major effort to fix the
Winter Choral Concert
repair system. The authority is working on F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 1 7, 2 0 1 0 AT 7 : 3 0 P M
a comprehensive, five-year strategic plan Frederick Loewe Theatre, 35 West Fourth Street
to preserve public housing that will “serve Mark your calendar for this annual Winter Choral Concert presented by
as a vital road map for addressing our cur- Music and Performing Arts at NYU Steinhardt. For more information
rent maintenance and repair backlog,” he and ticket reservations, pelase call 212.352.3101 or visit www.nyu.edu/
said. The plan will be released sometime ticketcentral/calendar. Admission is $10 general; $5 students and seniors.
next year, according to Sheila Stainback, a
NYCHA spokesperson. Christmas Eve Caroling in Washington Square Park
Until then, many residents could remain F R I DAY, D E C E M B E R 2 4 , 2 0 1 0 AT 5 : 0 0 P M
frustrated and exposed daily to health haz-
Meet by the arch in Washington Square Park for caroling on Christmas Eve!
ards in their apartments.
The Rob Susman Brass Quartet will lead revelers in singing holiday favorites.
The Washington Square Association will provide complimentary songbooks.
NYU’s Office of Government and Community Affairs
212.998.2400 • community.affairs@nyu.edu • www.nyu.edu/ogca
10 November 25 - December 1, 2010
N.Y.U.’s towering blunder inspires us to fight on
TALKING POINT
BY MIRIAM KAPLAN
I want to say that this statement from
Mr. Pei is extraordinary good news. Not just
because New York University has been defeat-
ed on the landmarks issue. But more impor-
tantly, because it shows how completely N.Y.U.
miscalculated in this regard.
In all of our statements at the Community
Board 2 hearings, we danced around the rea-
sons for objecting to the fourth tower. We were
addressing many important issues — in truth,
not so clearly and starkly as the statement from
Henry Cobb does — but we were on target.
And yet N.Y.U. couldn’t or wouldn’t hear
the message.
With all their high-priced consultants
— architects and lawyers — they couldn’t
see how wrong they were about the overall
design of the block. And they substituted all
that foolish talk about dialogue for a true
recognition of the spatial relations.
And in that is a great hope to take us for-
ward. Just as N.Y.U. was blind with regard
to aesthetics, they are blind to the intent of
zoning. And it is that blindness that will defeat
them in the end.
So far, it doesn’t look like we will have
someone like Pei to come forward on a white
charger in the coming battle — though who
knows what may happen?
In the meantime, we move on with the con-
Christmas
S S :
CHEDULE OF ERVICES
December 24
5:00PM - Vigil Mass for Christmas
December 25 - Christmas
12 MIDNIGHT - Mass of the Nativity preceded
Christmas carols begin at 11:30pm
9:00AM - Mass of
the Nativity
11:00AM - Mass of
the Nativity
fidence that we do see things more clearly than
N.Y.U. does; and with the sure knowledge that
these high-priced lawyers and architects are
really only hired to see to the accomplishment
of the will of those that hire them, and not to
defer to excellence where it exists.
I have been studying the history of N.Y.U.
this week: For the university campus and for
several buildings around the square they had
the services of Stanford White; for Bobst they
had Philip Johnson; for the south superblock
they had I.M. Pei — all of them great architects,
who had a vision about what the architectural
face of a great university should be and who
had a tabula rasa on which to work.
For Plan 2031, N.Y.U.’s biggest redesign
effort — probably since its former University
Heights campus in the Bronx — the architects
were constrained to work within an existing
context. N.Y.U. hired big guns. But an existing
context is not a proper arena for great archi-
tects who have their own vision and ego.
What N.Y.U. got was a plan that clashed as
badly as plaid with floral print.
What was needed were not-so-great archi-
tects — people who could subsume their ego
and come up with a design for new buildings
that integrated with the existing landscape.
That the architects could not see the ugliness
of their plans (not just the Pei block, but even
more so the Washington Square Village block)
is a serious mark against them, no matter how
high their ratings. That no one at N.Y.U. could
see the ugliness of the plans and reject them on
ST. ANTHONY CHURCH
154 Sullivan Street
New York, NY 10012
(212) 777-2755
www.stanthonynyc.org
that basis alone, reflects the fact that no one at
N.Y.U. has any aesthetic sense nor any basis on
which to execute good judgment.
Absolutely everything about Plan
2031 shows poor judgment: the sought-
after rezoning to C6-2; putting retail
on Mercer St. when there is plenty
Everything about Plan
2031 shows poor
judgment.
of retail one block away on Broadway; hous-
ing 1,400 students in a dormitory on a block
that has about 500 apartments; increasing
the underground acreage, even though there
is a stream that runs under the two blocks;
eliminating the driveways on the Washington
Square Village block, which would isolate
the two slabs from each other, but more
importantly would curtail the accessibility of
ambulances, school buses, deliveries and so forth
to each of the complex’s buildings; putting retail
in the ground floor of the Washington Square
Village buildings, which would totally destroy
their residential nature; installing academic
buildings and a public mall between the two
New school with British accent
BY ALBERT AMATEAU
A new private elementary school for chil-
dren 3 to 11 years old, World Class Learning
Academy, an affiliate of British Schools of
America, is opening next year in the East
Village at E. Second St. at Second Ave., in
the former LaSalle Academy.
The school is enrolling 3-year-olds for
its nursery school, opening in January 2011,
and is accepting applications for children
ages up to 11 for the rest of the school,
which will open in September, said John
Taylor, headmaster.
“We are the only school in the city to offer
the International Primary Curriculum —
based on the numeracy and literacy program
of the English National Curriculum,” Taylor
said. The English National Curriculum is the
standard primary-school curriculum in the
United Kingdom, Taylor explained.
The English connection goes further.
“We have royal patronage,” Taylor said,
Art for Haiti raised $30,000
Last month’s Tribeca art auction for
Haiti raised more than $30,000 to help
rebuild Children Harvest School in Port
au Prince, Haiti. More than 70 contem-
porary and Haitian artists donated works
to the auction, which was held Oct. 20 at
Manhattan Youth Downtown Community
Washington Square Village slabs, which would
absolutely destroy any sense of common com-
munity; closing the garage on the Washington
Square Village block and replacing it with
parking on the Pei block, with no mention of
how Washington Square Village’s residents
are to get from the garage to their buildings
— even if an entrance were to be provided on
Bleecker St., there would still be a minimum of
the equivalent of a three-block walk in the open
from the garage to 1 and 2 Washington Square
Village.
That top-class architects would sign off on
such a design — which effectively destroys
an existing residential community that pro-
vides some blessed open space in an open-
space-starved part of the city — just to sat-
isfy the expansionist plans of N.Y.U. reflects
poorly on them. They may be world-class
but their behavior is that of hacks who go along
with anything just to get the commission.
Getting back to Cobb’s statement:
Just because we have this good news,
we cannot relax. But we can go for-
ward, in the full confidence that an army
is going to form behind us. Because I certainly
believe that people will come out from the
woodwork to support us — now that they
have the confirmation that N.Y.U. so mis-
judged this one issue.
Kaplan is former chairperson, Washing-
ton Square Village Tenants Association’s
Task Force in Response to N.Y.U. Plan
noting that Prince Michael of Kent, a cousin
of Queen Elizabeth II, will preside at the
opening ceremony next year.
The new school has renovated 50,000
square feet of the building at 44 E. Second
St., which it has leased from LaSalle, the
all-boys Catholic high school. LaSalle is now
sharing the building at 215 E. Sixth St. with
St. George’s Ukrainian Catholic elementary
school.
Full-day tuition for the nursery school
will be $22,500 per year; for 4- and 5-year-
olds, the tuition will be $25,500 per year;
and for the upper grades, $31,900 per
year. The half-year tuition for the nursery
school in January will be $9,400, Taylor
said.
The British Schools of America, parent
organization of the World Class Learning
Academy, has five other primary schools in
the U.S.: in Chicago, Boston, Washington,
D.C., Houston and Charlotte, N.C.
Center. “These funds will go a long way
in rebuilding my sister’s school, which is a
refuge for its neighborhood and educates
over 250 children in desperate need,”
said Tribeca resident Jacqueline Fils-Aime,
sister of the director of Children’s Harvest
School.

After Pei protests N.Y.U. plan, market is new focus
Continued from page 1
said. “We expect the Department of City
Planning to certify our ULURP application
in the late summer of 2011 to begin a seven-
month review process, including community
board and department meetings and final
City Council approval,” she said.
N.Y.U. decided to drop the tower plan
after Henry Cobb, a partner of the architec-
tural firm Pei Cobb Freed & Partners, sent
a letter to L.P.C. saying that Pei, 93, was
strongly opposed to the proposed tower on
the landmarked portion of the superblock.
University design consultants had said the
additional tower would complement the
“pinwheel” arrangement of the Pei design.
The Cobb letter said in part, “A fourth
tower is profoundly destructive of the land-
marked entity because it closes a composition
that was intended to be open and upsets the
carefully considered balance between solid and
void. It also seriously compromises the gener-
ous visibility of Picasso’s Bust of Sylvette.”
Cobb also said the alternative proposal
on the Morton Williams site was “unattract-
ive as represented in [N.Y.U.’s] filing, but as
an as-of-right building…is nonetheless pref-
erable to the proposed fourth tower. Ideally,
the corner building would be designed so as
to make it more responsive to its neighbors
and to the landmarked entity.”
Andrew Berman, G.V.S.H.P. executive
Beverage Delivery to Your Home or Office
Over 2,000 Conventional, Unique and Hard to Find Varieties!
THE VILLAGER
READER SPECIAL!
Receive $25.00 OFFyour next online order*
www.mitchellsNYbeverage.com
enter promo code bevnytv25 at checkout
*minimum order of $60.00. May not be combined with any other coupon or offer.
www.mitchellsNYbeverage.com | 800-662-2275 ext 5
director, said he was gratified that the uni-
versity dropped its original plan, “in the face
of overwhelming opposition, including from
I.M. Pei.” However, Berman added, “N.Y.U.’s
insistence on moving ahead with its alterna-
tive plans for a development on the adjacent
non-landmarked supermarket site, as well as
‘We will be considering the
impacts on light and air,
shadows, wind tunnels,
open space, traffic,
infrastructure and many
other factors.’
Jo Hamilton
the remainder of its massive NYU 2031 plan
to add 2 million square feet of space around
Washington Square Park, shows that the
university still does not get it.”
Berman said N.Y.U. should look to places
like the Financial District to absorb its
growth, and vowed to continue to fight the
university’s plans for the Village.
Jo Hamilton, chairperson of Community
Board 2, said she was surprised and relieved
by the university’s withdrawal of its L.P.C.
application for the 400-foot tower.
“However, we are equally concerned
about the proposal to build on the Morton
Williams site,” she said. “It is immediately
adjacent to 505 LaGuardia Place and the
community garden and just across the street
from Washington Square Village.”
Hamilton said the community board is
now trying to learn exactly what the univer-
sity wants to build and how it would fit in
the ULURP application.
“We will be considering the impacts of
the entire project on light and air, shadows,
wind tunnels, open space, traffic, infrastruc-
ture and many other factors,” she added.
N.Y.U. officials said last week that the
university withdrew its L.P.C. application
as a mark of respect for Pei’s vision and
for L.P.C., which in 2008 granted land-
mark protection to the Pei-designed Silver
Towers plaza with three 300-foot-tall towers
around the 36-foot-tall, sculptural rendering
of Picasso’s “Bust of Sylvette.”
The original N.Y.U. plan called for a hotel
in the 400-foot tower, and the university
intends to include hotel uses in an as-yet-
undecided location in the larger project.
Hurley said, “Our former proposal had
four buildings and our new proposal has
four buildings. With the withdrawal of the
application for the tower on the landmarked
site, we will keep all of the proposed uses,
BVW\Q`cab
^WhhO
6][S[ORS
^OabO
3fbS\aWdS
eW\SZWab
ESSYS\R
P`c\QV
5ZcbS\T`SS
^OabO
4@3323:7D3@G
#% \R/dS
0Sb'Ab
 !%#'###
^Zc[\gQQ][
November 25 - December 1, 2010 11
including hotel and housing, in the mix.”
Lynne Brown, N.Y.U. senior vice presi-
dent, said in a prepared statement, “From
the beginning, we sought a design for the
Silver Towers block that was most respect-
ful of Mr. Pei’s vision. Some people dis-
agreed with our approach, others agreed.
We believed that among those who agreed
was Mr. Pei himself, who expressed no
opposition to the concept of a tower on
the landmarked site when we spoke to
him directly in 2008. Mr. Pei has now had
a change of heart. The clarity Mr. Pei has
now provided that the Morton Williams
site is preferable is helpful to us in under-
standing how to proceed with our uniform
land-use review procedure proposal.”
Cobb said this week that although he
was not present at the 2008 conversation
between Pei and N.Y.U., he has spoken to
Pei and other people who were there.
“Mr. Pei made no comment on the fourth
tower plan. On that issue he was silent,”
Cobb told this newspaper on Monday. Cobb
noted that the conversation occurred shortly
before L.P.C. designated the Silver Towers
complex a city landmark in November 2008
— two and a half years before N.Y.U. applied
to L.P.C. for approval of the fourth tower.
“The letter I wrote to the L.P.C. was nar-
rowly focused and carefully written, and the
only reason we commented was because we
felt obliged to comment on any alteration to
the landmarked site,” Cobb said.
>`SaS\bbVWaQ]c^]\T]`

=44
g]c`S\bW`S]`RS`
^Zc[
^WhhS`WOO\RPO`

1]c^]\OZa]U]]R
T]`RSZWdS`WSa
12 November 25 - December 1, 2010
POLICE BLOTTER
Guilty of murder
A Manhattan jury on Thurs., Nov. 18,
found Jeromie Cancel, 24, guilty of the
August 2008 strangling murder of Kevin
Pravia, 19, a Pace University student, in
Pravia’s Chelsea apartment. The jury delib-
erated a day and a half after the end of the
trial, which began Nov. 5, before they ren-
dered the guilty verdict. Cancel encountered
Pravia near Union Square Park and went
him to Pravia’s apartment at 239 W. 15th
St., where he garroted him with an electric
cord while the victim was asleep, according
to the charges. Pravia, an honors student
in the Lubin School of Business at Pace’s
campus near City Hall, had last been seen
by friends getting into a cab at Gold and
Fulton Sts. after a party. Cancel was arrested
three days later after burglarizing his father’s
home in Queens. He told police at the time
how he killed Pravia while watching a hor-
ror film. Cancel’s lawyer, Michael Alperstein,
failed to have the confession excluded as evi-
dence. State Supreme Court Justice Daniel
Fitzgerald is to sentence Cancel on Fri.,
Dec. 10.
L.E.S. serial burglar
Police are looking for a suspect they
identified as Irving Walker, 40, for 13 bur-
glaries on the Lower East Side from Oct.
12 to Nov.15. The suspect entered the front
door of apartments on Madison St. between
Rutgers and Catherine Sts.; East Broadway
between Pike and Rutgers Sts.; and Eldridge
and Forsyth Sts between Hester and Grand
Sts., mostly during the early morning hours,
police said.
The suspect often woke sleeping resi-
dents during the burglaries, police said.
Police described Walker as a 6-foot-tall, 210-
pound, black man whose last known address
was 2636 University Ave., Bronx.
He is suspected in the following bur-
glaries: 133 East Broadway on Oct. 12; 33
Catherine St. on Oct. 14; 120 Madison St.
on Oct. 18; 7 Monroe St. on Oct. 22; 105
Henry St. on Oct. 25; and 114 Madison St.
on Oct. 26.
On Nov. 3 he entered an apartment at
122 Madison St. at 2:10 a.m., and entered a
residence at 69 Eldridge St. the same day at
5:10 a.m. He is also a suspect in burglaries
at 201 Madison St. on Nov. 7, 113 Madison
St. on Nov. 11, 75 Madison St. on Nov. 13,
215 Madison St. on Nov. 14, and 74 Forsyth
St. on Nov. 15.
Bad samaritan
A visitor from Florida exited the subway
station at Canal and Varick Sts. around 5 p.m.
Sun., Nov. 14, to discover that her parents,
who had been on the train with her, were
nowhere to be seen. A stranger stopped her
and said, “You look lost. Let’s look around on
our tiptoes,” and then took her by the wrist.
The stranger then grabbed the woman’s wallet
from a strap on her wrist and fled. The victim,
38, lost $68 in cash, credit cards and her
Florida diver’s license, police said.
A washout
A man entered Savon, the specialty
soap boutique at 78 Seventh Ave. near
14th St., around 5 p.m. Fri., Nov. 19, and
told the saleswoman, “This is a robbery.
Give me your money,” police said. The
woman thought it was a joke and burst
out laughing, but the intruder put his hand
in his pocket simulating a gun and said,
“Give me the money or I’m going to kill
you.” But the woman pushed the burglary
button behind the counter and the robber
fled, police said.
‘This is a stickup’
Police are looking for a man involved
in the robbery of two Greenwich Village
bank branches last month. The suspect,
described as a heavyset white man, 5 feet
10 inches tall, between 55 and 60 years
old, with wavy gray hair, walked into the
Capital One bank, at 21 University Place,
around 11:10 a.m. Tues., Oct. 5, told the
teller, “Let me get my wallet out,” and then
tossed a black plastic bag on the counter.
“This is a stickup. No dye, right?” he added.
The teller began filling the bag with bait
money, whose serial numbers are recorded,
while the robber said, “You know what to
do. Good job.” The thief put the bag of
money in his coat pocket and fled south on
University Place, police said.
On Fri., Oct. 22, a man with the same
description walked into the HSBC branch,
at 576 Hudson St. at W. 11th St., at 11:34
a.m. He filled out a bank slip at the side
counter and then walked up to a teller, put a
black bag under the window and said, “This
is a stickup. Give me the money.” The teller
pushed the bag back out empty and the rob-
ber walked out and fled, police said.
Perry St. burglar
A witness who saw a man climb
through a window at 80 Perry St. at 6:05
p.m. Sun., Nov. 14, and climb out again
a few minutes later, called police, who
arrested Aniyah Simone, 16. The sus-
Photo by Jefferson Siegel
‘Hey, Regis — check it out!’
Last Thursday was Juror Appreciation Day at Manhattan Supreme Court. An annual
celebration saluting New York City jurors, guest celebrities filling the courtroom jury
box included Kelly Ripa, Jimmy Fallon, Tom Brokaw, Ralph Lauren, Julianna Margulies,
America Ferrera and Julia Stiles. The celebrities themselves were called for jury duty
in the past year. Ripa, above, held up her certificate of appreciation outside Manhattan
Supreme Court.
pect had credit cards and debit cards, a motorcycle to the Ducati Triumph agency
driver’s license and $5 in cash in his pos- at 155 Sixth Ave. at Spring St. at 11:20
session that belonged to the apartment’s a.m. Fri., Oct. 19, for servicing returned
residents, police said. on Saturday afternoon Nov. 20 to find
the bike, valued at $25,000, was gone.
The agency owner said the bike had been
parked at the curb in front of the location
Immaculate arrest after it was serviced.
Police arrested Michelle Harris, 44, on
Tues., Nov. 16, and charged her with the Aug.
16 theft of a handbag belonging to a woman Auto-theft reduction
who was praying at Immaculate Conception
Church, 414 E. 14th St. near First Ave. Car owners may join auto-theft preven-
Harris was recorded on a surveillance tape at tion sticker programs that all precincts are
the time taking the bag from a pew next to the offering neighborhood residents. The CAT
victim, according to the charges filed with the (Combat Auto Theft) program is for cars
Manhattan district attorney. not usually used between 1 a.m. and 5 a.m.
Decals on registered cars’ rear side windows
tell officers they may stop the vehicles oper-
ated between those hours.
Auto theft The HEAT (Help End Auto Theft)
program is for car owners over age 40
A Brooklyn woman who parked her car who sign waivers saying that people under
near the southwest corner of Vandam St. age 25 do not drive the vehicle. Decals
and Sixth Ave. at 12:05 a.m. Fri., Nov. 19, allow police to stop those cars if the driv-
returned at 5 p.m. to find her 2000 Dodge ers look younger than 25. For those and
Charger was gone. Police determined the other car-theft prevention programs in the
car had not been towed and there were no Sixth Precinct, which covers Greenwich
signs of broken glass indicating a forced Village, see or contact Officer Robert
entry. Jackson, 212-741-4811, at 233 W. 10th
St. In the Ninth Precinct, which covers
the East Village east of Broadway, contact
Jaime Hernandez, 212-477-7805, at 321
Motorcycle gone E. Fifth St.
A Brooklyn man who brought his Alber t Amateau
 November 25 - December 1, 2010 13

Photos by The Anonymous Photographer

In the empty underbelly of the beast, street art lurks

The Underbelly Project, an illegal show of street art, curated by street artists PAC and Workhorse, fills the inside of an abandoned Brooklyn subway station. The project began
in 2009. Artists, 103 in all, were escorted into the space individually to create their works. According to the project’s Web site, “Unobstructed by the pressures of commercial
sales, e-mail or daily routines, each artist painted one full night.” (There’s definitely no e-mail, since four stories belowground in the century-old station, there’s no WiFi.) It’s
one of the largest shows of such pieces ever mounted in one place. Many of the contributors are significant figures in both the street-art world and the commercial trade that
now revolves around it. Following the space’s opening to select viewers earlier this month, police have made at least 20 arrests of people sneaking in or out. It’s not that
surprising — given that the old station is located underneath a police precinct. Police have said there are no plans to remove the artwork.
14 November 25 - December 1, 2010
EDITORIAL
Hope for SPURA
After decades of inertia at the Seward Park Urban
Renewal Area, on the Lower East Side south of the
Williamsburg Bridge, the makings of a viable develop-
ment scheme are taking shape. Where six blocks have
lain vacant, occupied by open-air parking lots, there are
now visions of housing and commercial development,
and much-needed jobs and economic development.
It must be stressed that what exists now are only guide-
lines, not a plan, per se. But Community Board 3 — which
has been spearheading this process for the past several
years — is indeed now working toward a final plan.
The guidelines were presented Nov. 16 at C.B. 3’s Land
Use, Zoning, Public and Private Housing Committee.
Basically, they call for a mixed-use project, with equal
parts residential and commercial development. There
would be 800 to 1,000 units of housing. Under one pos-
sible scenario, the mix could include 40 percent market-
rate, 30 percent moderate and middle-income, 20 percent
low-income and 10 percent senior housing.
No retail spaces would be larger than 30,000 square
feet, effectively excluding big-box stores, though a
supermarket of larger size would be allowed. A movie
theater and parking space would also be included.
In addition, although they weren’t in the original
1965 renewal plan, C.B. 3 is also including in its rede-
velopment concept the four Essex St. Market buildings,
between Stanton and Houston Sts.
Leading the C.B. 3 committee on the renewal area
is David McWater. McWater, when he was board
chairperson, initiated the community-led, contextual
East Village / Lower East Side rezoning approved by
the city two years ago, which put height caps on new
development. He’s confident the SPURA plan will also
win approval.
Next month, the SPURA guidelines will be fleshed
out at C.B. 3, and it’s hoped the board will vote on the
concept in January. But there’s still far to go. The city will
need to do an environmental impact statement (E.I.S.),
then a uniform land-use review procedure (ULURP),
then issue requests for proposals (R.F.P.’s) to get devel-
opers for the 10 various sites. All this could take three
years, and, of course, construction would be phased in
over many years. McWater stressed it’s important to get
the approval process completed before Mayor Bloomberg
leaves office — since who knows what could happen
under a new administration? Whatever consensus has
been painstakingly built over the past two years could
evaporate.
The renewal plan itself has expired. But McWater
said, the city will give priority to former renewal-area
residents who seek to return and get affordable hous-
ing, if their income meets requirements.
In 2003, the city pitched a SPURA proposal with a
mix of housing, including 400 low- and middle-income
units. That plan was scrapped due to vehement com-
munity opposition. In contrast, this current process has
been community driven.
The key will be getting the area’s local elected officials
onboard, namely Councilmember Margaret Chin and
Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver. While many residents
of the Grand St. co-ops, where Silver lives, have his-
torically resisted SPURA’s development, opposing more
affordable housing, the co-ops’ residential mix has been
changing, getting younger, more diverse. There’s new
sentiment for movement on these eyesore blocks.
Now that a new, consensus plan is materializing, it’s
incumbent on Chin and Silver to engage and support the
process. If not, a golden opportunity will be lost; who
knows what sort of plan for SPURA will be proposed in
some future round, if any? It’s time for Chin and Silver
to help shepherd this long-paralyzed project through to
fruition. That would be a legacy to be proud of.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Art squeezed out of the parks
To The Editor:
Re “East Side, West Side, park improvements all around;
It’s a green golden age” (Progress Report article, by Adrian
Benepe, Nov. 18):
What Commissioner Benepe’s “Green and Golden Age”
refers to is green for the money and gold for the profits he is
funneling to corporations, BID’s and park conservancies at
the public’s expense. He is the commissioner of park privati-
zation; a real estate agent trying to get the highest price per
square foot for our public parks.
Free speech, artists’ rights and public use of the parks are
the collateral victims of this real estate scam that puts giant
holiday vending markets in the most crowded parks, and
luxury condos in new parks. Soon enough, he’ll have all the
trees removed from Union Square Park because they take up
valuable space needed by park concessions.
For a graphic example of Benepe’s “Golden Age”
see this link, http://www.scribd.com/doc/42641529/
Holiday-Market-2010-USP .
Robert Lederman
Lederman is president of ARTIST (Artists’ Response to
Illegal State Tactics)
Cyclists must obey rules
To The Editor:
Re “The peddling of pedaling and those pesky pedestri-
ans” (talking point, by Daniel Meltzer, Nov. 18):
I used to be a biker and was terrified to bike on the
streets. Thus, I had to limit my pedaling to the parks, and to
get there I would have to walk my bike on sidewalks. I would
have certainly welcomed a bike lane.
I no longer bicycle, and am now mostly a pedestrian or
bus rider. Bikes scare me to death. They come zooming out
of nowhere when I cross the street, completely ignoring red
lights.
What to do? Bike lanes are not the problem — prop-
erly used, they could be a boon. But, wherever they bike, if
cyclists don’t obey the rules, they are a danger. I don’t really
understand Meltzer’s objection to the lanes. If there weren’t
lanes, wouldn’t the bikers be on the streets instead, posing
the same menace as they do in the lanes?
Joan Wile
EVAN FORSCH
Wish list for the streets
To The Editor:
Re “The peddling of pedaling and those pesky pedestri-
ans” (talking point, by Daniel Meltzer, Nov. 18):
The situation is astonishingly weird already in the East
Village: First Ave. is so chopped up and impossible for cars,
taxis and the disabled, that setting regulations for bikers ain’t
solving the problems most of us have with this ditzy plan.
I personally want more bikes and more, more mass tran-
sit, but government continues to conspire against this.
I want cyclists (and I also want them regulated, fined,
imprisoned for life if they ride on the sidewalk, ignore sig-
nals, etc.). I want mass transit. I want private cars outta here.
O.K., so I want too much.
Lu Krasne
Incoming! Look out — bikers!
To The Editor:
Re “The peddling of pedaling and those pesky pedestri-
ans” (talking point, by Daniel Meltzer, Nov. 18):
Great article and right on! The bikers are like kamikazes.
They ride their bikes everywhere and anywhere at any speed,
with total disregard for traffic direction, stoplights or pedes-
trian safety — and that’s not just the delivery bikers. There
needs to be far more oversight and penalties for breaking
the law.
Gretchen Berger
E-mail letters, not longer than 250 words in length, to
news@thevillager.com or fax to 212-229-2790 or mail to The
Villager, Letters to the Editor, 145 Sixth Ave., ground floor,
NY, NY 10013. Please include phone number for confirma-
tion purposes. The Villager reserves the right to edit letters
for space, grammar, clarity and libel. The Villager does not
publish anonymous letters.
Sound off!
Write a letter to The Editor
 November 25 - December 1, 2010 15

Correcting some misperceptions post-St. Vincent’s

of St. Vincent’s decided to close the hospital in no small allocated to St. Vincent’s can be used to reopen a hos-
TALKING POINT part because of its overall debt of more than $1 billion,
much of which is owed to TD Bank and GE Capital. It
pital. In fact, only after we have the pieces in place for
a viable hospital will federal funds — such as mortgage
BY CHRISTINE C. QUINN, is true that a Health Department regulation does require insurance and healthcare grants — be available. By con-
JERROLD NADLER, that while a hospital is shutting down, it must care for its ducting an assessment, and clearly establishing a strong
THOMAS K. DUANE patients as it arranges for them to be moved elsewhere. foundation for a hospital, we can and will attract a new
AND RICHARD N. GOTTFRIED sponsor and generate crucial city, state and federal gov-
As we move forward in the aftermath of the tragic loss of ernment support.
our community hospital, we — the many friends, advocates The bottom line is: There is no magic bullet that’s going
and supporters of St. Vincent’s — must work together to There’s no magic bullet to get us a to get us a hospital immediately. It will take a lot of hard
take all of the positive steps we can to restore emergency work to get the decisions made and the financing raised. No
and acute-care services to our community. Having all the hospital immediately. one is happy with this situation. In fact, we are all angry and
ammunition we need in this battle is essential. Therefore, devastated by this tragedy. However, we are taking the need-
documenting the specifics of what services we need with a ed steps to make our healthcare whole again. Getting good,
community health assessment is critical to this mission. solid data to prove the case is an essential part of the job. So,
We believe our community needs an acute-care facility Unfortunately, we cannot rely on city zoning to force too, are demonstrations, letter writing, community building
and emergency room. But it will take hard facts to convince a hospital to re-emerge. Nowhere in the city’s Zoning and other advocacy, creativity and strategic thinking and
a potential hospital operator to invest the necessary hun- Resolution does it allow for a local government to force planning. No one tactic is exclusive. All are necessary. We
dreds of millions of dollars to finance a new facility, and no a property owner to use a piece of land for one specific must and we will work together to regain a hospital and, in
one else is going to gather this key data. Therefore, we, as a purpose — especially when the land is currently con- the meantime, maintain and expand high-quality accessible
community, must undertake this process ourselves and work trolled by the federal bankruptcy court. That is the real- healthcare for all, regardless of ability to pay.
together to compile that information. ity of the situation.
Opening a hospital takes more than knowing in our And, also unfortunately, neither the federal funds Quinn is speaker, New York City Council; Nadler is con-
hearts that it is needed and demanding it fervently. It also received by the Lower Manhattan Development gressmember for the Eighth District; Duane is state senator
takes reliable data to document to others that the facil- Corporation for rebuilding and revitalizing Downtown for the 29th District; Gottfried is assemblymember for the
ity is necessary and will be viable. That’s precisely what post-9/11, nor the federal healthcare grants previously 75th District.
we’re trying to do, with the support and participation of
a long list of community members, community organiza-
tions, healthcare workers and other advocates.
In our efforts to move forward in meeting the health
needs of the community, we would like to correct some
misconceptions that we have recently heard.
First of all, the assessment is about guiding future
healthcare planning efforts and its scope is being driven
by a broad coalition of community stakeholders, not by
any private parties or special interests.
Additionally, North Shore-L.I.J. has already begun
development of its urgent-care center and that center
will move forward regardless of the community needs
assessment already underway.
We would also like to clarify that while the New York
State Commission on Health Care Facilities in the 21st
Century (the “Berger Commission”) did identify several
hospitals and nursing homes as unnecessary and forced
mergers and closings, it did not state in the affirma-
tive that every other facility was needed. In a July 15,
2010, letter to Community Board 2, David Sandman,
the executive director of the Berger Commission, stated,
“The Commission made no specific recommendation or
findings regarding St. Vincent’s Hospital Manhattan —
Greenwich Village Campus.”
While Section 2806 of the New York State Public
Health Law does require the Health commissioner to Photo by Lincoln Anderson

make certain findings before closing a hospital, that sec- Call it the ATM that never sleeps in the city that never sleeps. Raising the
tion only applies if the commissioner, not a hospital’s
board, is going to force a hospital to shut down. It has
SCENE ordinary ATM sign to another level, a deli at Ninth St. and Second Ave. sports a
sidewalk-spanning, completely ATM’ed-out, neon canopy — leaving no doubt that
nothing to do with the St. Vincent’s situation. The board there is, truly, a 24-hour, cash-dispensing machine within.

Member of the
New York Press
PUBLISHER & EDITOR PUBLISHER EMERITUS ART / PRODUCTION DIRECTOR CIRCULATION SALES MNGR.
Association John W. Sutter Elizabeth Butson Troy Masters Marvin Rock
Member of the ASSOCIATE EDITOR SR. V.P. OF SALES AND MARKETING ART DIRECTOR CONTRIBUTORS
National
Lincoln Anderson Francesco Regini
Newspaper Mark Hassleberger Ira Blutreich
Association
ARTS EDITOR SR. MARKETING CONSULTANT
The Villager (USPS 578930) ISSN 0042-6202 is published Jason Sherwood GRAPHIC DESIGNER Doris Diether
Published by COMMUNITY MEDIA, LLC every week by Community Media LLC, 145 Sixth Ave., First Scott Stiffler
Fl., New York, N.Y. 10013 (212) 229-1890. Periodicals Jamie Paakkonen Patricia Fieldsteel
Gay City
NEWS
TM
Postage paid at New York, N.Y. Annual subscription by mail
in Manhattan and Brooklyn $29 ($35 elsewhere). Single copy REPORTER ADVERTISING SALES
price at office and newsstands is $1. The entire contents of
newspaper, including advertising, are copyrighted and no
Albert Amateau Allison Greaker PHOTOGRAPHERS Ed Gold
145 Sixth Ave., NY, NY 10013 part may be reproduced without the express permission of
the publisher - © 2010 Community Media LLC. Robert Lucarelli
Phone: (212) 229-1890 • Fax: (212) 229-2790 Elisabeth Robert Bonnie Rosenstock
PUBLISHER’S LIABILITY FOR ERROR
The Publisher shall not be liable for slight changes or BUSINESS MANAGER/ Julio Tumbaco
On-line: www.thevillager.com typographical errors that do not lessen the value of an
advertisement. The publisher’s liability for others errors or CONTROLLER RETAIL AD MANAGER Jefferson Siegel Jefferson Siegel
E-mail: news@thevillager.com omissions in connection with an advertisement is strictly

© 2010 Community Media, LLC

limited to publication of the advertisement in any subsequent
issue. Vera Musa Colin Gregory Clayton Patterson Jerry Tallmer
16 November 25 - December 1, 2010
G.O.P.’er: Democrats could be in for a close shave
Continued from page 4
against him and depose him as speaker,
Silver said he wasn’t worried.
“No. New York has serious challenges,”
Silver said. “Right now I’m focused on
working with Andrew Cuomo to get New
York’s fiscal crisis under control and get our
economy moving again.”
Meanwhile, Frank Scala, president of the
Albano Republican Club, does feel the tide is,
in fact, starting to turn in favor of the G.O.P.
in both the state and city. A Stuyvesant
Town resident, Scala has in the past run
against former Councilmember Kathryn
Freed and former Assemblymember Steve
Sanders, whose seat Democrat Kavanagh
now holds.
In a heavy Italian accent, Scala spoke
in a phone interview from his E. 30th St.
barbershop, La Scala — “like the opera,”
he noted.
“The Republicans decide to wake up a
little bit,” he said over the sound of whirring
electric shears. “We pick up seven congres-
sional seats in New York State.”
A problem for the G.O.P., though, he
acknowledged, is that New York City voters
tend to back the straight party line.
“New York City go for the Democrats.
They gotta do if the person is good,” he said,
as in, voters should base their decision on the
individual candidate, not solely the party.
Political
Rally
New Late-
Night Menu
In print or online, we’ve got you covered.
www.EastVillagerNews.com
“The Tea Party, it’s O.K., wake up a lot of
people,” Scala said. “I think it’s a good idea.
We gonna be in great shape.”
Randy Credico, another local candi-
date, not an incumbent, didn’t fare too
well running on a third-party line. A stand-
‘The city go for the
Democrats. They gotta do
if the person is good.’
Frank Scala
up comic and former head of the William
Kunstler Fund for Racial Justice, he ran as
a Libertarian against U.S. Senator Chuck
Schumer after failing to qualify for the
Democratic primary. He got 0.6 percent —
or 26,000 votes — on Nov. 2 to Schumer’s
2.7 million votes.
“I lost my interest after Schumer and the
state Democratic Party knocked me off the
Democratic primary ballot,” Credico said. “I
lost even more interest when I was restricted
to one box on the ballot, even though I was
nominated by two parties. The judge ruled
in my favor but stayed the decision till
after the election. I am writing a scathing
On Stage
Tonight
Movie
Shoot
Gallery New
Event Noodle
Shop
retrospective on the process, particularly
on the spiritually and corrupt Democratic
Party of New York, which is anything but
democratic. As Senator Charles Sumner said
in 1854, ‘A politician loyal to a party cannot
be trusted.’ ”
Unlike Gottfried, former Mayor Ed Koch
said he does believe in term limits for both
city and state elected officials. On Nov. 2,
in a stinging rebuke to the City Council and
Mayor Bloomberg, New York City voters
strongly backed returning to a limit of two
terms, overturning the Council’s legislative
extension of term limits in 2008. But Koch
said he supports a limit of three terms, not
two.
SCOOPY’S NOTEBOOK
Continued from page 3
$100 a month and can’t be raised. It’s about
time he got it, since he’s 77 and qualified for it
15 years ago. Ray once again is amazed by his
super staffer Eryn, who not only single-hand-
edly saws up and demolishes old refrigerators
for him, but biked all the way Downtown
several times to get the necessary paperwork
so he could get his SCRIE.
CORRECTION: The article on the new
PEOPS PORTRAIT PROJECT BY FLY - WWW.PEOPS.ORG
SOPHIE CRUMB - 11/05/2K10 - LOWER EAST SIDE NYC
SOPHIECRUMB.BLOGSPOT.COM
Through his New York Uprising group,
Koch has been leading the push for reform
in Albany. In the state Senate, with 62 seats,
all but eight members have signed onto the
Uprising pledge; in the Assembly, with 150
seats, 83 have signed.
“So we have a majority in both Houses,”
Koch said. The pledge calls for three spe-
cific things: independent redistricting, ethics
reform and a GAAP (generally accepted
accounting principles) balanced budget. So
far, though, Silver has failed to sign onto
the pledge.
“Ultimately, I don’t give up,” Koch said,
“and hope that I’ll be able to get Shelly to
join the reform movement.”
High Line maintenance-and-operation build-
ing in our Progress Report section last week
incorrectly stated that the Downtown Whitney
Museum would be completed at the same
time as the adjacent, planned “M-&-O” build-
ing, in mid-2013. While the article was cor-
rect in saying the Gansevoort St. museum’s
groundbreaking is scheduled for May 2011
— just six months away! — setting the record
straight, museum spokesperson Stephen Soba
said, “The Whitney has no intention of com-
pleting construction by 2013. Our planned
date of completion is 2015.”

EASTVILLAGERARTS&ENTERTAINMENT
Pacino ‘very good’ — but ‘Merchant’ misses the point
Tallmer ranks four Shylocks, wonders what Mostel would have done
THEATER
THE MERCHANT OF VENICE
Written by William Shakespeare
Directed by Daniel Sullivan
Through Jan. 9, 2011
At The Broadhurst Theatre (235 W. 44th St.)
For tickets ($66.50-$136.50), call 212-239-6200
BY JERRY TALLMER
Believe it or don’t, but I am not old enough
to have seen the great Jacob Adler’s astonish-
ing 1902-03 performance as a Shylock who
spoke only Yiddish throughout a Broadway
production of “The Merchant of Venice” in
which all around him were speaking elegant
Elizabethan English.
That in itself was a point sharply made:
“The Merchant of Venice” is bad for the
Jews. Is good for the Jews. Is both.
Al Pacino can never be accused of bom-
barding us with either Yiddish or high-
flown-sounding English. He just gives us a
Shylock of high Pacino intensity and a lot of
motion — Jews and Italians do a great deal
of speaking with their hands, so the legend
goes — and high Pacino intensity is compel-
ling enough to make anyone, even me, want
to rush to The Broadhurst Theatre to see
how he, and it — this outdoor “Merchant”
brought indoors — makes out.
He: Very good. It: Not so good.
First place, the costuming. The gentle-
men of the Rialto in sort of stiff, dark,
wide-shouldered Ad Age business suits circa
1950, the idea being to prove once more
for the thousandth time that Shakespeare is
really really relevant, even now.
The women — well, Portia — in sort of
high school prom gowns circa 1955, when
Joseph Papp’s Public Theater to be — then
the Shakespearean Workshop Theater — was
just setting forth in such inexpensive plum-
age on the Lower East Side of Manhattan.
Relevance? If “If you prick us, do we
not bleed?” isn’t relevant, now and forever,
what is?
Second place, the setting. I don’t know
where we would be these days without skel-
etal expressionistic (impressionistic?) stage
sets constructed of metal piping and such-
like, rods and joints and slabs and chicken
wire and nuts and bolts; nothing more than
giant cages, really.
“Like a prison,” an acquaintance sug-
gests. Exactly. But there are no prisons in
“The Merchant of Venice” unless you mean
that all Venice is (was) a prison — at least
for Jews. But we already knew that, didn’t
Al Pacino ‘gives us a Shylock of high Pacino intensity and a lot of motion.’
we?
There must have been, in theater, such
huge cage-like settings going back into the
Twenties and even earlier — but the first
ones to thrust themselves into my aware-
ness were when Julian and Judith’s Living
Theatre came back from exile abroad to a
1968 repertoire at the Brooklyn Academy of
Music with their “Frankenstein” and other
such disturbances of the peace.
Third place, the acting. Pacino is busy-
busy-busy, dashing all over the stage — but
his Shylock is also a good and deeply seri-
ous individual. He wants to dig up and
examine not just his own humanity but
whatever humanity must somewhere exist
within all these despicable bullying goyim
Photo by Joan Marcus
who spit upon his gabardine and call him
“dog” three times a week and twice on
Sundays, even as they haughtily apply for
a fatal loan.
At the Broadhurst Theatre I could hardly
tell one of these good lads from the other.
They were each trying so strenuously to
speak that elegant Elizabethan English, in
contradistinction of the whole Joe Papp idea
of bringing Shakespeare alive and well and
organically to our own populace.
From Pacino’s lips I heard every syl-
lable loud and clear. So much for those
who deplore (a) method acting, (b) the
late Lee Strasberg — Pacino’s beloved
mentor.
The other male actors in this endeav-
November 25 - December 1, 2010 17
or? Indifferent to indistinguishable. One
is the show’s Bassanio (David Harbour).
He’s the heavy who needs the dough,
almost gets his buddy carved up for the
sake of those 3,000 on-demand ducats
and then wins the girl who won the case,
only to betray her in the next minute by
giving away that ring she’d given him.
Another is that most obliging buddy,
Antonio (Byron Jennings). In director
Daniel Sullivan’s staging, these two chaps
spend an awful lot of time periodically
clenched in one another’s arms, staring
into one another’s eyes.
I’m fully aware that Shakespeare has
Bassanio more than once employ the word
“love” in passages like:
To you, Antonio,
I owe the most, in money and in love,
And from your love I have a warranty —
To unburden all my plots and purposes
How to get clear of all the debts I owe...
One footnote. At the Broadhurst these
days and nights, Al Pacino is the shortest
male on stage. I imagine this was deliber-
ate casting: the Little Jew, dashing here
and there among these giant gentiles.
As for the ladies, Portia is a bifurcated
role (half merciless ingenious mercy-quot-
ing lawyer, half idiot love-struck teensy-
weensy) that has defeated more than one
actress over the ages. I don’t know if it
defeats Lily Rabe, because, if I could
hear every syllable of Pacino’s, I could
fully decipher not one of hers until she
exploded — over-exploded — as the trial
of Antonio and/or Shylock begins. For the
rest, her unfortunate output was rather
like duck quacks.
Unfortunate, too — I guess the word is
gratuitous — is the interjected acting-out
of the punishing baptism of Shylock, in
the dark, like a mime show, complete with
splashing water. Pacino took his baptism
and scuttled off, as did the play when
all those Christian gentlefolk repaired to
revel and romance at Belmont. I am sorry
to have to confess that, even if it con-
tains some of the most exquisite poetry
in Shakespeare (“On such a night…”),
this whole courtship half of the play has
always bored the socks off me.
I mean the Belmont subplot, caskets
and all. Or is Shylock just a subplot?
Oy oy oy, there’s the rub. Over the
years I have seen four Shylocks: Boris
Tumarin, 1962 (at Off-Broadway’s no
longer existant Gate Theater); George C.
Scott, also 1962, ripping a passion to tat-
ters in Central Park; Dustin Hoffman on
Broadway, 1989 — methodical, reason-
Continued on page 19
18 November 25 - December 1, 2010
Let’s Have Hanukkah...and Chanukah...and Hanukah!
COMPILED BY SCOTT STIFFLER
CHANUKAH ON ICE
Congregation Emunath Israel has come
up with an innovative way to celebrate
Chanukah — by incorporating ice sculpting,
Jewish music, Chanukah crafts and kosher
latkes. Attendees will have an opportunity
to choose from a variety of Chanukah activi-
ties, listen to Jewish music, and participate
in creating Chelsea’s fist ever ice Menorah.
“Chanukah on Ice” takes place on Dec. 2,
6:30 visit www.chanukahchelsea.com or call
212-242 9882.
FIRST NIGHT OF HANUKAH
Stuyvesant Square Community Alliance
presents “First Night of Hanukah” — a free
Hanukah Lighting led by TORAHnyc (with
East End Temple)
There will music, refreshments and
Hanukah surprises for the kids! Wed., Dec.
1. Two lightings, at 5:30 p.m. and 6:30 p.m.
at W. Stuyvesant Square Park (16th St. & 2nd
Ave., near the statue of Peter Stuyvesant). For
info, call 212-717-4613 x6.
Just Do Art!
COMPILED BY SCOTT STIFFLER
CHITA RIVERA AT BIRDLAND
Too bad the charismatic, won’t-coast-
on-her-legacy Chita Rivera is like Christmas
— because we wish she’d come around (to
Birdland) more than once a year. Her most
recent concert there, in 2009, was a nearly
90-minute intermissionless lesson on how
to work a crowd, sell a song and earn an
audience’s love and respect (even though
it was hers for the taking from the moment
she set her tiny feet and toned gams on the
stage). Ever the seasoned pro, it’s likely this
week’s two-night/four-show gig will deliver
the same dishy pre-song patter that gave
2009’s performance its inside track appeal.
No word on the set list, but you’ll be telling
the story for years to come if Rivera dips
into last year’s repertoire and blazes her
way through the most articulate, relentless,
practically breathless interpretation we’re
ever likely to see of the Jacques Brel song
“Carousel.” At 8:30 p.m. & 11 p.m. on Fri.,
Nov. 26 & Sat., Nov. 27 — at Birdland (315
West 44th St. btw. 8th & 9th Aves.). Music
charge: $40 side seating and $50 center
seating ($10 food/drink minimum). For
reservations, call 212-581-3080. Visit www.
BirdlandJazz.com.
Mondays at Birdland, “Jim Caruso’s Cast
Party” features open mic talent from journey-
men crooners and more than one Broadway
baby who just can’t stop singing on her one
night off. Taming the wild cabaret aesthetic
— and charming the socks off the crowd as
he plugs elsewhere gigs of guest performers
and hawks “tonight only” discounts on those
swanky $10 “Cast Party” T-Shirts — is your
affable host, Jim Caruso. $10 cover/$10
ELEANOR REISSA CELEBRATES
HANUKKAH
Humor, pathos and inclusiveness get
equal sharing on a bill headlined by Tony
nominee and international artist Eleanor
Reissa — in her only NYC appearance this
season. Hailed as one of the world’s most
gifted interpreters of Yiddish song, Reissa
is accompanied by a band of musical lumi-
naries under the direction of Frank London
(of the Klezmatics). Marty Confurius on
the upright bass, Rex Benincasa on per-
cussion and drums, slide trombone player
Brian Drye and pianist/accordion player
Patrick Farrell bring their talents to the
table, as Reissa breezes through an after-
noon of Hanukkah songs and musical gems
from the Yiddish theater — including Abe
Ellstein’s “Abi Gezint” and “Oy Mama
Am I in Love.” Those who aren’t fluent
in Yiddish (and aren’t even Jewish) won’t
be left in the dark: Reissa will intersperse
Yiddish selections with songs like “Que
Sera, Sera,” “Brother, Can You Spare a
Dime?” and even “Yankee Doodle.” Sun.,
Dec. 12, 2:30 p.m., at the Museum of
Jewish Heritage (Edmond J. Safra Plaza,
We should all look so good: Chita Rivera rules the roost at Birldand.
minimum; 9:30 p.m.-1 a.m.
ROCK ‘N RUDOLPH HOLIDAY
FUNDRAISER
It’s been over a dozen years since vet-
erinarian Jeffrey Levy formed “Pet-Rox” — a
musical charity group founded composed
entirely of individuals involved in the pro-
motion of better animal welfare. On the
surface, their musical selections all relate to
the creatures we co-inhabit the planet with.
Photo by Stephen Kunken
Keep your eye on the (Yiddish) sparrow:
Eleanor Reissa.
36 Battery Place). Tickets are $18 ($15 for
Museum and National Yiddish Book Center
Members). To order, call the Museum
Photo by Laura Marie Duncan
But just below the furry surface, the band
is concerned with how those songs speak
to the human condition. Now, after hav-
ing performed at pet-centric places such as
Brooklyn’s Prospect Park Zoo, the band is
bringing their act to a place which has seen its
share of rare and strange birds: that legend-
ary Restaurant Row cabaret space known as
Don’t Tell Mama. Thurs., Dec. 2, 9 p.m. at,
well, Don’t Tell Mama (343 W. 46th St. btw.
8th and 9th Aves.). The donation, $25, is
your gift to Pet-Rox (who will donate partial
box office at 646-437-4202 or visit www.
mjhnyc.org.
CHANUKAH WONDERLAND
What happens for eight consecutive
nights, is different each time and offers
sizzling latkes, delicious donuts, meno-
rah lighting, chocolate Chanukah gelt and
prizes galore? The answer’s not exactly a
brain teaser, given that this is a Chanukah
(Hanukkah?) listing. But one thing’s for
sure — the fact that this particular celebra-
tion is jam-packed with fun (and maybe
some jam for those latkes?) is a no-brain-
er. “Chanukah Wonderland” is My Little
School’s gift to you. Dec. 1 through Dec.
8. Locations, times, prices vary. For event
details and registration, visit www.mylittle-
schoolnyc.com.
COMMUNITY HANUKKAH
CELEBRATION ON THE L.E.S.
What do you expect for nothing? How
Continued on page 19
proceeds to animal charities). The two-drink
minimum is your gift to yourself. So drink
up and rock out — Fido and Fifi are counting
on you. For reservations, call 212-757-0788
after 4:30 p.m. Find out more about the
band at www.HouseCallsForYourPet.com,
and listen to them at Pet-Rox on MySpace
Music - Free Streaming MP3s, Pictures &
Music Downloads.
LECTURE: INVESTIGATING
MANHATTAN’S MOST HAUNTED
HOUSE
The Merchant’s House Museum
delivers a unique trip back in time all
year long — but from October through
December, they’re especially busy. A vari-
ety of holiday-themed fare is coming
soon. But before the calendar page turns
to December, MHM hosts one last para-
normal-centric event (which acknowl-
edges its well-earned reputation as the
most haunted house in Manhattan). For
three years, paranormal investigator Dan
Sturges has been collecting startling evi-
dence which makes a convincing case
that something intriguing, strange and
(so far) unexplained is happening here.
Is it the work of former Tredwell family
residents and servants reaching out from
the final frontier? The skeptical Sturges
won’t say — he does invite you to draw
your own conclusions after learning about
his investigative techniques and hearing
recordings of disembodied voices and
viewing photos containing orbs of light
and a ghostly silhouette. Tues., Nov. 30, 7
Continued on page 20

Hanukkah
Continued from page 18
about dreidel games, storytelling, songs and
a menorah lighting? That’s what you’ll get,
for FREE, at this Hanukkah celebration
for the Lower East Side community! Join
friends, neighbors and classmates for a fun,
meaningful kickoff to this year’s Festival of
Lights. Play dreidel for gelt, and take part in
storytelling and songs before promenading
from the historic Mazer Theater to event
sponor The Educational Alliance — for a fes-
tive first lighting of the menorah. This event
is FREE and open to the public (perfect for
families with kids of all ages). Wed., Dec. 1,
4:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. at 197 E. Broadway
(btw. Clinton & Jefferson). For info, visit
www.edalliance.org or call 646-395-4245.
HANUKKAH CELEBRATION AND
OPEN HOUSE
The Educational Alliance Preschool
hosts this FREE Hanukkah event for Kids
& Families. Come celebrate Hanukkah
and learn about Educational Alliance
programs for toddlers and preschoolers.
Festivities will include Hanukkah arts
& crafts, dancing, sing-a-longs, storytell-
‘Merchant’ misses the point
Continued from page 17
able, businesslike; and now Al Pacino,
2010, at the Broadhurst.
It isn’t every day you get to see a motion-
picture superstar return to the living stage
and do a very good job, like three of the four
above. Mr. Pacino, with his unmatchable
nervous energy and his bred-in-the-bone
sincerity, certainly gives us a Shylock to keep
in the books.
But the best “Merchant of Venice” I’ve
ever seen and savored was the one directed
by and starring Russian-born actor-teach-
er Boris Tumarin, at that little lost Off-
Broadway theater back in 1962.
Tumarin’s Shylock was a cold, austere,
DOWNTOWN MUSIC PRODUCTIONS
Mimi Stern-Wolfe, Artistic Director
EAST VILLAGE CONCERT SERIES
BENSON AIDS CONCERT
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 1, 2010 @ 8PM
ST MARKS IN THE BOWERY
131 EAST TENTH ST. (NR. SECOND AVE)
SUGGESTED DONATION: $12
November 25 - December 1, 2010 19
ing, dreidel games, kosher refreshments,
tours of the Preschool and more. This
year’s celebration will also feature the
premiere screening of a new series called
“Shalom Sesame” (from the creators of
Sesame Street). “Chanukah: The Missing
Menorah”finds that super-special blue
monster Grover stressing when his spe-
cial friend Anneliese van der Pol (of
“That’s So Raven” fame) gets caught in
a game of tag with a chicken and loses
her special menorah — just as Chanukah
is about to begin! This first-ever com-
munal viewing of the film, coordinated
by the JCC Association, will be a special
holiday treat for kids and parents alike.
Sun., Dec. 5, 10:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. at The
Educational Alliance Preschool (197 E.
Broadway. btw. Jefferson & Clinton Sts.).
FREE. Appropriate for children age 6
and under. For info, call 646-395-4251
or visit www.edalliance.org/preschool.
NOTE: The Preschool offers full day, half
day, extended day and 2, 3, 5 day/week
options. Financial aid is available. To
learn more and set up a tour, please call
646-395-4250 or email preschool@edalli-
ance.org. Applications are due December
30th, 2010. The Preschool is located at
197 E.Broadway on the Lower East Side.
disdainful man of some intellect, looking
down with utter contempt on all these
wastrel mercantile pleasure-seeking godless
yahoos gambling away recklessly with car-
goes far at sea. It was the kind of perfor-
mance and sheer conception that made you
shiver.
But the best Shylock that could ever be
imagined neither I nor you will ever get to
see. The son of a bitch died on us in 1977
during tryouts in Philadelphia on the way in
to Broadway with this confounding drama.
His name was Zero Mostel.
Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimen-
sions, senses…? Anyone who ever saw Zero
in full dimension as Leopold Bloom or
anyone else knows the answer to that. I’m
confident Al Pacino would agree.
20 November 25 - December 1, 2010
Just Do Art!
Continued from page 18
p.m. at the Merchant’s House Museum (29 E. Fourth St.
btw. Lafayette & Bowery). For reservations ($20 general
admission, $10 for MHM members), call 212-777-1089
or visit merchantshouse.org/calendar.
BLACK GOLD — THE PASSION OF ALEIJADINHO
Music, dance, mask work, puppetry, poetry and video
projections are used to tell the story of Antonio Francisco
Lisboa (1738-1814) — Baroque sculptor of Brazil. “Black
Gold” is the dramatic account of a man born a slave and
freed at birth by his Portuguese father, a master builder
of churches. Winning Brazil’s Grand Prize at the age of
18, Lisboa became the Michelangelo of his country. His
life parallels the gold rush in the colonial cities and the
development of Brazil in arts, religion and politics, reach-
ing for independence from the Portuguese and its own
identity. Sat., Dec. 4 at 7:30 p.m. and Sun., Dec. 5 at 3
p.m. at Shooting Star Theatre in South Street Seaport
(40 Peck Slip, 2 blocks north of Fulton St. btw. Front
and South Sts.). Admission $18.00. For reservations,
directions, and further info: www.ShootingStarTheatre.
org or 646-825-1864. Also visit www.NYartists.org or call
212-242-6036.
Support your local cinema!
FILM FORUM
At 209 W. Houston St.; Call 212-727-8110 or visit www.
filmforum.org. For the Box Office, call 212-727-8112.
A nonprofit cinema since 1970, Film Forum is serious about
delivering on its original mission statement. That mission? To
provide a home for “NYC theatrical premieres of American
independents and foreign art films” as well as “repertory selec-
tions including foreign and American classics, genre works,
festivals and directors’ retrospectives.” The third screen “is
dedicated to extended runs of popular selections from both
programs, as well as new films for longer engagements.”
THE ANGELIKA FILM CENTER & CAFE
At 18 West Houston St. (at Mercer St.); 212-995-2000;
www.angelikafilmcenter.com.
This Arthouse cinema, with a cafe for discussion and
socializing, boasts locations in both New York and Texas.
Its sister space here in the city is Village East Cinema (www.
villageeastcinema.com).
2
Image by Eric Zim
Ho, Ho, Retro: Stock up on Record & CD stocking
stuff at the ARChive Holiday Sale.
CINEMA VILLAGE
At 22 East 12th St. (btw. University Place & 5th
Ave.). Call 212-924-3363 or visit www.cinemavillage.
com.
Built in 1963 “in the shell of a turn of the century fire sta-
tion,” Cinema Village’s three screens thrive thanks to the fact
that they “exist where we are: in the midst of most diverse,
cosmopolitan and cine-aware of cities.”
ANTHOLOGY FILM ARCHIVES
At 32 Second Ave (at 2nd St.). Call 212-505-5181 or visit
www.anthologyfilmarchives.org.
Since 1970, Anthology has sought to “preserve,
exhibit, and promote public and scholarly understanding
of independent, classic, and avant-garde cinema.” That
translates, rather well, into screening over 900 film and
video programs annually — with time left over to publish
books and catalogs and preserve films (over 800 films
to date).
HOLIDAY RECORD & CD SALE
The ARChive of Contemporary Music’s Holiday Record
& CD sale helps support the ARChive — a not-for-profit
music library which collects, preserves and provides infor-
mation on popular music from 1950 to the present (they
keep two copies of all recordings released in America, and
their collection numbers over two million sound record-
ings). There will be over 20,000 items for sale — but
don’t worry about depleting the permanent collection.
The items are new donations from record companies and
collectors, and there’s not a used, returned or defective
product in the bunch. What you will find, though, will be
collectible LPs priced below book value, hundreds of CDs
priced at $1 to $5 each and cassettes 4 for $1.00. Not
enough? There will also be many hard to find 7” singles,
shelves of new music books, African, Reggae & world-
music releases, Classical LPs (most for 50¢ or LESS),
videos, 60s psychedelic posters, and Sony Yule log DVDs
(just released by Johnny Cash, Mariah Carey and Kenny
Chesney, for $5 each). For the dis-en-vinyled, ARChive’s
newly-departed food stylist neighbors left behind “TONS
of high-end and everyday kitchenware.” Support the
ARChive mission by becoming a member, and you’ll shop
the sale before the general public and be welcomed at
their Dec. 9 cocktail party. For membership details and
other info, call 212-226-6967, visit www.arcmusic.org
and check out their blog (arcmusic.wordpress.com). The
sale takes place Sat., Dec. 11 through Sun. Dec. 19, daily
FILM FORUM
At 209 W. Houston St.; Call 212-727-8110 or visit www.
filmforum.org. For the Box Office, call 212-727-8112.
A nonprofit cinema since 1970, Film Forum is serious
about delivering on its original mission statement. That
mission? To provide a home for “NYC theatrical premieres
of American independents and foreign art films” as well as
“repertory selections including foreign and American clas-
sics, genre works, festivals and directors’ retrospectives.”
The third screen “is dedicated to extended runs of popular
selections from both programs, as well as new films for lon-
ger engagements.”
IFC
At 323 Sixth Ave. (at West Third St.) Call 212-924-7771. For
the Box Office, call 212- 924-5246 or visit www.ifccenter.com.
Open since 2005, it’s hard to imagine the neighbor-
hood without this three-screen source of independent, foreign
and documentary features. IFC regular happenings include
“Weekend Classics” at 11 a.m. every Friday, Saturday and
Sunday — and cult movies every Friday and Saturday at
Midnight. Those dependable happenings are supplemented
by “Short Attention Span Cinema” (short films which screen
before every feature). It also has (as the website boasts and this
author can attest to) — “organic popcorn with real, natural but-
ter” at the concession stand. Sure, you’ll pay a little more for the
real thing; but what else is new?

Just Do Art!
Continued from page 20
from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. At 54 White St. (3 blocks south
of Canal, btw. Broadway & Church. Take the 1 train to
Franklin, or any train to Canal).
MONK IN MOTION: THREE C’S
“Monk in Motion: The Next Face of Jazz” is a partner-
ship between BMCC Tribeca Performing Arts Center and
the Thelonious Monk Institute that presents the top three
winners from the renowned Annual Thelonious Monk
International Jazz Competition. Each concert features one
winner and their combo from various parts of the world,
demonstrating the versatility and variety of different jazz
styles. The “Three C’s” program showcases Cécile McLorin
Salvant, Charenée Wade and Cyrille Aimée — who will per-
form three 7 p.m. solo concerts on Sat., Dec. 4, 11 and 18
respectively. Single tickets are $25 (students/seniors, $15).
Those who purchase tickets to two performances can see
the third presentation free. At BMCC Tribeca Performing
Arts Center, Theatre 2 (199 Chambers St. btw. Greenwich
& West St.).
DEAR EDWINA
After debuting in 2008, scoring two Drama Desk
nominations and enjoying a successful 2009 holiday sea-
son run, the musical “Dear Edwina” is fast becoming a
seasonal family-friendly tradition in league with visiting
the Macy’s windows and presenting a long wish list to a
certain jolly fellow on temporary leave from the North
Pole. This heartwarming show about the joys and frus-
trations of growing up. Has our spunky heroine, (advice-
“4 Boats and Orange Sky” (2009, 45 x 65 inches framed, oil on paper).
KATHRYN LYNCH: CHOPPY WATERS
Whether floating on tranquil waters against a brilliant orange sky or struggling amidst a blue-hued storm, the new oil on
canvas works which comprise Tribeca artist Kathryn Lynch’s third solo exhibition at Sears-Peyton Gallery are intimate con-
templations of the bliss and danger we court when venturing into uncharted territory. “Choppy Waters” features composi-
tions centered on a small sailboat navigating stormy waters and charged climates. Lynch describes her creative experience
as “getting to go on an adventure.” Go on one of your own — through Dec. 18, at Sears-Peyton Gallery, 210 11th Ave.,
Suite 802 (btw. 24th and 25th Sts.). Hours: Tues. – Fri., 10 a.m.-6 p.m and Sat., 11 a.m.–6 p.m. Call 212-966-7469 or visit
www.searspeyton.com.
Photo courtesy of the Merchant’s House Museum
Who’s that man in the mirror? See “Lecture” on page
18.
Image courtesy of Sears-Peyton Gallery NYC
November 25 - December 1, 2010 21
giver extraordinaire Edwina Spoonable) sharing he wis-
dom on everything from setting the table to making new
friends. That it’s done through clever, catchy and poi-
gnant songs makes the experience enjoyable and engag-
ing for kids who know what Edwina’s going through as
well as adults who remember what it was like. Dec. 17
through Feb. 25 at the DR2 Theatre (103 E. 15th St.).
For tickets ($39), call 212-239-6200. For groups of 10 or
more, call 646-747-7400. Visit www.dearedwina.com for
additional details and full playing schedule.
ADVENTURE THEATER!
This interactive theatrical adventure for heroes of all
ages is brought to you by The Metropolitan Playhouse.
The dynamic improv company Freestyle Repertory
Theatre (which has been known to bring audience mem-
bers on stage to become part of the action) leads this
family-friendly immersive experience in which you invent
the plot, provide sound effects, become the scenery and
play important characters. “Adventure Theater” is per-
fect for children ages 5-13. The details differ every time,
but here’s the plot in a nutshell: The inhabitants of a
magical land desperately need your help. A wicked leader
has risen to power, and an emissary is sent to the mortal
world to seek a hero powerful enough to return peace,
happiness and prosperity to the inhabitants. Our Hero
— played by a child chosen from the audience — travels
to the magical land, meets fabulous creatures, makes
powerful friends and faces great dangers. Meanwhile,
the wicked leader is all too aware of our Hero’s presence
and is gleefully making plans for their ultimate meeting!
Dec. 4 through Dec. 12, 11 a.m. Saturdays and Sundays,
at Metropolitan Playhouse (220 E. 4th St. btw. Aves. A
& B). Tickets are $10 for children twelve, $12 for adults.
To order, call 212-995-5302 or visit www. metropolitan-
playhouse.org.
WALKING TOUR: MARK TWAIN’S NEW YORK
This walking tour lets it be known that 100 years after
his death, (figurative) footprints remain in Manhattan
made by Samuel L. Clemens (better known as Mark
Twain). “Mark Twain’s New York” reveals the specifics
of the famed Missouri-born, Mississippi-bred author’s
decades-long relationship with our decidedly northern
town. Writer Peter Salwen leads this tour of little-
known Twain-related sites peppered throughout lower
Manhattan. Tickets are $20. The walk starts at Broadway
and Spring St., on the Southeast corner (in front of the
Gap store). Walks take place at 1 p.m., Saturdays and
Sundays, through Nov. 28. The “Mark Twain’s New York”
birthday tour happens at 1 p.m. on Tues., Nov. 30 (Mark
Twain’s 175th birthday!). For details, call 917-620-5371
or visit www.salwen.com/twain.pdf.
FDNY PHOTO EXHIBITION
The FDNY is showcased through the work of New
Orleans native, and photographer, Lilli M. Albin —
whose exhibition “Selections from ‘On The Job’ ” fea-
tures pieces focusing on the public and private space
within NYC’s firehouses. As for the sponsoring venue:
The New York City Fire Museum (the official museum of
the FDNY) is located in a 1904 firehouse which has been
repurposed to house over 10,000 artifacts from NYC’s
rich heritage of firefighting. The Museum is open Tue.
through Sat., 10 a.m.–5 p.m. and Sundays 10 a.m.–4
.pm. Suggested admission is $7 for adults and $5 for
children, students and seniors. The exhibit runs through
Jan. 30, 2011. At the New York City Fire Museum (278
Spring St.) For info, call 212-691-1303 or visit www.
nycfiremuseum.org.
22 November 25 - December 1, 2010

CLASSIFIEDS www.thevillager.com
Chelnow
sea
www.chelseanow.com
downtown
®
express
www.downtownexpress.com

DEADLINE WEDNESDAY 5:00 PM MAIL 145 SIXTH AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10013 TEL 646-452-2485 FAX 212-229-2790

APARTMENT RENTAL PRINTING FINANCIAL DENTIST

FRENCH RIVIERA. Charming townhouse, Lithomatic Business
authentic village Gorges du Loup, Forms, Inc. 


France, near Nice, Cannes, Grasse. Established 1971 BPA & MERCURY FREE
New service - Shredding of your
Breathtaking views, 2 bdrm, 2 bath Non-invasive dentistry for kids!
$1250/wk. Available year round, turn key personal papers.
furnished. 941-363-0925 Continuous Business forms,

  
Snap-a-part Forms, Laser Forms & 

REAL ESTATE Checks for all systems. Offset form,

4-Color Post Cards. Announcements,
TriBeca - Laight & Washington Streets
For lease: Apprx 4000SP, ground floor,
Envelopes, Letterheads &   Helping our
Business Cards, Xeroxing, Bindery &
M15/TMU/Area B-2 zone district.
Mailing Services on site

  ! kids stay safe,
Conforming uses (wholesale/manuf)
NO Retail. Ask $50/SF. Call: 212-508-7334
Tel: 212-255-6700 " #$! % healthy and smart
Fax: 212-242-5963
233 West 18th Street, NYC 10011


 
WARWICK, NEW YORK (Next Door to the Chelsea Post Office)
 
FSBO

   
COMMERCIAL SPACE     Dr. Lewis Gross, D.D.S.
Dr. Lewis Gross, D.D.S.
• Lifestyle Change www.holistic-dentists.com | Tribeca, New York
www.holistic-dentists.com | Tribeca, New York
SOHO - Manufacturing space.
• Established High Ideal for service, industrial. Ground
End Antique floor 5.750 sq ft plus basement
Business $70/sf Call 212-944-7979
• Historic Barn
HOME IMPROVEMENT
www. EASTVILLAGERNEWS .com
Charming 4 BR Home Wall Women Painting & Plastering
45 miles NYC • $895,000 Over 25 yrs experience. Located in Chel-
www.warwickantiquebarn.com sea area. Excellent References.
845-986-7979 Brokers Welcome Free estimate
Call 212-675-0631 or 917-273-770

ANNOUNCEMENT COMPUTER SERVICES

PERSONAL COMPUTER SERVICES
Reliable!
Repairs, upgrades, installations,
Be KIND to troubleshooting, instruction,
custom-built PCs and consulting.
yourself 212-242-7221

and TUTOR
Be Kind to others Creative Minds' Tutoring
Pre-Kindergarten to Adults
All subjects/levels, educational

— June G
nannies, developmental
therapies, itinerant teaching,
early intervention &
Thank you
party planning.
Call Elizabeth @ 718/812-1910 for the fantastic pizza
& salads... Excellent lunch!
Need to place a legal ad for
- From your friends at The Villager Newspapers
your business? Call 646-452-2471
Jason Sherwood / Senior Marketing Consultant
legalads@thevillager.com
www.thevillager.com
 November 25 - December 1, 2010 23

Photos by Clayton Patterson

Oh, ja! Freaky fun at the Wild Style show in Germany

For the past several weeks, documentarian Clayton Patterson has been in Germany with the Wild Style show, a combination of
CLAYTON’S PAGE sideshow-type acts and tattoo convention. He’ll return to the Lower East Side in early December. Above and below left, Lucky
Diamond Rich, the world’s most tattooed man — whose tattoo transformation Patterson has photographed over the years — per-
formed for the crowd. Below right, a horned acrobat hung around.
24 November 25 - December 1, 2010

OUR EVERYDAY LOW PRICES

Vinho Verde Rioja Vallobera Yellowtail
BEAUJOLAIS Pago Malarina Shiraz, Merlot
J.M. Fonseca
NOUVEAU Twin Vines or Chardonnay
EST ARRIVE! 2008 750ML 4.99 2005 750ML 7.99 1.5ML 10.99
Sterling Discover our great values, low prices, incredible selection and huge inventory. Pierre Sparr
Vintner’s Collection Warehouse Wines offers warehouse values and warehouse quantities each and every Riesling or Gewurzt
Chardonnay day. Since we buy big, you always save big. We try harder bottle-by-bottle, to bring Alsace
2008 750ML 7.99 our customers the best values.
750ML 9.99
We have wine to meet all tastes and all budgets. Our enormous selection of wine
under $10 is the finest in New York City. We always have brand-name liquor at
Shiraz bargain prices too! Our knowledgeable sales staff is available to assist with your Lindemans Cawarra
Kumala selections, both large and small. Come in and let us welcome you to New York’s Semillon Chardonnay
South Africa greatest wine and liquor superstore, where everything is on sale every day. Shop
2004 750ML 5.99 with us and save with us. You’ll be glad you did!
2007 750ML 3.99
Ch. Serilhan Los Vascos Chardonnay Blackstone
St. Estephe Cabernet Sauvignon B&G Bistro Wine Cabernet Sauvignon
France Sonoma County
2006 750ML 10.99 2007 750ML 7.99 2006 750ML 4.99 750ML 9.99
Pinot Noir Louis Jadot Sauvignon Blanc Malbec Old Vines
Cono Sur Macon Red Canyon Terra Rosa
Chile New Zealand Argentina
2008 750ML 6.99 2007 750ML 10.99 2007 750ML 7.99 2007 750ML 5.99
Zinfandel Albarino Merlot Chardonnay Toscana
Havenscourt Serra da Estrela Longball Cellars Donna di Valiano
Johan Santana
2005 750ML 5.99 2007 750ML 7.99 2006 750ML 3.99 750ML 3.99

WAREHOUSE WINES & SPIRITS

735 Broadway Mon-Th 9am-8:45pm
Phone 212-982-7770 Fri & Sat 9am-9:45pm
Fax 212-982-7791 Sunday noon-6:45pm
Yes, We Deliver
Credit card purchases in store only. We reserve the right to limit quantities.
Not responsible for typographical errors. Prices effective through December 2, 2010.