Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Against For:
GRAVE MISCONDUCT
PSSG. MECHAEL T. ABDON
Provincial Drug Enforcement Unit,
Police Provincial Office 10
Oroquieta City, Misamis Occidental,
Respondent/s.
x--------------------------------------------/
POSITION PAPER
2. Hence, respondent has until October 25, 2019 within which to file the
same;
3. Having filed this Position Paper today, October 25, 2019, through
registered mail, this Position Paper is deemed filed on time;
4. On, November 24, 2018, at almost midnight (12 o’clock in the morning)
respondent arrived in his residence situated at Purok Villanueva, Barangay
Dipolo, Molave, Zamboanga del Sur, from a drinking spree with some of his
friends,
6. Respondent and his wife were too resounding that time that their fight
was effortlessly audible to their neighbours or to any person living nearby;
ISSUE
DISCUSSION(S)/ARGUMENT(S)
Respondent vehemently denies the false allegations against him for being
untrue, false, twisted and malicious. The truth being that, respondent arrived
during the wee hours of the evening – almost midnight – from a drinking spree
Page 3 of 6
SDP Case No. R9-2019-0043
Summary Dismissal Proceedings
Against PSSG MECHAEL T. ABDON
with his friends on November 24, 2019 which enraged his wife and as a result,
a verbal altercation ensued between them which were too resounding and
audible to their neighbours and to the persons living nearby – the complainant
included.
(a) Santos F. Rebutazo, who testified that around 1:00 dawn (1:00 AM) of
November 25, 2018, he was in the living area of his bedroom, browsing
in the internet using his cellular phone; that, he was surprised brought by
the loud noises from a neighbouring distance; that, he was certain that
such sound was that from Mechael T. Abdon who was at that time
quarrelling with his wife; that, he is certain that the administrative case
filed by complainant against the respondent was not true since his act
was purely a normal husband-and-wife-kind of issue2;
(b) Lovely Joy C. Bohos who attested that around 1 o’clock dawn (1:00 AM)
of November 25, 2018, she woke up to prepare milk for her baby when
she was also surprised to hear loud noises from a neighbouring distance;
that, the voices she heard were that of Mechael T. Abdon and his wife,
Cristina B. Abdon; that, she was also certain that the allegations of the
complainant in her complaint-affidavit in the case of Grave Misconduct
were not true;3
(c) Naome C. Galves, who attested that around 1 o’clock dawn (1:00 AM)
of November 25, 2018, she was fully asleep but awakened by a noise
which she heard not so far from her; that, she was frightened that time as
to what was it all about which led her to her living room to hear at least
clear enough what the sound was all about; that, she found out that it
came from the respondent, Mechael T. Abdon, and that of his wife,
Cristina Abdon, which were quarrelling that very moment; that, she was
certain that the complaint filed by the complainant against the
respondent is not true.4
(d) Cristina Abdon, who that on November 25, 2018, around 12:00
midnight (12:00AM), she and the respondent, who went home late that
time, had a big quarrel; that, she was so angry to keep on reminding him
to get rid of making a lot of friends who caused him to go home late;
hence, she was certain that the accusations of the complainant in the
Grave Misconduct case are pure lies;5 and
(e) Annallee C. Galvez, who attested that around 1:30AM of November 25,
2018, she was asleep together with her family in their bedroom when she
was awakened by a noise brought by a knocking of door the moment the
mother of the respondent herein was advised to meddle the issue that
the respondent had with his wife; that, she was convinced that their
marital issues which fuelled their anger during that time, was way too far
from the allegations raised by the complainant against the respondent
herein;6 and
(f) the mother of the respondent, Manuela T. Abdon, who attested that
around 1:30 AM of November 25, 2018, she was at her residence when
Cesar Dayna, who was living together with the respondent, went to her
and reported that the spouses Mechael Abdon and Cristina Abdon were
quarrelling so much that he alone could not stop; that, she hurriedly went
to respondent’s house to pacify him who was with so much anger that
time; that, she decided to get his son to let him get through at her
residence; that, that the respondent, at that moment, agreed and went
together with her; hence, she can attest that the allegations of the
complainant are not true.7
II. Assuming, for the sake of argument, but not admitting, that the
allegations of the complainant as well as her witnesses took place,
still, respondent maintains that he is not guilty of GRAVE
MISCONDUCT
The Supreme Court in the case of Narvasa vs. Sanchez8 defined misconduct
as “an intentional wrongdoing or deliberate violation of a rule of law or
standard of behaviour. To constitute an administrative offense, misconduct should relate to
or be connected with the performance of the official functions and duties of a public officer. In
grave misconduct, as distinguished from simple misconduct, the elements of corruption, clear
intent to violate the law, or flagrant disregard of an established rule must be manifest.”
(emphasis supplied)
Even assuming, for the sake of argument, but without admitting, that the
allegations of wrongful conduct against the respondent by the complainant
took place, Respondent maintains that he is not guilty of grave misconduct.
In this case, respondent has not committed corruption, nor there was clear
intent on his part to violate the law. He also did not defy nor disregard any law
or rule that a government employee, a police officer at that, observed.
8 G.R. No. 169449. March 26, 2010. 616 SCRA 586, 589.
9 Office of the Ombudsman v. Asis, G.R. No. 237503 (Notice), [June 20, 2018]
Page 6 of 6
SDP Case No. R9-2019-0043
Summary Dismissal Proceedings
Against PSSG MECHAEL T. ABDON
Other reliefs, just and equitable under any of the circumstance, are likewise
prayed for.
August 20, 2018, Ozamiz City, Misamis Occidental [for Pagadian City],
Philippines.
Prescilla N. Singayen
Purok Villanueva, Brgy. Dipolo,
Molave, Zamboanga del Sur