Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
B
services. However, a central theme throughout definitions of
y 2050, estimates indicate that over a quarter of palliative care is the promotion of quality of life, with family
the world’s population will be aged 65 years and and multidisciplinary involvement (Goldman et al, 2006).
older.The proportion of people aged over 60 years The definition and philosophy of palliative care has
will double from about 11% to 22% (Lancet, 2014), expanded more recently to include life-limiting illnesses, which
with the greatest percentage increase predicted include chronic heart, lung and kidney diseases, neurological
to be among those aged 85 years and older (Hall et al, 2011). disorders and organ failure.This is evident in the World Health
The growth in the number of older people has led to a rapid Organization (WHO) definition, adopted for this study:
increase in the number of nursing homes and care facilities for
‘An approach that improves the quality of
older people (Moran, 2009).
life of patients and their families facing the
Older people with life-limiting illnesses and those nearing
problems associated with life-threatening illness,
the end of their lives have different and often more complex
through the prevention and relief of suffering
needs than those in other age groups. Typically, the dying
by means of early identification and impeccable
assessment and treatment of pain and other
Olivia Wilson, Donegal Hospice, County Donegal, Ireland
problems, physical, psychosocial and spiritual.’
(WHO, 2016)
Gloria Avalos, Lecturer, School of Medicine, Medical Informatics
and Medical Education, National University of Ireland, Galway, As a result of this inclusive view of palliative care, older
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
RESEARCH
knowledge of palliative care in order to provide quality care Table 1. Palliative care training in nursing homes and community hospitals
to those who need it (Ronaldson et al, 2008).
Nurses working in older people care settings, such as Nursing home Community hospital
n (%) n (%)
community hospitals and nursing homes, are ideally placed
to deliver palliative care. There is a unique nurse–resident European Certificate in Essentials 2 (17) 8 (45)
relationship that exists owing to long lengths of admission in Palliative Care (ECEPC)
(Frahm et al, 2011), which promotes the delivery of palliative Information session within the unit 7 (58) 4 (22)
care. Such relationships should enable nurses to monitor changes
and broach the subject of palliative care with both residents Study session outside the unit 3 (25) 6 (33)
and families. However, the quality of palliative care delivered Total 12 (100) 18 (100)
to older people is often inadequate (Jerant et al, 2004; Gorlén
et al, 2013). Moreover, a lack of understanding of the basics of
palliative care among nursing home staff has been reported in more negative attitudes towards palliative care and poorer
Australia (Ronaldson et al, 2008), Ireland (McDonell et al, 2009), perceived outcomes for patients (Mason and Ellershaw, 2008).
Sweden (Dwyer et al, 2011) and Denmark (Gorlén et al, 2013), The questionnaire also asked respondents what palliative
with a need for more education highlighted across all studies. care training they had undertaken, i.e. informal short sessions
This study aimed to determine the palliative care knowledge on palliative care in their workplace, study sessions on palliative
and attitudes towards caring for the dying, of nurses working in care outside of work, the European Certificate in Essential
care of the older person settings in one rural region in Ireland Palliative Care (ECEPC). In the region where this study took
and identify palliative care educational needs. The study also place, both the local hospice and the Irish Hospice Foundation
aimed to determine which type of palliative care education fund the delivery of the ECEPC. The 8-week course requires
resulted in higher scores in palliative care knowledge and 2 days of attendance, one on the introduction evening and one
attitudes to dying. on the final day for the exam. The participants are guided on
self-directed learning for these 8 weeks, making it conducive
Research methodology to family and work life. The EPEPC is offered in a number
A cross-sectional methodology was used in this study. Cross- of countries, including Malta and is recognised by the Royal
sectional studies use a cross section of a population and determine Colleges of Physicians and General Practitioners and by the
a snapshot view. Ethical approval was granted by the ethics University of Surrey and University of Ulster.
committee attached to the main regional hospital in November The completed questionnaires were kept in a sealed envelope
2013 to survey all registered nurses (n=97) working in four placed in a box in the nursing office of each unit and collected
private and three state-run older person care units geographically by the first researcher 10 days later. The researcher stored the
spread across one rural county in Ireland.The seven care homes completed questionnaires in a locked cabinet.The questionnaire
represent one third of all older person care centres in the region. data were then inputted onto a password-protected laptop.The data
The first author met with the manager of each unit, explained were analysed using IBM SPSS Statistics (Version 20). Descriptive
the study and left questionnaires in each staff room. analysis was used to report the mean (standard deviation (SD))
The study instrument consisted of two questionnaires: the when data were normally distributed or to report medians
palliative care quiz for nursing (PCQN) (Ross et al, 1996) and (minimum and maximum) when the distribution was skewed.
the thanatophobia scale (Merrill et al, 1998).The PCQN consists Independent samples t-test was used to compare the means
of 20 items that require a ‘true’,‘false’ or ‘don’t know’ response. between two groups, while ANOVA (analysis of variance) was
It is a popular tool that has been used internationally and in a used to compare the means for more than two categories.The
variety of nursing settings such as community nursing (Hughes significance level was set up at p<0.05 and when zero was
et al, 2006), paediatrics (Knapp et al, 2009) and long-term outside the 95% confidence interval (CI). Pearson correlation
care (Raudonis et al, 2002; Brazil et al, 2012). The minimum was used to find out if a relationship existed between two
achievable score for the PCQN is zero and the maximum is continuous variables when data were normally distributed, while
20. The PCQN was tested on registered and student nurses the alternative non-parametric Spearman’s correlation was used
and shown to have an internal consistency of 0.78. The when the distribution was skewed. An r-value and Rho value
thanatophobia scale (TS) is a seven-time Likert scale (Merrill were used to indicate the strength of the correlation and the
et al, 1998), designed to assess attitudes towards caring for (+/-) sign was used to report the direction of the relationship.
dying patients, and was initially tested on nursing and medical
students and qualified doctors.Analysis of the seven items in the Results
TS resulted in Cronbach’s alphas of 0.84 at pre-test and 0.85 Completed questionnaires were returned by 61 nurses (response
at post-test (Mason and Ellershaw, 2004). The TS has mainly rate 63%); 52 (85%) were staff nurses and 9 (15%) were nurse
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
been used in studies with samples of medical students (Mason managers; and 41 worked in community hospitals and 20 in
and Ellershaw, 2004; Mason and Ellershaw, 2010; Morrison et nursing homes. The mean (SD) age of the participants was
al, 2012). However, it has more recently been used in a study of 42 years (8.8), the youngest participant was 26 and the oldest
hospital nurses (Clark et al, 2015). Scores range from a minimum was 64. The median (minimum-maximum) number of years
of 7 to a maximum of 49. Greater cumulative scores indicate registered as nurses was 16 (0.5 to 44). A total of 30 (49%) had
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
Table 2. Correct and incorrect palliative care quiz for nursing (PCQN)
a moderate level of palliative care knowledge, with the lowest
responses score being 5 and the highest being 18. The highest number
of correct responses was achieved for question 8: ‘individuals
Correct Incorrect
who are taking opioids should follow a bowel regime’ (n=57,
n (%) n (%)
93%).The highest number of incorrect responses was achieved
Q1 Palliative care is appropriate only in situations 50 (82) 11 (18) for question 12:‘the philosophy of palliative care is compatible
where there is evidence of a downhill trajectory or with that of aggressive treatment’ (n=56, 92%) (Table 2).
deterioration (F)
No significant difference (p=0.29 and 95% CI -2.14, 0.67)
Q2 Morphine is the standard used to compare the 33 (54) 28 (46) was found between the mean (SD) PCQN score for staff nurses
analgesic effect of other opioids (T) (11.7 (3.01)) and for nurse managers (12.4 (1.59)). However,
Q3 The extent of the disease determines the method of 20 (33) 41 (67) there was a significant (p<0.0001, 95% CI, 1.37, 4.32) mean
pain treatment (F) difference of 2.9 between the mean (SD) PCQN score for
nurses working in community hospitals (12.8 (2.39)) and in
Q4 Adjuvant therapies are important in managing pain (T) 46 (75) 15 (25)
nursing homes (9.9 (2.81)).
Q5 It is crucial for family members to remain at the 45 (74) 16 (26) There was no significant correlation (r=0.166) found between
bedside until death occurs (F)
age and a total PCQN score (p=0.201). However, the PCQN
Q6 During the last days of life, the drowsiness 24 (39) 37 (61) score improved the longer a nurse had been registered.This was
associated with electrolyte imbalance may decrease found to be significant, as Spearman’s correlation showed that
the need for sedation (T) p=0.021 (r=0.295) with a weak to moderate positive correlation.
Q7 Drug addiction is a major problem when morphine 33 (54) 28 (46) The mean (SD) PCQN score for those who had some form
is used on a long-term basis for the management of palliative care education was 12.4 (2.79), and 11.3 (2.85) for
of pain (F) those who had no palliative care education. The difference in
Q8 Individuals who are taking opioids should follow a 57 (93) 4 (7) means of 1.01 was not statistically significant (p=0.141, 95%
bowel regime (T) CI -0.36, 2.52). ANOVA within the three different types of
palliative care education was undertaken (Table 3) and showed
Q9 The provision of palliative care requires emotional 45 (74) 16 (26)
detachment (F) no significant difference in PCQN scores between those who
had attended an information session within their unit and those
Q 10 During the terminal stages of an illness, drugs that 26 (43) 35 (57) who attended a study day outside their unit (p=0.105), nor
can cause respiratory depression are appropriate
for the treatment of severe dyspnoea (T)
between those who completed the ECEPC and those who had
attended a study day outside their unit (p=0.781). However, the
Q 11 Men generally reconcile their grief more quickly than 39 (64) 22 (36) mean (SD) PCQN score for those who completed the ECEPC
women (F)
was 13.8 (2.39), while the mean (SD) score for those who only
Q 12 The philosophy of palliative care is compatible with 5 (8) 56 (92) had an information session within their unit was 10.6 (3.21).
that of aggressive treatment (T) This difference in mean scores of 3.2 was found to be significant
Q 13 The use of placebos is appropriate in the treatment 41 (67) 20 (33) (p=0.020, 95% CI 0.46, 6.05), indicating a higher level of palliative
of some types of pain (F) care knowledge among those who had completed the ECEPC.
The median score of the TS was 14.0 indicating favourable
Q 14 In high doses, codeine causes more nausea and 26 (43) 35 (57)
vomiting than morphine (T) attitudes towards caring for the dying, with the lowest score
being 7 and the highest being 36. The most positive attitudes
Q 15 Suffering and physical pain are synonymous (F) 37 (61) 24 (39) were seen in question 3: ‘it is frustrating to have to continue
Q 16 Pethidine is not an effective analgesic in the control 43 (71) 18 (29) talking with relatives of patients who are not going to get
of chronic pain (T) better’ (median=1.0) and the most negative attitudes were
Q 17 The accumulation of losses renders burnout 27 (44) 34 (56) seen in question 5: ‘It makes me uncomfortable when a dying
inevitable for those who seek work in palliative patient wants to say good bye to me’ (median=2.0) (Table 4).
care (F) No significance was found between the mean (SD) TS score
Q 18 Manifestations of chronic pain are different from 51 (84) 10 (16)
for staff nurses (15.2 (5.89)) and the mean TS score for nurse
those of acute pain (T) managers (15.6 (7.62), p=0.883). Similarly, no significance was
found between the mean (SD) TS score for those working in
Q 19 The loss of a distant or contentious relationship is 36 (59) 25 (41)
a community hospital (14.8 (6.68)) and for those working in
easier to resolve than the loss of one that is close
or intimate (F) a nursing home (16.1 (4.7)) (p=0.407).
However, the TS score was lower the older the nurse was.This
Q 20 The pain threshold is lowered by anxiety or fatigue (T) 37 (61) 24 (39) was found to be significant as Pearson’s correlation p=0.006, and
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
RESEARCH
that attitudes were more positive the longer a participant was Table 3. Mean and median scores of each TS question
registered (r= -0.290) (Table 5)
The difference in the mean (SD) TS score for those who Mean Median
(SD) (min–max)
had some form of palliative care education (14.7 (6.36)) and
those who had no education (15.7 (5.89)) was not significant Q1 Dying patients make me feel uneasy 2.23 (1.2) 2.0 (1–6)
(p=0.523, 95% CI -4.15, 2.1).A moderate negative correlation
Q2 I feel pretty helpless when I have terminal 2.02 (1.0) 2.0 (1–6)
(r=-0.340) was also found between the total PCQN scores patients on my ward
and the total TS scores. As the total PCQN scores increased,
the total TS scores decreased, showing that a higher level of Q3 It is frustrating to have to continue talking with 1.93 (1.3) 1.0 (1–7)
relatives of patients who are not going to get
palliative care knowledge correlates to more positive attitudes better
towards caring for the dying. This was found to be significant,
as Pearson correlation showed p=0.007. Q4 Managing dying patients traumatises me 2.46 (1.5) 2.0 (1–7)
clear that the person is in a progressive state of decline (Watson, death and dying are positively affected by experience (Mutto
2005). This latter point is important: ‘generalists’ continue to et al, 2010). In terms of practice, this finding suggests that
express difficulties in defining palliative care and refer to it as a younger, less experienced nurses would benefit from working
specialist palliative service, rather than ‘a philosophy and practice alongside older, more experienced nurses. Moreover, in terms
of care’ (Gott et al 2012: 235) that is an essential part of the care of education, younger, less experienced nurses may benefit
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
Declaration of interest: none
KEY POINTS
Brazil K, Brink P, Kaasalainen S, Kelly ML, McAiney C (2012) Knowledge and
■■ All nurses working in older people care settings should be supported with perceived competence among nurses caring for the dying in long-term care
the opportunity to undertake the European Certificate in Essential Palliative homes. Int J Palliat Nurs 18(2): 77–83. doi: 10.12968/ijpn.2012.18.2.77
Clark K, Curry T, Byfieldt N (2015) The effect of a care bundle on nursing staff
Care (ECEPC) when caring for the dying. Int J Palliat Nurs 21(8): 392–8. doi: 10.12968/
ijpn.2015.21.8.392
■■ Nurses with increased level of palliative care knowledge have more positive Department of Health (2012) The end of life care strategy for England. Fourth
attitudes towards care of dying patients Annual Report. http://tinyurl.com/hk6yqef (accessed 26 May 2016)
Dwyer L-L, Hansebo G, Andershed B,Ternestedt B-M (2011) Nursing home
■■ This study suggests older and more experienced nurses have more positive residents’ views on dying and death: nursing home employee’s perspective. Int
attitudes towards caring for the dying J Older People Nurs 6(4): 251–60. doi: 10.1111/j.1748-3743.2010.00237.x
Ferris FD, Bruera E, Cherny N et al (2009) Palliative cancer care a decade later:
■■ Younger or less experienced nurses may benefit from working alongside accomplishments, the need, next steps—from the American Society of Clinical
older, more experienced nurses Oncology. J Clin Oncol 27(18): 3052–8. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2008.20.1558
Fields A, Finucane AM, Oxenham D (2013) Discussing preferred place of death
■■ Discussions on the philosophy underpinning palliative care should be part with patients: staff experiences in a UK specialist palliative care setting. Int J
Palliat Nurs 19(11): 558–65. doi: 10.12968/ijpn.2013.19.11.558
of palliative-care education programmes Frahm KA, Brown LM, Gibson M (2011) The importance of end-of-life care in
nursing home settings is not diminished by a disaster. Omega (Westport) 64(2):
143–55
Froggatt K, Payne S (2006) A survey of end-of-life care in care homes: issues
from exploration of their attitudes to palliative care and caring of definition and practice. Health Soc Care Community 14(4): 341–8. doi:
for the dying as part of any palliative care training programme. 10.1111/j.1365-2524.2006.00628.x
Gaertner J,Wolf J, Frechen S et al (2012) Recommending early integration of
The most negative attitudes were seen in question 5 on the palliative care - does it work? Support Care Cancer 20(3): 507–13. doi: 10.1007/
TS; ‘It makes me uncomfortable when a dying patient wants s00520-011-1111-2
to say goodbye to me.’ Discussing death and dying has been Goldman A, Hain R, Liben S (2006) Oxford Textbook of Palliative Care for
Children, Oxford University Press, Oxford
described as ‘difficult’ (Fields et al, 2013; Whellan et al, 2014). Gorlén TF, Gorlén T, Neergaard MA (2013) Death in nursing homes: a
This finding suggests that a focus on drugs and palliative care Danish qualitative study. Int J Palliat Nurs 19(5): 236–42. doi: 10.12968/
ijpn.2013.19.5.236
emergencies training for nurses working in non-specialist units is Gott M, Small N, Barnes S, Payne S, Seamark D (2008) Older people’s views of
not enough, and must also include discussions on the philosophy a good death in heart failure: implications for palliative care provision. Soc Sci
Med 67(7): 1113–21. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.05.024
underpinning palliative care. Gott M, Seymour J, Ingleton C, Gardiner C, Bellamy G (2012) ‘That’s part of
There was a moderate negative correlation between the everybody’s job’: the perspectives of health care staff in England and New
total TS score and the total PCQN score, meaning that as Zealand on the meaning and remit of palliative care. Palliat Med 26(3): 232–41.
doi: 10.1177/0269216311408993
the palliative care knowledge level increased, the attitudes to Hall S, Petkova H,Tsouros A, Costantini M, Higginson IJ, eds (2011) Palliative
caring for the dying became more positive. This link between Care for Older People: Better Practices, World Health Organization. http://tinyurl.
com/pwbkz4k (accessed 26 May 2016)
knowledge and attitudes has also been reported elsewhere in the Ho TM, Barbero E, Hidalgo C, Camps C (2010) Spanish nephrology nurses’
literature, with studies showing a positive relationship between views and attitudes towards caring for dying patients. J Ren Care 36(1): 2–8.
good palliative care knowledge and positive attitudes towards doi: 10.1111/j.1755-6686.2010.00141.x
Lancet (2014) Global elderly care in crisis Lancet 383(9921): 927. doi: 10.1016/
caring for those who have a terminal illness (Thulesius et al, S0140-6736(14)60463-3
2002;Vejlgaard and Addington-Hall, 2005; Ho et al, 2010). Hughes PM, Parker C, Payne S, Ingleton MC, Noble B (2006) Evaluating an
education programme in general palliative care for community nurses. Int J
Palliat Nurs 12(3): 123–31. doi: 10.12968/ijpn.2006.12.3.20697
Limitations Jerant AF, Azari RS, Nesbitt TS, Meyers FJ (2004) The TLC model of palliative
The sample size of nurses (n=61) is relatively small and from care in the elderly: preliminary application in the assisted living setting. Ann
Fam Med 2(1): 54–60
a rural setting only. However, the sample size compares well Kapo J, Morrison LJ, Liao S (2007) Palliative care for the older adult. J Palliat Med
to Brazil et al’s (2012) Canadian study of 69 nurses. Moreover, 10(1): 185–209. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2006.9989
Knapp CA, Madden V,Wang H et al (2009) Paediatric nurses’ knowledge of
data were collected at one point in time, and different results palliative care in Florida: a quantitative study. Int J Palliat Nurs 15(9): 432–9.
may have been found if data were collected over different time doi: 10.12968/ijpn.2009.15.9.44255
Leppert W (2014) Oxycodone/naloxone in the management of patients with
periods. It can be difficult therefore to make casual inferences pain and opioid-induced bowel dysfunction. Curr Drug Targets 15(1): 124–35
in cross sectional studies (Levin, 2006). Levin KA (2006) Study design III: Cross-sectional studies. Evid-based Dent 7(1):
24–5. doi: 10.1038/sj.ebd.6400375
Mason S, Ellershaw J (2004) Assessing undergraduate palliative care education:
Conclusion validity and reliability of two scales examining perceived efficacy and
The results indicate moderate knowledge of palliative care and outcome expectancies in palliative care. Med Educ 38(10): 1103–10. doi:
10.1111/j.1365-2929.2004.01960.x
positive attitudes of caring for the dying among nurses working Mason SR, Ellershaw JE (2008) Preparing for palliative medicine; evaluation of
in older persons care settings. Although palliative care training an education programme for fourth year medical undergraduates. Palliat Med
did not impact on the mean overall scores in this study, there 22(6): 687–92. doi: 10.1177/0269216308090070
McDonnell MM, McGuigan E, McElhinney J, McTeggart M, McClure D (2009)
was a significant difference in the PCQN scores of those who An analysis of the palliative care education needs of RGNs and HCAs in
had completed the ECEPC compared with those who had nursing homes in Ireland. Int J Palliat Nurs 15(9): 446, 448–55. doi: 10.12968/
© 2016 MA Healthcare Ltd
ijpn.2009.15.9.44257
information sessions within their unit. All nurses working in Merrill J, Lorimor R,Thornby J,Woods A (1998) Caring for terminally ill
care of older people settings should be supported to undertake persons: comparative analysis of attitudes (thanatophobia) of practicing
the ECEPC. Finally, younger, less experienced nurses would physicians, student nurses, and medical students. Psychol Rep 83(1): 123–8. doi:
10.2466/pr0.1998.83.1.123
benefit from working alongside older, more experienced nurses McCarthy J, Donnelly M, Dooley D, Campbell L, Smith D (2010) An Introduction
when delivering palliative care in older people care settings. BJN to the Ethical Framework for End-of-Life Care. Irish Hospice Foundation. http://
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.
RESEARCH
The best wound care videos from the web all together in one place
www.journalofwoundcar
www.woundcaretv.com
British Journal of Nursing, 2016, Vol 25, No 11 605
British Journal of Nursing. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.032.128.070 on June 13, 2016. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.