Sei sulla pagina 1di 12

Spatial Gradient Analyses of Nutrients and Chlorophyll a Biomass in an

Urbanized Lagoonal Estuary: A Comparison between Wet and Dry Periods

Authors: D. L. White, D. E. Porter, A. J. Lewitus, and J. Keesee


Source: Journal of Coastal Research, 2008(243) : 649-659
Published By: Coastal Education and Research Foundation
URL: https://doi.org/10.2112/05-0498.1

BioOne Complete (complete.BioOne.org) is a full-text database of 200 subscribed and open-access titles in the
biological, ecological, and environmental sciences published by nonprofit societies, associations, museums, institutions,
and presses.

Your use of this PDF, the BioOne Complete website, and all posted and associated content indicates your acceptance of
BioOne’s Terms of Use, available at www.bioone.org/terms-o-use.

Usage of BioOne Complete content is strictly limited to personal, educational, and non - commercial use. Commercial
inquiries or rights and permissions requests should be directed to the individual publisher as copyright holder.

BioOne sees sustainable scholarly publishing as an inherently collaborative enterprise connecting authors, nonprofit publishers, academic institutions,
research libraries, and research funders in the common goal of maximizing access to critical research.

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Journal of Coastal Research 24 3 649–659 West Palm Beach, Florida May 2008

Spatial Gradient Analyses of Nutrients and Chlorophyll a


Biomass in an Urbanized Lagoonal Estuary: A Comparison
between Wet and Dry Periods
D.L. White†, D.E. Porter‡§*, A.J. Lewitus‡††, and J. Keesee‡

National Oceanographic and



Belle W. Baruch Institute for

Department of
§
National Oceanographic and
††

Atmospheric Administration Marine and Coastal Environmental Health Atmospheric Administration


Hollings Marine Laboratory Sciences Sciences Center for Sponsored Coastal
Charleston, SC 29412, U.S.A. University of South Carolina Arnold School of Public Ocean Research
whitedl@clemson.edu Columbia, SC 29208, U.S.A. Health 1305 East West Highway,
University of South Carolina Room 8220
Columbia, SC 29208, U.S.A. Silver Spring, MD 20910,
U.S.A.

ABSTRACT
WHITE, D.L.; PORTER, D.E.; LEWITUS, A.J., and KEESEE, J., 2008. Spatial gradient analyses of nutrients and
chlorophyll a biomass in an urbanized lagoonal estuary: a comparison between wet and dry periods. Journal of Coastal
Research, 24(3), 649–659. West Palm Beach (Florida), ISSN 0749-0208.

The effects of stochastic events on estuarine water quality parameters are often difficult to quantify spatially due to
the inherent variability in these systems. The use of geographic information systems to identify spatial patterns and
trends can improve such efforts. This work describes the use of geographic information systems and the Mantel Test
to determine the existence of trends and the persistence of spatial patterns in the relationships between nutrients
and chlorophyll a in an urbanized lagoonal estuarine system, Murrells Inlet, South Carolina. Relatively dry and wet
periods were compared, the latter following several substantial precipitation events related to tropical hurricane
activity in the summer of 1999. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentrations were elevated following the passage of
Hurricane Irene, and chlorophyll a did not increase concomitantly. Orthophosphate was found to have persistently
higher concentrations in the more urbanized regions of Murrells Inlet that were consistent spatially during the two
sampling periods. Strong spatial and temporal correlations between chlorophyll a and dissolved silicate : dissolved
inorganic nitrogen suggest a relationship between the latter ratio and the phytoplankton growth. However, there
appeared to be only a tenuous relationship between chlorophyll a and dissolved inorganic nitrogen and phosphorus,
both spatially and temporally, suggesting that nutrient requirements for phytoplankton growth were met by internal
estuarine processes, during this time period.

ADDITIONAL INDEX WORDS: Chlorophyll, geographic information systems (GISs), nutrients, hurricane, water qual-
ity, spatial analysis.

INTRODUCTION The effects of urbanization on estuarine eutrophication are


complex and difficult to assess. However, the detection and
The identification and analysis of spatial clusters and analysis of spatial patterns may provide insight into the re-
trends in natural systems can provide insight into ecological lationships between urbanization-associated landscape
phenomena because such patterns may be structured by com- changes and estuarine temporal and spatial variability. To
mon environmental processes (LENGENDRE and LENGENDRE, better understand the dynamics of spatial gradients in es-
1998). The presence of a spatial gradient may reflect the ef- tuaries and how they might be affected by stochastic events,
fects of broad-scale physical processes or ‘‘forcing functions’’ a high-salinity estuarine system (Murrells Inlet, South Car-
that create gradients in the physical environment (LENGEN- olina) was sampled during a relatively dry period in the sum-
DRE and TROUSSELLIER, 1988). Identification of common spa- mer of 1999 and again in the fall of 1999 following the nearby
tial patterns or correlations among environmental variables passage of three hurricanes: Hurricane Dennis (24 August–5
may indicate a common spatial gradient. In some situations, September), Hurricane Floyd (14–17 September), and Hur-
these gradients may be indicated by a trend such as a de- ricane Irene (13–16 October). Significant portions of North
creasing range of values in a geographic direction or other Carolina and the northeastern coastal counties of South Car-
spatial patterns that show some consistency over time and olina (SC) were particularly impacted by significant flooding
may indicate larger ecological phenomena. events during this latter time period (BALES, 2003; BURK-
HOLDER et al., 2004; MALLIN et al., 2002; PEIERLS, CHRIS-
TIAN, and PAERL, 2003; RAMUS et al., 2003).
DOI:10.2112/05-0498.1 received 27 April 2005; accepted in revision
17 November 2006. Murrells Inlet (MI) is a high-salinity lagoonal estuary rep-
* Present address: Clemson University, ITC, 340 Computer Court, resentative of similar coastal areas that are increasingly in-
Anderson, SC 29625, U.S.A. fluenced by anthropogenic development. In SC, small high-

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
650 White et al.

salinity creeks and inlets exceed the total combined area of


larger river-dominated systems (VERNBERG et al., 1992).
Shallow lagoonal-type environments that lack significant
freshwater inputs generally have lower nutrient levels than
riverine-dominated estuaries (NIXON, 1982). Phytoplankton
and nutrient concentrations on a systemwide scale have been
assumed homogeneous in these estuaries, based on the char-
acteristically high mixing and flushing properties. However,
empirical data sets to support this supposition are lacking,
because spatially extensive temporal studies are rare in these
systems.
In this study, spatially interpolated surfaces that charac-
terize water quality variables in MI—nitrate (NO⫺ 3 ), ortho-
phosphate (PO⫺ ⫹
4 ), ammonium (NH4 ), chlorophyll a (Chl a),
and silicate : dissolved inorganic nitrogen (Si : DIN)—are de-
veloped and discussed. These data are spatially intensive and
were collected during relatively dry and wet periods. These
two distinct periods provide an opportunity to investigate
spatial relationships under differing environmental condi-
tions. We hypothesized that (1) water quality variables are
strongly influenced by the diverse landscape in MI, leading
to gradients or clustering of these parameters; (2) Chl a is
spatially correlated to inorganic nutrients; and (3) spatial
gradients will intensify during the wet period as urban runoff
leads to increased nutrient inputs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS


Study Site and Methods
MI is a tidally dominated, bar-built estuary characterized
by extensive Spartina alterniflora habitat and high salinities.
The estuary encompasses approximately 3000 acres of
marshland, and the upland areas have been developed to ac-
commodate an increasing flux of residents and tourists
(VERNBERG et al., 1992). The estuary is surrounded by a mix Figure 1. Murrells Inlet land use/cover and collection sites for the 24
of residential and commercial development on all sides with August 1999 and 22 October 1999 data collections.
the exception of Huntington Beach State Park to the south-
east (Figure 1). The estuary has one exchange point with oce-
anic waters and has nine outfall pipes draining the upland
Spatial Interpolation
watersheds. MI has an average depth of 1.5 m and a maxi-
mum depth of 10.0 m during midtide (B. JONES and D. POR- The analysis of spatial structures was initiated by spatial
TER, unpublished data). interpolation of NO⫺ ⫺3 ⫹
3 , PO4 , NH4 , Chl a, and Si : DIN for the
Thirty sites were sampled in MI (Figure 1) on 24 August AUG and OCT data, using radial basis functions (RBFs).
1999 (AUG) and 22 October 1999 (OCT). Data collections RBFs form a spatial interpolation technique available in the
were carried out by two teams, one covering the northern ESRI ArcMap娂 software. The RBF interpolators are similar
extent and the other covering the southern extent. Water to neural networks and allow the user some control over the
samples were collected approximately 0.5 m below the sur- parameter settings. RBFs are moderately deterministic in-
face using grab samples in acid-washed, polyethylene, 1-L terpolators that are exact, meaning that the predicted surface
bottles. Three replicate bottles were collected at each sample must go through the sample locations. However, RBFs do not
location. Inorganic nutrients (NO⫺3 ⫹ NO2 ⫽ NO3 , NH4 , SiO4
⫺ ⫺ ⫹
account for spatial autocorrelation, thus making them less
⫽ Si, PO4 ) were determined by automated colorimetric anal-
⫺3
flexible than some other interpolators, such as Kriging, that
yses using Technicon AutoAnalyzers. Chlorophyll a was mea- will account for an autocorrelation structure and produce er-
sured fluorometrically after extraction in 90% acetone by a ror or uncertainty surfaces (ESRI, 2001). The RBF is using
freeze–thaw method (LEWITUS, KOEPFLER, and MORRIS, Euclidean distance between data points instead of in-creek
1998). Daily (24 h) precipitation data were obtained from the distance for calculating the predicted surface. Previous re-
National Weather Service for MI, and daily totals were search in MI compared the use of Euclidean distances vs. in-
summed to determine monthly totals. Salinity was measured creek distances and found improvement in prediction accu-
using a refractometer, and the mean among sampling sites racy for some environmental parameters under study; how-
was calculated. ever, overall, the use of in-creek distances resulted in unpre-

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Spatial Gradients 651

dictable and modest improvements (LITTLE, EDWARDS, and


PORTER, 1997). In addition, spatial autocorrelation was ex-
amined using semivariogram analyses for all of the parame-
ters under study, and in many instances the semivariograms
were found to be inconclusive (D. WHITE, unpublished data).
Thus, Kriging was not a good choice as an interpolation tech-
nique. To be consistent, the RBF was viewed as a means to
apply a consistent interpolation technique. RBFs make no as-
sumptions about the data and therefore are an adequate
method to develop initial interpolated surfaces. A weakness
of RBFs is that they are primarily suited for moderate chang-
es in surface values; therefore, large changes in short dis-
tances may invalidate this technique. A built-in cross-vali-
dation technique was used to calculate a root-mean-square
error (RMSE) for each interpolated model.
The interpolation methods were initiated by calculating
means for each parameter at each sample location. These
data were combined with latitude and longitude coordinates
and subsequently imported into ArcGIS as comma-separated
value files using the ArcCatalog functions. The projections for
the data were set to a Universal Transverse Mercator NAD83
coordinate system. Using the Geostatistical Wizard extension
in ArcMAP, the data were interpolated using RBF and a reg-
ularized spline function with a nearest neighborhood search
of 15 points for each variable. An anisotropic search area was
developed to account for the geographic orientation of MI that
roughly follows a 45⬚ trend (Figure 1). After interpolation, the
continuous surface was converted to a grid and followed by
raster calculations to allow for a conversion to an ESRI
shapefile. The grid was a floating point file that precludes
the conversion to an ESRI coverage file. To work around this,
the grid values were multiplied by 1000 and then converted
to integers. This grid file was converted first to an ESRI cov-
Figure 2. Creek network and sampling locations used for the GIS-based
erage file and then to an ESRI shapefile. This output file was
network analyses.
rectangular and covered a much greater area than that of the
area studied (i.e., the MI creek system). A data layer of the
creek system was therefore used to extract a data layer that
was specific to the creek system. The models are presented in a geographic information system (GIS). Digitizing the MI
in a manner to highlight spatial structures across the two creek system in the ESRI ArcView 3.2娂, a vector data layer
sampling dates, so in some cases, the classification range may of the creek system was created focusing on the primary and
not be ecologically significant. secondary creeks where the collection sites are located. The
source data originated from a detailed creek boundary file
Mantel Tests originally created by digitizing 1 : 4800-scale CIR photos ac-
quired at low tide during the early (leaf off) part of 1988 (D.
Interpolated surfaces are useful for identifying trends and PORTER, personal communication). The data locations deter-
patches in a spatial context. However, these types of analyses mined via a global positioning system (GPS) survey of the
are limited with regard to verifying or interpreting the pro- collection sites were also entered into this GIS (Figure 2). In
cesses affecting visible spatial patterns that appear within this context, primary creeks were navigable at low tide while
and between each collection period. The Mantel Test (MAN- secondary creeks branched from primary creeks and may or
TEL, 1967) was used to better understand the spatial and may not be navigable at low tide. These two data layers fa-
temporal patterns observed through the interpolated surfac- cilitated a network analysis using the Arc Script Shortest
es. This nonparametric analysis tests the null hypothesis that Network Paths v1.1 (REMINGTON, 1999) that calculated the
two independent similarity, dissimilarity, or distance matri- nearest creek distance between collection sites that were sub-
ces are not significantly different (L ENGENDRE and LENGEN- sequently exported from GIS into a matrix table (DIS). The
DRE, 1998; SOKAL and ROHLF, 1995). Two types of matrices second set of matrices consists of dissimilarity matrices cal-
were developed, including a matrix composed of the geo- culated by taking the unsigned difference among the mean
graphic distances between all of the collection sites based values of the parameters (VAR) of interest (NO⫺ ⫹
3 , NH4 ,
upon creek distances between the 30 collection sites. These PO⫺34 , Chl a, and Si : DIN), following the methods described
distances were generated from a network analysis performed by LENGENDRE and TROUSSELLIER (1988).

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
652 White et al.

These matrices were used to test both spatial and temporal


hypotheses. The first set of spatial hypotheses that were ex-
amined used the DIS matrix and the dissimilarity matrices
(VAR) of each parameter examined. The purpose of this anal-
ysis is to determine whether a linear relationship exists be-
tween parameter concentrations and their spatial location.
Thus, the null hypothesis for these tests is that there are no
significant spatial trends in the distribution of the parame-
ters under investigation. The spatial distributions of the pa-
rameters were also examined for spatial correlation between
the VAR matrices within and between collection periods, thus
exploring the spatial correlations between the parameters
over time and space. The null hypothesis for these analyses
is that there is no spatial correlation between parameters
within and between collection periods.
The basic form of the Mantel statistic, zm, is calculated from
the sum of cross products of the (unstandardized) values in
the two matrices excluding the main diagonal (which were
zeros because distance and dissimilarity matrices were cal-
culated; LENGENDRE and LENGENDRE [1998]. If dissimilari-
ties or distances correspond in magnitude between the two
data matrices, then zm will be large and indicate a positive
association. If the magnitudes of these values are dissimilar
from one another, then the correlation is expected to be small
(SOKAL and ROHLF, 1995). The current study also presents
a correlation coefficient (r) and the g statistic (standard nor-
mal variate). These are one-tailed tests because the hypoth-
esis tests the positive relationship between the two variables;
thus, the levels of significance that have been calculated for
the g statistic are based on the upper tail.
The Mantel statistics are tested by permutation (also
known as randomization), which is a general approach of
testing statistical hypotheses without needing to meet the
distributional assumptions of any particular statistical meth- Figure 3. Monthly mean precipitation and salinity from Murrells Inlet
(a) precipitation and (b) salinity. Error bars are ⫾1 SE (salinity only).
od, such as a normal distribution (LENGENDRE and LENGEN- Sampling periods in the present study indicated by an open circle (䡬).
DRE, 1998). In permutation, the reference distribution is gen-
erated from a randomization of the original data. The refer-
ence distribution is a composite of these randomizations to
generate a distribution that compares to the original data. were made after a relatively dry period, while the OCT col-
Thus, it serves a role similar to the normal distribution in lections occurred after significant rain events in September
parametric statistical analyses. The test statistic is compared and October during the passage of Hurricane Floyd and Hur-
to this reference distribution. There are two steps to the per- ricane Irene. The highest recorded precipitation levels were
mutation analysis, with the initial recognition that the ob- in September 1999 during the passage of Hurricane Floyd (15
served sample of parameters is just one of many possible, but September 1999). From 16–21 October, there was approxi-
equally likely, different outcomes that could have arisen due mately 216 mm of precipitation, primarily the result of the
to chance. These other outcomes are then enumerated by ran- passage of Hurricane Irene over the SC coast approximately
domly rearranging the parameters, and, on the basis of the 3 to 5 days prior to the OCT data collections. These rainfall
resulting distribution, the observed outcome is tested to de- events are reflected in marked salinity differences between
termine whether it is dissimilar enough to warrant rejection the AUG and the OCT sampling periods (Figure 3b).
of the null hypothesis (SOKAL and ROHLF, 1995). Thus, 1000 These stochastic events had significant impacts on nutrient
random iterations were generated out of a possible 1 million inputs into the estuarine systems, increasing the concentra-
with an alpha level of 0.05. Mantel Tests were performed tions of all inorganic nutrients (Figures 4–6; see also WHITE,
using the shareware Mantel v2.0 (LIEDLOFF, 1999). PORTER, and LEWITUS, 2004). A spatial gradient was appar-
ent, indicating higher nutrient concentrations in the northern
RESULTS regions of the estuary. Lower concentrations were associated
with the inlet and southern reach of MI. The PO⫺3 4 data ap-
Interpolated Surfaces (Maps)
peared to be the most consistent in regard to the spatial pat-
Rainfall patterns prior to the sampling dates differed be- terns over time (Figure 6). Although concentrations were
tween collection periods (Figure 3a). The AUG collections higher during the OCT sampling period, both interpolated

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Spatial Gradients 653

Figure 4. Interpolated surfaces of NO⫺3 for the Murrells Inlet creek sys- Figure 5. Interpolated surfaces of NH⫹4 for the Murrells Inlet creek sys-
tem: (a) collections from 24 August 1999 and (b) collections from 22 Oc- tem: (a) collections from 24 August 1999 and (b) collections from 22 Oc-
tober 1999. Legends are meant to assist in the identification of trends; tober 1999. Legends are meant to assist in the identification of trends;
thus, color scheme and class breakdown are not presented in a continuous thus, color scheme and class breakdown are not presented in a continuous
manner between collection dates. For a color version of this figure, see manner between collection dates. For a color version of this figure, see
page 690. page 690.

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
654 White et al.

surfaces indicated ‘‘hotspots’’ in the same general locations


during both sampling periods. These areas are located in the
urbanized region.
The Chl a data (Figure 7) show some similarities over time,
with higher concentrations found in the smaller creeks along
the southwestern region of the estuary. The reported Chl a
concentrations for AUG corresponded to annual maxima re-
ported by WHITE, PORTER, and LEWITUS (2004). Higher con-
centrations were apparent in the more urbanized region dur-
ing the AUG collection period. During OCT, a similar trend
was observed, with the highest concentrations observed in
the southwest region of MI. The Si : DIN data appeared to
track Chl a, with the greatest ratio of Si : DIN occurring in
the southwest and north–northwest regions of MI during the
AUG collection period (Figure 8a). The spatial gradients of
Si : DIN were also similar to the Chl a data during OCT, with
the highest magnitudes observed in the south–southwest re-
gion (Figure 8b). Overall, these data suggest that the north-
ern regions of MI had higher inorganic nutrient concentra-
tions. However, the Chl a and Si : DIN data did not follow the
inorganic nutrient trends because highest concentrations
generally occurred along the south–southwestern boundary
of the estuary.
The cross-validation procedure in ArcMap娂 uses all of the
data to estimate a trend model. A data point is removed, one
at a time, and a new predicted value is calculated using the
remaining values. This is repeated for all of the data points,
and the measured and predicted values are compared. The
overall performance of the model can be examined by looking
at the RMSE; as a value increases from zero, that is an in-
dication of increasing error in model performance. The units
of RMSE are the same as the parameter of interest, thus
comparing RMSE is only useful with models that are of the
same units. For the AUG sampling period, RMSE values for
NO⫺ 3 , NH4 , PO4 , Chl a, and Si : DIN were 0.13 ␮M, 1.58 ␮M,
⫹ ⫺3

0.08 ␮M, 3.59 ␮g/L, and 3.63, respectively. RMSE values for
the OCT analyses of NO⫺ ⫹ ⫺3
3 , NH4 , PO4 , Chl a, and Si : DIN
were 0.69 ␮M, 2.39 ␮M, 0.06 ␮M, 1.04 ␮g/L, and 0.42, re-
spectively. Overall, model performance for NO⫺ 3 and NH4

suggests that as concentrations increased during OCT model


performance decreased. However, PO⫺3 4 was relatively stable
between AUG and OCT and showed the best performance of
all models. Chlorophyll a decreased between AUG and OCT
as concentrations decreased; this trend was also observed for
Si : DIN.

Mantel Tests
The Mantel analyses were designed to test for similarities
and trends between the parameters in a spatiotemporal con-
text. A particularly well-developed spatial gradient for the
inorganic nutrients was apparent, with higher concentrations
observed in the northern regions of the estuary followed by
reduced concentrations toward the southern extent and the
inlet region. To test the null hypotheses that there were not
Figure 6. Interpolated surfaces of PO⫺3
4 for the Murrells Inlet creek sys- linear trends for each of the parameters examined, Mantel
tem: (a) collections from 24 August 1999 and (b) collections from 22 Oc-
Tests were computed (VAR ⫻ DIS). Mantel results indicated
tober 1999. Legends are meant to assist in the identification of trends;
thus, color scheme and class breakdown are not presented in a continuous the presence of a significant linear trend only for PO⫺3
4 during

manner between collection dates. For a color version of this figure, see the AUG collection period (Table 1). Significant linear trends
page 691.

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Spatial Gradients 655

Figure 7. Interpolated surfaces of Chl a for the Murrells Inlet creek Figure 8. Interpolated surfaces of Si : DIN for the Murrells Inlet creek
system: (a) collections from 24 August 1999 and (b) collections from 22 system: (a) collections from 24 August 1999 and (b) collections from 22
October 1999. Legends are meant to assist in the identification of trends; October 1999. Legends are meant to assist in the identification of trends;
thus, color scheme and class breakdown are not presented in a continuous thus, color scheme and class breakdown are not presented in a continuous
manner between collection dates. For a color version of this figure, see manner between collection dates. For a color version of this figure, see
page 691. page 692.

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
656 White et al.

Table 1. Mantel statistics for parameter comparisons during the August 24, 1999 collection event. Probabilities are for the g statistic (standard normal
variate) and are one-tailed based on an alpha of 0.05.

NO3 (VAR) NH4 (VAR) PO4 (VAR) Chl a (VAR) Si:DIN (VAR) DIS

NO3 (VAR) — r ⫽ 0.093 r ⫽ 0.272 r ⫽ ⫺0.061 r ⫽ ⫺0.053 r ⫽ 0.106


g ⫽ 0.662 g ⫽ 2.148 g ⫽ ⫺0.477 g ⫽ ⫺0.393 g ⫽ 1.314
P ⫽ 0.254 P ⫽ 0.0159 P ⫽ 0.6833 P ⫽ 0.6528 P ⫽ 0.094
NH4 (VAR) — — r ⫽ 0.151 r ⫽ 0.106 r ⫽ 0.061 r ⫽ 0.095
g ⫽ 1.289 g ⫽ 0.888 g ⫽ 0.491 g ⫽ 1.252
P ⫽ 0.0989 P ⫽ 0.1873 P ⫽ 0.3117 P ⫽ 0.1503
PO4 (VAR) — — — r ⫽ ⫺0.031 r ⫽ 0.016 r ⫽ 0.273
g ⫽ ⫺0.282 g ⫽ 0.146 g ⫽ 3.836
P ⫽ 0.611 P ⫽ 0.442 P ⫽ 0.0001
Chl a (VAR) — — — — r ⫽ 0.645 r ⫽ 0.099
g ⫽ 5.650 g ⫽ 1.372
P ⬎ 0.0001 P ⫽ 0.085
Si:DIN (VAR) — — — — — r ⫽ 0.051
g ⫽ 0.692
P ⫽ 0.2445
r ⫽ correlation between any two parameters, g ⫽ standard normal variate.

were identified for all of the parameters during OCT (Table a and Si : DIN matrices were found to be significantly related
2). over time.
There is interest not only in identifying spatial trends but
also in identifying relationships among the parameters dur- DISCUSSION
ing the sampling periods, which may indicate physical or bi-
ological relationships. Mantel Tests were used to test the null Overall, the nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) spatial trends
hypotheses that there were not similar spatial patterns be- are likely a function of nutrient inputs from urban runoff,
tween the parameters of interest. The VAR ⫻ VAR analyses groundwater, and dilution from coastal waters. This is sup-
indicated two significant relationships for the AUG matrices, ported by previous research in MI that looked at the potential
NO⫺ 3 ⫻ PO4 and Chl a ⫻ Si : DIN (Table 1). The data from
⫺3
spatial contributions of upland runoff and coastal waters in
the OCT analyses indicated more spatial interaction between affecting water quality and Chl a (WHITE, PORTER, and LEW-
the parameters. Nitrate and NH⫹ 4 were significantly related ITUS, 2004). The surrounding landscape of MI is highly var-
to PO⫺34 , but NO3 ⫻ NH4 was not statistically significant
⫺ ⫹
iable, with more developed upland areas surrounding the
(Table 2). Nitrate was significantly related to Chl a and Si : northern regions of the estuary and a state park to the south.
DIN, and Chl a ⫻ Si : DIN was significantly related. The inlet is a source for coastal waters that are nutrient poor
Further analyses testing the null hypothesis that there is relative to the estuarine water. Mantel Test results indicated
no association or correlation between the parameter matrices intensification of the gradients for N and P during OCT, fol-
over time found that the PO⫺3 4 matrices were significantly lowing the heavy rainfall in late September and October. Be-
similar between the AUG and the OCT collection periods (Ta- cause of the lack of significant riverine freshwater sources in
ble 3). These results support the observations of PO⫺3 4 ‘‘hot- the MI estuary, nonpoint source pollution runoff is likely the
spots’’ in the northern region of the MI. In addition, the Chl main source of ‘‘new’’ inorganic N and P following rain events.

Table 2. Mantel statistics for parameter comparisons during the October 22, 1999 collection event. Probabilities are for the g statistic (standard normal
variate) and are one-tailed based on an alpha of 0.05.

NO3 (VAR) NH4 (VAR) PO4 (VAR) Chl a (VAR) Si:DIN (VAR) DIS

NO3 (VAR) — r ⫽ ⫺0.022 r ⫽ 0.192 r ⫽ 0.576 r ⫽ 0.500 r ⫽ 0.207


g ⫽ ⫺0.178 g ⫽ 2.061 g ⫽ 4.615 g ⫽ 4.407 g ⫽ 2.883
P ⫽ 0.5706 P ⫽ 0.0197 P ⬎ 0.0001 P ⬎ 0.0001 P ⫽ 0.002
NH4 (VAR) — — r ⫽ 0.614 r ⫽ ⫺0.139 r ⫽ ⫺0.082 r ⫽ 0.296
g ⫽ 5.814 g ⫽ ⫺0.966 g ⫽ ⫺0.630 g ⫽ 3.731
P ⬎ 0.0001 P ⫽ 0.833 P ⫽ 0.7357 P ⫽ 0.0001
PO4 (VAR) — — — r ⫽ 0.018 r ⫽ ⫺0.018 r ⫽ 0.370
g ⫽ 0.170 g ⫽ ⫺0.185 g ⫽ 5.724
P ⫽ 0.4325 P ⫽ 0.5734 P ⬎ 0.0001
Chl a (VAR) — — — — r ⫽ 0.720 r ⫽ 0.158
g ⫽ 5.558 g ⫽ 1.998
P ⬎ 0.0001 P ⫽ 0.0229
Si:DIN (VAR) — — — — — r ⫽ 0.175
g ⫽ 2.373
P ⫽ 0.009
r ⫽ correlation between any two parameters, g ⫽ standard normal variate.

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Spatial Gradients 657

Table 3. Mantel statistics for parameter comparisons across the August 24, 1999 and October 22, 1999 collection events. Probabilities are for the g statistic
(standard normal variate) and are one-tailed based on an alpha of 0.05.

NO3 (VAR) NH4 (VAR) PO4 (VAR) Chl a (VAR) Si:DIN (VAR)

NO3 (VAR) r ⫽ 0.007 — — — —


g ⫽ 0.051
P ⫽ 0.4797
NH4 (VAR) — r ⫽ ⫺0.012 — — —
g ⫽ ⫺0.090
P ⫽ 0.5359
PO4 (VAR) — — r ⫽ 0.599 — —
g ⫽ 6.509
P ⬎ 0.0001
Chl a (VAR) — — — r ⫽ 0.528 —
g ⫽ 4.231
P ⬎ 0.0001
Si:DIN (VAR) — — — — r ⫽ 0.531
g ⫽ 4.498
P ⬎ 0.0001
r ⫽ correlation between any two parameters, g ⫽ standard normal variate.

Nonpoint sources generally include fertilizers, animal these particular areas due to development when compared to
waste, sediments, storm runoff, groundwater, and atmo- pristine forested watersheds of a nearby estuarine system
spheric deposition (JAWORSKI, HOWARTH, and HETLING, (TUFFORD et al., 2003). The Mantel Tests indicated a signif-
1997; JORDAN, CORRELL, and WELLER, 1997; PAERL, 1997). icant correlation between the AUG and the OCT data. This
These nutrient sources may be funneled into the estuary by stability is surprising since the AUG data were collected dur-
impervious surfaces such as roads, driveways, parking lots, ing a relatively dry period and the OCT data were collected
rooftops, and other common landscape features of an urban immediately after a period of heavy rainfall, resulting in the
environment (U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY highest N concentrations observed in MI during the course of
STAFF, 1997; WASCHBUSCH, SELBIG, and BANNERMAN, an approximate 2-year study (WHITE, PORTER, and LEWITUS,
2000). The diverse landscape features that surround MI im- 2004). Orthophosphate concentrations were generally less
pose different conditions on the estuary, resulting in regions than 1 ␮M during the dry and wet periods. Orthophosphate
that receive varying degrees of nutrient runoff. Investigators has virtually no atmospheric phases and stays largely in the
have shown that these systems are susceptible to modest water column and in marsh sediments composed of clay sed-
changes in the upland cover, with measurable adverse chang- iments and peat (FROELICH, 1988; WHITNEY et al., 1981).
es in the physical and chemical environment observed at 10 These physical processes may have implications in the ap-
to 20% impervious surface within a watershed (HOLLAND et parent lack of spatial variability for PO⫺3
4 in MI.
al., 2004). Analyses have shown a decreasing gradient in im- The interpolated maps for Chl a and Si : DIN were very
pervious surface from the northern region to the southern similar during AUG and OCT, suggesting a strong spatiotem-
region in MI (TUFFORD et al., 2003; D. WHITE, unpublished poral relationship. Previous research in MI has shown posi-
data). Higher concentrations found in the northern regions tive temporal correlations between Chl a and silicate (WHITE,
are associated with the urbanized features. Concentrations PORTER, and LEWITUS, 2004). The strong correlations ob-
decrease in the southern region, and a relatively nutrient- served between Chl a and Si : DIN were likely a reflection of
poor region is associated with the inlet. Thus, three regions diatom growth. Silicate is not limiting in these systems, and
in MI can be differentiated based on coastal and upland pro- N was not likely to be limiting during the summer, when N
cesses, including (1) a northern region defined by higher nu- concentrations reach annual maxima (LEWITUS, KOEPFLER,
trient concentrations; (2) a southern region with moderate and MORRIS, 1998; WHITE, PORTER, and LEWITUS, 2004).
nutrient concentrations; and (3) the inlet region character- Therefore, the Si : DIN pattern may be a reflection of phyto-
ized by relatively low nutrient concentrations. plankton uptake and remineralization of silicate and N in the
The interpolated maps indicate hotspots and clusters of nu- sediments and water column. Phytoplankton assemblage
trient concentrations that appear to be stable over time. This data indicate that diatoms are dominant in this system and
was particularly apparent for PO⫺3 4 , although further long- the spatial distributions of diatoms tend to follow those of
term studies are needed to confirm this. Previous research Chl a (LEWITUS et al., 2005; D. WHITE, unpublished data).
has shown fecal coliforms to be elevated in specific regions in The lowest Chl a concentrations were associated with the
MI within the general proximity of the observed hotspots for inlet region of MI, consistent with general findings that
this study (KELSEY et al., 2004). As noted previously, the southeastern U.S. coastal waters have lower phytoplankton
northern region of MI is characterized by various urbanized biomass than adjacent estuaries. Maximum Chl a concentra-
features that may be affecting specific locations within the tion was consistently centered within a creek located on the
estuary. In addition, the freshwater streams and ponds that southwestern fringe of the estuary, although peaks in the
drain into MI were found to have higher NO⫺ 3 and total P more northern areas of MI occurred during AUG. Spatial sta-
concentrations compared with a reduction in organic N for bility was observed for Chl a and Si : DIN despite the strong

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
658 White et al.

tidal flushing characterizing this system. However, this par- tation of estuarine processes. These methods also provided
ticular creek does not appear to be natural and is bordered the opportunity to formulate new hypotheses that may have
by several houses with small docks that support water access implications outside of this system. Of importance is the ex-
for residents. Observations in this area suggest this partic- amination of the possible internal processes that may be af-
ular section may not flush as well as the primary creeks in fecting the stability of the Chl a and PO⫺34 concentrations in
MI. In addition, based on documented linkages between spatiotemporal context. The lack of an observed increase in
coastal development and eutrophication (KENNISH, 1992; phytoplankton biomass concomitant with increased nutrient
PINCKNEY et al., 2001), spatial correlation between elevated loading during the summer may reflect a dominant influence
nutrient concentrations and phytoplankton growth may be of autochthonous regulation of phytoplankton growth (e.g.,
expected, assuming upland nutrient inputs were a significant nutrient regeneration), but potential other influences include
and critical source for new N and P. rapid recovery related to high tidal flushing rates or light
As was common with the inorganic nutrients for the OCT limitation of phytoplankton growth resulting from increased
period, the VAR ⫻ DIS comparisons were significant, indi- turbidity (BURKHOLDER et al., 2004; MALLIN et al., 1999,
cating linear trends for Chl a and Si : DIN. However, the in- 2002; NOBLE et al., 2003). Application of these analyses to
terpolated maps indicated that the trend was reversed for winter–spring periods is needed to test whether the influence
Chl a and Si : DIN. Also, the Mantel results indicated that of stochastic events on the distribution and magnitude of phy-
Chl a and Si : DIN were not significantly correlated to NH ⫹ 4 toplankton biomass depends on their seasonal timing.
or PO⫺34 (either positively or negatively) during these two pe-
riods. Nitrate was significantly correlated with Chl a and Si : ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
DIN during OCT. The interpolated NO⫺ 3 data for OCT sug-
gest that the strong clustering observed previously for AUG The research described within was supported in part by a
decreased to some extent during OCT. The spatial correla- Graduate Research Fellowship from National Estuarine Re-
tions between Chl a and NO⫺ search Reserve System (grant NA07OR0725), the Slocum-
3 may be not a result of a bio-
logical relationship but a function of increased NO⫺ Lunz Foundation (proposal R-98㛮115600), the South Carolina
3 inputs
near the marsh–upland interface where biomass was elevat- Space Grant Consortium, and National Oceanic and Atmo-
ed. The apparent disconnect between upland nutrient inputs spheric Administration grant NA90AA-D-SG672. In addition,
and phytoplankton biomass may be due to internal estuarine we wish to acknowledge the efforts of students and staff as-
processes meeting phytoplankton nutritional requirements, sociated with the Baruch Institute Geographic Information
primarily remineralization. LEWITUS, KOEPFLER, and MOR- Processing Laboratory at the University of South Carolina
RIS (1998) demonstrated the importance of regenerated nu-
who assisted in data collection and Bill Johnson of the Ba-
trients to phytoplankton in summer in a similar estuary, ruch Marine Field Laboratory and Dr. Don Edwards of the
North Inlet, SC. NOBLE et al. (2003) also presented evidence University of South Carolina for their efforts and guidance.
that the dominance of autochthonous factors (e.g., regener-
ated nutrients and grazing) over allochthonous factors (e.g., LITERATURE CITED
nutrient loading and changes in turbidity) in regulating phy- BALES, J.D., 2003. Effects of Hurricane Floyd inland flooding, Sep-
toplankton biomass in North Inlet in the summer was related tember–October 1999, on tributaries to Pamlico Sound, North Car-
to a relatively small watershed and lack of riverine fresh- olina. Estuaries, 26(5), 1319–1328.
water input compared to another minimally urbanized salt BURKHOLDER, J.; EGGLESTON, D.; GLASGOW, H.; BROWNIE, C.;
REED, R.; JANOQITZ, G.; POSEY, M.; MELIA, G.; KINDER, C.; COR-
marsh estuary in South Carolina, the Ashepoo–Combahee– BETT, R.; TOMS, D.; ALPIN, T.; DEAMER, N., and SPRINGER, J.,
Edisto Basin. Nitrogen loading would be expected to impact 2004. Comparative impacts of two major hurricane seasons on the
phytoplankton nutrition to a greater degree in the winter and Neuse River and western Pamlico Sound ecosystems. Proceedings
spring, when population growth is N limited in North Inlet of the National Academy of Sciences, 101, 9291–9296.
ESRI, 2001. ArcGIS娂 Geostatistical Analyst: Statistical Tools for
and therefore presumably in MI. Furthermore, the location
Data Exploration, Modeling, and Advanced Surface Generation:
and stability of the Chl a maxima in our study may be related White Paper. Redlands, California: ESRI, 19p.
to physical properties. The spatial interpolation maps showed FROELICH, P.N., 1988. Kinetic control of dissolved phosphate in nat-
higher biomass generally associated with the smaller creeks ural rivers and estuaries: a primer on the phosphate buffer mech-
near the marsh–upland interface. These creeks appeared to anism. Limnology and Oceanography, 33(4, part 2), 649–668.
HOLLAND, F.A.; SANGER, A.F.; GAWLE, C.P.; LERBERG, S.B.; SAN-
be somewhat isolated from the primary tidal creeks in MI, TIAGOA, M.S.; RIEKERK, G.H.M.; ZIMMERMAN, L.E., and SCOTT,
which may affect tidal flow, minimizing tidal flushing and G.S., 2004. Linkages between tidal creek ecosystems and the land-
resulting in decreased losses of localized phytoplankton bio- scape and demographic attributes of their watersheds. Journal of
mass. Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 298, 151–178.
JAWORSKI, N.A.; HOWARTH, R.W., and HETLING, L.J., 1997. Atmo-
spheric deposition of nitrogen oxides onto the landscape contrib-
CONCLUSIONS utes to coastal eutrophication in the northeast United States. En-
vironmental Science and Technology, 31, 1995–2004.
The use of the interpolation maps highlighted water qual- JORDAN, T.E.; CORRELL, D.L., and WELLER, D.E., 1997. Nonpoint
ity patterns in the MI system, and this is the first step in the source discharges of nutrients from piedmont watersheds of Ches-
apeake Bay. Journal of the American Water Resources Association,
identification of trends and patterns. These maps, combined 33(3), 631–645.
with the Mantel Test, allowed the testing of spatial and tem- KELSEY, R.H.; PORTER, D.E.; SCOTT, G.; NEET, M., and WHITE, D.,
poral hypotheses that facilitated the diagnosis and interpre- 2004. Using geographic information systems and regression anal-

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco
Spatial Gradients 659

ysis to evaluate relationships between land use and fecal coliform ‘‘new’’ nitrogen and other nutrient sources. Limnology and Ocean-
bacterial pollution. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and ography, 42(5, part 2), 1154–1165.
Ecology, 298, 197–209. PEIERLS, B.L.; CHRISTIAN, R.R., and PAERL, H.W., 2003. Water
KENNISH, M.J., 1992. Ecology of Estuaries: Anthropogenic Effects. quality and phytoplankton as indicators of hurricane impacts on
Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press, 494p. a large estuarine ecosystem. Estuaries, 26(5), 1329–1343.
LENGENDRE, P. and LENGENDRE, L., 1998. Numerical Ecology, 2nd PINCKNEY, J.L.; PAERL, H.W.; TESTER, P., and RICHARDSON, T.L.,
English edition. New York: Elsevier, 853p. 2001. The role of nutrient loading and eutrophication in estuarine
ecology. Environmental Health Perspectives, 109(5), 699–706.
LENGENDRE, P. and TROUSSELLIER, M., 1988. Aquatic heterotrophic
RAMUS, J.; EBY, L.A.; MCCLELLAN, C.M., and CROWDER, L.B., 2003.
bacteria: modeling in the presence of spatial autocorrelation. Lim- Phytoplankton forcing by a record freshwater discharge event in
nology and Oceanography, 33(5), 1055–1067. a large lagoonal estuarine ecosystem. Estuaries, 26(5), 1344–1352.
LEWITUS, A.J.; KOEPFLER, E.T., and MORRIS, J.T., 1998. Seasonal REMINGTON, K., 1999. Shortest Network Paths v1.1. http://
variation in the regulation of phytoplankton by nitrogen and graz- arcscripts.esri.com/details.asp?dbid⫽10895 (accessed March 1,
ing in a salt-marsh estuary. Limnology and Oceanography, 43(4), 2000).
636–646. SOKAL, R.R. and ROHLF, F.J., 1995. Biometry: The Principles and
LEWITUS, A.J.; WHITE, D.L.; TYMOWSKI, R.G.; GEESEY, M.E.; HY- Practice of Statistics in Biological Research, 3rd edition. New York:
MEL, S.N., and NOBLE, P.A., 2005. Adapting the CHEMTAX meth- W.H. Freeman, 887p.
od for assessing phytoplankton taxonomic composition in south- TUFFORD, D.; SAMARGHITAN, C.L.; MCKELLAR, H.N., JR.; PORTER,
eastern U.S. estuaries. Estuaries, 28, 158–170. D.E., and HUSSEY, J.R., 2003. Impacts of urbanization on nutrient
LIEDLOFF, A., 1999. Mantel nonparametric test calculator. http:// concentrations in small southeastern coastal streams. Journal of
www.sci.qut.edu.au/nrs/mantel.htm (accessed November 1, 2002). the American Water Resources Association, 39(2), 301–312.
LITTLE, L.S.; EDWARDS, D., and PORTER, D.E., 1997. Kriging in es- U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY STAFF, 1997. Urbani-
tuaries: as the crow flies, or as the fish swims? Journal of Exper- zation and Streams: Studies of Hydrologic Impacts. Washington,
DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Publication, EPA 841-
imental Marine Biology and Ecology, 213, 1–11.
R-97-009, 16p.
MALLIN, M.A.; ESHAM, E.C.; WILLIAMS, K.E., and NEARHOOF, J.E., VERNBERG, F.J.; VERNBERG, W.B.; BLOOD, E.; FORTNER, A.; FUL-
1999. Tidal stage variability of fecal coliform and chlorophyll a TON, M.; MCKELLAR, H.; MICHENER, W.; SCOTT, G.; SIEWICKI, T.,
concentrations in coastal creeks. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 38, and EL FIGI, K., 1992. Impact of urbanization on high-salinity es-
414–422. tuaries in the southeastern United States. Netherlands Journal of
MALLIN, M.A.; POSEY, M.H.; MCIVER, M.R.; PARSONS, D.C.; EN- Sea Research, 30, 239–248.
SIGN, S.H., and ALPIN, T.D., 2002. Impacts and recovery from mul- WASCHBUSCH, R.J.; SELBIG, W.R., and BANNERMAN, R.T., 2000.
tiple hurricanes in a piedmont-coastal plain river system. Bio- Sources of phosphorous in stormwater and street dirt from two
Science, 52, 999–1010. urban residential basins in Madison, Wisconsin, 1994–95. In: Pro-
MANTEL, N., 1967. The detection of disease clustering and a gener- ceedings, National Conference on Tools for Urban Water Resource
alized regression approach. Cancer Research, 27, 209–220. Management and Protection (Chicago, Illinois). Cincinnati, Ohio:
NIXON, S.W., 1982. Nutrient dynamics, primary production and fish- EPA, Office of Research and Development, Report No. EPA/625/
eries yields of lagoons. Oceanologica Acta, V(4, suppl.), 357–371. R-00/001, pp. 9–31.
WHITE, D.L.; PORTER, D.E., and LEWITUS, A.J., 2004. Spatial and
NOBLE, P.A.; TYMOWSKI, R.G.; FLETCHER, M.; MORRIS, J.T., and
temporal analyses of water quality and phytoplankton biomass in
LEWITUS, A.J., 2003. Comparing estuarine phytoplankton com- an urbanized versus pristine salt marsh estuary. Journal of Ex-
munities in southeastern U.S. salt marsh estuaries using high per- perimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 298, 255–273.
formance liquid chromatography and statistical analyses. Applied WHITNEY, D.M.; CHALMERS, A.G.; HAINES, E.B.; HANSON, R.B.;
Environmental Microbiology, 69, 4129–4143. POMEROY, L.R., and SHEER, D., 1981. The cycles of nitrogen and
PAERL, H.W., 1997. Coastal eutrophication and harmful algal phosphorous. In: POMEROY, L.R., and WIEGERT, R.G. (eds.), The
blooms: importance of atmospheric deposition and groundwater as Ecology of a Salt Marsh. New York: Springer-Verlag, pp. 163–181.

Journal of Coastal Research, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2008

Downloaded From: https://bioone.org/journals/Journal-of-Coastal-Research on 14 Nov 2019


Terms of Use: https://bioone.org/terms-of-use Access provided by Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco

Potrebbero piacerti anche