Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract
This research article deals with a modified version of leaf spring suspension system
introduced for the optimization of existing leaf spring suspension system design, by the
combination of two helical springs with the master leaf. To furnish this end, a semi-elliptical
type mono leaf spring of light weighted mini truck is considered for design and modeling
work. On both the sides of this mono leaf, a helical spring is designed and modeled at equal
distances from the center of leaf. All the modeling and analysis work is performed in CATIA-
V5R20. Stress analysis results at various loading conditions are obtained by both theoretical
and FEA methods, separately for typical mono leaf spring model and proposed model with
helical springs. Results show an average 8.3% stress reduction for any of the loading
conditions, by the utilization of helical springs with the combination of master leaf. The
proposed work have some certain benefits which could definitely transform the existing leaf
spring design into a more optimized, stable and flexible one for the overall better
performance and comfort to passengers.
JoAEA (2017) 6-17 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 6
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
specially the papers on helical springs; fatigue performance of the suspension helical
because the overall better performance of the springs. Tsubasa Tsubouchi et al. [17] their
existing model will mainly depend upon the research work presented a new and cheap
design of employed helical springs. Jiang and forming technique of helical springs with
Henshall [7] presented a general and correct rectangle cross section and high rectangular
finite element model (FEM) for helical springs ratio. In the research work done by Basaran
subjected to axial loads. Vebil Yildirim and Ozmen et al. [18], a newly developed testing
ErolSancaktar [8] presented a detailed analysis and simulation methodology for the durability
of free vibration frequencies of a composite of leaf springs was presented so as to direct
helical spring. designers in the product development phase.
Del Llano-Vizcaya et al. [9] in their research, Ladislav Kosec et al. [19] provided a useful
they provided very useful relationships failure analysis of a motor car helical spring.
between stress relief effects and fatigue life of Sushanta Ghuku and Kashi Nath Saha [20] in
helical compression springs. It was proved that their work, large deflection behavior of an
smaller the residual stresses greater the fatigue initially curved cantilever beam (master leaf of
life of spring. The results of their work are a leaf spring) subjected to varied loading
very useful in design and manufacturing of conditions had been studied both theoretically
helical spring. and by experimentation using MATLAB
computational simulation.
Fuentes et al. [10] in their work, they
presented the basic reason of premature DESIGN AND MODELING
fracture in leaf springs employed in Following sections describe the designing and
Venezuelan buses. Aimin Yu and Changjin modeling procedures carried out for typical
Yang [11] performed free vibration analysis of (conventional) and proposed mono leaf spring
cylindrical helical springs by means of an models:
analytical study. Kaiser et al. [12] presented Modeling of Typical Mono Leaf Spring:
VHCF-behavior (very high cycle fatigue) of A typical single leaf spring is designed and
helical compression springs made of different modeled in CATIA-V5R20. The designed and
materials. The objective of Shishay Amare modeled mono leaf in fact is a master leaf of
Gebremeskel [13] in his contribution was any semi-elliptical leaf spring suspension
associated with designing, simulating and system, employed in light vehicle mini trucks
prototyping of a single leaf spring for light and buses. Modeling in CATIA-V5R20 is
weight 3-Wheeler vehicles from composite done considering the dimensions and
material. properties as mentioned in Table 1 and
selecting isotropic structural steel as design
Jamil M. Renno and Brian R. Mace [14] in material [4]. Figure 1 is showing the design of
their research, modeling and vibration analysis this mono leaf spring model.
of helical springs with non-uniform ends were
taken into consideration. The approach Table 1: Dimensions and Physical Properties
bestowed in their paper provides many of Mono Leaf Spring Model.
benefits in designing and modeling of helical S. Description Specification
springs. N.
1. No. of leaf (N) 01
Research work done by Dipendra Kumar Roy 2. Width of leaf (b) 60 mm
and Kashi Nath Saha [15] corresponds to non- 3. Thickness of leaf(t) 16 mm
linear analysis of leaf springs made of various 4. Eye-to-eye length of leaf 1025 mm
types functionally graded materials (FGM). (L)
Youli Zhu et al. [16], their work dealt with 5. Camber 90.8 mm
case study of failure analysis of a helical 6. Poisson’s ratio (μ) 0.266
compression spring for a heavy vehicle’s
7. Density of material(ρ) 7860 kg/m3
suspension system and the recommendations
were conjointly made for improving the 8. Coefficient of thermal 1.17×10-5 K-1Deg.
expansion
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 7
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 8
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 9
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 10
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 11
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
14000
12000
10000
Load (Newton)
10000
8000 7000
6000 5000
4000
3500
4000 3000
2500
2000
1500 1490
2000 1000
99.28 148.92 199 248.2 298 347.5 397.1 496.4 695
0 993
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Stresses (MPa)
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 12
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 13
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
14000
12000
10000
10000
Load (Newton)
8000 7000
6000 5000
4000
3500
4000 3000
2500
2000
1500 1375.9
2000 1000 642 917
183.4 275.18 367 459
0
91.72 137.6 229.32 321
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Stresses (MPa)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS and helical springs model are significantly less
The outcomes of the whole study and than the theoretical bending stresses (by
accomplished work are described under the mathematical calculations)and FEA Von-Mises
following sub sections. stresses by CATIA-V5R20, induced in typical
mono leaf spring model of same dimensions and
Results parameters. Therefore, the design of introduced
All the stress analysis results are tabulated in combined leaf and helical spring’s model can be
the form of Table 4, and their correlations are said safe and considerable. The average %
shown in Figures 13 and 14. From the reduction in overall maximum stresses at
mentioned Table, Figures and stress analysis different loading conditions is achieved by 8.3%,
colored images, it is clear that the maximum by the utilization of proposed combined model
stresses produced in proposed combined leaf in comparison to typical mono leaf spring model
(Table 5).
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 14
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
14000
12000
10000
Load (Newton)
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Stresses (MPa)
14000
12000
10000
Load (Newton)
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Stresses (MPa)
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 15
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
Benefits and Scope of the Proposed Model trucks and buses. Proposed model and work in
Following points describe the advantages of this study can lead researchers in the field of
the proposed model:- conventional leaf spring system to work on
I. By incorporating such suspension springs more optimized typical leaf spring suspension
model overall stresses can be reduced system design. Therefore, further more
significantly. scientific researches and work can be done in
II. By applying properly designed helical order to make proposed model more beneficial
springs, deflection characteristics of leaf and efficient.
spring suspension can be controlled and
maintained, so as to achieve optimized CONCLUSIONS
comfort during the vehicle ride [22]. The improved efficiency and optimized
III. Number of graduated leafs in existing performance of the presented combined leaf
conventional leaf spring system could be and helical spring’s suspension system model
reduced by employing proposed model. will majorly depend upon the best
So, a new compact design of existing leaf combination of design parameters of helical
spring system could be possible. springs (i.e. wire diameter, pitch, number of
IV. A good balance between stiffness and coils) in proportion to leaf spring’s design.
rigidity of the typical leaf spring Therefore by maintaining the best combination
suspension could be maintained, so energy of these suspension spring’s design
storage capacity can be increased by using parameters, we can take advantages of benefits
such model to optimize the overall of each type suspension spring. And, this is to
performance of the suspension. achieve a more optimized, flexible, stable and
V. It seems, no necessity of heavy changes in efficient typical leaf spring suspension system
any accessory part or design of existing by incorporating the proposed designed model.
leaf spring suspension to incorporate
proposed model. NOMENCLATURE
σ max Maximum bending stress
SCOPE L Eye-to-eye length of leaf spring
From the above mentioned expected and b Width of leaf spring
possible benefits by utilization of such model, t Thickness of leaf spring
it can be surely stated that, the proposed p A constant for simply supported beam
combined leaf and helical spring suspension p Pitch of helical spring
could have a great scope in future work related W Applied load
to suspension system design for light weighted N Number of leafs
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 16
Journal of Automobile Engineering and Applications
Volume 4, Issue 3
ISSN: 2455-3360 (Online)
FEA Finite element analysis 10. Fuentes JJ, Aguilar HJ, Rodriguez JA, et
μ Poisson’s ratio al. Premature Fracture in Automobile Leaf
ρ Density of material Springs. Eng Fail Anal. 2009; 16: 648–55p.
E Young’s modulus 11. Aimin Yu, Changjin Yang. Formulation
h Height of helical spring and Evaluation of an Analytical Study for
d Wire diameter of helical spring cylindrical Helical Springs. Acta Mech Sol-
D Inner coil diameter of helical spring ida Sinica. 2010; 23(1): 85–94p.
n Number of coils in helical spring 12. Kaiser B, Pyttel B, Berger C. VHCF-Be-
havior of Helical Compression Springs
REFERENCES Made of Different Materials. Int J Fatigue.
1. Mahmood MS, Rezaei D. Analysis and Op- 2011; 33: 23–32p.
timization of a Composite Leaf Spring. 13. Gebremeskel SA. Design, Simulation and
Compos Struct. 2003; 60: 317–25p. Prototyping of Single Composite Leaf
2. Fakhreddine D, Mohamed T, Said A et al. Spring for Light Weight Vehicle. Global
Finite Element Method for the Stress Anal- Journal of Researches in Engineering
ysis of Isotropic Cylindrical Helical Spring. (GJRE). Mech Mech Eng. 2012; 12(7): 21–
Eur J Mech A Solids. 2005; 24: 1068–78p. 30p.
3. Mohd. Izaham Zainal Abidin, Jamaluddin 14. Jamil RM, Brian MR. Vibration Modeling
Mahmud, Mohd Juzaila Abd Latif, et al. of Helical Springs with Non-Uniform Ends.
Experimental and Numerical Investigation J Sound Vibration. 2012; 331: 2809–23p.
of SUP12 Steel Coil Spring. The 15. Roy DK, Saha KN. Nonlinear Analysis of
Malaysian International Tribology Confer- Leaf Springs of Functionally Graded Mate-
ence (MITC2013). Procedia Eng. 2013; 68: rials. Chemical, Civil and Mechanical En-
251–57p. gineering Tracks of 3rd Nirma University
4. Sorathiya M, Dhaval SB, Vipul BM. Vari- International Conference (NUICONE
ous Numerical Analysis of Composite Leaf 2012). Procedia Eng. 2013; 51: 538–43p.
Spring for Light Vehicle Mini Truck. Se- 16. Zhu Y, Wang Y, Huang Y. Failure Analy-
lected Papers of Mechanical, Civil and sis of a Helical Compression Spring for a
Chemical Engineering Tracks of the 4th Heavy Vehicle’s Suspension System. Case
Nirma University International Conference Studies in Engineering Failure Analysis.
on Engineering (NUICONE 2013). Proce- 2014; 2:169–73p.
dia Eng. 2014. 17. Tsubouchi T, Takahashi K, Kuboki T. De-
5. Senthil Kumar M, Vijayarangan S. Analyti- velopment of Coiled Springs with High
cal and Experimental Studies on Fatigue Rectangular Ratio in Cross-Section. 11th
Life Prediction of Steel and Composite International Conference on Technology of
Multi-Leaf Spring for Light Passenger Ve- Plasticity, ICTP2014, 19–24 Oct 2014,
hicles Using Life Data Analysis. Mater Sci. Nagoya, Japan. Procedia Eng. 2014; 81:
2007; 13(2): 141–46p. 574–79p.
6. Prawoto Y, Ikeda M, Manville SK, et al. 18. Ozmen B, Altiok B, Guzel A et al. A Novel
Design and Failure Modes of Automotive Methodology with Testing and Simulation
Suspension Springs. Eng Fail Anal. 2008; for the Durability of Leaf Springs Based on
15: 1155–74p. Measured Load Collectives. 3rd
7. Jiang WG, Henshall JL. A Novel Finite El- International Conference on Material and
ement Model for Helical Springs. Finite Component Performance under Variable
Elem Anal Des. 2000; 35:363–77p. Amplitude Loading, VAL2015. Procedia
8. Yildirim V, Sancaktar E. Linear Free Vi- Eng. 2015;101: 363–71p.
bration Analysis of Cross-Ply Laminated 19. Kosec L, Nagode A, Kosec G et al. Failure
Cylindrical Helical Spring. Int J Mech Sci. Analysis of a Motor-Car Coil Spring. Case
2000; 42: 1153–69p. Studies in Engineering Failure Analysis.
9. Del Llano-Vizcaya L, Rubio-Gonzalez C, 2015; 4:100–5p.
Mesmacque G, et al. Stress Relief Effect on 20. Ghuku S, Saha KN. A Theoretical and Ex-
Fatigue and Relaxation of Compression perimental Study on Geometric Nonlinear-
Springs. Mater Des. 2007; 28: 1130–34p. ity of Initially Curved Cantilever Beams.
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 17
Stress Analysis of Leaf Spring Suspension System Gayakwad et
al.
JoAEA (2017) 6-18 © STM Journals 2017. All Rights Reserved Page 18