Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
i
Chemical Plant Design Project Coordinator:
atawfieq@ugm.ac.id
Contributors:
ii
Preface
Plant Design Project (TKK 4280) is offered in the final semester (8th semester) along
with Industrial Placement (TKK 4281), Elective 4 and Elective 5. All subjects offered in the
final year (4th year) contain mainly advanced learning outcomes according to IChemE’s M-
Standard. Since the academic year of 2016/2017, Chemical Engineering Department
Universitas Gadjah Mada adopts M-Standard set by the Institution of Chemical Engineering
(IChemE) for the 2016 Undergraduate Curriculum. Therefore, it is important that all the
student learning, including Plant Design Project will facilitate the students in achieving the
standard learning outcomes stated by the 2016 Undergraduate Curriculum.
Plant Design Project is a capstone in Chemical Engineering Education which facilitates
Chemical Engineering students applying all subjects they have learned. In this project,
students have to integrate chemical engineering principles, product quality, safety,
environmental impacts, together with any economic considerations.
This guideline gives any information related to aspects of the Plant Design Project in
Department of Chemical Engineering, Universitas Gadjah Mada, such as objectives, learning
outcomes, management, and implementation, including monitoring, evaluation, and
assessment.
The department strongly believes that the Plant Design Project is one of the most
important elements of preparing highly competent future chemical engineers that will
assure a sustainable contribution of the chemical engineering profession to the prosperity of
the society. This mission can be realized only with close collaboration among the
universities, the industries, and chemical engineers professionals.
Any inquiries and suggestions on Plant Design Project should be directed to the Plant
Design Project Coordinator.
iii
Table of Content
Cover Page i
List of Contributors ii
Preface iii
Table of Content iv
I. Introduction 1
IV. Scope 1
V. Management 2
VI. Implementation 2
IX. Others 5
Appendixes 8
Attachment I.2: Example of quantitative flow diagram and overall mass balance macroscopic 13
Attachment I.3: Chapter “Occupational Safety, Health and Environment aspect consideration” 14
iv
GUIDELINE OF PLANT DESIGN PROJECT
FOR CHEMICAL ENGINEERING STUDENT
FACULTY OF ENGINEERING, UNIVERSITAS GADJAH MADA
I. Introduction
Plant Design Project is a capstone of Chemical Engineering Education in Universitas Gadjah Mada, and
a part of academic curriculum. In this project, students are trained to design a chemical plant by applying
knowledge they have previously learned. Here, students tackle various open-ended design problems in which
they sometimes need an iterative process to obtain a feasible solution.
The objective of Plant Design Project is to build students’ ability to design a chemical plant at
preliminary level by integrating elements of production system. In the project, students apply chemical
engineering tools (material balance, energy balance, rate processes, equilibrium, economics, and humanity)
along with best practices into a whole process system. The system must consider the aspects of Safety, Health,
and Environment (SHE) and sustainability. The students are trained to demonstrate their analysis-synthetic
ability. Various knowledge they have learned are applied in a comprehensive and integrative manner. Focus of
the design project is the application of engineering principles (scientific engineering, not engineering science)
in problem solving. That is the reason why interaction and communication between students and their project
supervisor play a vital role in the process. Hence, process during the design project is much more important
than the output of design itself. Through this project, students are expected to develop their soft skills, such as
communication, team work, and working within a timeframe.
1. To explain: background of a process, its implementation (plant location, market, etc.), and
societal impacts; and to describe the philosophy of process control.
2. To construct a complete process flow diagram of a process.
3. To perform detail design calculation for main equipment of a process and quick designs for
other equipment; with sound justification of the taken considerations and assumptions and
also to choose appropriate referenced standard.
4. To work with incomplete information or uncertain, interpret and quantify the effect of this
on the design and, where appropriate, use theory or experimental research to mitigate
deficiencies 1.
5. To evaluate economic feasibility of the project.
6. To prepare written report of the preliminary design and to present it.
IV. Scope
Plant Design project is a chemical plant design at preliminary level, consisting of: preliminary process
selection and economic review (market analysis, site selection), preliminary process design (process flow
diagram, mass balance, and energy balance), process equipment design (sizing, specification), lay out,
preliminary SHE analysis, sustainability, process control, utility, management and organization, as well as
economic analysis.
1
This project is considered as an exercise for students to do plant design. The data required for the design are
not solely derived from research, experiment, or literature, but can also be obtained from estimation, rule of
thumb, and or empirical formulas.
V. Management
The Design Project activities are directed by the Head of Study Program, supported by assistant, a
team of mentors, and project supervisors (lecturers) for each team. In addition, student assistants for CAD
(Computer Aided Design) and Engineering Drawing are also available. Job and responsibility for each personnel
are ruled by the Department.
VI. Implementation
2) Project Schedule
A student group already got the title is obliged to pursue whole steps of the project on schedule. The
project is strictly limited in 33 weeks which is divided into 7 stages:
• Stage 1 -T1 (Week 0-1) : Briefing on conceptual design project
• Stage 2 -T2 (Week 2-4) : Preliminary Feasibility Study
• Stage 3 -T3 (Week 5-7) : Preliminary Process Design
• Stage 4 -T4 (Week 8-22) : Equipment Design
• 4a. Quick calculation for all equipment (Week 8-17)
• 4b. Detailed calculation (process and mechanical) for selected equipment (Week 18-22)
• Stage 5 -T5 (Week 23-25) : Utility (need, process design, shortcut sizing, process flow
diagram for water treatment)
• Stage 6 -T6 (Week 26-29) : Safety, Health, Environment and Process Control
• Stage 7 -T7 (Week 30-31) : Management and Economics
• Compiling a final report (Week 32-33)
It is compulsory for students to have a consultation with their supervisor to complete the project.
They need to submit to Academic Office of the Department:
• a report at the end of respective stage, and
• a final report at the end of the project.
There is a penalty for a late submission. Format of the report is set up by the Department.
2
3) Oral Examination
A group who has completed the project can proceed to the Oral Examination. The students sign up
themselves for the examination by submitting a draft of design report which is approved by their
supervisor to Academic Office of the Department.
5) Assessment
Grading scheme of the students based on two aspects i.e. the Project and the Oral Examination.
- In the project, supervisor and a team of mentors independently assess the report submitted by
students and give a score with a 50:50 proportion respectively to the total. Assessment is carried
out at the ends of every stage. Evaluated factors and their weighted values are shown in Table
1a.
- After submitting the final design project report, the students have to conduct an Oral
Examination in front of a committee consists of his/her project supervisor, and 2 other examiners.
Even though Plant Design Project is carried out in a team, the Oral Examination is conducted
individually to assure that every student gets individual assessment. Aspects evaluated and their
weighted values in the Oral Examination are shown in Table 1b. Students must obtain the
minimum grade of 50 in the oral examination. In case lower than the grade, the students must re-
sit for oral examination set by the department.
- Final score of the Plant Design Project is calculated from the score the design project and the Oral
Examination with a proportion 75:25 respectively to the total. The score is then converted into
the final mark (A, B, C, etc.) with following criteria:
3
VIII. Format of the Final Report
1. Cover
2. Approval Letter from Project Supervisor
3. Statement of Academic Honesty
4. Preface
5. Table of content
6. Abstract
7. Chapter 1: Introduction
8. Chapter 2: Process Description
9. Chapter 3: Material Specification
10. Chapter 4: Qualitative and Quantitative Flow Diagram
11. Process Engineering Flow Diagram
12. Chapter 5: Material Balance
13. Chapter 6: Energy Balance
14. Chapter 7: Equipment Specification
15. Chapter 8: Utility
16. Chapter 9: Process and Equipment Lay Out
17. Chapter 10: Safety, Health, and Environment Consideration
18. Chapter 11: Management and Organization
19. Chapter 12: Economic Analysis
20. Chapter 13: Conclusion
21. Appendix
22. Bibliography
2) Language
Final report can be written either in Bahasa Indonesia or English. The abstract, however, must be
written in both English and Bahasa Indonesia.
3) Ethics
Students must obey the academic code of conducts, such as the ones that are relating to plagiarism
and academic dishonesty, while they are working on the design project. In general, plagiarism is
defined as a deliberately presenting work, words, ideas, theories, etc., derived in a whole or in a part
from a source external to the students as though they are the student's own efforts. On the other
hand, academic dishonesty means any activities consists of any deliberate attempt to falsify, fabricate
or otherwise tamper with data, information, records, or any other material that is relevant to the
student's participation in any course, laboratory, or other academic exercise or function. Students
who are found to have violated the academic code of conduct are sanctioned by the rules applicable
at the university (Rector Regulation No. 711/P/SK/HT/2013).
The Department sends periodically a sample of final design reports to external reviewers as a mean
for quality assurance. Advice and suggestion received from reviewer(s) are to be implemented for further
betterment of the design project.
4
IX. Others
Information that are not clear enough or causing multiple interpretations in this guideline will be further regulated by the Department.
Chapter in Final
No Item Content Assessment time Percent
report
1 Executive summary & Executive Summary: a brief statement of the problem or proposal Final submission 10
Final Report covered in the major document(s), background information, concise
analysis and main conclusions. Final Report: a complete report of the
design project with a correct structure and organization of the report
(Final submission in both hard and soft copy)
2 Teamwork The ability of the student to work together in the team. Whole process 5
4 Preliminary Process • Process flow diagram and block diagram (both qualitative and End of T3 4, 5, 6 10
Design quantitative)
• Rationale or judgment of a process selected
• Mass balance
• Energy balance
5
Chapter in Final
No Item Content Assessment time Percent
report
6
Table 1b. Assessment of Oral Examination
percent
3 Material behavior 15
4 Economics evaluation 15
6 Presentation performances 15
Total 100
7
APPENDIXES
1. Cover Page
This page contains:
a) Paper title
b) Plant capacity, in tons/year
c) Name and student number
d) Supervisor name
e) Paper’s year completed
4. Preface
One page containing a brief explanation or statement of:
a) Purpose of the report,
b) Assigned project,
c) Explanation on the specific equipment (detail design) () or other additional information needed,
d) Acknowledgements
5. Table of Contents
Containing list of chapter titles and subchapter titles of the report and their page number
6. Abstract
The abstract is usually in a single page (written in two version of language of Indonesian and
English). This consists of:
a) Brief explanation on process used in the design,
b) Product capacity (including side product),
c) Raw and supporting materials needed every year,
d) Utility needed (for every hour, except electricity (on kW)),
e) Number of workers, land area and plant location,
f) Fix capital and working capital needed, on US$ and Rp.,
g) Profitability judgment, including: break-even point, pay out time, return on investment,
discounted cash flow rate of return and conclusion.
7. Introduction (Ch. 1)
This part describes:
a) Background that illustrates the importance of the plant for country developments (reviewed from
the raw materials, product, plant location, market or labor sources),
b) Literature review on processes which are used for designing the plant and process election
judgment.
9
13. Heat Balance (Ch. 6)
Heat balance is composed with the following guide:
a) Reference temperature for determining enthalpy is 0 oC, or other temperature if necessary (with
judgments).
b) Units in kcal/hr,
c) For every single equipment in the designed plant,
d) Heat balance for equipment should be followed with flow number.
10
Further guideline for this chapter can be found in Attachment I.3
21. Attachment
In this part included:
a) Details on specific equipment, e.g. reactor, distillation column
b) Other equipment calculation (overall equipment)
22. Bibliography
Bibliography is arranged consistently according to the common styles used in scientific writing.
11
Attachment I.1: Design Project Assignment’s Statement of Originality example
CLEARENCE STATEMENT
We hereby certify that under the process of composing the design project we do not undertake data
fabrication and plagiarism of others’ works. All parts in the report are genuinely prepared by our self,
except as specified in the bibliography. If in the future, this design project report is found plagiarized
practices, we agree to receive any sanction from the department.
Yogyakarta,……..
Sign, Sign,
12
Attachment I.2: Example of quantitative flow diagram and overall mass balance macroscopic
13
Attachment I.3: Chapter “Occupational Safety, Health and Environment aspect consideration”
Chapter X
In designing chemical plant, process engineer is compulsory to consider occupational safety, health
and environment (SHE) aspect as mention in the engineer’s code of ethics: “Engineers shall hold
paramount the safety, heath, and welfare of the public performance of their duties”. Therefore, in
this Design Project, SHE study is mandatory to be written in a separate chapter by the student.
Students are required to make a SHE studies in form of checklist (+brief description) but
comprehensive. Explanation on how to write the SHE studies in Design project are written below:
1. This given format can be used as template on writing the SHE studies report in the Design Project.
2. Hazard columns are filled adequately with check (√)
3. Information column can be fulfilled with necessary explanation.
4. Handling column should be fulfilled (a brief explanation containing 1-2 sentences)
Hazard identification of all equipment and materials that have potency to inflict hazard are
compulsory.
The assignments in Chemical Plant Design Project have to contain at least one of the following:
14
Attachment I.4: List of Standard and Code
Standard can define as a set of technical definitions and guidelines. Standard serves as a common
language for defining quality and establishing safety criteria for the product. ASTM, API, ISO are
some examples of the standard. When governmental bodies adopt the standard and become legally
enforceable, or when it has been incorporated into a business contract, the standard will become a
code.
A. Mechanical Standards
A.1 Static Equipment
Pressure Vessels, Filters, Coalescers, Deaerators, Storage Tanks Heat Exchangers, Fired Equipment
Standard/Code
Standard Description
API 521 Pressure-relieving and Depressuring Systems
API 530 Calculation of Heater Tube Thickness
API 537 Flare Details for General Refinery Services
API 560 Fired Heaters for General Refinery Service
API 582 Welding Guidelines
API 650 Welded Steel Tanks for Oil Storage
API 651 Cathodic Protection of Above Ground Petroleum Storage Tanks
API 660 Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers
API 661 Air-cooled Heat Exchangers
API 941 Steels for Hydrogen Service at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures
API RP 535 Burners for Fired Heaters in General Refinery Services
API RP 538 Recommended Practice for Industrial Fired Boilers
API 2218 Fireproofing Practices in Petroleum and Petrochemical Processing Plants
ASME B31.3 Process Piping
ASME BPVC ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code
EEMUA 140 Engineering Equipment Materials Users Association
NFPA 85 Boiler and Combustion Systems Hazards Code
TEMA Shell & Tube Heat Exchangers
Standard/Code List
Standard Description
API 530 Calculation of Heater Tube Thickness
API 535 Burners for Fired Heaters in General Refinery Services
API 537 Flare Details for General Refinery Services
API 582 Welding Guidelines
API 610 Centrifugal Pumps (API Applications)
API 611 General Purpose Steam Turbines
15
Standard/Code List
Standard Description
API 612 Special Purpose Steam Turbines
API 613 Special Purpose Gear Units
API 614 Lubrication, Shaft-sealing and Oil-Control Systems and Auxiliaries
API 616 Gas Turbine
API 617 Axial and Centrifugal Compressors and Expander Compressors
API 618 Reciprocating Compressors
API 619 Rotary-type Positive Displacement Compressors
API 650 Welded steel Tanks for Oil Storage
API 651 Cathodic Protection of Above Ground Petroleum.Storage Tanks
API 660 Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers
API 661 Air-cooled Heat Exchangers
API 670 Machinery Protection System
API 671 Special Purpose Couplings
API 672 Packaged, Integrally Geared Centrifugal Air Compressors
API 673 Centrifugal Fans
API 674 Positive Displacement Pumps – Reciprocating
API 675 Positive Displacement Pumps – Controlled Volume
API 676 Positive Displacement Pumps – Rotary
API 677 General Purpose Gear Units
API 682 Pumps – Shaft Sealing Systems for Centrifugal and Rotary Pumps
API 941 Steels for Hydrogen Service at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures
API RP538 Recommended Practice for Industrial Fired Boilers
ASME B31.3 Process Piping
ASME B73.1 Horizontal End Suction Centrifugal Pumps (ASME Applications)
ASME B73.1M Specification for Horizontal End Suction Centrifugal Pumps for Chemical
Process
ASME B73.2M Specification for Vertical In-Line Centrifugal Pumps for Chemical Process
ASME BPVC ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code
EEMUA 140 Noise Procedure Specification
ISO 2858 End-suction Centrifugal Pumps (rating 16 bar) – Designation, nominal duty
and dimensions
ISO 5199 Technical Specifications for centrifugal pumps – Class II
NFPA 20 Firewater Pumps
NFPA 85 Boiler and Combustion Systems Hazards Code
TEMA Shell & Tube Heat Exchangers
18
Standard/Code
Standard Description
ASTM F959 / Standard Specification for Compressible Washer Type Direct Tension
F959M Indicator for Use with Structural Fastener/ Standard Specification for
Compressible Washer Type Direct Tension Indicator for Use with Structural
Fastener (Metric)
ASTM Standard Specification for Zinc Coating, Hot Dip, Requirement for
F2329/F2329M Application to Carbon and Alloy Steel Bolts, Screw, Washers, Nuts, and
Special Threaded Fasteners.
A.3 Piping
Standard/Code
Standard Description
ASME Piping & Pipeline*
ANSI
API
ASTM
ISO
SNI
ISA
NFPA
OSHA
NACE RP0198 Control of Corrosion Under Insulation
Note: For Pipeline (offsite & offshore): ASME B31.4
Standard/Code
Standard Description
ASTM Insulation
DIN
BS
NACE RP0198 Control of Corrosion Under
Insulation
19
EXAMPLE OF STANDARD/CODE
Taken from Megyesy, 1995, Pressure Vessel Handbook 10ed., Pressure Vessel Publishing, Inc., USA
20
21
22
Attachment I.5: List of Symbols and Identification
B. Equipment
Angle Valve
Check Valve
Symbol Symbol
Description Description
H2O
Water cooler Centrifugal pump
S
Steam heater Turbine type compressor
23
C. Process Equipment Numbering
Numbering example:
P-101 A/B indicates that the pump is located in area 100 of the plant
P-101 A/B indicates that this spesific pump is number 01 in unit 100
P-101 A/B indicates that a backup pump is installed. Thus, there are two identical pumps, P-101A
and P-101B. One pump will be operating while the other is idle.
24
OCTOBER 2016