Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who Have Been
Resuscitated Multiple Times
Gravador, Janelle G.
October 2018
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
In this point, the researchers would like to show and reflect their deepest gratitude
OUR FAMILIES for being the most supportive people in times of need and
the situation.
PROF. REGIE DE JESUS who have been enthusiastic and considerate in giving
study. Moreover, their honesty and transparency are very much appreciated.
ANA MAY S. CANCINO for lending her knowledge in editing the paper in
GOD in foreseeing the success and the struggles of the study. Providing strength
ABSTRACT
Cardiac arrest is the sudden stopping of the heart from beating due to electrical
malfunctions. One of the main management for this condition is CardioPulmonary
Resuscitation which consists of chest compressions and providing oxygenation through
the mouth. Unfortunately, poor prognosis of this condition had been the most common
cause of death in the Philippines and as well as the low survival rate for CPR. Survivors
may suffer from different draw backs of this condition. Thus, these difficulties may affect
the patients in a variety of aspects. Emphasizing in this study, are the experiences of
survivors who have agonised through the same management and condition repeatedly.
The similarities, differences and change in severities or improvements with regards to the
level of their health. Setting-up criteria for gathering samples through purposive sampling
method, informants are screened and selected. Information are collected by conducting
interviews with the informants using guide questions and personal assessments of the
interviewer and researchers without implying any ideas to the informants. This semi-
structured interview has been the main instrument in collecting and elaborating the
experiences of the informants. Moreover, in order to secure a valid and reliable data the
informants are only required to provide first-hand data.Experiences from the informants
are compared from their first times and after multiple resuscitations. Thus, this study has
revealed that informants have more serious complications rather than those who had been
resuscitated once. In addition to this, efforts exerted by the informants to regain, improve
and maintain their levels of health especially the health of their heart are much more
compared to those first timers. Moreover, the informants were not just affected physically
by the changes but also psychologically. Due to the differences in coping and adaptation
some had positive realizations like valuing their life more and living life better but others
have been more depressed due to the incapacity to perform old duties. This study have
revealed and concluded that with multiple resuscitations in a single individual, this can
affect them in all aspects of their life. Incapacitation can lead to depressions and anxiety.
Also, the more the condition reoccur the draw backs are getting more severe making the
survivors feel depressed and anxious. The domino effect of their condition on how a
single aspect has affected other portions of their being are elaborated and observed as
well as their coping to each difficulty.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page………………………………………………………………………….i
Approval Sheet…………………………………………………………………….ii
Certificate of Originality……………………………………………………………iii
Acknowledgement…………………………………………………………………..iv
Abstract………………………………………………………………………………v
Table of Contents……………………………………………………………………..vi
Introduction…………………………………………………………………….. 4
Theoretical Framework…………………………………………………………..6
Assumption …………………………………………………………………..…11
Definition of Terms…..........................................................................................13
Synthesis………………………………………………………..……………….18
Research Design………………………………………………...………………19
Research Locale…………………………………………………………………20
Research Informants…………………………………………….………………20
Research Instrument……………………………………………………………..21
a) Data Analysis……………………………………………………………..…22
b) Ethical Consideration………………………………………………………..24
Conclusions…………………………………………..……………………..63
Recommendations…………………………………………………………..64
REFERENCES………………………………………………………………………67
APPENDICES
Appendix F: Extracts
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Appendix G: Transcript
Chapter 1
Cardiac arrests happen when the heart actually stops beating along with electrical
malfunctions in the heart and patient suddenly stops breathing or gasps. It should not be
confused with heart attack because it is when coronary arteries are blocked and the heart
continues to beat though there is depletion with the blood supply in the heart muscles.
Cardiac arrest is one of the most common causes of death in the Philippines along
with stroke and cancer according to the Philippine Daily Inquirer (Buban, 2015).It is also
responsible for almost 20% of all deaths according to Department of Health Statistics.
For elder patients it is also found out that CPR often has poor outcomes than in younger
Survival of patients who are having cardiac arrest depend on how efficient and
fast CPR was performed. A delay in resuscitation can decrease the chances for survival
the act of reviving from apparent death according to Merriam Webster in 2018. CPR or
compressions and breathing for the patient through the mouth. It is also the standard care
for cardiopulmonary arrest and this is usually performed by health care professionals
(Mayoclinic, 2018). American Heart association have acknowledged that most people
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
who receive CPR have higher risk on surviving morbidities and advised
physicians to include in the chart if CPR is not performed due to the presence of a DNR
order. In 2016, there has been more than 350,000 incidence of cardiac arrest and the
overall survivor rate is 10.6% out of the hospital while incidence of cardiac arrest inside
the hospital is 209,000 with a survival rate of 25.5% (American Heart Association, 2018).
The survival rate for CPR remains poor. CPR is labelled as a traumatic and aggressive
procedure done to patients having cardiac arrest because it is painful due to the
compressions in the chest which may also cause additional health problems. Failure to
perform CPR can result to death and the little chance to survive from CPR can also cause
serious and irreversible damage to the brain (Ebell, Jang, Shen and Geocadin, 2013).
Aside from the physiological damages to the brain, cardiac arrest may also inflict
(2016), out of 30 patients who suffered from sudden cardiac arrest 46.67% developed
mild depression after at least one month and not more than 6months from the incidence
of arrest while 36.67% developed moderate anxiety. It is also mentioned in the study that
the arrest can be a significant stressor to the individual in which may complicate heart
diseases and also led to post-traumatic stress disorder and impairment in functioning.
This near death experience may affect them physically and emotionally making
most patient’s road to recovery difficult as mentioned above due to the changes they
underwent. It will be more problematic if this process is repeated to a single patient for
multiple times moreover; undergoing change after change with each resuscitation. Thus,
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
this research aims to understand difficulties of patients who had been revived multiple
Theoretical Framework
psychiatrist and an advocate for end-of-life care, she was influenced by her experience in
the World War II as a relief worker. She published books about issues of life and death
and one of her books which contain her 5 stages of grief is On Death and Dying in 1969.
These 5 stages are the reactions of terminally ill patients toward their impending deaths
stages of grieving in 1969 that is popularly known as DABDA or the Denial, Anger,
Bargaining, Depression and Acceptance served as a guide for understanding grief and its
development. However, it is possible for people to not undergo the stages or can only
In postcardiac arrest grieving can also happen due to their impending deaths and
may undergo these stages. Some article stated that these patients can attain acceptance
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
after having depression or with the term they used as feeling of “being dead” (Forslund et
al., 2013)
Postcardiac arrest patients can also undergo stages of grief due to their losses
when it comes to the changes that happen in their life after having cardiac arrests. Some
of the changes can be alterations with the diet plan wherein there is restriction
with some type of foods these patients used to eat. This change can make them feel upset
and they may grieve from the diet plan they used to have or from the lifestyle they used
to have. These changes to postcardiac arrest patients can be their loss that they grieve on.
researcher was able to determine symptoms of grief through his research in the Coconut
Grove tragedy in 1942. He stated that the symptoms of grief are 1) somatic distress which
is most likely to make the patient have difficulty in breathing, losing appetite or lack of
motivation 2) preoccupation with the images of the deceased 3) guilt 4) hostile reactions
and 5) loss of pattern of conduct or patients find basic activities hard to complete.
Lindemann also introduced how the “grief work” progress. He explained that in order to
reduce the symptoms of grief, you have to follow the 3 tasks of grief work which are
have strong bonds to the deceased they have to cut ties with the person or object. The
second step, which is re-adjustment patient needs to adjust to the environment and own
routines. Lastly, in the formation of new relationship the patient is able to accept and
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
make new bonds. If the patient is able to reach the last step he has successfully coped
These steps by Lindemann can also be done by postcardiac arrest patients who
have different type of losses depending on the change they have undergone. In the
situation of postcardiac arrest patients, it is important that they emancipate from their past
lifestyles for example and they should also re-adjust their selves to the changes.
Eventually, they should also form new bonds or new commitments with their new
the 8 stages in psychosocial development and his theory is highly influenced by Sigmund
Freud’s psychosexual theory. Erikson believed that the development of personality has
series of stages and experience in social interaction affects the development. Each stage
has two qualities and if a person fails to develop a psychological quality he/she may not
develop the skill to strengthen the sense of self however if a person developed the quality
he/she may have higher chances of overcoming conflicts. Mastery of each stage is not a
requirement in advancing to the next stage and the outcome of every stage is reversible
quality of life the person leads. Between the ages of 20-39 years old this falls to the
intimacy vs isolation stage wherein the major virtue to be developed is love. Love for the
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
significant other is a good sign of a strong support system thus promoting intimate
relationships with people and therefore reducing the chance of having depression after
traumatic events or during a disease. Postcardiac arrest patients aged 20 to 39 years old
may develop this characteristic to effectively cope with their experience. Conversely, if
patient has weak support system and is lacking of love from significant other he/she may
not recognize self-worth, may seem hopeless and helpless, eventually patient will
isolate himself/herself.
For the adults aged 40 to 64 years old, in the generativity vs stagnation stage, the
main virtue is care. In these years, a person focuses on the ability to be productive and
efficient to the society through accomplishments in work, establishing family and being
financially stable and if a person is not able to recognize the sense of generativity or
productivity there will be a feeling of stagnation for not being able to help te society. For
postcardiac arrest patients it is possible to not achieve generativity due to the interference
of their condition with their activities in life specifically in their work or their role as a
there will be productivity in life, achievements and stability thus achieving the sense of
generativity.
For the ages 65 years old and above, the main virtue is wisdom which falls under
the ego integrity vs despair stage. In this stage the final task is retrospection wherein
people tend to go back and re-evaluate their lives and their ability to acquire wisdom. In
postcardiac arrest patients, if they are unable to see the productivity of their life they may
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
develop the feeling of not being able to be at their best caused by the adjustments and
effects of their condition and lead them to the feeling of despair. On the other hand, if
they are able to feel satisfaction with their lives postcardiac patients may develop wisdom
and integrity.
This theory was first presented in an article in Nursing Outlook in 1970 with the
title of “Adaptation: A Conceptual Framework for Nursing”. The aim of this theory is to
explain the nursing science and its role in assisting adaptation of patients and also to
show that a person is a holistic being with different aspects. It defines the human’s ability
to think and re-adjust to the stimuli from the environment, to cope with stress, disease
and death and the role of nursing in the promotion of positive coping mechanisms using
basic needs of a human being such as nutrition, oxygenation, activity and rest. While the
self-concept group identity mode emphasizes the sense of purposefulness and unity. Role
function mode on the other hand is about determining the roles of a person which he
occupies in the society whether it is primary, secondary and tertiary role. Lastly, in the
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
interdependence mode, its aim is on attaining the integrity in relationships through giving
feeling persons as individuals or in groups use conscious awareness and choice to create
important so that people will be able to eliminate negative coping mechanisms and be
disease is the main goal of nursing and this is attainable through the help of nursing
process (Vera, 2014 ). For post cardiac arrest patient, it is also necessary to
acquire positive coping mechanisms that would improve their quality of life. The
physiological and psychological effects of cardiac arrest and resuscitation are their
external stimuli to adapt. With the aid of adaptation theory, nurses would be able to
This study aims to explore and have in-depth understanding about the difficulties
of patients who have been revived multiple times from cardiac arrests. Particularly, this
1. What are the difficulties of post cardiac arrest patients after multiple
resuscitations?
3. How may the lived experiences of post-cardiac arrest patients who have
Assumptions
experience because it is a traumatic event. Changes after cardiac arrest and resuscitation
when it comes to different aspects can be difficult for patients to cope with. Thus, if a
single patient undergoes same procedures for multiple times adjustments will be greater
survivors but this study focuses on those changes and how they are able to handle their
circumstances along with the problems that have been inflicted to the patients ages
greater than 30 years old who had been resuscitated multiple times from cardiac arrest
regardless if the resuscitation was performed inside or outside the hospital nor in a single
hospitalization. Interviews with the patients will be the main source of data of this study.
The researchers will focus on patients admitted in hospitals around Bulacan area that
This research will be able to give to benefits to the following groups of people:
Nurses, this study will be able to provide more elaborated information about the
difficulties of post cardiac arrest patients after multiple resuscitations and for
emotional well-being
patient’s condition and his/her feelings and perceptions toward his situation and
be able to help and guide the patient in coping with his present condition.
times and also to gain the proper attitude in communicating with these kinds of
people.
Definition of terms
Post cardiac arrest patients: people who have undergone and survived a
Cardiac Arrest: it is when the patient suddenly collapse because the heart stopped.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Do-Not-Resuscitate order: an order made by the physician and patient and/or significant
other which states that the patient will not be resuscitated if he/she had an arrest.
According to Mcgough as cited by Lunas (2016) many people don't realize that this is as
threat to the worldwide population. Due to its sudden manifestation of its symptoms such
as chest pains, irregular or absence of heartbeats, the events of cardiac arrest are often
affecting their day to day activities in life. (Philippine Heart Association, 2018).
it is the irregular heartbeat and malfunction of the heart, cardiac arrests may be
triggered by other medical conditions. Every year 170,000 filipinos die from
Standard (2018).
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation
In achieving the goal of the 64th president of the Philippine Heart Association,
Dr. Alex Junia which is preserving the cardiac health of the filipino people. He
had led the advocacy of making the Philippines a CPR-ready country (Philippine
is the most important treatment for cardiac arrest and it should be done within 4-6
mins because brain cells starts to die without oxygen. The main goal is to
Makati Medical Center as cited by Manila Standard (2018), once the patient does
not respond, pulseless and does not breathe, a trained first-aider must perform a
not very efficient on elderly patients due to higher rate of pulseless electrical activity or
nonarrhythmic causes of cardiac arrest in this age group (Borne,. Et al. 2017). Aside from
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
ICD, the classic and standard approach to cardiac arrest is CPR. Cardiopulmonary
Resuscitation is a series of steps to prevent death when the heart suddenly stops pumping
and it is a policy in hospitals to perform CPR on patient whose heart suddenly stops
beating but this policy can be affected when there is a presence of DNR order. (Johnson
Determination Act of 1991 to emphasize the patient’s right for making decisions
regarding their end-of-life care or make advanced care directives. If the patient cannot
express his/her wishes there are two ways to approach the situation. First is following the
patient’s advance care plan wherein patient was able to provide advanced decisions
regarding the plan of care he/she will undergo but if advance care plan was not made,
patients significant others can make the request by filing a legal document that would
Some studies focus on the life experiences of post cardiac arrest patients and
people who survived cardiac arrest and have been resuscitated had memories of how they
were revived and it has also been reported by a respondent that he saw himself left his
According to Forslund et al. (2017) on the first year of survival patients stated
that they still have this feeling of “being dead” but as they go along they have concluded
and have come to the realization that they have been given a second chance to enjoy life
and also according to Horizon Research Foundation (2007), the quality of life after a near
death experience of a cardiac arrest has no difference from being discharged from an
ICU.
27% of post cardiac arrest patients suffer from a psychological disorder such as
post-traumatic stress disorder and depression. Patients develop this disorder because they
are unable to cope up with their near death experience and other disabilities that have
been caused by the sudden cardiac arrest. It is also stated by the Horizon Research
Foundation that 20-50% of the survivors develop long term memory impairment and also
return of circulation which also increases the risk for infection. 40-50% of CA survivors
develop acute renal and respiratory dysfunctions. The most severe component of this
syndrome is the cardio circulatory dysfunctions which eventually lead to multiple organ
dysfunctions. The intensity of the complication is highly dependent to the delay of initial
The treatment for post cardiac arrest syndrome has two main goals: initial
management for shock and organ failure and cerebral protection. (Mongardon et al,
2011).
Netherlands by Wachelder (2009) states that, approximately 38% of people who have
survived, suffers from anxiety and depression. Another element in the experiences of post
Heart Association (2018), it is normal to be afraid for not having full control over one’s
own life but through positive self-talk and proper understanding to own condition it could
lessen its symptoms. In chronic patients it was found that these types of patients have
more often and intense thoughts about their deaths. (Khawar, 2013). In line with this, the
Heflick, there is a theory that proposed fear of death can trigger more positive behaviour
to people suffering from it. Therefore encouraging them to preserve life may increase
self-esteem. (Heflick, 2012). Statistically, 80% of people who suffered a near death
experience have claimed that this made a significant difference in their lives in various
he/she has now rather than stressing out over the past experiences. (Atwater, 2017)
capacity to perform activities, (Duruturk et al, 2015) and there is a feeling of fatigue on
patients even with small activities alone. After surviving cardiac arrests it was found out
50% of patients who suffered cardiac arrests have complained of chronic fatigue
(Wachelder, 2009) Patients may commonly experience fatigue after surviving an arrest.
Chronic fatigue with these types of patients can be addressed by planning activities,
The American Heart Association proposed few dietary adjustments that should be
applied in order to avoid heart attacks and improve the health of the heart. It is suggested
that avoiding salt, transfat, saturated fats and added sugars can reduce the risks being
included in the 326,000 people who underwent cardiac arrests in a year. (2018)It also
shows that along with proper diet and healthy habits it is also important to allot time for
proper exercise. For people with heart conditions it is important that exercise should be
kept in moderation and gradually increase level of exercise because extensive exercises
can stress out the heart. (Chest Heart and Stroke Scotland, 2018) It was advised by the
American Heart Association (2015) through their Cardiac Rehabilitation program that
one of the major elements affecting cardiac health is proper exercise. There has
been a study focusing on how muscle strengthening activities could help reduce risk to
acquiring CVD. Moreover, Physical activities are good predictators of the health status of
Along with diet it is also important to make a few adjustments in the lifestyle
especially removing unhealthy habits such as alcohol drinking and tobacco use because
this can add to the risks of developing cardiovascular diseases. (Mukamal, n.d) In
addition to this, The American Heart Association (2014) has advised people not to drink
alcohol if they have not started drinking yet because alcohol drinking can lead to increase
in blood pressure and could branch out into different heart diseases. The lack of
developing heart problems in the United States. (American Heart Association, 2015) A
program called Cardiac Rehabilitation is designed to improve the current condition of the
heart and there are three major elements that would reduce all modifiable risks: Exercise,
healthy lifestyle and stress reduction. (AHA, 2016). Aside from this, according to Sandee
good for the health and it is better not to drink at all. Therefore, total eradication of
alcohol from their diets can significantly improve their health conditions and it is a
consumptions.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Synthesis
The researches and journals mentioned in the review of related literature will help
psychological status. Also, according to the review of related literature, researchers will
be able to elaborate more comprehensively the feelings and experiences that the patients
have been through. In addition, it will also aid the researchers to identify the quality of
lives that patients may lead and be able to conceptualize a deeper understanding on what
have driven them to lead their lives and how, as nurses, will be able to improve their
well-being. According to the literatures that was reviewed by the researchers, they
discovered that there are managements can be done for post-cardiac patients. Implantable
cardio-verter defibrillator therapy is used to lower the sudden cardiac arrest of the patient.
Cardio pulmonary resuscitation can be perform to prevent death. For the patient
experiences for the first year after attack they felt like dead. There is a phenomenon
called “Post Cardiac Arrest Syndrome” where in some of the patient’s organ becomes
ischemic due to prolong cardiac arrest. They may also develop post-traumatic stress
disorder and depression because of feeling of death and loss. Some patient’s develop
positive outlook, they became more time oriented because for them the remaining time
they have must be productive and helpful to all. Effects would vary to every individual
and these can highly suggest what type or quality of life the patient may live. The known
knowledge in the experiences of post-cardiac arrest patients which has been revealed
discussed by this study by analysing and interpreting data that would be gathered from
Chapter 2
Research Methods
This chapter will present the methods used by the researchers in order to further
elaborate the answers to the questions the research aims to provide. Also included in this
chapter is the area where the study will be conducted along with how the informants are
going to be selected and what are the instruments that are going to be utilized in gathering
Research Design
characterize and elaborate the experiences of post cardiac arrest patients that have been
resuscitated many times. This study also explores the new angle that focuses on the life
experiences of post cardiac arrest patients who have undergone multiple cardiac arrests
and have been resuscitated successfully several times and the factors affecting them in
coping with their current condition. Phenomenological studies aims to gain a deeper
understanding regarding the point of view of the people about a particular phenomenon
and provide facts to support a phenomenal event. Also, to understand and analyse the
data given by the informants with consideration to their variations in beliefs, perceptions,
attitudes and coping abilities. In line with this, the researchers find the qualitative
understanding from the informant’s lived experiences and also to be able to arrange the
data thematically.
Research Locale
The study is conducted within the area of Bulacan. Researchers tracked down post
cardiac arrest patients in primary, secondary and tertiary hospitals around Bulacan. In
Bulacan Medical Center at the Intensive Care Unit 3 out of 10 patients are being
resuscitated per shift and 1 out of 100 resuscitated patients have recovered successfully.
Research Informants
snowball and convenience sampling. The first category is purposive sampling because
researchers set criteria that are satisfied by the informants. The informants should at least
have three successful resuscitation from cardiac arrest regardless of the location of the
old and above. The second category is convenience sampling wherein samples that are
chose are close at hand. As it happened, one of the informants is a friend of a researcher
which is conveniently interviewed by the researchers. These methods aid the screening of
informants that would provide necessary information relevant to the study. The third is
snowball method, wherein one of the informants recommended an acquaintance that also
Research Instrument
In order to extract information from the informants the researchers made a semi-
structured interview and formulated questions that would serve as guide in obtaining
precise data. Also, to explore more ideas brought during the interview other secondary
questions are also asked to elaborate experiences and ideas. Informants are expected to
provide first-hand information to ensure validity and reliability of data. The following are
1. What are their lived experiences upon having been resuscitated several times from
cardiac arrest?
3. What are the difficulties they have identified after being resuscitated multiple
times?
The researchers held an orientation for each participant discussing the benefits,
risks, their rights and how can they cooperate in the study. Researchers provided consents
had the participants express their concerns before signing. After the orientation and
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
tackling about the experiences of postcardiac arrest patients that were resuscitated
multiple times while avoiding questions that may lead the informant’s answers to what or
may contaminate the data. The entire interview was audio recorded and few points were
jotted down by co-researchers. There were no personal info taken from the informants
and they would be allowed to decide if the interview will be audio/video recorded or not.
As the interview was ended the researchers extended their gratitude by handing their
minutes to 1 hour. The researchers used non-probability sampling method which are
purposive and convenience sampling wherein researchers pick their informants based on
their own judgment keeping in mind the purpose of the study. Convenience sampling is
when the researchers choose their informants as per the accessibility of the informant and
Data Analysis
the informants, data are thematically arranged and grouped according to the
interpretations of their experiences and the likeliness of their situations. Informants are
subjected to interview for data gathering and extracted information are used in the study
for a deeper understanding with the process of the phenomenon and how it affected the
informants. The researchers have analysed the data, summarized and arranged it with
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
regards to the elements of the experiences. The thematic analysis method has phases as
1. First, the researchers will familiarize themselves with the data that have been
3. Themes and patterns that have been identified are reviewed. Irrelevant
4. Researchers will then provide facts that would support the themes or patterns that
have occurred within the informant’s experiences which are still clustered
thematically.
5. Clustered data are identified with regards to how it would affect the processes of
6. Thematically clustered data are now finalized and narrowed down in which will
researchers used this phase to analyse and elaborate the phenomenon that is being
investigated in this study which is multiple cardiac resuscitation on a single patient. The
four phases include the following steps in order to provide further understanding
informants
4. Through the clustered themes and meanings that were formulated from the
Ethical Considerations
As this study concentrates on the lived experiences of post cardiac arrest patients
that are resuscitated several times, researchers intended to emphasize that during the
progression of the study’s confidentiality and respect to the informant’s rights are
observed properly.
Before the conduction of the interview and during the first contact between the
informants, the researchers ensure the informants that they are not forced to participate,
researchers secured consents from the informants as well as giving them the choice to
remain anonymous or they may indicate their names along with their consents.
During the interview, researchers have also ensured that all informants have
answered the same set of questions and that there are no offensive questions asked during
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Conveniences of the informants are also given full attention considering their
schedules and availability. The researchers have ensured that the schedule or the duration
of the interview have not compromised them with regards to their daily activities and
work. These considerations will be strictly followed and considered by the researchers for
Chapter 3
This study focuses on the lived experiences of post-cardiac arrest patients who
have been resuscitated several times. These experiences include the struggles after the
Informants have highlighted these difficulties in which they remain to face for the rest of
their lives.
Moreover, due to these problems encountered by the patients it had affected them
in different aspects. Thus, promoting a holistic approach for these type of patients
because as addressing the complaints of these patients they must be viewed as a holistic
being that has different qualities in order to function properly and be considered as a
healthy human being. Stressful as it is, informants are able to verbalize on ways in
accepting and coping with the difficulties they tackled along their journey of challenging
experiences.
With the uniqueness of every individual, each informant had various ways in
coping. Some viewed the matter as a challenge and faced it head on but some chose to
just go with the flow and see what’s at the end of the road. Most patients started a new
life after several times of resuscitation and are able to follow treatment regimens as well
as acceptance of their condition. To sum it all, the experiences of the patients are gives
and takes. In order to gain something for themselves there must be a trade-off. This
Below are the following themes that would clarify and interpret meanings from the
Table 1. Theme clusters and Formulated Meanings under the emergent theme
experiences of post-resuscitated patients that have undergone resuscitation for once only.
Under the emergent theme “First Onset of Attack” theme clusters are devised by the
researchers to classify their experiences according to what aspect of their lives have been
First theme cluster Denial to Present Condition conveys how the post-resuscitated
patients handled their situation at their first attack and how it affected them emotionally.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Secondly, Requires Assistance with Activities shows that post-resuscitated patients are
having difficulties in performing daily tasks after having their first attack. The next theme
cluster which is Incompliance to Medication deals with the experiences of patients who
are in denial of their condition and refuses to follow medical advises. Another theme
patients made in their food habits to compensate with their disease. Lastly, the Decrease
in vices wherein the informants stated that ever since their first attack they try to limit
This theme cluster pertains to the initial reaction of the informants after having
their first attack and most of them are unable to accept their condition because of the
sudden onset of their disease. This predicament is imparted by the informants through
“ Nung una di ko talaga maisip na mangyayare saken yung ganito para bang
tinatanggi ng isipan ko yung sitwasyon. Masakit kasi isipin na biglaan eh.”
[PCAP4 line 12-15]
(I couldn’t really believe that this would happen to me. It was like my mind is
(I woke up and my wife told me about my condition. I was speechless. I don’t want
As the informants clearly stated that, it had been difficult for them to understand
and accept their condition. Denial to clinical realities is the main cause of delay to
patient’s treatment progress and mostly because they choose not to participate in
treatment as they view the the treatment unnecessary (Covino et al, 2011), grief is a
person’s initial response to loss. It can be manifested through sadness over different kinds
of reasons such as death of significant others, job loss and/ or change in lifestyle like
from moving out and chronic diseases (DerSarkissian, 2016). According to Kubler-Ross
(1969) in her 5 Stages of Grieving famously known as DABDA wherein the first stage of
anticipatory grieving, and have already proceeded to the first stage of grieving wherein
they try to deny and refuse to accept their current condition. Anticipatory grieving is
when a person is grieving before the occurrence of loss. It is usually a death expected
from either the person himself or from a loved one (Medicinenet, 2016). The informants
are unable to deal with their current situations, because they are not prepared to the
changes occurred. Changes that affect not only parts of their lives but the whole of them.
Also some of the changes are not that easy for them to accept, and that’s the reason why a
lot of the survivors of the first attack are not complying to the treatments. In line with
this, health providers must listen to the patient’s opinion, show empathy to the situation
that they are experiencing. Help the patients and relatives to understand the patients’
current situation and the importance for them to comply with the needed treatment.
In line with this, informants have also stated that due to their inability to accept
their situation they tried to normalize themselves and get back to their normal routines.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
” Yung unang beses ko kahit papaano sumubok ako ng mga trabaho sa bahay
pero yung katawan ko ba eh parang umaayaw kasi ramdam ko kaagad ang
pagod.” [PCAP3 line9-13]
(On my first attack I tried doing my usual chores at home but I felt my body is not
“Bale inatake ako ng unang beses talagang nagtrabaho pa din ako sa bahay.
Naglalaba, nagluluto, naglilinis pero noon eh ramdam ko na ang
panghihina.”[PCAP1 line 84-88]
(So when I had my first attack I still tried to work at home. Washing the laundry,
cooking and cleaning but with these activities I already felt the weak.)
As stated by the informants, these patients have attempted to get back to their
daily routines and past active and dynamic lifestyles. In their attempt, it was stated that
they fail to regain their old routines due to feelings of powerlessness and lack of strength.
This attempt to avoid their condition and regaining their past activities is the patient’s
response to their stressor or can be called their coping mechanism. Coping mechanism is
a person’s approach to stressor in order to solve, manage or adapt. One of the two types
situation rather than solving the problem it only reduces the symptoms and doesn’t
address the cause of stress as well as limits the functioning (Williams, 2018). One type of
maladaptive coping mechanism is avoidance. This is when a person tries to escape from
their stressors (Sincero, 2012). In contrary, a study shows that Maladaptive Coping can
example, they are more likely to escape victimization (Wadsworth, 2015). In the
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Adaptation theory of Callista Roy (1970) she stated that there are 4 different adaptive
modes and the coping mechanism mentioned above falls on the self-concept group
identity mode wherein it highlights a person’s sense of purpose. These patients are unable
The second theme cluster is also one of the main experiences verbalized by the
informants. The theme cluster Requires Assistance with Activities was formulated for
the reason that post-resuscitated patient are unable to resume their past daily activities, it
had been verbalized by the informants that more often their basic activities are
“Sa mga gawain nga kaunti na lang mga gawain sa bahay di gaano yung mga
simple kaya ko pa naman kasi madalas akong nagpapatulong kay ate kasi siya
yung bantay ko palagi” [PCAP3 line 57-62]
(When it comes to house chores I am only able to perform simple tasks. I can still
do some of them because my sister helps me with them and she stays me most of
the time.)
“Kahit maglaba pupunta pa yung anak ko siya pa ang maglalaba. Pati pagluluto
di na ko makapagluto ng maano” [PCAP4 line 55-57]
(Even when doing the laundry my daughter will have to visit me and do it for me
and also cooking. Cooking has been also difficult for me.)
their tasks alone they have also recognized asking for assistance in their activities is
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
inevitable. According to a study, a lot of patients who have cardiac conditions often
ability to perform activities. (Duruturk et al, 2015) Patients may commonly experience
fatigue after surviving an arrest. Chronic fatigue with these types of patients can be
addressed by planning activities, simplifying tasks and asking for assistance (Kim et al.,
2017). Relating to this, healthcare providers should collaborate with the patients. Help
them to perform their usual task like before. Also provide rest between activities to
conserve patient's energy and secure the patients safety to prevent further complications.
Advises. This theme focuses on the experiences of patients that states difficulties in
adjusting to treatment regimens. Aside from denial to their condition, the sudden changes
to their lifestyle have also been a factor for them to find treatment regimens to be difficult
(I only take my medicines when I feel symptoms. I don’t really take them
regularly. It’s difficult because I am not used to taking medicines and as other
“Kasi nung una kong binigyan ng maintenance ininom ko lang siya ng tatlong
taon tapos inistop ko nung inistop ko dun na siya umatake. Tapos uminom ako ulit
so nung mga nakaginhawa ako umistop na naman ako. Nung umokay na ko
inistop ko na yun.” [PCAP4 line 84-89]
(When my doctor prescribed me some maintenance drugs I only took them for 3
years and I eventually stopped. When I stopped taking my meds I started feeling
symptoms which made me resume taking them better again. Then again when I
The statements have shown that following medication schedules have been
difficult on these patients and would only take them after feeling relief from symptoms.
Informants are not allowing themselves to rely on medications because for them
medication might lead them for more complications and may worsen their condition.
Diseases, dosing frequency has inverse relationship with adherence in medication. It has
been discussed that patients suffering from chronic diseases who have drug maintenance
find it more difficult to follow drug schedules as frequency dosing of their drug increases.
(Coleman et al., 2012) Aside from medications informants also highlighted that on their
first onset of attack they find some medical procedures are not necessary. Informants
have been uninterested with procedures of treatment because they haven’t recognized the
Una kong atake sabi ng doctor pwede daw akong magpaopera pero baka daw di
ko kayanin. Naisip ko naman na madadaan pa naman to sa pag-iingat at siguro
sa gamot kung sakali kaya di din ako pumayag. Nagpauwe na ko sa mga anak ko
nun.[PCAP4 line 35-39]
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
(The the first time it happened my doctor recommended an operation but this
operation has low chance of survival. I decided not to take this offer because I
lifestyle)
(I don’t attend to check-ups regularly I just go whenever I feel like it. I went to
check-ups every time I feel symptoms but I rarely had them that’s why I’m
informants. Informants are also unable to recognized severity of their condition and it is a
role of a nurse to explain and help them understand it. Health education is important in
(Rodriguez, 2018) That’s the reason why some of the informants are not complying to the
treatment or operation. In line with this, nurses must clearly explain the importance of the
treatment recommended for them. Teach the relatives that complying with the said
treatment can help improve the patient’s health status and provide information is easy for
them to understand.
The theme cluster Adjustment in Food Choices pertains to the changes the post-
resuscitated patients done with regards to their diet. As stated by the World Health
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Organization (2018) unhealthy food preferences is the major factor in increasing risks for
chronic, cardiovascular and other conditions associated to obesity. This notion to adjust
“Nung una kong atake kasi kumbaga nag-ano lang ingat lang ako sa kinakain
pero nakakain pa din ako ng mga bawal mahirap pa kasi talagang pigilan. Gulay
minsan tapos minsan karne para balanse pa din.”[PCAP1 line45-50]
(I observed proper diet but sometimes I would also cheat on my diet because
and veggies)
“Oo malaki ang nagbago kasi lalo pag first time wala akong ideya sa
nararamdaman ko. Kaya naman tuloy pa din ako sa mga gawain ko at mga
pagkain ng bawal siguro bawas sa iba pero minsan kasi di mo rin mapipigilan.”
[PCAP3 line37-42]
(I really had a lot of changes on my first time especially. I only had limited
knowledge about it. Sometimes I would also eat food that are not allowed for me because
I get tempted.)
Through these statements, it was emphasized by the informants that after their
first attack they are able to change their dietary habits though not fully compliant they
have recognized the importance of adjusting their food habits to compensate with their
condition, because for them this is the easiest task to do first aming than the other
treatment and also easy to provide. The American Heart Association (2018) proposed
few dietary adjustments that should be applied in order to avoid heart attacks and
improve the health of the heart. They suggested that avoiding salt, trans fat, saturated fats
and added sugars can reduce the risks being included in the 326,000 people who undergo
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
cardiac arrests in a year. In ccordance to this, healthcare providers such as nurses must
teach the patient and relatives the proper diet. Advice the relatives to collaborate with the
patient eating changes habit so this could help the patient and prevent the patient to have
Decrease in Vices
The next theme cluster is Decrease in Vices which emphasizes the experience of
post resuscitated patients who drink alcohol and smoke tobacco. Despite having their
vices these patients have recognized how these habits of them increases their risk in
worsening their current condition. To further clarify the experiences these are some of the
“Sino bang walang bisyo malakas akong uminom noon pati sigarilyo. Unang
beses na atakihin ako nagbabawas ako kasi delikado na ang kalusugan ko.
Naninigarilyo pa din naman hindi naman tulad dati kasi dati umuubos ako ng
isang kaha maghapon.”[PCAP5 line 24-29]
(Everybody has vices. I drink and smoke regularly back then. On my first attack, I
(I still had my vices back when I only had my first attack because I really don’t
pay much attention to my condition. Though there is still the uneasiness every
Along with diet it is also important to make a few adjustments in the lifestyle
especially removing unhealthy habits such as alcohol drinking and tobacco use because
this can add to the risks of developing cardiovascular diseases (Mukamal, 2006). In
addition to this, The American Heart Association (2014) has advised people not to drink
alcohol if have not started drinking yet because alcohol drinking can lead to increase in
blood pressure and could branch out into different heart diseases. According to the
informants this changes are not that easy to accept that’s why little by little they are
trying their best to remove the unhealthy habits. In the like manner, nurses must provide
health teachings that could elaborate their understanding further to lifestyle adjustments
Table 2. Theme clusters and Formulated meanings under the emergent theme
“Recurrence of Attacks”
Recurrence of Attacks. Under this emergent theme are six theme clusters. These theme
clusters highlights the experiences of post resuscitated patients after having the
recurrence of their attacks and how it affected them. The experiences they shared were
thematically arranged according to the formulated meanings of their statements. The first
had been highlighted that with the recurrence of their attacks informants have accepted
their condition and the circumstances that comes with it. Another theme cluster on the
second emergent theme is Healthy lifestyle plus diet. The second theme cluster explains
the dedication of the informants in improving their quality of life by readjusting their
lives in line with the challenges of their disease. The third theme cluster is Strength
deterioration. This is when the informants emphasized their feelings of weakness and
fatigue during or after their activities in which links us to the next theme cluster which is
Shift in Societal Roles that focuses on the informant’s difficulty in adjusting their roles
from being able to being unable to do their responsibilities. Due to their inability to
perform tasks because of their deteriorating strengths it had been challenging for them to
get back to their past roles in their family and community. Another struggle for
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
hypenated patients is the fear over their anticipated loss that leads to another theme
cluster which is the Fear of Impending Loss under the emergent theme Recurrence of
attacks. Despite the fear of the informants they have learned to value and gain positive
view in life along with strengthened faith toward their recovery which points to another
The first theme cluster in the second emergent theme is Accepting Circumstances
of Health Condition. This theme cluster emphasizes the experiences of post resuscitated
patients wherein they have concluded and come to realization in accepting their
condition. Along with their acceptance, they were able to cooperate better in the
treatment process of their health condition and the patients were more willing to
participate to recover optimum level of health that they could attain. To clarify this, the
“Minsan sa isang buwan ang check-up ko dahil iskedyul ng doctor yun eh. Lahi
namin sa nanay. Edi kumbaga sa ano eh tinanggap eh yun na ang dumapo sa
pamilya yung ganoong sakit kaya ganoon.” [PCAP1 line 122-127]
“Pero ayos naman masaya at kinakaya. Kung maaari ay ayoko pero kung ano
man ang dumating ay ayos lang. panget o maganda basta handa na ko kung alin
man doon. Mas sumusunod na ko sa utos ni doc. Buong pamilya kumakain ng
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
masustansya. Wag matigas ang ulo. Sumusunod at iniiwasan ang bawal para
mabuhay pa ng mahaba haba.” [PCAP3 line63-71]
(It’s fine, still happy and fighting. If I were to choose, I would definitely choose to
be healthy but still, whatever happens, happens. Come what may. I have been
The above statement shows how the informants have accepted and adjusted with
their condition along with it is how they perceive there changes positively. In the 5 stages
of grief the last stage of grieving is the acceptance. This is when a person is now able to
acknowledge their loss whether this might be a person or object. (Kubler-Ross, 1969 as
cited by Gregory) In line with this theory, post resuscitated patients may have developed
and undergone these stages. Their loss may not be necessarily someone or an object. The
loss can be from their past selves or old habits that couldn’t be done anymore due to their
health condition. As posed by the statements above it is evident that they have accepted
such situation.
Another theme cluster is Healthy Lifestyle plus Diet. This theme cluster
highlights the changes the informants have made with regards to their lifestyles and diet.
In 89% of people who adheres in proper diet 81% of them have observed the
would recommend fish and chicken diet but over time patients who follow this kind of
diet gets worse (Shaw, 2014). In line with this, informants recognized these risks,
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
therefore chose to take action by changing their diet plans. It will be clarified further with
“Kumakain din ako ng gulay kaya lang di pwede na iisa. Bawal pang igisa. Tapos
sa isda naman bawal yung malansa. Tapos kelangan sa isda eh puro ihaw o kaya
pinangat. Pero yung mga ano baboy manok bawal talaga. Netong naging grabe
na ko dati kasi ay! Wala akong pakialam kahit na bawal . mamamatay kung
mamamatay. Eh ngayong nakita kong nahihirapan na ang mga anak ko di na ko
nag-ano. Nakita ko naman lahat ng anak ko di ako pinabayaan kahit ilang beses
akong naatake.”[PCAP4 line97-106]
(I eat vegetables in varieties but is not allowed to be sautéed. For fish steamed or
boiled are the only preparations. Meat products such as pork and chicken must be
avoided. On my first time I didn’t care as to what I eat and I eat what I want. But
when it had recurred I have seen how my children have suffered with me which
“Kakain ka ng masustansya at iwasan ang mga baboy. Kasi dati puro ako
matataba pero ngayon hindi na. madalas na ko sa gulay. Noon kasi sisig lechon
pero ngayon nakakatakot na. nahihilig na talaga ako sa gulay kasi natatakot na
kong maulit na naman pa yung nangyare”[PCAP5 line 104-109]
I only eat (Low fat and more nutritious foods. I always eat fatty foods back then
but now I have settled to veggies and grilled pork were my favorite but now with
the fear of my condition I stuck with vegetables because I fear that I might suffer
another attack.)
increasing risks of developing heart problems in the United States (American Heart
current condition of the heart and there are three major elements that would reduce all
modifiable risks: Exercise, healthy lifestyle and stress reduction (American Heart
Association, 2016). Therefore, adherence to proper diet would highly affect the quality of
health the informants will possess. Healthcare providers such as nurses could intervene in
this type of situations by providing proper knowledge on what type of diet should be
Aside from changes in diet plans informants also emphasized that along with diet
they have discontinued and eradicated completely their unhealthy habits such as tobacco
smoking. To a better understanding here are some of the significant statements made by
the informants:
“Pero ngayon hindi na. eh kahit labag sa loob ko kelangan kong sumunod lalo na
kung gusto mong mabuhay pa ng mas matagal. Kelangan iwasan ang dapat
iwasan hindi naman habang buhay eh magagawa mo yung mga ganoong bagay.
Iyong paninigarilyo ko tinigil ko na talaga. Minsan darating talaga yon.”
[PCAP5 line 29-34]
(Though it is hard for me and I don’t like it. I have to follow what is best for my
health especially when you want to live longer. Avoid what is harmful to health
because you cannot always do those things anymore. I have stopped smoking.
“Gaya nga ng sabi ko mga habits ko kung noon eh ako ay madalas manigarilyo
ngayon wala na talaga. Mahirap magkasakit ng ganto kelangan mag-ingat ka na
habang malakas ka pa.” [PCAP2 line 59-63]
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
(I had bad habits back then like frequent smoking but now I have stopped. It’s
hard to deal with this condition that’s why you have to stay healthy while you’re
Tobacco smoking has been the leading cause for cardiovascular diseases even
light and low-tar cigarettes can increase the risks. Smoking cessation can substantially
decrease risks of attacks within a few weeks (University of Iowa, 2016). With regards to
experiences of the informants, change in their lifestyle habits and removing tobacco
smoking to it can substantially decrease their risk of having another attack therefore
decreasing the chances of being resuscitated again in which also leads to decreasing the
anxiety felt by the informants as to the recurrence of their attacks and resuscitations. This
practice should be advised and elaborated by the nurses through health teaching imposing
Aside from changing diet and smoking cessation informants have also
emphasized that they have totally eradicated alcohol from their diet because it was
advised to them that alcoholic beverages can also harm the health of their heart. To
further explain informants have provided the following significant statements through
interview:
(I’m scared of drinking after my attacks. You have to change when you are sick
because if you are stubborn it will only worsen your condition. It will just kill
you. )
“Ganun talaga kung gustong humaba pa ang buhay, alisin ang kinakaugalian
mong gawin o kainin lalo mga bisyo na yosi at alak dapat wala na
talaga.”[PCAP5 line36-38]
(If you want to preserve and prolong your life you have to change your ways
In the like manner, alcohol consumption also contributes to increasing the risks of
developing heart diseases because alcohol can increase the levels of blood pressure which
may most likely lead to heart problems. Aside from this, according to Sandee LaMotte in
CNN Philippines (2018) there is no amount of alcohol consumption which is good for the
health and it is better not to drink at all. Therefore, total eradication of alcohol from their
diets can significantly improve their health conditions and it is a responsibility of nurses
With regards to healthy lifestyle informants have stated that in combination with
their proper diet and eradication of bad health habits they have also added exercise in
their daily routine to accompany them in keeping their heart functioning and active. In
order to clarify this notion the following statements will state their experiences:
“Di ako madalas nakahiga sabi nga ng doctor eh exercise! Sa umaga na parang
ah nagjojogging pero hindi naman jogging na patakbo yun bang unti unti na
lalakad ka. Yun iaano mo ang katawan mo para bang step by step yung paglakad
mo eh dahan dahan hanggang sa pabilis ng pabilis” [PCAP1 line 88-95]
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
(My doctor told me to exercise. I jog at the morning but with precaution because I
(After my attacks, I don’t usually do much but I go out and try jog and exercise. I
walk and run to aid proper and more efficient blood circulation.)
It also shows that along with proper diet, and healthy habits it is also important to
allot time for proper exercise. For people with heart conditions it is important that
exercise should be kept in moderation and gradually increase level of exercise because
extensive exercises can stress out the heart (Chest Heart and Stroke Scotland, 2018). It
was advised by the American Heart Association (2015) through their Cardiac
Rehabilitation Program that one of the major elements affecting cardiac health is proper
exercise. There has been a study focusing on how muscle strengthening activities could
help reduce risk to acquiring CVD. Moreover, Physical activities are good predictators of
the health status of an individual (Artero et al, 2013). Ability of informants to perform
therefore with moderation in exercises and activities could aid the informants to achieve
their old activities again if pursued with commitment along with other adjustments with
Strength Deterioration
Apart from the adjustments made by the informants, symptoms of the damage to
their health are still evident in their day to day activities. One of these symptoms is the
“Mas masakit yung pangalawa kong atake. Kasi yung pangalawa mas malala.
Yung una kasi unexpected eh biglaan talaga yung pangalawa naman alam mo na
kasi pag naramdaman mo na kaya may halo ng takot. Parang habang tumatagal
lalo kasing lumalala”[PCAP5 line 67-72]
(My second attack was more painful and worse. My first was unexpected but
when I felt the symptoms on my second attack I felt fear because it feels like with
“Nung pangatlong atake ko, mataas ang kolesterol ko. Eh ayun nga para akong
nawawalan ng pag-asa. Parang napanghihinaan na ko hindi parang dati na ang
lakas ko.” [PCAP4 line 45-48]
(I had high cholesterol levels on my third attack. I felt hopeless. I feel so weak
(It is harder this time. It is when you feel useless because your body can’t function
properly.)
Moreover, through the statements from the informants it highlighted that there is
feeling of fatigue on patients even with small activities alone. After surviving cardiac
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
arrests it was found out that most patients experience significant impairments in their
level of functioning. Up to 50% of patients who suffered cardiac arrests have complained
a way to explain this aspect of experience by the patients. In this stage of psychosocial
person doesn’t feel like he/she is able to attain productivity, it is likely that the person
will end up stagnant and lose his/her resolve to perform tasks. If the person feels like
he/she is able to function and still be productive despite other factors, he is able to cope
and therefore falls on the generativity side (McLeod, 2018). Thus, post resuscitated
patients may feel stagnated due to being unable to perform tasks because of the
deterioration in physiological strength but however they could also achieve generativity if
the informants are able to cope with activities and would be able to view alternatives in
This is also one of the responsibilities of nurses as helping the informants to find
techniques that could aid carrying out of activities or use of assistive devices that can
patients, it has also been emphasized by the informants that the changes they have
encountered have also wounded them emotionally. Most specifically, the changes in their
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
roles as a human being as to their functions in the society, friends and family. Statements
(I am not able to help with my family anymore. My daughter stays with me. I
used to come over to my friends but it is the other way around now)
“Nahihiya at naawa ako sa mga anak ko kasi dapat ako pa din ang tumutulong
sakanila. Eh ngayon sila pa nag-aalaga saken. May mga anak na sila naano ako
kasi dadagdag pa ko sa alagain at gastos”[PCAP4 line 68-71]
(I am ashamed to face my family because I can’t provide for them anymore. Now,
I feel like I am being a burden to my family.)
It was evident with the statements of the patients shows how significantly affected
Wachelder et al (2009), approximately 38% of people who have survived suffer from
anxiety and depression. As seen and observed by the informants, anxiety and depression
is likely taking place in their lives with regards to their inability to do the duties they used
to perform. In line with this, healthcare providers should intervene with this situation as
patients, it has also been emphasized by the informants that the changes they have
encountered have also wounded them emotionally. Most specifically, the changes in their
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
roles as a human being as to their functions in the society, friends and family. Statements
(I am not able to help with my family anymore. My daughter stays with me. I
used to come over to my friends but it is the other way around now)
“Nahihiya at naawa ako sa mga anak ko kasi dapat ako pa din ang tumutulong
sakanila. Eh ngayon sila pa nag-aalaga saken. May mga anak na sila naano ako
kasi dadagdag pa ko sa alagain at gastos”[PCAP4 line 68-71]
(I am ashamed to face my family because I can’t provide for them anymore. Now,
I feel like I am being a burden to my family.)
It was evident with the statements of the patients shows how significantly affected
Wachelder et al (2009), approximately 38% of people who have survived suffer from
anxiety and depression. As seen and observed by the informants, anxiety and depression
is likely taking place in their lives with regards to their inability to do the duties they used
to perform. In line with this, healthcare providers should intervene with this situation as
anxiousness toward anticipated loss. It had been highlighted by the informants that after
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
being resuscitated multiple times, it made them frightened of what are the other possible
outcomes of their resuscitation and how it would affect them as well as their significant
others. Being terrified of another arrest and resuscitation made them feel uneasy. To
further elaborate significant statements are taken from the informants’ interviews:
must. Sometimes, when I feel tired I also feel uneasy because I might get another
“Siguro yung gawain ko noon kasi normal, ngayon madami ng bawal. Kaunting
kibot takot. May kaba. Baka anytime atakihin” [PCAP3 line 48-51]
(Back then I have normal routines but now there are so many restrictions. With
just simple activities and I feel like there is going to be another attack)
“At yung kaba kapag may nararamdaman kang paninikip ng dibdib parang
hayan na naman jusko baka eto na to. Kasi pag inatake ka naman di mo masasabi
kung anong mangyayare” [PCAP5 line 95-98]
(There is fear every time I feel my chest tighten. I got this notion that tells me that
their attacks and moreover what would be its result. According to American Heart
Association (2018), it is normal to be afraid for not having full control over one’s own
life but through positive self-talk and proper understanding to own condition it could
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
lessen its symptoms. In chronic patients it was found that these types of patients have
more often and intense thoughts about their deaths (Khawar, 2013). In line with this, the
Heflick is a theory that proposed fear of death can trigger more positive behaviour to
people suffering from it. Therefore encouraging them to preserve life and may increase
worry towards their unexpected death happens commonly to patients with chronic
conditions like them but this fear or threat they feel to their lives can be utilized properly
in order to view life positively and to be able to preserve and value life better. This
concept must be realized by patients with the help of healthcare providers such as nurses.
Nurses should lead their patients toward this goal of life preservation through therapeutic
In addition0, informants who have considered that their condition may lead to
their own death have also prepared and felt dreaded that soon they may leave their family
behind. Patients have emphasized their feelings of worry about what would happen to
their family if the attacks would recur and result to death. In order to elaborate the
“Masakit at malungkot. Natatakot akong maiwan ang pamilya ko. Ayoko silang
iwan. Kelangan pa nila ako at gusto ko pa silang mapanood, makita at
makasama” [PCAP3 line 13-17]
(Painful and sad. I don’t want to leave my family. They still need me. And I want
(You have to change. It is hard to leave because my children are still young. My
husband can’t take care of them on his own. That’s why I still want to live longer)
Informants have emphasized their concerns regarding the aftermath of their death
concerning their families. The most distressing event a family could suffer is a death
crisis which is inevitable and could disrupt a family system. (Afolabi, 2014) Death of a
family member can highly affect family status functionally because of the sudden
presence of a space or void on where someone once was (Rosalia, 2016), this can also be
a factor that could contribute in developing a dysfunctional family that could lead to
problems and marital conflicts (Giuffra, n.d). Informants verbalized their thoughts with
regards to what will happen if death would finally separate them to their families which
may result to dysfunctional families. As nurses, along with the patient, family should also
be prepared with the outcomes of the patient’s disease. Through health teaching letting
the family decide and be included with the treatment activities of the patient would be
able to enlighten and prepare the family as to what are the possible situations their family
Spiritual Stability
In contrary to the dreadful situation of the informants, they were also able to cope
and thought of the good side. Informants were able to recognize that despite their losses,
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
recovery and attaining functional level of health is not farfetched. With proper discipline
productivity. To clarify this notion patients have given statements through their
interviews:
“Wag matigas ang ulo. Sumusunod at iniiwasan ang bawal para mabuhay pa ng
mahaba haba. Siguro laban lang! sayang ang buhay kung ano ang pinagkaloob
tanggapin na lang para mabawasan ang sakit. Magpagaling at sumunod sa
doctor” [PCAP3 line 69-75]
shame to waste life and you have to accept to reduce the pain. Take care and
(Be careful on what to eat. At night, we don’t know it might recur. Just be careful
because we can never tell when and where it might happen again)
By analysing the statements, it was evident that the informants have developed a
positive approach towards their condition. As they have perceived treatment regimens to
be helpful to relieving symptoms it also has provided them sense of control over their
condition. Moreover, this can also enable people to work for their recovery and provide
quality of life the patient would live. Aside from that, patients are also likely to be more
statements. Stability of the informants through this coping mechanism could substantially
affect their behaviour towards their condition making them more reliable and
resuscitated patients. It was also stated by the informants that they have learned to cherish
their life and make the most out of it. Due to the fear of dying it led the patients to value
and recognizes the worth of their life and health. Explaining these experiences from the
(I can see that I am a blessed person. The Lord gave me another chance to
(I am lucky that I am still able to spend time with my family again. I am grateful
Most patients having near death experience have emerged with more positive
perception regarding living a fulfilled and significant life despite their distressing
struggles and tremendous emotions (Hartley, 2016) Statistically, 80% of people who
suffered a near death experience have claimed that this made a significant difference in
their lives in various aspects. In addition these patients have developed a notion to focus
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
on what he/she has now rather than stressing out over the past experiences. (Atwater,
2017). As verbalized by the informants through their experiences, their attacks and
resuscitations have made them see the worth of their lives with regards to their unfulfilled
functions and as to their point of views of their achievements. This positive outlook could
with regards to the interventions that requires cooperation of patient and this positive
attitude should be achieved with the support of therapeutic communication used by the
nurses.
Family support
Through observation and statements of the informants, the support from the
family has been evidently shown especially after multiple resuscitations because it had
been perceived that cardiac arrests can manifest multiple times and it is likely to reoccur.
Significant statements taken during the interview with the patients will provide better
(They have supported me. That’s what helped me not to feel sad over myself and
they never made feel left out. I have seen them exert their efforts. When I feel
sick, all of them are there to take care of me. They never leave me. That’s what
made me stronger)
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
(I really had admonish from my wife but I understand because I know she
is only worried about me. My children were also worried and stayed with me at
the hospital. I am thankful for them. All eight of them were really there.)
Consistent and strong support system is one of the most significant essentials for
fast and efficient recovery of most patients suffering from different illnesses (Landau,
2011) in a study by Rosland and Piette (2015), family members should help their patients
feelings of anxiety of patients by having the sense of familiarity. With regards to the
experiences of the informants, the support provided by their family members had made
them feel at ease. Nurses assess the overall health of patients and included with these is
how the family members of the patient cope because ineffective coping of the family can
lead to disruption to the functions of the family in which should be seen as a possible
problem that threatens the health of individuals. Thus, this a responsibility of a nurse to
In line with the statement of the problems of this study, through extensive analysis of the
experiences of the informants the questions have been provided with answers.
1. What are the difficulties of post cardiac arrest patients after multiple
resuscitations?
Through the experiences of post cardiac arrest patients that have been shared, the
researchers are able to determine the difficulties of patients with regards to their
complaints and worries that have been expressed through the interviews. One of the main
problems faced by the informants is their inability to return to their old habits as well as
Their feeling of body weakness and short span of endurance have made them more
worried about their condition. Due to their incapacity for activities, this has also made
them feel useless and unproductive some have progressed to depression however most
are able to get by and see their condition positively. Aside from the depression there is
also fear towards own death. The two sides of post resuscitation results can be very
informants has wounded them deeply because it had made them too conscious of time left
for them and what are the things that they will miss. These difficulties are main concerns
of the informants but with these difficulties, adaptive coping techniques emerged.
As mentioned by the experiences of the informants, coping was never easy and it had
been their main struggle but through analysis, coping techniques presented and adapted
by the patients have made their way of living easier. As discussed above, one of the
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
informants is that they have adjusted their lifestyle in order to improve their health status
therefore making more able to perform activities. Along with lifestyle changes, they have
been more committed and adhered to treatment plans in attempt to strengthen them and
improve their capacity to tolerate activities. Also, aside from problems with activities,
anxiety was suffered by the informants due to their impending deaths. Near death
experience have affected them and have built up fear within them. With this fear,
second chance as well as to value their time and live a fulfilling life. This positive
outlook had led them to be more independent, reliable and cooperative to treatment
process also promoted adherence to medical advises and medication. Also, with the aid of
the optimism developed by the informants they are able to cope with their depression and
Chapter 4
Upon doing the study, all the data gathered by the researchers by way of using a
and analysed fully. The researchers also formulated the meanings from the statements
precisely arrange the gathered data and the formulated meanings into theme clusters
which are all under the emergent themes through extensive examinations. Nonetheless,
the statements made by the informants aided the researchers to come up with an analysis
as well as evaluate the experiences they had from their multiple resuscitations. From the
changes and adjustments they made down to their way of coping and accepting their
situations.
In addition to this, the extracted data from the informants’ verbal replies to the
questions provided are used by the researchers as basis for an in-depth discussion. In
order to broaden the understanding with regards to the experiences of the multiple
resuscitated patients. With the process of analysis and screening made by the researchers,
some information given by the patients were found irrelevant to the focus of the study
Under this emergent theme are the experiences of the informants on the first onset
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
of their attack and resuscitation. The following theme clusters are grouped according to
the aspects of health where the informants are affected. Alongside, are also how the
patient’s overthrew the difficulties and premises they have encountered along their way.
Also, emphasized in this theme, is how the informant’s view their selves after what
happened.
In this theme cluster, it had been elaborated that the informants experienced
inability to accept their condition mostly due to its sudden onset. It was also highlighted
how difficult it is for the patients to accept their condition. Moreover, stated in this theme
cluster are the manifestations of denial as the informant’s coping technique in facing the
This theme explains another experience of the informants wherein they have
are hard to be achieved by these patients due to the weakness of the body that they are
suffering. Along with this, is that informants tend to alter or reduce their activities and
more often it is necessary for them to always have someone available to assist them in
activities.
resuscitation. Adherences to diet plans and lifestyle readjustments are the major elements
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
compliance could be risky and may not promote increase to the level of health the
As part of the changes the patients should undergo is the modification in their diet
which is another experience that made the patient find their conditions to be difficult and
challenging. Diet regimens have been one of the main complaints of patients and also the
most difficult to follow. Informants have emphasized that oftentimes they are not able to
follow the diet requirement advised by the doctors and they tend to cheat more frequent
Decrease in vices
With cooperation of the informants, one of their difficulties is also removing vices
from their everyday routine. Though the adjustments like these are already done by the
patients, adherence and total eradication of these vices are not yet achieved and
challenging to these type of patients due to not recognizing the severity of their condition
Recurrence of attacks
In this emergent theme, it was highlighted the experiences of the informants who
have experienced resuscitation from cardiac arrests. This shows the difficulties and their
Due to its recurrence it made the individuals gain understanding and acceptance to
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
their condition. Along with this, their feelings of being unable to control their condition
Another theme cluster that explains what changes these patients have made with
regards to enhancing their health and preventing another attack. With these experiences it
also provided ways on how to keep and take care of their health as to reducing their risks
Strength deterioration
cluster. It was found out that with every recurrence of resuscitation, they felt weak and it
Demotion in the roles of the patients, in the family, community and society, have
made the informants feel worthless. Especially to the patients who have been providers of
the family, they have expressed disappointments on being unable to work and function as
Fear has been evident to these patients as they verbalized their fear of losing.
Losing their family, as with regards to their future death which explains their fear of
being separated to their family. Losing their own life, in line with their condition it is
undeniable that this may be the cause of their own death which is what they fear.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Spiritual stability
Despite all the losses they fear, these patients have verbalized some realizations
that their conditions have taught them and one of them is to value their lives because it is
a chance given to them to spend more time with the people around them and also having
Family support
Support system from their loved ones has been more evident after being
resuscitated multiple times according to the informants. They have also viewed as this as
their motivation in fighting off their condition and striving to live longer along with
Conclusions
The conclusions that have been the product of this research are as follows:
1. The experiences of the patients who underwent resuscitation multiple times are
arranged and classified into variety of themes. This study has focused mostly on
2. Along with the differences, the informants have struggled through, coping
behaviours were also tackled and explained as to how they have managed to
3. This study also shows the domino effect on how the patients have been affected
between each change they have to overcome and how does these alterations have
4. In addition, with regards to the different aspects of health this study shows that
5. This study also shows the variety of coping mechanisms used by the informants
and how it affected their condition regardless to the direction of its development
6. Introduced also by this study is the comparison of the experiences of patients who
have undergone resuscitation once and patients who had it several times.
Differences between the two set of experiences were elaborated to pin point the
7. Moreover, it is observed that to these people the element of time is very essential
for they view that they only had little to spend. Therefore, valuing their lives more
Recommendations
With all the gathered data, the researchers would like to suggest the following
recommendations for the lived experiences of post-cardiac arrest patients who have been
For the post-cardiac arrest patients who have been resuscitated multiple times
This research would facilitate them to exhibit the understanding towards their own
experiences and let them see what phase they are going to deal with which would let
them be aware of their own condition. Afterward, the research proposes to understand life
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
experiences of the post-cardiac arrest patients who have been resuscitated multiple times
in which this premise enact itself as living testaments that would draw the other post-
For the post-cardiac arrest patient who have been resuscitated once
This research would enable them to display the understanding with regards to the
experiences of the post-cardiac patients that have been resuscitated multiple times for
them to accept and recognized their condition early. Subsequently, the research intends to
help them to have insight on the things that the patients that who have been resuscitated
multiple times neglected to do hence; it would help them prevent worsening. Through
health teachings, the data gathered by this study could be disseminated to aid patients
understand their condition and take treatmen regimens seriously. Aside from health
teachings, coping techniques that have emerged in this study could be suggested to the
Primarily one of the common recommendations that the study would contribute for
the future researchers would able to extract portion of information on the study.
Moreover, the impact and difficulties of patients who have been revive not once but
multiple times from cardiac patients would be the keyword for the researchers to find the
needed information that the premise would be able to give. Furthermore, the researchers
could also consider suggesting, improving and revising the factors that are involved on
the research. This study could be furthermore elaborated and discussed using different
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
varieties of individual. In addition, different research designs and instruments should also
be tested to get another angle of approach that could help analysis be more broad and
extensive.
For the family of the patients who have been revive multiple times from cardiac
arrest
Lastly, the support system involves the family to dive into awareness to the
through this research. With the given research, physiological and psychological aspects
that are mentioned would enable the family to widen and maximize their understanding
regarding on how they can help them to cope with their condition. Moreover, adaptation
of other coping techniques could be provided by this study to multiple post-cardiac arrest
patients.
The research study can serve as references not only for future studies but also in
formulating care for these types of patients. Coping techniques included in this study
could be suggested to patients and this study would also serve as guide as to what were
possible difficulties patients would encounter. Having knowledge with the future
problems of these patients, nurses and health care providers may perform preventive
measures and prepare the patient to what it may have affected him/her.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Transcrip
Times Pag Lin Significant Formulated Theme Emergent
t No. e e Meaning Meaning Cluster Theme
No. No.
PCAP4 90- 84- “Kasi nung una - does not take Incompliance First Onset
91 89 kong binigyan medications of Attack
ng maintenance to Medical
regularly
ininom ko lang
Advises
siya ng tatlong
-uninterested
taon tapos
inistop ko nung with treatment
inistop ko dun regimens and
na siya
recovery
umatake. Tapos
uminom ako ulit procedure
so nung mga
nakaginhawa
ako umistop na
naman ako.
Nung umokay
na ko inistop ko
na yun.”
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
PCAP4 89 35- Una kong atake - does not take Incompliance First Onset
39 sabi ng doctor medications of Attack
pwede daw to Medical
regularly
akong
Advises
magpaopera
-uninterested
pero baka daw
di ko kayanin. with treatment
Naisip ko regimens and
naman na
recovery
madadaan pa
naman to sa procedure
pag-iingat at
siguro sa gamot
kung sakali kaya
di din ako
pumayag.
Nagpauwe na ko
sa mga anak ko
nun
PCAP1 84 140 “Pero nung sa - does not take Incompliance First Onset
- unang beses ko medications of Attack
145 di ako to Medical
regularly
nakakapagpa-
Advises
check up ng
-uninterested
madalas kung
kelan lang with treatment
sipagin ganon. regimens and
Kasi ang ano ko
recovery
naman
kampante ako procedure
dahil di naman
ako
nakakaramdam
ng kung ano
ano.”
ako kasi
delikado na ang
kalusugan ko.
Naninigarilyo
pa din naman
hindi naman
tulad dati kasi
dati umuubos
ako ng isang
kaha
maghapon.”
kaya ganoon.”
nahihilig na beverages
talaga ako sa
gulay kasi - proper body
natatakot na workout
kong maulit na
naman pa yung
nangyare”
- proper body
workout
- proper body
workout
na talaga.” alcoholic
beverages
- proper body
workout
- proper body
workout
others
References
ACLC Medical Training. 2018. Is it a Heart Attack or Cardiac Arrest. Retrieved August
2018 from https://www.aclcmedicaltraining.com
Afolabi, O. 2014 May 2. Death, Grief and Family Dynamics: The Impact of Family
Member’s Death and Delayed Grief Resolution on the Family System. SSRN. p 1.
Retrieved September 2018 from https://papers.ssrn.com
American Heart Association. 2016 July 31. What is Cardiac Rehabilitation Retrieved
September 2018 from https://www.heart.org
American Heart Association. 2014 August 15. Alcohol and Heart Health. Retrieved
September 2018 from https://www.heart.org
American Heart Association. 2015 July 31. Lifestyle Changes for Heart Attack
Prevention. Retrieved September 2018 from htpps://www.heart.org
American Heart Association. 2018. Coping with Feelings. Retrived September 2018 from
https://www.cprconsultants.com
American Heart Association. 2018. Heart Attack or Sudden Cardiac Arrest: How are they
different. Retrieved 2018 from htpps://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/
Atwater, P.M.H. 2017 December 14. After effects of Near-Death States. IANDS.
Retrieved September 2018 from https://iands.org
Artero, E.G. Lee, DC. Lavie, C.J. Romero, V.E. Sui, X. Church, T.S. and Blair, S.N.
2013 November 1. Efffects of Muscular Strength on Cardiovascular Risk Factors
and Prognosis. Journal of cardiopulmonary rehabilitation and prevention.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Borne, R.T. Katz, D. Betz, J. Peterson, P.N., & Masoudin, F.A. 2017, March 3.
Implantable Cardioverter-Defribillators for Secondary Prevention of Sudden
Cardiac Death: A Review. Journal of the American Heart Association. Retrieved
August 2018 from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/article/PMC552404
Braddock, C.H. Clark, J.D. 1998. Do Not Resuscitate (DNAR) Orders. Ethics in
Medicine. Retrieved August 2018 from
https://depts.washingtonedu./bioethx/topics/dnr.html
Buban, C.E. 2015, October 3. Do you know how many Filipinos die daily from heart
attack and stroke. Inquirer.Net. Retrieved August 2018 from
https://m.inquirer.net/business/200169
Bueno, M.T. Enriquez, E.J. Medina, T. Pastrana, E. Roxas, A. 2018 March. VISUAL
ACETIC ACID: Its Effectiveness as an Early Detection Test for Cervical Cancer.
2018. pp. 30-32
Chest Heart and Stroke Scotland, 2018. Home exercise and walking – exercise after a
heart attack. Retrieved September 2018 from https://www.chss.org.uk
Coleman, C.I. Limone, B. Sobieraj, D.M. Lee, S. Roberts, M.S. Kaur, R. & Alam, T.
2012 September. Dosing frequency and medication adherence in chronic disease.
PubMed. 18. p528. Retrieved October 2018 from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Covino, J.M. Stern, T.W. & Stern, T.A. n.d. Denial of Cardiac Illness: Consequences and
Management. The Primary Care Companion to CNS Disorders. Retrieved
November 2018 from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3267499/
DerSarkissian, C. 2016 November 6. What is Normal Grieving, and What Are the Stages
of Grief. WebMD. Retrieved October 2018 from
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
https://www.webmd.com/balance/normal-grieving-and -stages-of-grief
Ebell, M.H. Jang, W. Shen, Y., & Geocadin, R.G. 2013, November 11. Development and
Validation of the Good Outcome Following Attempted Resuscitaion (GO-FAR)
Score to Predict Neurologically Intact Survival After In-Hospital
Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation. Jama Internal Medicine. Retrieved August 2018
from https://jmanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/1735894
Forslund, A.S. Lundblad, D. Jansson, A. H. Zingmark, K., & Soderberg, S. 2013. Risk
factor among people surviving out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and their thoughts
about what lifestyles means to them: a mixed method study. BMC Cardiovascular
Disorders. Retrieved August 2018 from
https://cardiovascdisord.biomedcentral.com
Forslund, A.S. Lundblad, D. Jansson, A. H., & Soderberg, S. 2017. A second chance at
life:people’s lived experiences of surviving out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Wiley
Online Library. Retrieved August 2018 from
htpps://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/scs.12409
Gregory, C. 2018 February 14. The Five Stages of Grief: An Examination of the Kubler-
Ross Model. Psycom. Rertrived August 2018 from
https://www.psycom.net/depression.central.grief.html
Giuffra, M.J. n.d. Impact Death on the Family System. Research Presented at the
American Orthopsychiatric Associated Conference.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Hartley, V. 2016 July 5. How a Near Death Experience can change a Person’s Life.
Watkins. Retrieved September 2018 from https://www.watkinspublishing.com
Heflick, N.A. 2012 June 10. How We Cope With Death.Psychology Today. Retrieved September
2018 from https://www.psychologytoday.com
Holland, J.M. 2014, February. Elisabeth Kübler-Ross. Retrieved August 2018 from
https://ww.researchgate.net
Horizon Research Foundation Science at the Horizon of Life. 2007. Long Term
Psychological and Cognitive of Surviving A Cardiac Arrest. Retrieved August
2018 from https://horizonresearch.org/for-professionals/long-term-effects-of-
surviving-a-cardiac-arrest/
Jegtvig, S. 2014, May 9. For elderly hospital patients, CPR often has poor
outcome:study. Reuters. Retrieved August 2018 from https://www.reuters.com
Kim Y.J. Rogers, J.C. Raina, K.D. Callaway, C.W. Rittenberger, J.C. Leibold, M.L
Holm, M.B. 2017. Solving fatigue-related problems with cardiac arrest survivors
living in the community. PubMed. Retrieved October 2018 from
https://www.ncbi.nim.nih.gov/m/pubmed/28698007
Khawar, M. Aslam, N. Aamir, S. 2013 September. Perceived Social Support and Death
Anxiety Among Patients with Chronic Disease. Vol 52 p75
LaMotte, S. 2018 August 24. No amount of alcohol is good for your overall health,
global study says. CNN Philippines . Retrieved September 2018 from
https://cnnphilippines.com
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Landau, E. 2011 January 19. Healing touch of family, friends aids recovery. CNN.
Retrieved September 2018 from https://www.cnn.com
Lunas, B. 2016 March 2. Cardiac arrest deaths can be prevented if people knew how to
give CPR. manilastandard.net. Retrieved December 2018 from
https://manilastandard.net/mobile/article/200776
Manila Standard Lifestyle. 2018 April 30. The difference between heart attack and
cardiac arrest. manilastandard.net. Retrieved December 2018 from
http://manilastandard.net/lifestyle/wellbeing/264466/the-difference-between-
heart-attack-and-cardiac-arrest.html
Mukamal, K.J. 2006 . The Effects of Smoking and Drinking on Cardiovascular Disease
and Risk Factors. NIH. Retrieved September 2018 from https://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov
Philippine Heart Association. 2018. Sudden Cardiac Arrest and the value of CPR.
Retrieved April 2018 from http://www.philheart.org/index.php/cpr/569-sudden-
cardiac-arrest-and-the-value-of-cpr
Polit, D.F. Beck, C.T. 2017. Nursing Research Principles and Methods. Philadelphia:
Lippincott William & Wilkins
Rodriguez, E.L. 2018. Welcome to the Community Health Education Program. UIW.
Retriever October 2018 from https://www.ulw.edu/snhp/che
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Rosalia, 2016 April 13.Quality of Life: The Impact of Loss on the Family System.
CareCompany. Retrieved September 2018 from https://www.carecompany.co.za
Rosland, A.M & Piette, J.D. 2015 March 4. Emerging Models for Mobilizing Family
Support for Chronic Disease Management: A Structured Review. PMC. Retrieved
September 2018 from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Shaw, G. 2014 October 3. Can You Reverse Heart Disease. WebMD. Retrieved October
2018 from https://www.webmd.com
Sincero, S.M. 2012 November 23. Stress and Coping Mechanisms. Explorable. Retrieved
October 2018 from https://explorable.com/stress-and-coping-mechanisms
Unantenne, N. 2013 December. The Strength to Cope: Spirituality and Faith in Chronic
Disease. Retrieved September 2018 from https://www.researchgate.net
University of Iowa, 2016 October . Risk factors for heart disease: Frequently asked
questions. Retrieved September 2018 from https://uihc.org
Uy, J.R. 2014 October 20. Thousands die of cardiac arrest because witnesses do not know
CPR, say doctors. Philippine Daily Inquirer. Retrieved December 2018 from
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/645889/thousands-die-of-cardiac-arrest-because-
witnesses-do-not-know-cpr-say-doctors
Vera, M. 2014 , August 19. Sister Callista Roy’s Adaptation Model of Nursing.
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Wachelder, E.M. Moulaert, V.R. van Heugten, C. Verbunt, J.A. Bekkers, S.C. & Wade,
D.T. 2009. Life after survival: long-term daily functioning and quality of life after
an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. PubMed. Retrieved September 2018 from
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Whats’s Your Grief. 2017, April 18. Grief Work: the grief theory of Erich Lindemann.
Retrieved August 2018 from htpps://whatsyourgrief.com/grief-work-grief-theory-
erich-lindemann/
World Health Organization. 2018 October. Healthy Diet. Retrieved November 2018 from
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/healthy-diet
APPENDICES
LETTER OF INTENT
Dear Ma’am/Sir,
Good day!
We, Fourth year Nursing students in College of Health and Sciences of Dr. Yanga’s Colleges
Inc., are conducting a research entitled “Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Postcardiac Arrest
Patients Who Have Been Resuscitated Multiple Times”, in partial fulfilment of our requirements
in Nursing Research 2.
In line with this, we are humbly seeking your permission to allow us to conduct a study in your
institution. The research is directed only on the experiences of postcardiac arrest patients that we
believe can be for great help for the said study. Their interview will be audio recorded. This
would not affect the credibility of the institution. We can assure that the information given as well
as the informant’s identity will be kept confidential.
Your cooperation is very much needed and appreciated for the success of this study. We are
hoping for your utmost consideration regarding this matter.
Respectfully yours,
The researchers
Noted by:
Approved by:
Consent of Participant
I have read the information presented in the information letter about a study being conducted by
the Fourth year Nursing students in the Colleges of Health and Sciences of Dr. Yanga’s Colleges,
Inc. I have had the opportunity to ask any information about the study, to received satisfactory
answer to my questions, and any details that I wanted. I am aware that I may withdraw from the
study without loss of participation credit at any time by advising the researchers of this
decision.
With full knowledge of all foregoing, I agree, of my own free will, to participate in that study.
Print Name
Signature of Participant
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
The following are the guide questions asked to the informants by the researchers using
semi-structured interview:
2. Are there any changes made every after resuscitation? What are these and
4. Are there any differences between every resuscitation? What are these and
5. What are the aspects of your life that have been affected by this
phenomenon?
6. With all of your experiences about the phenomenon, how did it affect your
well-being?
8. What are the preventive measures that you are doing in taking care of your
health?
9. With regards to your condition, how does your family deal with it?
10. What can you say to the people that are having the same condition?
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Transcript Line
number number Statements
PCAP 1 1 Eh blangko ang isip ko noong mga
2 panahon na ako ay nirerevive pero sa
3 umpisa eh ang nangyare eh hapon
4 bandang ala una nagising
5 akonararamdaman ko na masakit ang
6 dibdib ko, pinagpapawisan ako. Butil butil
7 ang pawis nang magpunta ako ng CR
8 dumumi ako tapos butil butil ang pawis ko
9 at masakit pa din ang dibdib ko. Edi nung
anon a yun eh ginising ko yung kasama ko
10
sa bahay at humingi ako ng tubig na
11
malamig at akoy uhaw. Nung bumangon
12
yung kasama ko hinipo ako at ako raw ay
13
basang basa ng pawis pinainom ako ng
14 tubig at pinahiga ako at binihisa tapos
15 nagising ako nasa hospital na ako at wala
16 na kong maalala. Yun yung una kong
17 atake yung pangalawa eh halos ganoon
18 din basang basa ako ng pawis at dibdib pa
19 din ang umaano sa aken anjan na may x-
20 ray ako. Taon bago umano yung
21 pangalawa kong atake meron yatang
22 pitong taon o walong taon. Mayroon
23 akong ECG noon x-ray tapos eh
24 pinagbabawal akong uminom ng malamig
na tubig eh hindi ko din mapigilin na para
25
bang ang lalamunan ko ay tuyong tuyo.
26
Atsaka inanno ako na para bang ang
27
dibdib ko’y masakit na masakit. Nawalan
28
ako ng malay noon blangko ang isip ko
29 wala akongf maalala noon. Kumbaga sa
30 ano eh akala ko eh ako’y mamamatay na
31 sa ganoong sitwasyon. Pagkagisisng ko’y
32 nasa hospital na ako. Mayroon akong
33 takot, kaba na baka maulit ulit yung
34 nangyare na yun na kumbaga eh baka pag
35 nangyare na yun doon na ko matuluyan
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Transcript Line
number number Statements
PCAP 2 1 Ako naman eh walang maramdaman at
2 tulog ako nun eh. Sumakit ang dibdib ko
3 tapos yung pawis ko tumutulo na. sabi ng
4 asawa ko eh dalhin na ko sa ospital.
5 Nung papunta na kami sa ospital eh
6 nawalan na ko ng malay. Nung mawalan
7 ako ng malay eh nasa ospital na ko
8 pagkagising ko. Sabi eh yung ano ko
9 tawag dun yung sa puso. Nung ano
10 nireresuscitate. Eh ang isip ko ay wala
11 parang madilim lang. blangko lang ang
isip ko. Wala akong naaalala sa mga
12
nangyayare. Sabi lang ng asawa ko
13
pagkagising ko eh atake nga daw. Di ko
14
alam yung mga nangyare saken nun.
15
Basta ang alam ko eh nawalan ako ng
16 malay. Eh pagkatapos kong makasurvive
17 netong pangalawa kong atake naging
18 mas maingat na ko sa mga pagkain ko.
19 Kadalasan puro gulay at isda. Di ko nga
20 maaya mga kaibigan ko. Di na ko
21 umiinom kasi nagagalit kasi nagagalit
22 ang misis ko. Iyong alak bawal. Gaya ng
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
62
63
Transcript Line
number number Statement
PCAP 3 1 Naalala ko nawalan na ko ng malay nun
2 pero bago yun habang nasa bahay pa ko
3 papasok sa trabaho nakaramdam ako ng
4 sakit sa balikat ko. Iyon tapos mabigat sa
5 dibdib na parng makirot ayun pagtapos
6 nun wala na kong maalala. Wala na kong..
7 maalala talaga. Wala na kong maalala
8 kung paano pero sabi saken ni jenny may
9 ginamit daw saken noon. Yung unang
beses ko kahit papaano sumubok ako ng
10
mga trabaho sa bahay pero yung katawan
11
ko ba eh parang umaayaw kasi ramdam ko
12
kaagad ang pagod. Masakit at malungkot.
13 Natatakot akong maiwan ang pamilya ko.
14 Ayoko silang iwan. Kelangan pa nila ako
15 at gusto ko pa silang mapanood, makita at
16 makasama.. Sa pitong taon , matapos nung
17 unang atake ngayon maayos na kahit ano
18 ng mangyare. Oo madami sa pamilya, sa
19 trabaho, pati na rin sa aking sarili. Mas
20 lalo kong gustong makasama ang pamilya
21 ko kahit na ano at makapagtrabaho at
22 makasama lang sila. Maswerte ako na
23 nandito pa ako para makasama ang
24 pamilya ko. Nagpapasalamat ako na may
pagkakataon pa ko. Marami ng bawal sa
25
aking gaya ng sa pagkain, pag gawa ng
26
mga bagay na dati kong ginagawa di ko na
27
magawa ngayon. Adjust! Kelangan eh.
28
Para sa pamilya. Naawa ako sa sarili ko
29 kasi kung dati malakas ako ngayon
30 mahina basta iba na. masakit makita na
31 kung dati nakakatrabaho ka ngayon asawa
32 at anak mo na lang. naging taong bahay na
33 lang ako. Pero ngayon kelangan sumunod.
34 Oo malaki ang nagbago kasi lalo pag first
35 time wala akong ideya sa nararamdaman
36 ko. Kaya naman tuloy pa din ako sa mga
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Transcript Line
number number Statement
PCAP 4 1 Ang naalala ko nun masakit ang dibdib ko, masakit siya
2 hanggang likod hanggang hindi na ko makahinga hirap
3 na hirap na ko. Yun yung una ah. Tapos nun nawalan na
4 ko ng malay. Pagtapos nung nawalan nga ako ng malay
5 ilang araw akong tulog. Sabi ng doctor sa loob daw ng
6 24hours at di pa ko ako nagising wala na.. ang alam ko
7 lang may naikabit silang aparato sa aken. Sabi ng anak ko
8 kinabitan nga daw ako tapos kumbaga naiiyak na daw
9 sila. Pinapatabi sila ng doctor nun wala na. nung iano raw
10 ako nabuhay daw ako kaya lang yun nga tulog. Meron
11 nung una may nagbago kasi nakaka… lahat ng mga ano
nagagawa ko. Nung una di ko talaga maisip na
12
mangyayare saken yung ganito para bang tinatanggi ng
13
isipan ko yung sitwasyon. Masakit kasi isipin na biglaan
14
eh. Ayun tapos etong sumunod na atake ko. Ano.. mga..
15 nawalan ako ng malay mga… apat na oras. Sabi ng anak
16 ko nung pangalawa. Ang ano lang nun ginagawa ng mga
17 anak ko di nila ko pinakikilos wala, sila na lahat ang
18 kumikilos, lahat ng gumagawa. Dahil bawal na sa akin
19 eh. Di na ko pede nung mga bagay na dating ginagawa di
20 ko na magawa. Dahil madaling mapagod yung puso ko.
21 Pangatlo na netong July 17. Parang nanghina na ko.. sabi
22 ng doctor di na daw pwedeng maoperahan kasi baka daw
23 bumigay na. kasi daw yung puso ko di na dinadaluyan ng
24 kuryente kaya hirap na siyang mag-ano. Oo meron kasi
25 yung una ko nung nagkamalay ako nung medyo nagising
26 ako nabalik ko pa yung dating lakas ng katawan ko eh
yung mga dapat kong ginagawa ako nagagawa ko pa.
27
etong huli, wala na. konting lakad lang hinihingal na ko
28
mabilis na kong mapagod. Eh ano kasi kung di lang dahil
29
sa mga anak ko baka bumigay na din ako saka yung apo
30
ko. Syempre dalawa na yung doctor na pinuntahan namin
31 iisa lang ang sinabi. Kasi yung unang pinuntahan namin
32 kumbaga di na daw tatagal akodoon na ko bumigay eh.
33 Una kong atake sabi ng doctor pwede daw akong
34 magpaopera pero baka daw di ko kayanin. Naisip ko
35 naman na madadaan pa naman to sa pag-iingat at siguro
36 sa gamot kung sakali kaya di din ako pumayag.
37 Nagpauwe ako na ko sa mga anak ko nun. Napanghinaan
38 na ko ng loob kaya lang yung mga kaibigan ko na
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Transcript Line
number number Statement
PCAP 5 1 Sa pagkakaalala ko mga dalwang beses na. nung una
2 medyo bata bata pa ko yung pangalawa ilang buwan lang
3 ang nakakalipa. Yung una trenta pa lang ako nun
4 ngayong pangalawa 44 na ko. May lahi kami ng may
5 sakit sa puso kasi di lang ako ang ganito sa pamilya
6 namin. Yung lolo’t lola ko yung ang kinamatay nila kay
7 nung inatake ako kala ko mamamatay na ko. Masakit ang
pakiramdam ko na parang may nakadagan sa katawan ko.
8
Pero parang di ko din naramdaman kasi nakakita ako ng
9
liwanag kala ko mamamatay na ko. Habang nakahiga ako
10
parang nasisilaw ako tas wala akong maramdaman sa
11 paligid ko. Natutulog lang ako ng tanghali nun. Biglang
12 sumakit yung dibdib ko tas tinawag ko yung asawa ko tas
13 nawalan na ko ng malay. Di ko na maalala yung nangyare
14 basta paggising ko nasa ospital na ko. Dinala na nila ako
15 sa hospital. Actually, di ko maalala yung ginawa sa aken.
16 Nagising ako sinabi saken ng asawa ko yung tungkol sa
17 kondisyon ko di ako nakasalita. Ayoko eh. Ang naisip ko
18 agad “bakit? Bakit ako?”. Tumagal na din ng may
19 konting takot at kaba pero kahit ganun pasasalamat sa
20 taas kasi kung oras mo oras mo na ika nga ng iba. Ayun
21 lang wala namang pagsisise kasi buhay mo yan eh
22 ginusto mo yan. Syempre babawasan ang mga bisyo ko at
yung mga pagkain na hindi dapat kainin. Sino bang
23
walang bisyo malakas akong uminom noon pati sigarilyo.
24
Unang beses na atakihin ako nagbabawas ako kasi
25
delikado na ang kalusugan ko. Naninigarilyo pa din
26
naman hindi naman tulad dati kasi dati umuubos ako ng
27 isang kaha maghapon. Pero ngayon hindi na. eh kahit
28 labag sa loob ko kelangan kong sumunod lalo na kung
29 gusto mong mabuhay pa ng mas matagal. Kelangan
30 iwasan ang dapat iwasan hindi naman habang buhay eh
31 magagawa mo yung mga ganoong bagay. Iyong
32 paninigarilyo ko tinigil ko na talaga. Minsan darating
33 talaga yon. Tulad ko medyo bata bata pa ko nung inatake
34 ako medyo minalas lang ako pero ganun talaga kung
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Educational Attainment:
Personal Information:
Date of Birth: September 20, 1998
Place of Birth: Sta. Maria, Bulacan
Height: 5’4’’
Weight: 122 lbs
Civil Status: Single
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
PERSONAL INFORMATION
Age: 20 years old
Gender: Female
Height: 5'2 ft
Weight: 47 kg
Religion: Catholic
Birthdate: June 20, 1998
Birthplace: Bagumbayan Bulakan,Bulacan
Citizenship: Filipino
Religion: Catholic
Civil Status: Single
Mother: Carmela C. Doria
Father: Wilfredo C. Doria
DR. YANGA’S COLLEGES, INC.
Life Restarted: Lived Experiences of Post-Cardiac Arrest Patients Who have been Resuscitated Multiple
Times
Personal Information
Status: Single
Gender: Female
Nationality: Filipino
Educational Background
Secondary
Elementary