Sei sulla pagina 1di 7

International Journal of Nursing Practice 2008; 14: 122–128

RESEARCH PAPER

The lived experience of gay men caring for others


with HIV/AIDS: Resilient coping skills
Ian Munro RN PhD
Lecturer, School of Nursing, Deakin University, Burwood, Victoria, Australia

Karen-Leigh Edward RN PhD


Research Fellow, School of Nursing, Deakin University, Burwood, Victoria, Australia

Accepted for publication November 2007

Munro I, Edward K-L. International Journal of Nursing Practice 2008; 14: 122–128
The lived experience of gay men caring for others with HIV/AIDS: Resilient coping skills

There is a dearth of research conducted on the relationship aspect of gay men caring for gay men. This Australian research
conducted in 2002 investigated the emotional effects of HIV/AIDS on the gay male carers of gay men with the disease. This
study was phenomenological inquiry and employed van Manen’s approach to content analysis. Twelve participants for the
study were recruited. The results produced emergent themes relating to coping with HIV/AIDS, living day-to-day with
HIV/AIDS, coping with the last phase of AIDS towards death, saying goodbye and remembrance. This research highlights
the resilient coping style of carers of persons living with HIV/AIDS. The research also gives rise to recommendations for
practice and educational contexts in terms of the support and care considerations for persons living with HIV/AIDS and
their carers.
Key words: AIDS, gay men, HIV, relationships, resilience.

INTRODUCTION that this disease affected gay men who have this illness: it
There have been a small number of papers exploring the was seen as a debilitating illness, which led to an early
emotional impact of HIV/AIDS conducted either in death. The rallying of support from all sectors of the gay
America or in Britain.1–7 However, most research has and lesbian community to assist their fellow male infected
focused on families who are caring for a gay man who has members has been a unifying force. It can be argued that
returned home to be cared for until he dies. There is a no other disease affects individuals in this way.5,9–11 Some
dearth of research conducted on the relationship aspect of of the effects of this disease have been described in terms
gay men caring for gay men. This Australian research of the lack of a time frame for the disease process com-
conducted in 2002 investigated the emotional effects of bined with the relatively young age of the people affected
HIV/AIDS on the gay male carers of gay men with the by the illness.9 Because of the wasting of the body associ-
disease.8 ated with this disease, it has devastating effects on gay men
Before the introduction of triple therapies, one key who, according to Anderson and MacElveen-Hoehn,9
effect HIV/AIDS has on the gay community is the way highly value their body image. These authors further add
that AIDS and the treatment of the person living with
HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) is perceived through homophobic
Correspondence: Ian Munro, Deakin University, 221 Burwood Hwy, eyes. Added to this, the medical profession is forced
Burwood, Vic. 3125, Australia. Email: ian.munro@deakin.edu.au into complex trial and error medical management for

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd doi:10.1111/j.1440-172X.2008.00675.x
Gay men caring for others with HIV/AIDS 123

PLWHAs.9 Treatment was viewed from the perspective these components, which are central elements of nursing.
of AIDS being seen as an inevitably fatal, sexually trans- Further, Morrison claims that care will be the central
missible disease; however, since the advent of triple thera- concept that nurses will research in this new century, thus
pies for HIV, this disease is now viewed as one that can be defining for nursing the concept of care.14 Daily physical
managed. patient care is common to all aspects of nursing. Added to
With the view of HIV being seen as treatable, the need this is interpersonal care, which is one of the main areas
to protect oneself from infection seems to have become of that nurses have as their focus with patients. Watson
less focus for individuals in recent times. This is demon- maintains the nursing aim through the ‘caring process [is
strated by a rise in the recent infection rates of HIV. to] help the person attain (or maintain) health or die a
Although new treatments offer some hope to those peaceful death’.15 Similarly, Peplau believed that the role
infected, there remains the problem of treatment- of the nurse is to assist the patient to find new ways of
resistant HIV and new versions of the virus. In public coping with the world in which they live.16
health terms, it is superior to avoid becoming infected, Gaining an understanding of an individual’s illness
than treating the disease. In 2006, there were 39.5 million experience, and of their pain and suffering were two areas
people living with HIV worldwide. Of that number more Peplau viewed as the province of nurses, particularly psy-
than four million people were infected with HIV in 2006 chiatric nurses.16 Peplau bought into focus for the first
and 2.9 million people died with AIDS-related illness in time the role of psychiatric nursing: that is, the interper-
2006. In Australia, during the second quarter of 1993, 42 sonal relationships with patients.16 By utilizing the con-
people (39 male, 3 female) were reported as having newly cepts argued by Peplau, the nurse is able to develop a
acquired HIV infection, identified by a negative test nurse–patient relationship, in which Watson described
within the 12 months before diagnosis or the diagnosis of the therapeutic interpersonal process, one of her carative
HIV seroconversion illness. Six years after 1993, in the factors, to be one where ‘confidence and trust, faith and
last quarter of 1999, 43 cases were reported as having positive expectations are increased. The patient is more
newly acquired HIV infection. During the fourth quarter likely to value the nurse, [and] the interaction between the
of 2006, 96 males were reported as having newly acquired two’.15 It is important for nurses to have an understanding
HIV infection.12 A history of homosexual contact, with or of the lived experience of patients to be able to provide
without a history of injecting drug use, was reported in 86 better care to patients and their carers.
(89.6%) cases. Seventy-nine deaths following AIDS were
reported in Australia by 31 March 2007 compared with METHOD
112 deaths in 1999. These statistics while demonstrating This study was phenomenological inquiry and employed
efficacy in treatment modalities for HIV/AIDS, by a van Manen’s approach to content analysis.
reduction in AIDS-related deaths between 1999 and
2007, are alarming in terms of the rise in newly diagnosed Access to participants
HIV infection rates. Additionally, the figures have broader Twelve participants for the study were recruited from a
implications in terms of the predominant category variety of avenues, such as through gay general practitio-
affected by this illness being homosexual/bisexual males. ner practices, the Victorian AIDS Council (VAC) care
teams and major HIV/AIDS services. Sampling continued
Theoretical framework to saturation, that is, when no more themes were devel-
Nurses have a central role in assisting carers to provide oped or brought forwards by the participants, data collec-
care to their loved one. To be able to do this, nurses tion ceased.
should have an understanding of the intimate interper-
sonal care required for their patients; they also need to Ethical considerations
have an understanding of intimate interpersonal relation- Ethics approval was provided by Deakin University
ships. The concept of interpersonal care in nursing is Human Research and Ethics Committee. All transcripts
central to the way in which nurses interact with patients. were given a code and no names or health-care facilities
In the foreword to Watson’s work, Nursing: Human Science were identified. For the purpose of the thesis pseudonyms
and Human Care. A Theory of Nursing,13 Leininger argues were devised for both the informant carer and the partner
that many nursing theorists have attempted to identify or friend for whom they cared.

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
124 I Munro and K-L Edward

Data collection RESULTS


The data collection method was through two audio-taped The results produced emergent themes relating to coping
semistructured interviews for each participant. The time with HIV/AIDS, living day-to-day with HIV/AIDS,
and venue for the interview was contingent on when and coping with the last phase of AIDS towards death and
where the participant felt comfortable. The venue for the saying goodbye and remembrance.
interview was frequently dependent on whether the carer
wanted their partner to know that they were taking part in Emergent theme one: Coping with HIV
the research. Prompting questions guided the investiga- and AIDS
tion of the phenomenon of caring for someone with HIV/ Most men in this research expressed the notion that there
AIDS. The focus prompting question was—‘What is it was an element of luck involved in who acquired HIV.
like for you to care for someone with HIV/AIDS on a This created a ‘no blame’ circumstance, as the idea that ‘it
day-to-day basis?’. could have been me’, which allowed them to be compas-
sionate rather than angry about the presence of the infec-
Data analysis tion. Bennett18 identified the concept of luck in her
The process of analysis used was thematic analysis, con- research of 10 homosexual men. The issues explored
sistent with phenomenological thought. van Manen17 were ‘catching’ HIV and the stigma associated with gay
explains how analysis can be undertaken in three ways: men’s identity and HIV/AIDS. Her qualitative research
first, by reading the text as a whole to gain contextual developed a theme of ‘Lucky me’ where her carers believed
understanding; second, by a selective highlighting of pas- there were others who were in a far worse situation than
sages to identify themes from the data; third, by taking a they were. As a consequence, participants viewed their
line-by-line analysis of the transcribed interview to gain good health as being part of their luck. This also mini-
in-depth understanding of the phenomena. These three mized their own problems, placing their partner’s illness
processes were used in this research. in a larger perspective, but at times denying its impor-
Through this process of analysis, themes will develop tance for either man. From the time of becoming HIV-
from the research data. van Manen numerates four positive, a new identity was formed and with the diagnosis
descriptions which assist in the development of themes,17 came changes to relationships. One common element
namely: found among carers was their lack of blame for the partner
becoming HIV-positive. Having contracted the virus, they
1. theme is the needfulness or desire to make sense changed their sexual practices to protect the carer who
2. theme is the sense we are able to make of something was HIV-negative. Carers who were in sexual relation-
3. theme is the openness to something ships were able to carry on their loving sexual relationship
4. theme is the process of insightful invention, discovery, with their partner until he became increasingly ill with
[and] disclosure (van Manen’s emphasis). opportunistic infections. When he was ill, they tenderly
and diligently undertook complex care to nurse him back
Once the interviews were transcribed, they were read to better health.
several times to gain familiarity and comprehension of All carers in the research knew their own HIV status.
what was being said by the participants. Simultaneous While they identified themselves as gay men, they were all
listening to the taped interviews from the participants too aware of another stigmatizing variable to their gay
enabled further contextualization of the transcript- identity, that is, being seen as HIV-positive. The men in
revealing silences, laughter and so on that give access to relationships with HIV-positive partners had regular
more than just words. blood tests to be constantly informed about any change to
To assist in the refining of themes, van Manen sug- their HIV-negative status. If the carer were to become
gests that by means of writing and re-writing, a focus HIV-positive, they thought their future would be differ-
and clarification of the essences of the phenomena was ent. Some carers felt having regular tests was a reminder
developed. Additionally, a combination of reading the they were constantly at risk of acquiring HIV from the one
transcriptions and listening to the taped interviews was they loved. Some authors highlight how HIV-positive gay
undertaken to gain a whole and an insightful global view men who volunteer their time to care for others with
of the phenomenon. HIV, are witness to their own future.4,10,19,20 For example,

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
Gay men caring for others with HIV/AIDS 125

despite one carer in this study being HIV-negative, the allows individuals to temporarily escape their difficult
testing did not reassure him. This constant fear of infec- situation.25 At times participants described this sense of
tion had the effect of placing an emotional distance in his humour as ‘black’. To give an illustration of this, one
relationships. The carer discusses his repeated tests: carer in this study talked about a minister who was to
conduct a Salvation Army funeral service for his friend
. . . I went through a stage myself, where a few friends had living with HIV/AIDS. The minister’s name had a sexual
tested positive and I-tested negative and I went for another test connotation, which the carer thought was very funny. In
and tested negative and I was sort of getting a bit paranoid addition, he hoped there would be ‘. . . lots of tambou-
about the whole thing. Thinking well why are they all positive rines, as they would have been fashionable’. This carer’s
and I’m still negative? sense of humour assisted him to cope as he took part in his
friend’s funeral service.
Emergent theme two: Coping with
day-to-day living with HIV/AIDS Emergent theme three: Coping with the
All carers identified the isolation and social stigma last phase of AIDS; The decline to death
present, first from being homosexual and second, from It was essential that during this last phase carers had to
coping with a sexually transmitted terminal illness infect- educate themselves about the opportunistic infections, be
ing their partner. These factors made caring more vigilant and manage these potential symptoms. Carers
complex and difficult. Only one participant described this were excluded from using health-care services including
time as enjoyable while he cared for his dying partner. home-based carers, or seeking daily assistance from others
Some of the difficulties carers had to face included coping by the PLWHA as the PLWHA wished the carer to under-
with their partner’s denial of the illness, managing the take all of their care possibly as a means of limiting their
various treatment appointments and keeping up with dif- felt shame and stigma. This created a two-edged sword,
fering medical regimes. Several authors suggest that what one of isolation for both the carer and the PLWHA;
makes HIV/AIDS more complex is the relative youthful- however, most used the positive strategies they adopted in
ness of those who are ill and the fact they are male, their caring role—such as focusing on maximizing their
given that males are poor attendees of health-care remaining time together and ensuring quality. This was a
services.10,21–23 testing time and their relationship actively changed from
Five carers from the research had to cope with AIDS- that of mutual love, to that of care and dependency.
related dementia. Sadock and Sadock believed that AIDS Carers went through a grief process, in these cases, an
infects the spinal cord and brain of 67% of patients; as a anticipatory grief before the actual death of the PLWHA.
consequence, there is a high level of AIDS-related demen- Despite their diligent caring, the ultimate outcome was
tia. Dementia is very difficult for any carer to cope with, not that their partner would become well, but further
as there is a loss of personality of the individual and a deteriorate to his eventual death. There were a number of
decline in the personal habits of the dementing person.24 challenges to these carers and their intimate relationships;
The carer has to be vigilant all the time. One carer found however, they employed a number of strategies to maxi-
this with his friend when he ‘. . . nearly burnt the place mize the quality of life, making the transition from a
down. He burnt a towel over the heater. Little things, he sexual relationship to one where caring became the focus.
just forgot. He doesn’t drive; he hasn’t driven for years. There is an interesting parallel between nurses and these
He gets me to drive, which is fair enough. He doesn’t like gay men carers. Lawler argues that the relationship
to go too far from the place, as far as that goes’.8 So not between the nurse and the patient is crucial in the illness
only did carers need to watch for opportunistic infections, experience.26 She makes the point that nurse–patient rela-
but they had to observe all activities to ensure the tionships have clear boundaries about when they begin,
PLWHA and others were safe. how they will progress and to when they will end. Within
One of the many ways in which these carers coped was this relationship, the degree to which the patient is going
to use their sense of humour to help them cope with the to be reliant on the nurse is assessed and altered in terms
difficult situations in which they found themselves. The of their dependency needs. This relationship is con-
carer’s use of humour helped them manage and cope with structed in what Lawler describes as an environment of
life’s difficulties. Taylor suggests that the use of humour permission. This social construct, Lawler argues, gives

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
126 I Munro and K-L Edward

control to the patient, so they can feel anxious, vulnerable was often a difficult time not only for the carers, but also
and uncomfortable in unfamiliar surrounds. This relation- for family and friends. Making this event harder to bear is
ship Lawler discussed is clearly different from the rela- the relative youth of these men, combined with the stig-
tionship carers have with their partners. The men in this matization of HIV/AIDS and homosexuality. Past litera-
research formed close intimate relationships with the men ture indicated there had been a lack of involvement, or
they cared for, and the ‘nursing’ they undertook was exclusion of either the partner or friends from these
through a sense of connected love and compassion. This important farewell ceremonies.3,30,31 The carers from this
was a painful growth process for the carers and was under- research were able to either have the PLWHA final wishes
taken in relative isolation of supports because of the enacted, or be a voice at his funeral.
stigma attached to HIV/AIDS and the difference in
legal perceptions of a male–male defacto relationship as
compared with a male–female defacto relationship in Being resilient: Carers’ strategies to cope
Australia. In ‘normalizing’ the death, carers hoped this would assist
them coping with this premature death. By minimizing
their own concerns, carers hoped these would not add any
Emergent theme four: Saying goodbye, further stress to his last remaining days. To be able to be
but wanting to keep the memory alive with him, carers continued working without breaks,
Carers had opportunities through various public memori- because if they stopped and thought, this only brought the
als to remember those lost to this virus. On these occa- enormity and sadness of the situation they were into the
sions, those currently infected review their own health surface. Those with religious convictions called upon
status and lamented the loss of good health. These memo- these to assist them through this difficult time. Upon his
rials also provide the opportunity for health promotion death memorial events became important to help keep
message of safe sex. Carers had various methods of the memory alive. To assist this, carers kept possessions
remembering their loved ones. For some, speaking at which reminded them of the PLWHA.
their funeral was important. Others wanted to create a The early works of Werner and Smith32,33 and
regular memorial time, when friends could get together Garmezy34,35 explored resilience, suggesting that caring
and remember. The International Day of Recognition for environments, using humour, faith, reframing negative
AIDS was significant for some. Although not everyone in experiences and feeling hope were self-righting capaci-
the research had lost their partner, all the men had known ties. Bachay and Cingel suggested three constitutional
others lost to this disease. factors that enhance resilience: self-efficacy, well-defined
One carer had to cope with his own and his partner’s faith lives and the ability to reframe obstacles.36 The
feelings about death and dying; the partner was concerned authors put forwards that in conjunction with these
about what would be put on the death certificate. He did emotional and cognitive factors, support networks and
not want to be identified as someone who died from relational/psychosocial factors also play a role in enhanc-
AIDS. The PLWHA was concerned about the stigma asso- ing the experience of resilience for individuals. Involve-
ciated with AIDS, which was identified by Kubler-Ross in ment such as talking with, crying, laughing and relating
past research of AIDS clients.27 The carer was surprised at individually to the PLWHA are all forms of caring, all
his partners’ fear about becoming another statistic to this restorative and are qualities found in resilient individu-
virus. als, and yet difficult to quantify in terms of costs and
There are many ways to remember a lost loved one. benefits. The presence of at least one caring person, such
The most common ceremony is the funeral, saying good- as someone who conveys an attitude of compassion, pro-
bye to the physical body of the deceased, which assists vides support for a sense of well-being, and fosters resil-
those living in coming to terms with their loss. This cer- ience and coping strategies can ultimately move towards
emony is usually mixed with memories of the individual adaptation for both the PLWHA and their carer.37,38 The
when they were alive, so those present could share their experience of resilience did not result from avoidance of
collective memories with others. Funerals are part of peo- risk; rather, it stemmed from exposure to risk and the
ple’s social rites which allow the living to finalize their consequent successful negotiation through successful
relationship with the deceased.27–30 The funeral ceremony problem-solving skills.39,40

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
Gay men caring for others with HIV/AIDS 127

IMPLICATIONS AND 2 Brown MA, Powell-Cope GM. Themes of loss and dying in
RECOMMENDATIONS caring for a family member with AIDS. Research in Nursing
and Health 1993; 16: 179–191.
This research gives rise to four key recommendations for
3 Faugier J. Revealing hidden fears. Nursing Times 1990; 86:
practice and educational contexts. The first recommenda- 66–68.
tion is the development of home care education for carers 4 Folkman S, Chesney MA, Christopher-Richards A. Stress
of the PLWHAs which enables carers who are caring for a and coping in caregiving partners of men with AIDS. Psy-
loved one at home to develop skills and knowledge to chiatric Manifestations of HIV Disease 1994; 17: 35–53.
assist them to provide safe caring on a day-to-day basis. 5 Gregory D, Longman A. Mothers’ suffering: Sons who died
Part of this education should provide an opportunity for of AIDS. Qualitative Health Research 1992; 2: 334–357.
the development of carer networks and assist in the 6 Land H, Harangody G. A support group for partners of
persons with AIDS. Families in Society: The Journal of Contem-
liaison between home care, health services and the ‘new’
porary Human Services 1990; 71: 471–481.
carer. 7 McCann K, Wadsorth E. The role of informal carers in
The second recommendation involves support to supporting gay men who have HIV related illness: What do
carers to facilitate the development of a medical home they do and what are their needs? AIDS Care 1992; 4: 25–34.
history for the PLWHA. A medical home history can assist 8 Munro I. The lived experience of gay men caring for others
the carer in discussing various drugs that have been pre- with HIV/AIDS: Living, loving and dying in the era of
viously tried, or when various tests had been undertaken. HIV/AIDS (PhD thesis). Melbourne, Australia: Deakin
It can also assist in negotiating various and differing University, 2002.
9 Anderson H, MacElveen-Hoehn P. Gay patients with AIDS:
medical services to maintain a continuum for the
New challenges for hospice programs. The Hospice Journal
PLWHA. The strategy of keeping home health histories 1988; 4: 37–54.
needs to be supported in a standardized way to ensure 10 Barbour RS. The impact of working with people with HIV/
transferability of information between home and health- AIDS: A review of the literature. Social Science Medicine
care services who work with people with HIV/AIDS. 1994; 38: 221–232.
This research also highlighted a need for creating psy- 11 Martin JL, Dean L. Effects of AIDS-related bereavement
chiatric nurse consultant positions at health services that and HIV-related illness on psychological distress among gay
care for PLWHA, so that HIV-positive individuals, part- men: A seven-year longitudinal study, 1985–1991. Journal
of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1993; 61: 94–103.
ners, carers and family members could have access to
12 National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical
timely mental health expertise in terms of dealing with Research. Australian HIV Surveillance Report. 2007.
grief, managing the negative impact of stigma and result- Available from URL: http://www.nchecr.unsw.edu.au/
ant isolation, developing interventions related to AIDS- NCHECRweb.nsf/page/Quarterly%20Surveillance%20
related dementia and other mental, neurological and Reports. Accessed 13 August 2007.
behavioural disorders. These psychiatric services could be 13 Watson J. Nursing: Human Science and Human Care. A Theory
delivered in a flexible manner, either within the hospital of Nursing. New York: National League for Nursing, 1988.
or in the home setting. 14 Morrison P. Professional Caring in Practice: A Psychological
Analysis. England: Avebury, 1992.
And finally, that a social well-being strategy be devel-
15 Watson J. Nursing the Philosophy and Science of Caring.
oped by government health bodies to separate the Boulder, CO, USA: Colorado University Press, 1979.
enmeshment of homosexuality from HIV/AIDS in the 16 Peplau H. Interpersonal Relations in Nursing: A Conceptual
mind of the general public as a process of de-stigmatizing Frame of Reference for Psychodynamic Nursing. New York:
homosexuality. This social well-being strategy could also Putnam, 1988.
endeavour to foster an acceptance of gay men and their 17 van Manen M. Researching Lived Experience: Human Science
relationships and reduce the stigma associated with homo- for an Action Sensitive Pedagogy. London, Canada: Althouse
sexuality and HIV/AIDS. Press, 1990.
18 Bennett MJ. Stigmatisation: Experiences of persons with
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. Issues in Mental
REFERENCES Health Nursing 1990; 11: 141–154.
1 Brown MA, Powell-Cope GM. AIDS family caregiving: 19 Irving G, Bor R, Catalan J. Psychological distress among gay
Transition through uncertainty. Nursing Research 1991; 40: men supporting a lover or partner with AIDS: A pilot study.
338–345. AIDS Care 1995; 7: 605–618.

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd
128 I Munro and K-L Edward

20 Wilson J. AIDS: Do nurses understand their gay patients? 31 Biller R, Rice S. Experiencing multiple loss of persons with
In: Pratt GA (ed.). Issues in Australia Nursing, 3rd edn. Mel- AIDS: Grief and bereavement issues. Health Social Work
bourne, Australia: Churchill Livingstone, 1992; 171–180. 1990; 15: 283–290.
21 Bennett L, Kelaher M, Ross M. Quality of life in health care 32 Werner E, Smith R. Vulnerable but Invincible. New York:
professionals: Burnout and its associated factors in HIV/ Adams, Bannister & Cox, 1982.
AIDS-related care. Psychology and Health 1994; 9: 273–283. 33 Werner E. Risk, resilience, and recovery: Perspectives
22 Govoni LA. Psychosocial issues of AIDS in the nursing care from the Kauai longitudinal study. Development and Psycho-
of homosexual men and their significant others. Nursing pathology 1993; 5: 503–515.
Clinics of North America 1988; 23: 749–765. 34 Garmezy N. Children in poverty: Resilience despite risk.
23 Murphy P, Perry K. Hidden grievers. Death Studies 1988; Psychiatry 1993; 56: 127–136.
12: 451–462. 35 Garmezy N. Resiliency and vulnerability to adverse devel-
24 Sadock BJ, Sadock VA. Kaplan & Sadock’s Synopsis of opmental outcomes associated with poverty. American
Psychiatry, 9th edn. Philadelphia, USA: Lippincott Williams Behavioral Scientist 1991; 34: 416–430.
& Wilkins, 2003. 36 Bachay J, Cingel P. Restructuring resilience: Emerging
25 Taylor BJ. Relieving pain through ordinariness in nursing: A voices. Affilia 1999; 14: 162–175.
phenomenological account of a comforting nurse–patient 37 Edward K, Warelow P. Resilience: When coping is emo-
encounter. Advances in Nursing Science 1992; 15: 33–43. tionally intelligent. Journal of the American Psychiatrics Nurses
26 Lawler J. Behind the Screens: Nursing, Somology, and the Association 2005; 11: 101–102.
Problem of the Body. Melbourne, Australia: Churchill 38 Warelow P, Edward K. Caring as a resilient practice in
Livingstone, 1991. mental health nursing. International Journal of Psychiatric and
27 Kubler-Ross E. AIDS: The Ultimate Challenge. New York: Mental Health Nursing 2007; 16: 132–135.
Macmillian Publishing Co., 1987. 39 Edward K. The phenomenon of resilience in crisis care
28 Kellehear A. Dying of Cancer: The Final Year of Life. New mental health clinicians. International Journal of Mental Health
York: Harwood Academic, 1990. Nursing 2005; 14: 142–148.
29 Kubler-Ross E. On Death and Dying. New York: Macmillian 40 Edward K. The phenomenon of resilience as described
Publishing Co., 1969. by people who have experienced mental illness (PhD
30 Okoneski D. Gay grief: Issues of love, loss and loneliness. thesis). Melbourne, Bundoora, Australia: RMIT University,
Occupational Therapy in Health Care 1990; 7: 213–226. 2007.

© 2008 The Authors


Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd

Potrebbero piacerti anche