Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract
Since the 1980s seismic microzonation studies have been undertaken in Australia to assess the likely eects of earthquakes on
urban centres built on unconsolidated sediments. Presently the Nakamura method is used for processing data.
So far parts of Perth, Adelaide, Cairns, Gladstone, Rockhampton, Newcastle, Sydney and Launceston have been zoned. The
Launceston, Tasmania, study was the pilot study for many of these as it re®ned the methodology used and the data obtained
were incorporated into a GIS database. Building heights and site factor zoning maps were produced for the Launceston City
Council.
One of the major activities, of the new initiative by the Australian Geological Survey Organisation (AGSO), popularly known
as the `Cities Project', is coordinating seismic microzonation throughout Australia. Microzonation data have been included in
AGSO's geohazards GIS database. This is helping local councils zone land for seismic hazards. State Emergency Services use the
information to plan for emergencies resulting from the eects of earthquakes. These practical applications of seismic
microzonation data will help mitigate the destructive eects of any future large earthquakes occurring near major urban centres.
In the Launceston case it was found that there is a variable risk dependant on epicentral distance and the nature of relatively
unconsolidated sediments in various parts of the city. Disastrous ampli®cation could occur at some sites. # 1999 Elsevier
Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
2. Australian earthquakes
* Tel.: +61-3-6226-2476; fax: +61-3-6223-7547.
E-mail address: vagn.jensen@utas.edu.au (V.H. Jensen). Australian earthquakes are shallow (McCue et al.,
1367-9120/00/$ - see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 1 3 6 7 - 9 1 2 0 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 0 4 8 - 6
4 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
Fig. 3. Map of Australia, showing acceleration coecient (a) with a 10% chance of being exceeded in 50 years (Australian Standard 1170.4-
1993).
the damage in the 28 December 1989, Newcastle earth- 4. AS1170.4-1993, loading code
quake (Somerville et al., 1993).
Three factors contribute to the degree of vibration a In 1993 the Australian Standard 2121-1979
structure experiences during an earthquake: (Standards Australia, 1979) earthquake loading code
was replaced with Australian Standard AS1170.4-1993
1. the structure itself, its height and mass (resonant (Standards Australia, 1993) which incorporates the
period); knowledge gained from a greatly improved earthquake
2. the footings; data base accumulated over an additional 14 years of
3. the materials the footings are anchored to (see instrumental recordings.
above). This last item determines the ''S' factor used AS1170.4-1993, incorporates maps of Australia
in AS1170.4 1993 (see below). (`S' 0.65=solid rock, showing the acceleration coecient (an index related
`S' 2.0= > 12 m of loose sand etc.). to the expected severity of earthquake ground motion
measured in % g) with a 10% chance of being
It is assumed for the discussions in this paper that a exceeded in 50 years. A probabilistic analysis was car-
single storey building has a resonant period of 0.1 s, a ried out to produce maps with contours of locations
two storey 0.2 s and so on, generalising to an N storey with equal probabilities of receiving speci®c ground
building having a period of 0.1N s. motion for average ground conditions (Fig. 3).
6 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
Fig. 4. Seismogram of 8 May, 1990, Cadoux earthquake. Note the dierence in amplitude (>10 times) between Mundaring (rock site) and
Kewdale (Perth Basin sediments).
The urban areas discussed in this paper are not aver- soil deposits, i.e. a resonance type response due to pro-
age ground conditions, but unconsolidated sediments gressive lengthening of the structure period. NEHRP
(also described by various authors as soils, ®ll and (1988) stated that this resonance response is most
alluvium) with low shear wave velocities. These are to likely for structures having calculated periods greater
some degree accounted for in the tables of the site fac- than or equal to 0.7 s. Structures with natural periods
tor `S' for general and domestic structures associated of less than 0.5 s do not require these analysis pro-
with various soil pro®les. However the site factors cedures.
used appear to be too low. The maximum ratio of Note that the 0.7 s calculated structure period is
ampli®cation allowed for in the Loading Code is three comparable to the calculated predominant soil period
(from 0.67±2). In their conclusions to a microzonation (Tsoil) for soft soils considered as a single layer system
paper on Rockhampton, McCue and Boreham (1996) using the following equation with hn=20 m Vs=120 m/
make this comment: ``We have highlighted the poten- s'':
tial for a resonance between the building's natural
4hn
period and that of a soil layer on which it is founded, Tsoil
Vs
and suggest the need for revision of the table specify-
ing soil factors in the Loading Code.'' Gaull et al. where hn=total height of the structure above the struc-
(1995) mentions that the maximum peak ground vel- tural base; Vs=total earthquake shear velocity (in m/
ocity measured during the 8 May 1990, Cadoux earth- s).
quake, at the KEW site (unconsolidated sediments in Samali et al. (1994) discuss the acceleration response
Perth) was ten times that at the reference site MGO spectrum proposed in AS 1170.4-1993 in relation to
(Mundaring Geophysical Observatory), a rock site the dynamic analysis of buildings and other structures
(Fig. 4). and attempt to analyse ®ve major Australian earth-
In the AS 1170.4 Supplement 1-1993, some attention quakes to develop a unique Australian design response
is drawn to the importance of the resonance eect of spectra for inclusion in any future revised loading
unconsolidated deep sediment. The following comment code.
is made; ``Special dynamic analysis procedures should Many civil engineers in Australia are still unaware
be adopted for structures judged to be susceptible to of both the resonance eect of deep sediments and the
`Mexico City' (see Ampli®cation) type damage on soft seismic microzonation data that have been accumu-
V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15 7
lated over the last few years. Any new loading code
needs to pay more attention to these matters so that
engineers designing structures to be erected on uncon-
solidated sediments will be aware of and use the infor-
mation available. King (1996) comments: ``It is
essential that the end user (i.e. the structural engineer)
is able to accurately determine which soil conditions
should be applied to any given site. Thus although
shear wave velocity may be the actual site parameter
to be considered, a fuller description of geotechnical
properties (such as depth, density, cohesion, etc.) may
be needed to minimise the designer uncertainty.''
5. Empirical methods used to estimate local site Fig. 5. Block diagram of ®eld equipment set up.
response frequency and ampli®cation
this method (Gaull et al., 1995, Somerville et al., 1993;
Until 1989, the Standard Spectral Ratio (SSR)
McCue and Boreham, 1996). AGSO plans to reassess
method or variations of it were used in seismic micro-
the Perth data using the Nakamura method (see
zonation studies throughout the world. Nakamura
below) in the near future.
(1989) proposed a new method, the Single Station
Spectral Ratio (SSSR), now known as the `Nakamura'
method, which measures the three components of 5.2. Single station spectral ratio (SSSR) or `Nakamura'
background noise at a site and from these computes method
the site-speci®c resonant frequency. This latter method
has been used extensively in Australia. In a classic paper, Nakamura (1989) proposed using
the ever present microtremor low amplitude vibration
5.1. Standard Spectral Ratio (SSR) method in the ground (1±10 microns), due to waves, wind, cars
and trucks, etc. instead of the shockwave from an
The SSR method measures the spectral (Fourier) earthquake. This method does not require a reference
ratio of earthquake shaking at low velocity unconsoli- station. Nakamura found good agreement between his
dated sedimentary sites with respect to a nearby bed- method and that of recording actual earthquakes (the
rock reference site. Seismographs are installed in the SSR method). His method involves computing the
®eld and left to record earthquakes. As long as the spectral ratio of each of the horizontal components
spacing is relatively small the path eects will be simi- (E±W and N±S) of ground motion relative to the verti-
lar. The method gives the frequency dependent site re- cal component. Lermo and Chavaz-Garcia (1994) and
sponse amplitude, or ampli®cation, relative to the rock Field et al. (1995) found this technique to give the best
site. result in estimating the dominant period of a site,
This method works well where there are frequent when compared with the results from an actual earth-
earthquakes as is the case in New Zealand, but even quake.
there it is cumbersome and expensive as a great num- The Nakamura method gives the best site frequency
ber of seismographs are needed or it will take an im- response estimate available at the moment and also
practical amount of time to acquire enough data to gives some indication of the ampli®cation to be
zone an area. In Australia earthquakes are far too expected at a site. The theory behind his method is not
infrequent to use this method. well understood.
The SSR method has also been attempted recording The Nakamura method can be used on windy days
microtremor noise, rather than actual earthquakes, and at times of heavy trac, provided noise sources
simultaneously on hard rock and sediments and then are not too close to the recording equipment (Michael-
take the spectral ratio of the recorded components. In Leiba, 1995). This is the method mostly used in recent
Launceston, Tasmania this method was tried at the seismic microzonation surveys in Australia, except for
Coronation Park (sediments) and Gees Lookout (the Perth, one Newcastle study and Rockhampton. It
nearest dolerite rock site). However the noise level was lends itself well to the Australian situation, where
so much greater at the sediment site that the spacial earthquakes are rare phenomena. Additional advan-
ratios could not be used to determine the resonance tages are low cost and the speed with which many sites
period. In Perth, WA, Newcastle, NSW and (upwards of 50 or more) can be sampled in one day.
Rockhampton, Qld, useful data were obtained using A Norwegian paper (Atakan and Havskov, 1996)
8 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
6.2. Processing
Fig. 7. Australian urban centres that have been microzoned as part of the `Cities Project'.
V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15 9
Fig. 8. Earthquake epicentres in the Tasmanian Region. (Michael-Leiba and Jensen, 1995/96).
In its ®rst phase, this project will run from 1996±97 8. Tasmania
to 1999±2000. During this period it is planned to
develop techniques, methodologies and standards 8.1. Launceston
tested in `real world' pilot studies. The research pro-
gram was centred on Cairns and Gladstone, Between 1884 and the present, the city of
Queensland, in 1996±97. During the remainder of the Launceston, Tasmania, has been damaged on ®ve oc-
®rst phase period the following centres are also being casions by earthquakes with epicentres up to 200 km
covered: Mackay, greater Brisbane, the Gold Coast, away in the West Tasman Sea, just east of Flinders
the Sunshine Coast together with Botany (Sydney), Island (Fig. 8). As it was thought that the damage was
Adelaide, Launceston and Newcastle. In each of these due to ampli®ed site response (Michael-Leiba and
studies the emphasis will be on undertaking detailed Jensen, 1993), the Launceston City Council requested
seismic and other microzonation studies. Parallel stu- AGSO to prepare a zoning map of Launceston with
dies of community vulnerability will be undertaken zones related to the requirements of Australian
and mapped in the same Risk-GIS environment Standard AS 1170.4-1993 (Standards Australia, 1993).
(AGSO, 1997). AGSO has developed computer pro- A seismic microzonation survey was carried out during
grams with the capability to model the two-dimen- 1994/95 using the Nakamura method and equipment
sional wave®eld earthquake shaking sediments. as mentioned above. Recordings were made at 53 sites
The `Cities Project' has been established to maximise on sediment and three on dolerite.
the safety, sustainability and prosperity of urban com- As the depths of sediments were not well known, R.
munities. To achieve this, it develops and disseminates Richardson, Mineral Resources Tasmania (unpub-
the best available information for urban planners, en- lished), carried out a detailed gravity survey. It
gineers, emergency managers and risk managers to use revealed (Fig. 9) a complex geology involving at least
in mitigating the eects on the community of the two deep NNW±SSE trending valleys ®lled with vari-
impact of a wide range of geological hazards. ably consolidated sediments (Leaman, 1994). Some
10 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
cover from these valleys still exist on hill sides and further to the east on a thinner (80 m) layer of sedi-
tops and pose a landslip risk; from hydrological and ments (Fig. 11, L7).
potentially from seismic causes. Any future earth- The results of this study suggest ampli®ed responses
quakes will aect these built-up areas. of Tertiary and Quaternary sediments at 46 of the 53
Fig. 10 shows a 2D modeled cross section of line 4 sediment sites with periods ranging from 0.1 to more
on the gravity map (Fig. 9). The Brick®elds Reserve than 1 s. The three dolerite sites showed no site reson-
station was situated on deep (240 m) sediments on the ance (Fig. 11).
Trevallyn Fault (Fig. 11, L6) and Windmill Hill Sediments in the deep valleys showed ampli®cation
V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15 11
Fig. 10. 2D gravity model of line four of the Launceston gravity map (Fig. 9). Black is unconsolidated sediments (Leaman, 1994).
at periods from 0.7 to greater than 1 s (Fig. 11, L6), District. The buildings which would be most aected
which would be expected to most aect medium and by site resonance in this area would be low or medium
high rise buildings. Ceilings of houses in this zone rise buildings. There have been several reported cases
have been damaged by earthquakes. Natural periods of earthquake damage to these types of structures in
of 0.1±0.5 s were measured on Quaternary and this area.
Tertiary sediments overlying shallow dolerite basement Based on the microtremor measurements, the new
in the eastern part of Launceston's Central Business soils map (Forsyth, 1995), the gravity results and
Fig. 11. Four resonant frequency plots of Launceston sites. L12, L3 are dolerite sites, and L7, L6 are unconsolidated sediment sites. Note the
shift in frequency with depth of unconsolidated sediments (L7, L6).
12 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
9.1. Perth
10. South Australia
Perth is situated within 100 km of one of the most
seismically active zones in Australia (Fig. 12). Between 10.1. Adelaide
the years 1960 and 1995 the city has experienced the
shakings of an earthquake every year, the most The city of Adelaide has been subjected to a number
V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15 13
11.1. Sydney that the urban areas of the major cities should be
zoned for earthquake risk.
The Sydney Pilot Earthquake Microzonation Project In the case of Newcastle the area experiencing the
(Jones et al., 1996) was undertaken to demonstrate a greatest seismic intensity was located 10 km from the
technique which zones the likely ground shaking re- epicentre and roughly corresponded to the area of allu-
sponse to potential earthquake activity, and to deter- vial or ®ll cover (Figs. 13 and 14). The fault mechan-
mine the utility of the technique as an aid to ism was such that maximum shear wave energy would
emergency response planning in the Sydney region. be directed toward Newcastle, thus aggravating the
The area chosen covers the Homebush Bay± magni®ed shakings experienced as a result of the soil
Silverwater±Concord area and was selected because it ampli®cation due to deep unconsolidated sediments.
encompasses a variety of ground conditions and a The Newcastle seismic microzonation study by
large amount of geological, cultural and spatial data Somerville et al. (1993) used the SSR method (dis-
are available. The area covers about 4 by 5 km. cussed above). It found a good correlation between
Data from 1300 boreholes and pits were used to building damage and alluvial/®ll cover. Ampli®ed re-
compile a three-dimensional geological map. Also sponse was observed at frequencies ranging from 1.5
three hazard zonation maps were interpreted from the to 10 Hz, at sites with alluvial depth ranging from 40
geological and microtremor information. The two cri- to 5 m.
teria used to distinguish the zones in the three maps The Newcastle Region Public Library has accumu-
were the Site Factor (S) and the vibrational period lated a huge database with over 3000 bibliographical
range over which resonance and ampli®cation may be entries on the Newcastle earthquake. It brings together
observed. all the published and unpublished information relating
to the 1989 earthquake. This can be accessed via
11.2. Newcastle INTERNET. Two CDs have been produced: 1.
Earthquake & the Built Environment, and 2.
The 28 December, 1989, Richter magnitude 5.6 Engineering & Applied Science. The Library-address
Newcastle, NSW, earthquake dispelled forever the is: P.O. Box 489, Newcastle, NSW 2300.
notion that urban areas of Australia did not have to
worry about earthquake hazards. With 13 fatalities,
160 injuries and the greatest insurance payout 12. Conclusions
(>AU$2 billion) in Australian recorded history, all
due to a relatively small earthquake, it became obvious Since 1989 many seismic microzonation studies have
14 V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15
Fig. 14. Correspondence between the area of alluvial and/or ®ll cover (dashed line) and the area of highest intensity. Squares are microtremor
monitoring sites. The depth to bedrock (m) is indicated. (Somerville et al., 1993).
been undertaken in Australia. Lately these have used gravity map of Launceston, and Debbie Harding,
the `NAKAMURA' method. Much useful data have Harding & Associates, for her excellent drafting of the
been accumulated and incorporated into the `Cities ®gures.
Project' GIS database. A greatly improved understand-
ing of earthquake hazard in Australia has been gained.
This information should be incorporated into the next
References
Australian Standards Loading Code. An education
program should also be undertaken to make practicing Atakan, K., Havskov, J., 1996. Local site eects in northern North
civil engineers aware of the information available. The Sea based on the single-station spectral ratio of OBS recordings.
work undertaken in Australia could easily be dupli- Terra Nova 8 (1), 22±33.
cated in other regions, such as South East Asia, at a AGSO, 1997. Cities Project. The National Geohazards Vulnerability
of Urban Community project brochure.
modest cost, but potentially with huge savings in lives
Field, E.H., Clement, A.C., Jacob, K.H., Aharonian, V., Hough,
and money. S.E., Friberg, P.A., Babaian, T.O., Karapetian, S.S.,
Hovanessian, S.M., Abramian, H.A., 1995. Earthquake site-re-
sponse study in Giumri (formerly Leninakan), Armenia, using
ambient noise observations. Bulletin of the Seismological Society
Acknowledgements of America 85 (1), 349±353.
Forsyth, S. 1995. Launceston Geodata Project. Industry, Safety and
The Seismology Research Centre, Royal Melbourne Mines Division, Tasmania Development and Resources.
Gaull, B.A., Michael-Leiba, M.O., 1987. Probabilistic earthquake
Institute of Technology (RMIT), Melbourne, Vic., risk maps of southwest Western Australia. BMR Journal of
Australia, manufacture Kelunji seismographs. I wish Australian Geology and Geophysics 10, 147±151.
to thank Brian Gaull, Guria Consulting, Witchclie, Gaull, B., Kagami, H., Taniguchi, H., Gregson, P., Woad, G., Page,
WA, Gary Gibson, Seismology Research Centre, B., 1990. Preliminary results of the microzonation of Perth metro-
RMIT, Melbourne, Vic., Marion Michael-Leiba, politan Area using microtremor spectral ratios. In: Gregson, P.J.
(Ed.), Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics
AGSO, Canberra, ACT, for reading the manuscript Record 1990/44.
critically and suggesting improvements and corrections. Gaull, B.A., Taniguchi, H., Kagami, H., 1992. Microzonation of
I also thank David Leaman for his comments on the Perth, Australia, using microtremors. In: Proceedings of the 10th
V.H. Jensen / Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 18 (2000) 3±15 15
World Conference on Earthqauke Engineering, Madrid, 19±24 McCue, K., Boreham, B., Van Dissen, R., Gibson, G., Jensen, V.,
July 1992, Balkema, Rotterdam, pp. 6235±6240. McKavanagh, B. 1996. The Lake Edgar fault scarp Tasmania; a
Gaull, B.A., Kagami, H., Taniguchi, H., 1995. The microzonation of Holocene thrust caused by two or more magnitude 6+ earth-
Perth, Western Australia, using microtremor spectral ratios. quakes. In preparation.
Earthquake Spectra 11 (2), 173±191. Michael-Leiba, M. 1995. Microtremor Survey and Seismic
Gibson, G., 1990. An Introduction to Seismology. In: Conference on Microzonation Launceston, Tasmania. Report to Launceston
the Newcastle Earthquake, Newcastle, 15±17 February 1990. City Council. AGSO.
Jones, T.D., Neville, M.J., Scott, G., Sinadinovski, C. 1996. Results Michael-Leiba, M., Jensen, V., 1993. The West Tasman Sea
from the Sydney Pilot Earthquake Microzonation Project, (Flinders Island) earthquake of 14 September 1946. BMR Journal
Western Paci®c Geophysics Meeting, AGU. Brisbane, Australia of Australian Geology & Geophysics 13, 369±372.
EOS, Transactions of the American Geophysical Union, Vol. 77, Michael-Leiba, M., Jensen, V.H. 1995/96. Seismic microzonation of
issue 22. Launceston, Tasmania, The Australian Journal of Emergency
Kagami, H., Taniguchi, H., Gaull, B.A., 1991. A Study on Management. 10(4), 22±26.
Microzonation of Perth Basin Western Australia, Through Nakamura, Y., 1989. A method for dynamic characteristics esti-
Microtremor Measurements. In: Proceedings Fourth mation of subsurface using microtremor on the ground surface.
International Conference on Seismic Zonation, August 25±29. Quarterly Report of the Railway Technical Research Institute 30
Stanford University, Stanford, California, USA. (1), 25±33.
King, A., 1996. The Fundamentals of an Earthquake Standard. In: NEHRP, 1988. National Earthquake Reduction Program,
Proceedings of a seminar held by the Australian Earthquake Recommended Provisions for the Development of Seismic
Engineering Society, Adelaide, S.A, pp. 8±15. Regulations for New Buildings, Federal Emergency Management,
Leaman, D.E. 1994. Assessment of gravity survey, City of USA.
Launceston, for Launceston City Corporation seismic study. Samali, D., Parsanejad, S., Peterson, M., 1994. Response spectra for
Unpublished. Australian Earthquake. Australian Civil Engineering
Lermo, J., Chavaz-Garcia, F.J., 1994. Are microtremors useful in Transactions CE36 (1), 89±96.
site response evaluation? . Bulletin of the Seismological Society of Singh, S.K., Mena, E., Castro, R., 1988. Some aspects of source
America 84 (5), 1350±1364. characteristics of the 19 September Michoacan Earthquake and
Love, D.N. 1996. Seismic Hazard and Microzonation of the ground motion ampli®cation in and near Mexico City from
Adelaide Metropolitan Area. Report Book 96/27. Department of Strong ground motion data. Bulletin of the Seismological Society
Mines and Energy South Australia. of America 78 (2), 451±477.
Love, D.N., Bierbaum, S.J., Poulos, H., Greenhalgh, S.A., 1995. Somerville, M.R., Kagami, H., McCue, K.F., 1993. Seismic ampli®-
Seismic risk analysis and microzonation of Adelaide. In: Paci®c cation determined from microtremor monitoring at alluvial and
Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Melbourne, Australia, rock sites in Newcastle. Bulletin of the New Zealand National
vol. 2, pp. 59±67. Society for Earthquake Engineering 26 (2), 175±183.
McCue, K., Boreham, B., 1996. Microzonation for an earthquake Spence, W., Sipkin, S., Choy, G., 1989. Earthquakes and Volcanoes,
risk assessment at Rockhampton Queensland and implications for 21, 1, pp. 58±63.
AS1170.4, Transactions Institution of Engineers. Australian Civil Standards Australia 1979. SAA Earthquake Code. Australian
Engineering CE 38 (1). Standard 2121-1979.
McCue, K., Dent, V., Jones, T., 1995. The characteristics of Standards Australia 1993. Minimum design loads on structures
Australian strong ground motion. In: Paci®c Conference on (known as SAA Loading Code). Part 4: Earthquake loads.
Earthquake Engineering, Melbourne, Australia, vol. 1, pp. 71±80. Australian Standard AS1170.4-1993.